The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Zach Farris Flying Fairly Fast For Future Freedom PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
All right, so the wildest thing has ever happened in my agency was uh we were doing uh an event here for the local community, and one of our staff members ran to a mascot store, and we don't have a mascot, so they came back in a penguin costume and were holding up signs, come get your insurance quote, and with big arrows, and actually it drew a lot of attention. So uh people were like stopping by, like, what's this? and they uh you know did their quotes or whatever to be in the raffle and everything. But I was just like, you know, John, what are you doing, bro? He's like, What? He's like, I just wanted to come in with a little flare. And so my name is uh Zach Ferris with Fort Creator Insurance, and our corporate headquarters are in Longview, Texas, and I'm an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_00I are agents now. I am profitable and profitable agents. I am a great profit. I am agent. We are agents, we are insurance. Right now, while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_01We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_00Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years. On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results. Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us. If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
SPEAKER_01Boom! Welcome. Zach. So why the pig one? Like of all the choices that were there.
SPEAKER_02I have no clue. I was like, dude, you could have came back with like a shark or something like a dinosaur with the little worms. Right. Velociraptor, even. I mean, my favorite. Yeah. But he comes with a penguin. I'm like, bro, this makes us look weak.
SPEAKER_00Like the level of fierceness was pretty low. Right. Yeah. At least he didn't come back as a turtle.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. Unless it was a teenager.
SPEAKER_00Unless he's a teenage, exactly.
SPEAKER_02That would have been perfect. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Crazy. Crazy, crazy. All right. Well, Zach, we'd love to know how you got in this crazy business of insurance.
SPEAKER_02Man, so I got started back in 2014, and I actually started as a farmer's agency owner. So, you know, coming out of college, I was like, hey, let's uh just want to be an entrepreneur and didn't know what that looked like. And I just did a bunch of different interviews and basically how to own my own business and stumbled upon farmers, and so that's what I did. I was thrown to the wolves, essentially. You know, they take you on their farmers training, international training, whatever in Grand Rapids, Michigan. And man, I just got in the trenches and started selling auto home policies and never looked back. Was there for about three years? We did two million in revenue, and um we had over 37 producers working for us at the time.
SPEAKER_0037?
SPEAKER_0237. Dang. So, I mean, we were, you know, I grew up in a small town, so it was one of those things that's like everybody locally know like knew who I was, and then when I started, I opened the agency, like all my buddies started coming out of the woodworks from high school who it played sports with, and they all wanted to come work and make a lot of money.
SPEAKER_01That's awesome.
SPEAKER_02And so we were, you know, we blew it up, man. We did um in the first year we had about 12, 12 producers. We took off really fast when we got our 12th producer. We were writing about 115 to 130 policies a month, which doesn't seem like a lot. You only got 13 producers, but these are people that didn't have any insurance experience. Yeah, I didn't really know how to coach, you know. It's like you don't have time to really coach them either. Right. You're you're juggling that with being the HR, being the payroll, being the everything, the everything, right? Policies yourself because you don't want them to write more than you.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you're a firefighter at that point where it's just like anything that needs to get done, you're just hitting it.
SPEAKER_02Exactly.
SPEAKER_01It's funny how you go to the trading and you think, okay, I'm gonna learn everything I need to know to run this agency here, and you learn how to like log in and work the program, yeah, but nothing like that actually applies to owning the business. And it's just like, What's there's a lot, you know, you're just drinking out of a fire hose for the first year first five years, maybe.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's nuts. So let's continue that journey. How did you leave farmers and then open up?
SPEAKER_02So I would say about my second year, I kept getting blown up by recruiters to go the independent route from different IMOs, clusters, etc. And then I finally landed on um a franchise model company like Brightway, Goosehead. Uh so I ended up going with Goosehead. I invested in a franchise with them. And uh what made me go into that was with farmers, you know, if you have bad credit, you're you're not very competitive. And unfortunately, I was marketing to my age when I first started, right? So you either don't have credit or you have horrible credit because everybody's got student loans or they're buying boats because they work at the refineries and their debt to income is super high, so which tanks their credit. So I was like, man, I need to do something. I mean, yeah, we're killing it, but I'm like, if I can do all these different carriers when it's super price competitive for my natural market, then why not do it? And so I just took that leap of faith and did it. And sure enough, I tripled my revenue in the next four years when I worked with Goosehead. So yeah, it was a huge, huge win. And um, you know, working with them as an uh franchise E, it was it was cool. I mean, it was it's working for a franchise, right? You're your franchisee, you're a business owner. Uh everybody's gonna have their their pros and cons. And I just figured I was like, man, like after that fourth year, I was like, man, I I feel like I can do this better and solve problems that weren't being solved within their agency with the rise of technology and just build up my own franchise similar model or IMO. And so that's what landed me with Fort Creator, and here we are almost two years in, and uh we're we're rocking and rolling. We just started marketing this model in January, and we've I think we just brought on our 23rd agent, and we haven't even started marketing yet. So, you know, I just ran my first Google ad for a thousand bucks last week. But we closed two deals on it.
SPEAKER_01There you go.
SPEAKER_00Wow, two deals, two deals all cost of sales 500 bucks. What's the ROAS on that? That is fantastic.
SPEAKER_02Well, if I tell you that, you're gonna be like, wow. So our to join us, it's it's 10k.
SPEAKER_00Cool. So you know, so so you at home can figure that out. Exactly. Yeah, that's a good uh ROAS right there. Well, congratulations on that. It's huge, man. Appreciate it.
SPEAKER_01So when you first started in the in the business, right? You're drinking through the fire hose, you're trying to figure everything out, and it was probably not the most exceptional experience at the beginning, right? What was the first thing that tipped and you're like, you know what? I really do love this. This is this is awesome.
SPEAKER_02I think just the competitive nature of the business.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02You know, I grew up playing sports my whole life. I feel like there's no one that works harder than me, honestly. Like when it came to sports, schoolwork, just anything, man. So, like when I first started in the trenches, I was literally doing so many quotes, I couldn't even put them in the system. Because you know, you know, they had you start out doing quote sheets, right? The old school, writing them on pen and paper. And I would literally my training coordinator at the time, I think her name was Samantha. I was literally just feeding her quotes, and she was putting them in the system, quoting them for me. I mean, I think my first month, I want to say I did 76 policies myself.
SPEAKER_01Woo!
SPEAKER_02Because, you know, it's a you're like it's your natural market, right? We're just starting and yeah, selling all your friends and family. And like, I mean, I killed it the first three months, and then it's like, oh shoot, how do I get more leads? And that's when your referral network, you know, and that starts coming into play, your referral partnerships, and just trying different things. Your web leads, your social media leads, and funnels and all that stuff was coming around that time. And Facebook ads were getting they were pretty huge right when I started in all the different industries. So that's when they were like coming around.
SPEAKER_01So that was the wild, wild west back then.
SPEAKER_02Man, Facebook ads. Was it man? You could put all kinds of things on there to get clickbait, yeah. And you could target, yeah.
SPEAKER_00You could target analytics, very, very targeted demographics for sure. I don't know if I can say this on here, but I'm going to. Yeah, as if no one yeah. Uh nobody listens. But yeah, like like one of the fun things was to like target Home Depot, you know, like like Home Depot or FedEx and all that. It was so much fun to be able to talk directly to them. Hey, do you work at Home Depot? Check this out. Get your insurance discount today.
SPEAKER_01The FedEx package. Yeah. I mean, yeah, it was amazing. You just those were leads, right? Like just one after the other, just pour it in at like under a buck. 50 cents, 70 cents. It's just like, what the hell? And they answered the phone, or you could messenger them, like, oh, so great. We're at those days gone.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. It was so good. Yeah. Those are the opportunities that you need to jump on. Absolutely. People like Gary V, like we were talking about earlier. You he gets it. Like, he yeah, yeah. But I think in that case, we would uh we'd probably jump on that as well now after going through that. But um, I digress. Let's get a little bit back into the agency. Um, describe your team right now and their roles in the agency.
SPEAKER_02Okay, yeah. So we have uh our corporate team, we have executive management, we have myself, the CEO, and uh board member, and we have Shannon Nakua. She's our COO, she has a background in software, she's a software executive, so she's really she's really helped scale and grow the agency to new heights. We have our CTO, um Bob Davidoff. His background is computer science, computer programming. He uh mines Bitcoin all over the world for governments. Um don't know if I'm supposed to say that. So if I did, Bob, sorry, buddy.
SPEAKER_01Um let's call him Frank.
SPEAKER_02Frank, there we go. His name's Frank.
SPEAKER_00Frank.
SPEAKER_02Um there you go. And then we have uh let's say we get Kelly, Kelly Long, and her husband Steven both work for us. Uh Steven is our business development manager, Kelly's our corporate training director, and um Stephen was my best man in the wedding. So usually I don't hire friends, you know, but made an exception. I know he's a hard worker, and so so yeah, that's that's why we brought that team on. They're fantastic, though. They've Kelly, her training of the like the agents and giving them all the marketing resources, she's fantastic. Her background's in education, she was a teacher, but it's a perfect spot to put her because she knows how to teach. So she's just teaching agents how to do everything in our systems, etc., and how to be an agent. Yeah. And then as far as that, I mean we have a couple advisors and some consultants that work with us um on the board. Uh, we have Alejandro and then Michael. They have experience uh raising capital for companies, so they're helping us with that process uh at this point in time. So we are you know, we're we're rapidly expanding and always trying to to make deals, right? So that's the name of the game.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Cool. How about the culture in your agency? How's that uh read that and get that going?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so you know, with COVID, right? I mean, really, we got started right when COVID was right in the middle of it. So I saw how all these insurance carriers were starting to do things like openly. I mean, openly's got an all virtual team, they don't even have an office, right? So they all communicate via Slack and some other areas, uh, I guess like emails and stuff like that. But I hate emails. I get inundated with them. So we actually utilize Slack in our agency as well. And so what we do is to create that culture and that feel, right? As if you're coming in the office working with us is to uh they'll do a little intro video, tell us like the questions I haven't asked is like, hey, what's your favorite dessert? What's your favorite meal if we were to go to a restaurant? What's your favorite beverage? The reason I ask those questions because I want to be intentional and personal with them. And what I do for all the the new people, I send them their, I order them their favorite dessert when they get started and send it to their house. That's a great idea. So just doing something that shows that you care about them and you know you know some of their favourite favorites. It's like going on a date or having a relationship with someone, you you get to know their favorite color, etc. So that's what we kind of do in our agency. We make it like a family feel as much as we can virtually and um and just go at it that way. We have weekly calls and and meetings where everybody, you know, videos required because I want to see your smiling face, right? And I want to see if you're having a bad day and stuff like that. But honestly, everybody's like family, and I think that we are that way because we ask those those personal questions.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So it's fully virtual now? Yep. No office.
SPEAKER_02Well, we have we have an office, but it's like a honestly, it's a virtual office, right? So it's just it's just because insurance carriers require an office, right?
SPEAKER_01So there's a mailing address or whatever, but yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So I mean I do go to Longview every once in a while to pick up the mail. But for the most part, we are um everyone's virtual and it seems to be working fantastic.
SPEAKER_01So is it like with training and everything? Is that is that challenging, or is it just like how did you how did you adjust to that? Take us through that. Because I know a lot of people are talking about virtual employees now.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so we just developed an online virtual thing, and um and Kelly actually, so for example, we we try to get about at least five agents onboarding at a time. And so when we do that, you know, Kelly's able to walk them through all the videos that she's created on like our SOPs and uh standard operating procedures, all of the software we use and and how to basically essentially how to get paid. If you don't put your, you know, if you don't put your clients' information in our system, there's no way for us to track it and pay you. So she's developed videos over time. There's some people that want to just look go back and and watch the video because you're getting like drinking fire through a water hose, right? We're giving you so much information about how to utilize our system that uh we want them to be able to go and reference it back. So it's been working great though. Um, I will say the challenge is tying down a time that fits for everyone because sometimes sometimes you're gonna get somebody who's part-time, although that's not really who we're looking for, right? But when we first started out, we were making exceptions for people.
SPEAKER_01Gotcha.
SPEAKER_00Well, what are you doing like to recruit people? Like how are you recruiting?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so we have business development managers and um so BDMs, and we have uh headhunters that I contract. So they're just pounding the phones, LinkedIn, posting job ads for us.
SPEAKER_00Is that an ongoing process for you? It is.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it is. And and then we run ads, right? So we're running Google ads to to target recruiting agencies, uh, agency owners or agents who want to move from captive to independent, independent agents who already are their own agency owners, they can roll their book to us. What we do is we're taking the the extra payroll off. We're gonna do a commission split, but if you're not having to pay payroll, it it kind of is gonna make up for that with our commission splits and our profit sharing that we're gonna do with them anyways.
SPEAKER_00Cool, cool, love that. What are some of the complaints that you get from people with captives and indies that are that are coming over?
SPEAKER_02I would say with captives, they're man, they're they're very, they're just all skeptical, they're all over the place, right? Because, you know, like for me, when I was with Farmersland, that's they hound that on you, they brainwash you. They're like, uh, you know, they're not A-rated carriers, they're surplus lines, blah, blah, blah. That's what we hear from our district managers all the time. It's like only farmers, you know, only farmers, only, only whoever. It doesn't matter, it doesn't have to be farmers, it could be somebody else. The other big dogs, like State Farm, or it could be, you know, all state, it can be whoever.
SPEAKER_01How many producers do you have in your agency?
SPEAKER_02So we just hired our um, or we just not hired, but we just took on our 23rd.
SPEAKER_01Gotcha. And what would you say your most effective training tip is when you're bringing them on? Oh man.
SPEAKER_02I mean, be persistent. You know, be persistent. I mean, as far as the training tip, it's it's it's very easy to get complacent in the insurance world and just sit on your renewals. But you have to think like a business owner because if you have no new business coming in, your loss ratios are gonna go up, go up, your profitability goes down, and more than likely you can get terminated uh for having your loss ratios too high.
SPEAKER_00Since you're dealing with so many agencies, what that's got to be challenging to how do you manage that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I mean, you know, everybody comes in under our master code, so it is a little challenge. The way we combat that, right, is to write new policies. And so that's what we're big on and train on. And so we give them the training and and marketing resources in order to do that because some of these people, like we have agents that inherited books from their grandpa's or grandmothers, right? So they just have they just want different options in general because they don't know what to do. I'm dealing with one agent right now that's literally just reshopping their current book and not prospecting. I'm like, no, like that's your loss ratio is so high right now because you're not getting new business. And she's like, Well, how do I get that down? I said, You had to write new business. And she's like, Well, how? I was like, Well, you need to get out and do some marketing, do ref get referral partners, like go to loan officers, go to realtors, home builders, make those relationships. And we get her all those, we get her all that um the training to do that by you have to bring something of value to them, right, in order for them to want really want to do business with you. Yep.
SPEAKER_00Hey, what are you still doing here? Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, if you weren't listening before, we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_00Using these strategies did help Craig and I write over 10 million in premium in the last couple years.
SPEAKER_01And let me tell you, on this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same results.
SPEAKER_00Again, that's live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_01And if you jump on with us, we are certain that 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman