The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub! https://www.theidudes.com/Are you interested in learning “How To Predictably Sell 6-Figures A Month Fro...
If you're asking somebody to go to a movie with you, you can't walk up to a stranger and say, hey, will you go to a movie with me? Because that's that's freaky. Right. That's insane. Well, what do you mean you don't have money? You do have money. Right. Like you have insurance. You have a car.
SPEAKER_01
Hey, Craig. Let's get into some coffee talk. Hey, I love it. I love doing some coffee twalk. Well, you know, talk about what? Dogs, twatters, whatever. It's coffee twalk. Coffee t. Oh, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_05
It's a coffee talk. It is. They know that. We gotta do a new intro. I know. Yeah. We gotta do a new. Because then we could go, oh, it's a coffee talk. And it's like, oh, okay. Well, they didn't just say that. Right. That'd make more sense. Or maybe we should just get rid of that.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. Maybe we should talk about this in our meetings instead of on the air.
SPEAKER_05
Truth. So here's something interesting. And I I know we were talking about uh somebody that had a separate business about this, but when we're doing our sales talk, it's a completely different mentality and different mindset when you talk to somebody in a social setting, or if you talk to somebody that in a sales type setting. In a sales type setting, you're not gonna ask them how, like if they want to do stuff, they're you're gonna ask them things that might have multiple variables. You're gonna want to just keep pushing them closer to the thing, right? We were talking to somebody about booking calls. Yeah and and the person kept booking calls, like getting into a conversation, hey, can I help you with anything? And kept asking them these like questions that weren't necessarily moving them closer to the thing. They weren't saying, okay, what's your name? I'm gonna reach out to you. We're gonna book this call. Would this time work for you? And those questions that are just definitive of what needs to get done. It was more of general questions. Do you want to book a call? Well, no one's gonna want to book a call. Like if you say these things that they don't want that you want, well, their answer is always gonna be no. So you have to move it in that direction and say, hey, we need to book a sales call. Let's do this tomorrow at five. Does that work for you? Yes. Well, yeah, they're either gonna say yes or no, it doesn't work. Okay, perfect. What about four? Do you think that would work better in your schedule? Well, no, maybe that'll work great. Yeah. Okay, perfect. Excellent. So I'm gonna call you at that time now. Make sure I know your time's incredibly valuable, and so is mine. And I just want to make sure that uh you're ready for the call or that I'm ready for the call at four tomorrow. So I'm gonna shoot you text right before, and then let's jump on that call right at four. I'll make sure that I'm not late for you. Wow, so great. Okay, that sounds great. Okay, awesome. So whether or not you're talking about booking a call or or whatever it may be, it's gotta be the conversation has to be putting yourself to the next step instead of putting the ball always in somebody else's court.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, I agree a hundred percent. You need to move the piece, right, forward. And I think what's also good in the how to eat the elephant, one bite at a time, is break it down into steps and look at what are you looking for for the outcome of that step that you're on, right? Because that's gonna change in the beginning. You're not gonna talk to them like they're your friend or somebody that you're acquainted with, because you have to get them first engaged, right? It's a different outcome in that first step. It's just to keep them there. Like it's so if we're talking whether it's the booking or like when we're calling for our leads, lead comes in, we finally get a hold of them. They don't necessarily want to do the quote, so we certainly don't ask them if they want to do the quote, right? If we were talking to our mom, we would be a little bit more friendly and be asking if she wanted to do that. Well, we can't do that in this situation. Once we've established that the quote is now happening, then we're in another step, right? Now we have to move it towards a sale, and so the conversation is gonna change, right? Then you're gonna become you almost do become friends at that point because they need to know you like you, trust you, all that stuff. So it is interesting, and I think that they need to know people have to really focus on what step am I in in the funnel right now, and how am I gonna move it to the next step, and then what is my outcome of that next step. A hundred percent.
SPEAKER_05
And I think a lot of the time people, and we all do it, approach sales like kamikaze pilots. Uh-huh. And the conversation is all over the place. Right. The conversation needs to be directed in a very linear path. Everything has to be intentional, and it has to intentionally move to the next piece on the board to get around the whole board. Yeah. Right. It needs a con we always try to, and I think sales people have a problem with this, is especially when you're trying to sell to a lot of people. Uh you'll start talking to somebody, and you'll want to move that piece halfway down the board or all the way back around. And it's like, no, no, no. We talked about this. We talked about this earlier today. Always. And when you first meet somebody, you can't just book a call. You can't just, hey, the person just came into our world and hey, let's book a call, let's talk. It's like, whoa, slow down. Like you said the other, yeah, it's like you said the other day. If you're asking somebody to go to a movie with you, you can't walk up to a stranger and say, Hey, will you go to a movie with me? Because that's that's freaky. Right. That's insane. You have to take the steps to build the relationship, and you could probably do it in one conversation, get that movie day booked, right? You probably could. Like if you spend a half hour developing that conversation, hey man, oh, no way. It looks like you have a San Francisco Giants shirt. No, uh, you know, my son just played on that team, and yeah, there's a way to like build up into that, right? Yeah, I don't even know what's going on. Why the Giants? Why do I always I don't know? Because my kid really was on the Giants uh But regardless, like building, building, building, hey, you know what? Um, and then you talk about the movie, and then like, yeah, they wanted to maybe see the movie. Hey, would you want to go to that movie? Like, I think just I know it's kind of weird, but like and I'm sure you could actually book that appointment. But if you just went up to that same stranger and said, Hey, you gotta go to the movie with me tomorrow.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. And there's a way to serve the law of large numbers, especially when you're buying lots of leads and moving a lot of people through the funnel, which is what you have to do with PNC insurance, because we don't want it to be transactional, but the transactions are very small. So we need volume, right? It has to happen. And so, in order to get volume, you have to really start with a big top of funnel. And so we're moving, as we move them through, we don't want to continue to change it every single time. Do you remember interviewing F and Stefan? Remember that guy? Yes. So he was high-ticket sales, but still, I think that a lot of what the messaging that he had applies in that salespeople here will say, but what if they say this? But what if they say that? But what if it doesn't matter? You just you need to move them to the next step, right? And then this is gonna happen. Then you move them to the next step, then this is gonna happen. Like they could say all 12 objections or whatever the different objections are, but we know at the end of the day, most of those objections are just BS anyway, right? It's how do you move them to the real objection, which is it's too much work, right? It's either too much work or they don't have any money. Those are the real objections. So we have to get to those. And it's the same every time. You don't have to figure, oh gosh, when they say I need to talk to my spouse, what should I do? That's not hard. You have to get them from there to it's either they don't have money any money or it's too much work, right? Or they just aren't gonna do it. Money one is a very sensitive thing because nobody has money. Well, my see, my people think it's easy. That's the most surfacey answer. Right. Look, I don't have any money. Okay, and so when's your next payment with the lizard? Oh, it's the 20th. Perfect. So we can set this up so that it actually just takes place of that payment. So it's no different. All we need to do is to get that started as your counter route number. Put up the microphone, shut up, right? If but the save still the policy's just too expensive. Oh, well, so is it that it's too expensive? Is it that this policy is too expensive with the coverages that we went over and you agreed you need that you don't have over there? Or whatever the other thing was, right? Yeah. Or you don't have any money. Because right.
SPEAKER_05
Which one is peeling that onion, getting to the real well, what do you mean you don't have money? You do have money. Right.
SPEAKER_02
Like you have insurance, you have a car. And those situations where it is way, way more expensive, and already in our head as the producer, we don't believe that we're gonna get it. We still should really go for it because that's when you really win and you practice. Okay, you may not get it, but go for it full blast and try to get it. Every once in a while, you will win on those. Every once in a while, it's very rare, right? It's just a civil.
SPEAKER_05
You're guaranteed to lose more than you win. But if you put in a hundred percent on every time, you're gonna net the best result, right? You're gonna net the most wins you possibly could win.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. We were doing our coaching in the morning the other day and talking about all these kind of things. And then I asked everybody, I said, Have you ever lost the business when you were a hundred dollars less? And they all said, Yeah, it's happened before where they didn't believe it or whatever. And I said, Have you ever lost the business when it's a hundred dollars more? Yeah, yeah, that happens all the time. Right. And it's like you could win both of those at any given time. And the fact that you're losing business, like you're not closing it when it's a hundred dollars less, it's the same reason. They don't like you, right? They don't like you, they have no incentive to do business with you. You didn't explain anything, they don't trust you, they don't know you. They just, it's you're a robot. And until you can get past that and start like that, was jumping to the front, to the back of the funnel before they finished the front, right? They needed to make them like them first. And I love the questions we talk about, right? What are the three questions? What do you do for work? What do you do for fun? What is their family like? Right. I don't think there's anything more important in the phone call than those three questions.
SPEAKER_05
And it's funny too, because it's not the questions, it's the answers to those questions are going to lead you to the things that will close the deal.
SPEAKER_02
As Tony Robbins will meet of what will close the deal. The power of our questions creates the quality of their answers, it shifts the focus to what's really important. That's what has to be done, right? You have to take what they're thinking, which is, oh gosh, I'm doing something that's about as fun as going to the dentist right now. And you have to change it. You have to change their whole thinking about that. And you do it by unlocking the correct answers. And the correct answers are them talking about themselves. It doesn't even matter what they say, it just matters that they are. Right? When you can get them talking about their poodle that has bows in its hair and likes to run through the pond and get all dirty and come in their house and blah, blah, blah. Then now you've created a connection.
SPEAKER_05
Now that's when you sell the policy.
SPEAKER_02
Yes. Well, you don't even sell it, they just get it, right? $100 more, $100 less. We had one of my producers, so this is really interesting. And I don't think I talked about it. I think this was like beginning last week. We've been hammering the three questions. And they, for whatever reason, they don't feel like they need now, they are doing it, and it's in the notes, which has been a huge improvement, but you have to stick with it with them to get them to stick with clients, right? And so this producer wasn't asking it, and he's English is his second language, so he's really comfortable with Spanish speaking. But as soon as it's English, he gets in his head, and his English is perfect. I don't know what his problem is with that, but it is what it is. So with this, he got this lady to the point where she pretty much was gonna buy. We were about the same. It wasn't, I think we were even like 10 bucks more. And he said, Okay, where or she said, Where are you located? And he said, We're down in Tucson, and she was up in Phoenix, and she said, Oh, well, what do you she said, what do you do for fun? So she started asking him the three questions, right? And all of a sudden, they're having a conversation. Like he said, Yeah, I'm originally from Mexico, and then she said, and then because he doesn't like to do that kind of small talk that's really important, then she started talking. So she initiated that got her talking. She said, Oh, we went to Mexico for my honeymoon, and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. She started talking, talking, talking. She had said, I want you to email it to me. All the standard stuff that he never would have talked to her again. Well, by the end of her asking those questions, then her basically responding to her own questions, which he should have been asking. What happened? Rapport. Right. But she bought. Of course. At the end of all of it. Rapport is the buying. Right. At the end of the whole sale. It is. At the end of the whole thing, she said, you know what? Never mind. I'm not going to go get the email and shop around. Let's just do this. And that was it.
SPEAKER_01
Let's do it. And I'm like, dude, nice.
SPEAKER_02
We were more no we were $30 more a month because I asked him afterwards. I said, hey, name. I'm not going to say his name because I don't. So anyway, I said, hey, what would have happened had she not asked you that? Would you have even tried? And he said, we were 30 bucks more. I probably wouldn't have pushed too hard. And so see, it shows you how important it is.
SPEAKER_05
I a hundred percent. I would almost say that the sale happens when the person feels better about the sale. Meaning it's not about the price, it's about how they feel. If the lower price makes them feel good, they'll buy it. If the person on the phone makes them feel good better than cheap price, the cheap price might feel bad. Like, oh, feels like there's this isn't great. It's cheaper, but it doesn't feel good. So I think that the feeling of it is the real sale. Like if they feel good about it, they're gonna go with it.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. They buy on emotion, not on logic, right? Right. Emotion is created by how you made them feel, not by what you said. Everybody, future trips about oh, if I say this, what are they gonna say? Oh gosh, I'm gonna sound stupid and this and that. It's like none of it matters. Get them talking, they will feel good, and they are a magnitude more greatly likely to buy in the most strangest sentence ever delivered. And that's and that's a coffee talk. Hey Jason, so if somebody wanted to subscribe to this, what would they do?
SPEAKER_05
YouTube's smash buttons like subscribe, like things on uh social media platforms. And if you want to learn more about how to save your agency time and money, uh-huh, then check out live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that's a lot of fun. Love it. That was fun putting together. A coffee talk.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, baby!
SPEAKER_04
Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh 100,000 premium of even the worst internet lead, where can they go?
SPEAKER_03
They can go to live.com. That sounds exciting. Are we in a video? Yeah. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will live and it will show you the project.
SPEAKER_04
I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_03
Let's do it. Line up right now. Live.teledude.com. Live.teledude.com.
SPEAKER_04
That's live.teledude.com.
SPEAKER_03
Hey, great. There's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content. We have to do it. Which is awesome, but they have to do it. They have to text it. 520, 214, 2219. 520, 214, 2219. I'm gonna respond to it for sure. It's gonna be a week. It's gonna be our new community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and read crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. What the heck is that number again? I can't remember it.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.