The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Miguel Makes Moves, Manufactures Mayhem Magic More Magestically! PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
What are some of the biggest changes that you see in the next couple of years that are affecting our agencies? And uh really what can you do? What what are you planning on doing to hedge that?
SPEAKER_03Well, you know, from my point of view, it's technology, right? I mean, things seem to be changing. And, you know, I'm a technology person, right? In fact, you know, when I when I was working as a sport agent, that was that's one of the things that I was in charge of also creating a database for mailing purposes and things like that. So I've always been on top of technology and just figuring out how to do things more efficiently.
SPEAKER_01Right now, while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_02We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years.
SPEAKER_02On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results.
SPEAKER_01Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_02If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there. Last thing you want to hear a producer say is, okay, so I'll follow up in six months. Oh, oh.
SPEAKER_03And you know, I mean, and it does happen. And, you know, I mean, I mean, it could get tiring and discouraging sometimes, you know, and so I think that causes producers and even us sometimes to to kind of feel like like we um we should just move on to the next person. But if you do that with everybody, then before you know it, you know, I mean, everything is gonna seem that way, and you're not gonna find opportunities where there might as well there could have been some.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So we've talked about hiring, we've talked about training, we've talked about motivating. What are you doing to make it rain in your agency? What are you doing for marketing? For marketing, well, you know, we're doing obviously web leads.
SPEAKER_03We're doing web leads, we're doing some mailers, trying to get a little bit more on mailers and really, really hitting back our. I mean, we've been in business for a while, so we have a lot of a lot of win bags and and recoils. So that that's really our core source of leads at the moment. I don't think that I need anything else for now, but who knows? I'm always looking at different at different options. What's your approach with the internet leads? Our approach with internet leads, well, we have our telemarketers, which are great. And basically they're they work like transfers, right? So uh rather than purchasing, because I used to do also telemarketing leads that I used to purchase from vendors and and warm transfers and that kind of thing. And really having the telemarketers in-house helps kind of kill you know uh two birds with one stone, because by having my telemarketers on on board with me, not only do they get to know my team, but they also help them follow up sometimes. You know, I involve them a lot in the team, and that that's one thing that I think took me a while to understand. Sometimes I struggle with that, but you know, they're super valuable, not just because they create those warm transfers and they alleviate some of that that um burnout we're talking about or discouraging discouragement with uh with the producers that they don't have to be making all these outbound calls, but also you know, they they help us follow up, you know. And actually, I learned that from one of one of the uh telemarketers that we had uh a few months ago. She was awesome, she was so good, she would keep my agents actually in check because she would be like, Hey, so I sent you this person, what happened? You never said you never said it to me. And then I would see like, hey, so what's going on? Why why aren't you answering to what happened? Oh, you know, she didn't, and then I would talk to her and she'd be like, you know, this seemed like a really good lead. If you want, I can follow up with her. She would tell me, like, yeah, go ahead. And she would set, you know, tasks for herself and she would follow up and then she'd get him on the line again. Hey, I got this person on the line again, you know, can you take him? And and so now we're kind of adjusted a little bit and trying to train, you know, the other kind of marketers to do to also do that, where they not only help us get the initial lead, but if it's maybe a felt transfer or if it's someone that maybe didn't work out, we were not able to quote, they actually create a task and they also follow up with them. But I think that you know, a few weeks ago I got together with them and like, look, you know, I I don't know that you realize how important you are. I said to my telemarketers, right? You you are our first line of defense. You know, we need you to get us transfers. And if we don't have people to talk to, you know, we can't we can't really sell to anyone. So, you know, I started training with them a little bit more every Friday. Now we we do it. I think tomorrow I'm actually going to bring them on the on the call that we have every morning because I want to touch on uh base with them on following up and all that. And even though that that's not their main role, they actually I think they feel more integrated to the team. And the team also sees them as more, you know, part of the agency when when they are part of the training. And even though they don't do it all the time, just knowing how it works, I think that is it's helping us. So that's that's our one of our biggest processes that we have right now. We have, you know, I mean, like everyone, you know, we have lost people. So at times, you know, I went through a period where I didn't have enough agents, and I actually had the demarcus help us with with requests and just get do other other things that are that are maybe not that appealing to a licensed agent. And I don't want the licensed agents doing, but they're actually helping with that. So that's a big thing for us.
SPEAKER_01I think more than ever, especially, I mean, we can talk about inflation and everything else that's going on. I think that more than ever the agents are so valuable. And and it's like, why have them do all the stuff that they don't want to do? If we can take that off their plate, like and create a better work environment, we're gonna retain them more, they're gonna they're gonna love working for you, you're cre creating a great culture. It seems like there's no other option. I love that.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, it it's it's common sense. I mean, I just told you a few minutes ago that I spend a lot of time training my new agents, right? I mean, I I basically work with them personally, you know, for close to a month. Why would I want them doing things that are not really as valuable? You know, I already invested a lot of money with them, a lot, a lot of my time with them, helping them understand how to talk to customers, how to explain coverage and all that. That's what I want them doing all day long. I don't want them just dialing. And if I can get that to somebody else, you know, I I will do it.
SPEAKER_01And that's what they like doing, right? I mean, that they want to be on the phone, they want to win. Like when you're not getting anyone on the phone, and I mean, that's just by the time you do get someone on the phone, you're gassed. You don't sound great, you know. It's like and then and then multiple, and then doing that time and time again by the third quote, you're just I mean, it's it's not a pretty picture, but yeah, no, it's not, and and it all goes with the culture, right?
SPEAKER_03That that that we're talking about, creating it and showing them that look, you know, I mean, I I I care about you, I care about your career, I care about your goals, and this is the investment that I'm actually making, right? Um actually do better, all of us.
SPEAKER_01Yep. So, Miguel, are you are you hitting up any referrals? Are you are your agents asking anybody for referrals? How are you?
SPEAKER_03Well, actually, yes, I I forgot to mention that. That yeah, that's another big source of of business for us, referrals. We have a lot of uh you know connections with with local uh loan officers. And from my that that's one of the biggest things that I that I learned actually from my old days with with my uncles. Every week, that was that was one of my tasks, actually. Every Friday I would go to different real estate agencies from the area and actually just hand out you know flyers and and our business cards and all that every Friday religiously. And so we we got a lot of business through that, and they were really good leads. So to this day, actually, I had one of the realtors that was our referral partner from back then, just retired last week, and I actually helped her with the claim a few weeks ago, actually. So um, yeah, that that's another big one. I mean, that's another one that I am trying to get back to it. I tried it for a couple of months and it worked out really good. I don't know why we got out of it. But I actually, when when they would call us for endorsements for mortgage updates, you know, make sure that we finish them quickly and then we would hit them back with like, hey, you know, did you get uh the evidence of insurance that we sent to you? Uh yeah, we got it. Oh, great. You know, so is the closing everything okay? Yeah, and okay, it sounds good. And then the next day calling back again, like, hey, so how is the closing uh okay? No, you know what? They they actually changed it. Can you change it for me a little bit? Yeah, so after that, you know, asking them for a referral. I remember I think it was a couple years ago that I did it from like September all the way to December. And man, we connected with like three different loan officers, and one of them would actually refer us to a few more people within the office, and we ended up our December was like one of our best December that we had because because of this process. And man, I I actually stopped doing, I think we we did it that that year because we were trying to draw a little bit more, but that's another good one that I that I really want to get back to.
SPEAKER_01I love that. That's such a great idea. It's kind of like uh one of the processes we have here is never if somebody says they're gonna call you tomorrow, you be the one. No, no, I'll I'll call you. You know what I mean? Like, like take that responsibility on yourself, and that's what exactly what you're doing with the evidence of insurance is you're you're actually following up, like that you're going the extra step, right? You're doing the thing that nobody else is doing, so that's super cool.
SPEAKER_03And honestly, I mean, right right now, I think you know, there isn't that many refinancing uh going on, I guess. Um, but you know, we kind of you know, we kind of missed the boat a little a little bit on that afterwards because as loan officers, you know, that that's really they don't really care much about you know getting cookies or getting a $25 gift card or anything like that. They care to close the deal. And if you can assure them that you're gonna do everything that you can to do it, you know, that's gonna do it. I think you know that's the reason that this guy started actually sending us business because we helped him close one. And then I remember the next I when I told him, hey, if you have anybody else that's coming up in the that you would like a um an insurance option for, you know, let me know. He actually sent me one the next the next day, and we did the quote, closed them, everything. And then after that, he just started sending us a couple of weeks, you know, from that office. It was it was like four or five different loan officers. And uh I kind of handed it off to one of my producers, and and I, you know, I but I think that the value in that is actually making sure that that everybody everybody else is doing it from the service person that's taking the the call to the actual producer that's kind of growing that connection with with a loan officer.
SPEAKER_01Any tips on onboarding clients?
SPEAKER_03Man, I'll tell you that my Achilles heel. Um I really I really struggle with that. I have a process that is documented, but I think for me, one of the things that I struggle with is keeping us accountable. And I think that what's made it difficult for me is just wanting my desire to have my salespeople just closing and deals and that kind of thing, and trying to get somebody else to help with some of the um the tasks that may not be that um appealing to the to the sales guys. It's kind of hurt me a little bit. But what I'm doing right now is basically using agency Zoom. You know, there is a task that get generated from that. And so as a producer, you know, you you basically get two tasks and the task have have that all the different steps that need to be taken for everyone, and then just follow those those tasks. The part that I think that I struggle with is actually you know keeping track of that and making sure that those tasks are are actually completed successfully. But that's the way that I that I handle it. That's something that I think does need to be solid because it would ensure that your customers stay stay on board and no policy that's written falls falls off. 100%.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's it's crazy. I mean, we try to do everything. There's no way it's the the wheels are gonna stay on at all times on uh on every part. But you look at it from the like the custom the client journey from being a lead into getting quoted, right? We talked about that, and then becoming a client and that onboarding and then the retention and and all that stuff. It's kind of like you just just need to keep you know, keep tweaking different parts of that client journey. It's never all going to be perfect, but um, you know, yeah, it's something to work on for all of us.
SPEAKER_03And you know, and just when you think that you have it, then something happens. Like in my case, I I thought I had a pretty solid process, but then you know, I lost the per one of the persons that was actually helping me do the welcome calls. And then, you know, I started assigning it to the producers, and then I got somebody else and kind of took it back in. And so I think that having a process that's well documented and and well structured helps you with that, but you know, it's it's inevitable to I mean, those deals are always those things, uh, issues are always gonna happen. I think having it documented helps a lot. But for me, it hasn't it hasn't been 100% because that's a problem with it, to be honest.
SPEAKER_01Well, so let's go all the way to the end of the customer journey or the client journey. Uh, what's your number one retention strategy, tactic strategy?
SPEAKER_03I'd say I kind of preach that, you know, to everyone. My number one retention strategy is actually doing a good job from the beginning, right? It's a lot easier to retain a customer who has an umbrella policy, who has good uh liability limits, and and who who you did a good job with, than someone that maybe has state minimum coverage and maybe you know that's really all they have, everything. It's really hard to retain those people, especially when they're when they're shopping around. So I would consider you know doing a good job from the beginning, making sure that you that we explain coverage and that we build value from the very beginning. One of the the best things in in terms of retention, because because then when when they call about rate increases, and we know that that's happening a lot right now, you always go back to that. You know, remember that you know we had this, and remember that you know this is the reason that you pick this coverage, and so it all follows a circle, right? Because when they come on board, you know, if we did a good job, then when it's time to retain them, we basically do the same thing. We go back to that review. And a lot of times, you know, people think that they're actually getting quoted the same thing at somewhere else. And when we check their tech pages or their quotes, their estimates, that's that's not always true. And that is you know, basically the best way to to kind of help them see that, you know, there's there's more to it than than just uh the prize, right? It's it's also the fact that you know we actually spend the time helping them understand, and other places are more concerned with just the prize. Uh so actually what we do, we do have a retention script, but it's based on that. It's based on that on the on that review and the assumption that that we did a good job from the beginning.
SPEAKER_01It's almost like and I a hundred percent believe that the best like defensive strategy is a great offense, right? If you do the offense right, then that is the defense. You know, if you all the things that we talked about, the whole client journey, if you do that whole thing really well, it's the best way to uh retain your clients. Cool, man. Well, so besides listening to this award-winning podcast, what do you do to keep yourself motivated?
SPEAKER_03Well, you know, I spent a lot of time with my kids. I mean, I obviously the business is important and and and uh doing everything that we do in the agency is important, but you know, really my number one priority is my family, my kids. So so that keeps me uh motivated, you know, just spending time with them and making sure that that I'm there for them. You know, like this week I was actually at home for a good part of it because my five-year-old actually is not doing well, so you know, taking him to the doctrine. So spending time with them, and then also I'm a triathlete. I exercise and try to stay active with that. So I try to run a few uh triathlons a year. This year I had not know that, but that's one thing that I also learned from another book. You know, I mean, I I view myself as dad. I mean, I've I've done several, I think it's been like almost 10 years since I've done triathlons every year. I actually won uh third place in in my division a couple of times. Uh oh, that's awesome. So that that you know that keeps me motivated. And actually, I think that's how I got hooked up with uh with Craig once that he was doing that Regner uh race a few years ago, and he posted something on Facebook, hey, has anybody done this? Like, yeah, dude, I haven't done it, but I've been wanting to do it. And then we just started talking a little bit after that.
SPEAKER_01That's awesome. It's funny, like a lot of high performers in business are the same people that are doing that those types of things, you know. Like you have to keep your family happy at home if you're gonna be happy at work, you know. You gotta get and you also have to keep your body tuned if you're gonna be pushing it at work and pushing it at home, and like otherwise, it's crazy how negative you can get without working out and stuff. For me personally, like I have to every day. If I don't do, I have a morning workout. Well, I do it because of my back too, otherwise, I probably wouldn't be able to walk a couple of years ago. It was very I was struggling. But like that's the thing, and I do that because of my kids too, because there was a period of time that I couldn't pick up my kids, and it was, dude, it was the worst. They were little and I couldn't pick it up, and I was sick and tired of being sick and tired, you know? And it's like I if I have to do this every day, you know, work out a little bit, it also has its other benefits of like anytime I work out, man, I'm feeling way better. I feel stronger. I feel like I have more energy picking up the kids. I mean, like you being a father. I mean, you know, if you're running races and going to work, feeling good about it, you run a high performance team and everything, like you're gonna be there for your kids, you're gonna you're gonna show up in a better mood. It's easy to get derailed from all the things.
SPEAKER_03100%. I mean, I I definitely believe in balance. And I'll never forget, you know, I mean, I I just told you how long I've I've been doing this, and I remember back in the day when I was a young support agent. Back then they actually used to send the leaders, the market leaders, report on paper. And I remember, you know, I I always looking out for it, like, oh, here we are, and all that. And I so I remember someone that was always at the top, at the top of the list. And then when I actually became an agent, I was like, hey, so what happened to this person? They're like, oh man, you know, he actually passed away like seven, eight years ago. Really? Like, yeah, you know, why? I mean, I don't, he had a heart attack. I was like, oh, dude, man. I mean, so so that kind of stuck in my mind, you know, this person was so successful, yet, I mean, who knows? You know, I don't know what his life might have been like because I didn't know him personally, but I always remember that. I, you know, the business is the business, but there has to be a balance, and and so keeping that balance in sync, you know, with obviously work, you know, the family and and and your own self is super important.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Yeah, it's a big balancing act. You got to take care of yourself. So, what are some of the biggest changes that you see in the next couple of years that are affecting our agencies? And uh really what can you do? What what are you planning on doing to hedge that?
SPEAKER_03Well, you know, from my point of view, it's technology, right? I mean, things seem to be changing. And, you know, I'm a technology person, right? In fact, you know, when I when I was working as a sport agent, that was that's one of the things that I was in charge of also creating a database for mailing purposes and things like that. So I've always been on top of technology and just figuring out how to do things more efficiently. So I think that more and more that's going to become more important. Like right now, actually having uh the markers that would actually help us shorten the the lifespan of a lead, making sure that we use a lead management system, a customer relations system, and also being open to possibly doing business differently, right? Like, you know, me right now, voiceover IP is is actually a very common term, right? That most of us are actually familiar with. For me, I've actually been using that since like 2009 or something like that, because the the minute that that our company decided to let us get our own phone company actually went, you know, voiceover IP because of my technology background. And I've always been on top of that. So how that translates is when you know, when when COVID hit, you know, basically the same day, every everyone was able to work from home the next day, and now actually more than half the team is actually working from home, and we we're actually doing better than we than we were doing before COVID. So that you know, embracing of technology and just being prepared, I think that you know, you'll never go wrong with that. So that and and I would say, you know, from my stand, also with the carrier that I'm with, find the positive in everything. You know, there's always gonna be something that's gonna seem like, oh man, the sky's falling. And I mean, it's happened several times with this carrier. I think that you always gotta find a way to win. And if you just let yourself get involved in those thoughts that, oh man, how am I gonna do it? This is gonna be different, and I'm not used to doing it that way. Well, you know, I mean, if it was that easy, everybody would be doing it, right? But you know, we gotta be different and just figure out a way to win. And so for me, it's just being focused on the opportunity and really find a place of where you could win. That's my focus. And right now, with our carrier, is is really making sure that you're they're selling, and yeah, we're getting compensated a little bit different now. So, based on that compensation model, how am I gonna restructure my marketing and just make sure that now I bring the business that my company wants?
SPEAKER_01Dude, we talk to the agents all the time that are with different carriers, it's all the same, you know, it's just packaged differently, but there's always gonna be those ups and downs. I love that you said that because I mean it's true. I mean, hey, we're lucky that Google and Amazon hasn't taken over. Luckily, we're regulated by the by the states and stuff, otherwise, yeah, they they would be able to swoop in. So even though that there's some challenges at times, that's part of it, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and I mean the way that I see it is like, hey, you know, do I do I still like what I do? And I that's a hundred percent yes. Yep. And and B, you know, I'm I'm am I making more money than I would anywhere else? And that's also a hard guess. So then uh, do I have the potential to keep doing that? And that's also a hard guess. So now, okay, so how what adjustments am I gonna make to make sure that it happens? And that's it, right? Because for me, working in a technology field for 10 years, that that's one of the things that I learned. You know, nothing stays the same way, right? Everything changes, and actually, I think insurance with us, it's been a lot lower than it has been for other industries.
SPEAKER_01100%. So and you get to go home with your with your kid when he's sick, and you get to more uh family time anytime you want, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, what else can you ask for, man?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's great. Well, Miguel, thanks for going the distance on here. Um, I just want to acknowledge you for your 15 years of service and and being the leader that you are, and it's super cool to hear all the positivity. I I've known you for a while now, and it's all you're always bringing that awesome energy and love it, man. Thank you.
SPEAKER_03Well, thank you for having me.
SPEAKER_01Appreciate the invitation, and I I look forward to you know keep learning from you all too. Awesome, Miguel. Thank you. Hey, what are you still doing here? Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, if you weren't listening before, we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top ages throughout the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01Using these strategies did help Craig and I fight over $20 million in free in the last couple of years.
SPEAKER_02And let me tell you, on this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same result.
SPEAKER_01Again, that's live.teled dot com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_02And if you just followed us, we are third. 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you to see that.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman