The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The Insurance Dudes are on a mission to find the best insurance agentsaround the country to find out how they are creating some of the top agencies. But they do not stop there, they also bring professionals from other industries for insights that can help agents take their agencies to the next level. The Insurance Dudes focus on your agency’s four pillars: Hiring, Training, Marketing and Motivation! We have to keep the sword sharp if we want our agencies to thrive.&nbs...
Uh the wildest thing that has ever happened in my agency. Wow. I think it was back in like 2014. Back then, all I pretty much I had like three staff. I'd been in business for a few years and you know, spent all my money on direct mail, stuff like that. And so around that time I started to not ever answer the phone. Uh, I let my staff do it. And then, but I kind of had this rule. I was like, three rings, and you know, I'm gonna be really upset. But uh, I noticed it ringing, it ringing, it ringing. And normally I would just get onto them and let it go to voicemail and get onto the staff later. But uh this time I was like, you know what? I'm sitting around, I'm doing nothing. I might as well answer the phone, see if I can take care of somebody. Uh I pick up the phone, and then uh it was one of our insured, so like a current customer, and she was just calling saying, Hey, you know, it is is Trish available? I was like, No. All right, well, and to kind of restart, I answered the phone. I didn't say who I was, I just said, Hey, thanks for calling my carrier, and uh how can I help you? And she was like, Well, is Trish there? I was like, No, she's on the other line. Uh, is Christy there? No, uh, I want to say she's off at lunch right now. And then she asked, she asked for another person, I can't remember. And then finally I said, Well, I'm Shepard, I'm the owner here. You know, I can help you out. And she said, No, you'll just fuck it up and hung up. And that was the wildest thing that happened. And my name is and I'm in Cartersville, Georgia, and I'm an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_01
Insurance dudes are auto. I are interested.
SPEAKER_03
I am insurance. Right now, while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_01
We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_03
Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years. On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results. Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_01
If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. Boom.
SPEAKER_03
Boom.
SPEAKER_02
I love that. How did you react when they told you that that was what you would do?
SPEAKER_00
Well, that was the light bulb moment for me. It was like, okay, I did it. Like, you know, I wasn't a huge agency yet, but I at least had that part down. Which current customers realized I was the most useless person in the office. The best.
SPEAKER_02
There's nothing more liberating.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah. And so that that was, you know, kind of the moment I really moved from being an insurance agent to a business owner in my mind.
SPEAKER_02
That's awesome. I remember I remember going to a conference in Texas, and the guy that would run it would say, he was older at that time, and so it was a while back because now I'm old, but he'd always allude and talk about like, I don't even know how to log into the computer, you know. And I thought, ah, he's just joking. You know, like that's not possible. Thinking of all the stuff that I was doing, like being on the hamster wheel. And yeah, it's it's it's nice to be on the other side of that.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, it is. We Shepard and I were talking about that before you jumped on. It was it's like that, like that moment is the most liberating moment when you realize like there's other people better than you, like at the things, you know, at all the things, it's like, oh, that's awesome.
SPEAKER_02
Right. Yeah. At the beginning, you kind of want to be the best, like it's this ego thing. You want to be the best at everything, and then you realize that that makes you the worst when you're the best at everything. Yeah, right.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah. Cool. Well, I'm excited about this one. So, Shepard, for all the dudes out there, dudettes, uh, tell us how you got into this crazy business of insurance.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, so kind of just tripped and fell into it, you know, like probably most insurance agents, because no one grows up saying, hey, I want to be an insurance agent when I grow up.
SPEAKER_03
Yep.
SPEAKER_00
Uh yeah, so I was living in Georgia, or kind of backstory on me, uh, 17, joined the army, traveled the world, had a lot of fun, got to blow some stuff up, came home, got married, got out of the army, and uh my wife and I had some money saved up, so we were like, hey, let's go be ski bums. So we moved from our home state in Georgia. Like a week later, the Uha was packed, and we moved out to Colorado and uh tried to be ski bums. That didn't last very long because we ran out of money. Military does not pay that well. And needless to say, I was doing several odds and ends kind of jobs, doing this, doing that, trying to figure out what I wanted to do in life. And uh, you know, I started a business out of the insurance industry, completely failed. And uh, but in the course of that business, I bumped into an insurance agent with my carrier, and uh he kind of started pitching me on hey, come work for me. It's an amazing opportunity. I kind of got the hint like he was brand new. And one thing when I got out of the army, I was like, I'll never work for other people ever again. So uh I did some research, researched that carrier, that carrier only, which uh, you know, who knows if that was a smart decision. But uh researched the carrier. I then became uh got got in touch with like a you know district recruiter, and he kind of did the whole spiel, the pitch of hey, you know, here's what you could be making in five years and all that jazz. And so I was like, you know, I talked to my wife about it. She was like, I think you should do it. And I said, Are you sure? Because I don't really want to do that, but she said, You can do it. I was like, okay, so you know, go, got all my licenses. Back then they had a program where, you know, you could start as an agency on it from scratch and and uh so got approved for that and just kind of hit the ground running from there, did it out in Colorado for a couple years and mediocre, very low performing agent at that point in time. Needless say, uh, you know, I sold that book back to the carrier and moved back home to Georgia. And uh one of the cool claims to like our folklore is I was the very first captive agent representing my carrier in our state in history in Georgia.
SPEAKER_02
Oh wow, neat no way, yeah.
SPEAKER_00
I'm part of the you know, history of the company, I guess. Uh one to open their doors in our state, which is pretty neat. But that's I got insurance.
SPEAKER_02
Wow. So a lot of stuff happened in that time. When did it take? Like what was the earliest fire that kind of was lit under you, and you're like, ah, this is this is it, I love it.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah. Uh it was definitely when I started making pretty decent money, or at least gross income was doing really nice. Uh, you know, I when I was out in Colorado, I was a mediocre agent doing all the wrong things, and you know, I was making enough to get by. But when I came into Georgia, you know, I was like, okay, come in smart, spend money marketing, you know, do all that kind of stuff. So I, you know, I started seeing the the fruits of that pretty quickly. And I thankfully I had the foresight to reinvest every single penny I was making back into the agency to keep that growth going. And so, you know, it I would say probably a a couple of years, like maybe two years into my you know tenure in Georgia as an agent, that's when it just everything was on fire. I was like leading our state, entire state in, you know, total new sales, you know, just one of the top of the you know state for a couple years in a row. And so that was nice, you know. And uh, you know, and then I just kind of plateaued and hung out for a while until I, you know, decided, hey, let's grow some more.
SPEAKER_02
Right. About four years to really have it take and kind of figure it out.
SPEAKER_00
I would say yeah, because you know, I mean, the carriers don't teach you anything really on how to build it. And so you you know, you do a lot of trial and error, and don't, then that's where most agents you know struggle, is they're they don't take the risk of let's see if this works. And if it does, great. If not, we just lost a bunch of money, but let's keep trying.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, the carriers don't tell you about the business hat, they only tell you about the agent hat. And it's crazy because of course the motivation of the carriers is to you know constantly reach out to the clients and and everything for the clients, uh, which is awesome, but at some point you I mean you have to justify those costs with sales and like growth and everything else. So it's not, you know, you want to do everything right that the carrier wants, but you just you can't invest uh all of your time and your staff's time in on those things because uh that's gonna kill your business.
SPEAKER_02
Oh yeah. It is interesting. They they sell the concept of being the business owner, and you go with that and you think and we're gonna give you the support, and then it's we're gonna support you as the agent. And it is what it is, you know. I think everybody goes through that journey and learns from it, and the ones that make it through it are better for it, usually.
SPEAKER_03
Right. Well, so Shepard, you grew up. I man, I I keep wanting to call you Chep. Um you're gonna make me start calling you Chep, too.
unknown
I know.
SPEAKER_03
So you uh, you know, you kind of hit you you hit the ground running, but then you really started scaling up. I know that your your numbers now are just incredible. So describe your team like currently, how many members, what did they do, what are their roles, and how's that set up currently?
SPEAKER_00
Well, so beginning of this year is when I kind of changed the model. Uh and what I did was I really went and separated that true outbound agent team and inbound agent team. And you know, I took that off some other agent, I can't remember uh, you know, the idea, but uh it's where, yeah, you know, you want to work the lead game, stuff like that. Those people don't need to be answering the phones that are service calls. And I had made that mistake in the past where yeah, I just kind of had the hybrid sales slash service, and they tried to work leads, and it never worked out that way. And so, you know, now right now I have three, you know, basically inbound, you know, service agents that they're responsible for cross-selling, upselling, and just overall handling, you know, everybody, you know, all our customers, whether they're brand new or uh, you know, eight years in. And then the outbound team is just, yeah, they work directly on our leads that you know we purchase, work with the TMs, uh, you know, and really master just closing new business and bringing new accounts in. And right now there's three on that team with two more that are starting next week, which is really nice. And we're we're trying to rapidly grow over the course of 2022 and 2023.
SPEAKER_03
How many people on the sales team?
SPEAKER_00
Uh, there's gonna be five total starting Monday.
SPEAKER_03
So cool, cool, cool, awesome. And we'll we'll dive in. I I'm so curious of of their numbers and everything. You I know you're a high performance dude, so yeah.
SPEAKER_02
Why don't you talk a little bit about the culture that you've created there and and how that's been an integral part of doing what you do and getting the results that you're getting?
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, so the culture really definitely for me started uh when I was recruiting people. You know, I was like, okay, my recruiting strategies over the years had never really given me given me good results. And uh so it all kind of started with a setting a standard, you know, which I know I used to fail at, you know, setting that up front. And I really do a hardcore time now trying to paint them a very, very, very, very detailed picture before they're even hired. That hey, we're focused on, you know, continuous learning, continuous growth, and just really hardworking, hard playing, you know, kind of, you know, office setting. But you know, some of our producers, they're fully remote and started with me fully remote from day one. And uh, you know, so we kind of have that mixture of in-office and remote. And I haven't found any problems with it. Uh, it's been really good. I like it a lot myself just because it's so much easier to sit in front of a computer and talk to everybody, share the screens, you know, because anytime we got to troubleshoot something, it's so easy to do it over, you know, via Zoom or whatever. And uh, you know, that's kind of been the environment that we focus on. And then just myself trying to lead as like a servant leader, uh, you know, really trying to coach them as best as possible. I mean, uh, I have the attention span of a goldfish, so it's really hard for me to continuously day in, day out, coach them, uh, but I am for now. And uh, you know, I it's funny, someone once told me that workers that feel appreciated are always the most grateful and are always the hardest working.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
And uh, you know, I so far that's you know, since I kind of changed my model and started focusing on that, I really see a major difference in just the quality of people. And it's not like these people are any better than the people before them. It's just that they have that, you know, support, true support structure that I'm trying to provide. And that's my main focus day in, day out, is is just them and making sure they succeed. Because if they do, I'll succeed or go bankrupt due to not being profitable. One or the other. Yep. But more than likely, you know, success will breed more success. And that's that's what what we really try and focus on.
SPEAKER_03
When did that shift happen?
SPEAKER_00
Uh I mean, gradually, then all of a sudden, you know, is is really the best way to say. I mean, it's happened over the years uh in my mind and realizing it. And then when I, you know, listen to podcasts or talk to other agents that are successful, you know, you really start to pick up on the ideas and then you go to the draw, you know, go to the drawing board and say, okay, look, where do I want to be and work it all out from there, whether it's talk pass scripts, you know, marketing spend, how many employees you need, yada yada yada. It all just kind of like you got to take all that information, bring it into one room and put it all together like a puzzle. And uh so that's why gradually over the past probably two, three years, uh, but you know, instantly back in January when I really said, all right, let's pull the trigger and execute everything 100%.
SPEAKER_03
Love it. And then how do you recruit for that now?
SPEAKER_00
Uh so you know, a variety of things. I mean, it's just like the lead game, you know, you or you want multiple marketing sources. Uh, so recruiting is the exact same pathway. No matter who comes to you, though, they all have to have that system and process where your hiring portion is the exact same. So from interview, first interview, second interview, things like that. I've used a variety of recruiting companies, you know, corporately. I work with our uh corporate recruiters uh that are trying to recruit agency owners, but you know, they send me lots of quality people that may not, you know, possess the startup capital to go, you know, scratch agency by themselves, or they just want to work with an existing agency that's been around for a while that can teach them. And so I kind of work, you know, in those lines, you know, and then you know, sure, traditional job postings, spending on those, uh, anything really, just to gather people's attention. And then, you know, you know, headhunting yourself, reaching out to, you know, other agents, staff, you know, letting them know, hey, here's our opportunity. You may be a better fit here and give them something to think about. And if they are, then they'll apply and you may have success with them, you may not. Uh, I don't necessarily put any major priority of someone with experience over someone without, but they definitely don't have their learning curve is shorter though. Uh, the only thing you have to worry about is you know, if they bring a bad attitude or bad which you can usually filter that out, or at least I've been successful in filtering that out in the hiring process.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. What about once they're on and then ensuring that they're successful? What kind of what what sort of framework do you have for that?
SPEAKER_00
Uh so that's like a fluid document, definitely. That's always changing, trying to you know be better and improve on that. You know, we really try and hit hardcore with you know a week or two of product training, system training, you know, how to talk training. No matter if someone just came to me with 15 years of selling insurance, you know, we still want them on the same standard as everybody else. And so we really just kind of put that framework in and then the continuous daily training, you know, 15, 20 minute morning huddles every single day, whether we want to talk about a specific product, talk about objection handling, or just overall, you know, hey, who had wins, who didn't? That's that's proven to just really be worthwhile for us to spend that time.
SPEAKER_03
Hey, what are you still doing here? Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, if you weren't listening before, we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents throughout the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_03
Using these strategies did help Craig and I write over $10 million in free in the last couple of years.
SPEAKER_01
And let me tell you, on this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same results.
SPEAKER_03
Again, that's live.teled.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_02
And if you jump on with us, we are certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you.
SPEAKER_01
See you there.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.