The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The Insurance Dudes are on a mission to find the best insurance agentsaround the country to find out how they are creating some of the top agencies. But they do not stop there, they also bring professionals from other industries for insights that can help agents take their agencies to the next level. The Insurance Dudes focus on your agency’s four pillars: Hiring, Training, Marketing and Motivation! We have to keep the sword sharp if we want our agencies to thrive.&nbs...
The wildest thing that happened in my agency was we had this couple that just got engaged and they were insuring this ring for six hundred thousand dollars. Within the first month, I know, right? And they lost it. So I'm They have lost it. I know, like, how? Right. So I told a lot of people like, what does it look like? And I said, Yeah, it looked like a condo in Florida.
SPEAKER_01
Maybe I don't think people lose it. You go, Mr. Jason. We're already stepping on each other.
SPEAKER_03
Uh no. But what does a 600,000? I mean, that's a good question. What does that look like?
SPEAKER_00
Super beautiful, but I had a ton of people who were like, I have one of those medical detects, you know, detector. Where do they live? I have a medical detector. I'm coming up and I'm looking next to those, you know. Yeah. Super beautiful.
SPEAKER_01
I mean, I don't even understand how that that's crazy. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
So, anyhow, I'm Christine Angles with the Christine Angels Insurance Agency. Super like exciting name. And I'm an insurance dudette.
SPEAKER_03
Right now, while it's Friday minus checkout live, Doctalities.com.
SPEAKER_01
We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_03
Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years. On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results. Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_01
If you jump on this call with us, we're starting 2022. See you there. Well, welcome. Welcome to the podcast. It's so great to have you here. Thank you.
SPEAKER_03
We love having the insurance do that on the podcast, that's for sure. Happy to be here. Yeah. Cool. Well, why don't you kind of just take us back and let us know how how did you get into this crazy insurance business? Was it something that you wanted to do from a little girl, or was it how did you get into it?
SPEAKER_00
All right, good question. So, no, nothing really super normal. Um, my son's basketball coach was an insurance agent, and he said, Hey, um, there's an insurance agency for sale, you should buy it. And then within six weeks, I was like an insurance agent. So it was crazy. So I had been a software developer, then I was an at-home mom, and the coach said try it, and they did it, and that was nine and a half years ago, and it's been super great.
SPEAKER_03
Wow, that is so that is so crazy how you just jumped into it like that.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, it was a little crazy. In the first weekend, they had like we had like a Derecho storm, like crazy storm here. First weekend we opened, I had no power in my house, and like everyone's calling with claims, like you know, it was a terrible time. Everyone has claims, claims, claims, everything's uh the start couldn't have been any worse, to be honest. Like for the first week was terrible, and now it's been great.
SPEAKER_01
But well, yeah, it's always tough getting in because you're trying to figure out what the heck to do, and then you're like, wait, I'm just doing service and pay not money, yay.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, no, but it was just like you know, you want to feel responsible and take care of everyone. So we were just a little not prepared for that. I mean, it all worked out, we got it handled, but it was it was stressful.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, yeah. What was going on at that point where you're just like, I'm just yeah, I'll just buy it. Let's do this.
SPEAKER_00
Uh yeah, it was it just happened to be the right time, you know, when things happen. Um, my kids were getting older, was ready to kind of go back to work, but software development things changed. I hadn't been worked in 12 years, to be honest. So everything I'd been a VP of software development, and every everything changed. Oh, the whole technology changed, and so I'm like, what am I gonna do? And this just kind of I was like, you know what I need? I used to call it like a job just falls in my lap. Something just like happens, and then I just happen to go into it. And honestly, that's that's how it worked. It was just I think the flexibility of opening your own business, you know, you guys are insurance agents, you know.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. Yep. And let's be honest, there's really no no room for advancement in the software technology industry.
SPEAKER_00
No, but like but I was like old, you know, but that's but not old, but by that point, like everything that I knew was irrelevant.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
Like there were no iPhones, you know what I mean? When I stopped working, you know what I mean? Like it was so it was totally different.
SPEAKER_01
You were programming in cobalt. Literally. Well, that's great. So so take us back to your earliest win in the agency, and that kind of set the tone and created that fuel for you to to make it happen.
SPEAKER_00
Like, yeah, I think that so I started in July. First half year was kind of a wash, just pulling it together. The second year, you know, it all we won like big awards, chairman's conference, national award. And since then, you know, like you kind of get used to it. You you get kind of a thrill of being someone who achieves, who wins awards, who does that, and then we just started doing it from then on. So I think that first you know, the first year that we did it just became the way it's done.
SPEAKER_01
Cool. That's really great. So just like your first year you hit awards and you were already crushing it.
SPEAKER_00
No, the first half. So I started like mid-year. Mid year. So first half year. First half year, nothing. You know, just kind of pulling together, handling the Derecho, trying to like live. And then the first full year as an agency.
SPEAKER_01
Oh, I gotcha.
SPEAKER_00
Okay. Yeah. So that first full year, you know, we got kind of got into a groove, hired enough people, sold enough, got used to everything, and how many people we needed to have, and what roles, and then got things going.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. You got a taste for the taste for the bonus.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah. Yeah. What did you start off with with your your staff? Like what were you, you said you were when you were staffing right then, what were you looking for as far as like uh as far as your staff?
SPEAKER_00
I think at the time we might have only had like two staff and then hired someone for sales. I think also the thing is of having someone who was taking that risk of hiring someone that you think, oh, I don't know if I can afford, and you realize you can't not afford to have a hub, right? You know, you know, you have to have someone who's doing sales and you have to make that investment or it's not gonna work.
SPEAKER_03
That is one of the first like epiphanies, right? You're you're like, I I need to grow, I need to grow. So you're trying to get everybody to to sell, and then you're like, wait a minute, like I need a salesperson, but I can't really afford a salesperson. But if I don't get a salesperson, I I'm not gonna be able to sell.
SPEAKER_00
Exactly, right? Yeah, so and different personalities too, realizing that you know, there's different personalities you need on your team, people who want to care for people and take care, and then someone who's gonna, you know, bring the energy and it feels okay calling people and calling people. So just different personalities and having that mix.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, there's this awesome agent. I think he was, I think his name is Mike in my Colorado. He did a presentation called the the service agents the wardens and the uh salespeople the inmates, and the wardens always kept the inmates in line. I thought that was to this day. I'm like, that's ex that is so true.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, yeah. But it's funny here.
SPEAKER_03
So, what does your team um look like now? Like well and and how's that evolved? How their roles evolved and and the positions.
SPEAKER_00
So we've changed a bit in the last couple of years, but right now I have six people. I just hired someone to start Monday. So I have two people who are like primarily sales, and then I have two people who are primarily service, and one, you know, person is like kind of half and half. So and I just hired a new salesperson, so should be about half and half in terms of makeup team. And then myself, I also realized too. I think it took me a while to realize, you know what, just sell some stuff yourself. Um yeah.
SPEAKER_01
So you're still in the trenches, you're you're making sales also?
SPEAKER_00
I like being in the trenches.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
Not a lot, but you know, I think it's good for I think it's good for everyone. I think it's just good. It keeps me fresh and knowing what people are hearing and doing and that little thrill. So why not?
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. So it sounds like you've created a really good culture there at the agency. What kind of things did you do to do that? Did you do to create that awesome culture?
SPEAKER_00
This is really this is actually this is kind of probably my funniest story that I like this one a lot. I hired someone who looked really good on paper, and then she told me she didn't like me. And I was like, oh, that's kind of a problem. But um, you know, right? The small office. But she said, Well, you're like work, work, work, and then get up and dance like you're at Mardi Gras. And I said, Exactly. And then that became our motto. Like, so if I interviewed someone, I said, How do you feel about the idea that I'd like you to work, work, work, and then get up and dance like you're at Mardi Gras. They're like, Yes. I'm like, you're in. You know, so that's uh that's kind of like yeah, I think that's good. I mean that's that's how we run things.
SPEAKER_03
I I love that, I love the polarity, and and isn't it funny, like the clarity of knowing exactly like the way we are and the like our culture and the way we operate, and and just letting people know like here, here, here's some things you might not like, here's some things that you might like, and it's almost like you let the person self-select, like yeah, you want to be a part of it, right?
SPEAKER_00
Like, if that's what you like and and that's who I am, then that's fine, right? Exactly. And then embrace it, and everyone loves it.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, love that. So, how do you recruit for your agency?
SPEAKER_00
We ha I was thinking about that recently, and we've really kind of grown in a very haphazard manner. I've found people like I was re I was restaffing and I hired one of my oldest, closest friends. So that was great. I had a friend who'd never been in that insurance, um, but she's a great personality and do her. You know, so when I said you I said you could do this. She said, How can I do this? I'm like, you can do this. So I hired her, and that so you know, that was great. We're like, oh, the dream team, that's awesome. And then I, you know, so I've hired someone I found in Indeed, someone I found through a friend, someone found me. So I wish I could say I use this particular process and I use a particular tool. I don't. It's kind of not indeed, actually. I'm sorry, I should say LinkedIn. That was the surprising way to find someone, and I I wouldn't I would do that again.
SPEAKER_01
So I guess the strategy is there's a lot of lines in the in the lake, and and you're always fishing.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, like I think that you hire, right, based on um opportunity. Like if someone is, you know, I think you have to be open to if someone seems great to see if you can put them in the team.
SPEAKER_01
Um that a hundred percent. I think that where a lot of agents run into trouble, and it's happened to me, and I know it's happened to Jason, it happens to everybody, is if you're not always looking, then you end up at some point, we all know that they're gonna leave. And when they do, if if we look when we need, then we're in trouble, right? Because now we only have a very small subset of who's available. Like the perfect hire is not available at the moment that we need them. And I think that that's uh a really good strategy you have.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, and it takes a while too to get someone like up and running and doing things too. So I think you forget, you're like, oh, I'll hire someone in April, and then really it's gonna take a couple months to get up and running.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. So haphazard a little bit on the actual process, but I know that you likely are not haphazard on this piece, which is bringing that new person on after you've hired them. What kind of things do you do to ensure that they're successful when when they start?
SPEAKER_00
Sure. And then I also should say too, like I also added on like a lot of written communication. I realized that I we do a lot of emailing. So I realize I should, besides just talking, I added that as part of my tying process to make sure that someone's gonna be communicating with someone well that way. I just I have hired someone on Monday, I have a big checklist of here's all the things that you need to do and know how to do, and you know, just working through that. And so we do a lot of shadowing back and forth, work the checklist, which is a series of you know different things. Learn this, know how to do this, get signed into agency zoom, get signed into this. So a lot of not haphazard, but it's a whole collection of all the haphazard things that we all have to know.
SPEAKER_03
That's awesome. Yeah, I love that. What would you say? So you bring people on, what would you say is like your most effective training tip? Like, where do you think you excel in in your training?
SPEAKER_00
Well, I have a lot of things that documented. So we have a lot of things that are um, you know, documents like here's tips on how to do this, where I've done screenshots and stuff so people can refer to that. Uh, I also have a few people working remotely. I work remotely half the time, some people work remotely full time, and we use Zoom and the screen share all the time. So the screen share on Zoom and let me show you what I do is really an important part of how we I think do training.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, I don't think that that this this piece isn't stressed enough. And a lot of agents will then like keep repeating themselves day to day and and keep repeating themselves with every hire when you don't need to, right? You just have to create the process one time, get it down on paper or make a video or or however you want to facilitate that. But why make yourself be the Google of the agency, right?
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, and I think too, like um, yeah, I don't know. I I think we get do doing the zoom and saying just watch me do this, or let me or I give you a list of things that's not time sensitive and saying do these things, but you're not actually talking to I'm not investing in a lead or uh at the time, like work some, you know, learn how to close, learn how to talk to people separately, and then we add it all up and it all works out.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, yeah. Yeah. So we all know it's important to keep the team motivated. What kind of things do you do to keep them going when it just becomes a grind?
SPEAKER_00
Uh well, we we just did something really fun. Like last we we won like All State of Pinnacle Award last as to last year, and the whole team we went to the melting pot, and we had a great time. Yeah, right. Do you guys have it there where you guys are?
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's fine.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah. And so uh we started doing like monthly team lunches. Uh, I have one person who works remotely that's super fun, and that we're, you know, so we're like when we're all together, let's have a lunch, let's do something. But we we have contests here and there. I don't know if the contests work as much as really just doing having some fun things to do together. I think that's what people like the best.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah. Well, what do you do? Tambourines. We have tambourines are very important in our office.
SPEAKER_03
I love that. Is that true that's it at Bardi Gras?
SPEAKER_00
Yes, but also anytime. You never know. Like something exciting, something we need to celebrate, good sale, you know.
SPEAKER_03
I love it. You're the first tambourine. We bring I do uh we have uh the bells, the bells on our desks at work, which is fun, but like I never thought about tambourine. It'd be fun to have a whole bunch of drums, right? Just a bunch of loud things.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, I recently added a purse tambourine, which is obviously new, you know, because people are like, you don't have your tambourine, and I was like, I don't, it's too big, and so I have a small one now, so I always have it.
SPEAKER_03
That's awesome. I love that. So fun. What are you doing for marketing?
SPEAKER_00
Marketing. Um, well, surprisingly enough, our biggest strategy is sales by party. So um really half of what we do is we get through referrals and a lot of it is creating relationships, but um, we do a lot of fun things. Like I take people to Happy R a couple of weeks, a couple of years ago, we had a big event where I took everyone to Wolf Trap and we saw Lenny Kravitz. And so I invited all our referral partners. We went to a concert, we had a great time. So I think doing things that are fun, and then people, you know, like, oh me, Christine, she's my friend, she's in insurance. So I think that's that's our biggest thing. Uh I also do tons of mailings and things like that. But so I would say half and half, we do a lot of mailing and we get a lot of referrals.
SPEAKER_03
Hey, what are you still doing here? Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.tele.com. Register, five.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.