The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Influence People and Persuasive Selling with Brian Ahearn Part 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up, it's the Insurance Dudes Podcast.
SPEAKER_05We say a lot, help them make the decision, right? You you help them along so that they make that decision. Because if they make the decision, they're they're here for a long time.
SPEAKER_00Now, all of this taps into the principle that we call consistency. And consistency simply says that we feel this internal psychological pressure, but also this external social pressure to be consistent in what we say and what we do. So let me ask either of you this. Have either of you ever given your word to somebody that you would be somewhere or do something with them, but then you had to back out?
SPEAKER_05I can answer for Jason and say that this has happened.
SPEAKER_00Is that true, Jason?
SPEAKER_05No, I mean I everybody has, right? So everybody, yeah.
SPEAKER_00The real question is, and I'm gonna guess that that your reason was legit and your friend probably understood, but the real question is, how did you feel when you had to tell your friend, hey, I can't make it?
SPEAKER_05It's never good. Right. Yes. You're letting somebody down. That's right.
SPEAKER_00Again, even though they understand it and it's legitimate, you hate how that feels. And so we work really, really hard to do whatever we can to keep our word. Sometimes even with things we don't really want to do, but we know we'll look better to those people that we made the commitment to, but more important, we'll feel better about ourselves. And that's a big driver of human behavior. And I think it's one of the most important principles in selling because it's built on the questions. If I can ask you the right questions, you're owning that, right? And so when I come back to you and share with you that I've done everything in more than what you've asked, it's a lot easier for you to say, let's go ahead and do business.
SPEAKER_03Love it. What other ways besides the obvious sales conversation, can you use those kind of principles in in the agency?
SPEAKER_00Well, managing your team, right? When we talk about persuasion, I love the definition from Aristotle. Aristotle said persuasion was the art of getting someone to do something that they wouldn't ordinarily do if you didn't ask, right? If you walk into your agency, people are going to be busy doing things. And you may need them to stop and refocus onto something else. How you communicate with them might make all the difference between yes and no, or yeah, but dragging their feet versus yeah, enthusiastically. So how we interact with those people. So I'll give you a quick example because this is so often the case where a leader will walk by somebody who is on their team and tell them what to do. Hey, Craig, I need the sales numbers, right? And uh you've got all kinds of outs. Didn't hear you? Been busy, it's gonna get them later. I mean, there's all kinds of things that could happen. So if I learn to turn that into a question, Craig, could you get me the sales numbers? And I'll give you a date too. Could you get me the sales numbers? Let's say they're due Friday. Could you get me the sales numbers by Friday? You might say yes, but you might also say, Oh, I can't, I'm really busy. There's no way I'm gonna be able to get that. Now I don't have what I need. The savvy communicator allows themselves fallback positions. So I might say, Hey, Craig, would you be able to get me the sales numbers by Tuesday? Knowing that if you say no, I might fall back and say, Hey, I know everybody's busy. Any chance you can get them by the end of the day Wednesday. And the psychology of that is when you make a request after somebody says no right on the heels, the likelihood of them saying yes starts skyrocketing. Because we hate saying no. Plus, you feel like, hey, you know, Brian's given a little, I should give a little. So structuring that by asking a question and allowing for fallback positions. And then the final thing I'll say too is research shows that when you use the word because, lots more people do what you want. Because when the two of you were kids, if mom or dad ever told you to do something and you dared to say why, what did they say? Because I said so, right?
SPEAKER_05It's indoctrinated.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and you didn't hardwired. You didn't turn to your mom or dad and go, well, that's not really a legitimate reason. You just did it. And so we are conditioned. So now imagine somebody walks by and says, Hey, Craig, would you be able to get me the sales numbers by Tuesday because I need them for the board report? That's a totally different psychological interaction versus, hey, I need the sales numbers. You start learning this and you start weaving it into how you communicate with people. You never tell, you ask. You allow fallback positions, you give reasons, you will get what you need much more than the person who just operates out of habit and tells people what to do.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Well, and they'll like you more, right? And as they like you more, then they're gonna do more and so on and so forth. So you've written a couple books?
SPEAKER_00I have. My first book was called Influence People, and the word people is a subtitle for powerful everyday opportunities to persuade that are lasting and ethical, and it looks deeply at the psychology, and then I have business case studies, real-world business examples that I saw during my career, a little bit of talk about social media. And then the second book is directed at agents. It's called Persuasive Selling for Relationship Driven Insurance Agents. Love it.
SPEAKER_05Love that. So, can these skills uh you bring in social media, which is obviously a big thing still? And um, is are these same techniques usable in the social media space?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. It's interesting that you ask that question because human psychology, according to all the literature I've read, the human brain has not changed in some 40,000 years. So we're all operating as on Windows 3.1 or whatever that first system was. And so it's funny when people ask that question. I I can imagine people back in 1900 saying, Do you think this stuff works with the telephone? Right? Do you think this stuff's gonna work with the television? Right. Human thinking and it hasn't changed. All that's changed is the medium that we're using. And so, yes, when we're on social media, all of the psychology is at play, but you might need to apply it differently. I can give you like an example that you may have seen, you don't see it so much anymore, but people used to send around uh 97% of my friends won't respond to this, only 3% will have the guts too, and then they'll talk about something that's really needs help, like cancer. But that is working against you because most people tune out after they realize if 97% of the people aren't doing something, then I'm not gonna do it either. So they're trying to guilt you or shame you into some action, and they're actually hurting themselves by doing that. So there's all kinds of mistakes that people make, unfortunately, as they try to advance what could be very good causes.
SPEAKER_05Well, and you see agents post a lot like, hey, I just save somebody 450 bucks on their insurance. It's like uh it they're not jumping at your at your bit there.
SPEAKER_00But even that, you know, the psychology is people are far more motivated to take action when they think they'll lose versus when they'll gain. Many more people will take action when you say you're overpaying versus I will save you. And so that slight reframe into Craig, I was looking at your policy, and I think you've been overpaying at least $500 a year. What? Overpaying, you know, that grabs you differently than I can save you $500. Right. Because psychologically, if I don't save the $500, I don't really feel worse off. But when you tell me I've been overpaying, I feel like that came straight out of my pocket. And I am more willing to take action based on that. So these subtle reframes make a big, big difference in people's willingness to say yes.
SPEAKER_05You created the pain instead of the opportunity that is like bam. Love it.
SPEAKER_03Love it. What are some other little nuts, like that was a huge nugget, I think. And I think most people can huge, huge. What are some other insurance nugs that you would uh little tidbits that you could help the dude nation out there?
SPEAKER_00Well, if you've got experience in the industry, people may not know how much experience you have. And Jason, I have no clue as how old you are, but you look fairly young.
SPEAKER_05He's very old.
SPEAKER_00That doesn't mean that you haven't been in the industry for a significant amount of time. And so subtly during conversation, by maybe dropping out that experience that you have. You know, so if I'm talking to you and I might say, you know, Jason, I've been at this a long time. I've been in the industry now for 30 years, and what I've seen is, and I just begin to share, I'm not bragging about myself. I'm just very conversationally putting that out there. When I work with people who are on the company side in claims, and sometimes they'll say, Well, yeah, but I've only been in the industry for five years. And I'll say, Have you settled hundreds or thousands of claims? Well, yeah, in those five years I've settled thousands of claims. Okay. The claimant that you're talking to that you're needing to move their behavior so that you can speed up the claim process. You can say, you know, Mrs. Smith, I've settled thousands of claims that are just like yours, and I'm confident that I can help you get through this quickly. Mrs. Smith now has a lot of confidence. She doesn't know how long you've been in the industry, but she knows if you've done this a thousand times, you're probably good at it. So you find that way to put out in a very authentic, conversational way, that you've got experience and people are more willing to follow the lead of people that they think have expertise.
SPEAKER_05What if he just started yesterday? How does he frame that?
SPEAKER_00If he just started yesterday, then one of the things you have to do sometimes is admit weakness. And when you admit weakness, that gives you credibility. So you might be able to say, you know, Mrs. Smith, I'm really excited to work with you today, and I'm going to be right up front. This is my first day in insurance. And but I am so excited to get to help somebody like you. And you know what? When you talk about what your weakness is and then you transition with a but or a however, people tend to forget what came before but, right? Honey, I love you, but okay, here comes the hammer. You forget the I love you. So when you learn about that, you actually can use your weaknesses to your advantage by putting them out relatively early and transitioning over to what you see as your strengths, and people get more focused on that.
SPEAKER_05Can this help in conversations with your significant other?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely.
SPEAKER_03I don't know. Absolutely. They're tough. So I love this conversation because it is sales is everything. So this has obviously helped a ton of agents coming from you into their agencies and stuff like that. But what about you personally? What other areas of life has diving deep into this psychology helped you? What other cases?
SPEAKER_00Well, I always talk about the reason I love what I do is because I'm going to help people on a professional level and a personal level. I always talk about professional success and personal happiness because this is a 24-7, 365 skill. I mean, think about this. From the moment that a baby comes into the world, that baby cries. Why? Well, mom or dad needs to figure out is it hungry, does it need burp, fed, change, whatever. It has a need and it's doing what it can in its limited capacity to get the need met. Then we learn how to communicate, we get older, more sophisticated, but every single day we're trying to get our needs met. And how we do that, we communicate with people. So you better learn how to ethically and effectively persuade if you want to get your needs met. And we'll do that until the day we die. So people are going to use this eight to 10 hours a day in the office, but then they're going to go home and they're going to interact with their kids, they're going to interact with their spouse and their neighbors. And understanding all of this in terms of interacting with them, it's the same thing. So, yeah, I, you know, raising our daughter who is 25, interacting with my wife, we've been married 33 years, this comes into play every single day. I'll give you a couple of examples. I have uh on my um iPod, I have or my phone playlists for my wife and daughter. They are songs that make me think wonderful things about them. I listen to those, like if I'm going to get ready to go out with my wife or if I'm going to spend time with my daughter, because I want to mentally get myself in a place where I am super excited to be with them. That's something anybody could do, right? But I know it changes how I feel about them and then it changes how I interact with them and it creates a better experience for all of us by doing that one simple thing to change my mentality. Another thing that I do is I look for opportunities to give whenever I can. And I've come up with some pretty creative gifts over the years when I for my wife's birthday. When she turned 52, my big gift to her was let me ask this question. When you hear the number 52, what comes to mind? I've drawn a blank. Most people say a deck of cards, but there's 52 weeks in a year, right? Yes. So two things. So her gift on her 52nd birthday was a gift a week for a year. Whoa. That's a big commitment. They weren't really big or expensive, but every single week she knew she was getting something, which she was excited about. My daughter would go out and help me buy gifts so she got involved. It was everybody won. That's cool. And you know, and it felt great. So, but I understood too, I didn't give any of those to engage reciprocity, like, oh, you will be down. But I know that when you do those things for the people that you love, they naturally then want to do things that are beneficial for you. And again, you have a virtuous cycle where everything's on the up and up.
SPEAKER_0552 gifts.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so let's go back to that. First off, I wish I could do that, but like I think I would be like three weeks in and I'd like stop or something.
SPEAKER_00You did that for 52 weeks? Well, I would buy sometimes I'd buy several, and so I always had a uh five to eight in this bin. So it wasn't like every week I had to do it. But if I was with my daughter and we saw three things, then I would get those and I'd wrap those. And I always had things in a box that I could bring up, and and then she'd grab them and shake them and choose whichever one that she wanted. The other thing I would say, in terms of kids that we did for our daughter that was unique, everybody has a birthday, you know, everybody gets gifts on Christmas and stuff. We created what we called a special day, which was a day that we would choose at random. We'd wake our daughter up from bed and and say special day, and we'd have gifts and the whole day focused on her. And even though she's 25, she's still like, you better not stop doing special. So those are things that anybody could do, and they take a little bit of effort, but my gosh, what you get in return is so much more.
SPEAKER_05Is one of your wife's love languages the uh receiving gifts?
SPEAKER_00She sort of liked it that year. I think it's the, you know, you you're growing up and it's the thought that counts. You're like, yeah, right, give me the gift. But you get older and you start to realize how nice it was that you were top of mind for that person for that day as they were thinking about something. And then you start finding there's lots of other ways to remain top of mind. And it could be the the little texts in the middle of the day. It could be like, hey, and I ran the dishwasher for you, but just you know, making sure you point that out. Like, I didn't want you to come home and have to do this, and so I made sure I got it done today. And those little acts of kindness, man, they build up great stuff.
SPEAKER_03I'm gonna do special day. I have four kids. It's gonna be a lot of work, four special communities. That's a lot of special days. But that's it.
SPEAKER_05But are the other three gonna get mad if one has a special day, or should they all have special day on the same day?
SPEAKER_03They should all have probably separate special days because that hence that would make it special, right? And then just randomly, then they can be excited for the other person, hopefully.
SPEAKER_00Well, they if you do it for all four at once, you could call it not so special day.
SPEAKER_03Special, it's special not so special day.
SPEAKER_05I still have Pinzo for two more years, so I might do special day with him. That's pretty cool. Yeah, that is not might. Why might I I'll do it?
SPEAKER_00That's right. What's the make a public commitment so you don't so you feel the internal and external psychological pressure?
SPEAKER_05Yeah. I did that when we did um ignite. We had an event here at my office. Jason came out and and I declared that I would ride, and I hadn't ridden my bike in a while, and I declared in front of everybody that I was gonna ride my bike, and so I I had the pressure that I had to, and they called me out, and I did, luckily.
SPEAKER_00A lot of this stuff works also back on you to get done the things you want to do. And so by making that public commitment, and we we talk about when it's public and you have to actively do something, and it's a voluntary and requires a little bit of effort, all of a sudden you will be amazed at how much more you'll follow through because you're like, dang it, I don't want them to look at me and think I say one thing and do another. So anytime you've got that goal, you maybe you're gonna start riding a bike or run a marathon or lose 10 pounds, tell people, and that will give you more of a kickstart to actually follow through.
SPEAKER_05Love it. Well, the listeners can choose the dates of the special days. There's five special days to pick, and they can go in the Facebook group and just post what days are for what. How about that? Okay. I like it. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Did you ever study NLP? I've read some books on it, but no, I didn't study it uh directly. I read a ton. I I mean I've just tons of books on psychology, and and I'm a nerd when it comes to that kind of stuff too. I'm reading a book on economics now just because it's interesting and what's going on in the country and trying to understand about policy and programs and stuff.
SPEAKER_05Have you read nonviolent communication?
SPEAKER_00I have not.
SPEAKER_05It's interesting because it it has a lot of the concepts that you're talking about, or you don't when you're talking to somebody, it's not you, it's the it's the I approach, I feel this, and then at the end you ask for what you want, and and it's like the magic formula. It's really interesting. I love that stuff. That's a good one. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, this is all amazing stuff. So if somebody wants to, well, gosh darn it, I just stepped over myself. What is the number one piece of advice you'd give any insurance agent, either coming into the industry or that really wants to kickstart the agency? What would be the number one piece of advice you would give them?
SPEAKER_00I think the number one piece of advice would be do all you can to come to like the people that you work with, the customers of your agency and the underwriters who you're going to interact with. And not on a surface level, I mean deeply get to know and like those people so that they really begin to understand whatever it is that you're asking or putting forth is coming from a good place. Even if they don't agree with you, even if they have to say no, it is much easier to navigate those conversations when you know you've got a deep connection with somebody. And that ability to connect with people rests more on each of us individually than it does those people out there. Because I have seen time and time again when I thought initially somebody really didn't like me, and I thought I'm gonna put this into practice. I've not only made friends, I've gained advocates. Love it.
SPEAKER_05Well, yeah, those ones you the folks you turn around are the ones that end up being the strongest bonds. Like our client, that's what we we talk about on the phone with with the leads. If you know they get somebody, they're all angry and yelling, and and you can turn that around, they're a client for life. They they've absolutely win them because that's what they do to everybody else.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. That's right. When somebody says, Hey, I don't need a pat on the back to know I'm doing a good job, that's the person you better pat on the back because they say it because they don't get it, and it's a self-defense mechanism.
SPEAKER_05Ooh, interesting.
SPEAKER_03All these nuggets love it. So if somebody needs more Brian in their life, where are they going?
SPEAKER_00They are going to LinkedIn. Any person who's listening to the show, reach out to connect with me. And I guarantee you this, I will respond to you. If you don't put a note in, like I heard you on the Insurance Dudes podcast, guarantee you will get a message back from me. How did you find me? I I like to know why people are reaching out, but it's a great conversation starter. So when they come back and then they realize, hey, this is a real life person. He's not just accepting all these connections, he's actually communicating with me. So, and even if you do say that you heard me on the show, I'm gonna say thanks, and there's gonna be a message going back and forth, and maybe we'll get to know each other. So that'd be the first place. And the other place would be my website, which is influencepeople.biz. If folks go out there, I I've been blogging weekly for almost 14 years now. So there's tons of information, videos, previews to my LinkedIn learning courses. I've been on well over a hundred podcasts, so there's a lot they could go back and listen to. So uh that's another way to certainly connect with me.
SPEAKER_05Awesome. You were on a TED talk.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm gonna get back on it. I got canceled five days out because of uh COVID. The COVID's I'm waiting for the organization to repost when they're gonna do that, and then I'm gonna jump back on that. That's great. That was disappointing because I was gonna be their opening speaker, so I was psyched because it's here in Columbus, which meant friends and family, and five days out that'd be cool, they everything locked down here in Columbus.
SPEAKER_05Well, please make sure to share that with us when you do go on, and we'll share it out to the nation, do that nation too.
SPEAKER_00Thank you. Thank you.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, well, thank you so much. And and hey, thank you for putting together the hello, Craig and Jason sign. That's very nice of you. Love it, man. You're welcome. It's been great to have you on the show.
SPEAKER_00It's your special day.
SPEAKER_05It is. I'll tell my wife that today. It's my special day. Don't you know be nice.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, don't tell her it's her special day. I know what you mean by that, Craig. And trust me, that's more of your special day. I don't know what you're talking about. This is uncomfortable.
SPEAKER_05All right, then let's end it. All right, guys. Thanks, Brian. Thank you, Brian. Welcome.
SPEAKER_01Hey, Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Mm-hmm. Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium off even the worst internet leads, where could they go?
SPEAKER_02They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_01I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_02Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_01Live.teled.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_02Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_02Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah. Which is awesome. But they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm going to respond to these texts. I'm going to respond to them for sure. I'm into it too. It's going to be awesome. And it's a it's going to be our new texting community where we're going to get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. Mmm. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it.
SPEAKER_01I'm gonna text it right now.
SPEAKER_02520-214-2219.
SPEAKER_01All right. I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_05I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman