The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Mike Monaghan Insurance Man… If He Can’t Do It No One Can! PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
So the wildest thing that ever happened in my agency, well, I can't really share in this platform, but I'll tell you, I have uh security cameras uh on the front door and the back door, and I actually work in my office at reception. I kind of I'm one of those lead-from-the-front type people. And one day I'm I just sat down in my my chair very aggressively, and sure enough, I fell ass over Apple Cart right in the middle of the floor, and not one person in my office came to my aid and uh posted it on on the agency Facebook page because you know, I mean, it can happen to anybody, and and I'm sitting there laying there thinking about my life, thinking about why the heck did I do this. And I'm I'm sitting there, then it starts to think not one person's checked on me because I didn't fall gracefully, I didn't fall silently. It was not it was not something that would that people would not know happened. I mean, and and people are walking by the front of my agency, and uh nobody looks in. And eventually I kind of dust myself off and and I I sit back in the seat and uh again, no one really it wasn't spoken. But yeah, that that was interesting, that was fun, and um along with all the other ins and outs that you have in in the insurance business. But uh my name is Mike Monahan. Uh I own Monaghan and Associates in in Springboro, Ohio, and I'm an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_02I are inside. I am HRH.
SPEAKER_03We are insurance. Right now, while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_01We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_03Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years. On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results. Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_01If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
SPEAKER_03All right. Love it, Mike. Good story.
SPEAKER_00That is great. So I just wish, I wish on when I posted the video, I would have liked you know, Buddy Hackett. I would have loved to put his theme song to it because it's just a dead video with no, because it's a security camera, it doesn't have any sound or anything to it. And I'm like, man, I really need to sound track that thing. But uh Benny Hill? Yeah, Benny Hill. Yeah, not Buddy Hackett, Benny Hill. Yeah, that would be fantastic.
SPEAKER_03We'll have Envy do it. We'll and we'll post it in the Facebook group. We'll have Envy put the music to it. That'd be fantastic.
SPEAKER_01We'll uh make that moment infamous, or is it famous? I don't know.
SPEAKER_00I don't know either, but you gotta be able to laugh at yourself. You do.
SPEAKER_01That's great. I it is strange that nobody came to your aid.
SPEAKER_00It is strange, but they don't work here anymore.
SPEAKER_01Oh, well then there you go.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Well, not gonna work here anymore, is basically what's gonna happen. Oh, that's funny.
SPEAKER_01Not row, not row into the same direction.
SPEAKER_03No, no. So, Mike, we kind of dove into this ahead of time and then we stopped ourselves to start recording. But tell us how you got into this crazy business we know as the insurance business.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I lost a bet, really. Uh no, I went to school, got a degree in finance, and and right out of school went to work at Morgan Stanley because I'm an idiot and I didn't want to go work with my dad and and take over daddy's business, you know, like so many kids do these days. I said, I'm gonna do it myself, you know, because I think, yeah, I like to make things hard on myself. So yeah, I started in in October of 2000. The dot-com bubble burst, and then I uh fast forward, I find myself in the auto finance uh business, and I'm traveling across the country, going to dealerships, and my wife uh was pregnant with our firstborn, and you know, it kind of then we had a another kid, and I wasn't gonna see them very much because I'm traveling all the time, so I said, you know, I need to get back to kind of my roots and figure out, come back home. And uh my good buddy who was my insurance agent at the time uh told me about the opportunity of of buying a business here in the Dayton area, which is is Springboro. And uh yeah, I sunk a bunch of money into it and a couple of years later, now through COVID. So again, my timing is impeccable, you know. But uh the good thing, the good thing is with COVID though, you didn't have you didn't have people didn't have excuses, you know. Like it's not like I'm taking my kids to to soccer, we're not going anywhere. So we actually had one of our better months when it when when in Ohio there actually was a little bit of a lockdown for a little bit, but we had a great month that month, and it's just it's just like it like everything in this business, it's how you perceive it, you know. Right. So yeah. Yeah, so that's that's kind of how I got to where I am now.
SPEAKER_01Sure. And as long as you're not watching the narrative on the uh news, you actually could determine that things are actually doing pretty good because if our goal is to talk to as many people as possible and the phone is that tool, well, people were home, right? They didn't have anything better to do than answer the phone and and actually, all right. Well, I guess I'll do insurance because I normally say no, but I'm uh what else am I gonna do? What else am I gonna do? Right? It was a great time to get caught up on stuff, I think. Right. Um, but you know, this thing's a grind, it's it's tough being an agent. Take us back and and talk about your earliest win that really created that fuel. What was the fuel for your fire?
SPEAKER_00Oh man, the earliest win. Finally, I guess negotiating the purchase of the business was the first win. It was one of the 11th hour uh the seller uh kind of had cold feet and wanted to kind of change things up. So, you know, just getting that done was was definitely put some wind in my sails. And uh, you know, hiring the staff, getting things going, it's always good, you know. And I I enjoyed one of my first uh one of my first staff members helping them get through nose and hearing them say the things that we're training and talking about and saying, Man, this stuff actually works. I'm like, yeah, I mean, yeah, it does. So let's continue to try and do that. So that is the best.
SPEAKER_03I love that. Yeah, it's a lot of times us as agents, it's easy for us to be the heroes in the agency and and get the sales, but there's something about it when you when you can coach someone and then they overcome that, like whatever it may be, whatever might be their obstacle, they overcome it and it's like, wow, that works. And they're like, I don't know. There's some there's something about that that's uh super fulfilling. Absolutely. So what kind of team do you have? And uh what are their roles in the agency?
SPEAKER_00Small but mighty. Like many of us in the world, you just can't put a help wanted sign out there and go through it. So it's a constant recruitment process. Uh it's kind of like I don't work out, but I've heard you don't skip leg day. I mean, I haven't lifted a weight in anger since since the 90s when uh you know I was in high school. And uh so you can't skip leg day, you know, you always got to be recruiting. So right now I have two licensed uh staff members and myself. I'm certainly a player coach. My goal is to double that team in the first half of 22, and then to add two more by the second half of 2022, and uh, you know, get more teledudes dialed in and uh lighten up the phones because again, I just want to make this place just phones ringing off the hook, mass hysteria, dogs and cats living together. You know, that's kind of what I want. I like a high energy at the end of the day, everybody goes, Whoo, man, we had so much stuff going on. This was great. That's that's that's what we want. And and we're getting there. And like I said, I really like the the team that I've got. I just need more of them.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it I love the activity, right? Even with a smaller team, you can still feel it, right? When everything is everything is syncing and the phones are blowing up and and they're they're talking to people and doing quotes all day. It brings so much energy. And it sounds like you've created a really good culture there. And again, size doesn't matter when it comes to teams. And so talk about talk about that culture. Talk about the culture and and what you've done to foster that.
SPEAKER_00Man, I don't know. I just I like to enjoy the people I work with and uh I like to have a good time. Um I'm a little irreverent, and I've heard you talk about yourself, Greg. Uh you and I are very, very similar in the fact that the highs are very, very high and the lows can be very, very low. I'm manic, you know. Uh I I don't break things anymore. Um I'm well past that, you know. In my 20s, yes, phones got broken, uh, things got and then you just kind of seriously back up. But I believe in frank talk, accountability, but no hard feelings, you know. And it says, hey, yeah, that was that was a horrible call, but let's get them next time. Here are the things that you did good, here are the things that you didn't do good, let's let's move on. You know, I try and make it competitive and fun. You know, we play a poker game every week when uh when everybody has at least five homeowners quotes. Uh that could they every homeowner's bundled homeowners quote, you get a card, and we play a game of poker. And whoever whoever gets the best poker hand uh is is you know gets a hundred bucks. If everybody plays, uh the winner gets 200 bucks, you know, and just doing different types of things. And Fridays are movie day, so we'll watch a we'll have a movie on in the office while we're grinding because I know you guys uh love uh movies and uh I like to show these young guys some good movies because I got one guy in my office that never watches anything, nothing. If I name a movie, you tell me a movie, he doesn't know what it is, so we have to watch movies for him.
SPEAKER_01So that total tangent, but with with that well, no, I mean I think it's just so interesting because you know we're all in in an older bracket than than a lot of the workers that that we bring on, the sales folks. And what an opportunity to share some of the really cool movies that we've seen, right? Because I don't think they make anything close to like what used to be made, you know. Yeah, so I I don't know why Ferris Bueller keys come to my mind, but you know, like Ferris or Fletch or all these great like late 80s, early 90s movies are just so solid.
SPEAKER_03Put it on underheals, yeah. Put it on the underheals tab. Could you actually suggest somebody watch Fletch? Fletch is phenomenal. Absolutely. Okay. It's just there's definitely some stuff in there that um they wouldn't re-record.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely not. I give you a perfect example. My wife and I will watch we'll watch movies with our kids, like um movies that are completely innocuous to us when we were kids in the in the 80s. And we are watching it, the bad news bears with my then 10-year-old daughter, and I think uh my youngest was six at the time or something like that. And yeah, uh Bad News Bears with Walter Mouth out. Nope, you're gonna hard pass on that, brother, because it yeah, it got dicey real quick.
SPEAKER_01Oh yeah. Cannot show that at the office or you're canceled. No, no, no.
SPEAKER_00Well, and the other thing is if you hire the right folks on your team, you know, yeah, like we always say when we're talking, do you like the person that's sitting across the sure across the table from you? And uh, you know, yeah, can't have you can't have thin skin in this business.
SPEAKER_01No, and we do have the ability to kind of create our environment, and if we have to build something that is gonna be comfortable for everybody.
SPEAKER_03Yep. So how do you bring in new people into the office? Where do you find them?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I've I've listened to you guys now. A gorilla suit running through the parking lot with a with a good way to do it, a board, a board on me. Uh, you know, again, it can't be a passive thing anymore. Uh I you know, and and being caught up as a player coach, I spend way too much time working in the business, as you guys hear from a lot of people, and that's the biggest struggle with agents as they're trying to scale, is I'm still binding contracts, I'm still taking phone calls from folks because a big part of what I sell at Monaghan and Associates is me and that personal touch. And hey, I'm here to help you. If you need anything, call. Well, that that's great and all, but it is hard to scale that. And the recruitment thing is is reaching out and really uh talking to people in the service industry. I don't believe in hiring in people that have current insurance experience. I'd rather bring them in fresh, new, as long as they have the want-to and uh the drive, we can do everything else. So heck, reaching out to marketing teachers at schools, high schools, and colleges. I mean, just be you know, obviously you don't need a college degree to do this. You just have to be very, very smart, get your licenses and learn. So as long as they have drive, we're going after it. And diving into, you know, looking at resumes and and really trying to recruit people myself versus passively just, hey, here's a job posting, taking what I get.
SPEAKER_01Right. Yeah, that whole wait until you have to hire somebody. Nope. Um, and I know everybody listening has at some point done it, and I myself included, Jason also, that sets up the cycle of uh a lot of problems, right? Absolutely. Because then it's desperation, and we know what happens with that. So always be recruiting, so so powerful to uh to as a takeaway on that. Now you bring them on, so they they're a fit. You figure, okay, I'm gonna take a chance, we're gonna get we're gonna bring this person on. What does that look like? What do you do on that first day to really make sure they're gonna be successful?
SPEAKER_00Man, and and I'll tell you what, I I've had a run of unsuccessful hires, so I I so it's I gotta dig back, I gotta go back into my uh memory banks to really get a good one. But uh no, I mean the process is always the process. Like I said, I work in what I call the bullpen in my uh the fishbowl in my in my office. So I work out front, and it's an area with three workstations, and whenever someone's new, they work with me for at least the first two months, like sitting literally right next to me. And you know, we dive into I'm their Google for a month, if that if it makes sense. And so just to kind of bring them on, and we're you know, I'm making outbound calls, I'm listening to their calls. They they're sitting three feet from me. So that first day, when I onboard somebody, they don't have their license. Uh so for that first month, they come in in the morning, they take two hours and study on on my dime, and then once they're done with their study session, then they're making I'm I'm training them on uh the CRM, they're making phone calls, and I'm paying them for every time they get somebody to agree to a quote. And so that way I can kind of see in that first month whether or not they're gonna be successful. And uh we're also doing some training throughout that process, and then their goal is by the end of that 30 days, they have to pass their test. I was like, I don't care how many times you take it, but you're passing it in 30 days, or you know, unfortunately, it's just not gonna work. I've had in the past let people go on and on and on. At the end of the day, they just don't work out. So, you know, hold people more accountable to the standard. That's something that I've learned in the short time, is is I gotta not be the nice guy. But yeah, that's usually what the first week, month looks like when they're onboarded here.
SPEAKER_03It's funny that that accountability factor is huge. You think you're being nice by you know, not setting things that might be too hard for this person or something, but in actuality, they don't know what you're thinking. So you know, we we talk about this a lot with our service team, is like setting those specific goals or like the specific tasks that need to be done by a specific deadline because they're guessing, they don't know when these things need to be done or not done. They're guessing and their interpretation is going to be totally different than yours. So I think there's a huge amount of wisdom behind that, especially when you bring someone on, they want to know, they want to feel comfortable knowing that they're doing a good job. So if you set those specific dates that they need to be done by, and even if they don't make it, maybe they'll make it a day later or something, but at least they feel comfortable. Like it's it it actually creates more security by uh putting out specifically what you expect. I love that. Uh what what types of things do you keep do to keep your team motivated? I love the hard game. That is that is so much fun to do.
SPEAKER_00But what yeah, we we play the card game. Sometimes we'll we'll just you know gamble a little bit around the office. It's like okay, do you I I've had months where I say, okay, it's it's me against you guys. So we'll take all the business that I write in the month versus you guys, and if any one of you beat me, I'll pay you all a certain amount, but if you all beat me, I'll pay you all more. So that also kind of helps keep me sharp because again, I like you know, I like engaging in and doing the sales part of this business because quite frankly, that's my background. I'm learning all the rest of the stuff. I could always do the sales part of things and the business development, but now it's you know it's learning the managing and running the business type stuff. So uh that's one of the fun things that we do to kind of keep it fun. And I'm trying to teach them how to how to play golf too. So we have a little putting set up. So we'll and when sometimes when we don't do uh poker, we'll do golf. And yeah, I don't have too many golfers here. So yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, putting's a little bit anybody can putt, right? Sort of.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I got I I probably should show you some videos of that too.
SPEAKER_01So uh back to training a little bit.
SPEAKER_00Build a guy.
SPEAKER_01Oh, you'll uh oh it's slippery slope. Slippery slope. Well, we'll keep you out of trouble on that. But what do you think is a really effective training tip that you've done that seems to work with folks and and seems to help them to get results?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think having a feedback with the people on how they like to learn, um but I find that most most people, not all, they like to kind of just jump in. And I can and I equate it to how you know I got my girls to jump off uh the diving board on the deep end. Well, I I would jump into the deep end and you tread water and you jump in here. I'm gonna do it with you. And I find that the most successful training is just let's just jump in the deep end and start swimming around. And again, I think sitting next to me, listening to calls, and then listening to what I say. I love it when I hear people use what I'll say and it works for them, and they're like, Holy crap, what is this Jedi mind trick that I just learned? And one of the things I'll always say, it's math, not magic. You know, here are the inputs that you have to do to get there. You either gotta close better or you gotta do more work. So which is it? So, and you know, they probably get annoyed at the fact that I say it's math, not magic, all the time, but it is what it is.
SPEAKER_03Um that's funny. So moving ahead to marketing, with your experience, what have you done for marketing and uh what do you currently do and all that jazz?
SPEAKER_00All that jazz. Um marketing is web leads for me is is the main source of of the business that we're coming, that that's that's coming into the agency, because again, obviously people are it's an indication of people that have an interest that are shopping. Other than that, you know, having a social social profile and putting things out there, I I see feedback from it. It's nothing huge. But like I said, buying leads of people that are are uh in the market looking for things, and we just kind of build it off of there. And asking those people for referrals, again, I tell people, I was like, hey, if you can if you can double your your output just by getting someone to give you a referral, absolutely all day long, we'll take that. Uh but I think it all starts with those web leads, and because again, people run out of family and friends real, real quick. And uh, you know, you have to you have to always be in front of people that are looking and and doing things. So putting the web leads in and having having the teledudes calling them and setting up the phones ringing over here has been very, very successful for us. It and it didn't happen overnight. And I shared the other day, you know, we had somebody that was 396 days, and we fine we finally closed it. We finally closed it. Because, you know, we loaded it, we loaded in, you know, I loaded in a bunch of the old stuff that we had, and you know, it took uh two months of of the calling, and man, why are you guys keep calling me? Well, funny you should ask.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Because we're gonna keep calling you. Because it's gonna keep happening and keep happening, and keep happening.
SPEAKER_03Because it's important. It's important. That's what I always everybody's like, well, don't you bug people? Well, yeah. Well, if somebody says that is annoyed, say, man, we take our job seriously. This is important to protect, you know, protect you and your family.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely.
SPEAKER_03Don't you think?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. I I I tell my team, it's like, hey, it's okay. No one that you talk to today is gonna want to talk to you, but they need to talk to you. Right. And once you get them on the phone, then you're assuming that everything's gonna happen the way you want it to happen because that you're the best option for them. So when we're on the phone with people, uh I tell them I was like, hey, no doesn't bother me. I had to ask my wife to marry me twice. So I've heard the word no before. Right. We're just gonna do our best to try and help you and get you in a better position than you are now.
SPEAKER_01Only twice.
SPEAKER_00Only twice, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Wow, it took me a lot more. I really had to push. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I couldn't have asked, I couldn't have asked the third time.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, I was about to hire a telemarketer to just keep calling her. Just keep calling her. Just keep calling her. Get it on the 90th dial. You keep calling me and you keep calling me. You'll just keep calling me. I'll go. I'll go. I'll go. I'll go. I'll go. I'll go. Yeah, that's right, Cameron.
SPEAKER_03Hey, what are you still doing here? Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, if you weren't listening before, we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents throughout the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_03Using these strategies did help Craig and I write over 10 million in premium in the last couple years.
SPEAKER_01And let me tell you, on this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same results.
SPEAKER_03Again, that's live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_01And if you jump on with us, we are certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman