The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Unburden Your Business with Cassidy Arbeli Part 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up, it's the Insurance Dudes Podcast. I think that a lot of agents come in and then they just blamo agency ownership happens or not ownership, agency operation happens, right? So you're stuck on the hamster wheel just answering the phone, trying to do all this stuff that takes you away from the gross side of it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I went out and I really tried to do some research. I asked anybody I could to come have coffee with me. I was like, I'll come visit you, I'll bring you whatever, let's just eat, let's just hang out. And honestly, it's just my personality in general. Anyone who ever asked me, I'm like, yeah, let's do it. Like, let's just go have a chat. And I found that either agents had no idea how they were successful, they were just kind of doing it, and they just had like the innate personality or the skill, and they weren't sure what exactly was working right for them, or some agents just weren't willing to share, or the ones that were doing the best in my area really weren't as profitable as I thought. And I think the whole mentality of like just sell, sell, sell, everything else is gonna work out hit me, and I was like, okay, so this isn't actually the one thing I need to have a successful business, is just to increase revenue constantly, right? If I don't know what to do with my money or I don't know how to continue to grow my profit margin, if I don't know how to keep my team members, if I don't, you know, just the different things that you do. If I don't build a brand that I can use no matter what products I'm selling, no matter what life shifts our way, then what am I doing? And that really helped me understand that this isn't just about what products am I selling, what company am I selling for, or one particular type of policy or coverage that you're selling to people. There's a lot of agents that maybe will just sell a certain type of policy because they like it, it's easy, one, two, three, and they just want to get the sales. Like that's not what this is about, right? So, really just again designing my agency to work for me and what I believed in and what I wanted and understanding that it is a business no matter what. So that's really what I think changed everything.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Doing everything, providing every level of service and all these things as the agent, right? They could be painted as the picture of you're the agent, which is the sort of the employee. I mean, it's not scalable, right? You can't do the thing which needs to be done, which is growth, if you're doing all of those things. How did you find that comfortable place where you were actually playing the role of business owner?
SPEAKER_00So I actually was doing a podcast about this myself, and this came off of the book clockwork that I read, which I love, Mike McCallowicks, I think you say his name. He's like one of my favorite authors, but he talks about the four different phases of like business where you go from doing to deciding to delegating and then designing. And the idea is that when we first start entrepreneurship, we're doing all the things because we're opening the business, we know what we're doing, we have to teach all the others, and you get so overwhelmed by doing that, then you start hiring people and then you teach them how to do, and then you move to the deciding phase where now everybody's doing everything, but they don't know how to take initiative or ownership, and they're coming to you every second saying, Okay, make this decision for me, I don't know what to do. Right. And then you're standing here all day just making decisions, and then you're like, wait a second, I'm so sick of making making decisions. If I'm just gonna do that, I might as well just do the work myself and fire everyone, and you go back to doing and it's the loop. The cycle starts all over again. Yeah. And so the real thing was getting to a point where I could find the team members that, oh, you're really great at this and you enjoy this. Like, you could take ownership and master this department or this position, and I'm going to allow you to take ownership in bringing these results to our company and take initiative, like, have at it. If something doesn't work out, I got your back. If it works out, great, like let's push it and let's invest in that and spend our time doing that. And so I really focused on doing that part, getting them to the point where I'm delegating a lot of the work. And then all of a sudden, I was like, I have nothing to do. I don't have to answer the phones, I don't have to greet clients, they don't even have to know I exist. Even in my independent agency now, I'm pretty much a ghost. There's my name's not on the building, a lot of people don't even know that I own it. I was at a party a couple weeks ago and somebody was kind of telling me about something, and I was like, I'm pretty sure you're our client. I can solve this issue for you or I can help you. And they're like, No, no, no, I'm insured by this person. Like, that's my employee, like my team, or like I promise you you're with our agency. So it's kind of, and that's just something that I wanted to build. That was my dream. That doesn't mean it has to be everyone's. And so as I delegated, and then I got to a point where like, okay, I have a process where I can hold everyone accountable, but I don't really need to anymore. They know how to do what they need to do themselves, that I can start designing stuff. I can design if I want to open another location, if I want to go independent, if I want to niche down into commercial, and then even niche down more into specific industries, I can decide that I don't want to work anymore. I can just design other businesses and other streams of income, and that's kind of how that all started.
SPEAKER_04That is awesome. How was the transition from the captive to independent?
SPEAKER_00So the story is not a positive one, unfortunately. There's some things that happened with State Farm, which I'm sure you've heard stories from many people. It's not any different. But after some of the things that happened, I just had not a great feeling, and I really wanted to own my own book of business. I really wanted to have a little bit more freedom on how I could brand, how I could market, the things that I can do with my team and just have more freedom. And I knew my worth, I knew what I could do. So we basically walked away from a really large book of business being number one in our territory for a really long time in commercial. And I was like, I don't care about the money, I gotta go. My integrity just was not aligning with my you just completely walked away from it. Yep. Just went. They gave us six months, and I told my sales leader, I was like, Look, in six months I'm out of here. Like, do what you gotta do. If you have to make me leave now, it is what it is. And we opened independent, and in three years of independent agency, we tripled what we did that what we walked away from. Let's just say that. So it was worth it a hundred percent. It wasn't it was scary, it wasn't easy, but we came in with experience, we knew exactly what we wanted to do, and we just went for it.
SPEAKER_01It was you bring your team pretty crazy.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Actually, I think only one of them did not move over, or something happened. I think they moved, I honestly.
SPEAKER_01So you did Jerry McGuire, but they all got up and went with you.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Basically, without giving away any kind of details that you don't want to, but I think a lot of people have found themselves in that situation or might end up in that situation because that's a hot topic, right? When you're a captive, a hot topic is the independent side or or whatever. So, what were some of the things that you were going through? How did you overcome them? What have you found on the other side that you can maybe give shed some light on for some making?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I would definitely say one of the things was that I drank the Kool-Aid. I mean, I was state farm hardcore. I had been a client for all my life, pretty much, and my parents, like, that was it. I never thought that it would be anything else. I think that the issue was is that my trust in them got questioned, and my integrity got questioned by them, and then my trust came into question of if I trust them anymore, and then it started happening all over the place, and suddenly I realized like I am not in control. I've put in my blood, sweat, and tears into this, and important as it is for me that I've built this, I can do it again. Like, I believed in myself, and I didn't need them to believe in me, which it felt like I was just another number, and that's not what I wanted, especially the process of going through like an audit or a compliance thing, and then finding out after, like, okay, we didn't find anything, we still want you to be an agent, like, and the way that you get treated, and still not having anything basically happen, it was just really bad taste in my mouth, and I just I feel like you just gotta be careful, read your contracts, know that at the end of the day, like, business is business, right? So, like, I also didn't take it personal because it is what it is. I knew that I just it was my moment to move on to do something else, but I just think that you need to understand, like, you've got to look out for yourself, don't just go chasing all the awards and all the bonuses and all that stuff because that's all short-lived. It's really about creating this business long term and how you want it. Like, maybe you need to play the rules till you get the contract, right? Or till you get that appointment if you're with the captive or trying to get appointments with carriers for independent, but then what does that mean for you in the long run? Like, stop looking at the short-sighted things and really think about is this for you? And I still love that.
SPEAKER_04I love one of the things I love the you said is that you learned a lot and you had a lot of equity in that. And I think a lot of people can feel confined in a captive space, but what they don't realize is all the stuff that you're learning is really your equity. And to the point of what you did, it's like you had all that equity and you were able to transition out. Now, that might make some captive people like realize your worth, realize that you can do it regardless, and then that'll make it feel less confined, I think. You know what I mean? Too. Because I think when you are captive, you feel a little confined, but it's like, dude, you're crushing it. Like you could leave if you wanted to, but it might make you feel a little bit better staying.
SPEAKER_00I do want to give the time that I spent there the credit it deserved because it really did give me the space and the platform and whatever I really needed that I could absorb from them to allow me to learn how to do better in the next phase, in the next chapter. And if I didn't have that, I probably wouldn't have been as successful in the short time of independent agency that I have been and looking forward. And what's great is that suddenly my team members got tastes of what it's like to write half a million dollar policies and they're like, huh, I could do this. And all of a sudden, three months later, there was another one. And it's like these are the type of things that I only dreamt of, right? Like year one, year two, year three, even year five. Like, I never I was like, people do that, you know, people pay half a million dollars in insurance. We're like, yeah, they do. So when you get over certain levels, you almost laugh at yourself that that was a dream once it's realized, and then you start dreaming bigger, and it's totally possible.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So we're our worst enemy. We talk ourselves into thinking that we can't do those things, and then it's like, oh, well, that was that hard, right? It's all that's the anticipation is worse than the actual thing itself.
SPEAKER_00So that's what I always say when it comes to like so. When I coach or consult some of my clients now, on sometimes I'm like, you this team member's not working, we gotta get rid of them, like they're just not working for you. And they're like, but I have to fire someone. And I'm like, I promise you, dealing with this person for another month or two is so much worse than the five minutes it's gonna take for you to let them go. Like, that was one of the things I'm like, you know, it's really not that bad to have a I mean the conversation sucks, but it's like, would you rather deal with them for longer when it's not working out or set them free and have a five-minute uncomfortable conversation? And I think that's the kind of mentality, like, yeah, this is gonna have some growing pains, but then you're on the other side, and it's great over here. Like, come on over.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
unknownSo yeah.
SPEAKER_01So talk a little bit about the other businesses that you've opened now that you've been able to create the ownership piece.
SPEAKER_00There's quite a few. Um, we have a manufacturing company where we manufacture products and import export from China and then do some e-commerce. And then we have a how'd you get into that? You know, it's a combination of me and my husband, but also family stuff. So, like I said, I came from a family of entrepreneurs, and sometimes there's just some of them have been opportunities that have presented themselves, and some of them we just kind of fell into. So that kind of came from like a family thing, and then we just took it over, and then we bought commercial space when we transitioned to independent agency, and so then we tasted commercial landlordship, and so we've actually bought four properties since then, so we've become commercial landlords. We have an RV rental business, so we rent RVs on trips and a couple other things. I mean, there's all kinds of stuff, it's sort of random, but I really enjoy the low investment, high return, and stuff where I can create processes for and then I can step away where I'm not constantly in the business. So that's really more what I look for when I'm investing or trying to work in another industry. So the e-commerce is probably the biggest one that takes most of our effort, but it's me and my husband kind of doing it. So luckily I have somebody else to help me.
SPEAKER_04That's super cool. Love it. Well, talk about uh the coaching. I'm super curious. So you said this is this is your, I mean, this is what you really like to do, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, this is kind of my passion project. And I've been talking to two, but I really work with female insurance agency owners, and I'm really passionate because when I first started, even sometimes now, I mean I had a conversation today about this with another woman in the industry, and the comment was all of our male underwriters don't really like females. It's like, anyways, so why I bring this up is because I feel like we have a different experience in this industry, and as I think it's shifting and getting better, where it's a little bit more equal and there's not that much of like this gender feeling gap. I think that there is a huge lack in support for women specifically, and really want to find my own tribe too. I felt so lonely going through this, especially as a mom, and there's just so much more on our plate that I feel like is not addressed sometimes when it comes to business ownership, when it comes to our industry in general. And so I do business consulting with female insurance agency owners. I have an awesome Facebook group full of these amazing women that inspire me every day too. And I have a program called Agency by Design where I teach them how to really create an agency by design and not have this success just by default and stop following what everyone else is doing, right? So basically, take all the mistakes I made and take all the success that I've had and really use that formula that I feel like is what is necessary for you to have a long-term, healthy, growing business, and then specifically in this industry. So yeah, that's pretty much me. And then I podcast for fun and let my sassy personality come out there in the world. Um, my podcast is called Unburden Your Business, and the whole premise behind that is that you start your business to have time, money, freedom, all the things, and we don't want to just have it be another burden in our life, we want it to actually be a blessing. So I go on the podcast and just give out tips and things to talk about how to do that and unburden your business.
SPEAKER_01Oh, great. That's me. Is that on all the different platforms that can find that? Yep. Cool. Well, I know that you're up against the wall, you have to go pick up a little one. So let's end it with Final Question The final question. What is one piece of advice that you would give to somebody that is jumping into this industry and you can't say run the other direction?
SPEAKER_00No, do not run the other direction. Run like jump like head first. Honestly, the biggest thing that I think if somebody would have told me this would have made my journey to a little bit more success financially, I would say, is don't try to keep up with the entrepreneur's when it comes to the insurance industry. Like put your blinders on, decide what it is that you want, and just go. And don't worry about what everyone else is doing because there's so much amazing resources out there and people out there that are willing to help you, but at the end of the day, just stay true to yourself and you'll go far.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, shiny object syndrome just is a killer. There are so many things to do. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Well, well, is there anything else that you want to get out there? Any websites, anything for the listeners before you have to take up.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, you can find me on Instagram and on the podcast. Unburning your business is really just my brand and everywhere you can find me. And I'd love to connect with people. Like it's my favorite thing in the world to do. I have so much time now to kind of give back and hang out and get to know people. So please, if you're listening, if you've enjoyed anything, come hang out.
SPEAKER_01Well, thank you, Cassidy. Awesome. So great to have you on. It's always really good to have an insurance dudet on the podcast. So thank you. Yes.
SPEAKER_04Yes.
SPEAKER_00Thank you guys so much for having me. I appreciate it.
SPEAKER_01Well, thank you. And you may be getting an insurance dudet shirt in the mail, so we hope to see that on the show.
SPEAKER_00Okay, I'm waiting for it.
SPEAKER_01Will that be on Instagram? Is the question.
SPEAKER_00Yes, it will.
SPEAKER_01All right. Awesome. Well, thank you, and we will we'll talk to you down the road. Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_00Thanks.
SPEAKER_01Hey, Jason.
SPEAKER_02Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Mm-hmm. Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh 100,000 premium of even the worst internet lead, where can they go? They can go to live.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we going to be there?
SPEAKER_03Yeah. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will hit live and it will show you the product. The entire project.
SPEAKER_02I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_03Let's do it. Try it up right now. Live.teledude.com.
SPEAKER_02Live.teledude.com. That's live.
SPEAKER_03This is a new community that we are creating the community. We can tell everybody about. It is our live detecting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content. We have awfully texting. 520, 214, 2219. 520, 214, 2219. I'm going to respond to it for sure. I'm going to do it too. It's going to be a good idea. It's going to be our new community where we're going to get back to everybody that we can. And crazy content. Free content. And free the calculator that you just came up with. I mean everything free. I can't remember it.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman