The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The Insurance Dudes are on a mission to find the best insurance agentsaround the country to find out how they are creating some of the top agencies. But they do not stop there, they also bring professionals from other industries for insights that can help agents take their agencies to the next level. The Insurance Dudes focus on your agency’s four pillars: Hiring, Training, Marketing and Motivation! We have to keep the sword sharp if we want our agencies to thrive.&nbs...
The wildest thing that has ever happened to me in the insurance business, well, there's a lot of them, but let me pick one that's the kind of the weirdest claim story because you know insurance covers people's negligence, right? It doesn't cover your intent, just your negligence. So what happened was an individual that we insured had a home, had a 3,000 square foot home. It's a sizable home, but they had some problem with bugs, right? You know, bugs is and bugs isn't covered itself. So we had some problem with bugs. So you're supposed to get those bug bombs. You know, I'm talking about a bug bomb is you put that little canister down for those for you youngins that don't remember, you push the button and the the aerosol comes out, and the aerosol fills up the house and kills all the bugs. So the instruction said use one for every thousand square feet. So if you have a 3,000 square foot house, okay, people, this is math. I know a lot of insurance agents on here. You guys know math. It's gonna be three. Thank you. Okay, it's three. One of our customers, one of our insureds, used 32. Let me repeat that number. Somehow the decimal place got mistaken, 32. So you're saying down to two, right? 32. Who can't right? Three point, I don't know, but who cares, right? It what's the big deal? Here's the problem. He forgot to unplug the refrigerator. So when the refrigerator kicked on, it produced a spark. Oh no. The house, let me see if I can use my hand. The house went and basically it was just like one of those like movie sets. It went and it just fell apart. Oh man. And of course, we we covered that loss, uh, as we should. But uh, my rule to people is don't use 32 when it calls for three. My name is Stacy Galante. I'm with Florida Peninsula, an Edison Insurance Company, a carrier based out of South Florida in the good old state of Florida.
SPEAKER_02
So good.
SPEAKER_00
And I'm an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_02
Insurance dudes are automated to escape being handcuffed by our agency.
SPEAKER_01
How? By uncovering the secret of creating predictable, consistent, and profitable agency sales. I am Craig Futzinger. I am Jason Feltman. We are agents. We are insurance dudes. Right now, while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_02
We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01
Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years. On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results. Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_02
If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there. Oh, look at that. Boom!
SPEAKER_01
Right. That is a fantastic story. Yep. So I've used those, right? And obviously it's gonna kill bugs one within a thousand square feet. So they're in there, they're popping the tops of these things. I mean, I don't care what kind of mask you have on, you're whiffing a lot of stuff.
SPEAKER_00
But I mean, I'm imagine after five. I'm not sure exactly how they physically did it. They may have had some friends do it, may have had a bunch of people come over, each hit a couple of them and run out. I don't know exactly. I don't remember the case. This was probably 10 years ago or 12 years ago, but that thing kicked on. Now it could have been that it wasn't the refrigerator at all, but some of the bugs were just you know lighting up. Right. They set it off. Because you know when did this happen? When did it happen?
SPEAKER_02
Like legalization or before?
SPEAKER_00
Pre oh no, this was this was before. This was this was yeah, this was like 10, 12, 13 years ago. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02
Okay. Back when the bugs were smoking, just cigarettes, I guess.
SPEAKER_00
Don't smoke. Unplug your fridge, people. That's my rule.
SPEAKER_02
Wow. So is there any chance that they thought this through and thought if we do 32 of them, the house will blow up, then it will be covered.
SPEAKER_00
Here's the answer. I don't know how to say this right. I interviewed these people, and there was no chance they were that smart to do that. There was no chance. And, you know, unfortunately, all your stuff is your personal stuff is destroyed and things of that nature. I will say, I will say that we find many times that there is fraud. One of the departments that I oversee at our insurance company at Florida Peninsula and Edison is the special investigations unit, the anti-fraud unit. And so, you know, we do see people do that. This was not it.
SPEAKER_02
Right. You're like, no, no, couldn't have done it. Ah, you're like, it actually makes sense that they use 32.
SPEAKER_00
You know, sometimes you feel like you know, you're gonna, you know how like let's face it, people have been to a bathroom and they leave it and there's they've left some some scent in that bathroom. Not us, none of none of us, but you've walked in there, you spray a spray, you're like, one's not doing it. Next thing you know, you're spraying everywhere. Yeah, this is that to the extreme.
SPEAKER_01
You know what I'm saying?
SPEAKER_00
Just spray it. Yeah, just spray it.
SPEAKER_01
So, Stacy, tell us, how did you get into this crazy business of insurance?
SPEAKER_00
I I appreciate the question. Um, and I'm a big fan of your of the insurance dudes podcast. I will say that I was I was a lawyer, uh, went to law law school and um I University of Miami, although my I went to Boston University for undergraduate and then went to University of Miami. And I was in the I became a just a regular good old-fashioned lawyer, and I started by representing policyholders and suing insurance companies. So yes, so if you had a claim that was denied or wasn't paid, whether it was auto, you know, a collision claim, a comp claim, homeowners, windstorm, life insurance, you know, you name it, if a if they didn't pay or if they paid less, business insurance, et cetera, I would go after them. So I did that for about 12 years. And during that time, towards the end of it, make a long story short, I met uh a guy who was an allstate agent, my buddy Clint. He was an allstate agent for 17 years. He started off in the booth. He's a few years older than me. He started off in when it was part of Sears, if you guys were part of Sears. And so he would be in a booth. And like, and this is not sexist, this is really how it was. Men, women would be doing the shopping back then in the old days, and the men would be in the auto section. So they put the insurance in the auto section, whether it was home or auto insurance, they put it in the section, and the guys were bored, and so you try to sell them insurance. And so that that's how it was back then, and just that's the way the world was. And so he was an all state agent. He came to me again about 17 or 18 years ago, 18 years ago, and said, Hey, in the state of Florida, there's a lot of unplaced homeowners' policies because there's just it's such a problem state, Florida. There's hurricanes, there's fraud, there's fires, there's tornadoes, there's like crop we've had claims where crocodiles come into the house. So it's it's there's problems here. We'll talk about that. And so he said the government has policies that they'll give to you, they'll give to you to start a business. So he and I put together a business plan. Again, making a stupid long story even shorter. We put a business plan. We went to two friends that we had, both of them were Harvard MBAs. Okay. We're an agent and a lawyer. We're smart, but we're not Harvard MBAs. Okay, maybe some of us are. I mean, I'm sure there's agents of people that do everything. So these guys asked us literally a hundred questions. They gave us a hundred questions, literally, 90 something. We answered all the questions, we put together a business plan, and they investigated it and said, you know what, this is true. We can go to the state of Florida, get the policies nobody wants, and we'll do that. And so we put in our business plan, Clint and I, you know, we're at the time we were in our 30s, mid-late 30s, and we said, you know what? We believe that by year three, we'll do a hundred million dollars in revenue by year three. The Harvard MBAs and a couple other guys we got to join us later laughed. I mean, you know, your kid walks in. I don't know if you guys have kids and they say, you know, I'm gonna start a business, Dad. You know, here you are, kid. And so Okay, kid. Right. Okay, what do you guys know? What does the dudes know? Me and me and my buddy Clint, we're the dudes. Yeah. So what happens actually by year three, we were at about 150 million. And we started in 2005, and today we do 525 million dollars in annual revenue. There you go. Wow, we do that. Florida Peninsula, you can look us up, Edison. It's a combined, you know, it's combined company. But so that's how we started, and that's how I got into it. Did you do a victory dance around the Harvard MBAs? I did, I was twerking because in South Florida we twerk. You started it. Oh, I start. I started what was that one that you do like this that I can't do? It's the the flossing, the flossing.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, I can't floss. I can't either. Yeah, my body just says, What do you like? It's it's confused by the thought of me.
SPEAKER_00
What's the fl right? I can't do it.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, kids can do it though, right? Yes, kids can see it for the first time and just automatically do it. They're just disturbing, disturbing. That is awesome. So uh take us back to that that early win. How did that get going? Like, I'm sure you were doubting yourself a little bit at the beginning.
SPEAKER_00
Like, I I mean, I think we could do this, but we did. We doubted ourselves, and again, we had a lawyer who was a plaintiff's a policy holder lawyer. I wasn't like a corporate lawyer, I wasn't working for some big company, and my buddy was an all-state agent, a retail boot, just a retail agent. Okay, like a lot of people listen to your podcast. And but he and he loved doing it, but he had an idea that look, we can start something and we can take policies to get started from the government. They give you the money, they give you the policies, and then from there you're legit and you can sell, you know, you can file your forms and your rates and sell your policy to to everybody else that that that needs that policy. So getting the money, again, the Harvard MBAs knew some people uh to be able to put together the money. But I will tell you, back then it wasn't a lot of money. I think you needed something like eight million dollars to start an insurance company. That's it. And it's it's I mean, eight million is not a small amount of money, but I mean, I'm sure where you guys live, there could be houses within a couple of miles that are eight million dollars or five million. You know what I mean? I mean, certainly within a 50 mile radius, if you have 20 mile radius, there's $15 million houses, or it's it's not that much money, right? Um that's crazy.
SPEAKER_02
Yep, yep. So so so why don't you talk about so you had to see you scaled super quick, right? You built this from zero to 120 million in three years, two years. So three years. How did you build that team? How did you create the infrastructure to support that in such a short amount of time?
SPEAKER_00
It's a great two. I'll give it on two answers. The first answer is that there really was no infrastructure. When we started, including the six executives, we had two people answering the phone. I mean, if we answering the phone in like a financial bookkeeper, we had eight people. So we didn't have anybody, so there was no infrastructure. Okay. Um, however, we did within we within a certain number of months, maybe like six months, we outsourced phone calls, billing, and all of that to an outside local company that did it. So we outsourced it. We didn't have any of that in-house. Now we have a lot of it insourced. We have about 250 employees. We lease directly or vendor another 100-150 employees that just work for us through a vendor relationship, but we still have about 250 full-time real employees. So originally the answer is we had none. On the other side of it, when we did the what they call the takeout, when we took those policies from the government, from the pool, and a lot of states have pools of insurance policies, auto homes. This was just home renters and condo unit. When we took out those policies, we had to appoint their agents. So just like you guys, we had to appoint their agent. So we still paid them their commission. In Florida, it's normally about a 10% commission on homeowners. And right now, the average premium in Florida is about $3,500. Woo! So 10% of that at least per policy. And it usually doesn't even change on renewal. I mean, it's not like it goes down, it's usually around the same. Again, depends on the areas and different carriers, of course. So basically, we had to appoint them. And we took out originally, you know, I don't know, I'm trying to remember what we did. The first takeout was maybe 30 or 40,000 policies. That we didn't have 40,000 agents, obviously, but there were probably 2,000 agents. So we appointed 2,000 agents. They were now Florida Peninsula agents as a later in 2010 Edison. And so now they also have the right to service those policies and sell policies for us. So they, hey, they got a someone else comes in. Hey, you know, no offense to the bigger companies, the state farms, the all states, they don't write in Florida very much because we're a dangerous state. So companies like ours, the quote, smaller companies, you know, 500 million annual revenue and not 5 billion annual revenue, but we're still very, you know, we're still demotech a exceptional rated, mortgages accept us. We still got plenty of surplus and you know, a billion dollars in claims paying capacity. Those agents were writing, and now they had another market, and that was us. So super cool. Got all those I love it. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01
So going from so lean with that kind of growth, what were some of the the takeaways to build that team quickly and create consistency?
SPEAKER_00
Well, you're assuming there's consistency, and I think a lot of business, no, because I've watched your podcast and and I've watched other podcasts, and I know a lot of your guests have so much confidence and consistency. And the fact is, most of them are full of it. Some of them are they're all amazing business people, businessmen and women, but a lot of times they don't start that way. You stumble into it, you stumble to greatness. That doesn't mean you don't work hard. I get up in the morning. You know, I used to have to be at court sometimes for a 7:45 in the morning hearing. I didn't no one in law school tells you judges sometimes start before eight in the morning and you've got to drive there and park. Okay. I'm used to getting up, I'm used to working hard, I'm used to staying up late. I mean, look, I'm only 22 years old and look what I look like. Right. Joking. So the fact is, is that you have to try to, when you're scaling or trying to build, what you learn is you're not going to be, you're not going to have the whole plan. You have to stumble and you have to try things. And when something works, you stick with it. Now, there are good outsourced people, right? Even now, we get 10,000 phone calls, let's say a month, something like that, 10 or 12,000 phone calls, non-claims, just, you know, my mortgage changed, or an agent calling saying, can you appoint me? So we got 10 or 12,000 a month. You have to outsource some of that. And so those people are experts at what they're experts at. We're experts at what we're experts at. And so as long as you have people supporting you and you know what your weaknesses are, that's how you scale it. You don't have to do everything in-house because you're going to be less efficient, in my opinion.
SPEAKER_01
Hey, what are you still doing here? Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, if you weren't listening before, we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01
Using these strategies did help Craig and I write over 10 million in premium in the last couple years.
SPEAKER_02
And let me tell you, on this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same results.
SPEAKER_01
Again, that's live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_02
And if you jump on with us, we are certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.