The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
The Terrific Toby Hedges Totally Tipsy In Mississippi PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
thing that ever happened in my agency was this guy came in for a quote we thought had overalls on looked wet didn't have shoes on had sock wet socks on and just kind of yeah and was just talking to us and and said he needed help and I said where you been he said I've been in the field praying like okay and so we just sat there and text each other like what do we do and she said my office manager at the time said don't give him a ride and luckily he just eventually left so oh did you see where he went no we we kind of watched but I think he went next door or something that's probably the one of the wildest things and uh I'm Toby Hedges uh from Tupelo Mississippi and I'm an insurance dude right now while it's fresh in your mind check out live.televents dot com.
SPEAKER_01We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_02Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years. On this call you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results. Just go to live doteledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_01If you jump on this call with us we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there. Boom boom yeah I have a follow up culture for that it was like from the mid-calf down what was your methodology of testing wetness the color difference oh going from light khaki to dark khaki oh okay so the khakis were wet khaki yeah yeah and it was like okay and I said what were you doing?
SPEAKER_00He said I was just been he said I've been out in the field okay what were you doing out in the field? He said I was praying so that's it no fall yeah and so we just kind of sat there and from what I remember he just he just left you should have said if you're praying for water it looks like you got it yeah sounds like something you do here in Arizona pray for water you can walk around this town all day long and not get wet yeah Toby I love you you have a cigar in there lit up I do yeah love it you're you're our first cigar smoking insurance dude on the podcast on the podcast yeah yeah I was just Jennifer goes you did on the on the teledudes yeah it was about after lunch and cigars pretty good after lunch and I just started smoking a cigar yeah love it love it yeah have you had any whiskeys today today I have not uh not yet no not yet yeah not yet not yet that's later young yeah they go real good with the with the cigar along with the bloody Mary so that just depends so it depends on how many how many hang ups I can take when I need a drink I like that the whiskey goes good with the cigar and the bloody Mary yeah right the the you're yeah so have you ever had um a Bloody Mary with gosh I'm I'm a little unschooled at the moment but the the smoky uh whiskey like Mezcal that's not whiskey but it's a bloody Maria yeah yeah I haven't but now they're doing all these uh whiskeys where you can like turn the glass upside down and smoke it you know and all this jazz stuff and uh I just get a cigar and smoke it blow it and drink drink it's like you started why as men I think or dudes do we when we have something great we have to tinker with it yes and wreck it yeah I don't know if y'all drink but you go into the liquor stores now there's just gobs of choices of whiskeys and tequilas and the choices are mind-numbing you know we we complicated it I mean I went to the ATM machine the other day okay just gonna take out some cash there's five six steps I said where where was a time when I've just put my card in put my code and got cash you know right now I have to choose language what account what kind of cash quick cash fast cash ten dollars you know upsell downsell right do you want to open an account do you want to buy a policy right yeah so anyways it's just uh you're right so we tinker with it and seem like we want to donate three dollars of it yeah right you sound you sound remarkably like Matthew McConaughey has anyone ever told you that yeah yeah all right all right all right all right yeah there we go that was gonna be the test I taught a I taught an insurance class you know for them to take you have to sit so many hours in Mississippi and and we'd go over the test and one girl said that she goes you're gonna like talk like Matthew McConaughey and she said to say that all right all right yeah so I had to just had to do it in class in that class so well that was that yeah I wish we could get an audience like that selling insurance because they pay attention and and learn some stuff. Doesn't he say in Remember Days of Confused isn't that where all right all right all right came from I think it was yeah I don't even think you know what I'm not gonna quote the line because I don't want to be quoted saying the line so never mind let's just move on oh that was great that's good quality podcast so Toby what's a whiskey totin cigar smoking dude like you how did you get into this crazy business of insurance well I started originally from Arkansas and did an intern at UCA well for Northwestern Mutual at University of Central Arkansas that's where Scotty Pippen played ball and uh was always yeah yeah so I always liked people talking carrying on having a good time I knew that uh some people that I knew were in insurance business and were successful uh and so I interviewed there and they didn't want me at the time they were looking for somebody else I didn't have the experience I was 22 and so I interviewed with a company I'm with now and uh they they didn't want me over there in Arkansas and so I ended up getting a friend of the family and ended up in supposed to be in Oxford Mississippi ended up Tuvolo Mississippi so started a scratch agency in Mississippi didn't know anybody in the state or the town and started doing it saw some success liked most of it and then uh liked the the freedom and the challenges and that's just kind of where how all got started and I just knew that I didn't I didn't know if I could live in the corporate environment of all the stuff that happens you know the bureaucracy or whatever that stuff is that you call it you know I like to be in not the choir the preacher but in the congregation I can do and say what I want to you know yeah 100% yeah so that's how I kind of got into it yeah yeah well I guess the majority can live in that world right but I mean yeah you me Jason and everybody listening are not cut from that mold. No I I just you know you would have meetings probably like this you know there was a issue at one company where they weren't getting people to turn in their time cards you know to get paid what are we gonna do about them not turning their time cards I think my dad yeah my dad was at the meeting he said don't pay them don't pay them they'll turn in the time card you had to have a meeting about this you know well they probably had eight meetings about it I know so you know anyways that's just I think that I certainly couldn't do it now. Yeah not that anything's wrong with it but I don't know I just I just know that nothing's guaranteed except you know death and taxes certainly death so your money's not guaranteed so it's just fun to have some control over it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah and I I think it's exciting both ways sometimes you have real good months sometimes you have bad months but you just you keep going so yeah so you must have had some some nice wins in the beginning to kind of get your beak wet and and get you excited about this.
SPEAKER_00Yeah can you take us back to something that besides the guy with his wet gag well yeah wet gaggy what was that early win that to think um one of the neatest ones was uh when I first started I'd go give business cards out and what I did a little Snickers two or three Snickers two or three business cards and uh I just go around I'd introduce myself that's all I'd say and this lady came in and wanted a quote on a commercial building and I said well how'd you hear about me she goes you came in the office some time ago and left Snickers and a business card ended up writing her business car life everything that and then also seeing where when I would door knock or I'd go see somebody and leave a brochure and they'd call back and then ask how they heard about me. That and then you know there's incentive trips that you can earn earned one of those and there was an agent uh that found out that I wasn't hired in a certain place and said what happened why didn't we get this guy you know so that was some of those things and then of course I had a lady one day text me and she said she was uh thank you for spending so much time with her just listening and talking to her and I forget that because we get to hurrying and doing so that side of it's pretty powerful um what we can do with a pen and ensuring people and most of us certainly this group of guys and gals are doing it for the right reasons. Yeah and so seeing somebody this house is and I what really solidified it for me was in uh I think it was 2014. You know you hear we're gonna do this we're gonna pay we're awesome blah dah da and then actually seeing the tornado that came through our area and watching what the company did we showed up we paid there was no problems nobody complained that they didn't get paid and so seeing that believing and seeing you know is what so that's the the the biggest thing I think that slowly over time yeah solidified it for me you know and all this all this other stuff is trying to get to that point. It's just there's it's gotten so hairy to get to the people now.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_02So so yeah so Toby you're you are a one man shop right now. Right right now tell me yeah so so has your team have you grown it and and talk about like the team over time.
SPEAKER_00Yeah well at first when it I had it was me and a office manager secretary whatever we want to call that and that was that way for a while and then the company I work with started throwing out little nuggets where you could get an affiliate this set and the other and so I had hired a couple people to call certain times and I think I did that at the wrong time. So basically kind of what what I'm doing with the teledudes but it was a different version did that and then I hired a person to come in and sell be a producer and it just wasn't his what he was wanting to do. And then COVID happened and I was seeing the business change before then a lot of online lot of texting a lot of calling not coming in just the the the the way the consuming public bought it and so now I'm just me and then plan to get some more producers or hire producer at some point in time. So that's kind of how it's how it's evolved and we're a slow and our company's slow and steady growth think like barbecue you know low and slow. And uh I don't know when they're gonna figure it out but there's a few agents that are figuring out that this is not going to work anymore. We're gonna have to start doing some things a little different what does it look like I mean I think there's next person I'm probably gonna look and hire and is probably going to be a what do they call it virtual sales type person you know that person could be anywhere. So yep that's that's kind of what I'm seeing and um I had an agent one time said you're all by yourself? How do you do it? I said hell I'm good. You know he he laughed and I said but I'm just real who I try to write get it all done and so on and so forth so that's kind of where I where I've been and then you know had a couple kids and youngest one has is autistic so that takes a little bit more time. So we've had to adjust what I'm gonna do and how I'm gonna do it.
SPEAKER_02And so that's kind of where I'm at I mean the next thing I'd like to I'd like to find some producers but that's pretty much I feel like Nick Saban here that's pretty much you know how we got to let you go well you know let's let you go well you know yeah yeah so you run out no I think yeah I think the one man show so there you know there's we come across a lot of one man shops every once in a while and it's like uh you you always have such a great attitude and great outlook especially in the it you know the teledudes elite meetings and you're one man shop and you truly do enjoy like talking to your clients and and you love what you do and it's so cool. It's like uh it's a very cool perspective on it and not there's not a lot of people doing that these days like you said things are changing and stuff but you've you know now you got uh telemarketer and you you're you're doing things to to make yourself more available so it's pretty cool man yeah it's just we've got there's some agents I mean you can do whatever you want to of course you know like there's two or three or four or five but you can and I've done it I've grown too fast you know when I had an intern and and I had a person calling and I had an office manager and me and it just didn't work you know and so now I don't know what that's gonna look like but I think it's gonna be to where we're gonna do the teledudes because there's no other way that I've learned to how to get business besides calling people.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00I mean I I I've done it since 1998 you know with door knock and call it what we've always done. And even back in some of the literature and stuff that I've read back in the 50s it was the same way. When somebody came in for a quote there was a problem. You know there was you couldn't write them. So I've stopped all of my advertising and I'm just solely focused on stirring up outbound stuff by by the phone and so on and so forth. And I love it. And that's just what I've seen and you know why do I want to you know people say why are you buying leads Toby? I mean that's a lot of money and I was like well do you have a billboard? Yes how much you paying for that billboard a month oh 300 bucks okay for them to call you at least I can 300 bucks or whatever it is yeah I mean I don't know and so pretty expensive. Yeah so that's to get their eyeballs on it instead I'm like I I'd rather have a phone number and I can call them to try to so that's just what I've seen and I and I've tried all the different things and nothing else seems to seems to work.
SPEAKER_02We talked to some indie agents that have some good automations rolling and the version of contact rate that you get from just texts is pretty low. Like you still even with the great automated stuff that you can do on the independent side that we can't do as captives because you know we got some handcuffs on but right uh besides that like like they're they're still having to get people on the phone there's still a lot of waste if they're not I know some agents that aren't and they're wasting a lot of leads you know it's like let us call them then you know uh because I guarantee you we're gonna get a lot more people on the phone and and at the end of the day even if you are texting back and forth uh you still need to talk to them at some point at some point the conversation ends up on the phone right so I don't think there's any way to get around that you know right yeah and nowadays it's like the importance of contacting people like if you're in person it's really important and if it's on the phone it's really important and it goes back to email and whatever else.
SPEAKER_00So nowadays in a doubt call them you know yep they may not answer you know but yeah eventually it's gonna have to come back to the phone call I mean there's an 85% chance they won't answer today. Yeah I mean it's just and I've never understood it in a world where we're so connected we can get in touch with everybody easier but we're so disconnected yeah you know don't call me text me you know or I mean that's fine but I mean this is insurance we got to talk you know I mean I I mean I've done some things that I've written policies over text now you know because it just I couldn't get them and so I did it that way. But yeah I there's just a bunch of tools out there and there is you've got to figure out which ones you want to use and and do it. But it the human's still going to be involved.
SPEAKER_02Yeah I mean it's funny too because you see a lot of agents that are so heavy on the tools right they're all in on the automation and they they just poo-poo any of the old school sales methods and then you have the old schoolers that just absolutely won't use any of the tools they're just true to heart of the way it used to be but man it's like dude the combination of the both is the true magic. It's like going into you know go if you have both skills where you're the old school sales door knocking telemarketing type of dude and you mix that with all the cool tools that you have to really amplify your skills there's no stopping you.
SPEAKER_00Yeah that's what kind of what I'm doing I'm doing the teledudes and then I've got in the community I'm a member of the Realtors Board and the the mortgage bankers and then the community development foundation has a our chamber has a thing where you can be affiliate uh uh ambassadors where we can go to ribbon cuttings and such so oh cool I was thinking about mixing that stuff up and it's like this is what I need to do this gets me out there amongst the people a lot of times the same people but out there and then do the calling and you know just let it rip now the biggest thing I'll tell y'all this story this is I had I think I was sitting outside at my other house had a cigar had a good whiskey and I just it hit me. So you're relaxed I relaxed yeah it hit me and I said I started thinking about two things claims okay and retention since I started if somebody had a claim I would make a note and call them a week later you know be something like Jason just calling you seeing the claims going that was it you know and uh I'd call my lapses you know people that lapse I'd call them did it still do it today and I went oh my gosh my retention has stayed where it is you know it'd go up a little bit go down a little bit but it'd stay right there and then claims I'd probably lost a couple of people over 20 years because of claims too and it wasn't because you know things happen but and I went oh my gosh but guess what I've changed all the time and since 98 what marketing how to sell insurance whiskey whiskey too right but I mean I would go this way and I'd go this way and I'd advertise over here I call over here I do this I do that so I never did it long enough to bingo so I'm like my gosh you know and so I guess I'd get frustrated because it wasn't happening so fast.
SPEAKER_01You know I want it and I want it now before it was cool you know right and well that's uh that's our mentality right that's how we are as Americans or humans or business owners or whatever is we want it yesterday right yeah yep and so that's the I think that's you know part of the whole the whole function of the Teledudes elite and the group and and all of that is to help manage that part of it right is is help manage that piece because we went through it you know and we didn't have anybody else like we were we were out there figuring it out and I mean it was years of struggle and then when I finally broke through I mean I almost can't quit yeah I mean yeah that's part of your yeah yeah yeah Jason Jason told you just to or that spend more money no big deal that's right that's right but it's funny like when when the shift happens because I was terrified and I was watching every dollar oh okay and once I let go of that fear or I mean the fear was there sure the fear still comes back but being able to identify it and go okay that's just the fear you know like the all the what ifs but I don't need to what if this thing to death I have proof right I have proof over here we did 300k in one month we did 250 we did 270 like we were doing it and so it's like I know it's there I know we have the format right and it's just I just love that it's math you know like there's no and all those other things that I've done because I've tried everything and I've done every different possible thing that there is like we never really dove into the math and we never did it long enough and I think anything can work if you do it and you do it consistently right just keep doing it. You go knock doors you're not gonna get results today but if you do it every day you're gonna start closing people right is that the most effective use of of your time probably not right like no if I could just say I know if we quote 10 people we're gonna close one okay great so how many leads do I have to buy to quote 10 people okay great you know how many dials do I need if I'm gonna buy that many it's like having all of the analytics and numbers makes it very simple right to just execute on a marketing plan and then watch it go and know it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah I know or yeah and you would think that I mean there was times I would ask questions of the company and say hey what How do we do this? How do we do that? You know, they'd give you stuff and then not know how to get there, you know? Right. And so that was that was the pr you know, it's like I mean, McDonald's can tell you what where you need, you know, they've got like the franchise has some information. So there really was uh there really wasn't anything to follow besides what you what you thought to do, you know. And so like when I first I think I Googled, I don't know how I got on the podcast first thing. I heard that, and then I don't remember, started looking and then started chit-chatting wondering, I think Greg or somebody about the cost and this and that, and they're you know, hesitating on is this would this work, is this not gonna work, is you know, are they gonna answer the phone? Is this scan you know, all the crap that we you know go through? Are they gonna uh I mean I'm from Mississippi. I think I'm the only Mississippi person that I know of that buys leads. I think I'm the only one that does the teledude. So are they gonna answer the phone, you know, all this stuff? And I just, you know, decided one day I said, well, let me just do it and see what happens. And I started May 16th, and I told myself, I'm not gonna look at this hard at all until a year. That's so May 16th of next year. Now, some of your Lenny and some of the guys are gonna look at some numbers just to kind of see where if I'm kind of doing what I'm supposed to do and blah, blah, blah, and just to check in. And I'm just gonna see what it looks like then, you know. And I I mean, I can see what I've quoted and because Shelter keeps up with that. You know, they have a yeah, you know, you quoted so many, and so you're you know, you want to be like 30%, one out of three is what we are. So every three people we quote, we typically write one. Uh you don't want to get too high or too low. If you're too high, you're writing you're not quoting enough, you're too low, you're so and then I looked one day and said, Okay, how many, how many calls does it take to get the quote, you know? And then when I saw your thing that you did, that funnel, I still got a picture of it. I went, There it is. There it is. Because I mean the quote the numbers that you had, like the percentage and whatever, it was really close. And that's all I mean. Yeah, I mean and sometimes on the yeah, yeah, and sometimes on the the teled calls, sometimes I mean I some of them don't want to go too deep, and that's fine, you know. But for me, I know that the longer I look at the numbers, that's two or three people I could have called or whatever. But right, right. For me, that was my problem. I analyzed too much, and then greatest thing my wife taught me, she said, I said, I want to find out XYZ. She goes, Okay, what are you gonna do with that information? I was like, I don't know. Well if you don't know what you're gonna do with it, why the hell are you gonna get it? Right. You know, so just stuff like that that just makes you wonder, and sometimes you just want to know, but right you don't need to know, you know. So yeah, it's just interesting. And a lot of people tell me that I have the the skill set to not figure people out, but communicate with them and get them to comfortable to talk to you and because that's what you gotta do eventually, is like, hey, look, you know, this you ain't gotta buy this stuff. I just like to talk to you about it, you know.
SPEAKER_02I think that's one of the the keys, I think, to well when I see like you know, when I see our team get on that, and I think most salespeople do it, they go on the uh the the sales roller coaster, I call it. Yeah, you know, right? And when they're when they're high, they're high, and they sound great and they're not worried about sales. Because they're not worried about sales, they're talking to people and they're excited, so they're talking about all kinds of stuff, you know, and then they go down on those down swings on the roller coaster and they don't sound as fun, and then they get worried about their sales, so they're gonna get off. Uh, if you don't want to buy, I'm gonna go to the next call, right? And it's like so they're they're they're taking out the chit chat, they're cutting corners on the quote, right? And they're wondering, oh, these leads suck. Yeah, it's like, dude, you're not the same dude a week ago on the phone. You were excited, you talked to that dude for 30 minutes and he told you no. And then finally, after the 40-minute mark, he said yes. At 35 minutes, he was not gonna buy from you. You know what I mean? Like and and that's what you see, and then it's like, but they don't see it, you know? But it's it's a hundred percent what you're saying. You don't think about your wants. Like, if you're thinking about I just want to sell it, you're not gonna sell it.
SPEAKER_00No, that I don't and I don't know how they know it, but they do. Um, what somebody called it commission breath. Yeah, yeah. Uh I they do. I mean, they just think whatever it is. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So it's just Vegas knows about it too. Like, if you get desperate at the end and you go, you know what, screw it. I put it all in. What happened?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, exactly. Yeah, get out of here.
SPEAKER_01It's like every time, same thing. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I think that's the uh I think you actually have to you kind of have to get your mind right, like playing a football game or something.
SPEAKER_02100%. Hey, what are you still doing here? Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, if you weren't listening before, we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents throughout the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_02Using these strategies did help Craig and I write over $20 million in free in the last couple of years.
SPEAKER_01And let me tell you, on this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same results.
SPEAKER_02Again, that's live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_01And if you jump on with us, we are certain that 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman