The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Sheppard Bowen - How He Built A Massive P&C Juggernaut PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
What do you think is like some of the biggest obstacles that our agencies are going to be facing in the next few years?
SPEAKER_03I mean, you know, staffing A is always going to be an issue. And, you know, obviously, if you're able to, you can always offer a better work environment, better pay, you know, to attract the people you want, you know, other challenges, you know, or yeah, get in touch with people. As we've all seen with Stirf Shaken and all that stuff, you know, that that makes challenges.
SPEAKER_00I are agents. How? By uncovering the secret, predictable, insistent, and profitable agency failure. I am a great public. I am agent felt. We are agents. We are insurance.
SPEAKER_01Right now, while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_02We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years.
SPEAKER_02On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results.
SPEAKER_01Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_02If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you.
SPEAKER_01See you there. What would you say out of all of that is like your number one most effective trading tip that any agent could just take and run with?
SPEAKER_03Oh consistency. Hands down. If you don't do anything consistently, it's not gonna work. Yeah. And that's the that's the number one thing. Just do it, like Nike would say, you know. But uh they were right on the point of that one. Uh, is if you as long as you do something, you're better off than doing nothing.
SPEAKER_01Right. Yep. 100%.
SPEAKER_02So how about how about motivation? What kind of things do you do to keep the team motivated? Anything that you could share that's that's worked really well in your office?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so I mean, definitely we're big on celebrating, uh, celebrate any win, you know, whether it's, hey, I overcame this objection, that was awesome, even if they didn't close that deal. We love to, you know, hear that. We might share that, you know, if it's recorded, we might share that in in one of our next meetings so everybody can hear and work off of, you know, I feel like I might pay, you know, offer a little bit better of a comp plan than most uh right now, but that's probably just because I'm just trying to attract everyone as possible. But uh, you know, I love the work-life balance aspect. I love to see my people, you know, hey, go take a trip, go do something fun. I love to travel. My wife, my kids, we all we love traveling, we travel a lot. And uh, you know, so that's really fun. So I really encourage the team, hey, hit this benchmark or something like that. Let's let's send you somewhere for the weekend, you know, have have a good time. And uh, so you know, travel incentives and just overall, you know, compensation too, you know, the more they produce, the more they make.
SPEAKER_01Love it. Love it. What are you doing for marketing these days?
SPEAKER_03So marketing these days, you know, I'm really focused on, you know, the lead game. That's really, you know, I used to do a lot of direct mail, postcards. Man, I grew really fast back when I first started with postcards. But, you know, the thing without with that was, you know, hey, you're throwing money up against the wall, you can't really track it that well, and uh you don't know all the time, you know, who's calling in from it. No matter how you know you try and do a separate phone number, they may have your postcard, but then they look you up online and they call that number. So it's kind of a challenge. So the lead gain for us has just been what we're doing primarily because it just also just gives us endless opportunity to get in front of people. And so far, you know, you do a lot of work for maybe not a lot of sales, but it's a machine that you can truly track the metrics down to the key, which I love a lot just from a business standpoint, because trackability is huge.
SPEAKER_01It is awesome to know like numbers for everything. The more numbers you know, the more you know how to like it's like saves you an incredible amount of time. It's like you know exactly what levers to pull at any given time, just based on set of numbers.
SPEAKER_02As a paid lead source, what's your go-to?
SPEAKER_03Uh well, I got turned on to you know, a broker ILB. I would say going through one broker like that has been really nice. You know, I've done direct with all the big name guys and stuff like that. And I still do because our carrier, you know, co-opts us, you know, on certain lead vendors. So we'll do some with them, but you know, only enough to max out what what we get co-opt for. Uh, but the bulk of ours has come been coming through ILB, and I like it. You know, you can do massive amounts, and you know, you get a low cost per you know lead there, and it's it it makes it a lot you know more flat across the board on cost, and it's the same quality, absolutely same quality.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, they all it's funny, yeah, yeah. It's all the same, it's funny because because the agents always ask, and I talk about this all the time and and think it's kind of funny because it's a question I used to ask is hey, who are you using? How's you know, company XYZ, or how's this? And it's like that's not the question to ask. The question is, you know, what what contact rate are you seeing that is good, or what should I be looking for, not you know, the company because it's all data, right? It's all just forms people filled out with their information.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's funny, and it does, and it fluctuates like no matter who you're with, one week something's good, another week somebody else is good. Like it's like it's kind of a it definitely fluctuates. Yeah, as soon as you think it's amazing. Awesome. So uh moving on to referrals. Are you what are you doing for referrals? Are you tracking that? Are you having your team reach out and trying to get those?
SPEAKER_03So we kind of have right now a loose tracking, you know, system on referrals. Uh we we do do have some, but you know, they definitely focus a lot. After every call, we actually encourage massively. We just started doing like, hey, Google review, whether we close them or not, the agent, the producers are literally just trying to say, hey, you know, I know I could or could not have helped you out today, but at least did I, you know, make you a little bit smarter about, you know, what you need and you know, and things like that and coverage. And because we've made that switch, you know, it's adding people that are actually writing reviews on Google, and they may not even be an actual paying customer, but uh that's been something we've been trying to do. And then, you know, referrals, building like referral partnerships is always a wonderful thing to do. Uh, but you know, from lenders and realtors and stuff like that. One of the issues there is they have pretty high turnover and they're, you know, just like insurance agents. So therefore, building those relationships sometimes we struggle with just because those people move and bounce around. Yeah, but uh customer referrals, that's you know, a whole nother animal. Uh, you know, our inbound team, once a new agent sells something, that's where our inbound, you know, and then our service team really kind of focuses on getting those referrals during the onboarding process. And uh that's ways that they can make you know extra activity happen for the agency.
SPEAKER_02So you just said two of the words that encompass the next question, which is the onboarding process. Like what do you do when you're onboarding new clients? And and how has that changed the game for you in your agency?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so you know, we used to always do absolutely nothing.
SPEAKER_02And right, consistently.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, consistently we used to do nothing.
SPEAKER_01And so you know it was working.
SPEAKER_03And speaking right now, you know, we've kind of been doing it round robin to the service team of like, hey, here, you do the onboarding for this one, this sale that they just made. You know, I've realized that that's that's just you know not a smart method. And I'm in the process of converting to where literally there's one person in the office and their job is onboarding. And, you know, obviously they have other duties, but one service person to really onboard, really like take, you know, that extra step, you know, make sure all the documents are signed, make sure you know all the discounts are applied properly, really make sure the person, you know, is super ecstatic and happy to be a new customer of ours. Help them with cancellations, uh, you know, their their prior insurance, all that stuff. And uh, you know, so it's starting to got getting a little bit better for us where one person has that set system process and they're improving their ability on generating a live conversation or, you know, getting another referral or a Google review if we hadn't already gotten one. And uh so that's that's been kind of you know the process that we're starting to do that I can really see like a huge boost, you know, in customer satisfaction there.
SPEAKER_01I love that. And how are you? I mean, this kind of goes along the same lines, and it's probably this very similar answer, but just in general, a lot of agents want to know. I know out here in California the like the loss ratio is a big issue. So, like, how do you approach like retention and just everything with your agency? Like, how are you just containing it? You're you're bringing in a ton of clients now. How do you just overall look at that?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and so with that, you know, there's only so much you can do to retain business. Uh, and so when you put a lot of effort into retaining someone, it's like, come on, if our carriers really wanted this customer, their algorithm would rate them accordingly. And so is that's my belief. We can only do so much as an agency to retain someone. Fortunately for us in our carrier, just bought another carrier, so we now have like two preferred markets for our auto home umbrella. So that's been a huge lifesaver this year. Uh and so, you know, will that continue? I don't know, but now you know, we might be able to round robin them kind of with with that aspect, and and that might help out. But uh in the end, you know, leave on a really good note. I mean, help them get canceled. Like, try not to, you know, but hey, you know, if they're getting the same exact coverage, decent service at half the price, who are we to say, okay, don't you can't do that. That's terrible. Why not let them go, keep in touch, and just write them, bring them back two, three years from now. Create the forum. And and that's really the approach, as long as we're remarketing those win backs, then losing them for a couple of years isn't the end of the world.
SPEAKER_01So this is very interesting. I guarantee you there's a lot of agents out there listening, like, what the heck? Like, we spend so much time. I know so many agents that spend so much time on retention that it spills over into sales. Sales becomes 10% of you know the agency's uh efforts, and uh 90% is uh retention and and everything else, right? Um, there was a conversation I had with someone. I've never said this on here because it's definitely going to be controversial, but uh we when I first came into the agency, somebody said uh we're talking about sales. And I said, What's the swing on retention? Like you have four service agents, right? What if you just flipped them all to sales, did no service? Like, what do you think the retention difference would be? So we were talking about it, it might be a 10% difference. And I said, Well, if you did flip your four people into sales, how much faster would you grow? And wouldn't that net a better result? And the thing is with that, it's not a realistic scenario, it's not something you should do. You should be empathetic to your clients. There's no, this is not a this was just an exercise in thought. It wasn't like a hey, you know, don't ever help anybody again. But the reason why I said that was because you know, a lot of agents, especially the more negative ones, are just so focused on just I gotta keep it. I can't lose two autos this month. And it's like, dude, don't lose the two, who cares? Get four autos, go get four autos, lose the two autos. Like, and that's kind of along the lines that you're saying. But uh, what I love that you said even more is like take that effort of the retention and flip it into the win backs, like that same amount of effort that you're doing to try to keep them might be better served in creating a really awesome win back follow-up campaign to just say, man, if nothing's going right for you, we still want ya, you know.
SPEAKER_02I love that. Well, and you can automate that, right? Instead of just being reactive all day and trying to save it, and then the emotional component of it too, right? Where you're bummed out because they're leaving and you're trying to save it because it's a do or die. Why not leave them on a happy note where you weren't it wasn't all gross, where you're like, please stay, and then they never come back because they're like that was terrible, right? Automate it, and you just saved yourself a bunch of time.
SPEAKER_01100%. Super cool.
SPEAKER_02And if you really want to get get crazy with it, get their Facebook, the email they have associated with their Facebook, and then you could actually just retarget them on Facebook. How about that? Throw the pixel on them.
SPEAKER_01How do you find that email valve? I just went over my own.
SPEAKER_02What's your Facebook login and password? I do have 32 emails. Too many things. So, well, one of my favorites is is besides this podcast, what kind of things do you do to keep yourself motivated?
SPEAKER_03My wife motivates me on a daily basis. Wow. You know, I was nice of her. Yeah, no, she does, and not in a bad way, not like cracking the whip, you know. She literally leads me, just you know, really inspires me. She's really into fitness, health fitness, you know, and I would be the exact opposite. I'm generally lazy, you know. So uh it really helps me out and it helps me get a lot better just having her just a part of my life. And so she every single day she motivates me. I mean, she's extremely athletic, very fit, you know, just amazing. And like I'm always like, okay, yeah, I better go to the gym today. Can't have her, you know, being stronger, faster, you know, fitter than I am. So, you know, she's definitely the number one uh, you know, motivation for me that's the situation of my house. Nothing else I need.
SPEAKER_02Stronger, fitter, faster.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. That's awesome to hear, man. I love that. So going back to the agencies, what do you think is like some of the biggest obstacles that our agencies are gonna be facing in the next few years?
SPEAKER_03I mean, you know, staffing A is always gonna be an issue. And, you know, obviously, if you're able to, you can always offer a better work environment, better pay, you know, to attract the people you want, you know, other challenges, you know, or yeah, get in touch with people as you know, that as we've all seen with Stir Shaking and all that stuff, you know, that that makes challenges. But you know, anytime there's a challenge, there's always someone smart enough to figure a way to overcome it. So far, that hasn't been me. I'm just pirating off everybody else, but you know, I have no problem implementing other people's ideas, and occasionally I might have one of my own. But uh, you know, so it's really it's just staying consistent, you know. It's so easy to get complacent. And like I said, I'm from the military and we have an old saying that says complacency kills, and it really does. And so that's the number one, you know, killer of anything is complacency and crack.
SPEAKER_02And crack. Yeah, very close number two.
SPEAKER_03I don't know anybody who's died by a crack.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I guess it's I I don't have my circle is either. Well, they're good sayings. So, uh, how about your number one recommendation to anybody crazy enough to jump into this world and become an insurance agent?
SPEAKER_03I mean, definitely pay attention, you know, think for yourself, listen to everyone, but come to your own conclusions and don't stay negative at all. Like you just can't, like, yeah, you just have to look at the bright side of everything because it's all an uphill battle. And goodness, y'all know as well as anybody, if this were super easy, everyone would do it.
SPEAKER_02Caveman would do it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_02Yep, yeah, and it is easy. No crack, no complacency, no crack, no crack.
SPEAKER_01It is easy enough to where you don't have to sell that much in order to keep a job, right? Like, what other industry can you be in that you can have a certain amount of like sales this year and a certain amount of sales last year, and and still be able to continue, you know?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. I mean, the residual part of it is amazing.
SPEAKER_02It is, the math is there, right? Like, it's all there. You can figure it out with math, and if you follow it, you put in the process, you're consistent, it works out. It is pretty amazing.
SPEAKER_01So, Shepard, you have gone the distance, my man. I just want to acknowledge you. You know, you've been on the elite calls for the last uh, you know, gosh, couple months, and you're always in there with such an amazing attitude. Like, there's no way anything's gonna bring you. You're so positive with everything, and you're such a good influence on us and everybody else. So just want to acknowledge you for being such an awesome insurance dude. And your numbers, I mean, are amazing.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, the team's killing it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, super cool.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you and Carbonal are the current kings right now. Well, I got more carriers.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, you got a new couple new guys in there, so uh yeah, you're gonna give them a run for the money. Scale, scale, scale. Scale, scale, scale. Awesome, Shepard. Well, we appreciate it, my man. Yeah, thank you. Been awesome.
SPEAKER_03All right, well, thank you guys.
SPEAKER_01Have a good one.
SPEAKER_03You too.
SPEAKER_01Hey, what are you still doing here? Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, if you weren't listening before, we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01Using these strategies did help Craig and I write over 10 million in premium in the last couple years.
SPEAKER_02And let me tell you, on this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same results.
SPEAKER_01Again, that's live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_02And if you jump on with us, we are certain. 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman