The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The Insurance Dudes are on a mission to find the best insurance agents around the country to find out how they are creating some of the top agencies. But they do not stop there, they also bring professionals from other industries for insights that can help agents take their agencies to the next level. The Insurance Dudes focus on your agency’s four pillars: Hiring, Training, Marketing and Motivation! We have to keep the sword sharp if we want our agencies to thrive.&nb...
Now I am covering the predictable and fixable and profitable agents and failure. I am a great profit. I am Asian Felder. We are agents. We are insurance. Right now, while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_00
We took our notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents from around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01
Using these strategies led Craig and I to selling more than 10 million in premium in the last two years. On this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the same results. Just go to live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_00
If you jump on this call with us, we're certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there. That's from Foosball, Mr. Jason. Oh boy. All right, playbook. We're doing a playbook. Yeah. Now, what we'd like to talk about, I think last time we talked a little bit about uh different lead types. So we really want to help folks get results from leads and the whole system they put together to uh have success with leads. So, and our folks that we've worked with have a ton of experience in this, and um no point in reinventing the wheel. So we want to share some findings that we got as a result of buying leads and then uh putting lots of dials on them. So one of the things that we have found over time has been the enormous number of dials it takes to get a hold of uh leads. Yep. So yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01
So Craig um sliced off a a month of his uh agency from last year, and let's dive into those numbers a little bit. Craig, can you can you talk about yeah?
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, so we took uh a 30-day slice. Mr. Craig, you're tired. Oh, I just said a little yawny. Um we took a 30-day slice and looked at from dials to sales. Okay, now at that time I had 11 telemarketers, and uh we had in our funnel during that 30-day slice about 8,500 leads. Now, these leads weren't all purchased within those 30 days, some of them could have been 60 days old, some of them 90 days old, and even uh some uh further or further along the pipeline, but we touched or made dials to 8,500 of the leads that are in the hopper. So from all of those dials, right? In in the uh 30-day slice, 110,000 dials, 2,921 were contacted, right? So that's that's almost 3,000 new contacts. And uh that went that was either by the sales team or the or the teleteam. And then from those, they resulted in almost 2,000 transfers, so 1,901 transfers. And of those transfers, we quoted about 75% of them for 1,536. Now keep in mind if we quoted them but they didn't qualify because they had a DUI or no prior insurance or whatever, uh, for whatever reason, they get kicked and it doesn't count as a quote. So uh we had 1,536 real quoted households, and then from all of those, we ended up selling 496 items for about 200 or not about exactly 278,752 in premium.
SPEAKER_01
Wow, there's that is a smoking month.
SPEAKER_00
Smoking month. It it's one of the top months now. Uh, but that that's not the point of all of it. The point of all of it is to show the sheer number of dials and leads that have to go through that funnel in order to get to this amount of premium.
SPEAKER_01
Or anyway, so why don't we slice that up? So um dials zero to ninety-four is what you were looking at. What were the percentage of dials that were that were called between uh zero and eight, uh eight and twenty-one and twenty-one to ninety-four?
SPEAKER_00
So it's interesting if there's any statisticians out there that you're gonna love this stuff, but it fell into a normal distribution, which is bell curve, right? Look at the whole thing looked like a bell curve. So from dials eight to dial 21. So of or I'm sorry, from all the sales, how many dials it took to get to that sale, uh, 68% of it fell between eight and twenty-one dials. 68%.
SPEAKER_01
Crazy.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, and so over, so 22 plus was another 16%. So you're looking at 84% of all of the stuff that closed was at least eight dials.
SPEAKER_01
Wow. So eight percent, so sixteen percent was zero to eight dials or one to zero to seven dials.
SPEAKER_00
One to seven. So one to seven resulted in uh sixteen percent of the sales. Now, what's what's really really fascinating about all that is if you go around and ask all of your agent friends or talk to agents, which we've talked to lots of agents, most agents who buy leads are gonna call them under seven times. Usually it's two or three times. And what's really important is to also inspect that because you may buy leads, you may think that your people are calling them a lot of times, but if you really get granular with it, look and actually uh investigate that, they're probably calling a once, twice, or maybe three times my lady. Right.
SPEAKER_01
So diving into those numbers, not doing dials 24 through 94 would have cost 50% less premium. Yeah, that is insane.
SPEAKER_00
And in this case, that's $139,000 a premium, right? Wow. Yeah. And under the comp plan that the carrier that we're with, that's almost $28,000 of revenue. So by like same lead spend, right? Same lead spend, it would have cost almost $30,000 of lost revenue, right? That's the opportunity cost of not making those dials. So that's 50%. Yeah. And the cost of making those dials was well under that 30,000, right? The 27,800.
SPEAKER_01
Right. So let's do so. That was 50% less premium. So what about not doing from uh five to twenty-four dials?
SPEAKER_00
Let's call it eight to twenty-four just to be safe. Okay. But yeah, so uh now you're looking at an additional twenty-six percent less in premium, uh, which is seventy-two thousand in premium and uh another fourteen thousand five hundred in revenue. So most agents are gonna do four high-end right of dials on a lead. So we're looking at if everybody did what everybody does, they're costing themselves a ton of money, right? They're leaving that opportunity cost. In this case, had we had the same leads, bought the same leads, but not made the dials, it would have been forty-one thousand plus out of pocket, 42,000. So then let's that would have hit my pocket.
SPEAKER_01
Let's dive into the lifetime value.
SPEAKER_00
Right, that's the whole point of all this stuff, right? This is a big setup for for what for lifetime value. So we can look at our spin this month and then what we wrote from this month, and then say, oh, well, I spent 10 grand on marketing, but we only wrote 30,000. So so I'm not ahead. But we're not taking into account how long it takes for the leads to bake, right? How many, how many dials do we have to need, get on it, how much time has to go by before those leads start closing. And typically you're gonna, you know, if you're looking at the that bell curve that I was describing, the top of that bell curve is is about uh you know three to six three to six weeks in. So there's time involved, right, to get to where the sweet spot. And you also want to look at the the lifetime value of that business writ. So if we write, let's say a thousand uh a household for twelve hundred a premium. You with me still, Mr. Jason? Yep. Okay. If we write twelve hundred in in premium of new business, okay, it's gonna renew a certain number of times, right?
SPEAKER_01
Right.
SPEAKER_00
And you could figure that out from your retention, what the what the chance is of it renewing, or you can just calculate using the retention. So so let's assume that you know 90% of it is is gonna renew for some some amount of time. And you could and you could plug it in, plug it and chug it, but you could look at okay, if it renews five times, and even if it drops 10% because of the uh retention each time, you know what you're gonna make at the renewal, you know what you're gonna make at the next renewal, you know what you're gonna make make at the third renewal, you know what you're gonna make at the forward, fourth renewal, fifth, sixth. So you can go out as far as you want. Let's say just to be safe, let's go three years, right? So if it's an auto policy and it's a six-month policy, you may be seeing uh six renewals or five renewals after after the initial uh purchase. Well, you want to add that in to your overall revenue, that's your lifetime value of that client. And you know that you could actually afford to spend up to that cost without losing money, right? So that revenue rather.
SPEAKER_01
Let's look at that what you sold, the the 211,000. Yeah. 211,000 in premium, you would have lost.
SPEAKER_00
Right. So what's interesting is I could have spent 900 my lifetime value on the 211,000 in premium. Okay, so what we would have lost was 211,000 in premium. Right. If we didn't make those dials past uh five or whatever the or eight, rather, I think it was we did it from eight. Then that would have cost or the cost of that would have been uh the lifetime value 99,000 sixty-eight, right? So three years. Right. Doing uh that is a three-year, right, assuming three year, and uh in this case we did an 84% retention. So we did a lower retention just to I'd rather under uh underpromise and overdeliver. So we knew number one, we could spend 99,000 on marketing and we're okay. Obviously, we didn't even spend close to that. We spent about a third of that on marketing, but the revenue that we got as a result of it was 42,000, right? So this is what we would have what it would have cost every month if you annualize it, it would have cost us over a million too in lost revenue.
SPEAKER_01
Well, you mean 12 months if you did that 12 months in a row?
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, if we did it 12 months in a row.
SPEAKER_01
That is bananas.
SPEAKER_00
It really is bananas. It's bananas. And it's a banana sandwich. I remember we did uh we did a number of obviously lots of agent interviews, but the but the ones that stick out the most are the ones where those agents talked about you gotta know your numbers. And at that time we didn't really know our numbers. Uh, we certainly didn't talk in uh lifetime value or acquisition cost, cost per sale, and all these other things that that we now look at that really are the most important components because now you can make database decision. It's not a guess, it's not a bet, right? We're not buying Dogecoin and hoping it goes up. We actually know mathematically that it's gonna work out as long as long as we hang in there. Love it. Yeah, love it.
SPEAKER_01
Cool. Well, that's awesome. That is lifetime value and something to think about when you're purchasing leads.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah. I tell folks now look, if you're not gonna put the dials on those leads, then don't even buy the leads. Because it's just it's like buying the ice cream and then sticking out in the desert and waiting a month to eat it. You can't do that.
SPEAKER_01
No, wouldn't wouldn't pan.
SPEAKER_00
Well, wouldn't it pan? All right, Mr. Craig. And that's yeah, playbook. You almost said coffee talk. Uh I know. All right. Well, I'll see you next time. All right. Okay, bye-bye.
SPEAKER_01
Hey, what are you still doing here? Well, while you're still here and while it's fresh in your mind, check out live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, if you weren't listening before, we took notes from over a hundred interviews with top agents around the country and made it into a live webcast.
SPEAKER_01
Using these strategies did help Craig and I write over $10 million in premium in the last couple years.
SPEAKER_00
And let me tell you, on this call, you'll receive the exact blueprint to get the very same results.
SPEAKER_01
Again, that's live.teledudes.com to register for this upcoming Tuesday's live call with us.
SPEAKER_00
And if you jump on with us, we are certain 2022 will be an absolutely fantastic year for you. See you there.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.