The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Staying In Your Lane with Josh Phanco Part 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
From the scratch perspective and from the I guess from the the scratch perspective. What would you do differently now? Rather like the way you approached it. Yeah. Then and now with everything you've learned, how would you approach it differently?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, there's man, there's a lot of things. I mean, we just kind of jumped into it. Maybe I was a little overconfident in our ability to get sales going right away. Again, having started scratch and other businesses and sales, I felt pretty confident my ability to just make it happen. So I would say probably maybe spend a little bit more time on the front end really, really planning out like where you're going to get your business from and putting a really good system in place. You know, we come from a community that it's a larger community, but it's still very kind of small town, small town mentality. And so I kind of relied too heavily on my own network as my basis for building our business. And that's kind of how they tell you, you know, it's like, hey, go to the people that you know the best and they'll buy from you. I was shocked at how many people I thought that would come immediately and buy insurance for me, how many people were wouldn't even answer my call. I mean, people on the top were my best friends, right? So I think for anybody that's really interested in getting this business, starting from scratch, build up a business model that has nothing to do with your network. Your network should be like your gravy. It should be the extra, it should be the bonus, the cherry on the top. But if you can't do this business going out there and getting it from people that know nothing about you and could care less who you are, then you may want to reconsider it until you can figure out that model. So that would be my number one point of advice.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_03Can you imagine if somebody started a McDonald's and they're like, you know what? I'm just gonna start by my family. That's it. Yeah. Yeah. They better be able to eat a lot.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. That's crazy. Creating that measurable, the whole process where you can measure stuff, how much has that changed the game? Did you come in thinking that? Like, I I know that um you just spoke on you know what you were told, but what was in your mind coming into it about how you would develop your business and scale? Or was scaling just not even something you were thinking of?
SPEAKER_01I mean, it's something we were thinking about, but I didn't have an actual understanding of what that looks like in this business of actually how to scale, you know. Um, I guess in all the other sales jobs I've ever had, I've just been a sales guy, go out, build your book. I wasn't, you know, necessarily responsible for everybody else's growth and the overall business. So I understand it in general, like what we're trying to do, but actually doing it in the insurance model was was I was kind of learning on the fly. I had an idea, it's kind of like I kind of equate it to like being in college when you go to business school, they kind of teach you what business is supposed to look like, but then you get out in the real world and it's it's something entirely different. So I had a pretty good idea of what it was supposed to look like, but once I got into it, just get hit from a hundred different directions. And the reality of, oh my gosh, we haven't made a sale in three days, and then you start panicking, and then you're just and then you're just putting out fires everywhere, and you got calls that you you don't even know how to sell that because you've never sold it before. So even if I would have fully understood how to measure it and track it, I don't know if I gave myself enough time to actually do it. I wasn't spending enough time doing that. I was just selling and just trying to like survive daily. And I think that's where you know I had all the best intentions of spending some time on a Saturday or evenings of of really, of really focusing in on that stuff. But you just get thrown into the fire and you just start running and you go and all that stuff goes out the window, and before long it's you know, six months a year, and you haven't spent any time looking at the business. You're just right, you're just in the business, you know? Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02So well, the business can end up running you if you're taking on everything that needs to be taken care of and learning all the things that need to be learned, right? It just can it's so overwhelming. There's there's so many things, and anybody could walk in the door and be busy. But are you busy with the stuff that you should be busy with?
SPEAKER_01Yes, which and that's where I think I made the big that the biggest mistake early on again. Uh, and that's gonna be a theme in anything you ask me about. It's just how many mistakes I made at the beginning. But yeah, just getting busy and just letting that stuff go too early, just not staying disciplined to go, nope, timeout. We uh even if I have to walk away from a few sales now to make sure that I'm putting things in place in our agency to be successful in the long run, I've got to do that right now. So that's you've got to stay true to those things. You've got to, you know, make sure that you commit to those things on a daily basis or a weekly basis or whatever it is, just stay focused in on what you have to do to make sure the agency is is going down the right path that you want it to.
SPEAKER_03What would some tips that that you would give somebody that feels like they're wearing every hat, working 12 hour days and wants to transition, but feels like, hey man, I I'm I'm packed with 12 hour days. There's no way I can do anything. I can't train someone to do that or whatever.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I would say, well, okay, maybe you're right, but probably more often if it's like me, most of that stuff's not true. Um, you just have to do it, and there's no way around it. I mean, do you want to continue to work that way the rest of your life or do you want to find a better way? So you either have to decide to do it or you you just and most of the time I found that that's not true. Those are just voices in your head that tell you that's what it's gonna be, that you'll no nobody will ever be able to do it as good as you. Oh, there's you know, I'll never be able to get, you know, if I just get these things done, then I can sit back and focus on the business. No, it's never gonna happen. There's always gonna be another project or something else that comes up that's gonna take your time. So you're better off walking away from a few sales if that's what it takes to make sure that you stay on path with the things that you have to do as an agency owner. So don't believe all those voices in your head. And you just have to try it. You have to try a different way. If if it's not working for you one way, doing it that way, you have to try something different. Otherwise, you're just delaying the inevitable, in which is going to be either a mediocre agency. Maybe you'll have some success, but it's never gonna be as successful as it could be if you did it the right way.
SPEAKER_02It's so interesting to think about that question that Jason asked with the time, you know, it's the time machine question. You get in the DeLorean, you go back to the day you opened, and today's self tells that guy, hey, you need to do it this way. Well, I don't know that even if you had that knowledge, that you'd be able to execute the same way as if you didn't go through and fail through that process, right? You learn so much from going for it and messing up, so much more from that experience. And it's tough to come and actually execute on a plan without having that experience.
SPEAKER_01Oh, I totally agree. I mean, I think sometimes you have to feel the pain to understand why it's so important to stay with it. It's like the idea of you know, as a kid, you got to let them kind of touch the stove, otherwise, you've got to be there every time telling your kid not to touch the stove. Well, they do it once and they burn themselves. Guess what? They remember that the next time they'll never touch it again. And so you have to experience that pain. And I I think, Craig, like you're talking about, you know, that's sometimes what ends up being my compass in the morning, is like I don't want to feel that anymore. I don't want to feel I don't want to go another week having to be the only guy in our office selling. I want to create a system that enables everybody else to have the success so that I can step away for a couple of days or I can be out, I can be off my game for a day and we still are achieving our goals. So but if I didn't have that pain, it it probably wouldn't, it wouldn't, you know, resonate. And I'd just lean, I'd keep leaning back in on my own abilities and my own ego and all that stuff. So you got to experience it for sure.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I'm a huge strong believer in whatever business that anybody sets up. You have to set it up with the thought of you not being a cog in the system. Like you got to set it up to where anybody can that that you set up a system that every role can be filled by somebody else. Now you can jump in and do stuff, but if you're the one that has to do it, like you're the main person, you can never truly get to that point where you're running it. Because to your point, there's always there's always stuff like there's 10 fires that you know will show up later and oh, but you have plans to do this one thing and then you have to do the fires. It's like there's never a way to play catch up unless there's a system where it runs without you so that you can go above it and be able to pull the right levers and and look for that that future.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. And I think that's one thing I learned from you guys. You guys have, I mean, again, part of the reason I was instantly um kind of on board once I was there with you guys for two days. I mean, I saw it, you know, it wasn't, you know, before then you guys were just a podcast, you guys were just two people that blah, blah, blah. Say it, yeah, talk a lot, right? Typical guys out there just talking a lot. But no, but actually being in Craig's agency and seeing it happen and and and knowing you guys did a great job of helping us understand how you got to this point, it wasn't all pretty for you either. And that was really encouraging for me is it's not like you guys opened up shop one day and it just all worked for you. You know, you've been through a lot of the same stuff, right? And to have you guys be further down the road and to know, hey, there is a way. And kind of you guys are just further down the road for us, you know, than me was really, really comforting and to know, okay, there is a way. So that was really helpful to hear that and to know, okay. I think that's one thing, Jason. You've really always I always pick up is you're always hammering that point of like, hey, I don't want to be involved, I don't want to be involved with that, right? I gotta get out of the way and let my people do what they're gonna do. Um and I I still struggle with that because we're all different, we're all wired differently. I like having my hands involved in some things. Um, and so I always have to fight that urge, and my wife always has to slide my hands and say, get out of that, stop, let them do that. So but that is something I'm still working on for sure.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, the my way or the highway is that'll drive you crazy because I don't now like it, it took me a long time to let go of those things because I can go in there, I can walk in that room that you've been in there, I can go walk there right now, and something that somebody does will drive me crazy. And it's like, you know what, who cares? Because at the end of the day, we're just worried about the result. And as long as they're doing it, as long as they're legal, ethical, and not hurting anybody, then let them do it because they're gonna, if it doesn't work, they're gonna figure it out. And as long as you know they're not doing anything wrong and that doesn't happen. So it just works, right?
SPEAKER_03And helping people, I think that's helping. I think that's the one, and I know you you instilled that in your agency, and I know Josh does too. Because that's a big part of like you have to have a GPS and you have to instill that in your team. And I think it's like at the end of the day, this is not rocket science. You're helping solve people's problems. Oh, but we're so expensive, all these stupid details who cares like listen to them talk to them. Sometimes people just want it to be heard. And if you do that, they're probably willing to pay an extra premium for that. I mean, that's that's a huge value to a lot of people. I mean, I guess to anybody, being heard means a lot. And I'm sure any dude that's married to somebody knows that their wife wants to be heard. They don't want to hear you try to solve the problem and everything. They just want to know that they're being heard. But I think going through the agency and the sales process and everything else, just if you have that other person's best interest and you're just trying to help, like yeah, ethical and everything else, it'll all work out. It'll be good. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I have another question for you. I know that and then because for me, it was also something that wasn't done. In fact, I don't think I probably maybe every couple of months ran a meeting um at my agency. And now it's every day, if not twice a day. And how big of a change was that for you? And how important has that been to the effectiveness of your team?
SPEAKER_01That was probably one of the best immediate things we could do to change the the course of our like agency success. Right. But again, when we started the agency, I had all these grand plans of hey, we're gonna meet regularly, we're gonna do all that. But like I said earlier, that those all went out, all that stuff went out the door when I had to answer a phone to make a sale, or I had to get on the phone myself to do all that stuff. All that stuff went out the door. And I'd always use the excuse, well, we're a small agency, we see each other all day. You know, I don't need to have a meeting. Find ways to excuse that. You know, it'd go three weeks with no meeting, and I'd be like, ah, it's not a big deal. I've talked to them every day. It's the same thing. It's not. So one of the first things that came out of being with you guys, uh, my first action item was to make sure Monday, we met on a Thursday, Friday at your agency. Come back on Monday. I had already told the whole team, hey, we're gonna meet every day starting Monday, get ready. And we started doing it. And it was a little weird at first. I mean, I don't mind talking in front of people. I don't write, I mean, I've run a lot of meetings, but it was a little weird because well, what are we gonna meet about? They knew I was out of the office. They probably expected me to come in and I don't know, tell them they're all fired or you know, removing. I don't know. But everybody's a little at first a little bit scared about it all. But we just started meeting and I I, you know, just like you guys always talk about, I just I laid out a vision for where we wanted to go and some of the things that we're not accomplishing, but where we wanted to go and the investment that we're gonna make into some new systems and new processes. I laid it all out, I painted a picture, I explained why. I told them, you know, what was so great about being with you guys and some of the lessons that I've learned personally. I'm just very transparent and honest about it. And I just told them we're gonna keep meeting and we're not gonna meet because, you know, I'm not there to like crack the whip, I'm not there to beat down on anybody, I'm not there to even expose anybody. We're gonna meet because we're a team. And like we talked about earlier, communication. We can't go in the same direction if we're not talking. And I've heard you guys say it before, you know, if you're in a football team, you don't just everybody line up and everybody does their own thing. That doesn't work. You got to talk about what the play is gonna be. So we just started meeting daily. It was 15 minutes, you know, and sure enough, we'd go 20, 25, 30 minutes, mostly me talking. You know, I had to try to, you know, shut up a little bit and let everybody else talk. And but you know, we started doing that faithfully for uh a few weeks. And sure enough, surprise, surprise, everybody felt more engaged, everybody started owning it. Everybody, it wasn't like day one, everybody just came out of the gates and made you know 100 sales and we hit our goals. No, but little over, you know, little by little, I started I started seeing improvement, started seeing more engagement, more energy. But yeah, our sales, I mean, we no doubt those two months after that, we started seeing sales on a more consistent basis every day because I think our energy level was better. Everybody came out of that feeling like they were tied to a cause for that day. And uh so that was really important. Now I will tell you, full disclosure, we don't meet every day right now, um, just for a variety of reasons. I know, sorry. But what I have done, um, and I'm very, very purposeful in making sure that I'm communicating with everybody in our team every day about what their goals are, what we're trying to accomplish for that day. So we still get together, but what I do is I'll I'll walk over to a desk and I'll sit down, I'll talk with them. I'll I'll Slack, you know, we use Slack and I'll sit there and I will just comment on some things that, hey, you know, we'll just have a sidebar conversation about what they need to do for that day. I'll pump them up from the day before, you know, hey, I heard that call, you did really good on that, or hey, we're having some struggles on that. And we'll have a dialogue that way. So I'm way more intentional. I don't just sit at my desk, wait for the end of the day, see what the results were, and then go, okay, good or bad. You know, we're having an ongoing conversation. I'm way more intentional about what's going on with their day every day. So I need to get back on accountability-wise, I need to get back on to having these meetings every day. But um, because again, we just kind of start going back to our old habits.
SPEAKER_02So well, I think from a from a sell, like a sales coaching standpoint, this is the especially the PNC business, is is so close on almost every transaction, right? Yeah, there's a lot where we're double and you know, the ones where you're way ahead. But but the the meat of it is close, right? And the message they constantly hear from the prospects, from television, from everywhere is commodity, commodity, commodity, price, it's all price, it's all price. And what what I've noticed is the longer, or if we go a stretch without meeting, which doesn't happen anymore, but when we did, they you would hear more often, oh, they were just price focused. Oh, they were just price, you hear it over and oh, oh, well, that one was price focused. That one, and it's like, okay, then the job isn't being done on that call, right? We need we, of course, they're price focused because that's how they're taught to buy this, they're taught it's a commodity. So that conversation has to shift, but it doesn't shift unless the producer of the sales agent believes it to be true. And they're always going to revert back to that price focus because that's what everything around them is pointing them to. And so that's where I think there's such a huge value to that daily meeting is you're battling against that, right? You have to fight that so you can get them back over here. I mean, you were here, they wrote 22K two days in a row. I mean, that is that's not something that happens all the time. That happens when they believe. They believed because there were 10 other agents here, you know, they're like, wow, they must really, you know, you know, these guys, uh and so, you know, they but those days psychologically, they were like, we're on fire, right? Yeah. And I think that, you know, so much of it is psychological.
SPEAKER_01I think it's also one of the biggest benefits, put aside sales. I just think it's great for the team. You know, they love they're working next to each other, but again, we get in our own little world. So I think it's just a good, you know, it makes them enjoy their job more. They get to be around people, they get to share in experiences and talk about what happened the day before. They get, you know, hey, Joseph, you did a great job on this yesterday. They get pumped up in front of their people. So I think it's just good for morale and good team building as well. So yeah.
SPEAKER_03100%. So you went the distance. What is the number one piece of advice you'd give any insurance agent either coming into the industry or wanted to kick start the agency's heart? What would you give? Number one.
SPEAKER_01Man, there's so many, but I'm just for today, this is what I will pick. The best part, like what we're doing right now, the other greatest benefit that came out of everything that I've been doing since March, when I, February or whenever, when we got together, is I'm part of a community. We're all out there now on our own, trying to fight this fight on our own every day. Get out of yourself, like your own little world, reach out to other agents, be a part of a community like this and listen and ask a ton of questions. Don't do this alone. And if you're with a captive like I am, yeah, absolutely do everything that the company offers you, all the team stuff that they do and the little market meetings and all that. But get outside of that and go with people that will be real and honest with you about their struggles and what's going on. There's quite a few agents that are that I'm seeing right now on this call that we pick up the phone and call each other all the time, like, hey, I'm having this basic problem, or hey, man, my mind's not in the right spot. Because I will tell you, I think that's the greatest challenge that we experience in our business is it's not even the nuts and bolts, it's not the policies, it's not the insurance business, it's the mind game. Um, I've seen a couple of posts lately of guys that are just struggling with the mentality, you know, they're having success, but everything, you know, it's a challenging business. So you've got to have people that are for you, they're gonna encourage you when you need it, that are gonna pump you up, they're gonna tell you, I've been there, I know how it feels, stay the course. You've got to have a crew. I'm a I'm into endurance running and long distance running. And you know, if you get into ultra marathons, uh they have these things called crews. So you go out there, you got to run the hundred miles or whatever it is, but they have crews at these aid stations, and their job is to pump you up, their job is to keep you going, their job is to make sure if your foot hurts, that they they take care of that, get you back on the course and get going. You know, they can't run the race for you, they can't do everything for you, but you need a crew around you at all times to just keep you going because you will get in your own head and you'll go on a crazy cycle that just will take you nowhere. So get outside of yourself.
SPEAKER_02Love it. And we can actually take some uh a couple questions. Yeah, yeah. Live here on the live here on the podcast for the very first time. It is a uh groundbreaking day here. We have Dylan has his hand up. If anybody else wants to just do a little hand raise with the little button there.
SPEAKER_01Um I'm gonna if my headset dies, I'll switch it over quickly. Okay, cool.
SPEAKER_02Like a pro.
SPEAKER_00Oh hey. Hey, I'm in the same position you were a couple of years back, scratch agency here in Nebraska. My biggest issue is just finding somebody because I signed up. I'm like, oh tell the dudes like this won't be that bad. I'll start getting calls. Well, now it's like I'm working nonstop because I'm trying to quote, trying to set the appointments, also trying to be like involved in these meetings, also working with like agency and vp on like the success of using that CRM to the best, and then also everything else with farmers. My heart, my biggest thing is how do we find some staff? Would you be open to remote staff? I have a lady that's from like California that wants to work for me, but like can't really hope that the metrics are correct.
SPEAKER_04Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Mm-hmm. Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium off of even the worst internet leads, where could they go? They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there?
SPEAKER_05Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_04I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_05Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_04Live.teledudes.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_05Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_05Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah, which is awesome. But they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm into the code. You can respond to these texts. I'm gonna respond to them for sure. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. That's right. The calling calculator, sales material. I mean, everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it. I'm gonna text it right now. Five two zero two one four two two one nine.
SPEAKER_04All right, I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_02I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman