The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Eric Mangano - Agent Success Story With Dials Upon Dials PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
The wildest thing that's ever happened in my insurance agency was probably I had a client that uh basically had a total loss. And this uh this literally just happened four months ago. Water flooded his entire house. And uh come to find out he lives in the neighborhood outside my my uh agency's window, literally where my office is at. So uh, you know, he was here inside the agency about every day for the next like 90 days, threatening to kill me.
SPEAKER_02What?
SPEAKER_03At this point, I didn't know what to do. I didn't know if I should just transfer him out of the book or or I didn't know who to talk to because there were at the time that there was nobody in claims I could talk to. It got to the point where he was uh he started scaring at the staff. So I, you know, I didn't know what to do. I just had to put my foot down and and make sure he knows they can't talk to us that way and and that he needs to leave. And uh he came back with a whole different attitude. And uh pretty sure to this date his claim still isn't closed. He's not happy, but uh, but yeah, I don't know. That's probably the craziest thing. Uh my name's Eric Mangano, uh agency owner with the Mangano Collective in Lafayette, Indiana, and I'm an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_01Insurance dudes are auto-dicted to escape by our agents.
SPEAKER_02Now by the covering predictable and expensive and profitable agents. I am great. I am development. We are agents, we are insurance. Right now, while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_01We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_02Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years.
SPEAKER_01On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results.
SPEAKER_02Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_01If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
SPEAKER_02Woo! Yeah. Oh my gosh, it's terrifying. So the dude's house is right outside. Like you can you guys can see it from your front windows.
SPEAKER_03Literally the window behind me. Like straight across the field. Like we need to see his yeah.
SPEAKER_01You didn't take the hose from your agency and put it in his window or anything, did you?
SPEAKER_03No. You would have thought I did. The way he was out.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03It's a funny thing. It's a funny thing when people make claims. It somehow becomes your guys like the agency's fault sometimes, right? Yeah. So yeah, that was an interesting, interesting event for sure.
SPEAKER_02That's insane. I can't believe that. And he just for months just harassed you guys.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah, and I actually I just saw him like two weeks ago. I thought everything was taken care of. And you know, he was coming in. He I had a door closed. I was on the phone with a client, and I've got windows, and he's like slapping papers on the window. And I got my CSR sits right outside my window, and I was like telling him, hold on. And after I got off the call, he came in and he threw the papers on my desk, and you know, his premium's going up at renewal. And uh he wanted to cancel, and I said, Well, uh, who's down the street? You can go see him. And uh he ended up staying with us.
SPEAKER_01So you're like, Oh, great, he stayed. Yeah. The one save that you kind of don't necessarily we had one of those.
SPEAKER_02We had one of those that I inherited from the previous agency owner, just claims up the wazoo, uh, harassment, uh, lawyers involved, and it's like stuff that we didn't even do. And it's like constantly like, please do not sign up with us. Like, don't like like it's you're right, it's not right, it's not right. Like, this is this you know, this relationship isn't working out, whatever. And then she kept coming back, and then eventually she canceled, and then months later trying to come back, like she she's never gone. It's like, what is with these people?
SPEAKER_01It's like the ultimate takeaway. Like you're like, I like you're passionate about this takeaway. Like you're not even you're just saying no, but look at what happens with scarcity, right? Like you created the ultimate scarcity that now she you don't want her to be part of your agency. And she's like, Well, it must be good, yeah. Right. There's something we have that other other right. Why will everybody else just quote me? This guy won't even take me.
SPEAKER_02That is scary though. The slapping the papers on the window, I mean, that's just it's just too much.
SPEAKER_03And yeah, yeah, and it's it's funny because he always would show up at right when I'm trying to get out of the agency. And uh it's like, what do you do?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you just lock the door, yeah.
SPEAKER_03And it was uh, like you said, Jason, it was from uh the book I bought.
SPEAKER_02Uh oh. So much worse at that point because yeah, yeah, it's like, dude, I want nothing to do. Like, I'll literally pay you back to leave. I don't want your money. If anything, I'll pay you money to not be here.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. Oh well, dude, Eric, awesome. Uh, thank you so much for joining us today. Would love to dive in a little bit and uh hear the story of how you just joined how you got into this world of insurance to begin with.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so let's go back to uh 20 uh 13. I know everyone's pretty familiar with network marketing. I was uh in network marketing and uh I got introduced to a company outside of the company that I was in. Um I was I was selling energy drinks uh here in Indiana with uh with a group actually from the West Coast. Uh which one? Vima.
SPEAKER_02No way, yeah. Crazy, crazy. Yeah, I knew some people in the same circles.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, they're uh they were based at I think either Tucson or Scottsdale. But uh crazy.
SPEAKER_01Tucson.
SPEAKER_03Anyways, I uh you know at that point when you start you know ranking up, you know, I wasn't super high in the company or anything, but when you start ranking up, other companies start reaching out to you. And there was this one company out of Dayton, Ohio, um, that kind of introduced me to the insurance world. Never thought about insurance ever. Um, it was for life insurance. There was it was like an MLM pyramid scheme. I don't know really what it was, but I started uh going to class. Uh, I was gonna get my license, and I don't know what happened, but I just stopped talking to them and uh I went along with my life. And 2017 I got laid off from a pharmaceutical company uh in Indianapolis, and it was like the first time in my life where I got, you know, I was just like I hit a brick wall. I didn't know what to do, you know, outside of network marketing and and other jobs I've had. I've always had that entrepreneurship uh you know mindset and failed uh you know, different, you know, ventures like clothing companies and uh just small things. And um I knew it was either real estate or insurance. And why insurance? Uh was because my insurance agent was an all-state agent. He had reached out to me uh earlier that year, right before I got laid off, and uh asked me if I wanted to buy his book of business. You know, at the time, I'm like, what is he talking about? Which is crazy because the guy that owns that book of business now is actually a real good friend of mine. Yeah. And uh so, anyways, I just uh went along my uh about my life. Uh I picked up a job at GNC part-time uh to pay bills. Uh and I was making no money. And basically I uh I decided to go with the insurance. I went to an interview up in what's weird about this story is I I went to an interview with uh a life insurance company up here in West Lafayette. And to tell you where I'm from, I'm from Brownsburg. It's a suburb outside of Indianapolis. I've never been to Lafayette, to be honest, at this point in my life. And I came up here and I sat through this like four-hour pyramid scheme kind of pitch, and I was so angry because I was like, I at the time I had my first son, I just wanted things to get going. I was ready to hit the ground, just I wanted to learn. And I set through this thing, and I was like, wow, this I can't believe I did this again. And as I'm leaving, literally in the parking lot, I get a phone call from a recruiter from the company uh I represent now, and uh ended up spending the next hour drive home on the phone with him, and he told me uh, this was about five years back, that he had an agent that was one of the first agents opening uh a new agency in our area in quite some time. And you know, he liked my resume and what he's heard about me, so he wanted to see if I was interested and ended up getting a call from the guy that was opening the agency in Indianapolis and uh didn't look back. Nice, they looked back.
SPEAKER_02Nice. So go ahead. So I was sorry, just five, so it's been about five years.
SPEAKER_03Uh yeah, coming up on five years in uh September technically. Cool. Congrats, man.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, congratulations. If I know the company, which I may not know, you get a little uh plaque with a little emblem on it, don't you? For five years.
SPEAKER_03Uh well yeah, it yeah. I mean it's not five years of being in business, but yeah, I guess eventually. So you opened up in 2016? No, no, no. I opened up uh last year actually. Uh February 1st of last year. Oh, February 1st.
SPEAKER_02Oh, okay, gotcha. But you've been okay, cool. Gotcha, gotcha.
SPEAKER_01Nice. So you've been in this role as the owner here for uh a little over a year. What was the first big thing that that you can that you attribute to uh starting that fire, like really getting you excited about the drive to work?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so this agency that I bought, it was a weird situation. Um, never seen anything like this. At the time, there was I was looking for an agency. I I became a sales manager where I was at. And at the time I was I knew I just wanted to get out and do my own thing. There was no agencies for sale. I found this one agency, it was an hour away. I talked to my wife, I was like, we can make this happen. And uh the book of business was sitting, there was nobody here for well over many months, and uh that right there just fired me up, like just to be able to get into the door and had all these clients in this book of business to just create a relationship with. But I think the first big win was just, I guess, introducing myself to everybody in the agency and and hearing that uh sign of like relief that there's somebody actually on the other end and not just not just uh, I guess a computer or a call center. And then from there, um, you know, I just focused on on growth and uh seeing team members hit milestones before I ever did. Uh, like when I started really just fired me up. And uh what's crazy is I uh I had never been on a Zoom in my life ever up until this point. My second month, uh so it would have been March of last year, I got asked by uh the market leader, you know, if I would speak to uh I think all of Indiana and Kentucky agents on how I hit 100 items. And uh I'm like, yeah, sure. And uh, you know, I didn't realize how many people were actually gonna be on this call. Once I got on this call, I I was real intimidated, but it just kind of flowed. And once I saw that, you know, it it's still tough to hit that kind of milestone. It it's something, I don't know, it's I just lit up from there and just like I was like, I know we can do this, we can keep going, we can keep going. And seeing that, like I said, seeing the team members hit their milestones quicker than I ever did, like, I don't know, that's just watching other people win really fired me up in the beginning.
SPEAKER_02I love that. I I I think when you do when you when you have that sales element, I mean I I gravitate to that too, and man, it took me a lot longer than that to figure it out. It took me like over a year, or it took me at by the end of the first year. No, it was over a year at that point, so it took me over a year to figure out the whole sales thing, and then when you go from not being able to sell hardly anything, I mean it you could work from morning to to sunrise to sunset and not really sell anything, and then going from that to like actually starting to sell and no knowing why you're selling, how you're selling, and then imparting that on team members is it's addicting, man.
SPEAKER_03Really is it's very addicting, and I uh I've been selling stuff my whole life, you know, and uh insurance, there's nothing like it. People think uh you guys probably can relate to this. People people probably called you weird or crazy at some point in your life or in your career. And I when I talk to people about insurance, I'm like, you guys just you gotta you just don't understand. Like, yeah, there's something about what we do that it's just addicting.
SPEAKER_02It really is. It is. It's funny because I love marketing, and with traditional marketing, well, or direct marketing or whatever, you're always tapping into desire, and the thing that we're selling, no one desires, so you're like you you you don't get that element. Now we're talking about like relationship building and like all these other things to get someone to move closer to that thing, so it's very unique and it's tough. And if you're good at selling insurance, man, you can you could be good at selling just about anything.
SPEAKER_01And to top it off, it's there's nothing tangible, right? So there's I don't want it and it doesn't exist, and it's just but they gotta have everybody and they gotta have it, and they they've been told it's a commodity, so we have like everything stacked against us.
SPEAKER_03In the beginning, I got like I I guess before I started selling insurance, I considered myself a decent salesperson. In the beginning, we were doing a lot like all life transfers, and I remember that agency owner, he was like, like he didn't really know what they he didn't know what they were, like he didn't, he's never heard of them. Like we started day one together. He had no experience, and we just kind of hit the ground running. And all I knew was I just had to take this transfer, be the first person to pick it up, and it's all about persuading. You find out, you know, that you do the asset calculator at the time is what we had, a little sheet of green paper, break down certain things, and that's how I taught myself. And uh it just once I you know found out what they were looking looking for and needing, and uh reminded myself what we were on the phone for, it was all about persuasion at that point, and uh that's why I was so good at one call closes. So I love it. I think I I think that is what kind of elevated me in the very beginning was knowing that uh one call close.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, those are fun. I mean it that that's a fun game to play, is like you know, trying to get those right because they're so difficult, dude. Um so so tell us how how is your um right now, uh describe your team and like the roles in the agency right now.
SPEAKER_03Yep.
SPEAKER_02Um, so it's changed a lot.
SPEAKER_03Um, you know, I'm a student of the game, I pay attention to guys like you, a guy guys a lot older than all of us.
SPEAKER_02And uh I'm not older than Craig though, because I don't think that no, nobody else. I'm the oldest man on earth.
SPEAKER_03Um so I've got obviously myself, uh I've got one CSR, which I just uh replaced. Um she happens to be my little sister, and she is she is absolutely crushing it. She's and she I feel like she doesn't believe me when I say it, but she truly is. Uh so that makes me really happy. So I've got her, uh, my wife, sales manager, and uh I've got uh two LSPs.
unknownTwo.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. And then I've got uh obviously EFS, but wow. So when I when I started, I I I thought I had to have all these outside pieces to the puzzle. I had like a marketing dude, uh you know, like an assistant, and all like didn't need any of that. Like yeah, I just I kind of figured out that I could do what I'm doing without pieces, like I was too small and too new at that point. Right.
SPEAKER_01And you truly have a family business, right? Like three. That's how I was raised. That's how I was raised.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I was raised in a small family business. I I always tell my wife, and she just tells me to shut up. I always told my wife. That's normally I always tell my wife I picked up a broom when I was five, and uh that's when I that was my first job. Nice, and I I haven't stopped working since, but no, I grew up in a small family business and was kind of raised around you know how it's done. And um, I don't know. It's I always knew that that's kind of how it would be at whatever business I was gonna have.
SPEAKER_02But yeah, that's super cool.
SPEAKER_03Well, what did your family do? Yeah, they uh so they're one of three in the nation still. They uh they build clutches and uh drive shafts, and uh they had big clients like uh Jay Leno and uh uh other race car drivers, but basically they've been doing it since 1964, Fort Wayne, Indiana, and uh had multiple locations around the country, and it just inspired me as a kid uh watching how successful they made that business. And uh yeah, it just inspired me and I guess taught me a lot of principles about entrepreneurship and you know the ups and downs and stuff like that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And for for anybody under 30 that's listening, a clutch is actually a third pedal in the car that you push down in order to change gears. Just a little Google it, I think it comes up on the Google.
SPEAKER_03Um yeah, nowadays nowadays the the cores where they got the uh the paddle shifters and the electronic clutches.
SPEAKER_01You don't even need to that just takes all the fun out of it.
SPEAKER_03Right, exactly.
SPEAKER_02Man, I learned how to I I learned how to drive on my mom's mom had a 80, like an 85 BMW 325, and that thing had a clutch, and you had to press it like you were like you're a grip in the car and like press it as hard as you could just it was it was brutal, but uh it made me appreciate the automatic, that's for sure.
SPEAKER_01Oh, for sure. Yeah, I had several cars that were stick, it was the best. I loved it.
SPEAKER_02Well, didn't you have a steam engine when you first started? It was coal, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Coal and steam. Coal wait, how old are you? Uh 473. He looks good for your age. Yeah, I look great. That's the only way I can look great for my age. So you your agency brings uh the whole notion of culture in a different light because we normally say, how would how did you build the culture or ask how did you build the culture in your agency and incorporate that? But how do you maintain the culture with your wife and your sister there? Like, can it get a little challenging?
SPEAKER_03Oh yeah, for sure. Now, like I said, in the past year, a lot of things have changed at the agency. It wasn't always You know, just family was just me and my wife. You know, I've had the producers come and go, but you know, having my sister here now, I think it's kind of uh, I mean, it's honestly helped a lot. You know, there's any family business, there's gonna be arguments, there's gonna be challenging times and stuff like that. But uh, you know, one thing I one thing I made pretty clear when we were opening was culture is everything to me. If culture is bad, you know, it's not good for business. I'm always monitoring the culture, making sure people are in good boots when they walk in. Don't if you're not in a good mood, there's no sense in being here.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_03Because it's just gonna it's gonna bring everybody else down, shooting hoops. I got a basketball hoop in here. Like I think that's just a some it's it's just setting the tone, every you know what I mean. Like, we've kind of gotten off that lately, but just doing different things like that, I think uh makes everybody a little bit happier.
SPEAKER_01So, how many times have you had to send your wife home because she wasn't in a good mood? I'm gonna say probably like probably like five.
SPEAKER_02Uh huh. Oh wow, that could have gone well.
SPEAKER_03No, no, I don't think I've had to send her home.
SPEAKER_01She sent you home.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think she sent me home.
SPEAKER_01I think she sent me home quite a bit. We know who the boss is. You're right.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. That's awesome. How do you recruit? Are you currently recruiting how have you done in the past?
SPEAKER_03And yeah, so I get a lot of I get a lot of crap for this from other agents. I feel like, you know, they're like, how do you how do you do it? Like, how do you find these people? Like, I've never hired a company. Like I've looked into it, I've talked to them, all the companies that you guys have talked to. I believe in them. I don't believe in the price.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03You guys, maybe you guys do or not. I don't know, but to me, I know I can I'm a headhunter. I can find those people on my own. I know how to make the ads, I know how to take the time out. I get, you know, you're taking your time out of running the age of seats that find people. I get that part, but I'm too small to you know spend money on stuff like that. I feel like so I just do it on my own time at night and uh found everybody from Indeed.
SPEAKER_02Nice. Yeah. Well, you have a different skill set also. Right, I would say the average person. So um for you, it it probably takes a lot less time. Where I know, like when I first started hiring, there's so much guesswork too involved that I like I wasn't I wasn't what year did you start start thinking? I'm still I'm still horrible. Like, I I I assume everybody's awesome, you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm not a good home.
SPEAKER_02They're like, I don't really want it. I'm like, no, no, no, you can do it. You're gonna be great. Don't worry about it.
SPEAKER_03I think that's yeah, but I think that's just natural, you know what I mean? In any business, it's natural because I think I'm just now getting over that. Uh last year, I mean, I would get people in an interview sitting across from me, and I'm like, what am I doing? Like, yeah, how do I get this person out of my office? Like, they walked in, and I already knew that it was a wrong invite.
SPEAKER_01That's the best. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, you're only thinking, How do I get out of this hour?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, this was a great interview. Um, it just started. Yeah, no, I got it. I got your resume. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01If that happened to me, I would start saying, Hey, we run the first interview real quick. Um, so we're gonna be together for about 10 minutes. I'm just gonna ask a couple questions just to get that first one knocked out. Just to get you out of here. Just to get you out of here.
SPEAKER_03But no, there was uh one one month, actually, it was like one week last July. I was desperate. Like I needed people. I just had to let go of one of my producers. I was down to just my wife and and uh my main guy keeping inside of my office. And uh I got 32 resumes in a week from ND. Wow, 32. I couldn't believe it. Like, yeah, couldn't believe it. I think two showed.
SPEAKER_01And you're thinking if I don't get somebody on, I'm gonna talk to my wife all day.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and I'll be honest, I'll be honest, that little stretch between July and and um really December-ish last year was was I guess rough when it came to staffing. Yeah, I was just I was so picky. I because culture's everything. I already had people in here last year that threw off the culture, and that that throws off the momentum.
SPEAKER_02100%. Yeah, yeah. There was a defining moment too at our agency where I hired a bunch of people quickly and it went awry. And it was like once that happened, and I saw how like the yeah, like it like the the negativity and everything spread so quickly, and then it's just like everyone, yeah, dude.
SPEAKER_00It's a war, it I didn't even want to show up to work.
SPEAKER_03Like, no, I guess anyhow. Yeah, yeah. I mean, I remember as a uh producer, you know, before I own the agency, there was many days I didn't want to show up to work, and I love work, I love working. It's like I don't want to be around that person, like right, it just kills everything.
SPEAKER_01Like the spin on it, the positive side is when culture is strong and really, really positive, it makes people want to come in, like they're excited to go, right?
SPEAKER_00But have you ever had that?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, have you ever had that time, like that feeling where you're like, is this it's almost too is it too good to be true? Is it because it's like things are going so well? I know you guys have had that, had that, and it's like, how do I keep that going? You know what I mean? And then now I'm up all night. I'm thinking, yeah, right, I'm up all night. I can't sleep and I'm just trying to think of how to get to the next level, how to you know, make sure everyone's happy. And I like what uh I forget the guy you guys interviewed uh on the last podcast I listened to. I really like what he said about um employee time off and stuff like that, making sure people are happy. I truly live by that. Truly. You hit what's expected, take a couple days off, go golf, go do what you need to do uh to clear your mind. Because we're all human. Yeah, that's that's huge.
SPEAKER_02Was it Eric Merrick? Uh or I'm sorry, Chris Merrick.
SPEAKER_03I think he was in Alaska, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Chris.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, good dude.
SPEAKER_02That was great.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_03So that's that's amazing that they're in Alaska and Yeah, it's I never even thought there was that many people in Alaska. That's awesome.
SPEAKER_01Apparently there are. I thought it was more bears than people, but there's a lot of people there.
SPEAKER_02Hey, what are you still doing here? Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, if you weren't listening before, we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_02Using these strategies did help Craig and I write over $10 million in premium in the last couple years.
SPEAKER_01And let me tell you, on this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same results.
SPEAKER_02Again, that's live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_01And if you jump on with us, we are stirred. 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman