The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Captain Kirk Baker - The New Frontier of Agency Service and Task Delegation Part 2 RECAST
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
It's already they called in. We have their name and number. We text it to them. We don't save it. Totally compliant.
SPEAKER_00It's you texting, not us texting. Yes. Interesting. Buckle up. It's the Insurance Dudes Podcast. What kind of things do you do in your agency for training? How often do you meet?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I'm glad you asked about that. We uh we're we're kind of obsessed with training. We uh we meet uh one every uh Tuesday morning from 8.30 to uh 9.30. And we use Team by the Minute when we do our training meetings. Uh in fact, we recently had a team uh planning conference up in the mountains, and we took a few days off and again used team by the minute to cover the office while we were out. And uh, but in those weekly meetings where we do things like we'll go over the life happens videos, you know, those ones that have those, you know, three, four-minute clips of a of an emotional story. We talk about questions and and the art of asking good questions. We'll read a good book. We talk about the competitive advantages of our products. We talk about how to story sell and and how to tell those stories that I talked about earlier with you know, with attention to detail and with emotion. Uh, we talk about notes that I get from my various study groups and recent conference notes. We'll go over that stuff. So training is huge. I'm I'm a huge believer in training because you know, trained people outperform uh untrained people. There's just that's the way it is. I mean, Michael Jordan, I love this one. Michael Jordan in in 1992 and 93, his season average was about 33 points a game. And then he went to play baseball for a year and then he came back. And the season after he came back, his seat his average dropped to 26.9 points. Okay. This is the this is the goat of basketball and uh Tom Brady, the goat of football. In 2007, he had a 16 and oh record, right? He had 50 touchdowns and eight picks. Uh, then he has the ACL entry, right? And then in 2009, when he comes back, his record is 10 and 6. And he had 28 touchdowns with 13 picks, which is still good, but not Tom Brady numbers. And uh so even the GOATs require training. We, you know, when we think that we've learned it all, that's wrong. We have we got to keep training. And you know, our team is starving for this stuff. I've made the mistake of thinking, oh, well, I I go to all these meetings and I know all the, you know, know what I need to know. But, you know, I made the mistake of not being consistent with my training. So I've really tried to turn that around the last uh couple years or so and spent a lot of time training and and role playing and taking that seriously.
SPEAKER_00You do uh call recordings and playback calls, grade the calls. Yes, yes. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03They love two misconceptions I think people have with this is one is when I first got into the agency, I thought that it takes away time from selling. Well, if we're training an hour a day, it's taking away time from selling. But then you start thinking about how much time you spent selling poorly, and then you're like, oh my gosh, like that's an incredible. Now you're wasting not only you know money on staff that can't perform as good, but then you're also, if you're buying leads, you're wasting money on that, you're wasting opportunity costs. But and then my other thing is this, and I always tell, I mean, I tell our staff this, and I tell other agents that it's incredible that why in insurance are we one of the only industries that don't practice things, right? Like your golfer practices his swing, right? Your baseball player pack practices swing, but we tend to do a different quote every time. Like we're only quoting so many different things, right? And I said it's the equivalent of going up to the plate and just swinging the bat around in every direction, different every time. It's like you can't get better if you're doing something different every time. You gotta have a process. Yep.
SPEAKER_04And the other thing we try to teach them is to listen. I've had team members that are talkaholics and they're just not effective. We teach them you got two ears and one mouth for a reason. Uh, you're gonna connect better if you really listen. And it one of the things on that that we teach is it's more important to be interested than to be interesting.
SPEAKER_00I like that. Yeah, they want to talk about themselves, right? The person who you're talking to is gonna be a multitude happier with you if they get to talk about themselves.
SPEAKER_04Yep. The other thing we teach them is keep it simple. All right. Let's not make this complicated. It's just insurance. Uh, and so, you know, keeping it simple is real, like for example, when it comes to, you know, they have these fancy calculators on what's the right amount of life insurance. Well, we'll we'll talk to them about, hey, a million dollars of life insurance is gonna produce about $4,000 a month of interest income. Okay. So with that as your rule of thumb, how much is $500,000? Oh, that's $2,000 a month. How much is $250,000? Well, that's $1,000 a month, right? How much is $2 million going to produce? So that's $8,000 a month, right? It just keep it simple. You know, it's and you know, so many people, it's like if you had a 4,000 square foot home burn down, would you want to replace it with 2,200 square feet? No. You want to replace it with the full amount. And so we talked to people about the right amount of coverage. You know, the average uh wrongful death lawsuit from uh 9-11 was 23 times annual income. This is the government paying people 23 times annual income. Now, most carriers won't even write 23 times annual income, but you want the what's the right amount? The most you can get. And Einstein talks about simplicity a lot. He says a true genius uh makes the complex simple, right? And uh I love what Steve Jobs says about simplicity. He says uh five gigabytes means nothing, one thousand songs means everything.
SPEAKER_03I like that. A true genius makes the complex simple.
SPEAKER_00I must be dumb. I make everything so complex. We're all guilty of it, Craig. Yeah. Well, why do we overthink it like that, though? You know, we overthink it.
SPEAKER_03I guess. It is funny when we do do like uh a new project or something, or something even in the office. Starts off simple, simple problem that needs to be solved. It gets all tangled up, and then we bring it back to the simple solution. There's all this craziness in between.
SPEAKER_04Do all this stuff in the middle with the Dr. Seuss tools. Yeah, and now I'll admit we don't do everything totally simple. Like, for example, we take it real serious when it comes to their liability needs. You know, we we'll start off, we'll do a review appointment, and we'll talk about okay, let uh has anyone ever gone over what is the right amount of liability with you? No. Okay, so let's let's talk about this because I I took this real serious. I contacted some of our company attorneys and I said, what's the formula for deciding if one of my clients kills someone in a car accident, what's at risk? And, you know, how do you determine what is going to be paid out? What's it based on? You know, give me the formula. So I took that formula and I put it into a spreadsheet, made a fancy calculator out of it, and uh, we call it our liability calculator. Uh, sometimes we'll call it the asset review. It plugs in in each little category how much they have equity they have in the home, how much they have in their savings, how much they have in retirement, all these different categories. And then we all and we also protect their income because you know they can lose 25% of their income for up to 10 years, and then that judgment can re be renewed for another 10 years. And uh so we'll go and we'll put that together, and that's kind of how we'll start our reviews. That that's kind of the the most important part of the review because most people have never had this done, right? And if you take just a few minutes to go over that, we do it in five minutes, right? We get all that stuff, we get make a recommendation, and let's say that their uh liability calculator comes out to you know 1.8. We say, hey, you're a good candidate for a $2 million umbrella, right? And we'll we'll uh write the umbrella. And then when we do that, it makes it an easy transition into the other products. Um, because we, you know, automatically when we do that, the calculator uh puts the money into four buckets a tax-deferred bucket, a taxable bucket, a tax-friendly bucket, and a tax-free bucket. And uh, you know, we talked to them about the different buckets and how they can maybe move some of their untax-friendly money to uh a tax-free bucket, explain to them how they can do that with uh some permanent life insurance or super Roth, whatever you want to call it, and makes for a smooth transition.
SPEAKER_00I know I know a lot of uh folks from the carrier who you may be affiliated with, and they're notoriously good at life insurance. And I'm curious how it's a magnitude better than than many of the agents from the carrier who I may be affiliated with. I wonder if you if you share a little bit of your process, how you get to that, um, why it's such an important part or or why it's just it's top of mind with you.
SPEAKER_04For me, I just have a passion for it. I mean, yeah, it just for other agents, I think that when the company you work for puts an emphasis on it, then you're smart to take advantage of that emphasis. They throw promos at it, they throw, you know, but honestly, it's not about the pins, points, and the plaques, right? It is about protecting lives. And so we whenever we write a uh a life app here, uh, we don't call it that. We said, hey, I just protected a life today. And it's a completely different mindset when you think of it as protecting someone's life. And I'm telling you, millennials, younger people like that stuff. It gives meaning to what they're doing, right? Because uh, and when we started doing that, they started taking pride in their work and feeling like they were kind of like the first responders of life insurance because we're protecting lives. And we are.
SPEAKER_03That's what it's all about. That is. Yep. It's funny how that does get convoluted over time. Like it's like it's definitely something that us as agents need to remind our crew and even ourselves at times. Like, don't bend on that. Like that's what that's what you do. At the end of the day, of course, you want the sale, and we can get wrapped up in that part of it, but it's gotta be about protection, which ends up becoming the best way to sell. Because people are shocked when you're like, Yeah, you can't do that. Like, like, why is that person telling me like that's not like they're so passionate about that? Maybe, maybe I am, uh maybe I don't have the coverage, you know what I mean? Like it's the most of our agents that sell a lot higher liability and such, and and also book a lot of life appointments and everything else, are the ones that are passionate about that. And they're pretty much you can't like that's something that's instilled in them. It's not like a they don't waver. Every policy, it's like this is the right thing to do, and they're passionate about that, and they they sell the most. It's incredible.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Another thing is I I you know, I belong to about six different study groups. I'll tell you the names because you'll get a kick out of the names: the Dirty Dozen, the Flying Turkeys, the Aces, Top 100, MDRT study group, and travelers. And when you're in a study group, you got to be doing hitting the company numbers in order to feel good about going back to that study group. And I attribute a lot of my success to my mentors and my brothers and sisters in those study groups because they help you think big, right? They give you some of an accountability to not rest on your laurels just because you're, you know, lifetime this or lifetime that, and you got all these awards, who cares? What have you done lately? Keep it up.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's got to be part of the process, right? I found if to Jason's point too, and well, to both of you, when if we do it differently every time, if we take the shack free throw approach, where it's just sort of who knows what the hell's going on here, you know, versus I like to use Kobe instead of Jordan, but you get there earlier, you stay there later, you you practice, practice, practice, but you practice to a process, to a form, to a way to do it, then it just becomes natural.
SPEAKER_04Uh yeah, that's one of the things we talked about in our one of our recent training meetings is the Mamba mentality. He took 2,500 shots a day. Uh, he had a work ethic that was second to none. He was up at 4 a.m. to work out even in the offseason. He was the first in and the last out. He did tap dancing for better footwork. He brushed, he brushed his teeth when he was a kid with his left hand so he could be more uh ambidextrous. He it was fiercely competitive. So I think having that momba mentality is cool.
SPEAKER_00Right. And most people don't have that ingrained. You have to force yourself, right? You have to hold yourself accountable to that. Like there's the days where you don't feel like it and you've got to make yourself do it. I've I brought it up several times. We we had a guest on, his name's Jamie Alderton. He's an English guy that does you know workout stuff, but he's a he lives in England. Yes. So every morning he goes and jumps in the ocean. In England. It could be and he does it and he says, Do you think that I want to go jump in the effing ocean every morning? And it's like, no, of course not. The last thing I want to do is jump in the ocean. But he puts on, he sets himself up for success. He puts on his swimsuit and goes to sleep in that. So every night, yeah, there's no excuse, right? Now, I don't know where my swimsuit is. I don't know. So he sets himself up for that success. And I think that we definitely can come up with excuses. And if we can come up with excuses, then our staff most certainly will come up with excuses. So we have to create lead by example and give those opportunities where we reinforce that kind of mamba mentality or the Jamie Alder didn't put in your swimsuit the night before type thing.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. And speaking of team, we need to, I think it's important to show our team appreciation and do little things. Like every day when they leave, I say, I'll tell them I appreciate you. That doesn't cost me a penny, but it pays off in spades because they feel appreciated. You know, we give them a 401k, we give them benefits, uh, we give them an annual trip if they hit their numbers to Hawaii or a cruise or snow skiing. Uh if they get a compliment by a policy holder, we give them a couple movie tickets. Can't go right now, but uh, you know, if a policy holder is out of line and they're being a, I'll support my team and I'll tell them, hey, you don't need to take that kind of abuse. You know, you you if they're cursing at you and yelling at you, you kindly exit yourself from that call. I care more about you and I don't want you to not like your job. I don't expect them to lie when it comes to screening the calls. If I'm not, tell them that I'm helping a client, but don't say I'm on another call if I'm not on another call. You don't have to lie for me. We do random bonusing, you know, just here's a certificate for a massage or get your nails done or some cash. Random bonusing is huge, right? When you then when they expect a bonus, they earned it, that's kind of a given, right? But when you do random bonus, that is when they really fall in love with you.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it is incredible. That is a good really good point because it is incredible. When somebody expects something, and it could be a great bonus, right? It could be your monthly thousand dollar bonus, but when you just eat, I mean, even a hundred, twenty hundred bucks, like little bonuses for things that they didn't expect, it's incredible how much it's appreciated. Yep.
SPEAKER_00Little surprise attack, right? They're not expecting it. Yep. Yeah, it's a double that a hundred bucks is a thousand bucks when it's a surprise.
SPEAKER_04And it's also important that we love what we do. Like I do all I have team members do all the parts of the job that I'm not good at. I don't know how to quote an auto or a fire policy. I have no clue, right? Um, and I haven't for over 20 years, but I like to make relationships. I call myself the relationship brain maker. Uh, I like to do review appointments with my multiple line clients. My appointment, my review appointments that I do with uh the single line clients, I have my team members do that so they can quote the auto without fire, the fire without auto. I like to do the team training meetings. I like to have team meetings and motivate them, get them excited, get them pumped up. That's what I like to do, so that's the part of the job that I do.
SPEAKER_03And I love that because some so many agents beat themselves up. Like so many agents that you talk like or that we talk to that are smaller, they think like they gotta do it all. I gotta do it all. And it's like you don't do the things that you're that you love to do so that to your point, the passion comes out, and then you love doing that and get somebody to do the other stuff because try to find the person that honestly is passionate at that. Like uh one of my service agents, she's uh an amazing agent, but she excels at service. You know what I mean? And it's like put the salespeople that excel at that, and then they they're all excited about what they do. It's a good energy.
SPEAKER_04And speaking of doing things that you're good at, we're hey, we're humble here. We know that we're not good at everything. So we like to outsource, right? So we have a company called Client Focus that does our appointment setting. So they call all of our clients once a year, schedule an appointment. It makes it so I don't have to, you know, harp on my team, get this appointment. You know, they'll still set some appointments, but client focus does the most of them. And uh they are fantastic. In fact, right now they're setting, you know, phone and video appointments. Uh, when things are back to normal, it's usually uh face-to-face appointment. You know, we talked about team by the minute. We outsource for that. We have tracking software like Racing Snail and Today Appro and uh use training programs uh like uh Insurance Training Institute, uh Foster Canon, uh Speed Training. We have you know our late pay calls outsourced to a vendor that does that for us. Uh, you know, for our HR service, we have an attorney on call for that. For our our time cards, we have Clock Spot, for you know, we have someone that does our bookkeeping. I I'm a big believer in outsourcing because you save money, you know, and you use companies like Team by the Minute and you're only charged by the minute. I mean, did you know that only your team is only at their peak efficiency about 30% of the day, right? But you believe it. You gotta pay them for 100% of the day. So with Team by the Minute, you're not paying them, you're paying them by the minute, right? I mean cool if we could do that with our team where we only paid them by the minute for at their peak efficiency.
SPEAKER_00So I'm I'm definitely peak efficiency about 10% of the day. If that truth, no, it's true though. Let's just before we get into the last question, I'd like to dive a little bit deeper into the team by the minute. How does that work? So you just flip them over and you flip the phones over.
SPEAKER_04Okay, good question. So there's two ways. We have some agents who use them as a receptionist. And what we found is about 70% of the people that call your office, they're just trying to make a payment. And so what we do is we have we'll text them a uh a link or a phone number, we'll connect them with uh our company has a you know a connection service that they can just make the payment there. So that they're not even having to pay for that, right? That's just connected right to the company, they make a payment, boom, done. So that's the receptionist method. The other method is the four-ring method. And this is where you just keep it on all day long. And if your team's like trying to juggle too many lines or they can't, they're in the middle of a sale and they don't want to put someone on hold, you know, you have it pick up after four rings. And uh, you know, you can have it on all day long. And if it only picks up for one minute, you're only charged for one minute. But you had your phones covered the whole stinking day. What about the day after Thanksgiving? What about holidays that you know that your uh your company's not closed on and you want to give your team?
SPEAKER_00We're obviously opened on those days.
SPEAKER_04And and and we got a new service. This is hot off the press. This is big. Okay, we got a a new feature that we've added to the uh service called the review service. I love this one. So you know how you're you know, there's these review vendors that are out there. I don't know if I can mention their names, but there's a bunch of them. You pay 200, 250, 300 bucks a month, and they have these little templates that you text or email to your clients, and hopefully you get a Google, a Facebook, or a Yelp review, right? Well, right. Um, what we're doing with uh Team by the Minute is we're asking for you, right? And we're sending the text and the email for you, right? That is awesome. And uh it's an added service. We include it for free for a little while for our new new clients, and it's a it's a brand new service that we're just Starting, but that it takes away having to ask your team to do one more thing, right? Do you like asking your team to do one more thing? You know?
SPEAKER_00No, they don't like being asked to do one more thing.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. So and it's totally compliant because you're not giving an outside vendor the name and number, right? It's already they called in. We have their name and number. We text it to them. We don't save it. Totally compliant.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Interesting.
SPEAKER_04Yep. And so it's sweet because you're building your reviews. You're gonna, instead of having a couple dozen reviews, you're gonna have hundreds of reviews. And it's gonna, and you don't have to, even with these other companies that you're paying two, three hundred bucks a month, your team still gotta ask, right? Right. If they don't ask, it ain't it ain't you're not getting your two or three hundred bucks worth. With ours, I don't remember exactly. I think we're charging like 89 bucks a month for that extra service, but so it's a lot less expensive, and we're doing it for you.
SPEAKER_03That is awesome. Yeah. Love it. So we're excited. Let's say the world was ending tomorrow. And there was a couple weeks. Okay, or for a couple weeks. And there was one piece of advice that you would give another agent that was starting up in this new world. What would be the number one piece of advice you give to anybody coming into the industry or new agent or somebody crazy?
SPEAKER_04For new agents, hey, I think it's really important to love what you do. Do the parts of the job that you like. It's not, you know, Jason, Craig, you guys, you're good at different things. I'm sure you're not clones of each other, right? You do your strengths. And uh I think it's important to learn how to tell good stories. I think it's important to learn how to uh sprinkle in good questions. Become expert in asking questions. It's not about blurting out how much you know and trying to, you know, sell, sell, sell. It's it's asking good questions, being a good listener and being skilled at that kind of stuff.
SPEAKER_03Love it. And then team by the minute.com, right?
SPEAKER_04For the Yep, team by the minute.com. You can Google them and you know we'll set you up with that discount, that 5% discount, insurance dudes five. We'll get to the five percent.
SPEAKER_00Doesn't matter, uppercase, lowercase, nobody.
SPEAKER_04All lowercase. Uh all one word, insurance dudes five.
SPEAKER_00Awesome. Insurance5.com or as the promo for the uh website. So we will definitely put that in the show notes down below.
SPEAKER_04That'll uh that'll show up when you check out, it'll be in your cart, be a little discount code, fill that in, get five percent off for all your listeners. Good until the end of April.
SPEAKER_00Ooh, Lord.
SPEAKER_03Love it.
SPEAKER_00Let's do it. All right, perfect.
SPEAKER_03Kirk, thank you so much for investing some time with us and uh getting some great messages out to all the insurance dudes and dudettes out there.
SPEAKER_04Yes, hey, thanks for having me. You guys are all right, thanks, Kirk. I love your podcast, by the way. I listened to them and man, I really appreciate you guys. You're doing a great service. We need you guys.
SPEAKER_03Oh, thanks. Yeah, man. You when we started this thing, man, it was all about just talking to people alerting from people like you. So I mean it it's honestly helped us so much. So thank you. Great job. Everybody else that's been on.
SPEAKER_02Cool. Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it?
SPEAKER_04Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_02Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium off of even the worst internet leads, where could they go? They can go to live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_01Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_02I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_01Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_02Live.teledudes.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_01Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_01Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah, which is awesome, but they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. Greg, are you gonna respond to these texts? I'm gonna respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it.
SPEAKER_02I'm gonna text it right now.
SPEAKER_01520 214 2219.
SPEAKER_02Alright. I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_01Bye, Mr.
SPEAKER_04Greg. Wait, can they even listen to this on the radio anymore?
SPEAKER_02I love it.
SPEAKER_00I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman