The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub! https://www.theidudes.com/Are you interested in learning “How To Predictably Sell 6-Figures A Month Fro...
Hey Craig, let's get into some coffee talk. Hey, I love it. I love doing some coffee twerk. Well, you know, talk about what? Dogs, daughters, whatever. It's coffee twerk. Coffee twerk.
SPEAKER_03
Oh, Mr. Craig. It's a coffee talk.
SPEAKER_00
What are we gonna talk about?
SPEAKER_03
Coffee twerk. Dogs. You little crying emoji you just put on there? You're a little hangry right now.
SPEAKER_02
A little hangry, Craig.
SPEAKER_03
A little hangry. Craig, I wanted to go. I wanted to talk to you a little bit about leadership. What do you think about that?
SPEAKER_02
It's a subject I love to talk about.
SPEAKER_03
It's a good one. It's a good one. And um I I actually have an agent, and I used to be like this. I used to be the agent that when somebody came in, this is kind of what I think a lot of people like it's like, well, when you prove yourself to me, then I'll buy you leads and I'll put more where are you going, right?
SPEAKER_02
Closer to the Wi-Fi. We have to get a our Wi-Fi changed up around here. Oh, we gotta do that sometimes. I'm gonna sit on the I'm sitting on the floor in the kitchen in my office.
SPEAKER_03
I don't even know. Oh, yeah. Prove yourself to me concept. And I and I feel like a lot of agents have that mentality, like prove yourself to me. They do. But I don't know if that's great leadership. Aren't you supposed to lead by example?
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, well, that's the saying. I mean, I came into it with that with that mindset too, and I've since changed that. Right. Um, you know, I always say the Darth Vader leadership, right? Doesn't for me. I think I I came in coming from Merrill Lynch, playing by hand, you know, all day long, you know, whatever, 500 tiles, grinding, grinding, grinding. It's just, you know, whether it's a different world now or um or it's just 2020, um, regardless, it's it doesn't work. You know, and and I know that it was I grinded, but it and it was a struggle. It's like it could have, it could have been so much better if if there was actually a leader when um you know, when I was younger and going through that grind. Like there was nobody, it was just like figure it out, right? And hardly any, well, there was internet, so there was stuff to read, but and boards and and that kind of thing. But it was like you have to figure it out. And and a lot of people don't well, how did that be figure it out? Pretty alone, alone on an island, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_03
It doesn't feel good to to figure it out, right? No, it's like it's like it's like that dad syndrome that some people get where it's like, oh, I I had a truck through the snow, so you gotta be a man and deal with this. It's like but it's like, dude, did you like doing that? Well, no. Well, then why the heck would you make your kid do that? Like, what would you like? I don't know.
SPEAKER_02
It's the right of passage or something, right?
SPEAKER_03
Yeah. I don't like that mentality. I'm not a very doo-doo dude like that. Like, I don't have that in me. I I always question stuff, and and I just don't understand why people have that kind of mentality. I don't think if you look at it this way, I want the best result, right? Well then get the best result out of your people. Don't set them up for like a failure type thing. Because, like, let's say half the people don't work out with your with your you know, prove yourself concept. Dude, how much did you just spend hiring that person, having them figure it out, and then they're gone? Not to mention the morale and the office and everything else that goes along with that. That's not a culture that I would want to be a part of, right?
SPEAKER_02
Well, the audio is all you there.
SPEAKER_03
I am here, Mr. Craig. I'm waiting for your words of wisdom.
SPEAKER_02
Um like uh like Grant Butt must said, right? We've had him on the show, and and his whole thing is about culture. I mean, he gives out, and I was, you know, I was up in the middle of the night thinking, because you're always thinking right about this stuff. And um, I was thinking about how he gives unlimited vacation. And I thought it has to work, otherwise, he wouldn't give unlimited vacation, right? Otherwise, so here's the here's what can happen. Here's the outcome of that, right? Everybody never comes in and they say, I have unlimited vacation, right? But if they did that, then clearly you can't have the pair. So I think that it it's almost this reverse psychology, right? Here, you can take off as much as you want, but they're gonna feel bad if they do. And and so, in the same way, if if if you bring it, like it, like it doesn't mean lead by example doesn't mean you're out there writing policies, but it but it at least means well, maybe you are when you're the beginning of the whole thing, but it at least means you're coming in, you're helping to train, you're you're supporting them, right? You're giving them support from the leadership potential. And and and hey, maybe it's not you. Maybe now you've grown enough where you can hire somebody that can do that, but you have to provide the tools, right? You can't say go be a carpenter, but use your hands the whole time and put all this stuff together over here because I had to, right? That okay, great. That what did you teach, right? And to your point, and the cost, like I could like my team that I have now, since I've really gone into the JSON framework or mindset of um not making them, you know, the non-Darth Vader approach. I haven't had turnover. Like they're they're here, right? They're all here, it's on them. I provide training, I provide the resources, they get hundreds of leads a day, they have telemarketers. Like, you couldn't get a better they have the uh the highest base in the in Tucson. Like you couldn't get a better, here you go, right? And we're gonna teach you everything than what they have. So they'd be crazy if they want to be in this business to go anywhere else. The only other place is to go to a call center, which may pay more, but there's a trade-off there.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, and then you provide the culture that allows them to feel free and not want to be a part of that kind of thing. So you're providing them more value than they're providing you. Well, not necessarily, but you're providing them with a you're leading by providing them with value instead of saying, I'm not gonna give you value until you prove yourself you until you provide the value to me, then I'll provide value to you. You're not doing that. You're providing them value and they're providing you value. That's a good relationship, right? It's not a yeah, it's not a take, a take, then I'll give relationship. It's a it's a give take.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, and I'm always looking, and I know you are too, right? I always have I have a uh a virtual assistant that is like that looks at the ads, does the whole thing, right? Runs the the hiring part of it. Um, and back before COVID, we had the the the team hired thing going, you know, and now we're not doing that so much because we're just working the leads on indeed or whatever. But um, you know, so you always are trying to fill that pipeline because you never know if you're gonna find somebody. And I haven't played, I haven't had somebody new come on in a while, just because nobody good has come along, right? And nobody's made it before three, four interviews. So the other part is is not getting in that cycle of okay, you're Darth Vader, they don't like it, they leave. Now I gotta scramble to find somebody. I scramble to find somebody they suck because I made concessions, right? It's it's like, okay, we got the right team, we got the right culture. We're not bringing in somebody that's gonna rock the boat. And if we do, then it's on me. So we go super slow now, super slow. I've had somebody go through four and then say, nah, it's not 100% on it, and I'm not gonna do it unless it's 100%. And we all and everybody votes. And if one person says no, then it's no.
SPEAKER_03
Wow. Love it.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, because you're gonna rock that, you're gonna rock that boat.
SPEAKER_03
Don't they say about it? Rock that boat. It's cancerous. No, it's not cancer. Oh, yes, they do say that, Greg.
SPEAKER_02
It's like brand COVID in your office. Everybody gets sick all of a sudden.
SPEAKER_03
Right. Don't do it.
SPEAKER_02
Don't don't do it.
SPEAKER_03
So leadership begins with you, and it begins with that first impression you make on your staff and everything else. It's kind of hard to flip an opinion back, right? It's kind of like on a sale, it's kind of hard to recoup once you lost the the trust or the you know, the whatever anyways. It's been a long day, Mr. Craig. Let's deal with that. Oh, really? Yeah, do it, do it. One more thing. One more thing.
SPEAKER_02
Drop it, drop it like it's hot. The leadership, it it like you said, it it all comes down to the leader, him or herself. And what you see a lot, and in the you know, on the internet or wherever you talk to people, you hear people complaining, right? Oh my staff, oh this, but they're complaining, they're trying to, they're making up excuses about everybody else when at the end of the day, it's your business. If shit isn't working, it's because of you. And I think understanding that, like, okay, it's falling apart. Like you you changed some stuff and and some and it got a little wonky, and you're not writing as much, and you didn't start going, well, it's you know, their fault, it's their fault. It's like, did I do the right thing? You know, it's like you think about it, and it's like, hey, look, if if things go sideways, it's my fault. If things are going great, then I give them credit. But when it's going sideways, I know at the end of the day it's it's the dude looking in the mirror in the morning. It's it's it's my fault.
SPEAKER_03
And you know, it's the man in the mirror.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. You know, and yeah, it's it's critical to to be able to put the ego to the side. Kill the ego. Ego has no place in this freaking place, it doesn't do anything. Oh the best. Oh, my decision is final and right. It's like it does why why?
SPEAKER_03
Ego is a vibe.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, it is, and it's like everybody wants to be right, but be it doesn't matter if you're right, it matters if you're effective, it matters if you put the right things in place, it matters if you take responsibility. You know, there's so many things happening in the real world right now. Is is it this? Is it this? Who knows? Well, what do you ultimately you got to look at the outcome? What is your outcome? What are you trying to do? You know, like the the people call the the clients call, they complain about something, and it's like you don't need to get in this pissing match about the how. Just say, look, what's your outcome? What do you want? What's your outcome? What did you expect? What are your expectations? We'll solve for that. I'm gonna sit here, this happened. Then uh you know what? What do you ex what is your expectation of what should happen? And then let's work backwards. Rant over.
SPEAKER_03
I love it. Love it. Truth.
unknown
Truth.
SPEAKER_02
But are you looking at the man in the mirror? Let's we gotta drop that song. I'm gonna listen to that after this.
SPEAKER_03
I'm asking to change his ways, it's Craig.
SPEAKER_00
Oh yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02
We lost a good one. We lost Michael. Lost a good one.
SPEAKER_03
We did.
SPEAKER_02
Oh, maybe not. Maybe it's a bad one. Uh who knows?
SPEAKER_03
I don't know. She did go to his house.
SPEAKER_02
Right.
SPEAKER_03
I literally don't know, and this is a true story. I'm at this crossroads in my life where I don't know what's true and what's not anymore.
SPEAKER_02
No, there's I could see something happen on the street and still be unsure if it actually happened. Yeah. I could I mean, is this just a big are we just in a dream? I don't know. If we are, we are the best insurance podcast in that dream. So thank you for listening. You, the listener. And that will be a coffee talk.
SPEAKER_03
Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudespodcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, subscribe.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.