The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Victor Figueroa Victorious Fulfilling Fabulous Venture PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Number one recommendation that you give to all agents out there going into this new season.
SPEAKER_02The one recommendation that I would tell them is do not scale back. This is the moment to scale forward. So I hired my sister, first teammate. And my sister at the time, she wasn't working, she was a stay-at-home mom. Her husband did all the working. So I saw her one day, like probably a month and a half in into the agency. She was sitting at home and I was like, hey, why don't you just get off the couch and come and help me do something around the office? And she's like, What are you talking about? I'm like, well, I can't really pay you a lot. Like, I can give you 50 bucks a day. But all I need you to do is maybe uh just pick up the phone so that I don't have to be the first person to pick up the phone. And uh maybe uh call some people and I tell them that their payment is needed. And she she knew nothing about insurance, and she's never worked in a day in her life, you know, always a stay-at-home mom. And uh so she didn't want to do it, but then I kind of convinced her to do it because I'm gonna say also you gotta sell them on the on the dream, right? I convinced her to come and come and work for me, and all she would do is just uh call all my alerts, people who are pending payments. Um, we text people for payments, so I had her send out text messages for uh payment reminders. And uh we're four years in, and she's now full-time, she kind of runs the office when I'm not here. I know a lot of farmers' agents that would wish to steal her away from me.
SPEAKER_01Wow, that's awesome!
SPEAKER_02So she knows insurance very well, and yeah, she's still she's still here with us. Oh, so cool! That was my that was my first employee. It's it's kind of fun having my sister around here because you know, uh growing up, I grew up with nothing but brothers, so we kind of neglected our sister, but I learned so much about her uh working with her now.
SPEAKER_03So is she making $55 a day now?
SPEAKER_02No, no, she's she's now making over $25. So yeah, she's doing good. That's awesome. No, I I have to if not uh these other farmers' agents were are gonna offer her like 60 bucks an hour. They'd love to steal her away from me.
SPEAKER_03So you come into this thing, you probably didn't have a ton of business sense. Maybe the other office you said was a was a really big office, so it was busy, and you probably hadn't thought about like the traffic you need in order to write what you need to write in order to get the results that pay the bills. Like, what what did you do? Like, how did you put those pieces together in the beginning? I did not I did not know that.
SPEAKER_02I I did not know how to like uh do the math or anything like that. The only thing I knew was that I had a lot of friends and family that I could reach out to and ask them to switch over to me. So all I wanted to do was just kind of issue as much insurance as possible because I knew that if I issued a lot of policies, everything else would just kind of take care of itself, right? It wasn't until like I'm uh a few months into it that I started meeting other agents that they're asking me what's your ROI, how many internet leads do you buy, how many policies you're writing. And you know, I wasn't tracking any of that stuff. I was still thinking like a producer. I only had like about four bills: the rents, the light, you know, the internet, and uh the phone bill. So I didn't really have a lot that I needed to worry about. So I didn't really learn that I needed to really be more organized and just really track this stuff until an opportunity was presented to me. So the district said, Hey, we have this program called the Protege Program. We want you to train somebody for us, and in return, whatever they write, you get to keep. We'll give you a bonus if they finish early. And I was like, okay, well, you know, I did the math. I was like, you know, it sounds like it's a free employee for a few months and they can help me with my growth. So I went ahead and did that. We graduated her within about four months. And during that time, my district manager was like, hey, you know, how many, how much falls has Sharine, how many internet leads have you bought? So he ran a little bit of math with me and said, Hey, you gotta have this tracking system, you know, as uh being a business owner in order for things to be successful. But uh, you know, my first year or two, honestly, it was just dumb luck because we were just writing everything that came our way. We were writing boatload of stuff just because we had a fresh book that hasn't been touched in years. I was able to sell a lot of life insurance, which kind of uh you know tickled the district over there because that's all they wanted us to do. So I had a lot of like opportunities to write a lot of stuff within the agency at the time. So I didn't really track or buy internet leads or anything like that. I just never thought I needed to. But now, if you you can ask me, you know, now that I'm on with teledudes, I'm tracking it, I'm counting it, I'm an Excel spreadsheet Nazi now. So I track all that stuff now.
SPEAKER_03But at first, it's very you're just I had a lot of dumb and how long did that go? Like, how long did the dumb luck carry you? That's what I want to get to the heart of two years, two years, and so it runs out your friends and family, all of that stuff, the the book, you pounded the book. Like, did it just sort of dry up? Like, did you get to this point where you're like, oh no?
SPEAKER_02No, I I I I didn't because since I had successfully congrat uh graduated my protege and I wrote a lot of life insurance, the district rewarded me by giving me a free book. Smaller. Oh, gotcha. Okay. So with that little book, I had new blood to touch, new blood to kind of go after and cross-sell. So it carried me on to the following year. And then the following year, I was able to get a smaller book, so it just kind of carried me on. But since I was only doing proteges at the time, you know, I knew that the staff members were only temporary. So they were coming in when they had a whole bunch of people they can sell to.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_02So for the first two years, I just had I had all that stuff going for me. How how long would they stay with you? The proteges? Yeah. Um, well, I I wanted to graduate them in six months because if I graduated them in six months, then it I would get like an extra $7,000 bonus. So wait a minute. So you have free employees. Well, you gotta pay a well, I'm paying, I'm paying them, but the way I looked at it is in six months, I got it. It was like $31,000 to complete the program. So it probably cost me about $12,000 in payroll, but I got a $31,000 bonus.
SPEAKER_01So Seagre's does it. So your carrier gives you free employees plus extra money on top of it, plus if you're doing getting the free money, you're also gonna get free books of business.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and the person who's gonna become an agent has been trained on how to do everything in an agency. Well, giddy out. It's a pretty genius thing.
SPEAKER_02That's awesome. Yeah, that's that's that's how that's how I survived my first two and a half years. And now I have two I have two sales producers plus my CSR. And we do we do we're one of the top five in our district.
SPEAKER_03Who is your sister the CSR?
SPEAKER_02Yes. Okay, so she doesn't like sales, but she's great at customer service. Perfect.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So yeah, use her for her strengths. Exactly. Yeah. So she loves all that stuff. The unfortunately, farmers killed the protege program right now just because uh they're trying to slow down the uh growth production. But uh the second that thing comes back, I'm gonna be right on board on that. I'm gonna say, I'm gonna I'm gonna sign up, I'll train them a person if it's gonna give me a quote unquote temporary free employee with a little bit of bonus, and uh, you know, doing this for them will get maybe you know, rub them the right way and throw they'll throw a couple of policies your way.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, cool. I mean, I'll do it if I even though we're not farmers, I'd be happy to to take the bid and get paid too to do that. Yeah, it's it's genius.
SPEAKER_02And uh I I got to talk in one of the in one of the meetings that farmers has about doing these proteges, trying to get other agents to you know jump on board. They didn't have a lot of agents willing to do it. So they asked me if I would talk, and I just explained to them like, look, if you get $30,000 in the bonus, graduate them in six months, it probably cost you about 12 grand. So you made a lot of money, plus you get to keep 100 grand of what they wrote.
SPEAKER_03Right. But they'll go and stick their money in a savings deposit in a savings account and get one percent, right? Exactly. It would take 40 years to make the same return back.
SPEAKER_02It's just crazy. Yeah, and now it's even I think the program was uh before they killed it, was even getting better because farmers realized is that these proteges, when they go live, they needed to have a small book to just kind of give them a little bit of like income just to pay the rent or just something small. But what they're doing, what they were doing is they were temporarily parking that book in that agent's office at a hundred percent commission. So that agent would get the revenue of that book while they're being trained as well. So the bonus is still there, the policies they write, you keep, and you get to make money on the book that they're gonna take with them when they graduate.
SPEAKER_03So they only screened up the deal. But they slice that book, so if it's half a million, that that goes when they leave. Yeah. But as long as you have new ones coming in, who cares?
SPEAKER_02Exactly. I mean, it just it just made you you could just make a lot more money on it. Actually, that my last my second protege, I I had that deal going on. They parked a $1.3 million dollar book in my office that was generating about $12,000 in revenue a month, and I got to house that book for about five months, and then I got the full bonus, and then I got to keep $100,000. And some of the people in the book decided they did not want to leave, so I got to keep a couple of those of those policies. So it was uh it was it was it was such a great deal. I don't know why a lot of farmers agents weren't jumping on board on this. Are they insane? They're insane. They're insane. No, you know what? They're old. There's a lot of there's a lot of farmers' agents that should be retiring now, and they don't yeah, but but these are like hey, I'm I'm old and I only play golf now. Oh right, Craig doesn't they don't want to do nothing, they don't want to be a good thing. No, I can treat them. Well, these guys don't want to touch anything, they don't want they don't want to deal with nothing in their agencies anymore. They're treating their agency like if it's an annuity, right? They're just living off the revenue, they don't really care whether whether they're bleeding or not. They're just hey, this book gives me more than social security, so it's just a better deal.
SPEAKER_03Well, they better watch it because that's what happened with some other carriers that we know, and they've quashed that. They don't they don't take away your book if you don't sell anything.
SPEAKER_02You know, they they really they legally can't, I guess, because of the old farmers' contracts were very uh generous. That's what I heard. So what insure what farmers does now, and maybe this is what I can only assume that this is what they're trying to do, but by them putting changing the comp to variable and putting you know a performance metric on there is probably a deteriorate a discouraging factor for some of these older heads. Yeah. Say, hey, if you guys don't, you know, sell, you're gonna get cut by this much. And some people, some agents sell, some of them say screw it, even if they take half of it, I'm still in a better situation.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. So let's switch gears, talk a little bit about marketing. I'm curious, you know, we obviously you you mentioned that teleduce and all that stuff. I don't want to necessarily talk too much about that, but I will but I do want to understand your experience over time using leads. So when did you first come across internet leads and realize that this was some was like the only way to buy traffic, right? Like to create so exchange money and get quotes.
SPEAKER_02So I I've always worked internet leads at Ross's office. Ross always had um the internet lead uh lead going on, used to buy Facebook leads. So I've tried every a lot of different marketing strategies as far as internet leads go. The problem I had is I didn't have the resources to have staff and being able to dump an extra five, six grand on internet leads and turn that into sales. So as I started getting those these proteges, I started using some of that bonus money to buy the leads. So now I had money that did not belong to me and I can work it. So at that point, is that's when I realized I need to use this money to start buying internet leads and start creating a database of people. So I was using farmers' money that they were giving me in exchange for a training to buy these internet leads from Datalog, Smart Financial, and you know, a lot of different vendors that I use. But we've always worked on, and now I buy a lot of internet leads, and obviously, um teledues is in addition to what I to my leads now. But we live on internet leads for sure.
SPEAKER_03How was did you get good results when you first started? Like my experience was we bought them, they we would call a few times and we'd never really write anything. So I always had this bad taste in my mouth about internet leads because I didn't understand like the math behind it, right? Back in the old days. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02And you know what? The math is kind of like something that I'm like still kind of learning on it, to be sincere with you. I know a little bit more than I did a year ago. So what I the the way I see it now is yes, at first the internet leads are a little challenging to work if you're not used to that. I come from a background where I lived on internet leads, so it was just kind of more of a plug-and-play situation for me. The the one thing that I still recommend to a lot of agents that are interested in buying it to have a good CRM tool where they can create a database. Because to me, even if Felita isn't close today, I still have the data. So I bought the data, I can still call them six months from now, or I can call them every single freaking day. It depends on what CRM tool I have and what marketing strategies I feel. So a lot of people get discouraged because they just have them in their emails, they call them one or two times, and then they just they just don't know how to work them. We worked them for years at Ross' office, so I knew that hey, just because they didn't pick up today, they're gonna probably pick up six months from now, three months from now, sometimes two months from now when everybody stopped bombarding them with phone calls. Yeah, so that's where that's when you have when you have a nice CRM tool that can keep track of all this stuff for you. That's when it starts to really really come in handy. I think that buying data leads is like buying a toy like a car, uh like a toy car without batteries. You know, they they just gotta work together. You need the batteries to get that car to work, and the same thing with the CRM tool, you need those leads, which are the batteries, for it to work. And I think people always buy those separate, and that's why they're not successful at it.
SPEAKER_03Well, then there's multiple pieces, right? And then you need dials, and so like my mindset was coming from Merrill where I made a thousand dials by hand on a freaking you know, crank phone, right? And I'll operate that, you know, doing that thing, and like, oh, they need to do that too. But what I didn't understand was oh, well, they can't make that many dials and quote 10 pe 10 people's households, right? It's impossible. Yeah, it's hard. That was a big that was a big aha, like a big defining moment of this whole thing.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and yeah, and you know what? Last year I kind of learned a little bit more of it because I started hanging around. So the better I got and the better agent I became, I started rubbing shoulders with uh wiser agents, and I started going to these gatherings where all these agents hang out, and I you know, I had a lot of bar conversations, and those bar conversations were very, very useful to me. So, one of the things that I learned from one of another agent named Henry Morales, so you probably know him as well, too. Just not familiar with that company that you're visiting. Okay, got it. So um this other these other agents. So he he I was talking to him about my marketing strategies, and he's like, Hey, Victor, why why are you turning Henry? Okay, I don't know.
SPEAKER_01Enrique? No, don't know him, Enrique Morales. Oh, know the name, but don't know him.
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, I started hanging, I started rubbing shoulders with him a little bit more, and one of the things that he told me, he goes, Victor, he goes, Why are you turning your closers into telemarketers? And at that point, I kind of took a step back and I was like, This guy's right. I got guys that are top-notch closers, and all they're doing is sitting there cranking out phone calls. I need to figure out how to get these guys to stay on the phone, quoting at all times. It was it was that change that kind of really launched me ahead of a lot of my competition when I figured that out. And uh, so what I did was I started buying instead of data leads, I started buying live transfers. So, you know, that can get very, very expensive. But with farmers' cost share, where they'll reimburse us for half of it, or they did a year ago, it just made a lot of sense because now I can say, hey, I'm gonna pony up six grand worth of leads, and it only cost me three thousand dollars. So at that point is when I had all my guys just always quoting, always quoting, always quoting, and then my sales started really, really going up, right? But I still had a whole bunch of data, and that should still be worked. So that's when uh I reached out to Ross, and he's like, Well, you know, I use teledudes, so I was like, you know, this is great. I can stick all this data that I have and have somebody call it so my guys aren't telemarketers, and then have them transfer it over, and I can kind of peel back some of the money that I'm spending on data loss, smart financial. And uh, I only started discovering this part of it since November of last year when I started making all these changes, right? So I went from writing 35,000 a month to set in December, we did about 67,000.
SPEAKER_01Wow, double, yeah, double.
SPEAKER_03And then February because you you increase their capacity, right? It's like you could have your closers make calls, but then 75% of the time, all they're doing is dialing. It's like having an oil well that only pumps 10% of the time, right? Or 25% of the time, and the rest of the city. Exactly. It's like why would you remove capacity?
SPEAKER_02Exactly. So February came along and we did it better because that's when I signed up for Teledudes, and uh I signed, and uh, you know, January was a little rough because I was spending most of my time programming everything. We did a we did about 40,000 in January, but once everything was dialed in, we went ahead and had a $97,000 month last month. Holy crap! And then this month we're already at 47,000.
SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah, you have the weird wonky months because of Far.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so my my month technically will end on the 20th of March. So a week into this, and we're on pace to really, really crushing last month's number. Unfortunately, they'll they announced uh this month that hey, you know, we're gonna have this 10-day hold on everything. So I'm just like, well, that's great. I just kind of figured out what I needed to do, and now you want to slow it down.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, wow, you 3x' what you were doing from November, and then and then this month it was wise words of wisdom. Why are you making your closers into telemarketers? 100%. And what so here's a big piece to that, right? How did they feel back in October about making all those dials? And how what do they think like last month of being able to talk to more people? Like, was there a change in their personality?
SPEAKER_02Were they more grateful, or were they oh they they they they love the change, they love the change, and actually the atmosphere in the office is actually significantly better. Love it. Everybody's excited, you know. The attitude around here is uh is everybody's giggling, everybody's always trying to close. It I finally built that sales atmosphere that I've been wanting to have since day one. Love that.
SPEAKER_03So I think it cool, like you drive to the office and you're like, I'm excited to go in there, right? Like that's all that would be.
SPEAKER_02It's so hard for me to leave my office. Yeah. Um, my wife gets on my case, like, hey, you know, it's eight o'clock at night. I'm like, really? I'm like, you know, I want I was gonna leave, but then the basketball game started, so I kind of don't tell you that, you know, yeah. I don't want to miss it. I'm like, it should be over by 9 30. Um that that doesn't fly. I work on Saturdays. I love being in here. I wake up, I genuinely wake up excited to come in to see what we're gonna what we're gonna write. Yeah. What we're gonna write. It's just weird for me right now because everything just happened, all these changes that to slow us down just occurred within the last week. Just right when I figured out what had to be done to really beat everybody in my district.
SPEAKER_03But you know what? They're they're all gonna face the same thing. And the great news is that you can't control that piece, right? As long as you keep doing what you're doing, then it it'll it's all gonna work out. Like you're gonna be great.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and and even even right now, I I made a I did a strategy now where now, hey, we're gonna focus on home since auto is kind of like the complicated one. But we're all pretty good at quoting home, so why can't we just double down on that? So that's kind of the uh pivot we're making right now is we're just uh gonna buy leads specifically for home.
SPEAKER_01And here's the here's a secret the carrier I'm with doesn't allow to write my home. So I have mine with farmers. It's a great policy out here in California.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, unfortunately, that that is that is um, but you know, because of that carrier, people who work at that company just learn how to quote with multiple carriers. So because I had that experience of quoting with multiple carriers, the transition when I came here to farmers, and I came to a situation where farmers said no, I knew exactly where I needed to go. So, you know, being able to do that, I'm already ahead of some of my other my competition, which is you know, my colleagues because they don't know where to go.
SPEAKER_01Love that, and I know the other guidelines, super cool, dude. Well, I think it's awesome. I I hope you can navigate through the changes, and I know like we we're having the same kind of changes too, so it's just a lot to think about. I think that you know, in these times, like here's my thought on it is in these times it's it's time to pivot. It might be time to pivot, it might be time to do a lot of different things. The last thing that is a good idea is to just stop doing anything, you know. You gotta you gotta have that something to light you up every day and going backwards is never a good idea, right? We all know where that gets you, it gets you backwards.
SPEAKER_02It gets us back to working for somebody if we do that, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Especially when everybody else is is tightening up too, right? Like, yeah, the contra the contrarian view, the Warren Buffett mentality is real, right? Like everybody else, like, oh, it's all boy, recession. I gotta cut back on my on my marketing. It's like, dude, everybody's cutting back. What are you doing? There's uh it's all opportunity now, right? Less people doing it, and it's what happened with COVID. Everybody cut back. Jason and I launched a company, and the people that followed us on that journey scaled agencies, right? We scaled ours, and uh, that was pretty cool. It was scary. I do agree scary.
SPEAKER_02Definitely. Uh, the the good thing is that I'm I'm very versatile, so I'm not a one-trick pony, so I can do commercial, yeah. Um, I can do life insurance. So PC is what everybody is the biggest part of our books. Commercial is something that's we need to add, and I'm pretty good at commercial, I'm pretty good at life insurance. So what I told the guys, like, okay, we can't write auto, then let's write workers' comp because we're good at it. You know, you guys um I hear them complain from time to time, oh, I'm losing a price, I'm losing a price. Well, you know what? In workers comp, we typically don't lose to price, we usually win deals in workers' comp here at farmers. So, you know, making that adjustment is uh easier for someone like me because I took the time to learn commercial. Right. And I talked to some of the bigger agents, even agents that have given me advice that put me in this very good position that I'm in, there's they don't do commercial and they're struggling because they say, hey, we can't hire somebody to only do commercial, we don't have nobody to train them. I can do that. I can just get I could just have my staff start writing commercial and I can train them myself. Right. You know, I don't have to bring somebody with experience in commercial. So, and even with life insurance, we do quite a bit of it here, and you know, if as long as we're writing life insurance, those are good premiums. It keeps everybody, uh it keeps everybody uh you know employed, working, and we don't have to uh get rid of staff. Like I hear some of my farmers' colleagues talking about doing. And like that's not that's not what you want to do. This uh this to learn, you know, other stuff, get better. And you know what? When the floodgates close and uh we can start growing, we're gonna be better prepared and we'll be able to pick up right where we left off. And you know what? Even better than even better than 20 than we started earlier in 2023. Yeah, so I love it. I'm I'm excited for farmers to pick everything back up and the guidelines to get better because the second they do, I think I have the system necessary to really win.
SPEAKER_01Love it. So, what's the one number one recommendation that you give to all agents out there going into this into this new season?
SPEAKER_02The one recommendation that I would tell them is do not scale back. This is the moment to scale forward, keep on issuing insurance policies. If you have a 10-day hold, that's okay. Everybody else is doing it, so you're still a win. You just gotta keep on putting forward, you just cannot go backwards. You've came too far to let something like this set you back. You have to go forward, and that's that.
SPEAKER_01Wise words, love it, Victor. Thank you. You went the distance, yeah. An hour.
SPEAKER_03I just say one thing you burned your bridge to being able to join the gang by fighting them. So you don't have that as a backup. You have to be successful at this.
SPEAKER_02I bet you know, unfortunately, I think uh old boss is not even in town anymore. So, yeah, if that bridge was still there, he's not here. I'd have to move out of the state. He did the right thing. He just said, you know what? I'm still in everything, I'm moving somewhere else, and that's exactly what he did.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman