The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Inside Internet Leads with Jorge Carbonell Part 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up. It's the Insurance Dudes Podcast. If you have a contact rate of 30% on a lead source and your contacted transfer rate's 3%, is that what you're looking for? Or what specific number would you be looking for to determine what you need to do to train them better?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'll be honest, I haven't looked at that percentage. For me, it's just making sure that they're getting the three to four transfers a day. Sometimes I'm at scale with 10 telemarketers. So some will give me eight or nine in a day, and then another one will give me three. And I'm going to be happy with that, right? Now, let's say you have two, three telemarketers, and two of them are getting you got five from one, you got four from another, and then another one's consistently getting you one or none, you know, then at that point, you know, it's not the leads, maybe it's just a coaching opportunity, either with the TM or your team members and taking calls from that person, but it's just where you kind of work together as a team and and uh make sure that's a fluid transfer, right?
unknownOkay.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I've been watching and trying to understand the metrics. And you had earlier said that you really like to look at the metrics and I'm just trying to get an idea. Like to every Wednesday at 10 30, we do the meeting with the teledudes. And you we role play, we we kind of talk about what's going, what's working, what's not. You know, and I'm looking at I have the ILB leads and I have uh also ALM, those are the two leads we have now. So the last seven days, contacted is 49% on ILB. Oh, that's awesome. Contacted on ALM is 40. But when I look at contacted transferred, I'm looking at ILB about a 10 rate and an ILM 7% rate. And I'm trying to understand, is that good? Is that that's the about 10%?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, 10% is where I think we've talked about in the past where that's solid. They talk to 10 people, you want to get at least one or two transfers from that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03You're looking at about a 10% contact to transfer rate. What kind of contact rate are you looking at to say, hey, I'm successful on this lead source?
SPEAKER_0040%, 49%. I mean, that's awesome. I mean, day one. I remember when we first started talking about this in the different lead sources we were starting out with. We were like, shoot, if you can get 10%, um, that's decent. And now, uh, yeah, I mean, like I'm leveraging, I'm I'm kind of all in with the ILB at this point. That's where we're getting 200 leads from a day. Sometimes it's 150, 200, depending on volume. Yeah, we're seeing similar results as you. Contact percentage is great.
SPEAKER_03What's your minimum number before you would say, hey, this is not a good lead source? 10%, 15, 20, 30. What what contact? If you had to put a number, a line in the sand, what would it be?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, if it's under 10, there's something off. It could be your numbers being blocked, right? Or spam or likely. And I know we've had a lot of conversations around that. And uh, well, I'm sure there's gonna be solutions coming out. But um, so yeah, it could be the number thing, it could be a lack of activity, right? Just keep an eye on is my telemarketer actually doing 500 plus dials. Most of them are. Sometimes they have a day or two that they're off, but that's something to keep an eye on. But those are the only two things that would get in the way of contact percentage, right? It's your phone number and lack of activity.
SPEAKER_03So just again, just to clarify, because I'm a very anal person, I hate to be that way, but you had said contacted rate 10. Well, this is a family show. Contacted rate is 10 or better, but contacted transferate's also 10. Is that correct?
SPEAKER_07He's saying first day contact rate, baseline 10. You don't want to be under that. I mean, you know, it's nine and a half or nine, that's all right. And then it should improve over the week. Like if you look at a seven day, like what you said to be in the 40s.
SPEAKER_03Oh, I get it. I get it. Okay, yeah, because I'm looking at today, I look at seven days. Today we're at 13. That's good. Oh, that's good. Got it. Okay, yeah, that's good.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, okay. I I'm sorry, guys, but for I'm an FNG here, and I have you guys got me so confused right now. So confused.
SPEAKER_06So, so what's the direct question? Because we are doing a podcast, so we can go into more broad stuff in a so he's using like a lot of shortened terminology, I guess. Gotcha.
SPEAKER_01So just kind of kind of clarify what it is that he's saying, necessarily repeat the numbers, but kind of give an idea of what he's saying and why he's saying it.
SPEAKER_07Okay. Think of the entire like we call it the telefunnel, right? The telefunnel process, it starts with dials. So you have your dials up here and your teledudet's making 500 dials a day plus, right? Maybe 700, 500 700. The next step of that, and why it's so valuable because you have the optics onto it, is the contacts. So for a first day contact, like all the leads that came in today that are called on today, the brand new leads, we want at least a 10% contact. If it's below that, we now know that either your numbers flagged, the leads are all have bad numbers, something, right? Because just we've made, I don't know, now it's probably 26 million dials, and that's the analytics that we have from millions and millions and millions of dials. So you're good there. If you have that 10% or greater, great. Now you want to look at of those, how many did we actually quote, right? They were transferred and quoted. That should be 10% of that number. And when, and then now, if all of a sudden that's lower, you want to look at okay, there's two places that the ball got dropped. Either, well, it's somewhere on that transfer, right? If it transfers and it fails, either it's a tech issue, or on the other end, the handoff isn't going smoothly, or the producer is not asking the right questions at the up front. There's a dance that has to happen between the producer and the telemarketer or the caller, where they need to be able to get that and jump into it. And all of this, all of this stuff is in the peak performance challenge. So you can go right into the member site and actually we go over in detail all of those numbers. So that's really helpful for you.
SPEAKER_06Uh but I guess in overall with all this stuff, I would look for big discrepancies. As soon as you see big discrepancies between one of the lines within the funnel, that's when you're like, that's where where you need to kind of like dive into. Like when Tom asks contact rates. So if it's around 10%, you know, it can be down to eight, it can be down to seven, no big deal. But what you're looking for is like, dude, is it did it drop down to 5%? Did it drop down to four and then stay there? That's a big discrepancy. You can have one day off or two days off, not a big deal, but it's kind of like you're looking for these trending marks, right? It's kind of like the stock market. So you're looking at these trending marks. If things are really starting to trend consistently, we're talking weeks kind of thing basis. Now, with like we know that, hey, we got to figure out exactly where in the funnel we could tweak this to help it. And I think one of the things too that we see is a lot of people will start freaking out like on a day or a two-day basis. And it's really you're looking for more of like a week or two weeks or even longer basis. Where are these trends following? Because that's gonna give you more real data rather than like the day-to-day or two days. There'll be some days that we get barely any transfers. And I probably would have freaked out if I jumped into I have 12 telemarketers right now, 12 telemarketers, and I saw that number, I'd probably be freaking out. But now, I mean, I see the trends kind of going up and down. As long as we're like this instead of like this for a long period of time, then I'm good. But that does come over time, so it's really just kind of like following the trends, is what we're doing.
SPEAKER_07Another thing that I love is if you have multiple lead companies, like he mentioned ALM and ILB. I have I too have both of those. So what you'll see is some days you're like, wow, the transfers are a little down. Let me look at the numbers. The contact rate on ALM 4%, ILB 12. Now there's a big swing, right? It's not a we're flagged problem, it's the leads, like in that case, the ALM leads. And then I'm on the email with the guy at ALM saying, Hey, you know, what the hell? And then all of a sudden, magically they improve. So that's an important thing, too. And that's I think it's valuable to have multiple sources or a company that grabs data from different places. Yeah, great questions, which is also why I like ILB because they do it from a bunch of different places. So cool.
SPEAKER_06Did that kind of I know that helped went around? But is that pretty good, Bill? Cool, yeah, awesome.
SPEAKER_04And we can dive more into the new button.
SPEAKER_06We can dive more into that stuff too. Like, feel free to ask more and more going into that because uh really, if we can just I always look at it like time, we can just save time instead of reinventing the wheel, you know what I mean? That's why I like following some of those trends, is because then you could just kind of dive in and save time. You see a number start changing, and you're like, Oh, I know exactly what to do. So, anybody else for George Carbonov? Any questions for George? Yeah, Roger. I might be able to unmute him.
SPEAKER_07No, it says you have to ask him to unmute. There he goes. There we go.
SPEAKER_04Sorry about that. Now we're cooking. All right, what's up, Roger? Good afternoon, good morning, wherever you may be. Um my question revolves around spam or block calls. Once again, I've got 10 numbers uh floating through phone burner. Is there an easy way to check if my call is getting spam or getting marked spam? If my telemarketer called me on each of those 10 numbers to my cell phone, would I be able to see that? And or is that too elementary of an answer to uh is that is it that easy, or is there a harder way to doing that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's not that easy because it's all carrier dependent, it's kind of a wacky world right now. Uh there's a lot of changes going on with like the new rules that are being put in place. But yeah, I think there's two companies that have been like thrown around on this group. So I know we're kind of working on figuring out what works and what doesn't work.
SPEAKER_04And my question also is if you run if you have someone that's using Teledudes that has that spam block situation going on and it's uh occurring on a lot of those phone numbers, is what's the answer at that point? Get a new number, delete those numbers and start all over with yeah.
SPEAKER_00I swap my numbers minimum once a day for all 10 of my telemarketers. Sometimes we do it too, and if it's a slower day, we'll do it a third time.
SPEAKER_04Okay. And I'm assuming my telemarketer is swapping, but let's say she's swapping and it's still getting spammed or blocked on those other numbers. Do you just clear the deck and get two 10 new phone numbers through phone burner? Or yeah, and what is there an extra cost for that? Uh, how's that work out as far as cost-wise?
SPEAKER_00I'm not sure how phone burner works.
SPEAKER_06Okay. All right. Yeah, we can dive more into that phone burner talk to later.
SPEAKER_04But I don't know if that's my situation or not. Uh my contact rate uh as of yesterday was about five percent. It it probably runs about five percent, it's kind of what it's doing. Cool.
SPEAKER_06That does seem a little low. And what leads are you getting? I'm sending my leads uh to my telemarketer from Everquote. Okay. I always like to, even if it is kind of maybe on my end, I always like to call the lead company and say, hey man, can't make this work at this price with a five percent contact. Uh, just to be totally honest with you, I'm going to buy more leads or I'm going to buy them from somebody else, but I got to increase that contact rate. Usually when you have that conversation, it's like, well, I don't want to lose them. And and he'll pay more. So even if you're not going to buy more, I would at least start the conversation that way to create some leverage. Okay.
SPEAKER_04I was talking with my TM today, Avili. I was she'd mentioned about L ILB, of course. I've been hearing about LB, ILB, but I think uh she said it that might have been put on pause by Brandon. Is that correct on ILB leads? Where are you located?
SPEAKER_07Uh Tennessee. I don't know. Well, we can check with them. Okay. Brandon's the one that's communicating directly. He's sort of helping a support capacity. So okay.
SPEAKER_06And she also mentioned Maverick leads, also. Cool. I don't have any experience with Maverick. Okay. But I'm buying exclusively ILB at the moment, and they're they're pretty good. So okay, thank you. Yeah. Yeah. Cool. Great questions. But yeah, I would reach out to Everquote first off, create some leverage. Maybe they can drop it a dollar, or maybe they can give you some free leads or something like that. And then as that goes forward, lay yeah, I would start there and then see what happens. Cool. Any other questions for George?
SPEAKER_07George, how do you determine how many leads you should be buying and what capacity on the back end? Just kind of that equation.
SPEAKER_00I never well, the max that I would do is no more than 50 per telemarketer. And then as we talked earlier, as you start to scale it and as you build that bank up of leads, you can really tailor that down to anywhere about 30 uh to 50. But yeah, I would draw the line in the sand at no more than 50 per telemarketer. Because they're just not going to get to everything. I mean, you can get a thousand leads per day, but that's for one telemarketer, but that's not what it's about. It's about the activity and making sure that we are attempting contact for the same prospect. I want to shoot for at least 30 times in a given month, you know, or for 40 times in a given month. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Hey George, uh, just out of curiosity, do you have your producers uh calling those internet leagues or only your your I do have them on a very low priority uh Tom for like fresher stuff?
SPEAKER_00So like some like if a lead comes in, the TMs hit it right away. And then if like my salesperson's down on dials or down on sales, they can hit up the dollar or two. Uh but again, low priority, the highest priority would be follow-ups for them.
SPEAKER_07Great question. Cool. Well, what about you, Curtis? Curtis, you buy tons of leads. Put you on the spot.
SPEAKER_02I've only been doing this like a week, Craig.
SPEAKER_07I know, but I know you and I see you on the reports for our district. So you're crushing it in Utah. So you have a lot of experience with internet leads.
SPEAKER_02I've been using uh live call transfers for the first part of the year, but I don't know what the deal is for here in Utah, but they just they can't give me the volume. So that's why I started up with you guys last week. Yeah, but we're using right now quote wizard, ILB, and quote nerds. Quote wizard, I jumped on board with them because they were two dollars and fifty cents a lead if you bought a bigger amount. So we're we're seeing how those go.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_06Cool. What would you say? Like, because everybody asks which lead companies are good, what what would you say that you're seeing as far as the trends for those three? Just curious.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I'm looking at the contact rate. The contract rate for quote nerds is 30.56%, ILB is 32 and a half percent, and then quote wizard. I've only used them for two and a half days now, and it's at almost 20. For what time period?
SPEAKER_07First day?
SPEAKER_02Oh, just over the last week. Oh, okay. That I've been using them.
SPEAKER_07Gotcha. Cool. I don't know. It was like first day, man. They are nice in Utah if they're picking up at 30% on first day. Wouldn't that be amazing?
SPEAKER_02But we're also, I I mean, to start off, I also put in a bunch of my old quoted list of everything from like Alliance. So I just we're we're calling on all those too.
SPEAKER_06So cool. All right, cool. Well, thank you guys. Thank you, George, for going the distance with the last chance if anyone wants to ask him.
SPEAKER_01Is it for clarification? You're doing 50 new leads a day per telemarketer. That's the max. So if you have one telemarketer, don't do more than 50 per day. So I've got okay, so my current situation, and maybe this I need to be tuned up here. One telemarketer, and I'm getting 15 to 20 a day. Is that not enough? How many salespeople do you have? Me and one other person.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I would say probably 20 to 40. I mean, should be good. I mean, you said you're doing about 20. Uh I mean, as far as data leads per sales producer, I at minimum I try to do double what they used to say was only 10 per producer. I like 20 per producer at least. And then just since it's two of you, at least maybe 20 to 40 leads should get you there. Okay. Okay. Thank you.
SPEAKER_06And so what George was saying earlier, too, is it all has to do with that pipeline. So when you first, if you're earlier on and you don't have that long pipeline in the background for them to scoop up some of those leads, like let's say you're on the first month, then you're going heavier on those leads, where three months in of buying 50 leads a day, then you can definitely scale back so that they can hit those older leads. Because at 50 leads a day, they can only contact each lead 10 times in a month. So I would go in 50 leads a day to fill the pipeline, but then I would scale back, slowly scale back. And then you can kind of see the trends of scaling back of where, oh, okay, we're getting the same amount of transfers and I'm buying less leads. And then all of a sudden you're scaling back and then you're going, okay, now I'm getting less transfers. I got to buy more leads. So it's finding that kind of like you buy more at the front, and then yeah, it's a dance. And then you're dropping the leads a little bit. And then when you see that the transfers drop, you up the leads to get that, and then you kind of find that balance. Does that kind of make sense?
SPEAKER_01That definitely makes sense. So I dropped a little over 400 leads to start with. And then when you send the updated, and I'm using phone bar, so it's that's cool. I have to send the they have to send the the updated list, right? So when I send that updated list in, are they or is my team automatically using those new leads first, or do I have to instruct them to do that? So, what's the protocol?
SPEAKER_06They automatically, and those old leads go to the back of the line. So that's what I'm saying. Like as you fill in that pipeline, those old leads are getting to the back of the line, the new leads are filling in, those leads that you first put in are just they're gonna be all right, but uh newer leads will perform better, especially over time. So yeah, that's where you'll find that kind of balance. And how many are you buying right now? 50 a day? 15 to 20. 15 to 20.
SPEAKER_01Okay. And I and I'm gonna toss this out there real quick. But I got a 90-day free trial of ever quotes direct transfer deal. Okay. And I think to date I've gotten 10 total transfers out of that.
SPEAKER_06Oh, wow.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so that's and they're and they're charging premium money on a monthly basis to do that. Right. So it's a lot more than what you guys are charging. So I just want to throw that out there. It's it's completely unsuccessful. It's nowhere near the product of what we've got going on here. Another note: as soon as that ILP deal is ready for Nebraska, give me a call. Appreciate it. Thanks.
SPEAKER_06Cool. We'll have Brandon work on that for you. Yeah, so that is a good point. I mean, when we all started this, it was kind of like I think Georgia's even doing live transfers. Craig was, I was, and it was like the lead companies are pretty much buying leads and they have their best interest and trying to they know that those transfers are in short supply. So they can charge more for them, especially when it gets towards the end of the year, people are trying to make goals. So this is just a way to kind of put the ball more in your court. So I'm glad that you're having more success with us than with the other company. But cool. Well, let's wrap this cast. We can stay on for a few more minutes. George, thanks for coming on the insurance studio. Thanks for everybody. Thank you, Mr. George. Yes.
SPEAKER_00Keep crushing it. Thank you. Yeah.
SPEAKER_08Hey, Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it?
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_08Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium, yes, even the worst internet leads, where could they go?
SPEAKER_05They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_08I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_05Let's do it. Sign up right now live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_08Live.teled.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_05Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_05Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah. Which is awesome, but they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm ready. You can respond to these texts. I'm going to respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's going to be awesome. And it's a it's going to be our new texting community where we're going to get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean, everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it.
SPEAKER_08I'm going to text it right now.
SPEAKER_05520-214-2219.
SPEAKER_08All right. I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_07I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman