The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
An Instrument Rated Private Pilot and Insurance Nerd Jason Levine Part 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up, it's the Insurance Dudes Podcast. So when you came in, what size was it before you now are at double premium? It's about 7 million DWP. Okay, so now you're 14. That's a big book. How many staff do you have? Oh, that's a funny story in this labor market. I thought it was normal in Florida.
SPEAKER_02Oh, God. No, no, no. We've been blessed. And we've had people, we had a woman retire with us after 20 years. Oh wow. Last year in May. I've got a gentleman with us now. He's one of our top personal lines salespeople who's who's coming up on 15 years. He's just celebrated his 14th anniversary with the agency. But this labor market has gotten wonky. And as things quote unquote get back to normal, turn on the news. Actually, don't turn on the news, but go find some headlines to read. And the occurrence of people up and quitting is like unbelievable. It's crazy. So to answer your question, if you count myself, my wife, and our operations manager who's not a family member, um, we have ebbed between 10 and 15 total staff over the last year. And it's FAIA convention that I referenced that we were at last week. You know, the the reason I just tell this story, and if you want to get into some specifics, there are some great, crazy stories from some recent goings-ons personnel-wise, and and you know, I think I can keep it clean where it's not an HR problem.
SPEAKER_00There's a start with Florida man. Florida man.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, Florida man or Florida woman. She's out there too. But uh I'm at this convention last week and I'm talking to a good friend of mine from another part of the state, and she goes, Yeah, my whole personal lines department got up and walked out two weeks ago. Oh and that that is what we're seeing. And thank God that didn't happen to us. Three-fifths of it did. But but there is an incredible shuffle going on right now. And I think people do have pandemic fatigue. I think there are enough published statistics that we can say unequivocally that there are way more jobs than applicants right now. And I'm a free market guy, you remember? I I said cheeto. I didn't say delirious, I said cheeto. Um and supply and demand, right? So the supply is the way it lines up with the demand, the the market's nuts. It's all of a sudden wages are as much as 30% higher. Um, people are poaching like mad left and right. It's a weird world right now, but but I think we've done away with virtual school. I mean, there's still some of the traditional, like you can take one class online or something, but the virtual option in Florida is dead and gone. So when kids go back to school in August, they will be at brick and mortar schools with 100%. There's no other option. Uh, and I think that'll change a lot of things too. Look, we we closed our office down. So, Florida, banking and finance was always considered essential. We did not have to close our office, but in the interest of managing hearts and minds, I mean, I think we would have had a mutiny if we didn't. Uh and we only closed down for a couple of weeks. We were closed St. Patrick's Day to Memorial Day. And June 1st, my daughter's early childhood program reopened, and so did our office. Coincidence, not at all. It was uh so we understand the uh the childcare, how significant of a factor, of a variable that is. Uh so I I think we'll see you know some things start to ease, and and Florida goes back to school early. We're like uh second or third week of August. So we you know you don't even have to wait until September, like most of the country. We'll see, but it's fun down here, man. It's fun everywhere, right? I was just on on the line with a consultant right before you guys uh that we partner with who's based out of Rhode Island, but she travels the country, and she's her her response was kind of like you and everybody else. Yeah.
SPEAKER_05What yeah you I was gonna say, what's getting you excited this year? So uh obviously you seem to like the shakeup. It it can be dreary. I I think you seem like you're a glass half full kind of guy, right?
SPEAKER_02Oh, absolutely. I mean, look, you've got to be dynamic, right? That that's my whole thing is that this is the moment where an old timer digs their heels in and gets left in the dust. You just gotta stay on your toes, and and it is what it is. And you know, I've got another at least 15 years to play this game, so I I don't want to be in a cloud of dust.
SPEAKER_00Well, there's always some sort of challenge, right? I mean, this is just a different one, and it's more everybody's experience is the same different one. Well, money is printed unlimited and uh weird, you know, upside down. Everything is just not the way that it seems, but we'll get through it. Get be stronger for it.
SPEAKER_05Amen. What are you looking forward to? What are you bullish on in the uh within the next year or two? Where where is your agency headed?
SPEAKER_02Sure. Um I I think the answer to that, again, Florida is just a weird market. That question has had three different answers six months ago, 12 months ago, and 18 months ago. Um right now it's growth, but it's focusing on our core partners. And that the national carriers have started to re-expand their their footprint in Florida. And the only way we can even do things for people, sell insurance right now in the person alliance realm. Commercial lines is another story. Commercial lines, that that's gonna be the growth area. We're gonna add producers, we're gonna have a shitload of fun, and we're gonna make a ton of money and we're gonna help people. Personal lines, it's a different beast right now. We basically have maybe one or two, but there are like no carriers that will write a roof over 10 years old right now. Uh, we have carriers that will only write a roof if it's five years old or younger. Um personal lines, it's crazy. So they're calling Central Florida, the core Central Florida counties, Solo, SOLO, Seminole Orange Lake, and Osceola, the new Miami. So all the insanity that's always been Palm Beach Broward and Miami Dade, welcome to Orlando. Thanks, Miami. You brought all your damn baggage north. I appreciate the empanadas and the poladas, but come on, send the trash back down. And you know, meaning the fraud, the dishonest contractors. There are like eight law firms. And so, in another hat I wear, I've been very, very involved with the Florida Association of Insurance Agents, came all the way up through the Young Agents Council, was the chair of YAC, sat on the board of FAAIA, the big kids table, so to speak. So I'm I'm very plugged into this stuff. So, long story short, there are like eight law firms that have created a cottage industry out of how to cheat insurance companies. We've had three or four insolvencies in the last two years, and we haven't had hurricanes or sinkholes. It's when you've got you know $15,000, $20,000 shingle roofs being replaced for $40,000 and $50,000 because the attorneys and the PAs have to get paid. Oh, and by the way, all the roofing companies now usually have a staff PA or a staff legal counsel. Wow. These are roofers. Roofers. Roofers. It's an industry. Well, there's plenty of honest ones too. And like I said, there are eight law firms, and everybody knows who they are. And there are probably 8,000 law firms in the state, right? So this isn't, you know, Shakespeare saying kill all the lawyers, even though I use that quite a lot. But uh it sucks. So anyway, let me actually answer your question. Uh on the personal line side, I think it's really strengthening our relationships with our core partners and showing people the value of bundling because we have that back in Florida. Uh, we've got some national brands that'll do home and auto, and that's where they'll get aggressive. Unfortunately, we've had to tell people recently if they're calling up for a homeowner's quote, they're like, I am just not giving you my auto information. I'm shopping my home, that's what I want to talk about. We basically have to tell them, like, I'm sorry, call somebody else. Like, there's very little we can do for you. By the way, the reason that your rate just, and this is like real numbers, the the reason that your rate just went from 1,300 or 1400 to like 3,500 is your 16-year-old shingle roof that may very well be in great shape, but it's not eligible with anybody. Um, I do have a product or two where you could get actual cash value settlement for your roof. So you're just gonna sue me when you have a claim, and I really don't want you to sue me. So can I have your auto information? It's not tie-in sales. It's literally if you give me the auto, I've got like three or four markets that I can go to and get like 20 to 30% discounts. Otherwise, our property market is just screwed. Uh so commercial's the future, and and why that isn't scary, guys, it is forever and always, right? The the IA channel has controlled 70 to 80 percent of the commercial line's market, and direct writers only 20 to 30. Direct writers have controlled 70 to 80 percent of the personal insurance market, IA has only controlled 20 to 30 percent of that. Um, so that that trend is nothing new, so it shouldn't really be anything scary, even though it's it's a little maddening. Uh, but again, you've got to be nimble on your toes, and and if I've got to you know call my marketing guys and say, hey, some dollars that we're spending getting personal lines leads in, let's shift it over to commercial. And and I need to head up to I Days and Tallahassee and find some some good young talent, I'm all for it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. What portion of your book is personal versus commercial?
SPEAKER_02So after having said everything I just said, um so so those of you that know the typical makeup of a nationwide agent from back in the day, a captive nationwider, or the same as like a state farm agent today. I know a ton of them, I love them, they're great people, but derelict of duty, they're dangerous when it comes to commercial and they're personal as experts. So the the average nationwide shop was very small and commercial, 10% or less. We were right at 10%. So January 1, 2008, we were about 90% personal, 10% commercial. Right now it stands at about 70% personal, 30% commercial, and our our business plan wants to get it to 50-50. Nice.
SPEAKER_00A lot of opportunity there. Oh, yeah. Have you talked or met uh David Carruthers? I have.
SPEAKER_02I've sat through seminars of his uh at IAOA, the the insurance agency owners of land. Awesome guy. He is a boss. IAOA is a hell of a group of people.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I think they're like 7,000 members now.
SPEAKER_00That's crazy.
SPEAKER_02That's we were sitting in a bar drinking whiskey in Ireland, and uh it was actually a trip with with auto owners insurance, and we met this agent from Tucson, Arizona. And cool. Who you know uh John John Foxworthy? Yes, I do. So John. I actually bought part of his book, John Foxworthy.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's awesome.
SPEAKER_02For the carrier who we can't name a bar in Ireland with Foxworthy drinking red breast, and and he's like, You guys should check out this IAOA thing, and and it was fledgling. I mean, it was that I think they had had just that first conference in like San Antonio or something, and yeah, it was like this new thing, and we're kind of like, all right, whatever, like Facebook, cool. And now we're like annual IAOA attendees, and and we love it. We always get some some huge takeaways, and following Nick Ayers' personal Facebook account is now like my favorite sport. It's very interesting.
SPEAKER_00It's very interesting. You have to like roller skates. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, roller skates and banana hammocks once he moved to Airbnb. Yes, it's a little disturbing at times. That's his goal. So, you know, speaking of airs, let's talk a little bit about marketing. So, what do you do to grow your book? Because you, I mean, doubling up is is a pretty significant achievement. Why don't you pass out some tidbits?
SPEAKER_05And I think right before you answer that, I I think I want to state for anybody that has a smaller book, man, even at an an amazing 90% retention or something like that, when you're at 10 million, that means that you're gonna lose a million dollars. So if you're growing in those bigger numbers, it gets very difficult to continue that growth. So it's a lot more impressive than just, oh, he grew by a million. Yeah, no, well, he wrote like two million or three million to get to those numbers.
SPEAKER_02So yeah. So there's a lot of things we do, but but there's one single core fundamental thing. And that's what I love to share with people. We can get into all the digital stuff we do and and stuff we used to do that that we've kind of reeled in and how to create a presence as a hometown agent in sort of some outlying areas that have better underwriting guidelines than those core counties I mentioned, Seminole Orange Lake, Osceola. And the digital era really enables that because you know you can make yourself look like you're the hometown guy anywhere, and it doesn't really matter where you're sitting. That's not the fundamental. The fundamental goes back to when my folks, there's a whole nother story here. Keep it real quick, I won't even tell it. But when my folks came to Orlando from the Tampa Bay area, which is where my father's first agency was, uh, he did a similar thing with a nationwide book of business that he walked away from in Tampa and was given about an equal value book here. Remember, you don't own your expirations, captive land. I'll spare you the rest of the details. This is the fundamental. Stop obsessing over I've got to have this many leads and this many new clients. You need that activity, you need that volume, but the best lead you have are the people you've already sold to. And if you can go back and look, I know there are a bunch of hot shots going to go, I multi-line everything I sell. No, you don't. Get in your AMS if you have and do a reality check and look at your numbers. If you're anything above 60 or 65%, then you're truly a rock star. So if you're running between like 45 and 55, now you're probably average, at least what I see in my colleagues and even my own agency at certain periods, and then we relaunch these campaigns. But what what you have to do is turn inwards, especially when you have a super hard market and just a super weird market like we have right now in Florida with property. Um, and you have to focus on relationship building and multi-lining. And that's the secret. If you can multi-line, if you can bundle another 30% of the policies you've already got on the books, or insureds you've already got on the books, your retention is gonna skyrocket. Uh, that revenue pad is not gonna be temporary. Like a lot of people fall into the trap, and and we're Florida, right? So there's you know over a thousand people a day moving here, the housing market's out of control. So you get these agencies that are a homeowner's mill. But when there's a lull in the market or when rates go up, those people are screwed. But when you've got somebody who you've got their home, their auto, their motorcycle, their boat, their jet skis, they don't leave. Or it takes a lot more for them to leave. So that that account rounding, that cross-sell is is critical. And back in the day, my mother actually developed a program and it had all these things like you need three touches, and and if you you know, you make three phone calls and then you send a USPS postcard. I mean, this is the 90s, right? So there are some modifications to that. Now you still need a certain number of touches. Brandon Smith up in in Montana, speaking of IAOA, presented some awesome stats um at the last IAOA in San Diego, just before the world went batshit, in I think it was late January 2020. And and Harvard Business Review says you have to call somebody. It was it was insane. It was like 12 times before you actually get them on the phone on average or something. So anyway, you develop a campaign and you market to your existing book of business. And if you can ensure that that book of business becomes healthily multi-lined, that's how you do it. Sure, you need green, organic new revenue, new insured into the book. Uh, but to answer the question straight up, how do you do something like those doubling efforts? You turn inwards and you sell more insurance to the people that already trust you and work with you.
SPEAKER_00Right. Well, if you have a 50% of the book is is uh monoline, I mean a huge opportunity, right? Yep. So you mentioned a little three-step or three touches. Why don't you talk a little bit about that? Give away some of the meaty, the meaty details.
SPEAKER_02So it was really a simple program, and my mother was doing it, and our believe it or not, this did not come from nationwide. She brought it to nationwide, and Bourne was the care review. Their district manager took it to the state level, yada, yada, yada. True story, not some you know, BS, look at what we did. But it it was a simple program where they would run home no auto and auto no home lists and give it to each of the agents. And of course, everyone would have like 37 excuses why they're too busy, they have too much other stuff. There's this great story. The woman I mentioned who was with us for 20 years, we're still in touch. She's practically family, and by the way, she makes the best arroz con gondoles ever. If you ever make some Puerto Rican food, like I I always told this woman, if when you retire, if you want to open a restaurant or a food truck or something, I will invest. Um what's her name? Let's give her a shout out. Her name is Rosa Centenno. Nice. Rosa. So Rosa is an insurance pro and she can cook.
SPEAKER_00Well, shoot her in the lake and she'll she'll hear her mention on here.
SPEAKER_02Hey, hey, I will do that. But long story short, there's this great story where she was having one of these days where, like, oh, I just can't get it done. And my mother sat down in a chair at her desk and went, Well, I can't get anything else done until you get this done. So I'm not leaving this chair until you make your care call. Nice. Um, and it's it's a constant struggle, even you know, 25 years later when we run programs like this, because a lot of people they they just don't want to do it, they don't want to prioritize it. Um, but the original program was you made a series of three phone calls. So basically day one is a phone call, you you would pend it out, and and you know, day two might be like a business day or between one and three business days later, that's phone call two. Then again, one and three business days later, phone call three. And if you're still unsuccessful on phone call three, meaning you didn't reach the person, uh, you would send a uh a specially printed postcard in the mail back when the mail actually like was functional. And we do it a little bit differently now. I don't know if anybody works with uh Kelly Pierrot from Agency Performance Partners, uh, but she's an awesome consultant.
SPEAKER_00I think we didn't we talk to we we did, we had her on.
SPEAKER_02We had her on. Yeah. Kelly gets around and and in a clean way. And you know, she's an awesome. I mean, I don't know about anything else. She's I don't know. She spends lots of nights in hotels. We're gonna no comment, no comment. On the advice of my attorney, I have no comment. But like Kelly helped us kind of retweak the program uh you know last year, and it looks a bit different now where it's it's just a single phone call and a single email. But we're finding our agents have anywhere between I think the average success rate was like 38%. Um so let's say they're getting a hold of four in 10 people, but even just from an ENO perspective, we have bulletproof documentation that you know you got a phone call and and an email every year. Um we're no longer doing the the three touch points just because of book size, you know, the volume. We'd we'd need to hire multiple additional staff just to handle that. And and we're just not, it's just not practical at this point. And a matter of fact, that's one thing that we've got right now, uh, while while we're a little bit understaffed, we've got our intern for the summer from Florida State uh sending out those emails, not necessarily making the phone calls, but the email, like you know, that was one thing where my ops manager was like, well, maybe we should pause this for a minute. And I was like, Nope. This is one thing that will not get paused. It is an incredible account round opportunity, all right, and that EO thing. So the these people will be reached out to one way or another.
SPEAKER_00Man, it's filled with goodness, and we've gone the distance. Let's wrap it with one final question. If you could give, and I think we could go on for another hour, but if you could give one piece of advice to somebody jumping into this interesting world of insurance, not just the interesting world, but what would that be? Run like hell. Yeah. Run like hell. Yeah. Pick flight set.
SPEAKER_02I think I think it would be that you you've got to stay light on your feet. This is an industry that traditionally is slow to react, uh, slow to adapt, new technology, slow to change. And as an agency owner, you you've got to be the exact opposite. Uh, we are in uncharted waters, we're in unprecedented times, you know, and I'm not crying in my soup about it. I'm saying, you know, put on your dancing shoes and and stay on your toes. If you dig your heels in, don't waste your time. Uh, you know, just be constantly looking to how to triage what comes up in front of you and build a good team. And that is something that is a lot easier to talk about than to do. But team and culture are incredibly important. But just just stay nimble and and realize that what your values are, they may need to evolve um as this world evolves. Wow. That doesn't mean stray from them.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I I have to follow it up with one last question. If you were crying in your soup, what kind of soup would that be?
SPEAKER_02Oh, I'm gonna say clam chowda. Uh love some clamor. New England or uh Manhattan. Manhattan. Yeah. Why do they even call Manhattan Chowda? I mean, I mean, come on, guys. So so I I mentioned that we just tomato soup. It is, it is. Boston's on my mind right now because we we have an autoglass vendor who's a huge Red Sox sponsor, and and we ran into notice I can't say Boston Red Sox. It's the Red Sox. It it just it's how it spits. Yeah, Pakta Kahn. Have it yet. But uh my mom's from Boston and my grandmother had a giant Boston accent, so it's it's all good. And I went to I lived up there. But uh anyway, we ran into this autoglass vendor and they brought us up in 2019. We're out of time, but that's a whole nother wild, crazy story that involved uh I think Hurricane Michael. We got there and we got to sit right behind home plate in the second row and we were on TV all night. So we run into this rep at FAIA last week, and uh she's like, hey, you want to go back up there? And uh so we're we're going next month uh for a game against the Blue Jays, and it's it's the same seat, second row, right behind home plate. So I've got I got some chowda on my mind. Love it. Yeah. Anytime guys, we can't even talk about airplanes.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly. So let's uh shoot Emily another shoot her message today. We're gonna do a round two. Let's just get it going. All right. Yeah, great to have you on. Thank you so much. If anybody wants to find your agency, what is the uh URL on the underwebs?
SPEAKER_02No, no, no, just send a carrier pigeon.
SPEAKER_00Send a carrier pigeon, all right.
SPEAKER_02Perfect. You know what to start off with. Harry, H A R R Y Levine. So none of this Avril Levine Canadian crap with the A and the G. L I-N-E dot com. Uh you can find us on Facebook. I I have a young producer who's a Florida State grad who's like screwing around with Instagram or something. I don't know. I just told him to do that link. And uh yeah, and we LinkedIn, we we've got it all, but uh the the best is is the website and probably Facebook.
SPEAKER_00Cool, man. Thank you for uh going the distance. Love it. Yeah, man.
SPEAKER_02Check us out on Harry Loving Insurance.com and I will hit Emily up for uh for round two, and maybe we'll talk about like some crazy flying in the sky stuff. Yes, yes, love it.
SPEAKER_00All right, thank you, Jason. Thanks so much. Well, take it easy, guys. It's fun.
SPEAKER_03Bye. Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it?
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_03Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium off of even the worst internet leads, where could they go? They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes.
SPEAKER_04It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_03I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_04Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teled.com.
SPEAKER_03Live.teledude.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_04Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_04Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah, which is awesome, but they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm into it. Gregor, you can respond to these texts. I'm gonna respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it. I'm gonna text it right now. 520-214-2219.
SPEAKER_03Alright, I'll see you later, Mr. Jason. Hi, Mr. Greg. Can we even listen to this on the radio anymore? I love it.
SPEAKER_00I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman