The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub! https://www.theidudes.com/Are you interested in learning “How To Predictably Sell 6-Figures A Month Fro...
Hey, I love it. I love doing some coffee twerk. Well, you know, talk about what? Dogs, daughters, whatever. It's coffee twerk.
SPEAKER_01
Hey Craig. Um, this year I got some crazy growth goals for my agency, and actually I've been talking to a few other agents. They got some crazy growth goals. So um can you tell me a little bit what about what you're doing that's just crushing it in your agency right now?
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, well, we're doing a lot of internet data leads uh through a uh company called Everquote, and they're actually one of our sponsors. Ooh, yeah.
SPEAKER_00
Can you tell me a little bit about that?
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, part of the accelerated growth program, um, which includes having your own consultant that's gonna go over your results, and it's it's positioned to make those leads cost less so that you have lower acquisition costs and makes it totally doable.
SPEAKER_01
Awesome. And so so what have been what has been your favorite parts about it so far?
SPEAKER_02
I like the I like the visibility into the results, um, and and being able to compare what the the numbers that they get on their side with the numbers that I get on my side and seeing that they mesh up. So we know that the data is correct and that we're actually uh you know in in a cost per policy or cost per sale that uh that makes sense. Right. Yeah, they make it real easy to track. And you know what? Guess what? They gave us a deal to offer to all of the insurance dudes and dudettes out there. Oh, I gotta know about this. Yeah, you all you need to do is go to go.everquote.com forward slash insurance dudes. That's go.everquote.com forward slash insurance dudes.
SPEAKER_01
And they give all the insurance dudes out there a killer price on this. So I'm signing up.
SPEAKER_02
Boom.
SPEAKER_00
Oh, is it ro we're rolling? We're rolling. I got my coffee. Oh, you forgot your coffee. Oh, Dennis, look at my coffee. Oh, you got the insurance dude's mug.
SPEAKER_02
You know, love it. You know how I got this insurance dude's mug, Jason? How? That was weird. Well, as an insurance dude's listener, what I did was come up with some great topics that the insurance dudes could talk about on the air.
unknown
Oh.
SPEAKER_02
And when I did that, they sent me this insurance dude's mug. So actually, that's not all any of it is true because I am one of the insurance dudes. But this is what you can get. And since this is all audio, you're not seeing what I'm holding up, but I'm holding up a fantastic insurance dude's mug. Why don't you describe it?
SPEAKER_01
It says, dude, where's my coverage? On one side, and it has two dudes and the logo on the front, which is hilarious.
SPEAKER_02
My face is awfully fat in this picture.
SPEAKER_01
Oh, well, I you know what, Craig? Uh, we talked a lot today um with people about motivation. And really what it comes down to is when it comes to our, you know, whether it's staff or you know, when we're selling people, we need to come, we want to, we gotta meet them where they're at, right? And not try to bring them into where we're at.
SPEAKER_02
Yes, that's part of step two, establish rapport.
SPEAKER_01
Yes, and and one one thing really stood out to me today when we were talking about that. What was that, Jason? We cannot motivate our staff or well, we can motivate ourselves. I was gonna say, or ourselves. Wait, we can't motivate our staff? No, we have to find out what motivates them.
SPEAKER_02
Oh, do you have the bell? Uh oh. I would like you to ring it. Yeah, I mean, wow.
SPEAKER_01
And it and what that brings me back to meeting everyone where they're at. You know what I mean? Like, like, why are we trying to impose what motivates us onto other people? Like, we gotta figure out where they're at. What motivates them, and then we have to adapt to that. Just like when you're talking to uh a new prospect or something that has it in their head that they want the cheapest coverage or whatever it may be, meet them where they're at. Yeah, man, we'll get you the cheapest coverage. Yes, of course we have the cheapest coverage.
SPEAKER_02
Let's start talking. Yeah, you don't need to shift their focus right that second. Never mind. Meet them. Don't argue off the bat.
SPEAKER_01
What are you doing? How can you shift a focus when somebody doesn't even want to talk to you? You're not shifting anything.
SPEAKER_02
You shifting nothing. Nothing. Yeah, it is it is interesting, you know. Like before being an agency owner, I came from well, and I was younger too, so it's even you know more stubborn. Well, a lot younger.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah.
SPEAKER_02
I mean, that was when I was 14, and now look at it, I'm 21. Look at me. But but um coming from Merrill Lynch, I think I'm allowed to say them. Um I was making you know hundreds and hundreds of cold calls a day, right? So then I come here.
SPEAKER_00
Are you one of those people that say you made hundreds and hundreds, but reality you made 29 calls a day, but you're telling you know the how big was the fish?
SPEAKER_02
So though we're making all these calls, right? Doing all these sales, doing all these things, and then come own the business, the boss, I and and run it like Darth Vader, and and tell everybody you've got to do it. This is how I did it when I was doing it, and and and thinking that that's the way that since I that's the way I did it, that that's the way everyone else should do it. That talk about the opposite of meeting them where they are. Yep. And when you're dealing with um with my favorite generation of all time, the millennials, and I'm being serious because they're freaking awesome, right? They grew up in a totally different world than us, especially me, where there were only horses. But when when you're dealing with people that grew up, literally they came out of the womb and were handed an iPad, right? Right, they they they have something that on delivery. Here you go, welcome to the world, here's your iPad. Right? And and but but they've they've been used to instant feedback since they were tiny, right? Instant feedback, and so some people say, Oh, they need a trophy or whatever. It's like, no, they just had instant feedback for everything they did. And so so you have to meet them there, right? Not just hey, go out there, here's the phone book, go make a million calls. I mean, yeah, for for us that worked because we didn't have instant feedback. It was go freaking ride your bike until you fell, and then you're gonna figure out how that hurt or whatever, right? Right. These guys had a totally different world. Oh, what do you think about that? It's kind of philosophical.
SPEAKER_01
I know, it's crazy. I just want to know how if a baby grabs an iPad out of the womb, how they're actually gonna be able to like with they're so gooey, I think it'll just slip out.
SPEAKER_02
Well, I I say iPad, but I think it was likely like a uh iPhone Max, like the bigger iPhone. So to them it looks like an iPad.
unknown
Okay.
SPEAKER_01
No, but that is a good point. I mean, we do need to empathize with that, with that instant uh gratification, and that almost shows that uh maybe we're being slower. Maybe we're being lazier. Maybe we need to be faster with that.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. Well, I just okay. Last night I interviewed a guy and he's been after me. You know, I I we did a we did one of the hiring events, I've been just, it's been crazy. I got sick last week, so I haven't I haven't been able to make you know, call everybody back and just get caught up. I'm just not getting caught up. And and this guy's been after me. And I'm like, okay, well, you know, it's an interviewee that is chasing me, that's good. Right. And I talk to him, and and he's he from his voice, he sounds like, you know, about my age, late 80s, and and I'm thinking, and and so I start talking to him. He's from the car business, right? And then he what he starts talking about is oh, I describe the job, I describe how tough it is, you know, all the stuff to try to kind of scare him away and attract him at the same time. And and he says, Look, it sounds like your business is a lot like the car business. I ran the internet marketing department for the the dealership or the internet leads department. So he goes, I would get 200 leads in a month, I would call all the leads, I'd have to call them all 10 times, and and I knew that if I got 100, I'd get fifth, 25 appointments. If I got 25 appointments, 12 would show up. If I got 12, 12 to show up, then three buy. Like he just broke down the sales funnel and and is and is okay and ready to do that hustle because he comes from a different generation where that's kind of like he just figures out that's fine, he's ready to go with that. And I think that you know, over here you have a different generation that operates, you know, they're gonna be a little bit different on how they work with that. And it's not good one way or good the other way. It's just how do you meet them where they are and then help them to get the results that they need to get to their goal? Yep. I think that's it. That's it. I just talked way too much. You gotta say something.
SPEAKER_01
No, that was great. I liked it. I mean, that's it. I mean, I think it's just kind of looking at it from a different angle and and realizing that we can't motivate someone. Like we have to help them be motivated. You know what I mean? Find those things. I mean, everybody's different. We're in a different day and age. Like like money's not the only thing that motivates, you know what I mean? We haven't seen a world war in a while. Like, we're not in yeah.
SPEAKER_02
I mean, even for us, right? Like ultimately it's like, hey, let's make as much as possible, but it's is it just make as much as possible? Or like for me, it's it's can I work from the beach? Obviously, I can with this thing, right? What I'm holding up my iPhone. We should really get an affiliate link for iPhone. Um, but working you could work anywhere in the world. And that my goal now in in being, you know, the second half of life is to travel. I want to see things. And and and we're in a what better period in history to be able to do that by doing what the guest that we just had on, Sean, um was it wait, oh I'm sorry, Seth, Seth Preus, right? He talked about setting up the processes so you don't have to be there. Right. If you have the processes in place and you have the right motivation for everybody, then they're gonna do the things that you that that need to get done, and at the same time execute on the strategies that you've that you've installed in your agency, and things are just gonna happen. And all you have to do is be the conductor, right? You check in, make sure everything's going smoothly. Hey, do you guys have what you need? And then back out in the ocean.
SPEAKER_01
And I mean, we you and I both have talked about this. We like doing that, so it's like, but it's if it's set up in a way that it there is a process, then you don't have to worry when you're gone. Like you can come and go, and then it's fun. It's fun because you know, you're there for fun, you're not there because you have to be, you know, right? It's just a different mindset, I think, when you come in it like that.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah.
unknown
Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00
I think that's a good coffee talk. I mean, hey.
SPEAKER_02
Jason, why don't you tell them how they can win a mug?
SPEAKER_01
Well, you can go at the insurance dudes podcast group, join the group, and help us help you by giving us some great questions, some feedback, and we will adapt it to you. Basically, this we we we wanna we really wanna take this to the next level by serving at a higher level. And um it's very easy for these dudes to get lost in. I love background stories and all that stuff, so I get so lost in just talking to somebody about you know where they've been and stuff. But like, what's some stuff that can really help us take our agencies to the next level?
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, everybody's got a little nugget that they've they've got over here. You know, bring it up. Let's talk about it. Sometimes a lot of nuggets. That's what they say. Let's let that. I think we dropped the nugget that. Jason, I would be remiss if I didn't bring up one of our sponsors. Ever quote. Oh, tell me a little bit about them. Well, I've been using them for a couple months, and I'll tell you that the results are delightful. It's been now a couple months, and and over time, my cost per sale has dropped every single week. That is awesome. Tell me, so you're on a specific program with them? Yeah, it's called the Accelerated Growth Program. And this this bad boy gets you a better deal on those leads, so way less expensive, and you get a consultant that's gonna actually go over your results to make sure you're tracking properly.
SPEAKER_01
And so you and you've been doing that for the last couple months and I can talk about them?
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, and I and I see everybody complain about leads and this and that, and it's like, look, if you don't have a process to track and measure your results, then I can totally get it.
SPEAKER_01
You don't even know what your results are, right? And you asked them to give all the insurance dudes and dudettes out there a killer deal on this, and they came through, didn't they?
SPEAKER_02
They came through, and I know you're gonna take advantage of it, but if they go to go.everquote.com forward slash insurance dudes, that's go.everquote.com forward slash insurance dudes, then guess what? What? Deal City.
SPEAKER_01
I'm there. Do it. Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudespodcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.