The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Mike Monaghan Insurance Man… If He Can’t Do It No One Can! PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
What is your number one recommendation to any agent to do right now that can make the biggest impact in their agency moving forward?
SPEAKER_03I find that the person can sit there and plan and get everything dialed in is not going to be anywhere near as good as someone that's IRA.
SPEAKER_02I are I am A. We are agreed.
SPEAKER_01We are interested. Right now, while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_00We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years. On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results. Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us. If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you.
SPEAKER_00See you there. What's your favorite paid lead source?
SPEAKER_03Favorite paid lead source, the hottest one at the moment. I mean, uh, I think I think you always have to kind of keep checking. Um Everquote's been doing really, really good for me lately. I'd like to do some ILBs, but I'm in Ohio and uh my boy George. Mr. George. Mr. George, we actually went through training the same time. He just is a lot smarter than I am and uh got introduced to you guys a lot uh earlier than I did. And he is just a tenacious force of nature. And um he really is, and and the fact that he came from the corporate side of things, yeah, so he obviously has a leg up, and I'm around here still trying to figure out how to run a business and sell and do all that stuff, he had it not dialed in and he's off to the races.
SPEAKER_00So, you know so yeah, interesting thing about George is so he was client number one, yeah, and he came in and we didn't, you know, COVID hate came and and all that, and we were really at that point, you know, just Jason and I were doing well, and everybody's asking us, what what are you gonna, you know, what are you doing, this and that. And and then he came to us, he said, Hey, I wanna I want to do this, but I want to get I think he got eight. I want to say two. No, we got four. Four was it four? Okay, so he started like I did, and we're like, oh boy, and then very quickly though, he moved to eight or ten or whatever it was. He moved it up really quick, and we're like, dude, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, settle down. And he goes, Look, I worked on the corporate side, I would go into all these agencies every day before COVID when you could when you would go into agencies, and he's like, I saw what the guys that are crushing are doing, and I mean, I'm not gonna wait. Why wait?
SPEAKER_01You know, there's yeah, we we actually try to talk him out of it, so he got four right off the bat, and we're like, dude, it's just a lot of spend right off the bat. Most people, I mean, a kind of a kick to the gut if if oh yeah, start off that way, the first couple weeks are gonna be uh a little bit slower. So we try to talk him off of it, but he's like, No, no, no, I want to do this. I want to okay, okay, well, we'll help you. Um, he was on every uh every weekly meeting, and man, he just what an implementer.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, absolutely. And uh, you know, success leaves clues, and uh, you know, I'm just trying to trying to snoop around you guys and pick up a few things.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think it's kind of it's almost this opposite, you have to kind of uh the contrarian approach, right? Most people in the in the market they don't make money in the stock market because they sell when it's low and they buy when it's high, it's high, right? And so the same thing. He went in, he got more than most people would be comfortable with. When he saw, oh, I'm not getting enough, he didn't say, Oh, this doesn't work. He knew it worked because he'd seen it work and he said, I want more. And then he pushed, and then once once everything bakes, you get to the middle of the bell curve, boom, right? It just took off, and now he's past us, and he's yeah, he's he's an animal.
SPEAKER_03Get getting another getting another agency. I just uh you know, I know.
SPEAKER_00Well he's got that fat Michigan premium coming in now, so that's that's very helpful.
SPEAKER_03You know, he's younger than me, but I want to grow up and be like him someday. Exactly. Um, I'm getting another teledude fired up next week. Um, yeah, so again, like I said, I want these phones to just ring off the hook, and and you don't do that by continuing to play tiddly wings. Right.
SPEAKER_00It's just we talked about it with uh David DuFord on the previous uh interview where it's this having the abundance mentality instead of the scarcity, where it's like, look, I'm not gonna count and go, oh my gosh, we missed one. It's like, no, just I'd rather have too many and we're gonna get back to them, right? You're eventually gonna circle back. They're your bird dog, they're finding them. So it's just cool breaking free of that because I certainly had scarcity mentality and counted every little penny and worried about this and that. And once you let that go, yeah, it just opens up.
SPEAKER_01I think everybody, I mean, everybody does or should at some point. I mean, sure. No one goes into this willy-nilly. I mean, there's a lot of money to buy an agency or to all of it, you know what I mean? It's yeah, you're betting big, you're playing at the big dog's table, you know. It's not like yeah, some other businesses where you don't have the bet big, but but but with good information, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, or you just have your next door neighbor who's your all state agent who now works for corporate, say, Hey, you should buy an agency and go, why not?
SPEAKER_00Sounds like a good idea.
SPEAKER_03Sounds like a good idea, why not? You know? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01There is a version of that story for everybody, though. It's like it's so funny. That's why we always ask people like, how did you get into the industry? It's most of the time you're doing something, and either friends or family's like, hey man, why don't you try this? It's like, huh? I never even thought about that. And then insurance gets the ball, it gets the ball rolling.
SPEAKER_03And yeah, my and my thing was is I was looking at businesses to purchase because I knew I didn't want to be I didn't want to work for anybody else anymore. And uh, you know, I'm kind of a closeted computer geek, and I was looking at managed services business, and my buddy said, Yeah, just buy an agency. I mean, you have the background, it just makes better more sense to you. And yeah, and and it did, but you know, it's you know, people can't go into business for themselves unless they're ready to work hard. Yeah, and that's and that's okay. And that's okay. At least for a while.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Everybody sees the end product and they think that owning a business is easy, but it's like you're wearing twice as many hats. I don't care if you were a manager somewhere else, you're wearing the manager hat, the employee hat, the owner hat. I mean, you're and you're wearing them all throughout the day and switching hats. Yeah, there's a lot at first.
SPEAKER_03I just fixed I just fixed the sink in the break room. I mean, yeah. Uh right. You gotta you gotta get that done.
SPEAKER_00It is amazing, all those different hats, and and the so many things that you learn doing this too, like not just like you're learning things, but you're also learning things about yourself. Talking about I don't did we talk about it on here or before was the the ups and downs. Like I've learned a ton about myself and handling those ups and downs and really being aware of it. Like, you know, Jason will be talking, he'll go, Wow, you really are pretty aware of what you do. I'm like, Yeah, well, I'm trying to work on that, you know, and yep, and just like and it is there's this duality. Good salespeople are somewhat of an empath, right? Like you you can feel the other people's emotions, that's what makes you good at it, is being able to connect, but then that could, you know, when the ups and downs, that also can affect a lot. So you have to be able to it's balance, right? A thousand percent.
SPEAKER_03And it's very it could go very poorly for people that don't, you know. That's why I just I just keep myself as busy as humanly possible so I can't get myself into trouble.
SPEAKER_00Right. I love that you just use it for me. We just doubled up. Um I said that's why that's why I don't drink because that that can uh go down the rabbit hole. And then he loves that you used a thousand percent because that's his favorite thing.
SPEAKER_01I just started doing that. Yeah, I 10x the 100%.
SPEAKER_00But yeah, I 10x'd his 1000, I say 10,000. We've gotten into some really high percentages. Yeah. He he 10x my 10,000 yesterday.
SPEAKER_03You can't you can't double stamp a triple stamp.
SPEAKER_00Right, right. Unless you quadruple stamp it, but we do every day.
SPEAKER_03Every day. I'm in here quadruple stamping stuff. Nice.
SPEAKER_01Love it. Okay, so back to so okay, we we talked about leads. Are you doing anything right now for referrals for your agency?
SPEAKER_03Am I doing anything for referrals? Yeah, I mean kind of a referral program or I mean yeah, we'll friends and family send them a gift card and a thank you. Obviously, referrals are the big part of the business. Uh, my big thing is I just I train everybody to ask. You know, when you're onboarding it's uh somebody, it's it's fresh, it's new, it's exciting. Well, it's time to ask them who they can help and ask them for sp specific people. And hey, if we find somebody that uh you know that'll say yeah, we can talk to them. Hey, we'll even give you a little Amazon or uh gift card. Do you like Starbucks? Hey, thanks. You know, nothing crazy, but I think the biggest thing is is just to ask. I mean, and you train that to, you know, hey, I want you to ask them for a referral, and I want you to ask them where do they have their life insurance outside of work? Because again, my background is life insurance and and investments. I really want to get to the point where in my agency I can just do that part of the part of the business and you know, have the the property and casualty side kind of run by uh a manager, and I can just come back to just being an advisor for folks, even though some people don't like us to use that term, and I don't understand that because I give advice all day. Right.
SPEAKER_00You know, another thing that just the with the referrals, even if somebody doesn't have like maybe the resources aren't there to be sending out Amazon cards or sure or some little some little gimme, a handwritten thank you card goes uh 10 million miles.
SPEAKER_03Absolutely. I give everybody when they get hired, they get a stack of cards, whether of uh greeting cards, and and they're blank, so it's either a thank you card or a referral card or a sympathy card or you know, whatever. I mean, it's like just drop a note. I know your penmanship is horrible, but just drop a note.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03I don't know if the young kids are still, you know, if the the the under 20 somethings feel that way, but you know, they'll probably like, what is this thing? But I don't know.
SPEAKER_00What's a pen? Yeah, but but it's remarkable because you do not get very many handwritten anything anymore.
SPEAKER_03Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00And I mean, everybody that listens to this has heard me talk about Randy at Tiffany. The amount of jewelry that has been purchased because of his handwritten thank you card is remarkable. So it goes a long way. I like it. It goes a long way. What about new clients? When you when you bring somebody on, they purchase with you, they trust you to be their. I can't use that A word, I don't think. Yeah, trust you to be that that professional who's gonna help them with their insurance. Wow. Uh what does that look like? Is there is there a process behind that? Or is it just adios? Uh what what happens?
SPEAKER_03Completely Lord of the Flies. It's crazy down here. No, I mean, yeah, the pr the process is if it's one of my team that get gets them on boarded, you're obviously getting all the information up front, depending on when their policies start, is when you're following up on making sure the the documents are any uh outstanding documents are collected and things like that. And my goal is is is is once a week, generally on Fridays, to make uh at least welcome calls myself to say, hello, leave a message if you ever need anything, you know, or if I talk to them, you know, kind of oh, you love so and so. Yeah, they're great. I'm glad they're on the team. I'm glad you're a part of the family. If you ever need anything, don't hesitate to reach out and just have those those kind of calls. And there's obviously we want to send out thank you notes to hey, thank you for your business, put in a business card and ask for referrals and kind of go from there. That's lather, rinse, repeat. That's kind of the process.
SPEAKER_01Love it. Love it. So what do you do for retention? Do you focus on that at all, or uh is there anything that you can recommend that that maybe you do for retention?
SPEAKER_03Again, I I don't think it's scalable. Uh, and as I get bigger, I know that my hand personal involvement will be less, but I really try and get involved as much as I can to go through renewals and and talk with people. I do have my team make sure they get to their first renewal and and kind of handle that. And um it's part of their comp plan is to, you know, get them to their first renewal or you know, hey, they get there's some money coming back. But um again, our one of our mission statements here is to be our client's first and last call, to be someone that, hey man, I've got a question about whatever I'm gonna give I I'm gonna give Mike or whoever my agent is here a ring and just get their thoughts on it. And that's that's just kind of what we want to bring to the table for our clients is is someone that can, if not know the answer, get you the answer as quickly as possible. And uh a lot of people see value in that, and because that's the other than price thing, because that's what's so frustrating about especially the property and casualty businesses, is so many of the large carriers are racing themselves to the bottom by talking about how cheap, how cheap, how cheap. That's just right, you know, it it's doing everybody a disservice, but you know, that's why we talk about the extra stuff. And uh hopefully, hopefully it resonates with our clients and they want to stick around. And so far, that's one of my prouder metrics is is I I have a very good retention rate. Uh I want it to be better because again, I truly want them to be a part of the family. So yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Nice. I wish that some of the marketing out there would pivot away from the race to the bottom. Yeah. It just is pounding that message. There's only one way to continue to get cheaper.
SPEAKER_03Correct. And I and I don't like that way because it means I I have to make a pivot. Right.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and we certainly aren't going to be able to deliver on on what we're providing if there isn't enough dollars to to uh support it, right? And that's why some of these 800 numbers, you know, they you get some horror stories. And so it's important that we, you know, and it's like almost every conversation is unwinding that whole thing, you know, that the preconceived uh indoctrinated indoctrinated mentality that they have about uh insurance, right? Nobody wants to talk about it, they want it to be cheap, and you have to kind of uh you have to slow them down and unwind it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and that's why I would want national marketing for a lot of carriers, but there's one carrier in particular that's just got a bunch of a bunch of letters, and uh they do a great job of making it about being part of the club and being it a status symbol and being in the part of the in crowd. And I'm like, that's what it's supposed to be. I mean, that's what good branding does. And I don't know why smart people at other big carriers don't realize that.
SPEAKER_00Right. Be in the club, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Being in the club, it's yeah, dun, dunched the dun, dun, I mean, it's it's where you want to be.
SPEAKER_00Right. Yeah. There you are. So curious, we talked a little bit about motivating the team. Now, besides listening to this podcast, which I know is probably the number one motivator, how do you keep yourself motivated?
SPEAKER_03The podcast is a perfect time because my commute in is about the length of the podcast, so it's perfect. So it fits wonderfully into the schedule. How do you keep yourself motivated? I'll tell you one thing is avoid engaging with the negative people that are all they're you know, the guys and gals that just they just bitch about everything. I mean, right. And and oftentimes when you get that's one thing I like about the insurance dudes, the teledudes environment is there's not that. And because I always get nervous when I get into groups of people, groups like that. I'm like, all right, who's gonna be the negative Nelly that's just gonna pour ice water on everything all the time? But it's not like that. And I and I know the groups of people and the and the folks that I've been working with and talking to on those Wednesday calls have really generally been uplifting and helpful, not complaining about whatever this is going on or whatever that's going on, you know, the who moved my cheese type thing. Things are gonna happen, you know. Yeah, it's how we react to it is what makes us whether we're gonna be a winner or a loser. I mean, crap happens to everybody. So I mean, the biggest thing is just stay away from negative people and and look at my kids, you know. I mean my oldest will be 13 and my youngest will be nine, and you know, they go to Catholic school. That stuff's not cheap, man. So I gotta I gotta go, man.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, 20% are gonna create 80% of the results, right? And for the other 80% who are only getting 20% of the results, they're either gonna commiserate and complain and blame everybody else, or they're gonna figure out a way and they're gonna ascend, right? And put into that 20%. Because it's it's available, you can get there, but you there's gotta be some changes that have to be made. And I think it starts with the with the dude in the mirror.
SPEAKER_01Right. Speaking of change, what do you think are some of the biggest changes you that you see affecting our agencies in the next couple years?
SPEAKER_03Man, so many changes. There's a portion of the public that's always gonna want a person, an advisor. Oh, I said it, but someone to talk to, and you know, don't have to dial 1-800 and sit on sit in a uh and hold for however. So the good thing is I think that's always gonna be the case. But like I said, the thing that scares me is uh a lot of uh of carriers uh racing that price to the bottom. Who knows? I mean, uh more carriers may make people just be independent. You know, we've seen it with some big carriers that have turned their agents into independents. And if, you know, again, you just have to be able to be prepared for any of that. The great thing is the ability to communicate and engage with people on different levels is better than it's ever been. But I think it's a responsibility of the business owner to realize that you need to be able to engage with people how they want to be engaged with. And if some people are keyboard cowboys or cowgirls, you you know, you gotta email or text and do all that stuff. I'm more of a phone person, but you know, you have to be flexible and embrace the tools that come to you uh as they come and don't get all bent out of shape when things change because things are always gonna change. Yeah, it's just that it's just the winners figure out a way to change with it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yep. Man, what a phenomenal time here. Uh we're gonna dive into the last piece, which if you've been listening, then you know what it is. What is your number one recommendation to any agent to do right now that can make the biggest impact in their agency moving forward? Just do.
SPEAKER_03I mean, I find that a person can sit there and plan and get everything dialed in, is not gonna be anywhere near as good as someone that puts a plan together and goes. Just put the plan together and go. Course correct on the way. Nothing's ever gonna be perfect. You're gonna make a bad hire, you're gonna have a bad engagement with an employee, uh, you're gonna say the wrong thing to a client, you're gonna lose business. But the thing is, is you know, put together the time where you're working on your business, put your plan down and go. You know, oftentimes we have paralysis from analysis. I get stuck in that where I'm like, you know, I'm sitting here trying to figure everything out. Well, it's time to go. Because at the end of the day, we have to produce because we don't get paid until everybody else gets paid. So let's get it going. And that's why I like working with with this group is because it helps me give me the ability to work on the business and not necessarily in the business so I can scale. Uh, because again, that's that the way this business model is and the way the market is laying it out, you have to be grinding a lot more than you ever have. And a lot of carriers' compensations are based on people that are growing and not just sitting back and enjoying the the twilight years. Well, you either either sell your business or have people work under you that are still driving it.
SPEAKER_00So that's that's that's my goal. Yeah, throughout throughout history in business, anybody who's been successful or been at the top in the top five percent, one percent, whatever, they made decisions, they took action, and they created momentum. And that's precisely what you're saying there. And it's it's a hundred percent. It's maybe it's not necessarily building the plane as you're taking off, but close to it. Yeah, right.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, you're not gonna be putting in the last rivets as you're at the end of the runway. I I don't think that's a that's a good idea. Close. But close. I mean, yeah, you're filling the tires right at your at the beginning of the runway.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yep. I love we're going, we're going. Keep keep pressing the pump.
SPEAKER_03Harder. There we go.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So so Mike, how can all the insurance dudes or dudettes out there on the interwebs get a hold of you or or see a little bit about the the monogan empire that you're building?
SPEAKER_03Well, it's my only fans. No, I don't have an OnlyFans. Uh because good lord. Oh my gosh. Well, I guess people are kind of into middle-aged, overweight. No, but anyway. Um, no, uh, Monaghan and Monaghanan Associates uh were certainly on the Facebook. And um, heck, just if if you're ever in Dayton, just come on in, man. Just look me up, you know. I I try I try and get my name out there, but yeah, Monahan and Associates, and yeah, just look me up. And if you have a question you need help, answer is yes.
SPEAKER_00Love it. Thanks, Mike. What a great, yeah, what a great time. Thanks for for jumping in, and uh, we will uh we'll see you next week. Yeah, I appreciate you guys. Yeah, for sure.
SPEAKER_03Absolutely. Thanks so much. Thanks, buddy. Thank you, Mike.
SPEAKER_01Have a good one. Bye. Hey, what are you still doing here? Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, if you weren't listening before, we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01Using these strategies did help Craig and I write over 10 million in premium in the last couple years.
SPEAKER_00And let me tell you, on this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same results.
SPEAKER_01Again, that's live.teled.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_00And if you jump on with us, we are certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman