The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The Insurance Dudes are on a mission to find the best insurance agentsaround the country to find out how they are creating some of the top agencies. But they do not stop there, they also bring professionals from other industries for insights that can help agents take their agencies to the next level. The Insurance Dudes focus on your agency’s four pillars: Hiring, Training, Marketing and Motivation! We have to keep the sword sharp if we want our agencies to thrive.&nbs...
Where do you see the agencies going? What are you looking forward to?
SPEAKER_02
My main goal right now is hiring. I have the system in place, which I didn't always have, which allows me to be able to say to someone, hey, it will work, you follow the instructions.
SPEAKER_00
I are agents. Now I am predictable. Profitable. Agent, I am a great public. I am agreeing. We are agents. We are insurance.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, I was just talking to somebody in our office today, and I was like, going into these times of recession and all this stuff and all this craziness that you know you hear about on the news, and it's like, dude, we're in the best industry ever. Because you know what? People have to have auto insurance. So it's mandated by the states. So it's like, I mean, I I don't want to jinx it, but it's a recession proof industry.
SPEAKER_02
You're right. I think I thought in the COVID year I thought I'd lose people. I actually gained business during COVID, which if you'd said pull hand to fire, I would say I would think I'd lose money and business during COVID, which I did not. The next year I did, but the COVID year I did not.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, it was crazy. That year I remember talking to Craig because we were both at scratch agencies, and at that point we were investing, I mean, like obscene amounts of money into leads, telemarketer, and like the whole thing. Plus, we had a big staff. So I'm like, I was just like doom and gloom. I'm like, well, we have like almost a hundred thousand dollar monthly budget right now. Like if this gets shut off, like I don't have like hundreds of thousands to float this thing, you know. So you gotta pull the bezos though, man. Big risk. So you gotta do it, the big bets. So we just kept going and we're like, you know, week one, week two, like the shutdowns and stuff. And like, wow, this is I think that we could hold steady. And then it's like, we're having some of the highest sales we've ever had. We're like, this is insane because it's such a polarity of, you know, on one hand, there's a lot of infrastructure that's breaking down everywhere, you know. And then on the other hand, it's like we're we were doing really well. So it's weird time, weird time for sure.
SPEAKER_02
I will say this that I think this is a tougher job than the investment world. I can have a guy lose two fifths, it's not a big deal for him. But in our world, really, really based on premium, we can really lose people if we don't have the objections and are ready for the premium price raises that we have through the carrier. So I would say that this job is is pretty tough. But when I started, I thought it was going to be very easy. But I think it's actually harder than the investment world because the client is different and customers are different, and this is a harder, much harder road than it is being on both ends of the spectrum here.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, we're put in this position where we can't really niche in the PNC world. So when you can't niche, I mean you can kind of, but you know, it's tough, right? It's tough to niche down. So then you run into different clientele that you got to kind of take it all, which can be challenging. And I came from that world, I was at Merrill Nich, and it was a different kind of tough, right? Because you were the guy, like you do all of that activity, but you were also more like a sales agent because you didn't have all the other stuff, and here it's well, you have to get the sales, but also your HR and your payroll, you know, your HR, your marketing, your sales, your investments, your everything, right? You're a psychologist, counselor, psychologist, yeah, doctor. I put band-aids on people. I mean, you know, it's it's crazy, absolutely, and so you just have to like it's that thing, right? The grass is always greener. Like you look over there, oh, that must be easier over there, then just selling insurance auto insurance, right? It's like, oh well, but there's some other stuff.
SPEAKER_02
Absolutely. That was my thinking. I could do that, he does that, I can do it.
SPEAKER_03
You know, the whole say the grass is always greener, it comes from this story of these two farmers that like their properties are next to each other. They always looked at the other guy's farm and thought, Man, if I had that farm, then everything would be better. And the other farm was looking over, say the other one, and they ended up trading. Yeah, and then when they traded, they were like, Oh, same shit.
SPEAKER_02
Absolutely.
SPEAKER_03
So you come into 2020, and I know you said, and it turned out it was it ended up being okay, but let's backpedal before it was okay. What was going through your mind? Like, where were you mentally with what could potentially happen?
SPEAKER_02
Well, my goal was to be a mega agent. I got a little small agency just to get my feet wet because I didn't want to break off too much because I didn't know too much of the business. I already had my PNC license, I had all my licenses, but I just hadn't or been, I didn't do a lot with PNC. And I just thought his uh was PNC. Maybe I was arrogant. Hey, I could do that. If so and so does it, I can do it. It's not a problem. My agent does it, I can do it too. I started in 2019, in the middle of 2019. And in 2019, we were doing well. I had merited them, hard decision to make, but I had to do it. 2020 went well, like I said to before. 2021 took a strange turn, but we did okay. 2022, we were up 24. We were up over 200 in quotes. We were up, I think 15 in premium or something, but we were up, which was good for me. I just have to for me to really build, I need to be able to kind of double what I'm doing. So I'm just trying to make sure that I can take this to the next step. And how do I do that? That's tricky, right?
SPEAKER_03
I think you have the blueprint, but it's tough to take that mental shift to committing, right? To the additional, like you get to capacity with whatever you're doing, and as soon as those producers can't do more than what they're doing, like they can't physically do more quotes, like it's impossible, like there's diminishing returns because 10 households is the most, I think, really, and probably eight eight to ten is the sweet spot for what a producer can do in a day and really be effective. Once you're there, then it's okay, more leads, you know, more marketing, whatever the source is to drive traffic, and then then you can add more producers. This whole thing, right?
SPEAKER_02
More marketing, new producers, more marketing, new producers. Just just to get it ramped up, replication.
SPEAKER_03
So that's kind of where we are. I mean, that's how we've done it. It's always daunting every time you go up a notch, right? I mean, I think we all have our doubts we come up with and the reasons why we can't do it, even though we see everybody else doing it, and all of these things that are like tricks of the mind. And it's like the evidence is there that it can be done because we know there are people that can do it, and usually it's gonna be that 10 to 20 percent are the ones that are successful. That's just the way it works, right? Because the other folks fall into the mind games and they let it take over, and that's why most people are workers, right? Most people have a job, most people show up, they leave, that's it, they go do their thing, and we're crazy and we work 24 hours a day, or at least think about work 24 hours a day, right?
SPEAKER_02
Right, absolutely it's just interesting.
SPEAKER_03
Think about how not to work for 24 hours a day.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, I totally agree. So, what was the big breakthrough? I think not burning out my people, not to give you guys a plug here, but starting off small, and I couldn't get my guys to really make I was asking to make 80 to 100 calls, as everyone told me. That's a sweet spot. Make your guys make 800 calls, Paul. You'll make it, you'll make a killing. And I was burning them out. So I mean, they'll do it for three days, and then the other two days, I'm like, what happened? They do it on Monday and Tuesday, Wednesday. Everybody is shuts down, and and I'm like, what happened? I'm looking at the numbers, it's 12 o'clock, and we don't no one has over 30 calls. I think moving them from making just calls from the leads to actually actively receiving calls and being able to sell and overcome objections, having more of a the ability to tell them, hey, here's what we're gonna do. We're gonna get sharper and sharper every day um to overcome objections, and that's gonna be our selling point. First, we're gonna have a point of hey, do you just transfer me from someone else? How do we talk through? I'm getting a call from a telemarketer. The person just said, Why did he transfer you? And now we never have that problem. That's not even a problem for him because once we worked on it enough, it became a smooth transition. And guess what? We don't have that issue. We have other issues, but that's not that's not one of the issues that we have.
SPEAKER_01
If someone's releasing their stuff on there's always like these friction points, right? And then they seem so daunting and like it's not gonna work out, and then it's like you start practicing it and you start realizing, okay, why? Like some people hit that road where it's like, let's just say internet leads, nobody wants a quote, and you got to call them a lot. So it's like that's the end point, that's the brick wall. And it's like, well, that's a problem, right? The advantage of that is that you know, not a lot of people like to break through that. The other thing is it's like, well, how do we do it? And when you start inspecting it and working on it, then it improves, and then all of a sudden you build up a callus to that thing that you've been working on and you break through, and then that's not an issue. We got a process for it. It's like going to the next thing, and it's super cool. I love people that can break through because it feels good, you know. It feels good to have your team have a challenge that wasn't working out and then get them through that, you know. It creates a really good company.
SPEAKER_02
Well, what I what I do like is that when one person says, Hey, Paul, that actually worked. Yeah, so now I can go back to everyone else and you know what? You can say you just had a sale based on using the script. We just got to follow the script. Put in your own words, but we just gotta follow the script. So I think I think that helps a lot, and that just helps when you have success. Everyone buys in. If you don't, and everyone's sitting there saying, Hey, no one makes over 40 calls a day, that kind of stuff. Those are the calls that and you can show that those negative questions and comments.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, you said something interesting that I think would resonate from anybody that's else that's come from financial services. It's sales. So from the function of like mechanically, you know, the architecture of the sales pipeline, very similar, right? Like it's just sales, you got to do numbers, blah blah blah. Now, where the big difference is financial services, one deal, you sell one annuity, you could be making 20k, right? One client, 20k or 100k, whatever, right? Like, I mean, the sky's the limit to get that same money out of an agency, a lot more has to go into it, right? Like simple numbers, you could say, if I want 20,000 of revenue, I need to write whatever that is to get that money this month or the lifetime value of it over some period, right? Like it doesn't work the same. And so then when we say, Well, I'll make the dials, I made the dials here. Well, you can't because you can't write enough to justify that activity, right? For what we have to pay for, whether it's ourselves, our sales team, it just doesn't make sense. Like you will go broke. And so if you're listening and you're in the financial services, this is the kind of what like we went through. Like, I it you've gone you and I went through the same thing, Paul, on this one, which is interesting.
SPEAKER_02
So yeah, probably the same kind of mindset based on our background.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, there's a lot of people that do come from the financial services into insurance, right?
SPEAKER_03
I felt and thought the same way that Paul did, like, oh, this will be friggin' easy. If I can close somebody on a million dollar annuity, getting their auto insurance is easy. Well, sure, sure, it is easy, but guess what? I'm only making 20 bucks. So not 50,000. So I got a problem here, right? Like, I can't do 20 times X equals 50,000 amount of work, like it just isn't possible. Like, there isn't enough hours in the day to make the thousands of dials that I would need to make to do it. So it's interesting. It's just I love it, the different businesses and the different ways they work. But at the end of the day, every business it comes down to the math, and there's some equation that you can figure out how to maximize revenue.
SPEAKER_02
Yep. Just and the reason just to go just to circle back a little the reason why I chose and not to be giving them too much uh advertisement, but the reason why I liked uh Chick-fil-A is they're always packed, doesn't matter, they're right next to a McDonald's and KFC, and they are always packed. And I look at the other two, and there's no one there. You can have the same amount of workers, unlike KFC and McDonald's does, but if you don't have the product and you don't have the people willing to buy pleasure, you're not going to get the business. And that's something that they love to do with uh Chick-fil-A, and it's always my pleasure. So that goes a long way. Just a little customer service. I hate to be going so granular on fast food. But it's it's applicable, yeah.
SPEAKER_01
So, Paul, as we're coming into 2023 and just post-COVID and everything, like where do you see agencies going? What are you looking forward to?
SPEAKER_02
I think for me, looking at 2022 and and on something that uh Craig said, we're always thinking about this on New Year's Eve, which is my brother's birthday. I was sitting there thinking, where is my business going to go for 2023? And when I'm gonna do a little retrospect in June and figure out where I am, where I need to be. And did I do something wrong? Should I change position? Or how is this gonna work? But my main goal right now is hiring. I have the system in place, which I didn't always have, which allows me to be able to say to someone, hey, it will work. You follow the instruction. And here's what others have done and they've been successful. So for me, I think now that I have the process in place, when I started in 2019, I didn't know what I was doing. I was just following what every other agent was doing close by. But for me to grow, I just have to have a process in place that will actually allow my salespeople to do what salespeople are supposed to do. So for me, I don't hire any service people anymore. Those days are gone. I used to, but I'm not doing that anymore because I can do it myself if I need to, and they're not driving revenue for me as much as I've tried to get people to drive revenue. If it's not in your DNA, it's not in your DNA. I shouldn't force you or make you feel uncomfortable having to do something that you don't like to do. So it's usually not a good fit. So for me, I'll say that I'd rather have salespeople, and my goal is to just find salespeople that are willing to work and make usually the number one goal is to make a ton of money. Usually the ones that uh work well for me.
SPEAKER_03
There you go. Well, cool. You went the distance, we went two minutes over than we promised. But Paul, thanks so much. So awesome to have you. Hopefully, we'll see you at one of the elite calls one of these Wednesdays, and then if you're gonna make it out to San Diego, that'd be awesome too. So we'll see you around the corner. Thanks for coming on.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.