The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Representing The Agency Force with Ted Paris Part 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
One definition of success for people is successful people do what unsuccessful people don't. Insurance has been a great career. It's getting a little more demanding.
SPEAKER_00Buckle up. It's the Insurance Dudes Podcast. That reinvestment is what multiplies the thing. You growing those two books in that relatively short amount of time, I think you have an understanding that anything extra goes right back in, right? Otherwise, it's gone. You're not out buying boats and you know going to Vegas and that kind of thing. You have to reinvest in the agency, otherwise, it's gonna start to well, no, no, you're correct.
SPEAKER_01And I hope I didn't come across that you need to pay yourself an exorbitant amount of income. And my philosophy about you need to be the highest paid in your office might be that you're building equity in your business.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Well, I had a very simple philosophy in running my agencies, and also when I worked with the farmers district with the farmers as a district manager, when you have 25 agents working for you, they all have different goals and aspirations. Very simple philosophy, you do your budget. Okay. Right. And then when you're doing your budget, where do you want to be at? Okay, so if you have a $2 million agency versus a $5 million agency, the numbers are different, but you've set yourself your income level that you need. You set your budget up front about what you're going to invest in staff. Because staffing is not an expense, it's an investment. And agents who think staffing is too expensive or they have that employee mentality, they need to understand that your business depends on the assets you build up, not only the renewals, but how well your staffing does. And I would tell agents, and I would still tell agents, at the end of the year, you have a bonus. Okay. Whatever this bonus is, and however you're going to divide it up with your staff, you need to reward your staff to keep them happy, keep them satisfied. So good staff are hard to get. And then whatever you've done, if you have a bonus money left over, then half of it should go home and half of it should be reinvested. And you need to make sure that you're investing in your future by making sure you've got a retirement program set up. So I know a lot of agents, and the bigger the bonuses, the more money they spend, and the less money they have. So you better be smart about being that business person to do it. And since we're going to be talking about staffing, I'll do my little cutism that I have out there and stay point. You should har slowly, far quickly. And then the one that people always kind of raise their eyebrows back at me is that you can always replace someone who's not doing the job very easily.
SPEAKER_00Right. The whole notion of people want to avoid pain, it seems like with staff, and this happened to me back in the earlier years, where you have somebody, they're not great, but they're not terrible. And so you hang on to them way too long until it becomes so painful that you have to do the thing, which is to recruit and hire and interview and do all that stuff. Whereas now we're always interviewing. We all because you never know. You never know when you're going to lose three people all of a sudden because somebody else grabs all three of them or whatever happens, right? And so I think that being prepared is so critical in this and also foreseeing what is going to happen. Okay, well, if the commissions are going to go down or whatever, knowing what's going to happen so you can play that out, not just sit here, well, this sucks. This isn't fair. It's like, well, it is what it is. I need to figure out how to adjust, right? And I think it's just people in general don't like to change, don't like to adjust. That's a really, really important skill set to have as an agent.
SPEAKER_01You're true. I guess if you're in a smaller town with a little more personal relationships that you have to be concerned with, you never want to hire your cousins or your daughters, or be honest with you. I've seen agents do that, and something happens, you're all gone because it all happens the same thing. So I'm not against hiring spouses and staff and kids. But you need to make sure that you hold them to the same amount of responsibility that you would own someone else. But what I said about the thing about it is that your business, when you're growing your agency, you know, you got the growth spurt of it, okay? And then you used to be able to have the maintaining part of it, but most cafes' company are making that maintaining part a little more difficult. And they always want you out being the hunter versus the cultivator. So you always got to find talent. If you have someone who you have worked with and worked with and worked with and trained and trained and trained, now these cafes are wanting to turn all the service people into salespeople. Okay. And that can happen and can happen. You know, it's another one of my old sayings that someone from Tucky told me if you have a turd as an employee, excuse my language, and you polish that turd and you keep polishing and polishing, what do you end up with?
SPEAKER_00Polished turd.
SPEAKER_01Polished turd. And that's and so that's no better. It might be shinier, might be prettier. But that staff you work with, you who can't get to change and you can't get to improve, and you can't get their skill set, and they don't want to grow with you, then that's why I say that sometimes you need to replace a person, the person who doesn't do what you want them to do, you can find that guy or girl next off the street tomorrow. So it's it's tough to get rid of staff. I mean, no one ever wants to avoid to avoid that. But you know, when I own my retail stores and I had 60, 70 people working for me, it was a lot easier to replace those. And when I have three staff members who, if I know, know the family, know the kids, those are tougher to make those decisions. But still, you're probably doing that person as big a favor as you are not to let them get on to a new career or something that they might be good at, might like, might thrive at versus staying in a position where they're not comfortable.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, 100%. I agree. I mean, I think it's one of those things that if you take the emotion out of it or the dire like need for that person. And it's just like, dude, you want the best for them. So if they don't like it, it's like, why would you stay here if you don't like it? Like, why don't you get into something that you really like? And it's better for both of us in that way.
SPEAKER_01And why do you wagents stay in positions and jobs that they don't really like either? I mean, you got the fear of the unknown, is really what you know what it is. Uh, you're comfortable somewhat and afraid to take that next step. So people always ask me, what would I do? And I said, Well, you know what? I sold my farmer's district office at age 55, I sold my my captive agent at 62, so I'm not the person to ask that.
SPEAKER_02Well, I think some of us are wired differently. Yeah. I like to your point, like the fear of the unknown is what most people have. But like, though, sure you're the same way. It's like the fear of the known to me. Like, I can't do the same thing for 50 years. Like, that's how to but for me, that's like I just keep the opposite.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I'm attracted to the unknown because there's unlimited potential and possibility.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So this next step, it's you know, you are right, Jason. You're warred differently, and my wife would always cringe both times I I did those. Doing a lot, I'd say I already did it. What do you mean doing a lot? It's just done. Uh yeah, let's figure it out. But didn't do it all the spot.
SPEAKER_00Uh my wife cringes repaired.
SPEAKER_01I probably had repaired myself and already had the next thing in line before I was silly enough to do something stupid without having a plan. So and when your values where you're working at and the values of the company you're working with changes, then do you have a dilemma yourself there, other than just, you know, do I like the direction? Do I like what's going on?
SPEAKER_02But uh, which isn't a bad thing. I mean, heck, if you built your organization like a good business should be run. I'm sure it's scary to make those moves and the decisions, but I mean you can pivot and run your good organization with uh selling any product. I think that that's kind of like the equity that you'd like that's almost what keeps my head straight, right? Is like, okay, I just I'm gonna do what I do for my personal organization. And if I ever feel like the product that I'm selling or the company is going in a totally different direction that I absolutely don't want anything to do with, I'd be cool. I'd be cool, man. I want to keep doing what I'm doing, but I'm gonna do it with a different product.
SPEAKER_00Right. Find the opportunity. There's always the opportunity, there's always somebody winning. Identify who that is and do what they're doing.
SPEAKER_01And that's always easier if they're using yeah, most insurance agents want to share and willingly share with each other. So most of them have, and this isn't being negative, type A personalities, big egos. Uh they want to win the trips, they want to be recognized, and and the companies are always, whichever company it is, are always aware of that. And they know how to play agents in one whole time. But but doing well, being recognized, everyone likes to be recognized. Everyone wants to do well. And everyone's willing to share. I mean, that's why you have all these blogs out here. You know, most people are sharing uh and want to give back. But um insurance has been a great career. It's getting a little more demanding, and and I don't know if that's from the companies having an insatiable desire to make more and more profits uh than ever, and it doesn't need to come at the expense of the agency force. Okay, it can be equally shared at times, but you know, that's another story.
SPEAKER_00I think there's also some challenges in the competitive landscape, right? When you have the new players that have come along the last decade with much less expensive products and a consumer base that considers insurance to be a commodity and really doesn't see a big portion of the consumer base, doesn't see value to the agent. I think until they need them, right? Just sort of like insurance, like it's insurance. Oh, until you need it, then it's all these things are important. Maybe that's human nature. But that's, I think, created some pressure too. What are your thoughts on that?
SPEAKER_01Well, part of the problem with the captive company is they built their own little end powers out there. And at one time, these companies would have um different regions around, and some of the regions would, if you broke them up, would be some of the top 50 insurance companies. So they would have 14 different insurance companies out there with their CEO and their assistant CEO and their staff and their marketing, and they built up the sales force and marketing department. Uh, and it became like the federal government, you know, they had a budget and they had to spend all their money or their budget be cut. And heaven forbid they get their budget cut. So they got real fat in the middle.
SPEAKER_00Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_01And as they got fatter, these other companies would come out and offer a product that was loss ratios or loss ratios. I mean, it isn't cheaper for one company to repair a car or to fix a house or to pay a liability claim than another. But if you have a lower cost basis, then you can be less expensive. And the big captives got pressure from having bloated expenses and caused them to lose a great deal of market share. And there's five or six captive companies who all lost considerable market share because they got outsmarted. Uh, and then the insuring public bought into the thing about why pay more when you can get the coverage for less. Uh, the only problem with do-it-yourself insurance is when do you want your insurance cheap? When you bought it or when the claim was and unfortunately, sometimes if you bought it cheap, then you also had a cheap claim. If you bought the wrong policy, you might have a hundred thousand dollar deductible, not a $500 deductible. Yeah. But they got outsmarted, outwitted. The younger generation, I'm baby boomer, as you can tell, but the younger generation uh do a lot of do-it-yourself. I mean, they do go on the internet and check out. Uh, like my 39-year-old daughter, who's strictly a millennial, she'll check everything out, but before she buys, she calls dad. She said, Oh, what do you think? Uh, I'll take this, this, and this. But but uh, if you buy a cheap policy and you don't have the right coverages, you might be in a world of hurt when you get there, and then the insurance company will fall behind what this is what you purchased. We thought you knew what you were doing. If you're a captive agent, you get sued for Eno. Okay, you bought online. Well, you should have known better. You know, so there is a great deal of pressure from the companies, and then the the captive companies aren't allowed to have as risky investments. So if the market goes up a lot, they don't necessarily benefit as much because they can't have that much exposure to their uh reserves. Yeah, they got outsmart it to be to be honest.
SPEAKER_00Well, and if you look back in the last 10 years, the marketing spend for the ones for Geico and Progressive is astronomically higher than the captives. I think you could put all the captives together and and just Geico spent maybe double. It's a lot, you know, it's in the billions versus hundreds of millions. So it's just interesting. They created and developed that message of it's a commodity, right? You have flow over in the aisle with it's like a diaper aisle, but it's insurance. And and so they just created this monster that got out of control.
SPEAKER_01And like I said, we we sort of got outsmarted from the CAFTY world. There's still a number of people who want to deal with an agency for us, yeah. Uh and then have the advice. Most people will pay a little extra for the guidance and advice, uh, especially if they have a claim that wasn't covered the first time before they did it, they did their own insurance.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01Um that's tough. I mean, people don't want to pay more than they have to, and they have been hit for 15 years about well, I need an agent. They're too expensive, you can buy yourself without them. But here again, there's horror stories out there, and I think the captive companies should have been advertising what happens if you buy their own policy versus we can be cheap too.
SPEAKER_00Right. Cheap isn't better, like a whole marketing campaign about that type of thing. Where do you see the agent in 10 years, 15, 20 years?
SPEAKER_01Well, I I see the captive company or DM, and this is my crystal ball, okay. I would say it it's a WAG, and I'll let you W and then A S S guess. So a wild AS gas is what a WAG is, so we'll call it a WAG. So so my WAG is that um there's always going to be captive agents. Okay, are they gonna be in the numbers they are now? No. Okay. There's always gonna be agents in the independent world in areas that companies aren't wanting to go to as much as other companies. We had one guy say they're underserved markets, so I don't know if they're underserved or not. And there's always gonna be the online people and the direct people. I one CEO says that half the people want an agent and half the people don't. That might be a true statement out there that half the people want to do it yourself and can manage it and study and take care of it. Uh, the other half of people want someone to go to. What if this happens and help me out if this happens? So I I would say that most of the captive companies that I know of are going to have a declining captive agency force. Uh, the big dog, the big guy on the street uh out there is sort of bucking it and still thinking they're gonna need as many agents in the future as they do in the past, but that's that yes to be seen. So I would say there'll be shrinking captive companies will be a third or two-thirds or half as small as what they were.
SPEAKER_00In their agency force or their market cap?
SPEAKER_01Uh in their agency force.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01In their agency force. I tell people that if you're the mom and pop agent where you had one or two staff people working on a one on 123 Easy Street uh in uh main in hometown USA and have a $2 million, $3 million agency or smaller, and think that you're gonna survive technology and the shifting winds and sands of the insurance business, you're gonna be disappointed. If you're willing to invest and get a larger agency where you have eight to ten salespeople working for you and want to chase the uh be have the hunter mentality where you're always gonna be hunting for new business, hunting for new business, and and hope that the company reputation and claims and price will get people to retain with you and do a little bit of uh service work to help with that retention, take a lesser commission per policy, you could be fine. Uh but it's you can't sit on the fence. You either gonna have to go all in and do the investment, do the staffing, do the marketing, understand that you're not gonna be able to work hard for five years and then live the next 10 years on renewals, you'll be fine. You just hope that you're with the right company and in the right marketing place. I told one almost CEO, but was uh a pricing product manager one time that the world was not full of pink houses on Cul de Sacks. Okay, so that's from Indiana, and I actually saw John um Mellencamp play at a high school prom in 1968. Ooh, maybe some southern Indiana as well. Uh and he had that song Little Pink Houses, right? So all the insurance companies want little pink houses on colus sacks because there's no pools, there's no dogs, there's no animals, there's no bottom. Right. Yeah, there's no risk. They're not next to oceans and they're not next to mountains, and they're not in far areas. You know, everyone wants that piece of property. Uh, but um not everyone's gonna get that. So agents are gonna have to change. You know, in 19, I I saw something posted on on the page or our Facebook page, showed the app of a application that was in uh uh 1990, showed it. They found it somehow. He found it. It has the carbon papers, you know, six pages of carbon papers, and then turned the paper over, and then you had to make sure you were smart enough to turn the carbon with it so that you could actually read when you turn it on the other way, and a landlord policy of $120. Okay. And today that same landlord policy is thirty, seven hundred dollars, you know. Depending on where you're gonna be at. But I think there is a future for insurance agents. It's gonna be changed. Unfortunately, this is gonna be one of those ones where that if you're not willing to be bigger, uh it it's she's probably not gonna be around. So it's a tough gig if you're 60 plus and have a two million dollar agency versus being 45 willing to work 70 hours a week to build up your agency to 10 or 20 million dollars and uh and go forward from there. So it's gonna be a different mindset, different type of uh agency force.
SPEAKER_02That's awesome. I mean, that's awesome in the sense of that super clear, and I think that I agree a hundred percent. Which segues into the best follow-up to that is uh our last question, which is what would be the number one piece of advice that you would give any agent that uh wanted to really kick it into high gear or a new agent coming into the industry?
SPEAKER_01On the persistency and focus, determination held out for three words. One definition of success for people is successful people do what unsuccessful people don't. Okay. So a successful insurance agent is going to do the marketing, going to do the hiring of the staff, going to train the staff, going to have the three, five-year business plan. They're gonna be knowing what they're gonna be doing for the next month, not walking in on Monday morning with nothing to do, hoping the phone rings and someone wants to buy a car policy. Those days are over with, and you need to be more of a business person, as we talked about up front. Business person first, salesman second. Okay, and knowing that you have to be focused and determined. And then you need to be in the right area. If you're in farm ground, they need to be focused on farming. If you're in a city, you need to be focused on what's in the city and uh going forward. So determination, focus, persistency, a plan. The new agent coming in, well, they should have a mentorship for all new agents. The success rates of someone coming in scratch and borrowing money from mom and dad's 401k to start an agency, not necessarily a good investment for mom and dad.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I would think they should have a member a seven-year servitude like they did back in New England, back in the 1600s, you know.
SPEAKER_00Well, Ted, this has been awesome. Such uh good insight and information. If people want to check out Napa, could you spell out that website for us?
SPEAKER_01Uh of course it's Napa, the N-A-P-A-A-U-SA.org.
SPEAKER_00Cool.
SPEAKER_01W N A P A-A-U-SA.org.
SPEAKER_00And there's resources, and unfortunately, we're up against the wall here, but lots of resources there. Great group for agents to go to and really connect with other agents. So we really, really appreciate and are grateful for you coming on. Thank you so much. We'll talk to you down the road, hopefully, and uh and continue the conversation.
SPEAKER_02Thanks. Thanks for having me. Teddy, yeah. Awesome, Ted. Thanks so much.
SPEAKER_04Hey, Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it?
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_04Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium off of even the worst internet leads, where could they go?
SPEAKER_03They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_04I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_03Let's do it. Sign up right now live.teledude.com.
SPEAKER_04Live.teledude.com. That's live.teled.com.
SPEAKER_03Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_03Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah, which is awesome. But they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm gonna respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it. I'm gonna text it right now. 5202142219.
SPEAKER_04All right, I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_00I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman