The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Miguel Makes Moves, Manufactures Mayhem Magic More Magestically! PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
So the wildest story that you know that I can tell you from my agency is actually when one of my uh soon-to-be customers, I assume, you know, actually lied to us and uh bought a policy from us, and then we're trying to buy the the bundle, and then we actually only ended up doing the the auto. And he said that he would do the homeowners uh the next week. So it turns out that the next day, after doing the auto policy with us, he went to another agency nearby and he actually purchased uh home insurance from them. And everything was fine, you know, we're cool with that. However, after I don't know, two, three weeks, claims called me and they said, Hey, you know, we actually have a claim, a water backup claim from this customer. And he is saying that he told you to start the policy when he bought the auto policy, and the policy that that he has is really not gonna cover him because you know he says that that the rain actually took place the day or the night when when he bought the auto policy. So he was trying to get coverage for that, and so I had to explain everything to claims and all of that. And turns out that even if he had bought it, if we had bound it, it would have not covered him because there's a 10-day waiting period for water backup claims, and so they told me that explained all of that to me. So so he got so mad, so mad that he actually threatened to come to the office and beat me up. So I was like, you know what? I'm glad that you're telling me because now I can file a police report and let the police happens to me, you know, they can go looking for you, and you know, it was it was a little um scary, I guess, at first, but you know, it's something that we just laugh about now.
SPEAKER_02You were looking over your shoulder for there for a couple weeks, huh?
SPEAKER_00You know, actually, and and I'm crazy. Here's the thing, you know, you you guys, I don't know how far you live from your agency, but actually, I'm like five minutes from my agency, so anyone could you know just follow me and you know, but you know, I mean, I'm a firm believer that if you do well by everyone, there's really nothing to fear, and that's really how I live my life. So I'm not wasn't really afraid, but yeah, just a story to tell. Yeah, that's wild, awesome. Yeah, so so, anyways, my name is Miguel Gonzalez, I'm from Bolenburg, and I've had my agency for close to 15 years, and it's it's it's great to be here with you guys.
SPEAKER_01Right now, while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teled.com.
SPEAKER_02We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years.
SPEAKER_02On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results.
SPEAKER_01Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_02If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there. Nice, awesome. Welcome to the insurance.
SPEAKER_00Welcome, Miguel. And of course, you know, I am an insurance dude. Yes, look at him. He's put it out of gear. Look at that. I like this hat a lot. I wear it all the time. I love it. And I remember Jason saying once that you know, that's a way of marketing because you know, people are gonna be like, hey, you know, you're an insurance. And I've actually gotten that a couple of times, so so that's cool.
SPEAKER_02You are the insurance dude with that out.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it it is funny. People people always ask, they're like, What? What is that? You would never think that the word dude and insurance would ever go together until you, you know.
SPEAKER_03Until the end knuckleheads, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, but it is a good conversation for 500 episodes. Wow, that's amazing. That's pretty crazy.
SPEAKER_01So, Miguel, we've known you for a while, but we actually don't know over this. Uh we've found out that you've been an insurance dude for 15 years now. But like, what got you into this crazy business of insurance?
SPEAKER_00Well, it's funny that you ask because I know that you know oftentimes I've heard people say that I mean insurance is not one of those things that people want to grow up and and and do that for a living, right? And I don't think I grew up wanting to be an insurance agent, but my mom was a life insurance agent, my uncle wasn't a life insurance agent. And then when I was in college, I didn't know this, but one of my uncles actually owned an insurance agency. And when I when I realized that he was with Allstate, you know, I actually went over and hey, you know, would you hire me? And see, and so he did. So I worked for him for a few years when I was in college. I actually got my sister in the agency with my uncle. And so I really liked it, you know. So I ended up graduating from college in '96, went on to work as a software engineer for 10 years. And when I was going to be a father, you know, I started thinking, like, you know what? I don't think I can keep up with this schedule because I really loved what I did, but it was kind of demanding. I worked downtown and hours were long, and you know, there's traveling involved in my future. And so I thought back and I actually went back to one of the persons that that I knew from Allstate. And he was like, Yeah, of course, man, we'll we'll we'll consider you. And it's funny because I did one of those, you know, assessment, personality assessments, and I guess I didn't come back as as the ideal candidate. He said, you know, you you you're okay, but you know, we'll probably give you a chance just because of your background and and uh we know that you worked in insurance before. So, but that's that's what got me in insurance. And I don't know, I I think I I liked it. I never had I mean I like technology and everything, but I think I kind of knew that I would always come back to insurance because I mean he had just been in my family for for a while.
SPEAKER_02So what was one of the big oh sorry I was saying that's cool, but it is cool, it's very cool, and and and from that, what would you what would you say was the biggest early win that got you going, got you excited about what you were doing, besides somebody threatening to beat you up?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think that you know, I mean it it's it's kind of hard, you know. I it's true that I had a background in insurance and all that. However, you know, my background was not really being an owner or running uh uh a business, right? So knowing how to write the policy, knowing how to take a payment or whatever I did before, you know, is really no comparison to actually running an agency. So for me, it was a big shock, you know, the first five, six months. And I I think you know, what one of my biggest wins was when I hired my first person, right? I remember that she started with me like in December. I opened the agency in in March. And uh that you know, first part of the year, I kind of went in by myself. Sure, you know, I had the money for marketing, was doing a little bit trying to do everything myself, and I wasn't doing too too bad. I got my my my startup bonus and all of that. So that was that was one of the early ones, getting all those initial bonuses. But I think the the the one thing that made the biggest difference is when I hired someone and actually started uh marketing with that person, started buying actual internet leads, right? And they were a lot better back then. But but I think yeah, realizing that that I was not gonna be the one actually talking to customers all the time, and that I needed someone else and actually pulling the trigger on dad and deciding to spend money and bringing someone on board, spending money on marketing all that, and then seeing the return of that and actually making it back in bonus. That was my I think the one thing that that made the difference for me early on.
SPEAKER_01That is funny how that works out, huh? It's like it's almost impossible to not look at it like an expense, like it's just costing so much money when in actuality you're buying time, you're buying you, you know what I mean? Like it's it's an investment in the future, it's definitely delayed gratification, but um, yeah, it it's extremely liberating that feeling.
SPEAKER_00That you know what uh anybody that that that I talk to that that that's just starting a you know as an insurance agent or really any other business, that's one of the things that I kind of bring to their attention, right? Like I don't and and this is why I appreciate you know guys like you because you know you go on and you you tell us all, give us the recipe, you know, through the shows and and the other ventures they have going on on how to do it. And back then, man, I wish somebody was out there, you know, doing the same thing that that you guys are doing with with Teledudes or or uh with the podcast, because there wasn't really anybody that would talk to me back then, and and just figuring it out on your own. I mean, it it was scary and it was kind of costly, to be honest with you. But back to that, it's just realizing that yeah, you know, you you you do need to let go of that money and trust the process that you're gonna make it back. And honestly, it's been one of the big the best investments in my life.
SPEAKER_01I feel uh that's awesome. When I started, it's gonna be six years ago, it's exactly six years ago. When I started, I'll never forget like trying to figure it all out. And what what is the recipe? Well, like, what do you do hearing about all the cross-selling and everything else? I just we could not gain traction, not the kind of traction that you see in emails and you know what all the other agents are doing, and and it just nothing made sense. So yeah, it it is, and you feel like you're on an island, because especially when you're when you want to do a lot more, you know. I remember reaching out to uh the carriers and and asking what's the competitive advantage, and they pretty much said, You are you we can't tell you anything legally, and I was like, Well, that's crazy because I don't know anything. They're like, You are, and I'm like, I know nothing, I know nothing about what I'm doing. So if I'm the like advantage here, we we are in some big trouble.
SPEAKER_00But yeah, yeah, that's exactly how it was. I mean, I remember going to actually one of the the original meetings, you know, early on, and just you know, I always like to ask a lot of questions, and you guys probably know when uh you know when when I'm in the in the some the Zoom meetings and that I I can't help myself, you know, except that you know sometimes I don't I don't turn on my camera, so I can't ask questions if I don't have a camera. But um I remember early on going to to one of the meetings, and I was sitting right at the front and trying to ask questions and and trying to meet people, and man, it was hard. It was hard because you know, everyone is on their own, and in a way, you we're kind of competing against each other, I guess. But right, you know, and I remember talking to someone and I remember his name, Eric. You know, he was a heavy hitter in my market, and then I remember, hey dude, so so so what's going on? How are you doing? He was like, you know, I'm I'm buying leads from um actually X states from this vendor, you know, and um I can tell you more if you call me. And then I called him, and man, he never picked up again, and and he never picked up. And and so, and I I mean, not I don't blame them, obviously, you know, they're not getting paid to do that, it's not their job to do that, but it's all just to you know to show really how hard it could be and how valuable it is when people do things that that would help others, like you know, like some of the things that a lot of other guys are doing, and and you guys also. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So take us back. You you said you started, uh, it was a while before you did that first hire. So since then, that was 15 years ago. Up to now, what does your agency look like with your team and what are their roles in the agency?
SPEAKER_00So, you know, I mean, so so back then, obviously it was just it was me, you know, it took a couple of years, you know, before I hired a couple more people and that, and so I've gone through the process much like anybody else, I think, you know, just realizing that that your role eventually needs to change, right? Like, you know, at the beginning, I was doing a lot of the the service, a lot of the writing myself, and and and and all of that. And right now I have a team of seven people, and we are not entirely divided in sales and service, but it's more, I think I we try to do it more like task-oriented, where you know, some of us are are more uh specialized, uh, not necessarily 100% in service, but maybe in different tasks, right? And I've gone back and forth, you know, with different things, but right now, you know, that seems to be working uh really good. Like, you know, one of our my agents, you know, she's she's really crushing it, and she's just taking all the call-ins and and all of my referrals, you know. I give them to her, she's she's like a closer, and then you know, I have a couple of other agents that are just doing what we call the outside sales stuff where it's more outbound calling and all of that. And then I have a few more people that are that are basically just doing the service work and helping us get leads out of those um inbound calls, and that that is that is the structure. So it seems to be working for now. You know, I mean, I'm always open to making um adjustments and just changing depending on the need. But I think that uh based on what I'm doing right now, I will try to continue to scale that a little bit more and see how far I can get before I start you know looking at different options.
SPEAKER_02It's awesome to get to having that team and they look up to you and you're helping change their lives, right? By by providing be it a positive role model and helping them be successful. What kind of things have you done in the agency to create that like a strong culture? Because it sounds like you have that there.
SPEAKER_00Well, you know, I I started going to a lot of those, you know, uh self-development uh, you know, seminars and things like that, and and then attending different different insurance events and things and and all sorts of things. And I started picking up different things everywhere, but it really was hard to implement them. And I think you know, when when I started looking at at some of the roadmaps that are actually given to us by some of those um event uh organizers, right? It was kind of hard. So to be honest with you, I started following a more specific plan when I implemented the peak performance plan that you have, and that really gave me more focus in first of all making sure that that I was consistent with um with scripts, consistent with with training, consistent with marketing, and just making sure that it was not the flavor of the day, right? And obviously, you know, things have changed a little bit, you know, uh in terms of how we handle things, but there are things that that I I am very consistent with that that that that I don't really change anymore. And one of them is is making sure that that we keep the accountability through self-reporting, right? Uh, tracking activity and and um and basically every day being being on dad, you know, having our daily meetings and just touching base, even even when it gets kind of hard. And I know that you you know you were talking about or um making it funner and and all of that through different doing it differently. I remember one of my agents actually was telling me that you know she uh learned a technique of actually doing the script with a really high-pitched voice, right? So, you know, just finding variety with with uh how to implement things, but being consistent with the core structure of the things that I that I think that that that make the the culture really unique and and valuable. And then besides that, honestly, I feel that I care a lot about my team. You know, my team is is really excellent, right? And and and I would give anything for anyone in my team. They're I mean, they they're really hard workers, and helping them grow in the in the industry is is really one of my top priorities. And that's the other reason why, you know, I want to be consistent. Because I think it's hard to to get to that point when you when you realize that you know what, I'm not actually being a nice person to this team member by not keeping them accountable because because that I'm not doing them any favors. That's really not gonna help them, that's not gonna help them make more money in the future in commissions, or really grow as a professional. And so so taking on that role of knowing that, hey, you know, you kind of are responsible as a leader to help this person grow as a professional, to help this person provide for their family and really create an opportunity for them so that they could they could continue to do that. And that realization, I think, is is one of the reasons why I am very focused on being consistent with those things that I kind of brought up to you.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's funny, it kind of mimics kids too, right? Like it's easy to just sweep some stuff under the rug, but at the end of the day, you're not helping them. Like they need structure, they need accountability so that they can grow up to be awesome young men and women. But I mean, the same with our staff, you know, you want them to grow and it it's funny how in our agencies, uh, it just seems like you know, if you don't help someone grow, they eventually will find that somewhere else, you know. But like, yeah, it's it's our job to nurture successful people.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's exactly right. And and I think, you know, it's it's hard to come to that point because you you think like, oh man, I don't want to be tough, you know, they may be, I don't know, going through something. They I don't know. You know, I mean, really, it's in everyone's best interest to make sure that we're consistent, that we're keep them accountable, that we stay accountable ourselves. And that is really, I think, what you would expect from anyone that cares about you, right?
SPEAKER_01100%. So, how do you recruit? How do you bring people on the team?
SPEAKER_00Uh, well, you know, there are many different ways, right? I mean, as most of us right now, that's that's probably the most difficult part. But I for me, you know, I I use right now different vendors. I have used, I don't know if if we can um mention them in a, but you know, we have used uh the group events with the two different vendors that seem to be common nowadays, and then um uh I've also used um direct um advertising through Indeed, and then also with the team. Actually, I was trying to bring someone on board this week that that was referred to me by one of my my team members. I don't know if it's gonna if it's gonna work out or not, but I think that just having that all those different sources is important. I am trying to figure out how to advertise through Facebook and maybe you know just get a few applicants through there. And right now that's what that's basically what I do.
SPEAKER_02Cool. Awesome. So you bring about, let's say you hire up, right? You you do your whole interview process, five. What do you do? What's there in the door that makes them part of the team and that's ultimately successful?
SPEAKER_00Well, right now, I mean, I basically I have a plan for everyone, right? An onboarding plan where it varies depending on a little bit on the on the experience. If it's if it's someone that doesn't have a license, it will be a little bit different than someone that that's already licensed. But typically what I do is I go through the right now. I'm actually going through the script that we have, our sales script, and make sure that before they get in the phones, before they do anyone, before they quote anybody, they actually know that script really good to make sure make sure that they they actually know how to explain coverage the way that I want them to explain it. And I know that there's different opinions, right? Like a lot of people like to just put them on the phone and make sure that they have the grid. And I have tried that too, and I think it it has worked also, but right now I'm going this this way just because I want them to feel empowered or really confident that they know what they're doing before they start talking to anybody about insurance. So I have basically a list of trainings that we do, and really, I mean, they're they're not ready to actually go through until maybe second week of that. And we we just I spent time with them basically, I don't know, like three, four hours daily just practicing and making sure that they know how to how to um explain insurance, how to overcome the uh up front end objections and also the um closing techniques. That is awesome. Yeah, awesome.
SPEAKER_01So, what would you say out of all of your uh the training that you do, what is your most effective training tip that you could give all the insurance dudes and dudettes out there?
SPEAKER_00I think that one of the most effective things that I have learned is to get to know the person a little bit better and know how they learn. And there, I know that people use different uh personality assessments, and some people you know swear by them, some people don't. For me, I I really do like them because it tells me a little bit more about how they learn, what kind of person they they are, you know, what kinds of things are important to them. And so that way when I'm training with them, I can I can make that connection. And I can almost like when I'm when we're trying to close a customer, right? That you tell them stories, you tell you illustrate how this insurance policy is going to actually help them, you know, protect their family. Same way, you know, the better I know my team member, the better I'm gonna be able to coach them and actually um bring them on board with the um scripts and and and really the culture of the agency. So so that way when I'm training with them, I can tell them like, look, you know, this is a way that that you would do it, because remember that you know, in a year you want to get married and you want you want to probably buy a nice ring for your for fiance. So this is you know just making sure that that you follow our script, that you overcome the objections at least three times, you know, is gonna help you maybe not close every single person. person but we don't need every single one we just need two three more and and so this is how you're gonna do it and so so so that piece of of uh doing a personality assessment and just knowing knowing them a little bit better I think is is crucial to me. How about keeping them motivated because there's a lot of monotony right quote after quote after quote how do you keep them woo how do you keep them loving it yeah that's a tough that's a that's a tough one right especially I mean I I think it depends on the on the role like for me it is more difficult to keep a person motivated when they're on the outside team where it's basically a lot of calls and a lot of rejection sometimes it does seem like at times you you you really don't get it right taking breaks in between and maybe also taking some of those calls that maybe they were not successful with and just doing it with them. Like I remember last year I think it was in maybe a couple years ago a little bit longer I had someone he was like oh dude man that's not happening Miguel I'm like what do you mean like well you know people are answering but you know they don't they don't really want insurance man like oh show me one person that you got well I got this one Gary okay so what do you know about him? Well I don't know I mean it's just that he doesn't want insurance man you figure out who is who he's with yeah he's with progressive all right let's do this let me call him yeah you gonna call him like yeah but he's he said not to call him he's not interested I'm like dude we just bought that lead man we can call let's call him again you know so I call him and I'm like hey Gary how's it going? He's like yeah who's this like hey you know this is Miguel from all state and look you you were just talking to Ron a few minutes ago and yeah so he was just telling me that you you're actually happy with progressive but I think that you know there's a couple of things that that maybe you didn't realize and so I just want to tell you a little bit more. So what talk do you have with progressive he's like oh you know I'm a I'm actually a truck driver I don't really drive that much like really oh I can hear that where are you at right now? Oh man in Michigan and so long story short I ended up getting the quote and I handed it to him and I think that you know just doing that with them you know helps him see that not not only that that it could be done but that I'm willing to do it right that I'm not telling me to do something that I I wouldn't do myself. It doesn't always work out right I tried that with another person like a few months later and they they actually hung up on me so I was like sorry man but you know I was laughing up on it with them but I think that part of of just you know helping them see that it could be done and also that that I'm willing to do it that's also is yeah there's a way that that I keep them motivated.
SPEAKER_01And the fact like even if you think you get hung up on you're like that no big deal who cares you know like just that yeah just for them to see because they always think of the worst you know oh it feels so but yeah but like look it's no big deal you did it got it over and that and that's actually a tip that I learned also from and I think a few of my guys learned from from my there's a there's a word that we say in Spanish for someone that has your same name.
SPEAKER_00So my tocayo he he he will right so yeah so I learned that from Miguel like you know what if you get hung up you know you're winning and that's basically what I tell him right yeah look man we're winning man if we get hung up on that's okay I'd rather you get hung up on that you give up so yep yeah if you're not getting hung up on then you're not trying hard enough.
SPEAKER_01Exactly hey what are you still doing here?
SPEAKER_02Well while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind check out live doteled.com yeah if you weren't listening before we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents throughout the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01Using these strategies did help Craig and I write over $20 million in premium in the last couple of years.
SPEAKER_02And let me tell you on this call you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same result.
SPEAKER_01Again that's live.teled dot com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_02And if you jump on with us we are starting 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman