The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Staying In Your Lane with Josh Phanco
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
We have a live studio audience today, and um Alice is there being let in. I'm sure that they will be muted. So yeah, that's a little housekeeping. Mr. Craig, who do we have today? Is it Vicephalia? Are you Vitalia?
SPEAKER_04No, it's both. But it's Fresno and Clovis. We're pretty much the same thing. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Clovis. Isn't there a movie Clovis field? Clover field. Okay. I didn't even think about it, but would we do speed breakers? Yeah. Why don't we do a little speed breakers? It's not the Brady Budget with everybody. Let me be completely unprepared and not have it up. Luckily for notes, you can just search. So all right, Mr. Josh, are you ready for this round of speed breakers? Bring it. All right. Have you ever had a mullet?
SPEAKER_04Yes, believe it or not.
SPEAKER_00Well, we're done. It's awesome.
SPEAKER_04First crunch. I'm going to say Winnie Cooper from The Wonder Years.
SPEAKER_00You know what? Maybe they're with you. Most embarrassing thing your mom ever caught you doing.
SPEAKER_04Sad to say, but I actually took money from her wallet one day to try to just got caught.
SPEAKER_00Wow.
SPEAKER_04I shouldn't say that online.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I suppose she does. So the fastest speed ever driven.
SPEAKER_04Probably about a just over a hundred. I got nervous and slowed down.
SPEAKER_00Nice. Favorite cereal?
SPEAKER_04Lucky charms all the way.
SPEAKER_00Lucky Charms. How many kids? I have three. Have you made cry? Please wait for this question. Then three daily. Three daily. Perfect. Good job. Count chocula or count Dracula? I have never had either. I have no idea. Well, I don't think you can have Count Dracula. Oh, I don't know what that is. Oh, oh, I see. I thought you were on the serial thing. Yeah, I don't know. Well, one is serial and one's a serial killer, I guess. Fastest mile.
SPEAKER_04Recently, because I'm a runner, I just hit 609.
SPEAKER_00Oh, that's really good, man. You almost did the five.
SPEAKER_04Getting there. I'm trying to get sub-six as fast as possible.
SPEAKER_00Wow. You know what's interesting is none of these questions actually put the units. So it's like fastest mile. Well, driven, flown, you know, just everybody just answers. So it's a uh favorite flavor.
SPEAKER_04Flavor? Orange cream, anything. Orange cream.
SPEAKER_00Everybody picked uh ice cream on that. It's great.
SPEAKER_04Dogs or cats? Dogs. 100%.
SPEAKER_00That is correct. This interview will continue. Tacos or burritos?
SPEAKER_04Probably burritos, slight edge to burritos.
SPEAKER_00Slight edge, but they're very close, correct. Favorite video game.
SPEAKER_04All-time favorite video game, Super Mario Brothers.
SPEAKER_00Oh, I thought you were gonna say super tech mobile, because that is the actually. No, I'm sorry, I have to strike that. RBI baseball. Oh, that's my all-time technique. Yeah, that was a good one. And then, of course, the the fun one, Trump or Biden? In what? Like MMA? Yes. Sure. Uh no units. Uh, we'll go Trump in MMA. Yeah, he's got the size, he's got the size advantage.
SPEAKER_01I think he's gonna win. And final question: what was the first concert you ever went to? All the way back to Barney.
SPEAKER_04You know, I've heard you guys ask this to other people, and I have been thinking for a long time. I cannot remember my first concert, but I will tell you, can I just cheat and give you my favorite concert ever? I'm not much of a concert guy like everybody else. I I like concerts okay, but I they're not a big thing for me. But my favorite concert by far was Dave Matthews uh at Shoreline Amphitheater in California. That was the most incredible experience. I was in college, so it would have been probably late 90s, early 2000s. Yeah, probably around 2000. Yeah. So it was incredible, it was awesome. Yep.
SPEAKER_00They are good. I saw Dave Matthews open up for the the dead uh in Vegas, like in early 90s.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, no, that's when they were they were all over it, and uh he's great. I saw him probably he's I've probably seen him the most in different venues, so but that was an incredible venue. If you've never been to that, you got to go to a concrete shoreline. Yeah, that's in San Diego, right? No, it's up north, it's up by Palo Alto in uh near Stanford in California. Is it out in California? Outside, yeah. They built it for the Grateful Dead. So it's it was kind of where the Grateful Dead would do most of their comics. It's really kind of oh, that's awesome.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, super cool. So take us back from Dave Matthews to now, and how did you get yourself involved in this crazy business? Oh, it's all my wife's fault.
SPEAKER_04I'll just tell you that right now. Um, so I have uh I've done a lot of different things, all somewhat around sales and marketing, essentially. My first job, 14 and a half years old, was a dishwasher in Delhi. That to me was awesome. It taught me the discipline of hard work showing up and doing stuff that nobody else wants to do. So I was a cleanup in a deli in a meat, a meat department. So that was awesome. But essentially from college on, I've been in some form of sales and marketing role. I've worked primarily in sports marketing. I've worked, we have a triple-A baseball franchise here in Fresno. So I started out really as my main job there, uh, doing everything from being an accounting clerk to a mascot to ticket selling tickets to selling corporate sponsorships and you know promotions at the stadium, and then have done a variety of different roles for a couple of different sports teams and things here in the area. But more my wife um actually uh worked for Allstate Insurance and Claims for about 14 years. And she actually that was like her first job out of college and uh her real job, and she did that for a long time, and she ended up managing a claims unit for a long time, and then through a set of circumstances and things in her own life, as they were kind of consolidating some claims offices, she transitioned out of the insurance business and started doing some other things. We adopted a little boy from Haiti, and so she spent probably a couple of years um at home with him and then realized she didn't want to be a stay-at-home mom. So we started talking about what to do for her. So, because of her background with Allstate and in the insurance business, she started kicking some tires and through some relationships. We got in touch with um, not really a recruiter, but a sales leader uh that she used to work with. And uh before long, we started talking about the possibility of her getting into the insurance business as an agent. Well, she had never done sales and marketing, so quickly transitioned into, well, I would love to do that, but I'm not ready to do it. So we started talking more about doing it together. So my wife and I launched our agency about two and a half years ago. So with my experience in sales and marketing, her experience on the back end and managing a team and claims and all that, we thought it would be great to work together.
SPEAKER_00And you did you start scratch? No premium.
SPEAKER_04I started scratch, no premium. Started how was that? I've done it before another sales job. So I've I've created a book of business. So for me, it wasn't necessarily scary to do that. I actually preferred that model versus trying to buy a book. But yeah, I mean, it's incredibly nerve-wracking and stressful and really, really difficult financially, considering both of us, neither one of us have an income, you know. So that was difficult, but we've we've slowly and surely been growing it.
SPEAKER_00So you're so your wife brought industry knowledge, but was it a pretty steep learning curve the other side? Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04The the insurance part of it for me, it's just like anything, I've been in sales long enough. It's all about learning your product and what it is. And thankfully, you know, insurance is one of those things where you have it, so you kind of know the auto side of it a little bit. And I've been a little bit in the mortgage business, so I kind of knew the homeowner's policy, you know, insurance side. So for me, the learning curve was fine. I mean, doing all the licensing and everything was a challenge, but fortunately I got through it all pretty quick and it's kind of come naturally to me. I I really enjoy the insurance business. I love how it can help everybody. There's not a single person. I always tell people I can walk into a coffee shop and every single person there is a prospective customer or somebody that will benefit from what I'm doing. I've been in sales jobs before where you're selling to a very, very small group of people. So for me, insurance is great because there's nobody I can't help in some shape or you know, some form or fashion.
SPEAKER_01So love it, dude. How was it to go to not to go backwards, but I guess to go back? How was it? Um talk about the adoption. That must have been crazy.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that was a long process. So um, we started back in 2013, my wife and I, and our our church was looking at um starting a I guess a partnership with a mission or with a uh an organization down in Haiti. So we went down there and did a little mission trip just to kind of see if it would make sense for our church to be involved with this organization. And we had always talked about the possibility of adopting, but I would say within about three hours of being there on the ground and serving this orphanage for a week, we realized right then there was that was something we definitely wanted to do for our family. So we uh we started the process, and about four and a half years later, we ended up bringing our son TK home with us. So he was, yeah, so by the time we brought him home, he was just about five years old. It was about a four and a half year process. So we made multiple trips back and forth to Haiti, and um it was a great experience. We've got two biological children that are older and they got to join us with it. It was incredible. It was a it was a life-transforming event. And part of the reason we're even doing what we're doing now because we just it we wouldn't be doing this if we if we did hadn't gone down that journey because it kind of forced us to pull back a little bit, really figure out what we wanted to do long term and what kind of legacy we wanted to create for our family. And so having that extra time, you know, my wife being at home with him really forced us, you know, to kind of evaluate what we wanted to do with the rest of our lives.
SPEAKER_01Love and I knew that that had a correlation too. I don't know if I could work with my wife, but um, I know you guys work well together. We had that those conversations. So I figured that that probably was the uh something that strengthened your I guess your relationship, work relationship as well.
SPEAKER_04Cause that is Yeah, I wouldn't necessarily recommend, you know, they always say don't do certain things together like moving, having a funeral, a wedding, or changing jobs in the same year. We were kind of pretty much doing everything all at one time. So I wouldn't necessarily recommend that. But sometimes you got to be in the fire, you know, to really figure out what matters. So that's exactly what I think came out of it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, it it can be a lot doing all those things, but if you make it through, then I think it solidifies, you know, yeah, yeah. Foundation. Love it. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So what would you say? I know that there are uh other agents out there that work with a spouse. She brought a lot to the table. You did too. What are some tips that you can give some people working with spouse or, you know, I guess kids, whatever would be kind of similar?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, great. I mean, we first thing I would say is if anybody's thinking about doing it, one of the things we were really uh careful to do is we went we went out and reached out to other people that were doing it. So we have quite a few friends that are husband-wife teams, a lot of them are in real estate. We have a couple that um own or they run a distribution company for a water purification system and they've worked together for a few years. And so, first bit of advice was talk to other people that are doing it, figure out what kind of things that they've, you know, people that you trust, people that you know that will be honest about you, people that know you enough to know if you truly should be working together or not, you know, somebody that'll give you that feedback. We kept hearing, oh, you guys will do great. They've seen us work together. So whether it's through church or just through life, people have seen us work together and they knew that we would be able to figure it out, even if we were butting heads on something, they knew we'd be able to figure it out. So that was good to have that feedback early on, um, that validation. But I guess the biggest thing that I would say is a couple of things. One, stay humble. Uh, don't come into it thinking that you got all the answers. I guess it's the same advice I'd give to anybody about marriage. Just stay humble, show up every day, knowing that you know, some days you're gonna have it, some days you aren't, some days the other person's gonna have it, some days they aren't. And just know that you're in it together, you have the same goal, the same purpose. So let the little things go uh as much as possible. And then, you know, over time you'll figure out what your lane is, stay in your lane. I'm it's pretty easy for me to want to take over every aspect of everything. You know, I just kind of have that personality. I love solving problems, I love being in the action. And I had to learn, it took me probably longer than it did for her to learn that, but uh I had to just start realizing there's certain things I have no right to be involved with, and I need to trust her to do that. And just we just learn. And then for her, she I've been in sales a long time. It took her probably a long time to trust my ability in sales, even though you know I've I've done well over the years in different capacities and different sales things. She finally got to see it. And for somebody that's not a salesperson, she never really got it, she never understood why I did certain things. And so for her, it was really just a matter of seeing it in action and understanding the sales process and trusting me to take her through that process. And so, yeah, so stay humble, stay in your lane, and just trust each other that you're gonna be able to get through it.
SPEAKER_00So well, she had to be somewhat weary because you did sell her on the idea of marrying you, yes.
SPEAKER_04And if you know me, you know that's a giant sales job right there.
SPEAKER_00I mean, come on. I but but in all seriousness, I love the the advice of I mean, checking that ego is so challenging because you're and it's a balance, right? You you have to have some ego to be able to push through and get through some of these difficult times, but then you need to be humble and uh and check that ego and let it you don't need to always be right.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Well, it was hard too because you know, I don't know how it is for other agents out there, independents and other people that were uh other captives, but for us with the carrier that we're with, there's you know, we can't be a husband-wife team the way that we're presented. It's it's me. My name's on my face is on everything. If you go to our website, it's my face. And you know, she just kind of naturally just came up underneath that and said, Hey, we're gonna, you need to be the guy. It's your thing. But I look at it as we're both in this, you know, it's our company, it's we're partners in this. But so it was kind of easy for me to start just taking on more than I should and acting like it's all mine. But I had to remember, I had to go back and constantly check myself and go, nope, this is us, and it's not even just us. I mean, that's how we try to manage our our whole office. It's not just even the two of us, it's it's our team. We are a team and we're gonna make this work together. So it's about making making sure you're always coming back to that. What are we in this for? What are we trying to accomplish? Everybody knows their roles and just get to it, you know. Clear communication. Yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_00How important has has that been? I think that agents can maybe even sometimes doubt themselves and not want to communicate, and then you can kind of run and hide and and maybe not go through all the stuff, but you're the leader. And I think communication can be it, it's so important, right? To be clear on everything. And how important has that been in your agency?
SPEAKER_04Man, I don't know if there's anything more important to be honest. I mean, communication is key. I mean, uh on all levels. I mean, communication with clients. I mean, that's what sales is to me. It's just being able to properly communicate with people, understanding what they need, what you have to offer, figuring out that gap and and bringing that all together. Um, but for a team perspective and running an agency, I mean, that's probably the worst thing that I've been at. I mean, I I kind of pride myself on my ability to talk to people and socialize and all that kind of stuff. But I was first year and a half, as I kind of expressed with you guys when we went to Ignite, I had to look at myself in the mirror and realize that a lot of our problems were just me not communicating properly with our team, not creating proper expectations, not letting them know what I was holding and what I was struggling with. And not, I have all these expectations of them and what they're supposed to be doing, but I'm not even communicating, it's all up here. And then I'm frustrated and we're not getting anywhere and I'm making all these decisions and they don't know why. Once I start having real open communication with everybody, they're just like, oh yeah, sure, we can do that. So I think communication is absolutely vital and just it doesn't have to be perfect communications, but just talk, work it out. Um, have that dialogue both ways. If there's something's not connecting, if people aren't with you, or if they're just kind of saying, uh-huh, uh-huh, uh-huh, they're probably not really with you. So you got to get that buy-in and make sure that they fully understand what you're trying to communicate. That's yeah. So yeah, you're right on about that.
SPEAKER_00I love that concept in um that we it's in the peak performance, but you know, looking in the mirror, and it is if it's not working, it falls on the owner, right? Like you, you're it's very easy to blame everybody else and everybody, you know, across the board in life, not just in business, people want to point the finger at the others. But if something's not working, the only one that can really fix it is the dude in the mirror or the dude out of the mirror. And that's hard to own sometimes.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Well, if you remember, that was the first thing I think you had us all go around at the table and introduce, you know, why were we there? Why were we at Ignite? Again, I wasn't even a part of Teledudes at the time. I hadn't I followed you guys on the podcast and listened to a lot of the stuff and got a lot of value out of that. I had a couple of other agents that encouraged me to go and do this thing, spent some money to fly out there and hang out with you guys and take two days out of the agency. And granted, I was the only guy really making all the sales in our agency at the time. So that was a big commitment. But I remember distinctly when you guys told us to be prepared to talk about why we were there and what we were looking to get out of that. And we went around the table. And I just had to, like you said, I had to look in the mirror and I told you guys that look, I'm a great sales agent. I feel like really confident I can I can do the insurance business, I can sell a lot of policies, I can do that all day long. I'm not a very good agent or an owner. And that's why I wanted to go to Ignite is I wanted to learn from you guys and from other agents how to actually properly run an agency. And uh man, that was that was game changing for me right there. Even just admitting that was a huge thing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So it's it is, and it, you know, it's wanting to do everything and uh controlling the show and being the best salesperson and all of that, it's it's just not scalable. Right. But you can't scale that business. Nope. So um, and I know I I was there too.
SPEAKER_01I would say too, it's not as rewarding. Like it's super rewarding when you can transfer these like superpowers to people that um have never done sales or anything like that, and you start training and then you see them grow. And it's like, wow, that's huge. I mean, that was one of my eye-opening moments in the agency, was when I kind of looked at it, I was like, wait a minute, I don't want to be doing all this. I want to be training people to do it and see them. That's fun.
SPEAKER_04That's a great point. I think you're a hundred percent right on about that. I mean, there's nothing like watching other people be successful and to be able to do it. And I mean, it's like coaching, right? I mean, I I coach my son's little league team, and hey, I know how to play baseball, played it my whole life, but right, I can't get joy out of going out there and beating up on these little kids, you know, and hey, look how great I am. No, it's nothing like taking a kid that doesn't know what's going on and showing something and then they they figure it out. Man, I get more joy out of that than I ever did hitting a double or anything like that. It's so much better. So I think you're 100% right about that same feeling is is what I've been experiencing in these last few months, watching our team really start seeing like getting their legs up underneath them and feeling confident and understanding what they can do and realizing their full potential.
SPEAKER_01So and your sales have been incredibly uh much greater since then, right? Yes, consistently.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, we've had some bits of success before, but again, it was primarily me, or maybe we had one other seller that had a good run a little bit. But yeah, consistency-wise, absolutely. I mean, and what's funny, it was even before I kind of actually signed up for Teledudes and actually got the system in place, just the mindset of like, I need to start really running my agency differently, and just some of the things that you guys shared a lot about when we were ignite, just putting some of those things into practice in our agency immediately yielded results, long before we even got our systems in place to support the nuts and bolts of how to sell insurance. So, yeah, we've been climbing, we're uh we're knocking down our goals. You know, we're we're kind of a smaller agency still, we haven't been able to scale it yet the way that I'd like, but we're we're heading in the right direction and the trains going the right, the right way. And we know this is the direction that we're gonna we're gonna continue to go. And we know we're gonna have success. It's just now a matter of how quickly we can get there.
SPEAKER_01Love it. What would you tell somebody that's coming in? I know that's the final question, but yeah, well, I I guess from the scratch perspective and from the I guess from the the scratch perspective, what would you do differently now? Rather like the way you approached it then and now with everything you've learned, how would you approach it differently?
SPEAKER_03Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Mm-hmm. Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium off of even the worst internet leads, where could they go?
SPEAKER_02They can go to live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03That sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there?
SPEAKER_02Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_03I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_02Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teled.com.
SPEAKER_03Live.teledudes.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_02Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content. Right? Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah, which is awesome. But they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm in the case. I'm gonna respond to them for sure. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. That's right. The calling calculator, sales material. I mean, everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it.
SPEAKER_03I'm gonna text it right now.
SPEAKER_02Five two zero two one four two two one nine.
SPEAKER_03All right, I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_00I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman