The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub! https://www.theidudes.com/Are you interested in learning “How To Predictably Sell 6-Figures A Month Fro...
One being internets and one being mailers, because what happens, Mr. Jason?
SPEAKER_04
Where the focus goes, the energy flows, and there's no focus, so there's not much energy being spent on either one.
SPEAKER_00
Hey Craig, let's get into some coffee talk. Hey, I love it. I love doing some coffee talk. Well, you know, talk about what? Dogs, daughters, whatever. It's coffee tok. Coffee twalk.
SPEAKER_01
Oh, it's our favorite. It's our favorite. This is good. It's our favorite favorite. Well, hello there, Mr. Craig. Well, hello, Mr. Jason. It's a coffee talk. It is. This would be a fun one. 2022's six-step secret Swiss number two. Number three. Number three. I mean. Number whatever. It's just number one. I don't even see number one. Number one's sort of half built there. We gotta work on that, huh?
SPEAKER_04
Oh, it's built, Mr. Craig. Oh this one's a fun one. I like on this one.
SPEAKER_01
Yep. Yep. This is my fave. No, it's mine. You're such a copy. We're co-faves. Co faves. Okay. It rhymes with arching and it starts with an M. Can you guess what it is? Parking. Nope. One more guess. Arcading starts with an M. Barking. Nope, it's marketing. You came close though. Yeah, I know. What was that? I thought that the hint with the starts with an M might help, but you picked two words that did not start with an M. I don't think you should go on Wheel of Fortune.
SPEAKER_04
Well, this is good, man. I like this one. What is your favorite? I'm gonna ask you, what's your favorite market or the number one marketing source that you use right now?
SPEAKER_01
Well, 100 people survey top eight marketing strategies are on the board, and the number one answer is internet leads. Ding ding ding ding ding. That's the number one answer. Wowzers. Yeah. And it's funny because two years ago, if you asked me, I would probably say referrals, referral partners, social. Right. I mean, all this other yikki yick that you get that it's really difficult to put metrics to. And that's why I love I love internet leads because you can create the funnel and you can create predictability. Right. And how? How? Because you can organize you know that there's a flow to it, right? There's a funnel. You know that you're gonna have by a certain amount, you're gonna make a certain number of dials. So you have two numbers in the equation up there. You know you're gonna get some some contact rate. You know, from that contract rate, you're gonna get a certain number of transfers out of it. From the transfers, you know you're gonna get a certain number of quotes. From the quotes, you're gonna get a certain number of sales, and bada bing, bada boom, you're able to track each piece of that. And if anything is off from the baselines that we have come to know and understand, then you can fix it. Right? Love it. So I'm I'm gonna leave. That's it, I'm done.
SPEAKER_04
Mailers. Yeah, I actually think mailers might be better now than prior years. Why can you may ask why, Mr. Craig? Why? Like that or like why? Why? I mean, I get so much, it's ridiculous, but I love what Marty did where he took the mailers and he made sure that he got the kind of mailers, and I think they're a little bit more expensive that has phone numbers, and then had his telemarketers follow up with those, and he was doing about 30k a month from just mailers alone.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. What about mailers with Snapchats?
SPEAKER_04
I don't know what that is.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, I know. I was gonna I I was I wanted to follow it up with a cricket noise, but the soundboard doesn't work anymore. Oh if you know how to fix a Steam Deck, Stream Deck, shoot us an email. So yeah, look, this is the thing, and this is what I found because I have done mailers and I know that they're wildly successful. I know that there's a a longer, I think it's a it's a longer front end of pain where you're not getting as many uh callback ins for a while, and then they kind of three months, four months, six months, it really starts to to pan out. What I don't like is having producers idly sitting and then we're not a hundred percent sure how many dials we're gonna get in per day, and and that kind of thing. I like knowing if I buy 200 leads, this boom, boom, boom, this is gonna happen, right? This series of events is gonna happen. But you know, mailers are nice because it's a much easier call for the producers. Where they're not nice is if you are doing a co like two different strategies, one being internets and one being mailers, because what happens, Mr. Jason?
SPEAKER_04
Where the focus goes, the energy flows, and there's no focus, so there's not much energy being spent on either one.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, and I think that mailers are an easier call, and because of that, which one is gonna sit with the phone rings and which one is gonna get taken? Totes. You know, and it's so I just like to stay in my lane.
SPEAKER_04
Yeah, so but if you are doing mailers, things that you can do, I mean, make sure you have a dedicated phone number that only people from those mailers are calling in on you can have a little bit of data, make sure that you're not just doing them here and there, that you're consistently doing them so that when the funnel starts, I mean, just like Craig said, it doesn't happen overnight. That's going to be months, continual mailers to start seeing a flow come in, and then you can start seeing the numbers and you know, definitely chart that out and quantify, you know, your cost per acquisition and everything on that, and make sure that that funnel works.
SPEAKER_01
It's interesting though, they do get opened, and I mean, you know, what half a percent, three-quarters of a percent open rate. I think it used to be two and a half, and the guy selling it'll definitely tell you it's two and a half, but I think it's closer to when I did it and that was here, so I don't know. I mean, Arizona may be different than other places. You'd think that because it it skews a little older in some spots that you know, myself being one of those, that you'd get a higher open rate, but I did not have that be the case.
SPEAKER_04
No, yeah. So something else. What else can we do to market? Live transfers.
SPEAKER_01
Live transfers. Now we talk about that uh when we do our our call every few Tuesdays or so. We'll go through that. But live transfers are good because they're a little quicker, they're quicker, right? You're getting a quick fix, but where's the downside, Mr. Jason?
SPEAKER_04
Two downsides. One, the cost, maybe three cost can be incredibly expensive. Uh-huh. And when you don't when you miss them, you about have a heart attack. Yes. Yep. And not very scalable. Like if you start, if you have multiple sales agents trying to feed them enough to for a certain dollar amount a month that you want sales, then it can get crazy expensive.
SPEAKER_01
And unpredictable.
SPEAKER_04
Unpredictable. Yeah. One day it can be hot, next day it can be what, Mr. Craig?
SPEAKER_01
Hot or not. Or not. Yeah. And you really have to watch that that CPS on it too, because if you're paying $100, and I've heard that they're a little lower, but you know, if let's say you're paying $80 or $60 for a transfer, but you're close to 10%, I mean that's a $600 cost per sale. And that's right out of the gate. I don't know that you don't have the systems in place for the follow-up for those transfers because the cost is so extreme on the actual touches.
SPEAKER_04
So but it can work and it does serve a purpose. And going back to the story of when I first started getting into like internet leads and stuff, that was the first thing I did was those live transfers. And towards the end of the year, it can be a solid fix to get a couple extra on the books, and it makes sense in that in that circumstance. So has its place. Another thing is branding. Ugh.
SPEAKER_01
So I have a branding story. The guy from the you know those things they put on the shopping carts at the Safeway.
SPEAKER_04
Yes.
SPEAKER_01
I did that. I think my first year. So they they called and you know, and and I instantly liked the sales guy, and I'm brand new, and and man, I it was like five or six grand a month. Like it was ridiculous. And he's like, Oh, you're gonna get so many calls, and and you know, guess how many calls we got from that? Guess how many calls we got? None zero.
SPEAKER_04
How stoked were you when you went to Safeway and saw Mr. Craig?
SPEAKER_01
Oh, I was like, wow, look at that. I've arrived. And it was a safe way, and it was friggin' terrible. So, so run the other direction from those. Branding is tough because in most cases, if you're if you're captive, guess what? Your carrier is doing the branding for you. If you go and wrap your car, I don't know that you're actually branding your agency, you're branding your carrier, right? I mean, if it has a lizard all over the car, do they remember you or do they remember that company? And so I think that it's it's really important to be mindful of that.
SPEAKER_04
What are some ways that we can market for us? And one I think is a fantastic one, which is Google My Business. Yes, uh, for your locations. You uh organically you can just post pictures on there and Google will give you a little extra traffic. And if you spend actually, yeah, and if you use just a little bit of marketing spend, they'll throw some extra your way. So yeah, Google Google how to optimize the Google My Business page and Google will tell you, and then you can tell us thank you next year.
SPEAKER_01
And highly encourage you to ask for reviews. Yes, we get a lot of call-ins from reviews that the service team gets to write because the the other folks don't get that, but those are great, right? They're already somewhat pre-sold at this point.
SPEAKER_04
And if you can boost the the Google reviews, those aren't going anywhere. Like those are fantastic. Like the the ones that you know we had contests at one point a couple years ago, just non-we were doing contests for a while, uh, getting the Google reviews, and guess what? They're still there.
SPEAKER_01
So it's it pays you and uh and respond, respond to each one of them, and especially the angry ones, respond to those two. You're gonna get them. Don't have a freaking hissy fit. It's okay. You don't need to go on Facebook and say, Yeah, you don't need to go on Facebook and ask everybody to bury it because that's actually gonna hurt you, right? Don't fall into that trap. Like, oh, I got a bet oh one. You know what? It's gonna happen. Somebody's gonna troll you, no big deal. Social be your motivators.
SPEAKER_04
Social's another good one. Join some groups, some groups that you can add value to on like Facebook, and then let them know that you do real uh real estate insurance. Yeah, let them know you do that. You might be doing both. Oh, there you go.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. Uh but yeah, that's good stuff. You could go in a group that of something you like, like you, like an RV group if you like RVs, Mr. Jason does. If you like uh Spritter Vans as an RV, you can do that. Right. Fishing, do it, make it happen.
SPEAKER_04
Or just post some some stuff from social on the social from your agency for your agency's site and stuff. It it does help. It does help to you know have your have your guys share it and stuff. Yeah. Um, you'll you'll get one or you know, it's just it's kind of the the combination of all this that can that can help. You might have you should definitely have some marketing engine that you create consistency from, but you're doing a bunch of these other things on the back end too to help boost that stuff. Like when they Google you that you got all these reviews, and it's like, oh, all right, I'll go with them.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah.
SPEAKER_04
So it all helps. Yeah, and then the last two uh starts with a ref and ends with an Earl.
SPEAKER_01
Yep.
SPEAKER_04
Referral program and referral partners, referral partners, two fantastic things to add bolt onto the agency. Some people rely primarily on referral partners, which is fantastic. I love I love that.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, if you want really good uh referral partner strategy, look up I think we had them on twice, the Matheson Brothers. They built a hundred million dollar agency with lender referrals, taking uh loan officers out to happy hour all the time.
SPEAKER_04
And they gave us the blue.
SPEAKER_01
They gave us the deck, yeah. It's somewhere. It might be attached to there, might be a link to it from the podcast.
SPEAKER_04
Yeah. It's somewhere on the podcast. Go to the the iDudes.com T G E we can throw that thing up in the group up in the insurance dudes uh Facebook group. Yeah, join the face. That'll be the easiest. Join the Facebook group, the insurance dudes Facebook group, we'll throw it, we'll throw it up in there. Uh that's a good idea. That's a good idea. Okay. There you go. That's it. That is some marketing ideas, some stuff to dive into for 2022. Make sure that you're maximizing your bonuses. It's all that energy you have, Mr.
SPEAKER_01
Jason. You're just ooze oozing energy over there. I ooze. Yeah. Well, and that's that's a glove. The glove.
SPEAKER_02
Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it?
SPEAKER_00
Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_02
Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium off even the worst internet leads, where could they go?
SPEAKER_03
They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_02
I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_03
Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_02
Live.teledudes.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03
Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknown
Right?
SPEAKER_03
Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah, which is awesome. But they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. Are you gonna respond to these texts? I'm gonna respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it.
SPEAKER_02
I'm gonna text it right now.
SPEAKER_03
520 214 2219.
SPEAKER_02
Alright, I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_03
Bye, Mr. Greg. Wait, can they even listen to this on the radio anymore?
SPEAKER_01
I love it. I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.