The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The Insurance Dudes are on a mission to find the best insurance agentsaround the country to find out how they are creating some of the top agencies. But they do not stop there, they also bring professionals from other industries for insights that can help agents take their agencies to the next level. The Insurance Dudes focus on your agency’s four pillars: Hiring, Training, Marketing and Motivation! We have to keep the sword sharp if we want our agencies to thrive.&nbs...
But let's really focus on cost per sale and the amount of time we spent because you're not going to have reliable data to make decisions off of unless you let the leads marinate. Any good griller knows marination, it's going to take time. You can't marinate it in two minutes. So same thing with the leads. Your perfect marination time to kind of the middle of the cycle is about 45 days.
SPEAKER_00
How? By encovering the secret predictable, consistent, and profitable agency failure. I am great president. I am A development. We are agents.
SPEAKER_01
We are insurance dudes. Right now, while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com. We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast. Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years. On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results. Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_02
If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there. Hello, this is Craig Pretzinger. You are on the Insurance Dudes Podcast. This is another playbook, agency playbook for you. We're going to get into internet leads again here over the next few episodes that I'm going to produce. So buckle up and sit back and get ready to go. We're going to look at four of the biggest mistakes. In fact, all four of these things must be avoided or must be implemented. The opposite of them must be implemented in order to get results from internet leads. Now, before we dive into that, I want to set it up real quick with a real interesting backstory. And I wonder if this is going to resonate with a lot of folks out there. Likely you're on this, you listen to the Insurance Dudes podcast because you're interested in improving and potentially finding those little nuggets that we are able to extract from our interviews, or even if we provide a little bit of nuggets when we're doing these playbooks. A, we hope that you're getting some valuable information. But B, we know that if you're here, then you are looking for something that's going to work. And so this is probably going to resonate with you. I I know that I've tried over the years many, many different marketing strategies, many, many times have ended up or resulted in failure. And a lot of them have to do with uh executing on these four things here. But uh if anybody's read uh, I believe it's from the 12-hour work week, the optimism-pessimism scale. We talk about it in our webinar a little bit, but it's kind of like why stuff never works, you know. When we when we start with something, we get super excited and when we're ready to go and we want to get into it, ah, and we're and we're running. And then it doesn't happen as quickly as we want. So we go from this level of super excited, ready to rock and roll, uh, more coherent in understanding the thing we're using, but now we're not quite as certain or excited or optimistic as we were in the beginning, right? So we know more, but because we're not seeing the results, we're starting to get a little pessimistic about it. And eventually what happens is we hit this bottom. And at that bottom, we either dig in and make it work, or we give up. And oftentimes my experience was hey, it's not working, you know, I was really excited, but it's not working anymore. I'm throwing the towel, I'm gonna find the next thing. So, what we want to do for you guys, everybody listening to this, uh, all the insurance dudes and dudettes out there, is hopefully help to eliminate that entire curve, right? We want to break the cycle. We want to break the cycle of super excited, ah, it's not quite working, I give up. Because what we found is typically, and now that we've had hundreds and hundreds of clients with uh teledudes, we see everybody enters successful, or I'm I'm sorry, everybody enters super optimistic, and we've gotten really good at managing expectations because the inputs that we put into the thing are what dictate the results and uh how much effort and all of the different things that we're gonna get into, but it's critical to what's interesting that we've seen along the way is that whether or not the person gets success, what happens is at that bottom, when it's uh they they've now passed this part of uh it's I kind of get it, but it's not it's not really working. When it gets to this intolerable pain, and it's not always the case, but when it gets to that point, it is often that point right then that if we eject, we've just missed the boat. So I encourage anybody trying anything, any marketing strategy, to be aware that as humans, as soon as something gets uncomfortable, we're gonna move to avoid that pain, right? We're we're much quicker to avoid pain than we are to move to pleasure, which is uh success. So really, really important there. And that's with anything, you know, if it's if it's starting to get a little uncomfortable and painful, you're probably getting close. And that's that's an important thing. So the first the first thing, and uh this is totally in line with that piece of it, is with internet leads. So when we're buying internet leads, we go in with this expectation, okay, I need to find an ROI, I need to get back the money that I'm putting into this, or it's just a it's just a cost and it's not working. Well, what a majority of agents do is underestimate the time that it takes to get the results from the leads. Uh, anybody that's been on the webinar knows we show the uh the bell curve over the historical results of what it takes. It's gonna be about a 90-day, right? The safe life of an internet lead is 90 days because they're fully opted in. If you're buying the right kind of leads from a dependable and trustable source, then we're gonna we're going to have a 90-day opted-in digital certificate that that accompanies that lead that the uh carrier has, or not the carrier, the lead company has on their file. So we're looking at a 90-day cycle, which means somewhere closer to the middle, sometimes it's a little before, sometimes it's a little after, is the point that we're closing business. Sure, we're gonna get a lead in some cases or even on the daily, depending on how many leads we're buying. But we're going to get a lead, we're gonna actually make contact with them that day, we're gonna actually quote them that day, and we're gonna actually close them. That will happen, but that's only gonna happen a very small percentage of the time. So what we and and it was my experience, I remember the first uh the first five different times, you know, separate instances that I bought internet leads, probably all the way up until 2017-2018, was I buy the leads because everybody's buying the leads, and or the vendor calls and I get sold on some some program, and we buy the leads, we call them a few times, we don't get a hold of anybody, we don't sell any of them, and then we say, Oh, these leads are the worst, and and we get rid of them and we stop calling them, and we think, uh, well, just waste another two thousand dollars on leads. And what was important in this, if we take away from if I could take away from my experience and and my failures with internet leads, is it is important that we do the long play, right? So we're buying consistently, and we'll get into those pieces, but right now we want to focus on the time. It is incredibly important to realize that as we're calculating, we're tracking and measuring our cost per sale, all right, because that's the most important part, not the price of the lead. The most important part is the cost per sale. Of course, you're gonna want to be in the ballpark of five, six, seven bucks for a lead. Anything more, it's not gonna end in a good cost per sale. Anything much less, you may have a quality issue. Sure, we can find some deals out there that are two, three, four bucks. But you really want to keep your eye on those, uh, on your 30-day number, uh, your 60-day number, your 90-day cost per sale to see if you have those results. That is the key with all of them, right? Is we have to let the leads bake. Uh, as one of our good friends, George Carmenall says, we have to let those leads marinate, right? Once the leads have been called several, several many times, and it's been enough time, then we have an then we can make a decision on whether or not these are quote unquote good leads or these leads suck, right? And this all comes from giving it time, right? Which is probably one of the most challenging things emotionally to handle because we're spending, spending, spending, spending, and you know, the lead company is saying it's gonna take time. If you're with teledudes, we're gonna tell you, hey, those telemarketers are gonna have to call for quite a while before it really starts to pick up, and that's only at the beginning, right? Then once you have a pipeline, you don't take your foot off the gas, so on and so forth. So the first mistake to avoid is not giving leads enough time to marinate, because if we don't, we're never gonna be able to drive down that cost per sale. Just some quick numbers for you with internet leads. You can expect a cost per sale, she's all the way up to a thousand twelve hundred bucks in the first in the first few days, in the first week. And the as we what we'll see is over time, as those leads keep continue to get called, but we're looking at at the at the one week, at the two week, at the 30-day mark, you should be down much lower than that that initial heart stopping cost per sale. And then in 60 days, it's gonna be even less. And 90 days, we're looking for somewhere around that $200 to you know, anywhere uh between $100 and $200 as a cost per sale. If you can get it under $100, whoa, right? Then you're gonna pour gas on it. But but let's really focus on cost per sale and the amount of time we spent because you're not gonna have reliable data to make decisions off of unless you let the leads marinate. Any good griller knows marination, it's gonna take time. You can't marinate it in two minutes. So, same thing with the leads. Your perfect marination time to kind of the middle of the cycle is about 45 days. That, my friends, is the first of four really, really important key elements of internet leads so you can get results. And the mistake would be not giving them enough time. We'll see you on the football.
SPEAKER_01
Hey, what are you still doing here? Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, if you weren't listening before, we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01
Using these strategies did help Craig and I write over $10 million in premium in the last couple years.
SPEAKER_02
And let me tell you, on this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same results.
SPEAKER_01
Again, that's live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_02
And if you jump on with us, we are certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.