The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Jason Killings It! King Of Florida Part 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
What do you think some of the biggest changes affecting our agencies in the next couple years?
SPEAKER_03I think there's a few. One is people going direct, right? I think that that's going to be more and more of an issue.
SPEAKER_01Insurance dudes are autistic to escape being hidden by our agency. How? By uncovering the secrets to creating a predictable, consistent, and profitable agency sales achievement. I am Craig Futzinger. I am Jason Feltman. We are agents. We are insurance dudes.
SPEAKER_02Right now, while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_04We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_02Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years. On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results. Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_04If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you.
SPEAKER_02See you there. I'm pretty sure I know the answer to this, but how important are referrals to your agency?
SPEAKER_03Huge, huge. We've been open for 31 years. So yeah, yeah. We're in a pretty affluent area uh of Miami called Coral Gables. So, you know, the name recognition's there. Our clients love us. Some of them have been with us for 20, 25 years. Their kids have grown up and been with us. So wow. So referrals are huge. And then the other thing, since we're so big on property, is we we work with a lot of uh realtors, realtors and mortgage brokers. Oh, you know, with them, they just want to they want to sell the house or issue the mortgage and move on. So if you're efficient and you keep them happy, they'll just keep sending them your way. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02What are some tips for that to keep them happy and the and to create those partnerships?
SPEAKER_03The biggest thing, and I was actually gonna supposed to meet with uh a mortgage broker tomorrow, is the first thing is just like any sale, talk about their need. So are they working with someone now and what's their pain points? And usually it's the same thing. Like I send a quote, sometimes I don't get it back for two or three days. So what we do is we have an individual who works directly with that mortgage broker or realtor. So that's that's the first thing. So that there's this one-on-one interaction and they're kind of ping-ponging stuff off each other, and then if there's an issue or that person's out, then you know obviously the office manager can uh can get in. Second thing is get those quotes out quick. Even if you don't have all the information, if you know maybe whether or not they have an alarm or they're in a gated community, you don't have that, send out the quote and say this quote's based on X, Y, and Z. Right. They they just need something to start the mortgage process, right? Or or for the buyer to have a rough idea of what their expenses are gonna be. So get it to them quick. That's the first thing, and then and you can predicate it. You know, this is based on X, Y, and Z.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_03Um, and then they're happy.
SPEAKER_04So that that speaks to the whole the whole thing of having the capacity, right? You could go cheap, try to run lean, but then if you can't get back to realtor or a load officer for three days because there just isn't enough time of the day to pump out the quotes, that's gonna be so much more costly, yeah, right? Losing that opportunity and potentially getting a bad reputation for not even being able to provide business than it would be to pay somebody to be you know Johnny on the spot on that thing.
SPEAKER_03Exactly. Yeah, don't hire for the need when you see it. You have to hire for what you anticipate happening.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, always ahead. It's always like a little bit ahead, like, okay, can I afford it? Not really, but I probably should then do it. You've got to, right? It's almost like most decisions that we make to be really successful in this business, we're not ready for and we can't afford. Yeah. Right? Right. And you but you have to do it because it to in a month when we lose premium because we're not growing, we're even less ready and even less uh able to afford it.
SPEAKER_03Yep, exactly right. And that that was one of the things, you know, before I kind of ran the show here, there was a program, a food truck program. And as a sales producer, I was like, ooh, this is this is enticing, right? Annual commercial policies plus a general liability policy and an in the marine, like I'm gonna round out this account. Like, this is this is nice. Well, you know, me as the sales guy, I want gangbusters. I think I did 300 food trucks in a year. I set the record. Wow, subsequently got non-renewed, but that's part of the business, right? But but but talking about capacity, so I I oversold. So I went out there and I sold over 300 of these, but what do they need? They need certificates, they go to events. Every event needs a certificate of insurance. And we we learned the hard way that, like, you know, okay, Jason did his job. Like, who's gonna be behind him to get all these certs out for all these parks and colleges and cities?
SPEAKER_04And yeah. I remember, yeah, young, young in my career. I was like, I thought, oh yeah, commercial's huge because the premiums are great and all this. And they started selling a few deals, and the amount of service required for some of these, like a like a big commercial policy, like a contract general contractor, yeah, that you know goes and is doing work on a hospital and has all these subcontractors. It was like, oh man, and I am in Adobe trying to create these primary non-contributory weight room subrogation. Yeah, and you just oh, you miss the letter here, and you have to redo the whole thing. It's just oh yeah. So so yeah. Also know what you can do from a service standpoint or what the requirements are, huh?
SPEAKER_03Yep, absolutely, yeah. Just kind of map it all out, yeah.
SPEAKER_04And again, we talk about this a lot, is it's it's good to be narrow and deep instead of being the uh jack of all trades, right? Because then you're the master of none. So that speaks to the client, right? Servicing that client, bringing on that new client. How does that onboarding look for a new client? And what do you do to create the optimal client experience? So they want to keep renewing and renewing and renewing.
SPEAKER_03Good question. So there's a couple things. One is we both on the phone and via email, tell them exactly what the process is, what documents they need to sign, how they need to sign them, who's gonna handle the cancellation of their old insurance. We typically take that that on. We take that burden on because we we see there's a value add there because that other, you know, the incumbent's gonna try to keep them. So, you know, we're very transparent on the phone and then we back it up with an email on what the next steps are. And then what we also do is we have one service person who follows up just to make sure all those documents are in. So we don't run into compliance issues or you know, now with telematics being uh a bigger thing with a lot of the auto carriers, making sure that they did that right, whether it's plugging in a device or downloading an app on their phone, and then the first renewal, we're very, very diligent on reaching out to them and just making sure they're they're happy and discussing any potential rate changes. And then at that point, if we didn't cross-sell it at point of sale, you know, hey, by the way, have you thought about the life insurance or your homeowner's insurance or your neighbors? You know, we were able to help you. I'm sure we can help them, and then we and we do that all the way pretty much through.
SPEAKER_02Love that. And then I'm sure that helps with retention. Besides that awesome onboarding experience, what else are you doing to help increase that retention?
SPEAKER_03So that's probably the biggest thing we do in the beginning. Then the other thing is just impeccable service. So, like, even on if you look at like our web pages and our reviews, they're very, very positive, like probably almost a little overkill because we are so attentive to their needs. These people don't wait. If they need something, we get it to them right away, whether it's a mortgage change or a car change. We just show them that we care and that if they took the time to reach out to us, we're gonna stop and take that time to uh to do what they need. So that's that's a really big thing that we pride ourselves on.
SPEAKER_02How did you instill that on such a large team?
SPEAKER_03It's just a culture thing, and I remind them even the most difficult client pays their bill, and that bill allows us to pay you and keep these lights on, you know. So take the time to just do it right. And if you do it right, you do it once. If you do it wrong, you end up doing it twice. So, and I remind them that all the time, and it resonates with them, and just teaching from the beginning like this is our process, this is why we do it this way. Like, you know, I was in aviation, so we used to say that every rule was written in blood, right? Like somebody made a mistake that caused something bad to happen. Yeah, well, every process we have in this office is because we probably did it a more inefficient way in the past, and we came up with this.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I love that. Those processes are so critical to running a smooth organization, especially as you grow and you're at this at the level you are with 15 people. You can't have everybody doing everything a different way.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, there has to be continuity through the organization. Has to be.
SPEAKER_04So, how about you? Besides listening to this most important podcast, how do you keep yourself motivated?
SPEAKER_03Uh I I think I've just always kind of been a type A person.
SPEAKER_04Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_03And you know, my reputation means a lot to me. So I'm just I just never slowed down or bump the brakes at all. And right, I think part of it's like fear too, right? Like, so 15 years in, highly successful agent, you know, people know who I am. It's like you don't that you don't want people to catch a slipping, you know? You don't want to fall off. And then the thing that always scared me, probably slightly subconsciously, is it's like a freight train, right? Like when you're going and you're doing 60 miles an hour, it's awesome. But if you scale back and now you're doing 20, it takes a while to get back up to speed. Yeah. So I've always felt like it's just better to stay at 60.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. I love that. Momentum.
SPEAKER_03Just keep the momentum.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. This business is so interesting because of the tail, right? So if you go down to 20, right, you go from 60 miles an hour to 20 miles an hour, you don't notice a difference today or tomorrow, or the next day, or the day after. But in a month, all of a sudden, you do. Yep. And then, like you said, to ramp back up to 60, you don't just turn it back on because now you're going to wait another month for it to get better or even longer.
SPEAKER_03Exactly. And then this and then to see the results even you know, even longer than that. Like if you try to start going, you don't even know for another 30 days if your plan even worked.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_02Yep. Yeah. 100%. 100%. What do you think some of the biggest changes affecting our agencies in the next couple years?
SPEAKER_03I think there's a few. One is people going direct, right? I think that that's going to be more and more of an issue. I think that, especially with the more simpler type policies, right? Like maybe even auto. If we don't explain it right and create a value, people are just going to go to comparative raters or go to direct carriers. And there's there's a potential there that we go the and I was actually talking to my partner about that yesterday. Like, if we don't do our jobs well, we're gonna go the way of the travel agent. Yeah, right. Like, like, think about it from like the 40s up until the 90s, the travel agent was how you booked a vacation, right? How you coordinated your flight and your Disney tickets and the rental car and the hotel. And now every single one of us pretty much does it online on our own, right?
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_03So so we really have to be a value add to the consumer so that they want to talk to us.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_03That's one thing. And they're still travel agents, right? There's just less of them because some of them, some of them adapted and figured out a way to be a value ad. That's one thing that I that I'm keeping an eye on that I'm constantly you know cognizant of. The second thing is automation. There's technology that's available, something a lot of it that we take advantage of that um is going to help us automate a lot of the more mundane processes that we may have maybe have a person doing right now. So I think automation is is the second value where you keep that personalized touch, you can keep that value added by staying in contact, but uh you also automate some of the more rote processes that we that we do in an agency.
SPEAKER_04Love that. Yeah. Could you give an example of that?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so so just one example is the renewals, right?
SPEAKER_04Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_03So just envision, and we'll talk about property for a second, because if you're a captive auto, you're kind of limited. But say property. I know in Florida there's a lot of turmoil, there's a lot of rate increases. So, you know, we can automate a renewal email and even a comparative rater showing that listen, we know that X policy went up, but it's going up everywhere. Here's three other options that either give you less comprehensive coverage, maybe they cap water damage, or they're more expensive, or they're not offering you the level of liability that you have. So, you know, here's everything. If you want to make the jump, give me a call. We can talk about next steps. But I strongly recommend you keep what you have. Like, imagine just automating that. So not just uh not just the here's your renewal, but here's the work I did for you before I talked about that renewal.
SPEAKER_02Right. It's huge.
SPEAKER_04Definitely.
SPEAKER_02It's almost like beating them to the punch of shopping. It's like I'm gonna do this for you and prove that no matter what, I got you. It's not even giving them the the ability to go out and do that for themselves.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. And that's one of the things that that I teach my people from the beginning. I let them make this mistake because everyone always does it in the beginning, and then I I let them do it, and then I talk to them about why that's probably not the best idea. So, you know, let's talk about you know a mortgage broker referral, right? And they're buying a house, homeowner's insurance is expensive here. So you send them the best quote. All they see is that one number, right? And there might be some sticker shock there. Now you have to explain why you sent them that. Every person does it on their first deal, and I let them do it because I know it's gonna happen, and then I walk them back and I go, You quoted it with how many carriers? I quoted them with 10. Show them all 10.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, right. So that there are no other options.
SPEAKER_03It's like, okay, well, everything is right here. Exactly. If you show them 10, they know you shopped it for them, so there's no reason for them to shop on their own.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I love that, and and the learning by doing, and and it does seem to constantly repeat itself. I just had one of my I have a couple new producers, and this happens every time. I I think we'd all be nodding our heads here where they go, I just got one, and they they hang up the phone and you're like, Oh, okay, did you get payment information and you bind it? Oh, well, no, they're gonna they're gonna do it tomorrow, but they but they're a hundred percent in. And I'm like, okay, I'll believe you tomorrow. So let's circle back tomorrow. We'll talk about that when. And then inevitably, they didn't get a hold of them the next day. Yep, right? Yep, exactly. So you have to help them learn that they need like if that person is a hundred percent, then you need to get that payment information. You need to bind it, it needs to be done because nothing's gonna happen tomorrow. We're not gonna ever get a hold of them again, right? It's gonna be another 30, 60, 90 days exactly a hold of them.
SPEAKER_03Yep, the hardest part is to just get them on the line. You had a captive audience, right? They told you they liked it. Like, yes, what are we waiting for? I I'm actually it's funny as said that I'm working on that now in our sales CRM system where we have call scoring, right? So there's like a script in there, and not only does it gauge how well they follow the script, but it also gauges how well they overcome objections and ask for the sale because so often you see people like, okay, here's the number. It's like I tell them it's like uh order taking, it's like Burger King, right? Like you have it your way. They want a quote, you give them the price, and then there's like this pause where it's like, do they like it or not? Right. And it's like, guys, like ask for the sale, create a value, talk about property damage or what you did about rental car and rental car prices being through the roof, and then ask for the payment. Like, don't be afraid.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, we were just talking about that on the elite dudes call by saying, and it's 245 a month, then stopping. That's not a close. Nope. Right? It's 240. Hey, Jason, it's it's gonna be 245 a month. Like that that's not a close. It's 245 a month. All I need is your accounted routing. Who do you bank with? Then shut up. Exactly. Yep, you have to just push it. It's like there's they're right on the one inch line and they don't want to punch it into the end zone, you know. Yeah, it's this fear of hearing no, but it's already a no if you don't ask.
SPEAKER_03Yep, exactly right. It's like the you know, Seahawks with Marshawn Lynch in the Super Bowl a couple years ago. Yeah, it's like you're there, just you're there, get it. You know.
SPEAKER_04So you yeah, you brought up the CRM lead volt, right?
SPEAKER_03Yep, yep, that's it.
SPEAKER_04Talk a little bit about that. I'd love to hear about that and and have the listeners hear a little bit about that.
SPEAKER_03Sure. So, yeah, so you know, years ago I was using uh a CRM system that got bought by another company and they kind of pivoted to uh different vertical like mortgages. Um and then I I left there and I started using another another competitor, and I realized that by the time I spent with their customer service and trying to customize their system, um, I didn't have a positive customer experience, right? So I'm just I kind of got upset and I'm like, instead of fixing their system to work towards me, I decided to build my own system with you know our agency best practices and to make it licensable so that other agents could benefit from it as well. So that was uh that was the hard way to get an easy result, right? Like it took about a year of programming and then another year of uh beta testing it inside my office. Um, but it's working well, really, really well. We increased our production this year by about 42% uh in new business. So wow, so it was worth it. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04So what kind of stuff can it do?
SPEAKER_03So it does a lot, it has automation with regards to like email drip, call prioritization with a local presence, two-way text communication. I've even set it up now, especially with a lot of this TCPA uh rules that are coming in. Like in Florida, there's a Florida TCPA on top of the federal TCPA. So you can customize to your state's rules how often you want to reach out to a person and for how long. So it keeps you on the right side of the law. You know, workflows are in there. One big thing that I noticed that a lot of the other systems didn't do is none of us have a hundred percent closing ratio, right? Like it just doesn't happen. But what are we doing for the follow-up? Like, we know what kind of cars they have for sure, we know who their real carrier is and not what they put on the internet lead. And once we do a quote, we know when their policy is expiring. So, what are we doing using automation to reach back out to them before they shop again in three or six months?
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_03So, so like one of the things that I built in our system is a disposition window where our staff puts all that info in. And if they don't close the deal, which it's gonna happen, the system says, Hey, your policy's coming up for renewal in 30 days. We should have another look.
SPEAKER_04I mean, to have that go out automatically is huge.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, tremendous, you know, and that's built in from the from the get-go. So that's some of the key features that we that we built in there. Another thing that I built that we had added down the road was during COVID, I'm like, okay, so you know, this person is at home and this person's in the office, and I would email sometimes, or they're doing a quotes, they don't see the email. I'm gonna build like an internal community text messaging communication system right within the the lead system so all of us can communicate with each other right inside lead vault. So even our dudette, if she gets a live lead and maybe one person's already doing a quote, another person's at lunch, she can just send a message to there, and then whoever's available can pop up and say, Give it to me, I'll work it.
SPEAKER_04Boom. Yep, and then that one off sleeping at lunchtime loses out. Exactly.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. Shame on them for eating.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, what are they what do they think they're doing? Didn't they say didn't uh Gordon Gecko say that lunch is for wimps? Yeah, well, that's great. Where can people learn more about it? Is that leadvolt.com?
SPEAKER_03Yep, it's just leadvolt.com, uh L-E-A-D-V-L-T, and they can you know schedule a demo. The the website shows a lot of the features that we've built in there, and then there's more to come. Like I'm not we're not stopping.
SPEAKER_04So love it. I love that. So moving along, what would be your number one recommendation to anybody crazy enough to be in this business, get in this business moving forward? That would make the biggest impact for them and their agency.
SPEAKER_03I'd say you have you have to have passion, yeah, you have to love it, and not just the insurance itself, but just kind of the game of business, right? Like figuring stuff out, building out processes, training people, like you have to love it's like being a football player, right? You can't just love catching the touchdowns on Sunday. You have to love running your routes in practice, hanging out with your teammates in the locker room, like just have passion within anything that you do. The rest will work itself out. But if you have passion, and this is a business that you want with residual income and a steady stream, just go in, but dive, dive all the way.
SPEAKER_04Right. You got to go yeah, can't have one leg and one and another leg out.
SPEAKER_02Passion, super awesome. Jason Killings. This has been incredible. Dropping knowledge nuggets all over here. How can all the insurance dudes and dudettes out there find out what you're up to, learn about Lead Volt and everything in your world?
SPEAKER_03Sure, sure. So I'm on Facebook, I'm on the uh insurance dudes group page. You can reach out to me there. Um, you can email me, you know, at jason at leadvolt.com. I'll even I'll even give everyone my cell phone. They can feel free to text me. I love insurance and I love talking about it. I love picking other people's brains. So insurance is my life.
SPEAKER_04So as they walk past the subscribe button for the podcast and then pass the subscribe button to the YouTube channel for the insurance dudes, then they head over to Lead Vault or the insurance dudes group and and shoot you a message. Is that what you're saying?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Yeah, they can go to Lead Vault and schedule a demo. They can email me at jason at leadvault.com or even send me a text on my cell. It's uh and I'll give it to you guys.
SPEAKER_04It's you're crazy.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I don't think so. I don't know. Do it, do it. Let's see. Yeah, it's uh 631-839-7345.
SPEAKER_04Nice. Well, Jason, is it safe to say that you're killings it?
SPEAKER_03I like that, Craig. That is a first. I like that.
SPEAKER_02Dude, that is the title of this episode is Jason Killings It.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that's it. Just drop it and then have like a mic, a mic, and an arrow down. Nice. Well, man, thank you so much for coming on. Hang around, we'll we'll chat a little bit after, but uh, we really had a great time. And uh I'll speak for myself. I had a great time.
SPEAKER_03I had a fantastic day.
SPEAKER_04It was perfect. Yeah, awesome. Well, thanks for coming on, and we'll see you down the road.
SPEAKER_03Sounds great. Thanks, guys. Uh huh.
SPEAKER_02Hey, what are you still doing here? Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, if you weren't listening before, we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_02Using these strategies did help Craig and I write over 10 million in premium in the last couple years.
SPEAKER_04And let me tell you, on this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same results.
SPEAKER_02Again, that's live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_04And if you jump on with us, we are certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman