The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Bryan Taylor's Positively Terrific Part 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
So the craziest thing that ever happened to me in my agency was actually, I've only owned the agency for about two and a half years now. But the craziest thing that ever happened was about two months ago. I had uh I was in my office, I'm up front, and I usually keep the door closed, but I'm very accessible to everyone. And unfortunately that day I had the door open. And this gentleman walked in the office, and my office manager, Casey, was up front with a lady getting uh working on a renter's policy. And this man walks in and says, Where's Mr. Taylor at? And he just and he says, Where's Mr. Taylor at? And I said, I'm right here. He says, I'm pissed right now. First, I'm sitting here at my desk. I thought, I mean, I thought it was a joke at first. Your phone systems, they're terrible. Excuse me, they're terrible. I've been business with you for 20 years. I can't even get through to you guys. I mean, he he comes in, he says, You're gonna change your phone system, you're gonna change it now. So he walks around to the side of my desk, and I'm sitting there thinking, this guy's not kidding me. And then so then I'm kind of looking him over saying, I get ready to get shot here. And then I look at and then I look out, and this poor lady who's getting her renter's policy, she's looking back, thinking, you could tell she was scared to death. And Casey's looking at my office. My office manager's like, what's going on there? So I literally had to stand up. I say, Sir, you're gonna have to back away from my desk right now and and calm down a minute. So he backs up and he he just is relentless. And so finally he calms down and and he walks out. The lady, I looked out, the lady had already gone us, and Casey's like, This guy's a nut. I said, but he's never done this before in 20 years, is because we had changed our phone systems uh per the uh agency required us to do that. There, and so we got that changed, and he had to actually go through a phone tree. He's never had to do it, like never had to do it before, apparently. And uh uh so the poor lady thought she was gonna get shot. She left. We we lost a policy there, and and Casey was getting ready to call 911. So whoa, oh man, it was gosh, it it was nuts, but uh you know that's that's probably one of many I will have. I've had others, but uh my name is uh Brian Taylor with the Brian Taylor Agency, and I am an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_03I are eight.
SPEAKER_02Right now, while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_01We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_02Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years. On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results. Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_01If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
SPEAKER_02Woo! Boom.
SPEAKER_00Oh man. Oh man, it was crazy. It's crazy how fired up people get, you know, and and I look at it, I'm thinking, he obviously had a bad day starting out because this was like at 10 a.m. And you know, he'd called three or four times apparently, and I just and I said, uh, you know, and I realize that in the back of my mind, he's probably having a bad day, but there's ways to handle it, you know. And and I I think, you know, from this past, the funny thing is when I bought the agency back in 2019 of December, it was great. I mean, it was great. And then, you know, the the 2020, you know, doing well, and then this thing called COVID hit. And I I really think in the people's attitudes and their outlook on life, it seemed to change to the negative side. And I am blessed with a uh wonderful staff. Uh my office manager, Casey Glover, she's been here over 12 years, so I inherited her, thank goodness. And then I have a wonderful uh producer. And I've I've had uh I'm I'm down one, I've had it many, as many as three, down to one and and going to actually looking to to hire. But uh the aspect that Casey said, she is in her 12 years has never seen people so upset uh about the little littlest things. And that was just a big aspect of the way things seem to go now in any business, but you know, especially, you know, people really don't like to pay for their insurance, you know, uh every day. Right. And and you're thinking that uh we're we're causing, you know, they they can't ever leave us, you know, it's like they have no choice but to stay with us and they just take it out on on my staff or myself a lot of times. But but at the end of the day, I'm blessed. I love what I do. I really do. Uh I came into this. I I came into this a green horn uh uh doing this uh opportunity, but uh I had been wanting to do it for years, and uh, but this this opportunity uh came about and uh wouldn't change it for anything. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So yeah, tell us the story how you how you started. Well, you know, in my previous life, I worked at uh worked in athletics. Uh I never played, as you can probably tell by my physique here, but I was actually a a uh a manager, a student manager at Clemson for the football team back in the early 90s, and then actually uh my first job was University of Tolson, Oklahoma in the athletic department, and uh was able to go back to Clemson, worked there for years, and then got out of that. I got uh I wanted to actually have a life, being uh, you know, you work 60 hours a week, not making what the head coaches make, obviously football coaches there. And uh so uh did that for a while, and then I transitioned into sales, uh to athletic apparel sales. So I did that for for quite a while as a regional manager in the college and pro division for Russell Athletic. Then Russell basically went out of business because they could never compete with the Nike and Under Armours of the world, but had a great time and uh I knew it was kind of going that route. So I looked, I'd been wanting to talk to a lot of people I knew that were agents and from different carriers and really uh saw a lot of opportunity there for me as a person, but I knew to get into the actual business, I couldn't start a scratch agency because I had a family, uh, children. I need to have a little cash flow. And uh so so cash is keen. And um, so after about five years, and I finally found an opportunity. And the uh gentleman who actually we're we're still good friends, a lot of agents when they buy an agency, sometimes the deal at the end, it's not the most amicable thing dealing with the prior agent, but uh it went great with the with the two of us and uh still friends. He retired and uh he uh so I was uh what they say dialing for dollars, and uh and so uh and uh uh I was blessed, was able after about seven months to get the deal solidified and opened up in 2019, and uh didn't really know it's funny, and even now I I learn every day, you know, as as a uh agency owner, but as I mentioned with my uh Casey Glover, I know really leaned a lot on her knowledge and skills. And then I looked at what the former agent was paying her, and I'm thinking, my gosh, I can't believe she's still even here. So in in the course of you know, uh two and a half years, I've given her four pay raises, and uh I don't plan on stopping there as as the agency grows and multiplies because you know I see the true value in what she does, and and also she's the front line typically. So um, and that's a big part of of our agency is is the personalities, but also being available, accessible. And we're right here on Main Street, and we're in you know in Anderson, South Carolina, and we're we're have uh right on North Main Street. We compared to some other agencies, I mean, we average about 10 to 15 walk-ins a day just from a lot of its service, and then on top of the phone calls, because the agency here, it's been around since the late 60s. So we've had some policy holders that uh were here before I was born. So uh, and and they let me know that too. But but it's it's been great. I I I've been, you know, I love I love the opportunity and learn something new every day, you know, uh being being a part of this. Got a long way to go. Um working and and I really rely on other agents uh as mentors, sounding boards, uh uh to to gain knowledge to keep me from you know uh jumping off the roof. Some nothing's going right. You know, you know, you know, you're you're you're you know, you're not you hadn't sold anything today or and or you know, uh just whatever could be going on, but at the end of it, it's you know, it's a marathon. Yeah, as you as you guys obviously know, it's it's not a sprint. And I think it's it's just taking that bite a day out of what we need to do to to grow in a in a in a positive way. And uh so that that's been that's been this I've been fortunate.
SPEAKER_01Uh um, but uh yeah, so I love how you identified the importance of of that that really that really important key person that that kind of holds the glue together, and then placing a a really strong value on that, I think it's easy, um, especially when it gets tight, like it can get tight in this in this world, yes, um, to go to this world of you know, this whole scarcity mentality and pay pay people the least amount possible, you know, and all this. Yeah, but really compensating somebody, even though it may cost more, creates a lot of loyalty, and it's also going to get better results, and not to mention the cost of turnover. Had you lost this person, you'd have a whole different situation.
SPEAKER_00Oh, no question. No, no question. I mean, I I knew uh going into it, uh for for me, especially having no background in the insurance world, right? Uh and and PNC, uh, going into the aspect of of having her there, uh, you know, as I call her, you know, she's my work wife. You know, I mean, I'm we're attached at the hip here every day. And and it enables me to work outside the agency because part of what I do is is able going out and into the community. I'm very involved with different things like that, knowing that that if when I leave, I don't worry about a thing. I mean, it's gonna be it's gonna be taken care of. And if there's a problem, uh she'll she she gives me a call. But my goal is always my lack thereof of insurance knowledge when I went into it was obviously noted, but my life skills of of different uh jobs and organizations I work with on trying to lead people in the right direction, you know, we're all gonna make mistakes. And, you know, it's how we overcome those mistakes. If we're doing it in the positive way, you know, I don't necessarily worry about how we make mistakes, but when I hire someone, I always tell them, you know, when you leave here, hopefully it's not for a long time, if they're the right fit, I want you to leave here better than you can. And uh that that's always my goal and mentality and and to help them grow professionally and personally. And so when I look at that, I make sure they have the knowledge. My job is is to be in the background. Uh, you know, I I look at it as yes, I'm the agency owner. Uh at the end of the day, I'm responsible. Uh uh, you know, my name's on the line. But I I want to make sure they have the tools and everything they need to be successful in their job. That's what I got to make sure I provide. And also the training and coaching aspect of the uh and the profession that we're all in. And if if I can do that and and help them grow and put more money in their pocket, then they're gonna be more successful. If they're more successful, I am because I'm only as good as as my team, period. Right. I tell them that every day. If you're not producing, you're not doing the things necessarily, I'm not successful. And so I really try to make sure that they know that I am here for them. My door's always open and they I'm always accessible. And uh I love what I do. And uh some days, you know, you don't want to get up and go in.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_00Depending on if you just it's it's mentally exhausting. You know, this this job here, it's a uh always look at it. You know, I may be having a bad day or start of the day, but I don't want them to see that in my attitude. You know, I have to kind of I have to uh you know suppress that hold that in to really uh let them feed positivity. There's there's enough negativity going on.
SPEAKER_02Take us back to one of the earliest wins that kind of fueled that fire that you got.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I really think it was well, it was in 2020 we first took over the agency, and um I I feel like you know, not not necessarily as a group again, because I I don't try not look at at numbers per se daily, even though I do like everyone else does per se, but I don't dwell on it, but but I knew I guess it was going into the month of February of 2020, I only had it for three months, and we had outproduced prior year by $20,000 in premium, which was fantastic. And and so I knew I I I had the right mix of people there almost, even though one that was there's not with me now. And and but I felt like just the daily wins of them buying into my into my philosophy, okay, to kind of the direction I want to take the agency. I knew that was it was paying off. And I don't know if that's a great example of a win, but but I think a win is more of on the consistency of for me of what they're doing every day to enhance or grow the agency. And and so um I felt that in 2020. I mean, I I was blessed. We I think overall I I grew it that first year almost about a half a million dollars, you know, and that with me and two producers and and a uh uh uh office manager. And uh I thought, hey, this is going great. Then 2021 hit. And so, you know, went out with COVID for a month, uh uh had to basically well I let's put it this way I never fire anyone as I tell them at the onset. Uh they fire themselves and and they just they know they know what's what's involved, what's entailed. And uh I give them probably a longer leash than than some agents do, and uh sometimes probably to my detriment. Uh but that's just the kind of person I am. I'm not a not-for-profit. And so, and so uh, you know, I think it you know it hurt me initially, but yeah, 2021 was a challenge year for me as an agency. I think if I had that in 2020, I probably would have said, what have I done kind of thing. But but but knowing that it can be done, we now persevered, had to study to be a registered uh rep. And when you're 49 years old and trying to study, run a have a family and run an agency. Oh boy, that I think my wife was more excited I passed than I was. Yeah, those tests. So, and uh there was a lot on the line that year. So, so uh uh you know, bate based on uh what they require to have an agency. And uh so we got through that and got through 21, and uh um we're full steam ahead right now. So um just uh uh day by day.
SPEAKER_01Awesome. What what do you do for marketing in your agency?
SPEAKER_00So marketing, so we we have a uh makes it like a contact manager. We have I bet we have probably 12 to 15, probably about 12,000, you know, uh leads on there and uh that that we utilize this that's that I've garnered and that was able, you know, I purchased when I when I actually bought the book. And so we do a lot of that. Uh we do a lot of uh and referral based is is big with us as well. We do a lot of uh we ask for we ask for the referrals. That's one of the things I challenged uh my staff to do is is ask for that referral, which they don't mind doing, but sometimes you you get excited, you get in there, you make the sale, and you oh and I forgot to ask for the referral. And so that is something I really push for them to try to grow organically that way. I've done some digital marketing, uh locally, kind of uh strategic digital marketing, and I've actually done some radio ads uh and that was pretty successful. It's it's with the uh obviously we're near Clemson University, so uh football's king around here and and some big uh uh audience. And uh being that I used to work in athletics, uh knew a lot of people and and knew a lot of people there. So I garnered some good feedback on on that aspect of it, bought some leads, you know. As you guys know, uh it's either hit or miss. I've done uh what you call it, uh transfer calls. And those are I've never found success in those uh right now. Uh, but uh a lot of those is really just the leads. We know we buy leads from from our source. Uh try to keep new ones, so many new ones. That's kind of how I do that. You know, I'm trying to look at some different avenues to do that with. I've actually was on your uh call last week, uh learn a little bit about what you guys do uh on the uh iDudes there and and trying to uh uh to disseminate that. I know I'd mentioned before we got on there, uh uh Chad uh Kish, he's a local agent. We're actually only he I listened to him a couple of weeks ago and I started laughing. And and uh Chad's only like 35 minutes from my agency. Yeah, it's crazy. But the ironic thing is we've never met. And and so, because you know, when COVID hit, we never had any group meetings at all. We still haven't had one. So typically they'd they'd have you know meetings with all the agents and in a geographic location where you could actually meet the the other agents, and that's what I like because that's where you learn. I mean you learn from your peers. Sorry about the uh fire trucks going by here. But uh Chad was big on what you guys are doing, working on, and and I learned a lot from him. He's he's he's a uh great agent. He's done a he's he's done very well and uh in his business, uh growing his book, buying up the body. He's followed the process. He's followed the process, he sure has. You know, I think I think he's uh he's been doing a good bit longer, but I think he he really uh he's honed his you know his skills and profession as an agency owner and uh to his to his benefit and and I like learning from those guys. You know, I I'm not one of those to reinvent the wheel, you know. Yeah, you know, I wouldn't say I'm the smartest guy, but I'm I'm what you call a try hard. I'll I'll keep pounding on that wall until I finally break through. That's that's kind of me, you know. And uh uh I try to hire people that are smarter than me. Uh that that's my goal. You know, I don't want people because it doesn't bother me. I want people that are smart and good at what they do. My producer, he's he never was in it. Clemson grad, 29 years old. I knew he was going to be good. It took him about four months. I I was patient with him, and man, he's he's a rock star. Sent him to uh I know you mentioned Olson, uh Craig Wiggins, he's big in the southeast. Uh actually invested him, send him to training down in Alabama, and uh he loved it. I mean, I really try to invest in my employees. Not I don't look at it as an ex a cause, I look as an investment. That's what I try to do. So from Chad to really learning from others to training platforms and listening to you guys on your podcast. I mean, to me, that's awesome. I mean, that's where you gain knowledge, you gain little nuggets and and try to make them your own to be successful in an agency. I mean, I I got a long way to go to be a you know a Chad Kish, but if you do the right things and you do it uh strategically, you can get there. You know, yeah. I think I think you have to be smart about doing it. In today's landscape, um, you have to be real prudent on on hiring and how you go about uh the aspect of of growing your agency because they may want you to do certain things, but how's that going to benefit you benefit you as an agency owner? You have to look at business as a whole, you know, you know, is it the right time to hire? Is are you meeting your goals, which we are, or we we need to exceed those. But uh you have to find the right person, you know, the right fit and uh to do that. And so that's that's what I've been more strategic now, more patient about that than I was before to hire just to hire. And then, you know, I had at one time I had three producers, office manager, the two producers that I had, I had to let them go. They were remote, great people, but they I mean, they were terrible. I mean, that they they just were not, I mean, I I they they just was not for them. They're good people, but it was just not for them. And just because and they they had their license too. You know, I'm looking for folks that necessarily are licensed producers too.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00Um, but uh um if I can invest in them and they can just like the one I have now, he's been with me over a year, year and a half. So and he and he's and he's very happy.
SPEAKER_01So that yeah, that's what we've learned from the whole telephonal process, is is that just having the right you don't even necessarily need to have home run hitters if you plug them into the right system and process, then they crush it. And to one other point that you brought up, I I thought it was really it's interesting how COVID took away a lot of that community aspect. And that's what that was part of the reason when we launched everything to bring everybody together. And like today's haul is awesome, having you know, people from all over the country just yeah, yeah, just learning, you know.
SPEAKER_02Hey, what are you still doing here? Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, if you weren't listening before, we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents throughout the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_02Using these strategies did help Craig and I to fight over 20 million in three in the last couple of years.
SPEAKER_01And let me tell you, on this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same result.
SPEAKER_02Again, that's live.teled.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call event.
SPEAKER_01And if you come on with us, we are starting. 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you to see you there.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman