The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Sethe Smith’s Sacrificial but Smart Strategic Journey PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
What recommendation would you give to any young agent like yourself or old agent like Craig to make the real impact in the face of six years?
SPEAKER_01It was a good day yesterday. You know, I I got my series six, so that was awesome. So I then uh I got out of the office and or I mean the test there and I had text messages, one call closed, and like by the end of the day it was like eight grand a premium. I was like, okay, all right, it's a really good day.
SPEAKER_03So you ended the month not even being in the office, doing your own thing, but you also had a day like that. Yep. It was uh it was a really good day. That's phenomenal, dude. I I I remember when I got my series six and six three, and it was very stressful, and there were no sales. To be able to do both is how empowering it's yeah, I got like side story.
SPEAKER_04I got my so I have a series seven and I got that at Merrill Lynch, which I was their financial advisor. I was a financial advisor of Merrill Lynch prior to uh getting the agency. And the Craig just had a one of us, by the way, Seth. No, yeah. Well, number one, yeah. Number one, I can sell options, which you cannot. And number two, when when you went in, if you didn't get the 70, if you didn't pass, you're fired. So you go in, it's a four-hour test because it's like double. It it was insane. Like you can't even think by the end of it. You're like brain is melted. You know, you hit the bar, you do you want to see your results? And then it asks, Are you sure you want to see your results? And then I'm like, wait a minute, does it just ask you that if you failed? You know, and I'm and I'm like shaking. I was shaking and I had I had sweat dripping down my face, and I'm in this room going, If if I failed, I'm screwed, like screwed. We my wife just had Kenzo, so our second child just was born. I'd have to come home and say, Oh, well, I'm fired because I failed. And I clicked it and I got a 73 baby. Oh, they all said I had 73% too much. That is crazy. It was nuts, and yes, it is better. Yeah, yeah, just one up. Yeah, no problem. Yeah, no, I did it's I I don't ever want to take that again. So, what about plans for like recruiting? Do you still recruit on a daily basis or you know on a weekly basis? What do you do with that?
SPEAKER_01So I do my recruiting a little bit different, I guess, uh, than what you hear all the time is always be recruiting, always be hiring. And mine is I tend to like to try to get referrals in that first before I go outside, just for they tend to be better candidates. And it's also one of the least extensive ways to do so. But as far as like for me, like last year when I was planning to hiring, started about a month and a half in advance, knowing that I'm gonna have to comb through all these resumes, I'm gonna have to weed out the the best ones and people not showing up and supposed to sound good, but then end up not being good, you know, that type of thing. So honestly, my myself, yeah, he had no experience in the sales industry. He uh worked in the restaurant industry for nine years, which one having a job for nine years was huge, right? Continuously with the same company. And then, but being in the restaurant, you know, customer service is already there, dealing with unpleasant people sometimes was already there. So, and uh it was just hungry. And I was like, you know what, gonna take a chance and the best choices I made. Love it.
SPEAKER_03What did you do when you brought him on? How did you inspire him to be up to the level of your expectation?
SPEAKER_01High commission. Um like I'm a firm believer in the lower base, higher commission. Like, and sometimes, like, can we lose out in the long run? Or like up front, right? Like we could potentially be paying out more, but it's based on the renewals rate that we get up there. But I want to incentivize by not only paying very well on commission, but also throwing bonuses. We hit our goals as a bonus every month, and depending on how much you contribute contributed to it, depends on how much you get out of. And um, you hit it six months in a row, get another bonus. So it's one of those things that I just I do feel like rewarding them is huge. Um, but also it needs to align with us, right? If we're seeing our goals six months in a row, that's huge. So we you know, throwing a bonus out there is just makes sense, it devises them to um just write the the business there. And you know, I I do more of a hands-on approach with the teaching too. Like I do like to show them, I do like to um like I said, I'm still in sales, so I like, you know, they can listen to my calls, they can watch me do it, like whatever the case may be there. Um, I just feel like that does help out quite a bit to just show them like this is what I I've done, this is how much I've done while not being able to 100% focus on sales. So this is what you know, imagine what you can do. This is all you're gonna do. Don't have to worry about any of that other stuff. You just sell and this is how much you can make and it's all based off of you. If it works for you, great. And I laid that out in front before offering. And you know, I I do uh I do like to do a two approach, like I'll present them two commission structures, right? One with higher base, low commission, or lower commission, and one with lower base, higher commission, and they'll make much more on the higher commission. And it's like which one would you pick if I offered you a job? Ooh, love that.
SPEAKER_04That is a that is really a really good idea. I like it. Like that's a great qualum because if it they go for the high base, you know. Uh I just wonder, huh? Yeah. So of what do you do then take it away?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, what do you do? No, I just like like I said, I don't this is part of like the last interview phase, right? You're in front of them, you're like, hey, you know, if uh this is a good fit for both of us, these are the type of structures that I have laid out for myself people. Which one would you pick?
SPEAKER_04And I let them say I want the I want the five hundred thousand a year with no no commission. I'm just like, okay, perfect.
SPEAKER_01Um, we'll be in touch and then I just leave it like that. And then never talk again. I'll call back and say, you know, you know, we decided to move in another direction, but um, but that just lets me know that there the hunger's not there and I need hunger.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I love like I I've used that in verbal form. I've never thought about actually writing out two commission structures in which the base is incredibly low, but like incredibly high upside, and then show them the difference and then have them decide that's such a good, that's such a good qualifier right there.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, and I think you know, like we explain it to them and when we we know it backwards and forwards because we talk about it all the time, but for them, they probably like uh-huh uh okay, they don't understand, right? Like they're not following, but they don't want to look bad, so they just agree, and then here we are pay overpaying them for the base because at the end of the day, everybody's gonna if if they're presented in their mind with two different things, one's 1500 and one's three thousand, they're going for three thousand, right? Like, why wouldn't you? Because what if it doesn't work? What if I guess that's where your the support that you're gonna give once they're on is a really important component of it too. What what kind of support do you give? Like, what are you do you get them leads? Like what how how's your do guy writing business?
SPEAKER_01So obviously we do they'll do so. Um we have that. So we buy quite a bit of internet leads. Um, we don't do the live transfers, it's just honestly too expensive if you buy them from these companies once half the time they're just gonna tell them whatever they can to get them to actually just send them over, right? Get their 65, 100, 120 per call. And unless your company or have companies are, you know, closing 25 to 40 percent of business, it just doesn't make sense on how many you have to get to close, right? So what I do is uh it's a two-part system. I use Tell Dudes, our telemarketer, as a a person to have leads coming in, right? Or calls coming in to them. But that's not our only the only thing. I do expect still dials, I do expect follow-ups. I we do not just sit, you know, twiddling our thumbs and just say, Man, I really hope I get a call and they just want to close. And it's like we can't do that, especially today. Um, so it's a it's a two-part system, but I do spend more than I ever have um in marketing. But I have to look at once again, like these past like two months, especially. I'm writing more than I ever have. So it it kind of like you you just have to spend that, you have to support them. I mean, if you're gonna tell them, hey, you can make X amount with me, you better have a plan in in store for them if they're taking a chance on you, right? You need to make sure that you have something in place for them, a system that is going to help feed them. Now, I can't, you know, guarantee anything that's dependent on them, how hard they want to work, how hard they want to follow up, what they want to do. But at the same time, you still have to supply a quality flow for them. Like you, you should be able to make that commitment to them. Like, hey, you can make this much with me, and they're believing in you, right? To be able to help get them there. So you need to believe in them by supporting in them. Um, whether it's you know, marketing, like I I don't do much with mailers, to be honest with you. I just I I don't see much success unless you're gonna spend an astronomically high amount. Um, and you're okay with waiting three months to two years for them to call you, which I'm not. So um I do try to sprinkle them, but I decide not too with going forward this year. I'm just gonna invest more into real-time internet leads and uh just my telemarketer and spend more there on also referral programs, networking programs, that type of thing, like to build better relationships, creating those center to influences um this year is one um is what I'm gonna be one of my goals do to help support them as well.
SPEAKER_03It's it's funny, you you reminded me of what it was like when I first started. When I first started, I I remember hiring, like trying to hire people and showing them like, hey, you can make a lot of money here. And then they would come in and I'd and I'd show them a commission and I said, You should be here, you should be here. Like, look at all like these other people and groups and agencies are are, you know, they're like other agencies can do it. If they can do it, you can do it. And I wasn't buying them leads. Like I I took no responsibility for giving them business because I also heard in those groups like bring me, you know, a hundred deck pages and all this stuff, right? Yeah. Uh and I remember hiring people thinking like, oh my gosh, like you'd hire them, they would come in all excited within like a couple months. It was like the balloon was deflated. They're like, I'm never gonna make money, and then they would leave. And I remember hiring two or three people that way and feeling like when I was trying to hire them, feeling like, oh, this person's not gonna last. Like it's almost like you're selling them a bill of lies, right? And then fast forward to actually spending money on marketing, it was like, dude, we're in this together. Like, I'm buying you tons of leads. Like it became more of a joint relationship and it became something where you could like believe in it and and like they they actually had a chance. All they had to do was actually follow the the the steps that you lay out.
SPEAKER_04I think you're missing a big part of that too. You gave them the why, right? Like what we were talking about today earlier. Like in the first example, it's the what you it was all what, right? Like, hey, you're gonna make the money. If you do this, you're gonna you make a bunch of money, but you pivoted when you when that second set and you and you went through it. Hey, we can we can make an impact on the people that we insure because we're gonna give them better coverage. You give them that why that where we we like literally, I know for certain that there's tons of people that have the wrong coverage out there and nobody does a damn thing about it, right? Like the they go to they go over to the other place, the other place says, Okay, I'm gonna match you apples to apples, okay, great. And they do that, right? But where did the apple come from? Like they started when they were 16 and they've had the same coverage since they were 16, you know. So having, I mean, even my kids were in a head on. I've talked about a million times. My kids were in a head on, it was the freaking scariest day of my life. Thankfully, they didn't get hurt, they're fine. But in that head-on, like we learned the other driver who was at fault had 100, 300, that's nice, 15 for property damage. 15, 100, 300, 15 with a gecko, right? And and it's like, what a gross oversight, right? Like, imagine if she didn't hit my kids in in an old Avalon, but instead hit me in the Model X, right? Now there's a problem, right? And and it's not just it's such a tiny detail that could have a huge impact because if they hit if they hit that car, oh shit, I'm going after them, right? Like I don't care. I'm taking your house to pay for my car because they could have it. And so it's like it's like we literally impact their lives and protect them from something that could be detrimental. And it's difficult to move them from that, but that's part of our responsibility as in what we do. And I think that then also, like you talked about how you're selling, like I haven't sold logged in and sold a policy forever, right? But I still sell in that I'm selling that vision and that why to my team so that they can do it. Because I love to sell, but I I I do nobody any good by me, you know, making $15 for the year on a renter's policy. Like that doesn't that doesn't move the needle.
SPEAKER_01No, I definitely agree. And I and that just comes to you know the whole thing that separates us, right? If we're gonna be if if you're gonna treat them like just like we said, transactional, expect every every interaction to be transactional. And you're and expect lot bigger issues down the road too, because you can't take that time to when you brought them over to say, hey, for literally five cents, ten cents more a month, I can take you from that 15 or and might say 25 in property damage to 100,000, 500,000, whatever you want to do, you're still taking cents a month. And people like when you connect it, like you said, I go, hey, you go hit out that Tesla, you total it. What do you think that's gonna cost you? 25? No, you're gonna be paying that person 70 to whatever model they got plus thousand. Um, where do you think that money's coming from? Not us. I mean, like if you're only gonna pay for 25, that's what we're paying, then we're gonna pay, but where do you think the other money comes from? And once they actually connect that, like, hey, like they can come after my actual money, and it's not just uh bought, it's an actual, like you can changeably um feel it and talk about like it that it, like you said, is gonna be the difference and the huge difference.
SPEAKER_04And depending on the state, like it can come straight from it could be garnished, like child support or whatever, you know. So it's crazy. Like, like we we have a responsibility to be honorable and have integrity and and can get them the right coverage, even though they don't want to, right? Kicking and screaming in the same way we have people come to us, hey, how are you writing? How did you do a million and a half of premium last year? Well, here's what we did, and then oh, I don't I don't want to do all that, right? It's like, well, that's how you do it. Okay, this is what you need to do, and it's it's shifting, it's taking somebody and shifting how they look at something so that they understand it, right? It's just at the end of the day, they just don't understand because quite frankly, insurance sucks and it's boring and nobody likes it, right? Like, that's just the fact, right? Nobody likes it.
SPEAKER_01I tell them that when they talk about it. When I'm selling someone, I'll be like, Hey, I know this is the one of the worst things to talk about, and it's like nails on the chalkboard. I was like at the end of the day, I was like, My my end goal for you is to take care of you and your family. And I don't want you calling me saying, Hey, I have this claim, I don't have enough coverage. I don't want that. Never right, yeah.
SPEAKER_04And that's why, like, and I know that you follow uh some of the sales stuff, we're telling stories, we're doing these things, like, which is a little different, but it's a framework so that if we don't the head-on story, right? Like that's a real story, that's something that happened. And I used to say it on every single call when I was doing sales after it happened because it's powerful and it and it conveys the message and the importance, and then it shows that I'm passionate about it, right? Whereas if I just said, Okay, I got you at 1530, 15. Do you understand what those mean? Of course, they're gonna say yeah, because they don't want you to explain it, and and then you move on, right? Like, who cares? Who? Why? I don't care. That's the what the Geico guy said. That's what the other, I don't care, right? But hey, this is look, look at what happens if this is done wrong, and and right now it isn't done correctly, but this is so give let me give you a scenario, and then boom, right?
SPEAKER_01Like, oh, okay, that that's at that point, you know, you know, you're still gonna have those people who are like, nope, still don't want to do it. And you're like, okay, you know, like we just have to do our our part to offer the right coverage, and the every situation is different, right? You're gonna have some people who are high earners, you're gonna have some people who are low earners, so not all coverages makes the sense, but to me, like I still want to give higher coverages than lower, but you're still gonna have those customers so that are just gonna tell you, nope, I don't care, you know, but they can try going after me, but they can't get anything from me. It's like you say that you'd be surprised. Um, so and that's essentially like you know, you just we gotta do our part and we got to help educate whether they feel like they want to be educated at that moment, right?
SPEAKER_03100%. So, Seth, what recommendation would you give to any young agent like yourself or old agent like Craig to make the biggest impact in their agency?
SPEAKER_04And you can't say run the other direction. We're assuming that they have to become an agent.
SPEAKER_00I was just gonna tell you to retire, but no, I mean I don't try it.
SPEAKER_01Um, I mean, dive in. I mean, that's like that's the thing. Like, unless like I'm fully invested in this, like it this I'm putting everything I I can back into the business. I'm trying to, you know, pay myself as little as possible so I can put it more into the business. Because to me, you just look at the the end goal. What's your end goal? I want to sell this for a lot more than what I bought it for, right? I want to create a retirement for me that's not based off of hoping that I'm gonna get it from the government, right? I want to create it for myself and I have the power to do so. And I think for younger agents, it's just think about your end goals and just focus on that, on like what steps you need to make to get it and just dive in. Take those fears out of the way. You're gonna make mistakes. You know, my uncle told me when I first failed my broker office, um, failed in six months. I didn't manage it right, thought I could do everything myself, you know. He said it's not about failing, about what do you do after you fail. Are you just gonna go, you know, just look down and just not take a chance again in your life? No, you're gonna fail many times, but it's just moving past the times that you fail and just realizing what did you do that caused you to fail that time, and now you know what not to do. And um, and just being able to just um accept that you will you will fail, you'll make some bad decisions. But at the end of the day, it's what how you react to those that will help uh love it, get you to your angle.
SPEAKER_04I mean, the same thing. Jason and I failed with leads more times than most people even buy leads, right? In order to figure out the art and science behind it. I think a lot of people would give up. I mean, it's discouraging, it sucks losing, you know. But then you go, oh, okay, that didn't work. Now I okay, you know, it's clues, clues.
SPEAKER_01You know, you might lose a thousand, two thousand dollars with a lead company, and you're just gonna have to be like, okay, I know not to use them again. Let's move on to a different one. You know, it's like you're just gonna have to eat it and just be like, I made a mistake, and or you know, like I should have done more research or whatever the case may be and just move on and just uh find someone else.
SPEAKER_04That $2,000 class is a lot less than than going to Havid. Yeah, you can't even use that.
SPEAKER_00100%.
SPEAKER_04And I love the fear you said uh or have faith in the government to have the money. I think in this case, we want to have fear about that, faith in our agency, right?
SPEAKER_00Things that we can control.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, 100%.
SPEAKER_03Seth, thank you for going the distance. This has been awesome. Really appreciate it. Yeah, awesome.
SPEAKER_04Thank you, and uh we'll see you on the next uh lead call.
SPEAKER_01All right, sounds good, guys.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman