The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The Insurance Dudes are on a mission to find the best insurance agentsaround the country to find out how they are creating some of the top agencies. But they do not stop there, they also bring professionals from other industries for insights that can help agents take their agencies to the next level. The Insurance Dudes focus on your agency’s four pillars: Hiring, Training, Marketing and Motivation! We have to keep the sword sharp if we want our agencies to thrive.&nbs...
What would your number one recommend recommendation be to any agent that they could do to make the biggest impact moving forward?
SPEAKER_02
So I think figure out a way to make your phone ring, right? Because I think that makes everybody in the agency working there happier. I think that it's less of a grind when that happens.
SPEAKER_01
We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_00
Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years. On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results. Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_01
If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you.
SPEAKER_00
See you there. Cool. I'd like to learn a little bit more about like referrals. It seems like you you do have that really cool culture. You guys are going out, you guys are meeting people. How how do you like keep track of your referrals? It seems like you probably get them pretty easily with your personality. You have a very outgoing personality. Talk about that whole process.
SPEAKER_02
Sure. Um, how do we keep so I right now I've been doing a lot of fun like raffles, particularly during the pandemic when we couldn't get together and do fun things. It's like, what are we gonna do to be fun? You know, so we started doing raffles of things. So I did like home office things. You know, first I had like a really fun office chair or get a new monitor, and so we raffled off things to do things to spice up where you were, you know, in there so we did that. And now the raffles have continued. You know, say, okay, this month we're doing now actually we're raffling off the melting pot, which is why we all went. So, you know, whoever refers to us, someone's gonna win, you know, an experience taking their, you know, we had a Valentine's Day, we had a French restaurant, you know, the nicest French restaurant around here. We had a gift card for that, things like that.
SPEAKER_01
Oh, nice. And I love it.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. And we try to be something that it's not just money or something, I don't know. We're trying to do something that's has some sort of you might not get for yourself kind of thing.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I think that's much more motivating than just some cash or a gift card. It's like, oh, there's something cool that I never would have thought of or bought for myself, then it's a little bit more, I guess, sexy.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. I I do have two uh this great photographer who I've been working for the last couple of years. So every like year or so, we'll do a um headshot event. I think other people have probably done them, but so I'll ask, Do you want to come get a you know fresh headshot? And last time I had like a photographer come to my house and we had headshots and I had a party, and you know, it was fun.
SPEAKER_00
That's awesome. I love that idea.
SPEAKER_02
Go I was gonna say everyone had like a then I started doing like rock-up songs, like it was I was trying to get people into into their your turn for your you know, your photo. So we started doing rock-up songs, like you know, so having some laughs of playing just a gigolo, uh, you know, someone's got like mortgage lender's going up to get his picture taken. It was it was funny.
SPEAKER_01
Oh, that's a lot of fun. Yeah. So you touched a little bit on mailers. Why don't we talk about paid lead sources? Like what what kind of different or paid marketing? Like what what is your favorite thing? What has gotten you the best results? How do you track it? Like the whole the whole gamut on these things.
SPEAKER_02
Okay, good question. So um right now I don't buy any leads or live leads or leads. We don't so my I feel like my goal is to get the phone to ring. So have people call us. So if I send a mailer, they're calling in and asking for a quote. If it's get a referral, they're calling in and asking for us a quote. So we're not chasing and running a list and doing that. It's all driving inbound calls to us.
SPEAKER_01
Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_02
So I spent a lot on mailers, and so essentially sending out home home insurance quotes and people then calling follow-up.
SPEAKER_01
So let's dive a little bit deeper on mailers. How long have you been doing it?
SPEAKER_02
The mailers are a long time. Um five, I don't know, many years at this point. Um, but how do I track it? So I am really crazy about details and like the you know, definitely if I do any marketing, this you know, we keep track of the phone number that came in on, and then we're tracking all the calls that came through. I don't want to miss that golden call that came in. So we're tracking and make sure that got called, make sure that got followed up on, sold, and then we track, I track whenever anyone makes a sale, like I say, well, where did that come from? So we track, we use agency Zoom to track our, you know, all our sales that came through, where they came from. So I keep track of how much I spent um on a particular thing, and then we see how much revenue came in because of that, and then you know, was it worth doing?
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. Do you know about what your cost per sale is on the mailers?
SPEAKER_02
Um that's a good question. So I was just looking at that the the other day. The the thing is, and I let me see, I don't I know how much came in. The problem is you have to look at like, okay, if I didn't do the mailers, then we wouldn't get an award, we wouldn't get a bonus. I don't think I may if I just got that the cost is expensive. So if we just did that, we would make no money on it. If they never renewed, if we didn't achieve a bonus, there'd be no money made. Right. In all honesty. But because those other things happen, then it it it's worth it.
unknown
Okay.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, for sure. Uh, you are you comfortable sharing about how much you spent on the mailers?
SPEAKER_02
I think last year I I I spent like I don't know, on people are listening to like $50,000, I think. You know, I don't know, $50,000 but people spend money on a lot of money on leads. That's not crazy, is it?
SPEAKER_01
Right. No, no, no, not at all. And especially if it's getting results. I've just tried to paint the picture for the listeners, like of the different types of things. We do a lot of leads and and calling leads and use telenteam and and all that. So, you know, there's many ways to skin the cap. Sure, of course. And it's just investing in whichever long-term strategy to get the results, right?
SPEAKER_02
Because yeah, and referrals, I spent half of that. So like I got the same amount of sales through professional referrals and spent less than half that money. So that's why I like that. But like yeah, but like how much can like you know you can only make some, you know what I mean? So you want to grow that, but that's also time intensive, and like yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01
And then the ramp, so yeah, that's time intensive. Of course, it has a higher conversion, they're calling in. Then you have the mailers, which I think probably my experience with mailers was it took it took about six months for it to really start to get traction when I was doing it. I don't know if that was your experience.
SPEAKER_02
Um, no, as soon as we drop them, I mean they call when you drop it, then they call. You just have to drop a lot, I guess. I feel like you have to drop a lot. Cool. I mean it's a low percentage, it's low, like the numbers. That's what I was like called. That's why I call it the golden call. I'm like, that's just call us $200 for my phone to ring.
SPEAKER_00
And you talked about referrals earlier. Are you are you in in with how well you're tracking all the other stuff? Are you tracking the referrals?
SPEAKER_02
Oh, yeah. So we honestly, I mean, we don't use a major lead system, we use like eagents, a regular customer management system that also has the for customers. We use that for our prospects. Um it has a referral source, we use that. So everybody we mean we don't talk to anyone that we're not quoting, right? So you know what I'm saying? So it's not like we're talking to a hundred people, like we're only talking to people that we quoted, and then every quote has a referral source.
unknown
Okay.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah.
SPEAKER_01
Yep. And and do you also not work the quote up unless you're talking to them? What do you mean? So do you work a quote up if you actually didn't make a contact with them, or do you only work the quote up if you're talking to them?
SPEAKER_02
Well, the only leads that I have are people I'm talking to. So there's no one. There's no one exists unless we're talking to. I mean, I guess like we have the old leads like requotes and we do work like people who we quoted last year, I'm not and and then people who left us. So we do work those kind of things, but there is no one. There's no list of anything unless we're talking, you know, unless there's a person.
SPEAKER_01
Oh, I gotcha. Right. They have to call because you don't have their information from the mail drop or the referral yet. So awesome.
SPEAKER_02
Right. Yeah. So I mean I do use it like a quoting software that creates the mailing quote to send them, but so we didn't actually physically like there's not a person who went in there, just the quoting software creates one for everything for the mailer.
SPEAKER_01
And then that's that's sort of the dummy quote, and then you you have to dig in deeper once they once you talk to them. Right. Okay. So we talked a little bit about onboarding new hire and the kind of things that you do there. What about for new clients? Because I think that that that initial experience up front is so important to uh help with retention. What kind of things do you do there? Do you have a set process?
SPEAKER_02
Um, no, we're terrible. I mean, honestly, but I really do think that we're really good about the onboarding. Like the pre, like we the pre-sales process is a full insurance review. We've spent a lot of time with that person explaining coverages, getting them where they're to be. So by the time they're done and the policies are bound, they've been done. We've done really kind of pretty much everything. You're going, you know, we've gone through everything. That cycle itself, we take care of canceling their, you know, prior insurance. We do that, but that's part of the sales process. Once they're in, we really do nothing.
SPEAKER_01
Um and I think you almost onboard them on the sale.
SPEAKER_02
I feel like that's pretty much cool. Oh, I know. This is fun. So we do do something, um, and I used to call everyone myself, but I think that everyone on the team is doing a great job of that, so it's not really as critical. But uh, I have created something we call it, I call it the Nuggets list, and everyone gets like their list of who they sold each month and look for and we we both review it to see like, did we miss any opportunities? Should we have asked them for something else? Is this something else we should do? That so at the end of each month, the sales person every salesperson looks through their list and reviews each person, and then I send it to me, and then I review it. So it's not that um there's something standard, we literally review each sale to make sure we've gotten everything done, and then we move on.
SPEAKER_00
That's cool. I like that. What would you say your number one retention tactic is like? Are are you doing anything particular to help retain?
SPEAKER_02
You know what? We are really responsive. Really responsive. I'm like crazy about if I get an email, they're getting responded to. Like we just make sure that everyone who wants something from us gets responded to quickly. And we will do insurance reviews, but uh, we don't necessarily have outgoing things, but I will do customer appreciation events. We had a Ben and Jerry's party, like as after like everyone's vaccinated, we're like, okay, let's let's do something else fun. It's not a ton of people come, but I send everyone a gift card who wanted one to Ben and Jerry's who wasn't able to come. And this is also really this actually was you remember like very early the pandemic when it said you need a mask, but there was nowhere to get masks because they didn't exist yet. Like I don't know if you can remember that world. Yeah. So one of my one of my team members shows, and we said, if anyone needs a mask, we will send you a mask. You know, and then people were like, Oh my gosh, and you know, and so that was really, and we just sent him to that. Helped. That was good.
SPEAKER_01
Then you sent him you sent him a Chebaka mask. No, she sold them by hand. Oh, not the one that that was not a good impression. Can you can you do a Chewbacca, Jason?
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, I had that costume in my house for years, that Chewbacca costume. That was a good one.
SPEAKER_00
Really the one that would make the noise? God, I always wanted that one.
SPEAKER_02
No, not the noise one, just the furry face one. No noise. You had to make your own noise. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01
Now, this is a total segue, but if anybody's watching Boba, the Boba Fett series, there is a Wookiee that is like the mean Chewbacca on it. He's phenomenal. I don't know what his name is, but he is anyway. Yeah, he's very tough. He is very tough. So yeah, big, big Wookiee. I mean, they're already big. So this is a good one. Besides listening to this podcast, how do you keep yourself motivated?
SPEAKER_02
I have a group of agents who are like super positive people, you know, just great. Like I think surrounding yourself with people who are going to not complain about oh, this change, oh, this technology, oh, this whatever. Just surrounding myself with people who are, yeah, you're gonna play a little bit, but are going to be positive and give you encouragement. I I think that makes all the difference.
SPEAKER_00
I love it. It's so true. Keep keeping yourself around positive people is just is the number one, I would say that's the number one thing in life.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah. Yeah. It changes everything.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, when you're around the negative nellies or negative norms, I guess I should say, um it is like kryptonite.
SPEAKER_00
It is.
SPEAKER_01
It is.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, absolutely. No, so I think that's that's the thing. I think you just have to surround yourself and then you're good to go.
SPEAKER_00
Love it. Love it. So, what do you think is the biggest changes uh that you see that's affecting our agencies within the next couple of years?
SPEAKER_02
Oh, this is good. Um, you know, it's a lot of things things change. I a lot of people are worried, like, oh, things are changing for us, they're being changed to us. And I think the reality is like I am kind of happy. I'm I'm hoping the companies change and realize what people are doing. Like people are doing things more for themselves online, um, buying policies, you know, for themselves can online. So I think keeping up with that and seeing how things will change, the you know, how people want to communicate with agents, I think that's the biggest thing. So how that fleshes out, we'll see.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. You definitely are gonna get left in the dust if you don't keep up with the technology as agents, um, regardless of whether it's with um our shared carrier or you know, any carrier, right? You've gotta embrace that technology.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, and you know, because people are people are gonna change it. So just how is that gonna affect our mark market? I don't know.
SPEAKER_01
We'll see. Yeah, you you just can't keep kicking out cobalt.
SPEAKER_02
I used to encoding something called SQL Windows, like some some rare, bizarro little coding thing, you know. It's all fine.
SPEAKER_01
Is that what Windows 98 was?
SPEAKER_02
You see, you don't even know. Like this one saying no one knows it. Everyone's like, what was that? It was just like a flash in the pan. It worked for a while though. It's good.
SPEAKER_01
Well, as we wind down here, what would your number one recommendate recommendation be to any agent that they could do to make the biggest impact moving forward?
SPEAKER_02
So I think figure out a way to make your phone ring, right? Because I think that makes everybody in the agency working there happier. I think that there's less of a grind when that happens.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. If you can fill your agents, your sales agents or LSPs or whatever we call them, if you can fill up their pipeline with eight to ten quoted households a day, they're gonna be making good money. And that's the that's sort of the bar that we set here.
SPEAKER_02
That's way too much in my that's we don't do that many.
SPEAKER_01
We just yeah, we power through them. And yeah, the more opportunity you create, I think the bigger impact that they can have, and and it helps them.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_00
Love it, awesome. Well, gosh, Christine, thank you so much for coming on here and sharing your wealth of knowledge and and letting us be a part of your world for a little bit.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, thank you. Super fun. I don't know, but yeah, thank you.
SPEAKER_01
Thank you. Yes, do that. It was awesome having you, and uh, we appreciate you taking time. We know you're super busy and that it is a uh you know there's a lot to do. So taking that taking this time out to share some of the insights with our audience is fantastic and really good.
SPEAKER_02
Thanks, have a good day. Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_00
What are you still doing here?
SPEAKER_01
Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.txt.com before we just go to the rest of the live. Să te găsiți aici.
SPEAKER_00
Sem asta live, desta live, scimite, a fost un dimensiata.
SPEAKER_01
Aștept, am gestiți se.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.