The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Perry's Marketing Sanctuary Will Gleefully Marry Your Keyword Canary Part 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
I can see that you practiced the um overcoat of the objections, which is critical, right?
SPEAKER_01So earthquake is the only thing. What do you have down in there? So we got a dust storm, right? When the booze come through?
SPEAKER_02They call them a haboob. A haboob is the big dust storm here.
SPEAKER_04Buckle up, it's the insurance dudes podcast. How are you excluding the people that are Joe Schmoe down the street's client and they just want to make a policy change?
SPEAKER_00Well, most of those people, once they're with, you know, as a uh like a captive carrier, right? So if like you're with like you're with your farmers, American families, all state, state farm, right? Once they have the agent relationship built, okay, once they have that, they normally know just to call that agent, or if you've done what you do right, is what every company is after these days, because they want people to go online. They want them to set up their account online, they want them to download their app. Okay. So once they download the app, then if if I have a question, I'm like in my app, it's gonna hit call and it's gonna direct them right to the agency that you're already doing business with. Do you run into that sometimes where you have people that stumble across your ad or something like that that's with a different agent? Yes, I mean you do. So, but I one thing I will tell you is when you come, if you really drill down the search engine marketing and you're out there, it also depends on the product that you're going after. And I want you to think about it this way. And hopefully I can explain this well enough, is that if you're in auto insurance and you're with a carrier, right? And if you're an agent and and one of your customers gets in an accident, they normally hit somebody else that's with a different carrier. So now who do you have? You have two people now trying to find somebody from your company to handle claims. So you got to eliminate these claims calls, but you have your customer that's trying to get a hold of claims, but then you also have the person they hit trying to get a hold of claims. So when you bid on auto out there or anything dealing with auto quote, you're still gonna get service-related calls because there's so many people trying to get a hold of what they need. But if you take it to renter's insurance, you really you eliminate that other party. So then, like there's more people searching for renter's insurance out there, and there's still some that are looking for deck page. So, but you eliminate a ton of service calls. And if you go one step further and you go after certain homeowners insurance quote keywords, you think about it, homeowners quote, there's literally no other traffic coming in. The word is very, very clean, and you don't have all these other people looking for claims. And if anybody has a club home claim, they're not calling the 800 number, anyways. They're calling their agent and because it's a burndown or it's something major and they're not talking to somebody 800 number. So the quality of the key word gets better over time. And I have found that by just going after literally home, I write so much more business and I don't play with everybody else because there's nobody bidding. I'm sure after this podcast, everybody'd be in my backyard now. But it's just that's that's how I just look at it. Well, you know, but only and then Yeah.
SPEAKER_03I'm sorry, go ahead.
SPEAKER_00So it's that, and then just going after like what is it now? Like, is it the Gen X? Is that the newest one that everybody's trying to go after? And it's all online shopping, but you have to think about what the future holds. As if you can get a hold of somebody from Gen X to do business with your agency, you need to then train them to build a relationship with you rather than just doing everything over the phone. Let them bind online, take care of them, but then ask them if they want to meet. Most of those guys won't come in. But what a lot of agents are missing is they're not doing like Zoom conference calls or Zoom calls with their clients. Like if you if like here we can all see each other, but instead of having people come in sitting with you in your agency, just start setting up Zoom calls with people, they can go on their phone or do whatever, and you can talk to them face to face and you build the rapport and you retain the customer. So that's just kind of what we've been focused on recently.
SPEAKER_04Oh, I love that. I love that. Yeah, we had somebody on our podcast a couple years ago that had that was talking about like the neural pathways and stuff in our brain, and that when you see someone, even though it's on a screen, but you're seeing and you're talking to them, it's your brain is almost processing it as if you guys are together. You build that same kind of bond. So I think that's huge. It's one of those things that now everybody's been trained over the last year and a half to use Zoom. I mean, everybody knows how to use it.
SPEAKER_00And it's so easy now. You just text a link out or just email a quick link and they just hop on and here we are. It's almost like a FaceTime call. It's funny, is that I'm not a big FaceTime person on my phone, but I'll get on Zoom calls all day long and chat with people, especially like if I have a call that's gonna go bad with a customer, meaning they you know they get an unpleasant experience with my office, with claims, or didn't understand something right. It's better to actually speak with them over the video or face-to-face than it is to just do it over the phone. Because then people get real hot over the phone because they're hiding a little bit. Whereas if they can see your facial expressions, they can they know that you care because you really do. And sometimes that's hard to interpret through your voice.
SPEAKER_03So I love the tears coming down. They're they can't keep yelling at you. Emotional.
SPEAKER_04How do you get your staff to do that? Okay, because it's one of those things. It's like I I know with customer service, it's tough, man. You those people that are upset, it's tough to deal with. How do you get them to actually say, okay, take that tough person and then also get online with them? But I I think that's an amazing strategy.
SPEAKER_00Well, with uh, so I have three offices now. Um, and I was one of the first, like in the the first in company history to have three out here in Vegas, and I opened it up during COVID. I just I finally felt like they thought, who's crazy enough to try this? And so I was like, well, let me try it. So but it's but what I had learned though, what I'd learned though through COVID when I had that third office is like the challenging is the team camaraderie and getting everybody on the same page. So I did do more Zoom calls and I had like morning huddles almost every morning from like 8 45 to 9, just quick 15 minutes, shout out a Zoom, and then we're all just talking and we can all see each other on video and we're explaining what's happening within each office. So every day everybody just got super comfortable talking in front of the camera. And then a lot of times with the consumer, if you're talking to them, they don't understand something and say, you know what, this is much easier if I can show you on your screen or on my screen, is okay, I can actually share a link with you and go over this, and you can see like my mouse like right on there and go that route. So, and people have been very receptive to it.
SPEAKER_03There's almost no excuse for them not to get on because you can do it from your phone, you can do it from your computer, put on your TV. I mean, it's just I think the hardest part is probably getting the team to actually do it. Because once you're good, you just say, Hey, we're gonna hop on here. Did you get the link? Click it, right? You don't even need to say what you're doing, and they go, hey, we're on.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you're absolutely correct on that. So just but yeah, my team, and then well, I tell my team there's like we have like uh every carrier has obviously like a secure platform that they want you to use, whether that would be Zoom or whatever they're using at the time, is a lot of times there's some difficulties right away helping people understand how to kick the link out. But I just practice with them and they send the link just directly to me until I get them to like learn about it. And once you do the first couple, you know, it just gets easier. But then I've been telling people in my office rather than sending an IAM or an email, because a lot of times it's misinterpreted, just it's what's coming up, and we've seen it on um movies like in the past when we watch where basically, oh, let me call so-and-so, and they just like click a button and just like and it just comes up, and the person's right here and they quickly talk to them and hangs up. They kind of like eliminate the whole waiting to connect part. I think as technology gets faster and faster and faster, when you want to buzz somebody in one of your other offices, you're gonna instead of chatting with them like through chat, you're gonna click and just see them face to face. And but at what point does like the companies, like some of these big captive carriers, right? Or state farm, all say farmers, Americ Family, Geico, Progressive, right? Some of those online companies, at what point does one of these companies start to make the move that when you have a claim, rather than talking to people over the phone, because that's all they do business right now, is somebody to take a step forward and actually start doing video chat with the consumers out there. And who's ever first at the game and can figure it out and taking care of the customer is gonna, I feel like, win in the long run.
SPEAKER_04100%. Yep. It's definitely one of those things you gotta invest some time into thinking about what does this look like in a few years and how can we start implementing some systems and processes that mimic what so we'll be pros by then. We won't be left behind.
SPEAKER_03Do you have your sales team do calls on Zoom as well?
SPEAKER_00So if the customer wants to go through it, go through with it, yes. And and uh with my agency, and they used to not let us do this before, is that I'm licensed in uh three other states. So I've got Arizona, Utah, and California.
SPEAKER_01Get out of here.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I know. It's like I target right around your ears. So it uh telling everybody because that a lot of people go, they argue with me, and as right, as you would too, is if you you would be like, Well, why would you do business in a different state? Because that person's gonna just switch to a closer agent after a while and want to go down the road. And I said, and I fight with you and I say, no, not really. And they say, What's your spin? I said, Well, in California, I said, you know, if you think about it, if I'm doing my business like in San Francisco or like in the LA area, all over the place, I said, What happens when a catastrophic event happens? Right. I said, Not only are you affected as the customer, but so are the agents and team members that you do business with, and you're back in line at the 800 number. Wouldn't it be nice to have me? You know, I'm a hot skip and a jump away, plus everybody comes to Vegas, you can visit anytime, but we're talking over the phone. I've the expertise and I can help you and the staff big enough that if you have a catastrophic event, you are not at an 800 number. You call my agency and we're taking care of you.
SPEAKER_03So it's just I can see that you practice the um overcoat of the objections, which is critical, right?
SPEAKER_01So earthquake is the only thing I guess what do you have down in there? So we got a dust storm, right?
SPEAKER_02When the news come through, like they call them a haboob. A haboob is the big dust storm here.
SPEAKER_04But so for an agent that's listening for an agent that's uh maybe not doing a bunch of tech stuff right now, I mean, how can they start getting into this and not feel that overwhelmed?
SPEAKER_00You know, I think it's just baby steps. I mean, again, going back to if you're not comfortable on the video, set yourself if I mean depending on what platform you have, set yourself with a Zoom and start having a Zoom with your team meetings. You and you I mean, we sometimes we have some of these offices, you know, two, three people, so we're not gonna do a Zoom that way, but we could, or if I'm working from home one day, I can then zoom in with my team and everybody's sitting at their desk having the Zoom meeting, and you're just getting comfortable in front of the camera in front of speaking in front of people. And it's just baby steps like that and little practicing. It even goes back to internet leads when we talk about the processes of closing deals there. Most people don't like internet leads because they bought 15 and they could only handle three. So it's just like buying this a couple a day, you know, getting used to how the whole system works, and then adding a couple more, adding a couple more, because it's like really your system and your process is broke. And that's why, I mean, if you want to lose weight, right? Gotta go to the gym. If you don't go, not gonna lose weight.
SPEAKER_03Not gonna happen. Not with all these cannolis I'm eating. So I am still like one of these things that that's really been picking at my brain for a long time, and every time it comes up is the selling using Zoom. I think that knowing that physiologically, there's a connection, like we're you know, human-to-human talking, right? And we know that if somebody comes in, I mean it's almost a done deal, right? Unless we're quadruple people buy, right? Like your close rate goes up astronomically if they come in. So if having that Zoom conversation is that close to being in person, it would seem to me that that would be huge in closing rate and conversions.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And then the other thing is like what you do too is that if you think about it, this is the way I I feel like it's gonna go like in the future, if you want to deck out your office, but you start to put like little cubby holes, like like you have like in my office, like I have like little sections all the way through that ever there's all these desks in. So then after a while, I mean, today, like you know, you can see like a little background in there. At what point do you start making all the backgrounds instead of having a fake background? You make cool little backgrounds so that when your team comes in, like I'm sitting here today, it's in the sports room, or tomorrow I'm sitting there, you know what I mean? It's the fashion room, or things like that. So you're sitting in all these different rooms and you're always switching it up for the customer when they're coming in. So it looks fun, like in your agency, because people want to be they want to be a part of that. Yeah. So I love that. That's super cool. It's like we're just going down a rabbit hole here.
SPEAKER_03You guys are like, Oh, I'm just it's just how's my brain going, you know, and how often does the prospect say, hey, we'll email it over, right? And then they usually we have a way to overcome that, but how much more would it be to take it that step further instead say, Hey, you know what? Click the link and and let's make sure that that worked for you, right? And then they click it, boom, you're up and go, let's go over it now. And you just freaking scroll through it, right? I mean, then it's like, okay, what are you now? What are they gonna say? Oh, I want to print it out and I want to like because nobody's looking through the email. We all know that, right? That's just I want to get off the phone.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and they're also getting pretty good, I feel like, with the uh the technology with companies of just being to quickly text message a document, you know, because back in the day, you know, everything was email, but if you think about it right now, a lot of it's now moving to text. You can quickly, if I get a PDF on my phone, I can actually just text it right to you. Yeah, and it's crazy that way. So it's the same thing is that when we're if when these computers get really good, which some of them are, you know, just the technology, it's it's sometimes hard for the big carriers to like completely move because they if there's data, you mean everybody's worried about privacy and security, which is super important. But after a while, just be able to talk to somebody like, hey, let me just text you the document or here, let me text you the binder rather than emailing the binder over, and you just share it right in a secure connection.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. So it's amazing. Super cool.
SPEAKER_00It's uh I don't know, you get even to the phones, right? You're FaceTiming somebody, and you could do it through right through Zoom. And it's like, how do I set this device up in my car? Because everybody's doing their whole device and like mileage and everything else, and you could literally step them through them as they come into your office five, 10 years ago. You guys remember how that was. They're coming in, you're going out to the car, now it's just all over all of our video.
SPEAKER_04It is super cool. I love all that stuff. I love how similar it is too to. I mean, you're trying to create kind of back to the idea of doing different rooms, you're trying to create an experience, right? And you can create that with technology. I think people were really afraid of technology taking away a human element. Well, put it back in there, you know, like use the technology to create a good human experience rather than take away.
SPEAKER_00It's uh I'm sure you guys see it though, too. It's uh a lot of business being done online, you know, and so sometimes it's harder for a captive agent to compete with like some of the online companies that's that are really good. But when somebody has a claim, that's why they go back. And I feel like the agent is always gonna win at the end of the day because of the customer experience. And the agents that figure out the technology piece faster are gonna be the ones that win win at the end. So hundred percent.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, humans still want the connection, like they don't want it for everything, right? But they want to know that behind the scenes, the Wizard of Oz is actually pulling some levers and they're protected the right way, right? And so when the house burns down, like they don't want an 800 number, they don't want to just fill out some form. They need to, you know, have somebody console them and and walk them through it. So yeah, there's a lot of power behind that.
SPEAKER_04Love it. So, Perry, final question is out of your 20 years of being in the industry and um continuing to evolve with the times and being kind of on the forefront of that, what is the number one piece of advice that you give any insurance agent coming into the industry or maybe somebody that really wants to kickstart their agency into the future?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think it just goes back to the some people think of a stupid answer, just to training, you know, just like from like day one, just continuing to try to get better. Sometimes like I think I'm good at something, but I continue to try to train to just get better, whether that's meeting with customers, that's just going through the quoting process, that's learning like new technology, or that's just brushing up just like on my skills in general, you know, about just different products. And like as long as you continue to train, I feel like you're gonna win in the long run. Most new agents struggle because they just don't understand how to bind the policy. They're very good at talking to people. People want to buy with them, but when they say yes, it's like day one, it's like, well, how do I take money to put it into the system or how do I quote it? As you guys know, like the sometimes it's the systems and the training, you know, and nobody's everybody just kind of breezes through that stuff and they don't go back. But it's just being relevant on it and just trying to figure out what's best and just continuing to push yourself. Like I've been looking at, like, I mean, I feel very good in the insurance field. I'm in here working every single day 16 years later, but I'm also doing some courses like on the side out there, some business development courses, quick month or two, a few online where we're talking with different people and strategizing just to stay fresh out there so that I can stay up because I don't know where this world's going and where technology is going to take us. Yeah. So, but it just, you know, just the grind and just, you know, having patience. I mean, my I think my number one thing that makes me successful is my patience with my team. You know, I'm okay to give somebody two, three, four, ten tries, you know, over and over. I try to see the good in something rather than just be like cut to or quick to cut somebody. I very rarely I think I haven't fired anybody in probably seven, eight years before since I've let go. I just I try to win that way. And then just my other best advice if you want to win, just give back to others, you know, and try to help other people succeed. The more that I've given to other agents across the country, you know, or team members and trying to help them succeed, the better it's worked out for me. And I don't know if that's just how it is, but I've always just been blessed and lucky, I guess. And but I think that's you know, you pay it forward and you'll get it in return.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. The greater the abundance in your mentality, the greater it comes back. So yeah.
SPEAKER_04I love that. I love that. Well, it seems that anybody that has good luck, it's usually there's a lot of reasons for it, you know, and it sounds like you pouring into other people have really come back tenfold. Love it. Carrie, where can people see you, get a hold of you, check out your stuff? What's your stuff?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, right there. So it's probably on LinkedIn.
SPEAKER_00It's like I always tell people and I help people all the time is like I just go out and say, find me on LinkedIn, shoot me a message. Yeah, I always respond to the messages. Love giving people a call that don't mean know me from Adam, just say, hey, this is how I would look at it. Here's my best take on it. I obviously enjoy helping people, so do that. Google me. So I don't have any Facebook or anything like that. Nice myself. You escaped. No offside, there's no upside to Facebook.
SPEAKER_03So Perry, thank you, man. It's been so awesome uh hanging out. Hope we'll catch up again down the road. I will probably see you uh at LeedsCon. And uh see out the call. Have an awesome presentation there. Yeah, top golf uh on uh Wednesday night, right? So yeah, well, cool. It's gonna fade out. Sorry, go ahead.
SPEAKER_00Oh, I said I appreciate you guys having me on.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Oh, it's awesome. Yeah, thank you so much. Yeah, thank you for your time. And uh thank you so much uh for listening to Inshurts Dudes. Hey Jason.
SPEAKER_06Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it?
SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_06Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium, yes. Even the worst internet leads, where could they go? They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes.
SPEAKER_05It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_06I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_05Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teledude.com.
SPEAKER_06Live.teledude.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_05Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_05Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah, which is awesome. But they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. You can respond to these texts. I'm gonna respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it.
SPEAKER_06I'm gonna text it right now.
SPEAKER_055202142219.
SPEAKER_06All right, I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_03I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman