The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Inside Internet Leads with Jorge Carbonell
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up, it's the Insurance Dudes Podcast. So, what we'll do here is we're gonna continue the trend for this week. We're gonna interview George Carbonoff again on the insurance dudes. But we're gonna be talking a lot about leads because carbs has been diving deep in leads. He's been getting all deep and dirty in leads. Yeah. Right?
SPEAKER_00I'm so technical.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. He's an analyst so much. It's a rabbit hole. Yeah, it is. You just keep going. There's so many numbers you can crutch. I'm a big metrics geek, so like I just track everything. So it's fine.
SPEAKER_00I love it. I don't believe that George ever did speed breakers.
SPEAKER_05Ooh. I definitely did speed breakers. 100%.
SPEAKER_00He didn't do the new one, so let's just 100%.
SPEAKER_05Oh geez.
SPEAKER_00The new one. I think he's trying to avoid it. And I don't know if he knows the 80s trivia either. That's even better.
SPEAKER_05Not even born in the 80s.
SPEAKER_02Oh did you ever see Back to the Future? Yes. Okay. That's good enough. Do you know what Knight Rider is?
SPEAKER_00No. Okay. Well, I'll skip that. Do you know who David Hasselhoff is? Yes. Okay. So I can go to the second. So that you ask the questions so that you can ask the questions. Sure. You know, it's it's I I need to diagnose need. Here we go. Have you ever had a mullet, Mr. Carbonel? No, negative. Really? You'd look really good with one. Jack or Jim?
SPEAKER_05Jack.
SPEAKER_00Jack. That was my choice back in the olden days. Most embarrassing thing your mom caught you doing for the second time.
SPEAKER_05No comment.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Ever jumped out of a plane.
SPEAKER_05No, I'm afraid of height. Oh god, no.
SPEAKER_00Worst.
SPEAKER_05Uh Raptor.
SPEAKER_00Oh, nice. Yeah, that is the best one. Everybody defaults to T-Rex. And when we're in Vegas, I'm gonna make you go on the New York roller coaster. Count Chocula or Count Dracula? Uh Dracula. What year did Marty go back in time to? I don't know. And everybody on here, yes. Everybody on here, everybody on here is a potential guest, so we can take notes and ace this thing.
SPEAKER_05Um just get that right though. Let me just for the record.
SPEAKER_02Well, 85 was the current year, and then he went back to oh right, right, to 60 67 in the past. Was it 67? 57. No, 55, 30 years.
SPEAKER_0030 years, 30 years ago. You don't have to know the answers your own questions, by the way. Why would you? What song was playing at the enchantment under the sea when George and Lorraine first kissed?
SPEAKER_05No idea.
SPEAKER_00Earth Angel. Earth Angel. What kind of car was Kit? Oh, you don't know that one. Skip. And what country is was it a Camaro? No, it was a Firebird. That's dude. Which is the same car? It's the same car. I mean, one's a Pontiac. So half right again. Yeah, it's like one total. I'd call you half half maybe a quarter right. So we can round down. What country is Hasselhoff huge in? And you have to say huge. Capital U. Is it like Australia or something? Or that's a negative, negative ghostwriter. It is in Germany. Okay.
SPEAKER_05Uh Germany, yeah. Dogs or cats?
SPEAKER_00I don't know how to respond to that. Okay. Tacos or burritos?
SPEAKER_05Burritos.
SPEAKER_00Okay. What was the final villain in Ghostbusters?
SPEAKER_05Uh some big green thing. I don't know.
SPEAKER_00Not green. Not green. Big stafe puff marshmallow man. Oh, it looked like the Michelin man? Yeah, but of marshmallow. Oh, okay. And Trump or Biden? Trump.
SPEAKER_02Oh, he says it. I like it. It's quiet, but it was like almost a question. So I like it. I don't know if he sneezed or final question. What was the first movie that ever made you cry? Oh, Titanic. What part?
unknownOh.
SPEAKER_02Oh. Yeah. That's so sad. It is sad. It was. It's sad.
SPEAKER_05You almost made it.
SPEAKER_02I think we did your history. In one minute or less, drop Titanic to where you are now. In one minute or less.
SPEAKER_00Jason's going to be singing the song from Titanic.
SPEAKER_0560 seconds or left or less. So college grad, no idea what I'm doing in my life. Uh start with in claims, go into product, uh, go into leadership, go into sales management, start opening up agencies for other agents and quit. And now I have my own agency.
SPEAKER_00Bing bada boom. 18 seconds. Perfect. Why'd you decide to do that? Why'd you decide to become an agent?
SPEAKER_05Well, in my previous role, I was helping other people kind of achieve their dreams. And I just kind of noticed that the opportunity. So that was one piece. And I'm very self-driven. So it was just, you know, why don't you just do this for yourself? And I just enjoy building teams and um driving and just knocking things out of the park. So doing it for myself and my team. That's the big thing. You know, right now, yeah, I'm doing it for myself and my family, but I also have a team of people here that I feel I want them to be successful, right? And it's awesome to see them reach their personal goals. So it's a good feeling to see that.
SPEAKER_00To go to coach instead of player. It's interesting to use baseball analogies because you were a football player in college.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_00Running back. No, no, linebacker.
SPEAKER_05Even the yes.
SPEAKER_00The opposite. Yeah. The one tackling. That's the football is a sport, Jason. Okay. Cool. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Well, I want to talk a little bit about leads today because you're a data guy and you do a lot of spreadsheets. So when you first started, and I know we kind of got in this before, again, 60 seconds or less, we'll just go through this. But when you first started, what were you buying for leads and what has changed and what have you learned in that process?
SPEAKER_05So for me, and when I'm dealing with a lead company, it's I'm looking for somebody that's not going to like try to take advantage of the agency. When I first started, I got definitely taken advantage of. Like they're like, oh yeah, we're going to help you out. We're going to give you the best deal in the world. And I'm paying 12 bucks for a lead. And you know, not knowing anything, it's like, oh, great. You know, this guy just hooked me up, or this girl just hooked me up and we're going to crush it. And then you start to see that I'm doing the numbers and I'm getting like six, seven, eight hundred dollars cost per sale. And I'm looking at the numbers again. And I'm like, this cannot be sustainable. There's got to be people that are getting better deals than this. So that's one, just making sure that you're working with the lead company that's transparent and helping you out as much as possible. And they want you to be successful. Because if you're successful, then they're successful, right? So yeah, so it went down to like just doing my research, just putting the lead companies up against each other, saying, like, hey, now what's the best deals you can give me? Make sure you got the right filters, make sure you can take care of the zips. And at this point, it's making sure they can meet the volumes that we need to be successful as an agency. So that's another big thing. And yeah, with the especially with teledudes, obviously, we're kind of in a meeting where everybody in this lead group is using the program. It's again going back to volume and the right lead price, and in combination with the activity that's going to get you the best cost per sale, right? What's going to give you the best contact rate as well.
SPEAKER_02Right. So when you first go into buying leads now, what are some of the things you're looking for? And how are you approaching it with your team?
SPEAKER_05Well, for my team, every lead's premium lead, best leads in the world, take them and crush them. Anytime we get a transfer from one of our teledudets, it's a live human being. It's then a great opportunity to take care of a prospect or a family. And in terms of what we're looking for, as far as the leads that we're getting, we're looking at contact rate. So obviously, there's gonna be like we get a lot of leads a day. We get 200 plus leads a day. Like there's going to be some junk in there. Like I get that. But overall, I'm looking at the whole system all together. What is the overall contact percentage? And overall, what's the cost per sale for all the leads that I've purchased? I don't get too hung up on one lead that says, what is it, man? Hasselhoff. I only got one lead that says it's called Hasselhoff and lose it. I know that overall that I'm gonna get a good return on it. And that's what I'm looking for is consistency.
SPEAKER_00David Hasselhoff. David Hasselhoff. There you go. Yeah, I'm Matt. When we first launched Teledudes and people were coming to us before there was a community, before there was elite dudes, before all the stuff that we all the other stuff that's in there, the PPC, you came in. I think you started with eight. I can't remember. Was it eight? Five. Okay, you started with five, and then like after a week or two, you were like, okay, I want more. And then all of a sudden, no, well, now you're at 10 or 12. I can't remember. But we usually kind of recommend baby steps because it's it's a big spend and it could be challenging to watch that go out and wait for the results to happen. So, how were you able to manage your emotions at the beginning when you first dove in? And why did you decide to do that?
SPEAKER_05It's for me, it was pretty easy. So it's super hard to find good people, right? We the people are and staff are so integral to your success. I always say it's people and marketing. So on the people side, you want them to be successful, right? If they're successful, again, going back to it, your agency is successful, and it's super easy to really burn them out if you're buying a bunch of leads and you're having them make two, three, four, five hundred dials a day. So you're gonna get burnout, right? And you're also gonna, it's just an inefficient way for them to spend their time. Like, why are they gonna spend their time dialing when they can spend their time talking to people? So I see when you guys started this program, I was like, this is great. It's like just kind of seeing the light. Like these telemarketers, right? They're just an extension of my team. Like when I talk to them, I don't even say like telemarketers, like it's just like you're a team member, right? You're a lead generator, you're a team member, you're a caller. I never even used the word telemarketer with them, honestly. Yeah, they're great. I think now I have it's two. I I think one-to-one is a very good sweet spot. Um and I think we're at two to one at this point. There's constantly talking to people.
SPEAKER_02You got to just have them dialing. So with the lead volume, I mean, how you figured out how to manage lead volume, the ups and downs of losing, gaining staff. I know you went through a staff change at one point. How are you managing leads throughout all that?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I mean, we've been as little as like when we first started out, as little as 100 leads a day, all the way up to 300 leads a day, and we've tailored it back to 200, just because we have such a large bank of leads. Like it's just the lead is an asset in itself that you continue to call on. It's kind of that buyer guy mentality, right? We're gonna get you at one point, we scrub them and we make sure they're compliant, all that good stuff, but we can consistently follow up with these folks. So, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Do you have the analytics on what the longest oldest lead you have that closed?
SPEAKER_05We just closed one from nine months ago yesterday.
SPEAKER_00Well, did you look did you look at how many dials were on it?
SPEAKER_05I think it was like 50 something, but again, we uh have it go through the first 90 days, and then I have uh kind of a recoil campaign that goes to DNC scrubber, right? And uh, I have that set up on a separate campaign, really low priority. Yeah, but it's awesome, it's just like little touch points, and like anything that we win on those, like it's just it's awesome.
SPEAKER_00I think that's interesting. You bring up that part of it. You had the one to one, and now you have two to two to one. I'm about two to one. I figure I'd rather have more activity on the front and less producers who are writing more business each. My top one wrote 60. So it's just when you see one can do 60, then the rest see that, and eventually they'll get there. So just feed them. And they cost you pay less by having one write 60 than two write 30, right? So I'd rather have one write 60. But I think it's interesting when you fill up that pipeline and you have so many leads in the system. I know Jason has a trillion leads in there, and you've got a million leads in there now. You almost need the extra group of callers to be able to hit those old leads too, right? So because and they flip. I mean, you and that I've talked about we had a one that was over 90 dials on it, probably some other ones. I haven't looked at all of them. How important is that to you?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, definitely something to keep an eye on because especially on the front end, because I know we have very particular cadences in the group that we share and stuff to make sure that we're hitting them enough times. And we're caught reaching out to these prospects so frequently that as that bank builds up, they sometimes rarely get to that 45, 60, 90 day mark and they don't get as as hit as much. So you can add another teller marketer, right? And it's gonna really start to help you with getting into the back end of leads closer to that 90-day period when guess what? Nobody else is calling them at that point. Right? Everybody quits after the first two calls and says this lead sucks.
SPEAKER_02Right. Such a huge advantage. It's funny how, like, when you start filling the pipeline, it's hard to explain what happened six months to one year later because they are making those follow-up phone calls and you're constantly selling leads that are older, and those are supplementing the new leads. So if you can find the balance of the old and the new, all of a sudden your cost per policy, it really is like a machine that has to kind of go the distance to really squeeze all the juice out. At what point were you nervous and thought, like, what other things have you tried and what do you look at on a daily basis to make sure you're on the right track?
SPEAKER_05Quote volume, so quoted households. So I track up the amount of so with the company, there's folks that get quite are qualified, not qualified, et cetera. So we look at that pretty closely, making sure we're talking to quality prospects. It happens, I would say probably 30, 40% of the people we speak to don't even qualify. So we actually don't count that as a quote. And then we look at we want to make sure that each agent is quoting at least eight to 10 households per day. So that's super important. And I think that's gonna get them to that 40,000 in premium or plus, at least in our state, with how good my sales team is at this point, similar to like what Craig was saying. Like I used to have nine people, but we have five salespeople that are doing better than nine. So I'll take that all day.
SPEAKER_00Well, and they improve over time, right? The your salespeople get used to those transfers and how to handle them because you're training them. And it just takes time.
SPEAKER_05Yep. What was another question you had there, Jason? That was like a two, three-part question.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. No, I think you're good. You know what I'd really like to do is I'd like to uh keep this conversation centered around really around leads in buying. And I'd like to open it up to everybody that's on the call. So if we could do a little raise of the hand and then we'll unmute you, and then you can ask George a question on leads.
SPEAKER_00Okay, I'm gonna tentatively uh okay, Tom, you better be good. Ready?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Can you hear me?
SPEAKER_00All right, yeah, got it. What's up, Tom? Welcome to the insurance dudes. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So I've been taking tons of notes, learning everything I can. We're still not exactly where we need to be. So just to confirm, I think you guys had said, and George, I wanted to get your take on it, that really you're looking for five or more live quota transfers per TM per day. Is that correct?
SPEAKER_02I'm not getting that now.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I'm getting more three to four, but that's where I set the goal. Absolutely. That's where I want to move. So, like when I'm communicating to my telemarketing manager and I'm looking, I communicate with them honestly more throughout the day than I do with my sales team because I know like if they're doing well, my team's gonna do well. So I focus a lot on that. But yeah, I push them hard to get, and then we could do incentives. I'm sure you're familiar with that. We could do incentives to help them, you know, they're just like salespeople.
SPEAKER_01But yeah, you if you're not getting those numbers, that's my follow-up question, is to dissect or diagnose where you need to apply some coaching or some training. Obviously, I would imagine you look at contact rate. And if so, what contact rate? What live transfer rate are you looking at as an example? So if you have a contact rate of 30% on a lead source and your contacted transfer rate 3%, is that what you're looking for? Or what specific number would you be looking for to determine what you need to do to train them better?
SPEAKER_03Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Mm-hmm. Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium of even the worst internet leads, where could they go?
SPEAKER_04They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_03I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_04Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03Live.teledudes.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_04Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_04Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah, which is awesome, but they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm gonna respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it.
SPEAKER_03I'm gonna text it right now.
SPEAKER_04520-214-2219!
SPEAKER_03Alright, I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_04Hi, Mr. Greg. Can we even listen to this on the radio anymore?
SPEAKER_00I love it. I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman