The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Keith Zabrocki Will Rock Ye! PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
What do you think the biggest change that you see that's affecting our agencies within the next couple years?
SPEAKER_02I can tell you that the insurance business is a constantly evolving landscape and that if our feet are planted into the ground, we're going to get run over.
SPEAKER_00Insurance dudes are autofitted to escape being kept up by our agency.
SPEAKER_01How? By encovering the secret creating predictable, consistent, and profitable agency sales. I am Craig Hutzinger. I am Jason Feltman. We are agents. We are insurance dudes. Right now, while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_00We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years. On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results. Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_00If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there. What do you do to keep the team motivated?
SPEAKER_02Oh man. All right. So this past uh last month, right? So December, and I took the idea from another captive agent with the uh the company I'm with. I bought a uh Plenko board. And yeah, this thing is so much fun. So we did one call close challenge. And the one if you got a one call close, that uh you would get a Plenko chip. So you drop it down. And what I did is I said, hey guys, you get a one-call close, you could get anywhere from 10 bucks to 50 bucks, depending on where it lands. But either way, you get a one-call close, you're gonna get something. And so sure enough, it be kind of kind of became kind of a team challenge where everyone was just wanting, they were just vying. They get that one call close because they wanted to get that fifty dollars, and they came up with strategies and tactics, and they wanted that fifty dollars. But the thing is, is that it was fun for them and it was fun for me, and it really kind of boosted our our sales for the month of December because typically in December, especially once you get towards Christmas time, you know, you'll start to see the production kind of drop off because you know, people are just not not thinking about insurance, and they're thinking more about you know the holidays and you know, finishing up those Christmas gifts and stuff like that. So the Plinko board was huge. I'll also do like uh coffees for closers. So if you get five items in that day, the next morning I'll buy your coffee at Starbucks. So that's kind of a a nod to Glengarry Glenn Ross, if you guys have seen that movie. Yeah, so just uh little things like that. I mean, it's not breaking the bank, it's not intended to do that, but you know, like anything, if you have a competitive team, they want to be a part of that winning side, right? Yeah, and um, it's always just kind of fun to be able to do stuff like that. We also do team challenges where we say, hey guys, you know, look, if we get X amounted items here this week on Friday, I'll buy everyone Cheesecake Factory. So yeah, and you know, everyone knows those portion sizes are huge. Um I mean, seriously, man, I don't think there's uh dish that's under 2,000 calories. It's crazy, but sure enough, man, it's just kind of fun to be able to have those types of uh those team challenges, individual challenges, to where it kind of pushes everyone to kind of realize their potential, and uh they all have a good time doing it.
SPEAKER_01That's great. Love it, love it. So, what is your agency doing for marketing right now?
SPEAKER_02Good question. Um, so we're kind of an all of the above type of approach. Um, so we're doing direct mail, we're doing uh live transfers, teledudes, live transfers, internet leads, we do uh referrals from mortgage loan officers and realtors. I have a uh sales producer who is actually a realtor as well. So he's got an extensive network of loan officers that refer him business, and you know, uh he does the same with clients that he's showing homes on. So it's kind of an all the above type of approach. I used to do a lot of Facebook leads until uh COVID hit, and then you know that kind of went by the wayside. Craig and I actually worked on that together years back, but yeah, that's fallen by the wayside. I might do that again.
SPEAKER_00You were the king of the giveaway, uh the zoo tickets, right?
SPEAKER_02Oh my gosh, man, that was crazy. Yeah, you could literally get you know, for 50 cents and an ad spend, you could get a long form lead. It was crazy.
SPEAKER_00No, it doesn't. Nope.
SPEAKER_02Nope, not with all the privacy, all the things that Facebook has come up with. Uh right. Yeah, that I think that ship has sailed, man. But uh, I mean, if it's possible to do it and it maybe not so labor intensive because it did, it was a complete time suck at the time. I mean, if I can do it where it's more automated, I'll do it again. But that's my current strategy is uh, you know, direct mail, referrals, internet leads, teledudes.
SPEAKER_00Well, the you know, the big ad companies were losing business to all of us peons figuring out how to do marketing, so they had to talk to Congress and get that all handled. Yep. So they did.
SPEAKER_02They did.
SPEAKER_00Poor Mark had to look like a robot drinking water.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that was kind of I don't know.
SPEAKER_00One of the best things ever.
SPEAKER_02What was that? I mean, it wasn't even I don't think his glass even tipped.
SPEAKER_00No, it might have been part of an Oculus simulation.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think you're right.
SPEAKER_00So out of all those things, do you have a favorite? Do you have something that that you like more than others? What what do you lean on?
SPEAKER_02What as far as the uh the marketing?
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Oh, clearly. Um, I don't want to come across as being biased in this, but the live transfers from the Teledudes is is king for me because and I'm sure my guys will tell you that as well, is because you get somebody on the line that's being transferred and that's agreed to getting a quote is the name of the game. You know, my guys will tell you, and in fact, I'll echo it, is that writing policies is easy. It truly is. Writing policies and binding policies is easy. Yeah, convincing somebody to get a quote is the toughest part of the job.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, if we could take that out of the equation, right, to where you're just getting transfers in and your LSPs, your salespeople are doing what they're supposed to be doing, and that's selling, not prospecting, not convincing somebody to try to get a quote, you know, stuff like that. Right, that plays completely into their skill set. Yeah, it's it's what their job is, and uh it makes everyone, I mean, they're binding deals from it, so it's a good thing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's the it's the biggest thing that we train on and push in our agency is that part of the sale, right? The front end, or we call it the pickup line, right? Like you said it exactly right. It's harder to convince the person who just filled out a form to get a quote to actually follow through and get the quote than it is to close them. Once you convince them, now you're halfway there.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you're absolutely right, man.
SPEAKER_01So you're doing mailers as well. Do you have them reach out to phone numbers that you get from mailers?
SPEAKER_02You know, I don't think I've ever received phone numbers from mailers. Okay. So I wish that were a thing, but um that's what Amador was doing for ages. Oh, no kidding.
SPEAKER_01He was finding ones with numbers, and yeah, so he had a two-pronged.
SPEAKER_02Oh, I see. Okay, yeah. The vendor that I was using up until two months ago, and I kind of put a pause on it, and I said we'd pick up here in the spring, was a vendor that was taking photos or that were uh you know, grabbing the uh the subject property photo from maybe county auditor or something like that, and they would actually print that on the the top of the page, and it would be inserted into an envelope that had like a plastic, you know, uh transparent plastic. So when you're kind of whomever and you're getting your mail out of your mailbox and you see a picture of your house, you're probably inclined to open that up, right? So sure enough, you open it up and then you unfold the piece of paper and says, hey, you know, we could save you money on your auto insurance or your home insurance, you know, call this number, blah, blah, blah. So we were actually getting anywhere from a one and a half to a three percent response rate, and we were doing very well with that leading up until fall, and then it started to drop off drastically. So that's one of the things with direct mail is that it's not reliable, right? It's either gonna be hit or miss, and it's also extremely expensive. So you're uh you're kind of gambling, you're rolling the dice every single month. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Hard to track, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Did you ever find that it would create laziness towards the internet leads? Meaning, right? Like, okay, if I have a choice between the transfer that's coming in or the call-in from the mailer, you know they're always gonna jump on that because it's easier.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, that's true. You know, as far as the call-ins from the mailers, we were getting anywhere from 20 to 25 a month. So it wasn't, you know, the frequency in which the teleteam was able to produce. We're talking 25 to 30 a day, you know, with the teleteam. So plus at the same time, yeah, they can see it uh as far as where it's coming in, whether it's be a transfer or if it's coming in on a direct mail channel, but um it's not that frequent to where they have to choose between taking this call or that 20 times.
SPEAKER_01So, how important are referrals to your agency? How do you approach that?
SPEAKER_02You know, I wish this is a lost opportunity for us. It really is. We really need to focus on referrals, and I've got a couple of guys that are actually testing out some ways uh to be able to get some referrals now. I wish I could tell you that that's something that we tackle and we really kind of focus on, but unfortunately we don't. And I know that we do. So going into this year, that's one of the things that we all agreed that we're gonna focus on was coming up with a great funnel to be able to collect names and phone numbers of people that we sold so that we can get back out to those people to kind of expand that uh book of business within that immediate family. Yeah, so uh is it important? It is, but I can't say it's that important because obviously I haven't done anything with it, so clearly it's not that important in my eyes.
SPEAKER_00Isn't it funny? But the thing that we know that will have the highest close ratio and all that, it's like it's right there, and it's just Mario, we just don't do it.
SPEAKER_02But we're lazy.
SPEAKER_01But I think the challenge is this you have this Ferrari, right? You're you're like you said, you're getting 25, 30 people a day uh for live transfers. It's hard to focus on something that you might get one here and there. You know what I mean? It's just not, I mean, visually, it's harder to see, it's harder to right, it's harder to implement when you're driving a Ferrari every day.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and it's another question to ask, right? We're asking, oh, can you give us a review? Can you uh by the way, we have life insurance. Oh, you need an it's like there's so many things that we hit them with, it's like another thing.
SPEAKER_02Yep. You know what I'm thinking about doing now that we're kind of oh actually, no, this is probably a bad idea because I know that there's some limitations. I know there's some limitations on what we can financially incentivize somebody on an annual basis. I think it's like $25 or something like that. Correct me if I'm wrong, where you can give somebody like a $10 gift card for every referral that they give you. So maybe we could come up with like a funnel, like a woo foo form or something like that that we can send out to people and have them submit like a name and a phone number, and if we quote them, then we'll mail a $10 gift card to that person that referred them. That'd be cool. Something like that.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I really need to look into that and find out as to whether there is a limitation of how much money we can give somebody for a referral.
SPEAKER_01And if there is a limitation, you can do it somehow, they earn points where you know something.
SPEAKER_00They could come in and play the Plinko. Right. So just sell the Plinko chip. I along it was when my wife and I were really young, right when we first met, we went and joined LA Fitness, and the guy like we did all our stuff, you know, we're sitting at his desk, and then he turned the monitor around towards us and he put the keyboard in front of us, and there was like it was a form, and it had like 10 spaces. And he said, I'm gonna go grab your paperwork, I'll be right back. I need you to fill this out with everybody you know for referrals, and he and he walked away. And I was just like, Oh man, that's he had he had rapport with us, so we felt bad not putting something, but then we're also like, I don't want to blow it up everybody we know, you know. But it was it was so aggressive, and you know that if he does that every single time, he's bound to get results, right? So for sure. It was interesting, it was just an interesting approach. I think it was a little too savage, but it was something. So we talked a little bit about onboarding the team, right? When you bring somebody on, what you do now? Let's talk about onboarding a new client. So you bring on a new client, we want to create that optimal client experience right off the bat. What kind of things do you do to ensure that that happens?
SPEAKER_02Welcome call. Absolutely. Welcome call. We're or welcoming to the agency, we're checking to see if they've received their uh their documentation and mail, uh, insurance cards, all that stuff. We are uh also making sure that they've downloaded the uh the mobile app, that they've elected all the preferences that they're supposed to elect. If there's any you know any other programs that they're supposed to be enrolled into, you know, we help them out with that. The idea here is to get them good with all their stuff that they need to get taken care of before first renewal. We don't want them to lose any discounts at first renewal because of something that they didn't do in the six months leading up to first renewal. Right. So that welcome call is absolutely critical. If um, yeah, I mean, at the end of the day, if we don't get them on the phone, then it's an email. And that email is gonna be followed up with uh a secondary email, just making sure that they're aware that these are things that we want to assist them in walking through. Now, of course, in our service items, you know, leading up to I think it's 30 days before first renewal, we are gonna get uh you know a notice that they're up for renewal and we'll check to see as to whether they did that. And if they didn't, we'll of course reach out to them. So uh yeah, sure, I expanded that time frame a little bit, but I'm just kind of taking you through a journey, the agency effort to make sure that they are completely good to go with all their stuff.
SPEAKER_01I love that. So now we have we've kind of taken the journey from how do you get people in, how do you get your staff in, how do you onboard people? And now what would you say that you do for retention? Like, give me some ideas. Like, what are some of the things that you focus on that you look as the big idea behind uh your agency and being able to retain your clients?
SPEAKER_02Value and service, man. So one of the things every single client that and I don't call them customers, I'll call them clients, right? So that's just a thing with me. I feel like a customer can come and go. Customers are people that shop at a grocery store that can choose to not go to that grocery store for you know the next six months. A client is somebody that you have a business relationship with and that you're always going back to, and it's constant, and that business relationship can last years or decades or you know. So as far as as far as our clients go, every single person that calls into the agency, we want to make them feel like they are the best thing ever, right? That they are the IP, and we're gonna do anything we possibly can to make sure that they are good to go. So um we do that through, well, one, explaining everything to them in terms of discount utilization, their coverage. If they don't get it and they they're just not understanding over the phone, we'll do Zoom calls with them. We're very transparent, we're very educational, we're very open to making changes and suggesting certain things. We want to make sure that they're fully aware of what it is. And even though we can't control price, because a lot of people call in based upon price, we are going to educate them on why it is the way it is, and then just offer up some suggestions, you know, to keep them. Because, you know, with internet leads, they come to you on price, they leave you on price, right? And that's kind of the thing. So we want to make sure that we're kind of stopping that cyclical shopping every six months or every year by driving a wedge between, let's say, uh a call center insurance company who you don't know who you talk to, and you'll probably never talk to that person again because they have a thousand people in cubicles there. Or you can call my insurance agency and you're gonna be on a first name basis with uh with everyone that you talk to, and you kind of feel like some sort of uh, you know, like an extension of your family. So that's one of the things that they're not numbers to us, they are people, and we're gonna treat them. We've all heard this treat treat someone the way you want to be treated, but it's so true, especially if you're looking to maintain a business relationship with somebody that's you know, years or five years, you're gonna have to treat them, yeah, with some respect and with some courtesy and make them feel good about you know choosing your agency or my agency to continue to do business with. And um, I guess that's our claim to fame.
SPEAKER_00I love the notion of breaking the cycle, right? Because they've been taught, we were talking about it earlier, they they've been taught over and over by the billion-dollar marketing machine from uh the call centers that it's you know it's a commodity, it's a commodity, it's a commodity. And if we can change that experience even in the sale, and they come to the realize because they have to come to the realization that it's different, not us telling them it's different, right? Like once they believe it's different, then their perception has shifted. And it comes with all the things, right? Telling the stories, telling them what you said, you know, it's this it's the local agent, but even more so, you know, this is how you'll be handled when something happens versus what you're accustomed to, and then changing coverages, right? Because they probably had the same coverages over and over and over because all they do is match them and quote them and give them a price, right? So that's right. Love that, man.
SPEAKER_02And I'll I'll tell you what, we've come across so many people that you know, when we're explaining coverages to them or we're asking them about their current coverage, they don't know. They don't know what they're insured for. And even if they did know what they were insured for, like they pull up their deck page, they don't know what it means. Right. So if we can be that agency that will one kind of explains their perils, right? So bodily injury and property damage and collision and comp and all that good stuff. If we are able to educate them on what those perils mean and then make suggestions as to how we can increase those and still, you know, add value at the same time potentially even save them money, then we would be doing a service to that client. And we've come across so many people that are insured with uh competitors that are just on state minimums, or they say, Hey, I've got full coverage only to pull up their deck page to find out they don't have full coverage, right? It's a big disconnect as to what they're insured for or what they think they're insured for compared to you know what they believe. So uh education is huge. It is, yeah. With us, it's big.
SPEAKER_00So one of my favorite questions to ask here is besides listening to this podcast, how do you keep yourself motivated for you? Like, what do you do for yourself to stay motivated?
SPEAKER_02Okay, so I pull so much from so many different areas. Like I listen to Jocko. Yeah, I love him. Jocko, he will, yeah, that guy is that guy is no joke. David Goggins. Yeah, he is uh he is also no joke. That guy doesn't take any excuse, chestnuts. Yeah, look, um when it comes to motivation, I feel like I know that there's a bigger potential here. And for me, I'm striving to get to that space. And even when I get to that space, I know that there will be a space that's even bigger than that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So I'm not saying that you know I'm never gonna stop uh like I'm a Grant Cardone, but I know that if uh there's opportunity in this space and I'm gonna continue to drive and hire and coach and grow this agency to where it can be, you know, the biggest agency, you know, by production in Ohio. And until I'm there, man, I'm gonna keep on striving.
SPEAKER_00George Carbonell. I hope you're listening to this.
SPEAKER_02I was I as soon as I said that, I was like, man, I'm gonna get a message from George.
SPEAKER_01But how fun is that, right? Because I know George well and I know and I know you. And it's like two good dudes. That's who I want to be playing against. Cause when you're playing against somebody, you're also, you know, that that's the fun.
SPEAKER_02He's such a good guy, too, man. He's about five miles west of here. And man, he, you know, seriously, the guy, I mean, he runs uh he runs a great agency, but he always makes time to be able to take my calls. Every time I call him, it never goes to voicemail. He always picks it up. I'm like, man, you're truly unique guy. I mean, because you could send me to voicemail, you can call me later, but you don't. He he takes my calls, and I'm certainly appreciative of that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, he always sends me to voicemail.
SPEAKER_01Oh, really? He's joking. Yeah. So, and I love the positivity, and I love the that how you're hitting everything with the challenge, and you're looking at it like, hey, no matter what, there's always going to be more of a challenge. You strive on that. And in the insurance game, there's a bunch of changes, and there's there always is, right? So my gosh. And I would say for right now, what do you think the biggest change that you see that's affecting our agencies within the next couple years?
SPEAKER_02I can tell you that the insurance business is a constantly evolving landscape, and that if our feet are planted into the ground, we're gonna get run over. You know, we're gonna be just be, we're gonna be extinct. We will be obsolete real quick if we don't adopt with the times.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So, you know, my carrier is going through a lot of changes to where they're gonna be switching out our phone system, they're gonna be driving us towards a lead CRM that I'm not too keen on, but it is what it is. We're just gonna have to be able to roll with the punches. So adapt and evolve, right? Yeah, we're gonna have to zig and zag, I guess. Yeah, um, I don't have the foresight to be able to kind of describe in detail what I'm gonna be able to do because I know I've got some time before these changes are gonna be implemented for my agency. So I haven't really given it that much thought because I'm just right now I'm just focused on growing as fast as I can with as many deals as I possibly can get in the door before that change happens, and then I'll I'll figure it out.
SPEAKER_00Right. You got to focus on what you can control. Yeah. And and we know right now we can control our growth by executing a certain playbook, and you know, maybe that changes, maybe it doesn't, but when something's working, as Mr. Jason loves to say, pour gas on it, right? We're pouring gas on everything we can.
SPEAKER_02We we know it's in the horizon, but we know it's over the horizon. We can't see it as right now, so yeah, nothing we can do here.
SPEAKER_00So, what would be your number one recommendation to any agent that they could do to make the biggest impact moving forward?
SPEAKER_02Hiring coaching. I mean, if that and I know that there's a lot of tentacles and a lot of you know side streets that those two points kind of take you in, but you know, look, you're not gonna achieve your goals if you're a one-man shop or a two-man shop. You have to hire and you've got to go big. Then as soon as you get these people in, everyone's gotta be on the same page. They have to buy into that mission statement, they have to buy into that culture that you're trying to create. And if you've got people and you've got culture, and then you know, start sprinkling on the leads and you know, adding fuel to the fire, you're gonna create an agency that is gonna be humming and cranking out hundreds of thousands of dollars per month, and then keep doing that for a couple of years, and man oh man, you've got yourself uh a beautiful thing. Momentum.
SPEAKER_01Love it, yeah, love it. Yep, Keith. Thank you, my man. How can all the insurance dudes and dudettes check out what what my man Keith is doing on the interwebs?
SPEAKER_02I guess I would tell you, just hit me up. I'm on Facebook.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And we'll make sure to pass out your cell phone. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, just you know, actually make that real big. Yeah, yeah. Home home address too. Make sure you do that. Sure.
SPEAKER_01I'm actually gonna run a giveaway ad to your phone number. I think that's old school. See how many how much uh the leads will cost.
SPEAKER_02Please do. I was hoping that you were gonna suggest that. I wasn't gonna do it because I didn't want to come across as that guy, but thanks for doing that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. We'll do it, we'll split test two different ads, see how it works.
SPEAKER_02There you go. But it's my office and my home.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, let's see which one performs better. Thank you so much, Keith. It's awesome to have you. It's awesome to see you uh every week on the uh on the Elite Dudes call. Yeah, man. And uh, you're a great, great member of this community. So really great insurance, dude. Thank you. Great insurance, dude. And make sure to uh get Emily your home add literally your home address, and she'll email you, or she'll send you not email, she'll send you a shirt. We'll get you a new insurance dude shirt. Okay, we'll do you need a hat too. I do. Oh, and a hat. Let's do it. Yeah, let's do it. Let's do it. The new hat. Geared out. Looks good.
SPEAKER_02All right. Well, that sounds awesome. Well, hey, thanks for having me on, guys. It was a pleasure. I'd love to do it again with you. Thank you, my man. Loved it.
SPEAKER_01Awesome. Good stuff.
SPEAKER_02Thanks, guys. Thanks for y'all.
SPEAKER_01Have a good one.
SPEAKER_02Bye.
SPEAKER_01Hey, what are you still doing here? Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, if you weren't listening before, we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01Using these strategies did help Craig and I write over 10 million in premium in the last couple years.
SPEAKER_00And let me tell you, on this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same results.
SPEAKER_01Again, that's live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_00And if you jump on with us, we are certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman