The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Chad Kish Keeps Krushing Krazy Konstant Premium Part 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
So the wildest thing that's ever happened in my agency was probably one of the times where I almost got into a fight with the donut guy.
SPEAKER_04Oh boy.
SPEAKER_02So listen, man, I was a new agent, you know, trying to study for my financial tests and uh bought a book of business, had all this stress, and you know, couldn't figure out how to do anything and have all these vendors coming in all the time. So I told my front desk people, I was like, do not let these vendors come in. I'm working trying to build business here. Those were long and uh frustrating days when I first started. But, anyways, um, guy comes in, kind of look, you know, look like uh a kind of a weird guy, but he had a box of donuts and uh had some uh customers in my front office there, and he comes in wanting to sell donuts to me for uh some off-the-wall charity, you know, it probably wasn't even a charity, but um probably like a donut scheme or something. But anyways, um told the front desk office not to bother me, but this guy insisted that he had to talk to me and uh said I was very unchristian-like because I wouldn't uh talk to him. So back in those days it didn't take much to get my blood boiling, so I'm kind of like irritated. I storm out there and I'm like, dude, I I'm telling you, I'm not interested, so you know why don't you just go? And he kind of said, Well, you're not very Christian like, and so I got real close to him and I kind of whisper in his ear so none of the clients could hear me. And I said, Why don't we go outside to talk about this? I could see, you know, he probably could see the anger, and uh so, anyways, um he walks outside and I walk outside and he has the donuts and he's kind of like backpedaling, and so I took a step forward and I tried to knock the donuts out of his hands, and um he starts MFing me and running, and I'm chasing him down the down the uh main main street, and all of a sudden old beat up Pinto comes flying and the door opens, he jumps in and the door slamps takes off spinning wheels and um took off. And so um my staff from that day on, you know, I always refer to the donut incident and me trying to fight the donut guy. That's pretty funny. So um, anyways, uh my name is uh Chad Kish, I'm HD owner here in Easley, South Carolina, and I'm an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_00Insurance dudes are autofitable IR agents now by profitable profitable agents. I am great. I am agent. We are agents, we are insurance.
SPEAKER_01Right now, while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years.
SPEAKER_03On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results.
SPEAKER_01Just go to live.teledes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_03If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you.
SPEAKER_01See you there.
SPEAKER_03Oh man, I love it.
SPEAKER_01So I think we could all relate to something that's happened in the agency, like the donut guy. But what I find so interesting about that story is that he had a getaway driver. So obviously, this guy is pissed off some other people. It wasn't just you if he had a getaway car.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. You have to question when somebody pulls in with a dozen donuts of Krispy Kreme, and that they're they're trying to uh get money for charity. A lot of times it's you know, I've learned that it's a scam.
SPEAKER_03So uh why not just sell the donuts? Why do they have to chalk it up to a charity? Does that make it more marketable?
SPEAKER_02I guess I guess they could maybe you know charge more for the donuts, right?
SPEAKER_03It's so in the donut funnel, they're increasing their conversion rate by uh the donut scam funnel. They increase their conversion rate by throwing in charity.
SPEAKER_02Well, their acquisition cost is low, and then they get a good return on investment.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_02Because they can sell me on the charity.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that helps push it. It's a good marketing stance to the charity. I wonder if he was registered 501c3.
SPEAKER_02Interviewed that guy for sales position.
SPEAKER_03See, now if this happened today, would you have turned it around into an opportunity where it's it's now, hey, maybe you'd be a good sales guy. I mean, he is persistent, yeah, right.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. In today's world, though, like right now, we just went through half half my team is out with COVID, so I got the door shut and um trying to keep as many people out because I'm just trying to maintain my staff right now.
SPEAKER_01Right. Yeah, it's crazy. Uh, we're hearing this across the board. I mean, there's just stories left and right. I I had to close my office last year because of it, and then one of my offices closed, and then like a couple weeks later, the other office had to close. And yeah, it's crazy, man. I mean, this is uh navigating those times can be tough, that's for sure.
SPEAKER_02I've I've had COVID twice and I just had it uh beginning of the year. Oh, and then luckily half my team works from home, so I was able to spread out the team so that you know we didn't get like everybody sick, but and then up that half my sales team was out all at one time.
SPEAKER_03Ugh, it's tough.
SPEAKER_02It's been a struggle uh ever since, you know, trying to catch up.
SPEAKER_01I think yeah, when you get momentum and something comes in to kill the momentum, man, it's tough because it's like that momentum's fun. It's fun when you got a team rocking, especially in sales. So let's backpedal a little bit and let's tell us a little bit about how you got into the insurance business. Pre-donuts, pre-donut incident.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, pre-donut. Well, it was 2013. I was in surgical implant cells, orthopedics, did that for 12 years. It was a uh great industry, but I really wanted to um have my own business, and that's how I got into it. Never really thought I would sell insurance, but had an opportunity, bought a uh a small two million dollar agency in 2013, and uh kind of learned learned everything the hard way, learned how to do everything in the office. So here it is uh eight years later, and through some acquisitions and some scratch agencies, I've you know, pushing like 12 million now. So it's been a good ride so far.
SPEAKER_03Nice congratulations, Chad. Yeah, that is awesome. What would you say the earliest win was that really, besides the donut guy, that was fuel for your fire that really got you going? And and there was some you know, aha. Oh, this can work.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so um I just put it this way when I first started, when you um have a debt on your book and um you're coming in new, you kind of have a ceiling on what you think you can do. And so I tell I always tell the story that kind of changed my whole thinking on business and what I was doing was I had I had been an agent for three or four years, and I was pretty proud of myself because I was always, you know, one of the top guys in the market. And I went to a um honor ring event and you know, at the at a Ritz-Carlton, whatever, and I thought I was kind of a big shot because I was there and was golfing with uh some other agents and started talking to some other guys. And one of the guys said, you know, we were talking about numbers, and he said, Yeah, I wrote 100,000 uh last month. And uh to me that just blew me away because I I was still a smaller agent. I just had one or two salespeople, and I think I was doing 40 or 50. And I said, Well, how are you doing that? And he he started talking to me, and it just really you know blew my mind. So I asked him, I was like, Hey, can I come and uh visit your operation? And this guy was like two hours away, and he's like, Yeah, sure, come on. So um went to go see what he was doing, and he was running his operation 180% different than what I was, and he had started Scratch office. So after visiting him and seeing you know what he was doing and what the potential was there, I decided in 2018 to start a scratch right after that. And uh by you just kind of using this blueprint, I was able to put up some really big numbers and grow really fast with that scratch contract. And so ever since, ever since then, I've just really been trying to gravitate towards listening to uh people that are smarter than me, people that you know have been doing this longer and have had success. And that's one reason I'm an insurance dude. You know, I've I've stumbled onto this and I feel like this is really uh a game changer for us as far as like growing, you know, that growing with the type of business that we want to write, growing uh growing our agency long term.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's amazing once you plug yourself in with other people that have a vision maybe past the ceiling that we have for ourselves, right? You can't really see it when you're in the woods, but then when you when you get up at a different the next tier and you're able to see it, like you went to his office, you saw the vision, you're like, holy smokes, my brain never even went here. I'm busy fighting donut guys, and and you're you know, you just it sometimes you have to see it, and and I think elevating like Jason and I are in some coaching groups that we paid a lot to be in, but now we're with people that it's like holy moly! I mean, I never even thought of that. And it it everything levels you up, just really interesting how important community is.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's what I love about the website you guys have, the encouragement. I love when people put up, hey, I wrote you know 15,000 this today, and my team's killing it. That positive reinforcement, and I tell you that like you just said, when you first start, you're just fighting through the woods, just trying to figure out how everything works in office. It's so overwhelming, but um, you just have to be open to that paradigm shift, yeah, believe you know, believe it, but you know, having mentors and stuff. I didn't really have a mentor, so you know, groups like this, this can be your mentor, you know, you because you can see what other people are doing.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, love it. Yeah, it's it's crazy. You don't know, like it's like the thing. The most frustrating part is when you just don't know. And it's like, hey man, I'm open ears, like I want to, I want to know, you know. So it's like being able to see, like you went into that agency, you saw how it's done. Man, if you see it, you can do it. Like that's just the way it is. But a lot of times it's hard to, you know, you see the numbers that are coming in on emails. It's like, how are they doing that? That that first year that I was at uh when I first came into the insurance business, I came in from I was working at bars and stuff like that before, and I came in, and man, I was like, I don't even know how to sell two policies, let alone you know, a hundred thousand, like that. There, I was so far off, I didn't even know where to start. So finally, when I saw somebody that that did it, they were kind enough to take me kind of under their wing, and it was like, ah, now I get it, I can do it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and and it's just like the expectation, right? So, like we used to have these markets where we were like 30 or 40 in the market, and I remember when I first started, if I was in the top 10, I was excited, I thought, man, I'm really good. Yeah, but now I look at it, and if I'm not number one in my market, then I'm pissed. Yeah, yeah, you know, and I'm looking at I'm looking at like what you guys are doing in your zone. I'm trying to get to that level to where I can get in in the top 15 in the zone. Yeah, and um, so that's kind of what I'm shooting for. But I've I've had a lot of success, but it's all relative to what you think you can do, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, 100%. Yep. What's that quote? Is that if you believe you can or can't do it, you're right. The Henry Ford quote. I love that one.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01So okay, so you bought the agency, you started growing your team, you're you're a much bigger agency right now. Uh, describe your team and the roles that they have in the agency.
SPEAKER_02Well, since I've been able to scale, I've scaled through um, like I said, the scratch, and then I have two acquisitions. I last year I bought a book about 2.6, and then this year I just closed on 1.8, and I'm merged merging some of these locations. And uh the beautiful thing about it is that you can um if you customize between sales and service, you can kind of cover a lot of gaps. So, like I have a I have six service people. All they do is customer service and our phones integrated so that you know they can all take calls, doesn't matter what location they're in or whatever, but they're cross-trained to service clients. And then I just have a sales team right now. I'm at five salespeople. I've had made some big changes with my sales team because I was running the scratch office. I really wasn't too concerned about um retention or uh cross-selling. I just really focused on premium, and we really ran up the premium in our scratch office. But since uh, I'd say May, I've really started to just look at my retention and quality of uh new business coming in. And so I've had to kind of change out my team members because some of my team members weren't good at writing the type of business I've wanted. So right now I've I've got a pretty solid team of five LSPs that are um yeah, they probably average around 25,000 a piece, but I'm kind of looking to um add a few more and kind of keep scaling up.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, love it, methodical, right? You grow a little add, grow a little add. We can just keep leveling up.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think that's that piece is important too, because uh we recently were have really looked into the quality of business and same thing, trying to really uh up the quality. I think that's a good point to make that um sometimes you start growing so fast and you're into putting up numbers that it's nice to like you gotta step back and say, okay, where are we writing the quality business? How are we doing that? Is everybody doing that, or are some people taking shortcuts to win? You know? Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I just I was talking to my team about that, and even like an I've kind of noticed that some of my call-ins are monolines, and those are ones that cancel more often.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And I tell my team, I was like, guys, just because somebody calls in, you can't just do a shortcut and write them a quick policy. You gotta, you know, we we leave with liability, we talk about the risk, we try, we provide value, we're not selling on price, right? And if you take the shortcut, those customers probably are gonna leave as soon as you know they get a little hiccup or a price increase.
SPEAKER_03Right, right.
SPEAKER_02And so um, that's kind of been my marketing strategy. Um, in my sales process, they all dovetail pretty well together. And the insurance dudes, uh the teledudes is is phenomenal because one thing I really like about that program is because you we actually control the data, we're giving the data to the telemarketers so that if you have good data, you're gonna write better business. And if you have a good sales process, you know, hopefully you're writing uh umbrellas and cross-selling and having better retention with your book as well.
SPEAKER_03Right. Love it. Yeah, so creating that kind of environment where they're writing better business, they're they're doing all the right things, requires uh a culture shift. And you said that you do have some remote folks. How do you maintain or create, foster uh a strong culture at your agency?
SPEAKER_02Um, to be honest with you, that was a challenge. That that was a real challenge I had because I had all these moving parts, I had people everywhere, and I I gotta give you guys credit for um, I don't know if it was Jason or Craig or which one y'all um came up with this, but having a daily meeting every morning, that's had such a huge impact on my culture.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And I think the reason why is because it's made me a better leader for my team.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I'm communicating better with my team. I'm taking the time to to coach them up, we're talking about issues. And you know, at first when I started the meetings, I thought, well, I'm not gonna have enough info to talk to these, you know, what am I gonna say to my team every day? I but it just, you know, every day we just have something that good that comes out of the meeting that you know I wasn't even really prepared to talk about, but you know, it just works out to where it really strengthened, you know, for people that are that are um working from home, you know, you still want them to feel part of a team. And so just having that that daily meeting every every morning, that's that's been a huge difference uh as far as our agency culture.
SPEAKER_01I love that. It is it it's not easy to do. I remember when we first started doing meetings and they were bars, they were we were barely doing them, but I mean showing up to those doing the meeting, I would get so nervous every day because I was like, oh, what do I say and and all that stuff, and then fast forward to now, then it's like uh Miguel just hit me up today and said that they're doing uh doing a second meeting because we used to do two meetings a day, and then when COVID hit, having everybody at home uh initially, we did two meetings a day because we wanted to hey kind of check in later on the day, see where everybody's at and stuff. And like I said, my that agency shut down and uh they're all working from home again, and yeah, they're doing that second meeting, but I just the meetings are powerful, it's crazy, and you don't want to like I didn't I didn't want to do them at first.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, but it worked, it works, it really helps.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think everybody has the same sort of approach when they haven't done the meetings, meaning that like we say, Oh, what am I gonna talk about? Or you get nervous about you know being the dude and and getting up in front or you know leading the thing, but it's it's so fundamentally easy, and it is precisely what they want and need, right? The team wants to be led, they want you to be fuel for them to really blow it up. And uh, you know, as everybody says, it is the most it's one of the most important things that changes an organization is having those sales meetings. Salespeople need to be uh led.
SPEAKER_02I think leadership, the the agent has to be the leader, and uh my experience is has been I haven't always been a good leader, and I I've always you know been a hard worker and made numbers and stuff, but um really what turned the leadership thing for me around was when you just decide that everything that happens in the agency that is a failure, if you take ownership of that, um and then work on the issues instead of trying to blame the LSP or blame somebody else for why we're not doing the right numbers, or maybe we're losing customers. So you gotta just take ownership. And uh that really I feel like that and the and the daily meetings have helped our culture a whole bunch.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so awesome. Throwing away the ego, right? Yep. I mean it's funny. The guy that wants to beat up the donut guy is ego driven and frustrated and you know, scarcity, and then the guy that is sitting here reflecting on everything and all these any failure is me. I mean, that's a 180-degree shift, you know.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I mean I have LSP, I would have LSPs in the past that I thought maybe had more potential, and I would prow beat them. And it just it wasn't really good leadership. I should have just you know tried to instead of beating somebody down, just say, look, maybe this is it for you or something. And so I try to lead by um by being positive with everybody, and I don't really try to scold my team because I don't think that really works.
SPEAKER_01No, right? I agree, and we've all been there. We've all you know, we've all been there, that's for sure. I think the reflection and the the realization is how a good leader looks at it, right? See looking back at those times and going, oh yeah, that I haven't always been the best. And I'm not now, like I'm definitely not the best. And but you know, trying to strive to be better is is definitely uh what it takes. Let's kind of move forward into your recruiting process. Just curious how you bring on people as you've grown. And how big's your team now?
SPEAKER_02I have six service and five sales. I'm always recruiting. I use different vendors, I have um ads out there all the time. And uh so I'm I'm a member of another um training group, and I I try to listen to successful agents to see what they're doing. And I one thing I stole from another agent, he he did a webinar about it, but is work from home salespeople. And during this COVID time, and you know, the fact that people just don't want to work, really kind of don't want to work. I I used his strategy of um trying to find people that were willing to work from home with the idea that I could broaden my footprint versus you know, the whole way I would look at it was just to try to find somebody within 20 minutes of my office, you know, because you could find somebody good that's 45 and not 45 minutes away or an hour away, but eventually they're gonna get tired of the commute and be like, you know what, I'm just gonna go with this guy that that I'm closer to. That always limited you know the amount of good people you could find. So the work from home thing has been great because I've pinpointed different cities. Like I've uh hired a um girl that lives in Charlotte and uh, you know, um would have never done that before, and she's one of my best um producers.
SPEAKER_04Wow.
SPEAKER_02And so, you know, Charlotte's two hours from where I'm at. So um you can find better qualified candidates, people that have uh insurance experience and with sales experience. They just may not live in your state. So if you find someone that's good though, I mean it's you can do all the meetings and everything that we do with Zoom and and all of our reports, everything you can do, you can work from home. So that's been something new that I've done this year. I've hired several remote and it's worked out really well. Before I was kind of doing word of mouth and I wasn't really probably wasn't that good at finding people. That's something that I've become better at doing, but you know the interview process and everything, but that that's the big game changer that I that kind of tried to evolve to is the work from home type of uh position.
SPEAKER_03And how about onboarding somebody when they they're working from home so what's that process look like? Because obviously it's a little more challenging when you're not sitting with them and able to constantly be with them.
SPEAKER_02Yeah so the first thing is is I I I wouldn't hire anybody that didn't have already have their license and have experience because I think it would be too hard to try to train them as a work from home. But so when I do find the right person what I try to do is um I've kind of learned the hard way that you could hire you think you got somebody really good and then they have to go through your carrier's um appointment process. That could take you know anywhere from two to four weeks or whatever. What I've learned I kind of start doing now is before I do that I'll let them call leads in my um lead I have you know probably 40,000 leads in my lead manager system. And so I'll put them on the phone first and see how they do see if they see if they're able to um get quotes off of you know warm to cold leads. And um I usually give them a quota I like to see them sell you know 10 items by the first week or so. If they're local I'll tell them to bring in um on their first day they have to bring in 10 deck pages. And I'll tell them that they have to get all those quoted and then I just kind of put them you know like on a 90 day plan and if if they're not hitting the numbers then I'm quick to let them go.
SPEAKER_01Nice. Nice yeah slow to hire and quick to fire you know it's funny when people analyze my disc profile I don't know if you've ever done the disc thing it's pretty crazy and insightful but like that's the one thing that they say like you probably keep people a lot longer than you should. I'm like yeah yeah I have it and I know it too and I should yeah that's a tough one it's it's hard to fire people.
SPEAKER_02It is I I've had sleepless nights and I've just learned that you know I I'll just call them and say hey look it's not working out sorry and good luck.
SPEAKER_03Yeah well and I think it makes it it makes it easier if you really create those expectations and then it's you know there's daily meetings and there's accountability meetings and and everybody really knows what they're doing.
SPEAKER_02Well I left out a big part of what I do too I I've skipped over the interview process. Yeah I do the interview on Zoom and then I show them how all my leads come in how many phone calls they have to make you know they're gonna have to make 80 phone calls at least every day they're gonna have to get so many quotes so many items there's a pyramid that that I have that shows you know the bottom is how many calls they have to make which is 80 or they have to get 10 quotes or sell three items. Yeah and you know I've kind of used some of the formulas you guys have talked about with uh teledudes um because now that I'm have a lot of a lot of transfers coming in I'm I'm upping the requirements right because they should be getting more quotes now because I'm investing more in into the program.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_01Hey what are you still doing here? Well while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind check out live doteledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03Yeah if you weren't listening before we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents throughout the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01Using these strategies did help Craig and I write over 10 million in premium in the last couple years.
SPEAKER_03And let me tell you on this call you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same results.
SPEAKER_01Again that's live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_03And if you jump on with us we are certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman