The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Eric Mangano - Agent Success Story With Dials Upon Dials PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
So let's bring it home with the the number one recommendation. So uh an agent jumping in, getting their feet wet now, what's the the number one thing you would give them as a recommendation as they hit the ground running?
SPEAKER_00I would say if I could uh if I could redo it or not redo it, let's just say let's give me I'll give the recommendation making sure they have the right processes in place and really study the industry and whatever I guess company you're going to be representing and stick to those processes.
SPEAKER_01I are interested. I am great. I am interested. We are agents, we are interested. Right now, while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years. On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results. Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_03If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there. So when you you you bring on that new team member, we want to insert them into the culture, make sure they're going to be successful. What kind of things do you do to ensure that they that they hit the ground running and are super successful?
SPEAKER_00The biggest thing I do is something I've never seen, I guess, done. I've worked at two different agencies. And the biggest thing I do is I like to understand where they're coming from. And I lay out a blueprint for their success. Um, figure out what they want to see, whether it's whether it's a dollar amount or if it's the time freedom or it's whatever it is, just fulfillment. And we kind of draw up a blueprint from that point and uh create milestones and stuff like that. And like the onboarding process just comes with showing them the systems. I'm very, very hands-on when it comes to the agency. Um, I really just like to make sure people understand truly what we're doing here, and all the ways to not overthink what we're doing because what we sell, it's it's very easy to, I guess, overthink in certain times, especially when you're new, and especially if they're coming from another agency, you've got to really get them to understand this isn't uh thorough company, this is how we do it. We've got the best products, in my opinion. And we gotta kind of instill that in their brain that this is this is what we're selling, and uh yeah, but from there, I just show them the Agency systems and uh just kind of roll with it.
SPEAKER_01What I love that the theme is so far for hiring, uh training, and the way you approach everything, it's a mindset first approach. It's all like everything that you've talked about, culture and everything else, it's a mindset first approach because you understand that that's where it all starts. I love that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I've been in agencies where you it's just different, they don't get to know you and uh just kill them, man. It really does.
SPEAKER_01Yep.
SPEAKER_00I'm really I just kind of throw people out there to be honest in the beginning. See how they do it for the first week. I know a lot of people don't do that, but I like to do that just to feel them out.
SPEAKER_01Well, and I think when when you approach it where, like, you know, what's best for you, where do you want to be, like, what are your goals and stuff like that, then you can align, you can tell them what you're about, bring them in, and you already know like you can give them the autonomy to kind of do that for the first week. Whereas if you're not asking those questions and that stuff, then uh being thrown in, you feel they probably feel isolated because I've I've been I've been in that certain that that point where I've hired people, hey, just kind of get used to it for a little while, but I didn't start with those questions, and I think with starting with like getting to know so they feel like, hey, you're welcomed here and I actually care about you. I think that's the missing piece when some people bring people in without like a game plan just to feel it out. And that I know that's where I've gone wrong in the past, is just like, hey, come in, and then next thing you know, dude, they're they're done. You know, a couple weeks later, they're just like this place sucks.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And you like, you know what's coming too. You know what I mean? Right. You can feel it. It's like how can how can we make this quicker? Yeah, you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_01So disconnected, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, cool.
SPEAKER_01What what so you bring people in, you let them um get acclimated for a week. Um, what would you say your most effective training tip uh from then on is?
SPEAKER_00I would say um training tip, meetings, to be honest, role play. Um being on a meeting daily, and uh just making sure they understand exactly how we, I guess, enter a call. I would say roleplay 100%. Just making sure everyone's on the same page. And I know you guys talk about it all the time. That's really it. Understanding understanding the underwriting, you know, the the uh the rules, regulations, like how can we not waste time? I don't like wasting time. Um I've wasted a lot of time on brand policies. Yeah, if you can understand the rules, I think it's in any company, it's going to excel you a lot quicker.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_03So the game. Yeah. Yeah. So how how about keeping the team motivated? What kind of things do you do?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so uh I think I do a pretty good job with it. Uh, I just started this bonus back in uh uh January. Uh actually, uh another insurance dude, uh friend of mine, kind of came up with it. We call it the hustle marks tracker, and we kind of designed it around you guys, to be honest. And uh the CRM system we use, you know, so we we track quotes, we track sales, we track talk time, we track dials, um, and each category has a point system associated. Uh basically, you have to have like 8,000 points the first month, and first time you hit it, it's a $500 bonus, and basically it gets a little harder the next month, and then you just add $100 each month to keep going. And so far they've been hitting it, and it's really been a motivator, and just being able to see like the numbers, I get it just keeps everyone on track. That right there is the biggest thing I think. Next to uh like the one call close. I had I dropped the chips like most agents do nowadays. That's huge in our agency. Like we post the videos on social media, and everybody chimes in, like that follows us, and uh just you know, put out 20 bucks, 50 bucks, whatever it is for one call close. And uh yeah, just making sure that energy is high. I try to have music. I kind of think like Wolf of Wall Street in a way.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Remember them. Like I try to have some kind of music every every day everyone enters the agency. I just think it it sets the tone and it motivates people. I love that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So you said um at the beginning, you said uh that you you had a marketing dude, um, then you pulled that back. And so so what are you doing now? What's a what's your marketing strategy? What are all the different things that you're doing?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I started uh I started with ClickFunnels. I started uh building ClickFunnels out. Yeah, and uh I uh honestly I I I didn't learn too much. I just he was doing everything and I got really upset with I guess the direction it was going in. I got a ton of people from you know, to quote, and we were talking to tons of people from it. The the marketing span was a lot lower than I expected it to be. The problem was is I associated it around a giveaway, and I learned very quickly they don't care about what you're selling, they want whatever it is you're giving away. Uh so, anyways, I got away from that. Uh, got on live transcribers, was spending way too much, cost for sale was way too high, and uh it was a what you guys started your new season January, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yep.
SPEAKER_00I promise I've listened to every single episode of you guys, every single episode, I promise. It was like it was like episode 400. I was like, okay, I'm gonna do it. What you guys don't know probably is December of 2020, I was on a uh Zoom with I think you two, and it was just me. And I thought I like hopped off like after like a minute, like you guys are about to start. I just I thought it was too good to be true. Like someone had a system like this, so I just started listening to the podcast, and right around like episode 400, I was like, okay, I gotta do this. Like, we're we're changing gears the perfect time, and 100%. That's I I I run with the telemarketers with the teledudes and uh internet leads, and that's it. I'm doing that.
SPEAKER_01That's awesome. Crazy. That is crazy.
SPEAKER_03I did not know that. Isn't it interesting though, how similar that is to the telefunnel in that it took him 400 episodes of listening? 400. It's like a hundred, you know, a hundred dials on a lead.
SPEAKER_00I don't know what yeah, and I don't know. I don't know what episode it was you guys had uh William Hung.
SPEAKER_03She bangs. Right. We had William Hung from American Idol. Is that who was he was on uh I don't know what episode. American Idol. That was when we were interviewing, we weren't just focusing on agents, we were interviewing all kinds of different people.
SPEAKER_00We yeah, you guys did interview quite, yeah, quite a bit of and you guys interviewed, but it was I think it was around an episode uh where uh Mr. Corbinet was on, and uh that's I guess what pushed me to really do this. I reached out to him on Facebook, and uh yeah, he plays a major part in why I'm here too. So just seeing I guess the excitement around what you guys do, yeah, and being tired of live transfers and and uh cost per sale being twelve hundred dollars.
SPEAKER_03Right, yeah, it's been fun because George has been with us since the very like he's client one. He was client one, yeah. He's the first one, and it and it's so much fun interacting with George because now we're real good friends, you know. I mean, we went, yeah, we've we've we've hung out, you know. So it's it's it's been a cool, it's been really cool developing the friendships that we get from this community. And um, yeah, George is now, I mean, he's writing over 300k. It's it's amazing. We need to bring him back on since he's hit, he's gonna win a big award.
SPEAKER_00He's not far, he's not too far from where I'm in. I think he's probably three or four hours from me, but um it's just amazing knowing that there's people that are actually doing stuff like that. Yeah, yeah. It inspires agents like me, you know what I mean? So yeah, and uh 100%.
SPEAKER_01I mean, that's why, dude, that's why that's why we did the podcast, and I'll never forget coming in. I mean, I came into the the company and the insurance world five years ago, it was only five years ago, and I remember coming in and seeing some some numbers and going to the events and stuff and seeing some of these numbers, and I'm like, wait a minute, most agents aren't doing this, but like, how are people doing these numbers? Like, you know, somebody will get up and talk and they're selling uh you know, a hundred, a couple hundred thousand a month, and it's like, bro, I can't even write ten thousand a month. Like, right, what's the what's the secret here? How do we do this? Because yeah, yeah, and so like that whole journey, just like just like seeing people that are doing things that are different and that are pretty cool is just amazing to yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00And I I like uh I don't know if you guys I relate a lot of this to the new Tony Hawk documentary. Have you guys seen it yet?
SPEAKER_01No, but I'm writing that down on HBO.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's on HBO. I relate I relate a lot of what we do here with uh the telephone and everything to what Tony Hawk talks about because he's what mid-50s? I think he's like 55 years old, something like that. Yeah, he's still on the uh the half pipe, you know, trying to get awesome 1080s and stuff, and and and if you watch it, there is like a five-minute segment where he is just eating crap over and over and over, and you know, he even says it to the camera, like, I'm gonna get it. That's how I feel with what we're doing here. Like, I know I'm going to get to where uh you know I'm I'm picturing this is gonna take. Like, I know it's it's eventually going to come. Yeah. Um, once I start believing in something, I run with it 100%. Yeah, and since I've owned agency, I haven't there hasn't been one thing that's uh even brought me close to that feeling.
SPEAKER_03So yeah, I think it just with like what I used to do, and and maybe you did too, and I know Jason did, is it's like, dang it, this thing didn't work. I'll try this. And you just are it's like the constant search. So maybe the rush comes from finding the thing that you think is it and it actually isn't, you know, or yeah, maybe it would be if you stuck with it long enough, but but it's always the search, you know?
SPEAKER_00Yep, and and and where I'm at right now, it uh the process is is just searching uh you know for more money, you know what I mean? Just to sink into it, uh, because like you guys say uh add fuel to the fire, and that's uh that's where I'm at now. Sink as close as I can into it.
SPEAKER_01Cool, man. And what are you doing with referrals? Are you are you uh using are you utilizing some referrals in your agency?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. Uh and referrals uh the best, right? Uh my uh my wife has I think seven or eight referral partners. Um she's amazing at what she does, and honestly, she's taught me a lot too. Um I didn't even get to tell this story, but uh I actually hired my wife at the last agency I I was at, and uh I wasn't supposed to date her and uh ended up dating her. Anyways, she had been in the insurance industry about three years at that point, and she taught me a lot about the referrals and insurance, and yes, we utilize referrals 100%. Um we're always asking for referrals, we're continuously keeping in touch with our uh mortgage partners or real estate partners. I'll have coffee with them every now and then. And I've I found over over the time it they don't care about gift cards, cookies, donuts, they don't care about that. Like they don't, it's all about how quick can you get it done. What I what I always tell my team is create COIs, go out there on your weekend, whatever, when you drive home, just try to create one or two relationships a week if you can. And the only thing you need to tell them is I'm quick, I'll get you what you need, less than 10 minutes, and that is how you lock a good partner in right there that's gonna stay with you, someone that they know that they can count on. I've heard partners say, you know, I've waited 48 hours for uh an agent to give me a call back. I'm just like, how?
SPEAKER_03But yeah, that's it's a layup, you know, like calling exactly all from a lender is a layup, they're gonna buy. So why don't you turn that around and just knock it out? You know, it's crazy, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but outside of that, gift cards to uh any any any uh you know prospect or whatever. Um would you like a Starbucks gift card, like five, ten bucks? Um, I find that has always been something that people get excited about.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. How about onboarding new clients? Do you have a system or uh process that you use in order to kind of lock them down?
SPEAKER_00Uh yeah. So yeah, just uh I probably do, I guess I think RADC might do it a little bit quicker than than most do. Correct me if I'm wrong. Uh I like to get get them on the phone like the day after the policy sold. Like I want us to be excited to talk to them that next day. And you know, just make sure, you know, we just follow up, make sure everything is was done correctly, if they had any concerns or anything, um, making sure all the you know the documents we needed are are taken care of, and and you know, really just spreading that message that uh what we can do for them off for Zoom, you know, calls if they need it, uh talk about a referral uh system we have in place and stuff like that. And overall, we've had great uh feedback, and that's that just lets me know we're doing uh, I guess, the right thing. But I will be honest, I'm not gonna, I'm not gonna uh I'm not gonna act like we're perfect because that I think right there is where we lack the most. Uh, and that is something I pay attention to the most when I'm studying, you know, agents that have been in business a lot longer than me on how we can develop and and and grow into uh you know the onboarding, you know, making it making it a lot better process for new new clients and stuff like that, not just new clients like people renewing. And I think that's a process that you're always revamping. It's just what I see from it.
SPEAKER_01100%. And no, nobody is great at everything. I think the people that the greatest agents are always understanding that there's a bunch of weaknesses and a bunch of stuff to and they're constantly trying to improve, improve the different parts of the funnel and everything.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01What's what's your number one retention tactic? Or what comes to mind? Like what's one of the focuses when you guys talk about retention? Um, what's something that that you feel might drive it the most in your agency?
SPEAKER_00Probably, um, I mean, obviously, making sure we're getting all of their business. Because why would someone want to leave if they had everything with you and you're doing them right? You know, just getting positive reviews. I don't know. I I guess where I'm going with this is just making sure. Uh yeah, I don't know where I'm going with this. Just I guess trying to get every piece of business under the book. I don't know if that's a good answer or not.
SPEAKER_03No, there's no wrong answers.
SPEAKER_00But no, I just uh you know, making sure the discounts are there, you know, it's it's it's important. Yeah. Um making sure the legal reviews. Yeah. Uh I think that's reviews are huge.
SPEAKER_03Yep.
SPEAKER_00Google Analytics are no joke.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. And it's like that's such an easy thing to ask for that can be just an afterthought, but then you also have to help them make it happen, right? Like make it easy for them. Send them the link. Do the because if you don't send them the link, there's there's very low chance they're gonna do it. If you do send them the link, it's still like 50-50 or maybe even less, right?
SPEAKER_00Do you guys attach that link in your email ever? Or do you guys have your CSR?
SPEAKER_03Shoot it through uh whatever approved texting system you have, depending on what carrier you may represent. Yeah, I'm not sure. But yeah, you can grab it from Google My Business, is it has the little link and you can just right in there. Well, cool. So besides listening to this podcast, which I know is huge, um, as you've listened to every single episode, how else do you keep yourself motivated, Eric?
SPEAKER_00I've always been good at putting myself in front of people that are uh a lot further than I am. Uh, yes, the podcast, I promise you, I get mad at you guys when there's not a new episode every day. And I'll I'll find myself on repeat listening to other episodes or whatever. But um what keeps me motivated is getting myself in front of uh people that I See as you know a lot bigger than me and where I want to be, and trying to get them on a phone call. I've had agents that are massive on a phone call that didn't want to give me the time of day. I've had agents that are massive that took the time out of their day to call me when they don't even know who I am and just connect with me and give me tips and stuff like that. So I would say when I'm feeling really down, I'm reaching out to you know whoever, whoever I I guess inspires me. You know what I mean? So I think that is uh my biggest motivator, knowing that in my down times or in my lows of the business, there's people out there that are making it happen and and I'm just seeking inspiration.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I freaking love that, and I don't think anyone's ever articulated that, but it's a hundred percent true, and I don't think most people don't have the gall to like in those low points to reach out to somebody that's actually achieved more. Like, there's a certain human uh amount of humility that you need for that because that that those aren't the points that you would feel to reach that you would feel to reach out, right? But you know these are the points that I need to reach out, and I'm gonna take that advice and roll with that big time. Like that is because it's true that like you reach out to some. I mean, you talk to anybody who's crushed it harder than you, and immediately you feel motivated, like at least I do. Absolutely, yeah. So, like that's huge. That's what an awesome yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00There's uh and I find I find you West Coast agents are more willing, I guess, to talk and give advice. I don't know something about the the uh Midwest and how around that, but or the East, or the East reaching out to Tom Burks cold.
SPEAKER_03Oh man, he's a good dude though. He's a dude, but dude, like that that Alright I think you've ever interviewed.
SPEAKER_01Yes, yeah, dude.
SPEAKER_00You guys have ever interviewed. Like, I I think I played him three or four times.
SPEAKER_03So we were so blown away. Like when we got off, we were like, that was the best interview we've ever done. That was incredible.
SPEAKER_00Because literally, like how he talks and everything. Like, I come from an Italian family, yeah. That is literally them, like Chicago, yeah. New York, but it's literally them. I'm just rolling, I don't have that like full Italian, you know, like he has, and it yeah, I was just cracking up.
SPEAKER_03Hey hey, yeah, guess what? Guess what my favorite cheese is? Dude, it's the best.
SPEAKER_01You're fire. Tom Tom intimidated like our team, like the at the the insurance dude's intimidated the team it and intimidated us a little bit at first, and it was like he just has that um he has that east coast, uh, you know, like he yeah, he's got that hardware exterior.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's swagger, it really is. And uh and once I found out like what size of an agent he was, like that's someone you gotta pay attention to, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And he's deep too, man. Like he's spitting all kinds of like wisdom and quotes and books that he's read, and I'm like, dude, I love that. It's so good.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. We were writing a lot down during that one. That was great. He's so fun.
SPEAKER_01So so looking forward, you're you're obviously um trying to push ahead. And uh what what are some of the biggest uh changes that you see affecting our agencies within the next couple years?
SPEAKER_00Automation, 100%. Yeah, automation. Uh, I think if you're not growing, you're dying, right? So dying. You know, the the the big internet companies are going to take over everything. I don't believe, it's sad to think, but I don't believe there's gonna be brick and mortar agencies. Think everything's gonna be rent from your house or uh, you know, your shed or whatever you're at. But uh that's where I truly believe it's going. And I I think if you're a growing agency, you're going to survive no matter what for many more years. Yeah. As long as you have the right processes in place.
SPEAKER_03All about processes.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_03So so let's bring it home with uh the number one recommendation. So uh an agent jumping in, getting their feet wet now. What's the the number one thing you would give them as a recommendation as they hit the ground running?
SPEAKER_00I would say if I could uh if I could redo it, or not redo it, let's just say let's give me I'll give the recommendation, making sure they have the right processes in place and really study the industry and whatever I guess company you're gonna be representing and stick to those processes. I think we all go through it as agency owners or business owners, we're always revamping, but insurance is a completely different uh monster. And if you come in with the right processes and just stick with it and and and run with it from the very beginning, you're gonna be massively successful. And uh, and I guess the next piece would be don't be scared to spend money. I was very scared in the beginning, and uh you can't be scared in what we do, yeah, because it eventually comes back to you.
SPEAKER_03100% are huge, huge sound uh pieces of advice. I wish that I had heard at the beginning, right? I didn't know processes, so it was like a circus and afraid to spend any money, total scarcity mindset, and I think it's done, right? It's like running on the hamster wheel, yeah. But taking the time to put those, we've done a million episodes on doing processes, having processes in place, and you know, most of us entrepreneurial folks hate that piece of it, right? Putting together processes is like kryptonite, but right it saves you so much time and money down the road.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_01Cool, man. Well, Eric, dude, you went the distance with us. Thank you so much. Yeah, just want to acknowledge you for being such an awesome insurance dude. Uh, you know, I I love the your story that you worked for an agent first. So a lot of us didn't do that. Um, I did for a couple months in my father-in-law's agency, but like I I think that it's a different, I think you get a different perspective when you actually are in the trenches for a while. So I think that's super awesome. And um, you're absolutely you're dominating with your family and everything. I love that too. So yeah, so love it, man.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, thank you. Thank you. It's awesome to have you on. It's always good to see you on Wednesdays and interact with you in the group, but uh really grateful to have you. And I'm glad that we've helped motivate you. I mean, it's cool, it's really, really awesome.
SPEAKER_00No, thank you, you guys, for uh you know, being very inspiring. I appreciate it a lot.
SPEAKER_01Love it, man. Thank you. Hey, what are you still doing here? Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, if you weren't listening before, we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01Using these strategies did help Craig and I write over 10 million in premium in the last couple years.
SPEAKER_03And let me tell you, on this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same results.
SPEAKER_01Again, that's live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_03And if you jump on with us, we are stirred 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman