The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
RECAST - Mega Agency Owner Secrets with Queen Dudette, Stephanie Hamilton
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Hey Jason. Hey.
SPEAKER_01How you doing, man?
SPEAKER_03Oh, I'm good. I heard we had a super killer dude.
SPEAKER_01That's right, dudette, this time. Actually, we're talking about make it agency owner secret with the Queen Dudet, Stephanie Hamilton. Are you ready?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, let's get this thing going.
SPEAKER_01Boom.
SPEAKER_02Welcome to the insurance dudes podcast with Insurance Agency Owners, helping us to think of different ways to optimize our business and our lives.
SPEAKER_01Is that dramatic?
SPEAKER_05That is dramatic.
SPEAKER_01Is that good?
SPEAKER_04That's dramatic.
SPEAKER_03We'd like to see the look on the faces.
SPEAKER_04I just laughed. I did not pass.
SPEAKER_03It encourages people to move off iTunes and then go also watch the video on YouTube.
SPEAKER_04You could have warned me, I could have done it.
SPEAKER_03Oh, that's great. No, we need to get the guest reaction.
SPEAKER_04Oh, okay.
SPEAKER_03And it's usually about the same.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Well, I think we naturally will gravitate towards looking at his wall and uh yeah.
SPEAKER_04What is all of that?
SPEAKER_01It's my uh my uh teenage schoolroom poster.
SPEAKER_04Oh my god, you have Henry Carmen on your wall.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Film Ted's Captain Neo.
SPEAKER_04Is that Hulk Hogan?
SPEAKER_01That is, with the ultimate warrior.
SPEAKER_04Okay, great. You gotta do better. I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_01And yes, this is my office.
SPEAKER_03At work, not at home. Yeah, it's back there. That's what you get to look at on mine.
SPEAKER_04No, no, you gotta do better. Come on. You gotta get some posters.
SPEAKER_03Wait, I know I can do something. Hold on. Let's see how quickly I can work. No, I'm under the I'm under the gun here. How about that? Now he's in San Francisco.
SPEAKER_04Or no, the posters are still better. Only have these little hands. That's all that's all I got for you.
SPEAKER_01There you go. Yeah. Thanks for coming on. Insurance dudette. You're that doodette.
SPEAKER_04Oh, okay. I got it. I can do I can do that.
SPEAKER_03I'm good. We don't have many insurance doodets, so this is great.
SPEAKER_04I can be the dudette, I guess.
SPEAKER_03So how's it going? You're over at Eric's. You're over at Eric's.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I'm actually up here this week.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, uh, got in at 3 30 yesterday morning and I fly back out tonight.
SPEAKER_03So do you still live in Alabama?
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Are you gonna move to Ohio? No. Wow.
SPEAKER_04It's cold.
SPEAKER_03So how's that gonna work?
SPEAKER_04Uh I just do everything remotely and do um Zoom chats with the team. Okay. So no, I don't do cold.
SPEAKER_01Well, remote, I mean it's the future.
SPEAKER_05That's right. That's right.
SPEAKER_01So so tell us, tell us, tell us a little bit for somebody that doesn't know you or anything, tell us a little bit about your background, your history, uh, what got you in the insurance business and what you do now.
SPEAKER_04All right. So um let's see. I got in the insurance business. I'm gonna tell my age here, and I'm not really excited about it. Um, probably about 17 years ago. Um, and I actually started out selling life and health insurance. And yeah, a guy just one of the guys I went to high school with, he was like, You gotta try this. And I was like, okay, I'm not doing anything worthwhile now, so I might as well. And that's how I started actually. No, right? Just take it on a whim, it's fine. And this is where I landed. Um so uh I started out doing, you know, just life and health, doing some group benefit enrollments and stuff like that. Um, and then I actually went to um nationwide for a while and worked there for a little while, and it was actually going really good. Um, but they were going more to an independent style agency. Um, and I like the like the whole like exclusive type deal where you're not having to learn like 15 different agents, like fitting different products for people. So um I actually went to all went to an all state agency and I stayed with him for probably a year and a half, two years, and then I actually bought that agency from him. And I actually was an agency owner for a little over five years and you know, had kids, husband's a police officer, you know. So I um I was like, dude, this is just too much. Like I have little bitty babies, all on agency. I was like, I uh this is overwhelming, and you're never home. So, you know, um so I actually sold it and went to work for a mega agency, and I was there uh a little over three and a half years, and I was actually the sales trainer, coach, door changer, whatever you want to call me for that day. Um, and I actually helped them build a coaching and training program, and and I just actually wanted to do a little more and kind of go out and venture out a little on my own and do a little of my own thing every once in a while. So um now I'm actually working remotely in Ohio. So I like it. It's fun. This is actually my second week.
SPEAKER_00Congratulations.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, it's fun. I like it.
SPEAKER_01Cool. So what what I mean that's a big that's a big change. Um yeah, how is it working remotely remotely?
SPEAKER_04You know what's funny is um they see like as much as you see of me. So I can have on a huge shirt, my hair can be fixed, and I can have on shorts and flip-flops, and it's great. I mean, what I mean, is it better than that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Pajama pants, super baggy pajama pants.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I mean, you're not seeing anything else, so it doesn't really matter.
SPEAKER_03That's what I do normally at at the office.
SPEAKER_04Right. Well, you know, I came from an environment that was super uh non-casual, like very business, very, you know, uppity kind of deal. So um it was definitely a big change for me to be able to wear my um shorts to work.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, even when you're there at Eric's, I I mean I'm under the impression there's foosball tables and beanbags and and all there is a swing.
SPEAKER_04So he took a picture of me in this swing earlier with my feet propped up on a table, and I was like, that's so professional, Eric. We don't post that anywhere.
SPEAKER_01So with all the environments that you've been in, I'm curious because I freaking hate collars. I don't like wearing suits. Like I loathe wearing suits. Anyone that knows me's like Jason. No, and like a tie feel I feel like it's a noose.
SPEAKER_05Right.
SPEAKER_01So I hate that. But environment-wise, pros, cons, what do you feel? What what kind of being in such a such a conservative environment and then all you've all your experience, pros and cons, what do you think? Move into a farm environment.
SPEAKER_04You know, I'm kind of 50-50 actually. Um, I like the whole super conservative environment um because it kind of ups people's game a little, just because they um I feel like when they dress for success, it definitely kind of ups their game a little. Um plus, you know, in that environment also, there were a lot of walk-in customers. So I mean, it was a little different, you know. Uh now they walk in in my house that I have to talk to. So I'm just face to face with them, and that's all they see. Um, but like when I came up here, everybody was like, oh my god, like you have heels on and like dress pants, and you're gonna be overdressed. And I'm like, this is what I'm used to. I don't know what else to wear. So I mean, I I like both ways. Um, it just I think it depends on where you are and kind of what environment you're in. It, you know, it's all it all works.
SPEAKER_01So has your role been consistently the same through the last agency, the current one, and how has that changed? What exactly do you do? How do you implement yes?
SPEAKER_04I would say it is um it is it's gonna be a lot the same. Um, I was basically somewhat running the other agency. Um, and that's kind of what I'm gonna be doing here a lot of. Um, I'm trying to take as much off of his plate. I told him my main goal for him was to sit on his back porch and drink beer if that's what he wanted to do. That's um that is the goal for um not necessarily him, but for me, you know, if that's what if he needs to take off, um I don't want him having to check emails. I don't want him having to wonder what's going on. Like all he's doing is seeing emails come through that say somebody got a sale, you know, unless the office is on fire, I don't want him to be concerned about it. Um, so that's really that's my goal for this agency. Um, and that's you know where we were at with the last agency. Um, I kind of feel like we had arrived, so to speak, at the last agency, and it wasn't as it was challenging, but in different ways. So this is back to kind of the challenge I like, like getting everybody up to speed, getting everybody um where they they need to be on their goals. Um, because you know, being a quote scratch agency versus a mega agency, they have different challenges. And I actually these challenges fit better for my personality. You know, they just um not that there's anything wrong with the megas. It just I like I like the challenge of helping somebody go from nothing to a mega. That's fun to me. I like that, I like that tournament.
SPEAKER_01And that's fun for them too.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, oh I'm sure. I'm sure.
SPEAKER_01Craig, sorry, I steamrolled you.
SPEAKER_03Oh, that's the steamroller. If you were a wrestler, your wrestling name would be the steamroller. Maybe it should be.
SPEAKER_04You should get you an outfit and make you a poster.
SPEAKER_01Oh like one of those onesie outfits, right? With the room.
SPEAKER_04And it has like steamroller on it.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_04You gotta get one.
SPEAKER_01It would be funny.
SPEAKER_03So most agencies in growth mode, right? Being at the front end, being a uh in the in the growth cycle of a business, where before you were at probably mature, right? They were it was maintained, not really grow, because when you have a book of that magnitude, all these megas, there there isn't a lot of growth, right?
SPEAKER_04Because well, we did grow a lot, but yeah, yeah, required to grow a lot.
SPEAKER_03Exactly, exactly. So so when you're is the the formula different for a startup and how to how to manage those people because that's what you're doing, you're managing the the people and the processes. Is it different? What and and how is it different?
SPEAKER_04No, honestly, I don't think it's different. Um, I'm using the same managing techniques, the same processes. Um it is on a smaller scale. So, you know, some of it I'm kind of having to hold off implementing yet because we're just not there yet. Um but a lot of it is the same. I mean, people managing, I think, is uh probably the most difficult in any agency you go to. Um everybody struggles with that. You know, you just have to um you have to hold them accountable, and that's the same everywhere. You know, people are gonna do what you expect of them and they're not gonna do anymore. And so you just have to keep pushing and pushing and pushing until um you get what you need out of them. Um, but honestly, everybody here, and I mean they've been here for 18 months, so uh me coming in as the new girl um has you know it has not been challenging, and I was kind of expecting that. Everybody's kind of just open-armed and jumped right on board, and we've, you know, we're writing more than they ever have. So I'm kind of excited about that.
SPEAKER_01Talk about that. So, what what what did you do to to increase that? And what do you do to push people?
SPEAKER_04So um I tell them it has a lot to do with the southern charm. Um, we somehow have a way of doing that. I don't really know how that works. Um, but no, I um I think it was more anything, you know, um agency owners have a lot on their plate as far as you know, just running the business. Um they don't allow time to hold people accountable because they're doing other things, trying to make this work or that work and trying to figure out, okay, well, these links are working, these are not working. So it's difficult on their level to try to come in there and go, okay, why are you not making phone calls? Okay, why are you not doing it this way? You know, um they don't have a lot of time for that. Um people say all day, well, they can make time. Well, there's only so many hours in the day. So somebody like me can come in and especially coming from where I've been and gotten the training that I have, I can just come in and take over. And they don't have to, they can just kind of relinquish that control and say, okay, look, she knows what she's doing. I don't really have to worry about it, and just kind of hands off and kind of watch it develop. Um, we've made some, you know, I mean, even in two weeks, we're gonna make some tweaks um to things and that they're doing. And I have to make tweaks to myself because I'm working with a totally different crew that's in a totally different environment than I've ever been in. Never been to Ohio. So, you know, it's just um I'm used to working with these little southern girls that um are totally different. So, I mean, even I have to make changes to myself and how I react to things and how I, you know, manage them because it is it's just different. Um, but it's a lot of fun. I'm I'm liking it so far.
SPEAKER_01Nice. And to get a little bit more granular, like what is your process? Like, what are we talking about? What are some tangible daily things that we can implement from Yeah? So what does that look like?
SPEAKER_04So um I think the biggest thing for most people is gonna be listening to phone calls. Um, a lot of people don't do that, you know. Um now when I'm here, you know, like like yesterday and today, um, I'm kind of listening to them live. I'm sitting right in there with them and they're in an open room. So I can kind of, unless they're both like in deep conversations at the same time, I can pretty much listen to every phone conversation they're having. So I can, you know, I can either chat them if I don't want to, you know, walk over and go, oh my god, don't do that. Um, I can kind of chat them and say, hey, look, try this. I mean, we just actually um I have one that she struggles a tad with closing like right on the spot. She, you know, she's just a little nervous about it. And so I'm chatting her going, close him, close him now. And so we close the deal. You know, it's just um, and sometimes I'll listen live to them without them knowing. I don't, I never talk to them while we're live because I don't want to, I don't want to make them nervous and I don't want them to mess up what they're doing. Um, but I'll listen, then I'll come back to them and say, hey, you know, look, why don't you try this next time or let's try this? Um that's probably the biggest thing I do, honestly. Um, and then everybody all day knows where we're at. So from the first policy, or before we even sell the first policy for the day, I know exactly what we need every single day. So from the first policy that's sold, we do basically a countdown all day of okay, now we need this much more. Now we need this much more. So I'm kind of, I guess I call it in your face, but not really like aggressively in your face. They said they were scared of me and I was like, why? I'm nice. But it's kind of, you know, it's everybody, I need everybody to be a team player and everybody to know uh, you know, where we got to go and what we got to do to get there. So if it's out there all day, every day, it it's gonna be kind of ingrained in them to know where we have to go. And that's important to me because I mean, I can know, Eric can know, but if the whole team doesn't know like the big picture and where we're trying to go, it's we're not gonna get there. So um, those are the biggest things to me though, is keeping it top of mind for everybody and then listening to phone calls.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, reps or or LSPs or or it really anywhere in in life, right? If you're in sports or whatever, if there isn't somebody there to give outside perspective, yeah, it's gonna if it starts going south, it's just gonna keep you know, the shift just starts to turn. So it's so I think that that listening to calls, replaying the calls, and then and then sitting down and going over those calls is the most valuable thing activity that you can do as either agency manager or agency owner, right? Because that's where they learn. Because they're doing it. You know, like we can watch YouTube videos about sales, we can watch all these things that are that are out there, but unless we actually are taking action, this is the theme of the day. You're our fourth, and every single one of these we've been talking about taking action, um, you know, you're actually in there, right? Right. It's it's just remarkable. And I I don't know that there's a question there.
SPEAKER_01I'm just agreeing with the only how how did you get into that role? Was that something that you created? Was that something that was taught to you?
SPEAKER_04Um, so so I guess um being coming from an agency owner, when I started at the old agency, um I started out in sales, and so basically I had to kind of prove myself. Um and I kind of held myself to a a different standard, I guess, because I had owned an agency expected more of me than would anybody else just because of where I'd been. So, and I knew, you know, I I can do those systems in my sleep. So any by anytime anybody had a question, they wouldn't go bother anybody else, they would come to me. And it kind of got to the point that I was basically training without a title. So um anytime anybody knew would come on, um, I basically would kind of show them the ropes and show them how to um make everything happen. So I guess it was a mutual thing, you know, um when it came time that we were hiring a bunch of people and um everybody was kind of gonna need training at the same time, um, that there was no way I could really produce and train effectively on both sides. So um my goal was to replace what I was doing. So, you know, I needed to replace 80 items a month. That that was, you know, my average was gonna run around 80 to 85. I needed to be able to replace that with, you know, and it may take two people for a little while. I needed to be able to replace my production in order for that role to be effective. So um that was um that was probably about six months after I started. And um I was doing that when I left. So I kind of I guess I kind of created it, but had some help along the way. Nice to answer your question.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Okay.
SPEAKER_01Why why so you created this, you had a an awesome position. Now you're you're going more what was the big drive? Because I think okay, selfishly I'm asking this question.
SPEAKER_05So it's okay.
SPEAKER_01As I'm growing, you know, creating these roles and stuff from a retention standpoint, what would have kept you?
SPEAKER_04Um, you know, my biggest thing was, and I think everybody, you know, everybody has their own ideas and on ways they want to do things and on um, you know, just their differences differences of opinion, I guess, would be a good thing. Um, you know, and I was to the point that, you know, I was getting asked all the time to come to other agencies, like, you know, come in my agency and train my staff. Come to my agency. But that wasn't possible because I had 35 people I was responsible for. So I was not able to, you know, I couldn't, I couldn't leave. And I knew if I could find somewhere remotely that I could work and that would allow me to kind of venture out a little too, and everybody was kind of on the same team and on board with it, that it would all work. So when it came time that I was to that point and I was ready to do that, it was either I was going to do that or I was just gonna go buy an agency and do it for myself. So this presented itself and I was like, oh, I got the best of both worlds. So I can kind of I can it was gonna be really hard for me to travel and coach other teams in on my own agency. Um, you know, just because you need to be in there, especially for the first, you know, three or four years, you kind of gotta be hands on a lot. Um that wasn't that wasn't gonna be an opportunity for me for a while. And I was like, okay, so I can do this for a while, and then if I want to go open up my own later, I can. I still have that opportunity. Um, so this opportunity presented itself and I jumped all over it.
SPEAKER_03Cool. When we talk about accountability, what what is your methodology for doing that? I mean, there's a we have a lot of listeners and then they are always asking how, how, how, how, how, how. Right. And I know that it's it's doing, right? Just do, figure it out. But what specifically are you doing that's getting the results that you're getting?
SPEAKER_04So really and truly, um, I'm a very motivating person. I'm not going in there, you know, cracking the whip, going, you're not doing what I told you to do. That's just that's not my style. You know, um, I am more um, hey, look, I want to know what your goals are because what if I can figure out what you need to do in life, whether it's you're a single mom and you need to buy your first house, whether it's, you know, you want to pay off some loans, whatever that is, I'm trying, I'm gonna try to figure that out first. Because when I start trying to hold you accountable, I can remind you why I'm holding you accountable to that. Because like you need to get from point A to point B, and you can't get there doing half the work. You've got to give give it all you got. So, um, but really and truly it comes down to activity more than anything, especially you know, on the sales side. Um, so I know how many calls my girls need to make every single day in order to get where we need to get. So if we're at half of that at like two o'clock in the afternoon, I'm like, okay, look, we only got a few hours and we're not where we need to be. I'm like, okay, look, guys, I need this many calls in the next 30 minutes. I need this many calls in the next 30. And I'll kind of start breaking it down in small chunks. Yeah. So that they're not that I don't say, look, I need 500 calls in the next four hours. I'm taking like a little overwhelming.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Yeah. It breaks it, you know, but that's just like, you know, when an agency owner says, okay, I need to grow 30,000 points in the next however many months, they don't get that. That's not their, they work on a day-to-day basis. So I break it down to the point that they can, it's small chunks for them so that they can get to where they need to go along the way. And I don't make it about, I tell them all the time, I'm like, look, this is not about me, this is not about Eric. This is not about the agency. I need you to do this for yourself because you have stuff you want to do. And if I can get them to do it for them, everybody wins.
SPEAKER_03Find their driving force, then tie the activity to the result, give them the driving force. I mean, it's it's a simple formula, but yeah, but one that many agents putting out fires all day long don't end up getting down and doing this most important activity, right? As an agency owner or or operations manager, this is the most important activity, in addition to those phone calls.
SPEAKER_05Right.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. It's and I would probably say consistency, right? It I mean you were doing that every day, all day, right?
SPEAKER_04Said that one more time. I'm sorry, I missed part of that.
SPEAKER_01You you do that, you were doing that every day, all day, and you continue to do that all day, every day. So it's not something like, oh, this week, this week they're into this, but trust me, it's not gonna last long. I've been allowed to do that.
SPEAKER_04Um, and that was a struggle for me in the beginning, I'll be honest. Um, you know, it really took me a while to hold people accountable because that was something that I was like, know what you're doing, you know. Um and it was just like, why aren't you doing this? You know what you have to do. So I kind of had to get in the um in the groove of holding people accountable and then getting consistent about it so that I'm not doing something one day and then not doing it for four and then doing it again another day. So yeah, it's all day long I'm reminding them of what we're doing, while we're doing it, and how we're gonna get there.
SPEAKER_01That's my biggest problem. My honestly, my big like I'm always everywhere, and it's like just getting on those consistent things. And when I do and I get a process and I'm consistent, you see results. But you you jump on all these things and you're like, okay, I'm reviewing calls, and then next week you you miss them.
SPEAKER_04That's why you have a me.
SPEAKER_01That's why you have a you.
SPEAKER_05That's right.
SPEAKER_03Stephanie Hamilton clones. Only available on insurance dudes.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_04I'll start making little little me's bobbleheads, that's awesome.
SPEAKER_01That is awesome. Um, what other nuggets, what other pieces of information do you think that agents like seeing seeing it from your side is so awesome because you get to look at it from a non-objective uh view? Uh right, is that right? Non-subjective or whatever.
SPEAKER_05Whatever we want to call it, it's fine.
SPEAKER_01Whatever. We don't want to talk about from a different view, and you can see it from a different perspective. So, what do you see? Like, like help me and Craig right now. Like, what would you what's your best advice for us?
SPEAKER_04Uh really and truly to to say that again, besides having me?
SPEAKER_01Anything without knowing anything about us.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_04Like I know nothing.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Um so really and truly, it's to delegate as many tasks as you can. That honestly, because um, and it's just like, you know, I was talking about Eric, like he can't do it all. It's it's literally not possible. There's so many, there's so many little things that get missed every single day just because there's not enough time and there's not enough use going around. So, you know, if you can find people that can take things from you that you feel good about, that you trust them, but you know nothing, you know, we're not gonna have any balls dropped, we're not gonna have any issues with, you know, compliance or anything like that. Um, that's probably the biggest thing is because you start replicating things that you can do and take off of your plate to where you're working more on the business instead of in the business. And I never understood that when I owned my own agency. And that's probably why I'm sitting where I'm sitting today, is because I did not grasp that. I was like, no, I can't like I can't relinquish these things because nobody else is gonna do it right. Um, it was more of a you know, it was a control thing. You know, you didn't want to, I didn't want to give any of that up. And um, so and that was one thing when I came here, I was like, okay, you look, you're gonna start passing some of this. He's like, What do you want? I said, I want your emails, I want payroll, I want this, I want that. He's like, Um, do you even need me here? No, not really. We're good. We're good, you can go. But that's you know, that's that's the biggest thing for agency owners, I think, is find somebody that you can trust that you can give the uh retain, you know, listen to the calls is a time sucker, really. Um and payroll can be a time sucker at time. Give things, give those things away so that you can do more stuff that you need to do to help the agency grow.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, makes sense. Keep it stay at the strategic level. Yeah, right. The agency owner should be up at the strategic level as you know, run uh uh being the business owner, not the business operator. Right. You have somebody else down here working on the tactics that support that overall vision and strategies, that you know, whatever they are.
SPEAKER_01I'm so glad I remembered this. There was a question that so when we talked to um Eric, he mentioned he extracted 6,000 leads from his current book of business. And we went on through the cast because it went really well, so many great pieces of advice, and I never went back to it. I had it written down and everything. So it's way better to ask you because you did it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01What how did you do that? How did you learn that and the methodology behind that?
SPEAKER_04So the first one of the questions he asked me, and I guess I was, I don't know if I was really interviewing or if I was already hired. I'm not really sure how all that worked. I mean, I was kind of like, yeah, I'll take the job. Yeah, you know, do a professional interview. But uh, here he comes. So I'm gonna have to listen, he's gonna have to listen to me tell this. So um he his first question to me was like, So are you gonna uh make me start spending an extra $10,000 to $20,000 a month on leads? And I was like, No, why would I do that? And he said, Well, um, I don't really want to do that. I was like, we're not doing that. I was like, dude, how many win bags do you have? And he was like, What? How do I run those? And I was like, Oh dear God. I was like, how many recoins? And I was like, I don't know. I was like, oh, okay. So I mean that's where we started. And we ended up coming, I think by the time we narrowed it all down, we probably got anywhere from three to four thousand, getting duplicates out and you know, people that just junk that you don't want. Um, but we probably ended up getting a good three to four thousand out of there that um, and we've actually written some in the last couple of weeks. So um just narrowing down processes and stuff that you can do stuff off your own book that you know you don't learn in school, they don't teach you that stuff. You kind of have to figure stuff out on your own. So that stuff really helps.
SPEAKER_01So just taking the time to really dissect all those reports that we always push aside. I don't think not many if you want to be real, like not many agencies have a great win-back process. Right. Four week quotes.
SPEAKER_04Um but they work and they're free. I mean, you already got them, why not work them?
SPEAKER_03And we have the technology. I mean, you export a list, you dump it in there, and it starts doing it, right? Oh, easy is yeah, instead of spending 15 bucks on each of those dials.
SPEAKER_05Right, right. Yeah, but but it's true, right?
SPEAKER_03Like if each of those 30, 3,000, think of the cost at 15 bucks per yeah, that's 45 grand in leads if I did the math right. I mean crazy, right? Right there. And and if we know if we know from data how many times they've actually been worked, right? They probably called them three times at the most, right? When we know from basic data 20 times why we didn't call them 20 times.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, so you just create free leads. It's great. Free leads are good leads, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. As far as uh uh processes, do you do you find it more advantageous to mix those in with like an agent, the win backs, the requotes, and all that stuff, or do you find it more advantageous, like, okay, now we're gonna focus on win backs?
SPEAKER_04No, I mix them all in.
SPEAKER_01Mix them all in. And what as far as scripts and the way you go into it, um, how would you approach a win back?
SPEAKER_04Okay, it's super easy. You're gonna laugh when I tell you this. But so when they I mean, they're calling. Are you gonna role play with me, Jason?
SPEAKER_01Sure.
SPEAKER_04Okay. So, like the phone's ringing and you Hello? Hey, this is Stephanie. How are you today?
SPEAKER_01Pretty good.
SPEAKER_04Good. Hey, I am calling from Eric Brown's All State Agency, and you used to have your policies with us. We've had a lot change since you left. Do you still live at 123 Main Street?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but you guys are way too expensive. I tried to call in and uh the phone, I went to voicemail, so I just did ended up going to Geico.
SPEAKER_04Hey, I understand. Uh hey, look, I I understand completely, but look, I promise you a lot's changed. It won't take me about 15 minutes. I can have you a quote ready, and I promise you we're gonna go over your coverages, make sure everything's good and that you are taken care of. Are you still um driving that 2019 Range Rover?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, if you are you gonna give me a better price than you gave me? You guys are expensive. I'm paying half as much.
SPEAKER_04Hey. Hey, look, I understand price is important. It's it's important to everybody. But look, what's most important is what kind of coverage you have. So I'm gonna make sure that you do not walk out of here today or that we don't get off the phone without going over what coverage you have and to make sure that you are taken care of. I don't want you calling me in six months when you've had a wreck saying, Oh my god, I don't know if I have enough to pay for this. No, we're gonna make sure you got enough to pay for it. So are you still driving that Range Rover?
SPEAKER_01Boom, there you go.
SPEAKER_04And I think that that's not gonna be objections, Jason.
SPEAKER_01I was like, dang, if he comes up with one more, like no, but listen, like I hear about everybody in different states and stuff, and I I I hate ever being negative. I never want to say like, but I'll tell you one thing, California, everybody's too busy for everything. It's all about price. So like ours is really the at that point, because we do all the that stuff, but it's like now it's a numbers game. We got to hit a lot more people because people are just um, but those are the real objections that we get, and we get a lot of hangouts and stuff like that.
SPEAKER_04But yeah. And we get, I mean, I'll be honest, you're gonna get those anywhere. Um, and I don't, and you're probably right. Um, California is one of those states that's just a monster of its own. Um, but you're gonna you get a lot of those same object objections every single state. It doesn't matter. Um it's just how you handle them. And then you do have to figure out, you know, how many of these am I gonna have to call to get a sale? Because you guys may have to call a lot more of those type people than we do. And you just kind of have to figure out your numbers and you know, I I need to call X amount to be able to get a sale on a win back and start rolling with them.
SPEAKER_01Yep. No, that's it. I mean, that's what we've like like I told Craig uh we're it's about 15 to 20 calls right now that we're getting a sale on, and you know, our agents make like 300 calls a day, and it's a lot, but it's the way that you equal the amount of other states.
SPEAKER_04So it's like you just figure out what happened. You kind of gotta figure out your own numbers and figure out you know what you gotta do every day to get where you want to go. But once you figure that out and you start doing it, you're gonna write what you need to write.
SPEAKER_01And I think when you role-played right now, the key piece is everybody says assume the sale. Like you're constantly needing to assume. You kept at you explained something, but you never asked, Do you want the quote? Like, nobody wants the quote. Nobody does.
SPEAKER_00No, I don't want a quote from you. I don't want to ask. I don't want to talk about insurance. I like it.
SPEAKER_03Do you want a root canal? No.
SPEAKER_00No.
SPEAKER_03No way. Take the focus off that, right? You're shit. And and Jason's over here focusing on price because that's what at the top of everybody's mind and what they're trained to in this world, right? Is it's about the price. And that's what Geico says, that's what Progressive says. It's what they all they all try to tell us. And so you're just steering it back to coverage, right? If you you little small wins every time that you say, look, we're gonna get you the right coverage. I agree the price is super important. However, we want to need to look at the coverages because that's even more important. When you have that accident and you've hit somebody and they're laying on the side of the road and are gonna sue you, are you concerned about how much it costs? Are you concerned that you have a million dollars of protection?
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_03Most important at that moment.
SPEAKER_04Right. Well, we had one. Um, actually, I think it was the first of this week. Um, they had actually gone to progressive and they had slashed their coverages to state minimums. And so, and we got them back and gave them what they needed. So, you know, it's you know, people don't understand when they go somewhere else and they're just getting a cheaper price. They don't really understand what's happening in that process because it's not explained to them. They signed the policy, they got what they got, and just hope to God they don't get in a wreck during the process.
SPEAKER_03Right. Yep. The cheapos are gonna focus on the price because that's how they win, right? That's right. We're gonna focus on the coverages because that's how our clients win. Right. So that's where the fundamental difference is is we actually care about their outcome, right? That they don't even know that they that they have. Their most important outcome is to have the right coverage. Right. At the end of the day, that that's it. They don't know it, they think it's to have the best price. Yeah. But you're, I mean, you do great job. Thanks.
SPEAKER_01And I've noticed too, like uh tell me from both of you guys and your agencies. Um I've noticed that agents think that they've gone through that the quote and they've uh built all the value and stuff, but like the next day or the day after, if you talk to them, it's like uh the the client doesn't realize or they don't remember all that stuff. So you gotta like resell them. So it's hard to like for me, like we're conscious about it now in the office, but letting everyone know listen, you every time you get on the phone, you need to resell those benefits and uh coverages and everything as if they don't know because chances are there's no way they can memorize what you said.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03In the same way that Stephanie identified with the staff what the purpose is. I think oh, she froze for a second. But the but it in the same way you find out the purpose for the staff, right? You're diagnosing the staff's need, we need to we diagnose their need, and then we're served like the value doesn't matter if you serve that value and it's just some benefit, right? If the if it truly benefits them, where it's the coverages, and you know, here's the accident or whatever, right? You uncover, you show them. Um, a great little a great line we heard somewhere was if if every time you hop in your car, imagine taking all your stuff, everything you own, all your bank accounts, everything and stick it in your trunk. And you're driving around with everything you own in your car. Because if you hit somebody, you injure them, that can be taken. Now they're now they're thinking about that, right? So we have to move them to that spot so we can give them the benefit. Otherwise, they do. You're right, they forget.
SPEAKER_01Even even if you give the best presentation, I still like, dude, next week when all their crap's going on, the kid was you know screaming in the morning, wife's mad at the dude, and the dude answers the phone. There's no way he's gonna remember all the crap told him.
SPEAKER_04I feel like the wife's mad.
SPEAKER_01That's what I was thinking. Why couldn't yeah, why couldn't he be mad at her? Why didn't I have to be mad at Lara? I think God my wife doesn't listen to this. She she's been brought up now a couple times. Several times today. We're all good too. Oh, just four foot again.
SPEAKER_04How many times is that today? Like three or four, probably. It's fine.
SPEAKER_01Probably, yeah.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_03You guys are such a good uh a good combination too, because you're you're here tactical. Eric's very strategic, and and how does that interaction like how often are you guys talking? Because you said he could go drink beer, or I know that that isn't what he wants to do because he's pretty active in a lot of different things. He's sitting here laughing.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_03So not beer. Sorry. Poke your head in, Eric. Say hi.
SPEAKER_05He said, poke your head in, say hi.
SPEAKER_03Hey, there he is. Look at that. Yeah, how how does that work and how how much interaction is there?
SPEAKER_04Um, well, I mean, of course, there's been a lot more in the past two days because I've been here. Um, but honestly, we probably talk what four or five times a day. Three or four. Yeah. I mean, if we're not talking, you know, somebody's texting the other one. Um, and you know, this is all new, I guess, you know, really for both of us. So it is a it's a newer process. Um, as time goes on, we may not talk as much. Um, we may talk more, depending on what um what else is going on. But um, we actually talk quite a bit throughout the day. Um he always knows where, like what I'm doing and what's going on and um like what I'm telling the girls so that if I'm not in the office and I'm like, hey, can you run in there and you know fix this or do that? Or um, or if he's out of the office, um, I know where he's at, I know what's going on. That way um, we're always kind of both on the same page so that um there's no disruption in anything.
SPEAKER_01Communicate document that do you have some sort of like strategy session to know like where to go and create clarity and all the fun stuff? Um yeah, I just gave you access to my calendar.
SPEAKER_04I was about to say, yeah, I kind of just have access to everything. I was like, hey, I need this, this, this, and this. Okay.
SPEAKER_03And how easy it is it now? You know, it's 2019. You can you can give access to all these different things, and it's it's everybody's accessible at every moment.
SPEAKER_04You just gotta be willing to do it, honestly. Um, if you're willing to do it, you got somebody that you know you can trust and you know that's going that's got the agency's best interest at heart, um, and you're willing to do that, I don't know why you don't. Because that can just free up so much more of your time for you to do other things that you need to be doing. So it's it makes life so much easier.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Quick question. Did did you create a uh a an exit plan? Like when you've changed role?
SPEAKER_04Did I create an exit plan? Like from one agency to another? Yeah, like like because in my mind, I kind of did, I guess.
SPEAKER_01No, I mean, I mean, because I'm now again, I'm thinking selfishly, like, okay, so I'm building this role and um I mean it it got you gotta have somebody on deck that can you always gotta have somebody on deck, right? They can replace a role or something like that. Is that something that was implemented or is that something that I don't know?
SPEAKER_04Um no, um, because no.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I don't know. I don't know. Which is something that's scary, right? If you have a Stephanie Hamilton who's doing it all for you, and then Stephanie Hamilton is no longer there, there's a big hold a plug, right? Like we we need there's all of a sudden a lot of water coming in the boat, right? And how do you fix it?
SPEAKER_05Right, yeah. But I would also fix the boat from sinking.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I would also say this. I mean, that's a good that's a good thing to do. I mean, uh as you're delegating and all this stuff, I mean, creating processes and being able to, I mean, if it's written down, somebody can follow it, right? So it's like Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Um, and that's you know, that's a good that's one of the good things for agency owners to be aware of, though, is that you know, you kind of need to be on the same page with the people that are in your agency, especially if you're gonna put them in a leadership role. Um make sure that you're always talking to them, you always know what's going on, um, because things like this do happen. And you know, there is no exit strategy. Um, you know, you kind of um have ideas and then um they start to transpire and you figure out real quick that you can make it happen, and it's either a do or die kind of thing. You kind of have to jump on board, and you know, if if you don't support their ideas and you're not all on the same page, then things like that do happen and there is an exit.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, and then but that's all business and that's the way it's gonna go, especially when you're successful and all that stuff. It's just gonna happen.
SPEAKER_04It happens, yeah. You know asking hard questions over here. He's asked the hard questions, Craig. You didn't warn me about that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I know. Well, I'm just honestly, I'm just curious. Like, I love I'm so like I love business in general. Like, I would probably say like business and processes are more interesting to me than insurance. Can you believe that?
SPEAKER_05Oh, I agree. I agree.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, execution of those processes, right?
SPEAKER_04Like just to see them through and then what's not worth what is what yeah, it's yeah, insurance is not that interesting. I mean, it is what it is, everybody's gotta have it, but you know, I like to figure out how you can make it better. So I'm kind of with him on that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well I until this episode or until we started doing this, like I I would tell people that like insurance is boring. Like it is boring. It's not exciting. No, it's not. Nobody wants to talk about it. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04We're all selling the same thing, we're just doing it a little different.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_04I mean, really.
SPEAKER_01One agent was so funny, he always says that he's hawking snake oil. It's just but he's joking, of course, you know what I mean? But like he's a he says, I'm a snake oil salesman.
SPEAKER_04Can you please uh message me his name because he and I will probably get along great.
SPEAKER_01I love that stuff. I love it too, because I mean I don't I don't think that. Uh, but I mean a lot of people do think that. It's fun to make fun of us because we're just yeah.
SPEAKER_03We're all doing the same thing.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Well, awesome. Anything that you could think of that that we should have asked that we missed?
SPEAKER_04No, I think Jason covered it all.
SPEAKER_03Oh, it was all Jason, huh?
SPEAKER_04I was about to go. Oh Lord, my seat's getting like I'm about to start rocking back and forth. What are you gonna ask next?
SPEAKER_03He gets tired, he's just he just gets real, you know, he's out here.
SPEAKER_04Just I'm gonna I'm gonna request a list of questions next time and go. I need these prior to the dudette conversation, okay?
SPEAKER_03Well, well, thank you, Stephanie Hell uh Hamilton, the the for uh one of the few insurance dudets.
SPEAKER_01Dudets. Dudet. You're the queen, you're now the the queen dudette right now.
SPEAKER_04I'll take that. I'll take that title. I'm gonna make Eric have me a sign made that says that. We're trying to figure out what the copy. Yeah. They were trying to figure out my title, so I'll take that. Yeah, I'm gonna have that my email signature.
SPEAKER_01We gotta get you a caricature.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I mean I need to.
SPEAKER_03Thank you, Stephanie. Appreciate your time.
SPEAKER_04Thanks, guys. It was fun.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Appreciate you.
SPEAKER_02Thank you. We will see you on the next one.
SPEAKER_04All right, bye-bye.
SPEAKER_02Bye-bye. Your insurance dudes podcast is sponsored by Agency Vall, an industry leader in agency coaching, hiring and retaining top talent, and sales training with the seven-step trusted advisor sales framework. Are you up for the challenge? For $99, you'll get 28 days of access and an opportunity to join a private platinum coaching group. For more information, navigate to www.agencyvault.com.
SPEAKER_01Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman