The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Bryan Taylor's Positively Terrific Part 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
What would be the number one tip that you would give an agent coming into the world right now? Starting off, you know, depending on whether you're a scratch or I'll say on buying an existing book, you really, when you're going into it, you really need to be all in.
SPEAKER_01I are in three. Right now, while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_00We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years. On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results. Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_00If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you.
SPEAKER_02See you there. Chad alluded to on his call, but I think he has uh remote workers. I think he had one in Charlotte, North Carolina. I can't remember exact city, but that's the challenge for me is I I have not the ones I've had have been an utter failure. They haven't been they haven't worked out. But I know there's an opportunity. I I'm more engaged when they're actually in the office because I like that uh engagement there. Some people can work remotely, but you have to be disciplined to be a remote worker. I mean, I'll tell you flat out, I can't work at home. I mean, I have to be engaged in the office or in front of the customers. And I tell those, tell them that you can't just get up, put on, put on your uh wear your pajamas or t-shirt. You mean you got to get up, get dressed, put on your slack, shoes, button up, be professionally, have a have a setup to do. But I I think you have to be, they're there. And I think we're becoming more our world's going that way, but but and to Chad's point, I think he mentioned that they try to have a lot of Zoom calls to feel like they're connected with that. So I'm I kind of gained a little bit of knowledge from that on some of your shows that you've had. I've got, you know, what can I do? If I find someone that's a rock star as a remote worker, then it gives them the flexibility to be successful. You know, to me, honestly, you should be the most successful one if you're a remote worker, because really there's you don't have to deal with walk-ins like we do. I mean, we we like I said we got 10 to 15 a day. So you're not you don't have the interruptions other than the phone ringing. So, you know, that that's a challenge. I think for all of us in our industry now, it's good you're seeing more and more of that uh on the on the remote side. And how do you deal with that? How do you uh actually incorporate that to making it a successful business for all of us? And uh because you know, people want to be included in how do you do that in the best way, you know, if they're not there actually in your office uh on a day in day out basis. Uh so that that I think that's a challenge. I think that will evolve going forward, not just with us, but a lot of a lot of industry, I believe. It'll be interesting to see how that plays out because you know, you have these large carriers and different corporations, they're they're going more remote. And is productivity there, you know, whether it's on the claim side or or dealing with customer service. So it'll be interesting as as this evolves more and more to see how that plays out for all of us. Um, Zoom is fantastic. I think, you know, like we're doing now. I mean, you're Arizona, you're in California, and I'm in uh Lil'O South Carolina, you know. And so uh we even got Zoom and internet, it was pretty amazing.
SPEAKER_01Yes, no, it's it's crazy. I mean, yeah, I I think if anything, the going through that experience, we had to go, we had to bring our computer by we had to go remote um for a long time here in California. And uh we just had to get good at it fast. Um the cool thing is that there's a ton of tools, and and now we had to learn them quickly, like like to your point, Zoom and stuff like that. I mean, most grandparents today know how to use Zoom, you know. But three years ago, that wasn't the case. So it was not the case. Yeah. It's pretty, it's pretty crazy the position we're in. There's a there's definitely an you know, like to your point at the beginning of the conversation, you know, people uh are t tend to to go towards the negative a little bit more. I mean, it's but there's also this whole other thing that we're not talking about, which is all the positive stuff, which is is like the remote tools and yeah and all these things that we got kind of forced to do, but have has made our lives a little bit easier. Like I yes, I'm not in the office as much. Um, and I never will be again. And I think a lot of uh like half of our staff uh works from home.
SPEAKER_02And I yeah, I remember I think I remember you talking about that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00I'll never go. But that March of 2020 when everybody had to go home, he his agency did over 250k. That's amazing. And and I think there weren't many agencies that did that. There weren't many agencies that put in more telemarketers and more leads and just went all in than what he was doing. So I just want to tip my hat because I know that he wouldn't ever talk about that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, well that's the but that's a testament to what you guys and what you have done on the process, it's all about process. Uh I think that's the key to to any agency or any any business that you run is is the process you put in place. I'm trying to get better at that from learning from uh you guys, learning from others on your podcast, learning from from uh good friends of mine within the industry that that do this on a day in and day out basis. And to your point on on going back on the positive side, you know, one of the things that I uh think that really helped me is uh based on going through the challenges of last year and towards the end of 2020, you see, and then anything with within the industry itself, you if you go on Facebook or you go on different links, they have all these different uh posts you can, you know, these sites you can go on. The negativity was off the charts. And I said, I I refuse to go go down that road because we all there's negative in everything. So I'm gonna feed myself on the positivity because if I can do that, I'm gonna I'm gonna help get my mind in the right uh in the right frame of mind to and that'll enhance me and also help make my staff better because we look for if you look for the negative, you're gonna find it just like that. Yep. But there's so much positive in what we do, so much things that we can do to help folks out there in the business, because I truly I I love what I do because I'm able to help others. And whether it's just talking them through that or they call up, some of them are crying, and just helping them through whatever they may be dealing with at that point in their life. Uh whether they're, you know, yeah, we're gonna get plenty of of negative phone calls, but the the ones we have that are positive, the good the customers that appreciate what you do. And that's why I love what I do every day and coming in. And uh, because you know, we're problem. I mean, as I tell my staff, we're problem solvers. I mean, that's it. That's what that's what we do, you know. And so we just try to be that go-to source. And uh, you know, I want them calling me not just on insurance, but any little, you know, where they really get build that trust is when they're calling you asking about just on investments or or cars or you know, should I buy this car? You know, you know, there you have that trust factor with with with your customers. And uh if you can do that, you're winning. You're winning every day. So um, yeah.
SPEAKER_01So and I think Yeah, you mentioned referrals earlier, and we you and you've been talking about process. So I'd love to know what is your process for referrals? How are you tracking and measuring and and uh succeeding with those?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so on the on the referral aspect of it, we go into the uh call itself when say James is in there uh quoting an individual. And by the way, when we're going through that, always tell them, look, we're most likely not going to be the uh cheapest one out there. And anyone can always find someone cheaper. We're gonna educate first. We always educate. We make them understand the importance of why they have this type of coverage and the importance of bundling to potentially uh lower your overall rate as a whole. But we're educating and we build and that's how they build the trust. And and James is is a he's the nicest, most pushiest guy you'd ever meet. He he's he's got a knack for it. And so the goal at the end of the day, he has a little sheet he marks off and says, Hey, at the end of every call, make sure you ask for the referral. You know, hey, since we, you know, since you, you know, hopefully I've done a good job for you and hope you, you know, you're satisfied with what I've told you. Um, we're here to help you and be involved. You know, if you since you had such a great experience, would you mind sharing uh another individual's name and number that I could reach out to since I was able to help you guys out? Love to speak with them to see if I can help them out. It's it's pretty simple. I mean, it's it's it's it's really it's not rocket science as as we all know, but it's just don't forget to ask. And so that's one of the aspects there we we try to hone in on and we mark it on one of our uh platforms to keep up with you know how we the sales and the dinger we marks on their referrals we know how that's going. We can keep track of referrals and things like that. So are we perfect at it? No, but uh um it's just we have meetings every week to remind each other of the good things we've done, the things we could have done better, and always learning. I mean, we we always said if you're not learning, you're not growing, if you're not growing, then you're gonna be dying. So that's that's the bottom line there. So yeah, referrals are a key, but you know, we try to really dive in because those leads that we have, I said we got about 12,000. I mean, I've paid for those. Those that's a lot, that's a lot of money. So worth seven to ten times over the course of two weeks, and then we don't get rid of them, you know, then we go back to them later. And uh, so that's probably one area that we've been successful. We we we hit we hit our numbers where we need to go, but to uh you know, listening to you guys last week on the call, really see the importance of really driving, you know, being more efficient in opportunities to to sell, to work with folks on the phone. And if we can do that, we're gonna grow even more exponentially. Um, and that way, as I told them, we're we're growing. I continue to hire, and we hire another service to really have you guys focus just on sales. And and that's always my goal, is really to to enhance where they're they focus on sales, service focuses on service. And then I'm I'm here to I guess sometimes referee. Right.
SPEAKER_00So Brian, besides listening to this podcast, what how else do you keep yourself motivated?
SPEAKER_02So man, well, let's see. Um is there anything else? I mean, we you know, I like a little bourbon at night that always keeps you motivated. There you go. What kind? Well, I I you know, like uh uh Basil Hayden, uh a little, you know, Buffalo Trace, uh, you know, Jameis, you know, the simple, you know, I'm not at Chad Kish level, I'm not at top shelf level yet. You know, but uh but but uh one day I'll get there. But uh no, I do that. I I like to, you know, I really I like to talk to uh to keep myself motivated, uh listen to podcasts, like you guys uh try to be a part of uh uh go with the mentors that I have to I speak with, other agency owners, other business leaders too. You know, what are they doing? Because you can garner, gain so much knowledge from that. You know, being in my past working in athletics for so many years, you know, listen to a lot of coaches. And uh uh at Clemson, we've got you know, uh Dabo Sweeney won two national championships. We we I know some of the coaches there, some of them play when actually when I'm working, that's how you know I'm old now, but uh I try to gain knowledge from from whether it's the the coaches to to business leaders to podcast and uh you know and my wife, you know, she she has to keep me motivated too because uh it's so funny. She she uh I remember it was about two months ago, she says, Do you like what you're doing? I said, Yeah, I really do. She said, God, you're you're always seeming so stressed. I said, I know weirdly enough, I I am very stressed, but I just love what I do. It's just a different, and you guys can probably relate to it when you have that because you go to bed thinking about your your business per se. And then you wake up thinking about it. And you know, especially when you got now a little less, but a million reasons why you you gotta focus and drive your your business to uh to grow and and pay debt and uh to enjoy the fruits of your labor later. And uh um, but you know, I think uh if if you keep it in perspective and knowing you do the little things every day, then then it will pay off. And and and so um not to say there's challenges, there's months where you're like, my goodness, what have I done? But I've always met my goals and I've I've had I've had good uh people around me. And uh, I think for me is probably being a little bit more aggressive on the uh leads sales side. I think going out there to truly if it's done properly, you can exponentially grow even that much greater for and grow your grow your wealth uh by by investing in your business on leads, especially in this industry here. And so that's been a really positive thing uh uh to me to look at and and and see what other agents do. You know, there's there's another great agent. Uh I work we were in uh training class, and you need to get her on the program. She's she's fantastic. Uh Joanne Hartman in in uh Texas, she's out of uh her agency out of the Justin, Texas area. And uh she she actually worked for a the uh owner, and then she bought one of her agencies, and she's she's a rock star. I mean, gaining knowledge from her and those people like herself of what she does and just how she relates to the clients and how she can just really hammer, get to the point and just close the sale. She she's amazing from people like her and others from all over the country because every geography is a little different. Uh, but you can gain so much knowledge in other areas too. Uh, you know, from you know, and sometimes you gotta keep things in perspective too. I mean, when you're looking at a smaller, smaller area, your numbers are a lot less. But some of your most successful agents are maybe some of your smaller little towns and stuff that have really grown their book of business. Some of the other agents, uh super agents, you got a metro area of a few million people, like she does out in out in the Fort Worth, Dallas area. But it it's it's it's how you I always tell my staff. I mean, I got another independent agent right across the street from me, uh great guy. And I got two others, I mean, less than a mile, but we're our only competition. End of the day, we got to do our work, we got to put in the calls, we gotta uh take care of the the customers, and we can't worry about what others are doing. So if we focus on what we're doing, and like you guys always thought on your processes and getting those correct and embedded, then then the sky's the limit, you know, because that if you if you worry about what other people are doing, you know, oh man, you know, we we can't compete or or you know, our rates are going up or theirs are going down, and and it's like, you know what, we're still gonna win because somebody else says they're always gonna be successful. You have to figure out what you're dealt with and and and figure out how to how to get around it and make success out of it. And if you can do that, uh and stay positive and look at the positive versus the negative, what you can't do, what can we do? I mean, let's figure out what can we do and let's do what we can do and do it the right way. Do it ethically and correctly, do it the right way. You know, we're gonna lose we're gonna lose customers like everyone else does. But we always say, you know, I talk to them sometimes, I may have lost you now, but I'm gonna get you back in the Taylor family here before long. Nice, you know, and and a lot of them, that's like, yeah, call me back later. Some of it, you know, it's understood.
SPEAKER_00You know, Brian, when when you said um two months and your wife in the same sentence, I thought you were gonna go a totally different direction.
SPEAKER_02Oh yeah.
SPEAKER_00Because then we would have had something in in serious common there.
SPEAKER_02Oh yes, yes, yes, yes. I better clarify.
SPEAKER_01Speaking of challenges, yes, yes, yes.
SPEAKER_02It is the challenges, yes, yes. After 20, after going on 27 years of marriage. I mean, it's it's uh Wow. Yeah, yeah. That's awesome, man. In May, she's she's still there. I don't I don't know how, but uh be a I I guess, you know, I don't know.
SPEAKER_01I guess a pair will not so let's go into the the future a little bit. We talked about a little bit of challenges, but like what are some of the changes you see affecting our agencies in the next couple years?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you know, of course, hit on that one on regarding remote, remote workers. I I think that's a big one. I I think that's something that really kind of need to keep an eye on and uh and how people manage it. Uh, I I think as I mentioned, Chad, seems like he's got a good handle. I actually need to reach out to him and talk to him. There's another agent in the Greenville area as well that's been pretty successful, you know, trying to figure out you know how you delve into that. But uh, you know, I really think the evolution of where there, you know, the push, especially in our industry of having that aspect of the remote workers is probably the biggest change. And also, you know, right now, you you know, with inflation and how we're dealing with that as a society as a whole, you know, everything's going up and the challenge is there. That's probably more short-term problems. Hopefully that's gonna change for the better later. Um, but uh I think and also with find, you know, retention, staff retention. I mean, it's just hard to retain staff in any industry, you know, you hear about it all the time. So how can that's the number two biggest thing I think is how can you create an environment where they want to come in every day, they want to be here, and how you deal with differences in, especially in the age bracket I see of younger generation to my age in my 50s, and the older ones, you know, when you're dealing with their perception is different on how they view work, work life. Is I just work all the time. I mean, you know, when I was in athletics, you know, they they almost shamed you if you didn't, if you went home, you know, you didn't put in 12 hours, you know. It's just right, you know, now it's like they expect to have that time off per se. They expect to and get paid for what they, you know, they should get paid. So that's a challenge, I think. And I think is our workforce is is gonna be a it's a big deal in in in how we motivate, retain, and and compensate staff, you know, that and remote workers, uh I think that's gonna be a challenge and maybe that's kind of a combination of both there. Maybe that's where it's maybe the solution kind of lies in between, you know.
SPEAKER_00So what do you what do you see or what what would be the number one tip that you would give an agent coming into the world right now? Uh say that one more time. I'm sorry. The number one thing, like the number one piece of advice that you would give to an agent starting off.
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah, yeah. So I would uh starting off, you know, depending on whether you're a scratch or I'll I'll say on buying an existing book, you really, when you're going into it, you really need to be all in. I mean, you you need to be all in. That's what you know you're gonna be, what you want to do, because failure is not an option here, okay? I mean, you have to go in that mindset that you will succeed, you will not fail. Understand your numbers on the agency, understand that. And if you don't understand, there's a lot of things I'm still learning on different things, get that advice, get those with from your peers. They're more than happy to walk you through that. But probably the number one thing is man, you got to have the right staff. You will succeed or fail with the uh staff you have in place, and uh um if you can get that right, uh man, your life's gonna be a lot easier, a whole lot easier.
SPEAKER_01I think that's huge advice. Your people are your your biggest asset. I love it. Yeah, Brian, I want to acknowledge you for um coming into the industry at a crazy time and and succeeding, pushing through and constantly growing and and uh pushing yourself. So that's that's incredible. So just want to say, you know, you're doing an awesome job, and we love talking to uh insurance dudes out there that are trying to have a hey, yeah, you know, in it is a world that of kind of negativity sometimes, but you have a very positive outlook and you're pushing ahead and we love it.
SPEAKER_02So yeah, well, no, I appreciate it. I appreciate you guys having me on. I mean, obviously uh you have a lot of super successful agents. I probably I said, Man, they must be hurting for entertainment, man. They got me on the program, but I don't know, but but you know, I I think uh but it's good, I think it's good to hear from all sides, all levels of kind of where people are in their career. Um it's an awesome opportunity. And uh if you do it the right way, you're gonna be successful. And you can't judge one person's success necessarily over their their billfold, but it it's their uh their quality, are they doing the right things? You always need to grow, you always gotta grow, but how you work that is is important to that each individual, and uh you that's that's success for me, is those and and and to help others in the community. And and if I do that, uh we'll have a good life.
SPEAKER_01Yep. So I 100% agree.
SPEAKER_02Have a good life. So love it. Yep, appreciate you guys. Yeah, yeah. Thank you.
SPEAKER_00You meet you went the distance. Thank you for jumping on.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, uh I hope I hope you can understand me here. Uh, you know, may have to call a decoder out there or something. No, no, I love a translator, I should say.
SPEAKER_00Really good uh crystal clear mic, too. So well we're gonna wrap it. We're up against the wall here, but uh you went the distance.
SPEAKER_02Well, I appreciate it, guys, and and uh look forward to catching your other podcast. And uh I'll make sure nobody hears my. I'm kidding. No, but no, it's been good. It's it's been it's been fun. It really is. So thanks, Bronyan. Take it easy, Ryan. It'll be good.
SPEAKER_00Talk to you too.
SPEAKER_01Hey, what are you still doing here? Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, if you weren't listening before, we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents throughout the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01Using these strategies did help Craig and I to fight over $20 million in three in the last couple of years.
SPEAKER_00And let me tell you, on this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same result.
SPEAKER_01Again, that's live.teled.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call event.
SPEAKER_00And if you jump on with us, we are starting. 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you to see you there.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman