The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Staying In Your Lane with Josh Phanco Part 3
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up, it's the insurance dudes podcast. I'm in the same position you were a couple years back, scratch agency here in Nebraska. My biggest issue is just finding somebody because I signed up. I'm like, oh tell the dudes like this won't be that bad. I'll start getting calls. Well now it's like I'm working nonstop because I'm trying to quote, trying to set the appointments, also trying to be like involved in these meetings, also working with like agency MVP on like the success of using that CRM to the best, and then also everything else with farmers. My biggest thing is how do we find some staff? Would you be open to remote staff? I have a lady that's from like California that wants to work for me, but like can't really hope that the metrics are correct.
SPEAKER_07Okay, I'll chime in first. I like remote teams, but you need a home base. This is just my opinion. And you need to establish the home base first, especially otherwise, that's a whole nother element that's gonna be added of pain to figure out because you're already trying to figure out, like you said, so many different things. So I would say in office, I would also say one of the I think the hardest things early on is just expenses, right? Things cost money. You know what I mean? Either you're gonna exchange money for time. There's a finite amount of time, and it sounds like your time is pretty much extended. So I would leverage money. If you have to get a loan, take a loan, but like a service, like team hired, awesome. We'll get you uh people lined up for your hiring. And then in that case, then you could just figure out questions that you want to ask. What are the important values that you have as an agency and characteristics? And then so when they line up those people for you, you can weed through them faster. It's kind of like this. Now that you're quoting a ton, right? You can probably weed out certain people faster. Like you can spot things better because of the volume. And I think that when you hire like that, where you got a bunch of people lined up and you do a bunch of interviews all together, you can pretty much see the diamonds and gems within those people. It makes it a lot easier than just one at a time. That's where like a team hired. Well, what do you think, Josh?
SPEAKER_01No, I think to your point, I would say my only thing would be about remote is I think it's really hard to develop culture and get somebody really bought in on what you're doing. I mean, if you have to do it in the short term, because that's your only option, it might be better. I mean, it doesn't necessarily mean that's the best model, but sometimes you just got to do what you got to do. But I would say ideally, you've got to have a home base. You've got to be like we were talking about with the meetings, you've got to have people that are gonna be connected to you every day. So if they can't be a part of the team and they don't feel like they're a part of the team, I mean, we have telemarketers through teledudes, and you know, one of the biggest downsides of that is they're in the Philippines, right? But she's we have done everything we can to create an atmosphere where she's part of our team. And once we did that, her results have taken off. So you have to have that culture, you have to have, you have to have that sense of team. Otherwise, you just have a bunch of independent people out there that aren't bought in, and you can't build a solid agency or a solid business around that long term, I don't think. Right.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, you'll have incredible turnover. And I mean, I had it for years and years, turnover, turnover, turnover, because it was like interview one, hire them, they last until I didn't like them or they washed out, whatever, and just rinse, wash, repeat. The way to approach and think about hiring is the same as your sales funnel. It's there's a certain you have to talk to 60 people, you have to line up 60 people to get 20 to show up, 20 to show up to get one that is actually good. And most agents interview one or two or three people and they pick one of them. And it's like you're just not finding the right people that way. That's why to what both of them said, I mean, somebody like Team Hired, I've had tremendous success building a team that these two guys have both seen and Brandon and uh that I mean, I haven't had turnover. I haven't had turnover in a year, like it's the same team, and you know, there's a lot to it, but it but we built the culture with remote. I have one guy that that is remote, but I would not start it that way. It's that's like an add-on. That's an add-on, yeah. Exactly.
SPEAKER_00I had three people I offer jobs to, and they just had to get licensed and talked for a few weeks, and they were telling us going good, working on it, working on it, and then one day, like you know, it's a week out until they're supposed to start, and all of a sudden they just disappear. Right. Yeah. And then my girlfriend might be starting with me soon, but it's like I don't want to go down, you know, like what Josh and them did with no income from both of us, really. You know, just everything's being put into this company because now I've been sitting here and before this, like I felt like I was doing nothing with my leads, and now it's like, okay, now my leads are into the funnel. And then now I'm just trying to figure out like, do I the 20 I'm getting daily, do I call those myself, or do I just straight up hand them right to the marketer and just have her call immediately on those?
SPEAKER_04I mean, I have my teledudets are are on all of the everything fresh. I mean, for I've tested it both ways, no difference. I mean, we you know, because I just look it straight at the cost per sale. A cost per sale is just as good or better when the front end of the funnel is them because they're sifting through them, they're finding the contacts, right? Those 20 leads, you're only gonna talk to two of them today.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, my cost cost per sale right now when I just factored factored it with my lead vendor recently, was like 172 and like 30 cents or something over how long now it's just over this last uh photo cycle because you know us farmers are weird and there's uh ends here in two days. Well, and that's really gonna be under 200 bucks. Yeah, I'm sitting there like easy quotes though. So that's my issue is just not the volume is just not there. So I'm hoping over the next month that volume just picks up.
SPEAKER_01To my point, or to our point earlier, you're talking about whether or not you should take the call to let them do it. I mean, it's the same thing I was talking about earlier. If you do it, that's fine. You'll probably have more success today, but you're gonna hurt yourself in the long run. You've got to get to, I mean, that it's proven that you're only gonna be able to grow and scale if you have other people doing it for you. And as long as you're always the solution, you're gonna have the same conversation six months from now. So I think you've got to you've got to find a way to rely on your telemarketing team and other people to really to work that out for you. You might suffer in the short term, but I promise you, it's proven. Look at Jason, look at Craig, look at all these other guys that are further down the road than all of us. It's the only way to grow and it's the only way to scale so that you you actually have a quality of life and your business is gonna be way better for it. So you've got to find a way to just trust the system. And I've done it, I've had some stuff where we were doing pretty well managing it more in-house. But once I started just relying on the system and doing that, we've been fine. I mean, it's there hasn't really been a big drop-off. So I think you just got to trust it and go for it.
SPEAKER_07And I know I need some producers. I I would add, so look at kind of like what we said earlier. Look at your you said there's a few people that you've lined up that were gonna come into the agency. Just over hire, get just fill that pipeline. So fill it so much that there's no like you're gonna be terrified if everybody works out. You know what I mean? It's better to have that problem than the other problem. So just go all in, fill that pipeline, get a ton of people that want and continue that every day. When I did my scratch agency, we did an in-house process and we did it a lot like we did with the teledudes. And it was the same process, and it was every day, every day lined up. I had to line up so many interviews today because we knew that they'd fall off. And then you know what I mean. And we just kept doing it. It was hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of booked interviews. And we but we filled all the states at the end of it. But just look at it like that, it's the same process. Just get those leads, get them to you know, agree to being a part of the agency, try to get them licensed. And even though that you have three people and you only want one, get four more people that say yes to it. And then you won't have to worry about your girlfriend or anything.
SPEAKER_04And if they all show up, then figure out how to pay them and you guess what? You're gonna get results. Yeah, it's the best problem ever. It's been my experience that they don't all show up. It just doesn't happen.
SPEAKER_00I'm just trying to get away from like you guys sitting wearing all the hats because it's like you can't necessarily run a business if you're doing everything. I think Bill kind of is in the same spot as me here locally. He actually is like a 15-minute drive from me. We had a meeting the other day with a local farmer's another local farmer's agent, and I mentioned you guys and sent a link to our area rep guy, and here's Bill today. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Well, you know, you pool resources, do there's ways to share. We get creative. Jason and I did a lot of that in the beginning when we we opened scratch right near at the same time, and you gotta find a buddy and uh bounce stuff off of. And that's also what's so great about this community is you know, you've got a whole bunch of buddies here.
SPEAKER_00So totally thanks, my reason is I just started this and I'm going on vacation for a week Friday. Oh boy.
SPEAKER_03We still have our call and set appointments. Sorry. I've literally been signed up for about an hour. So I'm no no kidding. I mean, it was uh I got off the literally got off the phone uh with uh Haley 25 minutes before this started.
SPEAKER_04So that's awesome. That's funny.
SPEAKER_03Welcome, welcome.
SPEAKER_04We love it, welcome. And then uh Ryan has his hand up. Let's uh jump over there. Thanks, Bill and Dylan has to unmute. Is Ryan there?
SPEAKER_02How about now? Can you guys hear me? Yes, how's it going? How's it going, you guys? And uh Jason, fellow of Southern Californian. How are you doing, man?
SPEAKER_07Good, man. How you doing?
SPEAKER_02Good. I'm glad to be a part of the team. I'm down here in Laguna Nigel, so not too far away from you, man. Love it then, I love it then. Yes. Um, so hey, we got rolling, of course, on Teledues officially on Monday, which our um amount of transfers we had was just absolutely phenomenal in the last 48 hours, and we are stoked and ready to go. I did ask for my uh primary sales producer, Sandy, he had some questions. Do you guys have a suggestion? Because of course we do get a lot of these prospects that are calling in because of course our telemarketer was not able to connect with them, um, and they're calling us back on our sales only line. So when the prospects call back, do you recommend setting up a voicemail at all? Or would you avoid that at all costs? I'm kind of worried about the voice.
SPEAKER_04You get a better result if you just they'll call back. If they've called once, they're gonna call back again. Because you're gonna call you and avoid the voice. Can't say the A word on here. But um, yeah, I would just have no, you don't need a voicemail. Okay, so you can try both of those.
SPEAKER_01What is that, Josh? Are you not able to answer the calls? Is that what you're saying?
SPEAKER_02Like your people are busy, or are you just no, so so the telemarketers, of course, are not leaving our telemarketers are not leaving voicemails. So, of course, randomly throughout the day, basically because they're using our sales only line. So we're getting the prospects that are calling back the sales only line, wondering, well, who the heck is calling me? Of course, from this I know a number that's not leaving a voicemail. So, of course, we're picking it up and we're immediately trying to drill in and say, hey, you know, let's go ahead and get you started on a quote. And then sometimes, of course, if it doesn't have to get picked up, obviously avoid the whole voicemail aspect, I'm assuming.
SPEAKER_04And you can test it both ways too. You never know what is what's gonna work the best. And that's just, I mean, we've tested every different possible way. For us, it's better if there isn't. They just answer they're like, hello. Like they don't say any, it's just hello. How you doing?
SPEAKER_02And then do you guys have any recommended talk pass or scripts that you recommend? And not for the actual transfers, but of course, when those prospects call back, wondering who the heck is calling me, what should I have my staff saying? Of course, hello.
SPEAKER_04What's hello, hey Dave, how you doing? And if they don't know who's calling, then I did if identify yourself.
SPEAKER_01They asked. It's we used to overcomplicate it. We used to try to be all fancy with it, you know. Hi, this is the Fanko group. How can I help you? And you wouldn't have this whole script, didn't work. So all we do now, their name pops up, depending on what system you have. I don't know. But in our world, we know who's calling back in. We can see their name and their number. So we'll just call and go, Hey, this is Josh. Hey, is this is this Justin? Hey, how you doing, Justin? And they love hearing their name. So we always drop their name if we can see it, always drop their name and then they go, Yeah, this is Justin. Who's this? Like, oh, hey, it's it's uh Josh. You know, I was just giving you a call. Thank you so much for calling us back. We're so excited to get a hold of you. And you know, just get Brandon, man. If you could get Brandon to answer your phone, be fast to talk to you for the next three minutes. But have his energy, you got to train him to have that energy. Like, Justin, man, it's so good to talk to you, man. Thanks so much. Like, we have been we've just been so eager to get a hold of you. It looks like we got information here about your quote, about your auto insurance. I've got everything pretty much ready to go. I just need to verify some stuff, and you just go right into it. And they, if they don't want to talk to you, they'll hang up. Who cares? Those we we actually made a sale yesterday uh on a call back exactly that way.
SPEAKER_04And think about what Josh did. Nobody wants this quote, right? Nobody's interested in getting an insurance quote. It's the worst thing, it's like the dentist. So that call comes, the person cut is like, wait, who is this? But Josh is so cool and is and he has so much energy, the guy's at least given him a chance. And then he when the dreaded insurance conversation topic comes up, now he's like, Ah, dang it, but this guy's all right. Okay, I'll stay on, right? It's either that or they hang up. And I think that all you want to do is increase your chances, increase your probability on every single interaction, and that's the whole point of this, right? It's numbers. And so if you can you're doing large volume and you can increase your probability here, increase your probability here. It's like uh inside baseball, right? We're just trying to increase those numbers based on the data, and so I love that, Josh. It's great.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I love callbacks. I mean, at first I kind of looked at it like, oh, but then I started thinking about it. Wait, these people are actually they got a missed call and they took enough time to call it back. They're curious. It's crazy. They either are waiting for you, they're trying to get a they're thinking if somebody that's gonna call them for business. If they're we get a lot of calls from landscapers back, they think that somebody's calling them to get their moat, you know, their lawn mode or whatever it might be. So they tend to always call back. But man, if these people took the time to call you back, that is the guy you want to get on the phone. And you better bring energy because I'm telling you, you'll get a pretty good response back if you do it. So those are great ones. Train your people to answer that phone.
SPEAKER_02A little over the top. Thanks, man. That's that's gold. Thank you.
SPEAKER_07Yeah, and so I would challenge you to do this. Have fun with this. So we talk about meetings, right? I would hold a meeting within the next 30 minutes or whenever they're back from lunch. Have a meeting and say, hey guys, let's approach this. So basically, the two things you don't want to sound like a salesperson, you don't want to tell sound like a telemarketer, you want to sound like their buddy. So write out a script with them, say, hey, how can we not sound like a telemarketer, not sound like a salesperson when they call us back and start writing it out? Have fun with it, have your team kind of work it in, get that script going, and then have everybody memorize it. It'll probably be like two lines or whatever, and then just teach them the transition of going right into the quote without asking for it. Don't ever ask for the quote, just go right into it. But those few lines, have them help you come up with it, something that sounds like it's like their friends or however they talk to their friends, and then hit the phones hard and then have a little contest with them. Hey, man, whoever can get a quote, whoever can get two quotes for the rest of the day, I'll give you, you know, 20 bucks or whatever, something like that. And I bet you you can kickstart those callbacks today.
SPEAKER_02I like it, Jason. Thank you, man. You got it, Brian.
SPEAKER_04I don't know if you went into the PPC, the peak performance challenge, but there's a ton of that stuff in there in the member site that you could grab.
SPEAKER_02I have not had a chance to yet, but that's on the uh the member site you were saying.
SPEAKER_04Yep. Yeah, the tons of gold. Or gold.
SPEAKER_07Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Gold. So well, cool. We have gone, we've gone the distance. Mr. D.
SPEAKER_07Distance. Yes. Love it. Is there any final last minute questions? Or we'll just uh I mean it is Mr.
SPEAKER_03Bill. Wild Bill. Yes.
unknownOkay.
SPEAKER_03Sorry, my assistant just interrupted me as you start talking to me. Um okay, so um I've started off with the fireburner. Yes, the phone is the phone burner system. So when you guys are talking, when you get that callback, you guys are using the ricochet system, and that callback's telling you which one of those people is calling you back. And I'm assuming the the phone burner system does not do that, correct?
SPEAKER_07No, but it doesn't matter.
SPEAKER_03So I think randoms over there going.
SPEAKER_07So here's the thing is workshop it. Just like I said, I said with Ryan, I would do the same thing, workshop it. So that's the challenge, right? Is that you don't know their name. Hey, hey, uh let me double check. Who's this? Who's did you call me? Uh yeah, let me check. Uh who's this? Oh, Ryan. Oh, hey, Ryan, how's it going? Oh, I know our office was trying to get a hold of you. So glad that you took the time in. So, you know, and then go into it or whatever. But where I'd workshop that a little bit, I'm sure you could come up with something fire to something will work.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. But tonality, I'm telling you, tonality is the the base of all of it.
SPEAKER_07If you're up not yep, and not sounding like a telemarketer or a salesperson. So tonality, but but not sound like how you want to this is hello.
SPEAKER_03Oh, so I gotta change my entire damn voice. That's what you're telling me.
SPEAKER_04It's just well, but you can do it, right? Like it's just hey, how you doing? And they're like, whoa, this guy. Like, I mean, Bill, who's your best friend? Greg's my best friend now, I suppose.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_07Who calls you? And what do you guys talk about? What gets you guys excited? Like, what would he guns and motorcycles? There you go. So, dude, I just got hey, Bill, I just got a new Smith and Weston, you got to check it out.
SPEAKER_01Like, what would you do? Are those at the same time? Guns and motorcycles, or are those like two different houses?
SPEAKER_03At the same time. This is the Wild West here in Nebraska, man. You get you go, you go 20 miles west of where I'm sitting right now, that's no man's land.
SPEAKER_04I stuck out and he got through the gatekeeper, got to you.
SPEAKER_01Uh he didn't even have the right name, wrong name, but I got loved his energy so much. And then he called back and called. He did the same thing with somebody else in our office, but uh yeah, we still talk about that guy.
SPEAKER_07I know we're going way over, but Josh, can you tell the story? Because I think that story is money.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so the headset doesn't die. Again, I'll plug in real quick if it does, because this is worth it. So I get a call on myself in my office, right? So I'm sitting there, I get a call, I I answer it, like you know, my little monotone voice. Hello, this is Josh. It's like he didn't even listen. He's like, Russ, hey, how are you? And I'm like, Russ, that happens to be one that had that was one of our producers at the time. He's like, Rush, how are you? I'm like, fine, but this isn't Russ. He's like, Wait, what? This isn't Rush? Like, no, I'm like, who is this? This is Josh. I'm like, are you looking for Russ? He's like, Yeah, I'm looking for Russ. I mean, he's just super excited. I mean, it was the happiest guy in the world. Anyway, long story short, by the time we figured it out, he was trying to call one of our producers to try to funnel life sales, life insurance sales to him. So he was some guy that was selling a service where you could get life sales funneled into his agency and they would make money. So he was calling one of our guys off a lead list. But his energy level was so high that we had a fun time on the phone call. And I told him, Well, you know, it's actually funny, I'm his boss. And uh, you know, he'd probably be a little uh alarmed if he knew that you were calling him and all that kind of stuff. Well, anyway, get off the phone call because he obviously wasn't looking for me. No more than 30 seconds later, he calls my wife's cell phone. She's she's literally five feet away from me right now, and I can hear it through the phone. She answers the phone and he goes, Rah, hey, how are you? She goes, She goes, Who is this? And and uh she goes through the whole story and she goes, Well, you know, funny enough, you just called my husband, and he's sitting right across from the way from me. And we just, and anyway, we had a good old time. He was laughing, we were laughing. He ended up calling me back like a few minutes later and just like, hey, I just want to apologize. I must have had my information wrong. I told him, Hey, it didn't matter, man. You made our day, you're doing a great job. Keep it up. You're gonna be really, really successful in what you're doing. He didn't, it was just awesome. I mean, to this day, and that was like an absolute lesson to me. Your energy is all that matters. He didn't even have my name right. I wanted to talk to the guy, so it was so cool.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's so awesome. People love it, they love it. I got one last thing in closing. Uh, Josh, who's the lady behind you?
SPEAKER_01Oh, that's my can you hear me? That's my daughter. Uh, she's here for summer school, so yeah, that's my daughter. We're a family agency, so everybody wave at her. She's yeah, there you go. There she goes. I'm like my teenage daughter. Well, go sell her a policy. So let me go.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, well, hey everybody, thank you for jumping on and uh doing this interesting methodology of of recording the show. You're all gonna be on it permanently, so congratulations. And uh thank you, Josh. Josh, yeah, thank you. Huge. Let me just say that too.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you guys are awesome, and we're all grateful to you guys. You go and get told that enough. So we just appreciate all the work that you guys do all the time. Thank you.
SPEAKER_07Uh oh man, you're the best. I'm gonna keep you around. Yeah, listen to me around. Yeah, you will you you know what? I'm gonna clip that out. I'm gonna send that to my wife. Yeah, she needs a good idea.
SPEAKER_04She's not gonna listen to this. All right. Well, all right, thank you. And uh we'll catch you on the next uh Wednesday, and I'll wrap it now. Hey Jason.
SPEAKER_06Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Mm-hmm. Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium off of even the worst internet leads, where could they go?
SPEAKER_05They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_06I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_05Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_06Live.teledudes.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_05Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_05Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah, which is awesome. But they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm into it. Craig, are you gonna respond to these texts? I'm gonna respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's five two zero two one four two two one nine. That's five two zero two one four two two one nine. I love it.
SPEAKER_06I'm gonna text it right now.
SPEAKER_05Five two zero two one four two two one nine.
SPEAKER_06All right, I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman