The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The Insurance Dudes are on a mission to find the best insurance agentsaround the country to find out how they are creating some of the top agencies. But they do not stop there, they also bring professionals from other industries for insights that can help agents take their agencies to the next level. The Insurance Dudes focus on your agency’s four pillars: Hiring, Training, Marketing and Motivation! We have to keep the sword sharp if we want our agencies to thrive.&nbs...
I think my favorite and uh wildest story is when I first started at the carrier, and I had a lady, she was 83 or 84, she came into my office, and we were all having a little uh meeting with the three LSPs, and all of a sudden she says to me, Who's the owner? And I said, That's me. And she said, I need to talk to you because I don't want you as my owner. First of all, I didn't like your picture that they said to me, and second of all, I didn't pick the owner, so I want to go somewhere else. So I called her into my office. We sat down and I said to her, Um, what's troubling you? She said, Paul, my son just died in California, so I've got in my car and I went to see him. But the problem was I had actually gotten hit the week before, drove by, hit my car, and I had to have it fixed. I kept the rental car longer than the 30 days, and the actual carrier said to me, We're not gonna go over the 30-day limit, you're gonna have to pay for that extra day. And she, first of all, was mad because of that. And then, second, because Carrier said to her, This is gonna be your new agent, you're gonna have to grin and bear it. So I think she was grieving and she was upset about the car being hit when she came from church. And number three, she didn't know who I was and didn't know if I could actually help her. So, to make a long story short, we actually called their firm and said, Hey, could you give her one more day? Her son had passed away, and she was over in California across the country, and she needed that time, that 30 days to get him buried. And and they actually allowed it to happen. And we are close as this now. I'm not an issue, she stays on time, doesn't have an issue. She actually will come to the office when she did, and she's never had an issue with us going forward.
SPEAKER_02
That was a heck of a welcome to the agency.
SPEAKER_03
Yes, and speaking of agency, I am with the Woodburn Agency and I'm an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_01
Insurance dudes are automated to escape being handcuffed by our agents. How? By uncovering the secret to creating a predictable, consistent, and profitable agency sales engine. I am Craig Futzinger. I am Jason Feltman, we are agents, we are insurance dudes.
SPEAKER_00
Woo! Love it. I'll tell you a secret. When a client walks in to Jason's office and says, Who is the owner? I need to talk to the owner, and he's the one standing there. He will say, Hold on, let me go see if I can find her, and then he'll run away. That's not too far from the tree. Right. You maybe you don't say her, but I think I would say her just to really, really make sure that they're clear it's not you.
SPEAKER_03
That's funny.
SPEAKER_00
Uh that's too funny.
SPEAKER_02
Cool. Well, welcome, Paul. I was super excited to have this chat today. I love your background. If you're listening, you don't get to see the awesome picture of St. Thomas in the background. That's the U.S. Virgin Islands, right?
SPEAKER_03
That is correct. My home state, or I shouldn't say state.
SPEAKER_00
So help me understand because you said something about Philadelphia earlier.
SPEAKER_03
Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, then you're saying St. Thomas, and my understanding is they're nowhere near each other.
SPEAKER_03
They're a little far apart. Yeah. Okay, so you you would be correct. You probably got an A in geography, I would say.
SPEAKER_00
No, oh, I I don't highly doubt that.
SPEAKER_03
You didn't get an A.
SPEAKER_00
I went through the American school system. We don't know anything. So do you live in St. Thomas?
SPEAKER_03
I went to school on St. Thomas, and my parents said, Hey, you're going to college. And I said, Okay. And we had someone come down from Wisconsin for college day because we couldn't go anywhere. It's just too expensive, obviously, to go anywhere to actually uh look for colleges. So they said, Hey Paul, why don't you come to Wisconsin? Snow is just like sand, just a little colder. Just take that in for one minute. It's like sand, just a little colder. And you send me to Wisconsin.
SPEAKER_00
I've never heard that one. That is hilarious.
SPEAKER_03
Very optimistic way to describe it. But here's the thing: me being, I was a biology pre-med major with minor. So for me, I said, I'm a smart kid. Here's what I'm gonna do. I know water freezes at 32 degrees. So what I'm gonna do is I'm gonna go down to my little supermarket, get me a jean jacket. That's what I said. Get me a jean jacket. I went back home, I put it on, I opened my freezer, and I said, you know what? It couldn't ever get colder than it does in that ice freezer that I have. And I opened the freezer. I'm like, I'm still warm, I'll be okay in Wisconsin. Minus 20 degrees. No one told me about windshield, so there's windshield, but nobody ever says anything. And I wish I could have found that lady, that recruiter that got six of us to go to Wisconsin. That's how it started.
SPEAKER_00
We need her to work at the office, selling insurance.
SPEAKER_03
You fly it onto an island and tell people to move to Wisconsin. Unbelievable. And we felt that is crazy.
SPEAKER_00
That's a tougher sell than insurance.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, we felt well, we didn't know. We had no inkling as to what was going on. We didn't know when to like I say stuff to my mom now, and I say, Hey mom, it's 20 degrees today, and she'll say, Oh, okay. She doesn't know it's 88. How do you compare 88 every day to 20 degrees?
SPEAKER_00
She doesn't know, and it's always 88, right?
SPEAKER_03
And it's always 88.
SPEAKER_00
Exactly.
SPEAKER_03
At nighttime, she gets a little cold, it gets to 80 at nighttime. She's freezing at 80 degrees at nighttime. So that's the kind of stuff we had to deal with. I think I couldn't stay there any longer, and I moved to Pennsylvania to finish up my college career, and that's how I met a young lady, and uh and I stayed.
SPEAKER_00
You so you stayed at Philadelphia?
SPEAKER_03
So that's kind of my super cool so I stayed in Philadelphia in suburbs of Philadelphia.
SPEAKER_00
So Gino's or what's the other one? Gino's or is it Pat's or the two cheesesteak places? Is it Pats?
SPEAKER_03
I would say Gino's, but for me, I usually don't go to either one. I'm just tourist to be honest. That's more of a tourist, yeah, tourist spot. Kind of like uh when I lived in Seattle, it's watching the guys throw the fish. Right at the fish market. What am I doing?
SPEAKER_00
It is kind of cool.
SPEAKER_03
I've seen people eat fish before.
SPEAKER_00
I don't know why they throw those fish.
SPEAKER_03
Where are we going?
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, same thing. That's dude. I love St. Thomas. My first daughter, but right before she was born, we had friends that went out on a cruise ship in the Bahamas, and my wife was pregnant and was throwing up, so she couldn't go. And like a bonehead, I went, which I couldn't get away with that these days, that's for sure. Oh no. So I went for a week and we went to Saint Thomas and Saint Martin. Is that St. Martin?
SPEAKER_03
Well, it just depends on your yeah, St. Martin.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, well, anyways, and dude, I came back from there and I was I told my wife, I said, We're moving, we're we're moving to St. Thomas. Like this is the best place I've ever been.
SPEAKER_00
Is it like Puerto Rico for tax stuff?
SPEAKER_03
No, I don't know why Puerto Rico has that great tax shelter, but we're territory, so I don't think Puerto Rico is a territory. Unlike Puerto Rico, we're a territory, so we're subsidized by the U.S. government.
SPEAKER_00
I think Puerto Rico's a territory, it's not a state, but I did go to the U.S. uh who knows? It could be a company. Maybe it's a company.
SPEAKER_03
They do not have that uh tax spread.
SPEAKER_00
So you were gonna be a doctor, and instead you became a doctor of insurance.
SPEAKER_03
Correct.
SPEAKER_00
How's that?
SPEAKER_03
I did that. I started off, and then they said you have to do six more years of college. I said, Come on, that's too long. I gotta find something to do, and I gotta find it quick.
SPEAKER_00
So I actually started So six more years of college is just like four years of college, just colder.
SPEAKER_03
You should have been there to to uh problem, just do it, it's just a little colder. Recruit me. You should have been there to recruit me, like the lady from Wisconsin. You should have been there to recruit me anyway. So after college, I decided I'm gonna get a job somewhere, and then uh I'll branch out. So I actually found a job. It wasn't in a hospital, it was actually, and this we used to be my pickup line. I know this doesn't work now, you're not allowed to do it, it's against the rules. But I would say at bars, hey, you I test birth control pills, and I'd be low, you test birth control pills, of course. So my job at that point in time was working in the lab and hit all the birth control pills, and we had to make sure that the estrogen was enough in each batch so that if somebody sued, they would be able to say, Hey, it's not us, it's you. We have essentially the same exact amount of estrogen or whatever it is in each batch that we need, and you just have to go pound sand and be happy you're pregnant. So for me, I was the tester of the birth control pills, and I'm gonna die saying that to my dispatch.
SPEAKER_00
That's amazing. I thought I was gonna say all the things that have just gone through my mind right now. I know you can't it's like you got a silence out of 2023.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, that was just like I said, that was a different time, a different space, and you could get away with saying stuff like that, but now I would never. I'm part of their organization moved to Puerto Rico to try and get the pills to be cheaper, and I was out of a job because last one hired, first one to let go. And back that time there was no career builders, there was no indeed, there was no none of those. And I eventually found a firm that said to me, Hey, we're gonna have you sitting here at a desk, we're not gonna pay you as much. But the good thing is you're gonna get to talk to a lot of rich people. So I said, I'd do that. So I sat there and I would just get calls, and the calls would come in. There was no script, your training was by fire, and I'd sit there from eight to six o'clock every single day and take calls. Hey, I'd like to run an illustration for a hundred thousand for Craig. Could you do that for me? And I'd go there, I'd look at send it to them. They call me back, hey Paul, that actually worked. Could you send me another quote for Jason? 100,000, so I can put that. Paul, that worked. And I did that for a while. And the owners of the company came to me and said, Hey, Paul, you've reached your ceiling. And I knew nothing about annuities, stocks, and bonds, mutual funds. I just went there because I needed to get another job and I had loans to pay. So I'm there working. And he said, Hey, Paul, we have positions that are around the country that you can actually do this as opposed to being internally, you can do it as an external. And I said to him, and this is how I just happenstance to fall into this for 25 years. They just said, Hey, Paul, you can do this outside of the company and we're gonna pay you. So they said to me, Hey, Paul, um, and this is where my US education came in. Sorry, sorry to say that. This is where my US education came in. They said, Hey, we're gonna move you to Washington. And I'm looking, oh, we're in Pennsylvania. Oh, it's right nearby. I'll take Washington any day. Yeah, Washington, DC. I'm in. And I said, No, no, no, Paul. It's Seattle, Washington. So I'm like, Seattle, Washington, what in God's name are you talking about? Seattle, Washington. I have I don't know anything about Seattle, I don't know anything, and I had just gotten married, so I gotta convince my wife, like that lady convinced me, to move from Pennsylvania, where her family is, to move to Seattle. And by the way, Jason, yeah, by the way, Jason, she's pregnant. Uh so that's not happening. I'm trying to sell her. I'm moving to Seattle. We moved to Seattle, so I'm just gonna say it happened, it worked. Um wow, and we moved to Seattle and we were in sale almost five years. And we had, and when I first started the territory, it was actually, I think I was number 34 out of 35 when I started. We ended up in that five-year time frame becoming number seven in the country out of probably a hundred and thirty-five people like myself. Uh, so we did pretty good. I can't complain. And I'll tell you this when you'll find out that everything is always half full. My glass is always half full. It doesn't matter what happens, I think I won on life just by what I accomplished already. Anything I was working on, borrow time because life has been good to me, and I can't complain. I cannot complain. So for me, that 34 out of 35 territory I wasn't happy about, and you're gonna move me from Pennsylvania all the way to Seattle as my prize, and I'm like, why would you send me there? I'm one of your best internal people, and you're gonna reward me by sending me to the 34 out of 35 territory, but it wasn't worked, you just have to persevere, and if you talk to enough people we do now, it turns around. So that's kind of been my mindset, and that's what kind of got me into this is so so take us from there.
SPEAKER_02
How did you get into the agency that you're in today?
SPEAKER_03
Okay, so great question. The market went south, 2001 happened, and the investment firm I was working with decided that hey, Paul, we're gonna give you less of a territory and less of a territory and space and less product. So they cut my territory in half, cut my products that I sold in half, and my wife's grandmom was gravely ill, and she would fly back and forth. She was pregnant and she had our little guy, and she'd fly back and forth from Seattle all the way to Pennsylvania, and it's a flight. So it became tough and it didn't make economical sense. So I said to them, hey guys, I'm glad for the opportunity. I hate to leave you guys after 10 years, but I do have to do what's best in my family's interest. I came back and I looked for something. I found another investment gig, of course, and I stayed there for a little bit until the market tanked again. And this time I'm getting a little older. My kids are almost teenagers, um, getting ready to go to college, and I had to decide whether I can go on this roller coaster as much as I did now because I went somewhere else and I was the number one on person form. The problem is once you get cost cutting, they cost cut, and you're part of the cost cutting, even if you did well. So, what determines that I can stay with the company even if I do as much as I can? What determines that?
SPEAKER_00
Results.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, if the results are there and I still get cut, I gotta find a new solution. So for me, I said I'm not gonna keep doing this over and over again. I gotta decide that I'm gonna try and fend for myself. And if I succeed, I succeed and it's my doing and I get to reap the benefits of it. And if I don't succeed, that's on me too. But at least I'm not gonna fire myself for being successful. So that's how I got into this. And I tried a whole couple, I'm not gonna give out all the results because I thought they were really good. But I'll tell you one. I tried to go into Chick-fil-A. I don't know if you know how Chick-fil-A works, but they're fantastic. No money up, you don't put any money down, they pay you a salary, you just have to be there, and they build a store for you, do all that stuff for you. And all you do is stay there and you have to do it for two years, I think, and then the third year you're on your own, which is a fantastic model that I would in a minute. It's tough to get in, and you're absolutely right. It's tough to get in. But that was one of them that I looked at that I thought was going to be a phenomenal, phenomenal story, but it just didn't work. Not that this isn't just as good or better. I don't have to stay uh there on the weekends and at nighttime and miss out on my family, but that was one of the things. Check cashing was another one, which my wife is like, You're crazy. Who would check cash? But it just depends, ROI and and if it makes sense for you as a business. But that was kind of where I was going to at least try to stay. And I ended up saying, I want to stay where I'm still kind of in the investment world, but I'd still have people and what to do the uh retail space, which is extremely tough and hard on someone. Work life balance was was going to be tough.
SPEAKER_00
So tough to balance in those places that are not office hours. Correct. It's tough. That's interesting. Uh chickway.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.