The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Influence People and Persuasive Selling with Brian Ahearn
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up. It's the Insurance Dudes Podcast. Boom. Bubba. I am super excited. How about you?
SPEAKER_00It's gonna be good. Yes.
SPEAKER_02Who do we have today? Mr.
SPEAKER_00Brian Ahern here in studio. I said it right. I don't think you could say that any differently.
SPEAKER_01You got it pretty right. Ahern.
SPEAKER_00Ahern. Ahern. Did I say not Ahern?
SPEAKER_01Nope. You got it. You got it right. Some people say uh hearn, but it's Ahern.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's gotta be A. A for perfect. Awesome. Well, welcome to the insurance news. That's awesome. Why don't you go into that one? A for awesome. A for perfect.
SPEAKER_02So awesome.
SPEAKER_00Yep. That's right. It's uh I'm just making sure you're paying attention, Mr. Jason. Okay, good. I'm trying. If you're watching on YouTube, instead of just listening to audio, you can tell that Jason is not paying attention. Right. Speedbreaker! Speedbreakers dive in. Let's dive into speed breakers. Brian says that he's ready. Maybe he is, maybe he isn't, because there's some new questions. Brian, have you ever had a mullet?
SPEAKER_01No, but I had a tail in college. Oh, yes, the rat tail.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's the old school mullet. That's a good one. That was the best. Oh, nice. So that dovetails perfectly into the next question, which is Jack or Jim?
SPEAKER_01I'm sorry, say that again.
SPEAKER_00Jack or Jim? Johnny or Jose.
SPEAKER_01Jim is in G Y M.
SPEAKER_00No, Jack as in Jack Daniels or Jim Beam.
SPEAKER_01Oh, okay. Uh I'm just gonna go Scotch.
SPEAKER_00Scotch. He goes to Scotch. Johnny. Most embarrassing thing your mom ever caught you doing.
SPEAKER_01Probably four years old, crap my pants, running up the stairs, trying to get to the bathroom.
SPEAKER_00Oh, good. That is awesome. We haven't had that one. I like it. Have you ever jumped out of an airplane?
SPEAKER_01No, not yet.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Best dinosaur? T-Rex. It's the crowd pleaser. How many kids?
SPEAKER_01Little arms.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. How many kids? How many kids? I'm gonna say one. Have have you made cry? Sorry, please wait for the whole question.
SPEAKER_01It was one because I confirmed that with my daughter today. All her friends were scared of me, but she only only she cried.
SPEAKER_00Nice. I love it. Count Chocula or Count Dracula?
SPEAKER_01Uh Chocula.
SPEAKER_00What year did Marty go back in time to? 1986? Oh, that was 1950 something.
SPEAKER_01That's probably when the movie came out.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Yes. Pretty close. I think what Jason, what is it? 50 85 and 55. 85 and 55, 30 years. Bonus. What song was playing at the Enchantment Under the Sea when George and Lorraine first kissed? Never saw it, I don't think, or no clue. Earth Angel. What kind of car was kit?
SPEAKER_01I thought it was a Transam.
SPEAKER_00Bing. Yes. It's either a Transam or a it is a Transam, isn't it? Trans Am is a Firebird. Well, it's uh Einhorn is Finkel. It's the same car. Where were we? Oh, what country is Hasselhoff huge in?
SPEAKER_01Germany.
SPEAKER_00That's correct. Dogs are cats.
SPEAKER_01Cats. I know you want to end the interview there, but if you saw my daughter's cats, you'd fall in love with them. Okay. That is our first cat. They are like a scarried couple watching these cats and their heads turning and how they play, and they don't require anything of me. So oh well, that's good.
SPEAKER_00As long as they don't require advantage. That is, dogs are just yeah. So much work. What does Alf stand for?
SPEAKER_01Alien life form.
SPEAKER_00That is correct. Yes. You are just crushing it. The final villain in Ghostbusters.
SPEAKER_01The Staypuff Marshmallow Man.
SPEAKER_00That is correct. The first person to nail it. And of course, everyone's favorite, Trump or Biden.
SPEAKER_01Uh Tulte Gabbard.
SPEAKER_02Well played, sir. And what was the first concert you ever went to, all the way back to as far as you can remember?
SPEAKER_01Ario Speedwagon. I was a junior in high school, down at Ohio University.
SPEAKER_02That is great. Ooh. Ooh, that is good. So back from the Speedwagon into now, how did you get it involved in this crazy business of insurance?
SPEAKER_01This is actually pretty interesting. I was at school. I had accepted a job with a department store chain. Last week of school, I get a letter from Traveler's Insurance. Knew nothing about insurance. In fact, whatever thoughts I had were all negative. But I went to the interview because I was dating a girl. And so I thought I owe it to her to see if I can get the job because it's in my hometown, Columbus, Ohio. And I go and lo and behold, I get the job, and the first day of work, I met my wife. So wow.
SPEAKER_00If you had not tried to impress the girlfriend by going to get this job, you wouldn't have met your wife.
SPEAKER_01True. And I had to impress her, so I still was having to work through stuff like that.
SPEAKER_00You're stepping in some dangerous territory.
SPEAKER_01My wife, when she met me, she literally said, When I saw you walk in the conference room, the HR conference room, we started on the same day. She said, I looked at you and thought, what an egghead. Travelers really got a winner here. Wow. So I stumbled out of the gate badly. But the moral of the story is eggs are good for you.
SPEAKER_00Yes. That is fantastic. So walk us through Travelers. What was your experience there?
SPEAKER_01It was great because it was first job out of college, and it was it's a terrific company. Got great learning. Obviously, I met my wife. I learned just a ton about underwriting. I was in personal and then moved over to commercial, how big companies operate. And from there, then I went to a much smaller company called State Auto Insurance, which is located here in Columbus, Ohio, and got to take that big company experience and bring it into the small company. So I felt like I got the best of both worlds, but uh totally, totally positive experience at both places.
SPEAKER_00Fantastic. And then what did that lead to?
SPEAKER_01So almost 20 years ago, I came across uh the work of a man named Robert Cialdini, Dr. Cialdini, who was a social psychologist out of Arizona State University. And I was so enthralled with his material. And when I came across it, he studies the psychology of persuasion. And when I started to hear him talk about it, the light bulb came on. I was like, this is the foundation of selling, and this is what I want to do with the rest of my career. And so I started weaving it into everything I did sales training, sales coaching. I ran a corporate university, everything I was doing corporately, weaved it in and set up my business on the side. And then two and a half years ago decided it was time to jump ship and do this full time.
SPEAKER_00So you were doing that for a company at first?
SPEAKER_01I was uh working with the field salespeople at state auto insurance. Oh, okay. And then I started working with the independent insurance agents and doing uh multi-day workshops for them to help them with their sales skills and from there moved into the corporate university. And that was uh after that, is when I decided it was time to jump. So not out of an airplane, but jump.
SPEAKER_00It's so interesting because agents will go in and often not have any experience with insurance, right? They come from another industry, open up a shop, and then it's a baptism by fire. They have to learn the business, the industry, the lingo. They have to learn how to become a manager, a hiring manager, a salesperson, you know, all of these things. And then zooming down on that specific area, there's the selling and being good at selling, and then there's the part of being good at prospecting or marketing, right? Bringing in the people to sell. It's a dynamic to be able to spin those two plates.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. And unfortunately, most people are simply taught all about the policy and how to talk about the policy, but not really taught how to sell or you know what is the psychology of selling. And when you understand how other people think and behave, and you start adjusting how you interact with them, it's incredible the difference that it can make. And that's what I teach people how to do based on the research from social psychology and behavioral economics.
SPEAKER_02So I love this subject because it's it's definitely one of my favorites to believe everything is. I want to know what were some of the first aha's that you had, especially diving into I I thought it was Caldini, but Caldini's work. What were the things that really got the wheels turning and then implementing uh with agents?
SPEAKER_01Okay. Well, as I said, when I heard him speak, and it was a video from Stanford, he spoke there back around 2001, 2002, and I was intrigued by the psychology because I saw how it related to sales. I appreciated his stance on ethics. He talked about non-manipulative ways to do this. But what really was probably the aha, I'm a very logical person. I started my career in underwriting, you know, things are pretty black and white, yes or no, that kind of thing. And truthfully, I thought sales was a bunch of BS. I just thought it doesn't matter how you talk, agent just wants the lowest price, and uh customer just wants the lowest price. And then once I started getting into selling and I started to realize a good salesperson can make a big difference in terms of helping you get what you need, and then layer on top of that this psychology that when you look at what the research shows and what a difference it can make when you engage the psychology, that was the aha for me. Like, wow, four times more people said yes to the very same thing just because they changed a couple of words or reframed how they presented that. And I just thought that was so amazing. And I guess that logical part of me wanted to understand the human mind more. And so I started diving in deep in all of that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we are so oh, sorry, go ahead. No, no, no, you go. I was just gonna say we are very, very focused in our agencies on the training of the staff, on constant sales training. It's uh daily, if not twice a day, where we just we work on little stuff because it's it's the reps, right? It's not once they have a broad understanding of that psychology and understanding and really buying into the idea, because I know obviously, if you're working with a lot of agencies, you know that first you have to sell them on the idea, right? They're like, ah, whatever. You know, we just quote them and and what we find is especially if you hire somebody from outside, they're usually terrible if they came from the insurance industry as a salesperson, right? Otherwise, they'd be where they were and never have left. So you bring them in, you have to break a lot of bad habits because it's sort of this. I'm just gonna quote you like quote isn't even a word we use in the agency because it's we're gonna have a conversation about your insurance and find out about the coverages you have without getting too far down the rabbit hole because you know, people turn off when they start talking about insurance, so you have to be careful. But I'd be interested in knowing like when you walk into an agency and you start talking to that team, you start working with them, what's the first thing that you do as you're observing them?
SPEAKER_01Well, perhaps the most important thing is teaching them about uh the psychology of what we call the principle of liking, that it's easier for people to say yes to those they know and like. Now everybody's like, oh duh, I get that. But most people, when you observe them, they don't understand how to put it into practice and they focus on the wrong thing. So we teach people some very simple things. For example, you know, when we connect on what we have in common, it is very natural for people to like others that they see as similar to themselves. So always making a concerted effort to talk about or find out what you have in common and make that a starting point of your conversations. But the big problem that people run into is they try to get people to like them. Now I know that the principle says if people like you, they're more likely to say yes. But you can come across like a used car salesperson when you're desperately trying to get that person to like you. And the key really is do everything you can to come to like that other person. So if you two guys really start to say, wow, Brian really likes me, that's where you start opening up to whatever I might share, because deep down we all believe that friends do right by friends, right? And if you sense that I truly like you, you're more open to what I share. But because I do like you, what I put on the table is in your best interest. It's not just to make a sale, it's to give you the best product, best service possible. So we've got this virtuous cycle where I'm doing everything I can to like you, you're sensing that, and it becomes so much easier for us to do business. I love that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that is great. What are some of the things when you do go into an agency that you see that almost every agency does, that these are the first few things we need to implement to make a change?
SPEAKER_01Well, one of the things, I mean, right off the bat, when you walk in, you're gonna probably be greeted by somebody. Uh, and that person's gonna probably be fairly nice, but they should be very outgoing. I mean, think about when you walk into Starbucks, right? Everybody, hey, how you doing? You feel really good about that. You can get coffee lots of other places and you can get it a lot cheaper. But you usually don't get that same feel when you walk into those places. So everything starts at that moment. I tell people they may not do business with you just because they like you, but they'll never do business with you if they don't like you, unless you offer something that is so out of the box that they just can't get it elsewhere. So everything starts there. And then there are little things that you can do to engage. For example, there's a principle of reciprocity. If I do something for you, Jason, you feel this sense of obligation to want to do something in return. If somebody walks into your agency, and I know that Craig, you're down in Tucson, right? So if somebody walks into your agency, it's always hot. Having something for them that they can have, like water, is a nice gesture, but you never want them to go get it themselves because that doesn't engage the principal. It's when somebody says, Oh, it's warm out today, would you like some water? Absolutely. And that person hands it to them, right? Right. That's where reciprocity is engaged. And all of these little interactions, the really being nice as they come in, connecting on what they might have in common, handing them that water, all of this is starting to build this momentum that's going to make it easier when they sit down with the person who they're gonna start talking about their insurance needs with. Um, for example, you guys ever stay at the Double Tree? You ever stay at the Debbie?
SPEAKER_00I have, yes. I have.
SPEAKER_01You know, everybody knows the Double Tree because of the chocolate chip cookie. Yeah. And it's a good cookie, but the Embassy Suites has pretty good cookies too. But the difference is when you check in at the Double Tree, they hand you the cookie right at that moment and it sets the stage for everything else. When you're walking in and out of the embassy suites, you can grab as many of those vanilla or chocolate cookies as you want, but it doesn't engage people the same way as that simple act of presenting that gift as soon as they check in. That's the kind of thing that you want to think about when somebody is going to come into your agency. How can we engage them in this way that makes them feel very different than the what they feel when they go to another agency?
SPEAKER_00You have to differentiate that very, very red ocean. And it's so powerful. We talk about this all the time with the staff or with the team, about all of the little details. And it's why we we hammer out that it's scripted, it's a loose script, but you there's certain things that you have to say. And like, ah, but some new person, I don't want to say that. And like, no, you have to say that. Like part of this is non-negotiable because it does, it creates that momentum. And you're at the plat, you're at the plate, you're swinging, and you have to increase the chances of hitting the ball. And the sum of all of these little details are what create that optimal uh chance.
SPEAKER_01So, what I teach people about, we I've used the term principle a couple of times, these principles of persuasion that are across the globe. Uh, as social psychologists have studied this, to one degree or another, humans respond to all of these. So, when you understand these principles, as opposed to just a script, you are more flexible in terms of how you can interact with people. So, I don't want people to say things exactly the way I say them. I want them to so deeply understand the psychology that they can use their own words. We're essentially saying the same thing, but it sounds completely authentic because it's using the way you talk, Craig, or the way you talk, Jason, as opposed to the way I might have said it exactly.
SPEAKER_02Love it. Love it. Yeah. What are some things over the phone and how different is it than in person?
SPEAKER_01Well, over the phone, obviously, you can't read body language, even though people still have body language. I mean, they're squirming in their chair or they're shaking their head yes or or no, but you can't tell that. So over the phone, you have to pay a lot more attention to tone of voice because tone of voice is going to indicate where somebody is in terms of their emotional state. Are they really into what you're talking about, or are they just dispassionate? Are they bored? Is there something else on their mind? You really have to get good at catching tone of voice. And then it becomes even more important to ask a lot of questions. Because if you can't see that person and you're not asking questions, you don't know if they're just looking off in out the window or what. But when you engage people with questions, even if they don't answer them out loud, they're always answering them in their head. And so you want to keep somebody in. You have to utilize questions. And Jason, to one of the questions you asked earlier about, you know, what are some things you see that people do wrong? A lot of times people spend way too much time telling people rather than asking. And if they ask and that person answers for themselves, now they own it because they are the ones that put it out on the table. It wasn't pushed out on them as advice or opinion.
SPEAKER_02Can you give examples of both?
unknownSure.
SPEAKER_02And the different ways to frame?
SPEAKER_01An example would be when I would work with agents and I would say, what is a reason that somebody's going to want to do business with you? Almost all the time they'll say, because we're local. And I'm like, okay, that might be a good reason. But in the world that we're in where we can do so much over uh Zoom and other platforms, is that really as big a deal? So what you need to do is simply ask the question, Jason, is it important to you that, you know, if you needed to sit down with your agent face to face for a difficult conversation, that you'd be able to do that in 20 or 30 minutes if you had to? Almost every person will say yes. And at that point, that's where you can say, you know, that's what most of our customers appreciate about us being local, that we can sit down with them if something comes up immediately, looking them in the eye and having that conversation. But the fact that you said it now, it becomes one more trigger for you to potentially say, that's who I want to do business with. And whatever it is that you think is unique about your agency, and certainly uniqueness is a factor in some why somebody would want to do business with you. Because if they can't get the same products or service or combination from somebody else, then that makes you more valuable. But the best way to get them to see that is by asking questions. So I would say anything that you think is a unique factor about your agency, how can you, rather than advertise it, ask a question to get people to verbalize how they feel about it?
SPEAKER_00Love it. Why is it that the producers will maybe they would even know this, but then they'll revert to back to telling it instead of asking those questions?
SPEAKER_01The same reason so many people are bad at golf because they've had so many bad reps to begin with, and they know what they should do, but in the moment, thinking takes a lot of work. And so once you become preoccupied with all the other things, you just naturally fall back to what's comfortable. So this is a skill that you need to really retrain your brain and get into the habit of asking lots of questions. And so you talked about, you know, that you continually talk to your staff in little bites about things. You would want to continually reinforce the value of asking questions and getting them to do the same thing. The beauty of it is you don't have to carry the conversation. You ask the question, you take a breath, you let that person talk, you display good listening skills, you ask another question, you let them talk. It's actually a lot easier when you learn how to ask questions as opposed to a monologue.
SPEAKER_02Love it. Love it. It's almost like you're helping them do the thinking for them instead of throwing it in their court and they might not connect to the dots.
SPEAKER_01There's a pretty well-known sales trainer out in the Phoenix area, who, Tom Hopkins, who likes to say, when you say it, they doubt it. But when they say it, they believe it. And that's always true, right? When something comes from us, we own that. When it comes from you, it might be good, it might not be good, but boy, when it comes from me, I feel differently about it.
SPEAKER_00Right. We say a lot, help them make the decision, right? You you help them along so that they make that decision. Because if they make the decision, they're here for a long time.
SPEAKER_04Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Mm-hmm. Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium off of even the worst internet leads, where could they go?
SPEAKER_03They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_04I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_03Let's do it. Sign up right now live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_04Live.teledudes.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_03Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah. Which is awesome. But they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm going to respond to these texts. I'm going to respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's going to be awesome. And it's a it's going to be our new texting community where we're going to get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. Mmm. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it. I'm gonna text it right now. 520-214-2219.
SPEAKER_04All right. I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_00I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman