The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Go Toe to Toe with Kaleidico and Bill Rice The Lead Gen Expert Part 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up. It's the insurance dudes podcast. I agree. That's why we always say that initial contact is like the uh the pickup line. You don't want to go too deep with that pickup line, make it super, super surfacey and not yeah, you don't want to go into the first date or the proposal right off the bat.
SPEAKER_01You would just say you're not gonna and I think too, like, you know, I talk about silence all the time and just dropping something out there and and letting that consumer spin the story. A lot of times when you go like headlong in there and you say, Hey, this is Bill from insurance company, and I want to do this for you or whatever, bam, defense goes up. But if I just say, Hey, this is Bill, I'm just checking in, uh, a lot of times that person starts going, okay, who's Bill? Oh, I inquired, and that makes sense because they remember filling out that form, right? You trigger that, and all of a sudden they're kind of back on their heels trying to figure out, and then they start responding to you versus you kind of going in there with guns blazing and they get that defense going. So I love to just let them get their brains spinning and them trying to figure out how to respond. And a lot of times it works out okay, right? So because then they feel like, oh, I gotta fill the silence.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, silence is key, I think. I think it's when we get into especially like the sales talk, I mean, people have to realize that it's not the same kind of conversation that you have with your friends. There has to be everything's uh has to be intentional. Silence has to be intentional, or the questions that you asked have to be intentional with trying to initiate some sort of outcome rather than uh trying to see where they're at. Like, hey, do you want a quote? It's like nobody wants a quote.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, don't ask a question if you know you're gonna get a no-to. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01What do you guys think about scripts? I'm like a big believer. I I feel like that helps, you know, is to hire a script and yeah.
SPEAKER_00One of my guys here in my office, he's really good in talking with people and has done well with his connection, right? So he's so good at creating the rapport, but he's almost too good. And so what's happened is he makes them into friends and then can't close them, right? And so historically, he's he's been sort of back of the pack, not really crushing it. And we've been really working this script uh, and we've been doing over at we have some other programs with teledudes and all these things that we have these the script that we follow. We've worked it in, and and I just was all over him, and my sales manager was all over him to follow the script, and we finally like got it into his head this month. Well, last month he had his best month he's ever had. He was almost at 40k. And then um this month, he's top producer right now. I mean, he's already at he's already over 10k, you know, just the after the first four days of the month. So it's been really interesting because you can do a lot more training, a lot more when you're doing those calls, right? We call them the hot seats when we're when we're listening to the calls and and the whole team is evaluating the call in front of everybody. Um it's a lot easier to evaluate the where that call went if you're consistent, right? You you can't keep coming to every call with a different approach because then you have no way to analyze and and make improvements.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, it's a benchmark. You just don't know. I think even too, like you know, salespeople, we're always, you know, we like to talk, right? And we we we can wander off and we can talk about a million different things and kind of and having that script to know, hey, uh it's okay. The consumer, the customer is gonna take me off this path that I could I know where I need to come back to, right? And just have that, you know, pull them back in. It really helps all of us because it keeps us on the the journey, but it does allow us the flexibility because that's important, right? You're building rapport, you're letting them take you off the path, you give them that sense of control, but you know you you got these check marks to kick off right and you can uh pull yourself back in.
SPEAKER_00So it's exactly what he said because I said, Why is there such an improvement? And he said, Because I know where I need to come back to. Like he just has this little GPS, you know. It's like, okay, they go over here, okay. You let them kind of wind out, you know, finish talking and then shh bring them back. Yeah. So yeah, it's been really exciting.
SPEAKER_02It's like if I go to the grocery store without a list, I am wandering around grabbing all kinds of stuff. I can spend two hours in a grocery store. But if I have a list, boom, I'm on it. Like, yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. That's how you end up with the oops berry. You're just like, oh, right. Oops.
SPEAKER_02Oh, that's so funny. Here's a weird question, but like with your clients, when it comes to the insurance, are are they more apt to the script or are other industries more um drawn to a script?
SPEAKER_01I think for sure insurance is the hardest to get on a script. Because again, if you're talking health or life, or you know, you're talking about life events um that are more sort of broad based. And you know, mortgage, you're talking about a house and getting a house. It's a particular life event, you're focused on that. Believe it or not, we also do senior living, like residence, you know, and everything. It's a life event, but insurance. I'm gonna need a soon. Exactly. Well, we could tell you how to sell that too, but no, just for me. Just for you. Okay. That's good. It's soon, or like because I got a really nice place. Uh but uh yeah, I mean, so when you're talking about health or you talk about life, probably even things like home and auto, like you're talking about risk across their whole spectrum of their life. So you're you're asking them a bunch of stuff, you're asking about their family. And so I think it's it's really easy and comfortable to wander off into just the whole person's life. And that builds rapport and it feels good and all that sort of. So I would definitely say insurance is probably the least structured sort of sales process. And I think sometimes that makes it tough because you just like your guy, he's you know, he's he's really good at building rapport, he's making best friends, but uh, but then he feels bad about selling his best friend something, I guess.
SPEAKER_00Or, you know, so I think that it that summarization is very accurate and it it's in line with kind of the way that a lot of agents run their business. So a lot of and don't don't throw tomatoes at me, agents, but a lot of agents kind of go in and let the day unfold, and they don't have all these processes in place in their agency, and then they're on the hamster wheel, right? They're always on the hamster wheel, like because it's just it comes at you. So they're the agent, right? And the agent operates the business, whereas the business owner or the agency owner, it's much different, it's more structured. You have all the processes, and like that's the way we've set up our businesses because we couldn't do this podcast and run teledudes and and do all these other things that we're involved in if we didn't have structure. And so I think that it's it's a lot of work to lay down the structure up front, but it's very liberating and allows you to unplug from the business, right? Like we just look at cost per sale. I don't agents constantly, which lead company, where do I buy? Well, it's like I don't care, man. I'll just I'll buy all of it. We're buying all the data, and whichever one performs the best from a cost per sale standpoint, that's what we're gonna pour more gas on.
SPEAKER_01Right. Well, and I I think too, you know, to that point, and and this again, being on the lead generator side of things and more the marketing side of things, one thing that I always try to remind people is understand where that lead is coming from, where that consumer is coming from, and it can help you sort of structure and potentially that script script needs to be a little bit different, right? If it's a referral and it comes from Aunt Susie, then yeah, you're probably gonna wander a little wider and you're gonna use kind of the friends stuff. But if this is coming off of the internet and they filled out a form and they probably filled out a form three different places and they're probably getting like 10 different calls, like acknowledge that. So just when it's convenient, give me a call back or whatever, and that's different than hey, you know, Susie gave me your name and she's my aunt, and I love her to death, and she makes great cupcakes and everything. When's the best time to meet you for coffee and let's talk about you know the life insurance you're looking for? You know, so really being able to structure that, I think understanding that each one of those leads is created in a different way, and the consumer comes into your funnel in a different way can be super productive too.
SPEAKER_00So what kind of volume for lead generation are are you doing in the PNC space for real time?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so for real time, we're doing it on behalf of insurance agencies. So we're actually building the websites, generating those. And so you know, our average client is usually an office, probably has anywhere from six to ten folks in it. Um, and we're generating real time a couple hundred leads a month for them. Um, and then on the age lead side, which again is is through a client. So we're we're actually we work four lead generators too. Those guys are selling to even individual agents, you know, thousands of leads uh a month to agencies or to individual agencies. And that becomes that's the whole system, right? That's uh, and you guys have probably done some similar stuff. That's you know, that's building a book of business with data. And so that's a whole different process. So yeah, those are kind of the two spectrums. Uh, we're not a real-time aggregator, we're actually doing it on behalf of the individual companies themselves and just getting getting their website to generate leads for them.
SPEAKER_00Is it challenging to compete SEO-wise against like your ever quotes and your quote wizards? And I mean, they own that that form space, don't they?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so we actually do this for all of our industry. We do it for mortgage and we do it for and mortgages, we do multiple branches, agencies. We're we're only we're not as big in insurance um on the real-time side. So the way that we do that, I mean, just the secret sauce is um we use three sort of three legs of the stool marketing-wise, right? Um, we do Google Ads and we super geo-target around the you know the branch or the office itself so that we're we're not competing with ever quote across the whole nation, even though you got a statewide license, we're gonna target those inquiries down by a tight radius around the office. And then the SEO and the content that we're putting on the site, that we're we're competing a little more nationally. Um, but we're trying to be high in the funnel. We're trying to research, trying to figure this thing out, just understand insurance. That's the kind of content that we're building there, letting SEO flow in. Um, and then the big moneymaker is as we're acquiring those, and and a lot of these guys are also buying leads, aged or real time, we're dumping that into the database. And then the third leg of the stool is email marketing. So we get we get nurturing working on that database. So we're doing the database marketing, and that's producing leads. And usually that's producing probably most of your leads um for really good operations that have been around for a couple of years.
SPEAKER_02And can you talk to us a little bit about that email funnel? I think that's something that's I mean, in church, they just usually don't have enough time to be writing out uh email sequences that are so long or or don't even really understand. We have templated emails that you get with your CRM. Six go out, and that's it. So just to kind of behind the curtain a little bit, what kind of email sequences are you talking about to generate those types of results?
SPEAKER_01So there's a couple of different uh kind of put them in buckets, right? So if you're working data or you uh this is pretty common too for insurance folks, so it's probably interesting. Is a lot of times new insurance agents will come in and they'll uh like, oh, those are the cold leads, you know, go work them, or here you go, here's the book of business, like you can go work there, and then they're again cold leads. So we'll send out a three email warm warm-up series. That again, it's it's usually just uh as simple as just checking in. Hey, it's been a while since I talked, just want to see if you have any questions. You know, this is what we talked about last sort of thing. And again, that's automated. We're pulling just a little bit of personalization data out. Uh, we'll do that three times. We'll do it once when we trigger the campaign, we'll do it about three days later, and then we'll do it about 10 days later. And then that, if we get no response, if we get a response, then we just pick it up, it's a new lead, right? If we don't get any response, then they kick over into the nurturing sort of campaign. Um, and then specific to the product that we think or based on the data says they were interested in, um, we'll hit them once a week. Um, hopefully we're doing content on the website. So we'll hit them once a week. Hey, here's something to think about. Maybe it's not always about insurance, but it's something that's usually on our website, a couple lines linked to an article. Sometimes, uh again, since we're we're building these out in batch so that they'll run a whole year. Uh we built one where we did it, it ran for every week for two years and then it looped around and did the same thing again. And consumers don't remember, right? You can even sprinkle in some other stuff from other websites that just tell them. And then usually once a month, we're hitting them with an offer. So it's like, hey, hey, this is what's happening in an insurance world, or here's what's happening with rates, or here's what's happening in the market, and you should be concerned. And so that's the one-off. So all I have to do as an insurance agent, once I've batch written those emails, and again, they're really short, none of them are over a hundred words. Some people do these big long things, and those just don't work for us, right? Just a couple of things, a link, call me if you got any questions. But once a month, I'm sitting down and I'm finding something from Yahoo News or or Yahoo Finance or something like that, and saying, Hey, this is why you should call me this month. And that's the one thing you do for email for the entire month, and that works. You can do that on almost any. I mean, you can get more and more complex, but that's the that's the basics.
SPEAKER_02That's awesome. Yeah, and that's something that most insurance agents don't have enough time to do is build out those sequences and and manage those lists. And it can be a lot of work, but it can be obviously pretty rewarding as you build your database. Yeah, you can do some you could no no no. What were you gonna say? You can do some of the things.
SPEAKER_01Oh, I was just gonna say there's some other things that you can do to systemize that a little bit. I mean, one of the things that we do, and you can do this as a simple, you gotta be careful, you can't just dump raw data in here. But as long as you've you got data that's real, you know, you can use something like a constant contact or a MailChimp, or you can some of these other email packages. But you a lot of times you can do this thing called RSS to email. So if you are doing blog posts, um, which is something we set up, we're actually writing the blog post, which you can hire somebody to do, right? You every time you publish, that triggers the email automatically. So now you're it's completely automated and you're building that list over time. So that's another little technique. So there's there's a lot of little uh sort of low-tech things that you can do to really ramp up the automation. So love it.
SPEAKER_02Well, I would love to know, especially from your perspective. Uh, lead gender is is such an interesting and and cool subject, especially going into the future. Everybody's purchasing on the internet now, and especially after the last year, we're super bullish on internet everything. Um but what would you advise either somebody that's been an agent that's been in the business for a long time or a new agent coming into the industry? What would what would the number one piece of advice you'd give them?
SPEAKER_01Uh as far as their lead generation strategy?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, as far as marketing from what you've learned well with internet marketing with insurance.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I'm gonna give a little bit of a fluffy answer. It really depends on the raw materials you start with, right? So if somebody, if you go into an agency, you're starting, they got cold leads or they got a book of business they're gonna hand to you, then I'm starting with email because there's gold in those hills, and I'm gonna get the email cranking. If I got nothing, no raw materials or anything, um, then my strategy would be uh sort of a couple fronts. I'm obviously gonna harvest that first hundred or so referrals. Like I'm gonna work my contacts, I'm gonna get those first hundred. Everybody wants to do that. Friends and family, everybody wants to support you at the beginning. They'll give you Johnny and Susie's name. So I'm gonna go ahead and do that. And then I'm I'm probably going to buy some leads, right? Because I don't have enough money to build a website yet. I don't, so I'm gonna buy some leads, and maybe it's real time, maybe it's age, um, but I want to buy some leads that have some intent on them. So don't go just buy that raw consumer data, right? You get something with intent, somewhere where they filled out a form, they've raised their hand, there's some sort of attempt. It could be now, it could be later, and just buy a little bit of those. And a lot of times, depending on the agencies you go through, they'll give you some marketing budget uh to buy that. But that's gonna give you the most at bats to really get that sales system started. And you know, like you guys said, like start with the script. Make sure you have the script before you start burning through that marketing budget. Get that script right and then go after those leads. But the bottom line, I I see too many agents, too many just salespeople. They'll chew up all the sales advice on the internet, they'll watch all the YouTube videos, and they don't have any leads. Like, so what are they gonna do? They're talking to themselves in the mirror. So you gotta have those leads, you know. But buy hook or crook, get some leads and start working on it.
SPEAKER_00A lot of pieces to the funnel.
SPEAKER_01And then you can you can build out the more advanced stuff, the brand and the website and all that stuff later. But get some leads and start getting some reps in.
SPEAKER_02So if people want a scoop of Bill Rice, where are they going?
SPEAKER_01Oh yeah, so I mean, yeah, scoop of Bill Rice. Um, so uh if you want to talk about age leads, um, and we've got a bunch of sales stuff and some videos, I put together a little page, billrice.com forward slash age leads, and it's mostly focused on kind of how to work those because it's an interesting, cheap way to get started. And then if you want to go beyond that, you can uh find me on YouTube as Bill Rice. You can find me uh on YouTube uh searching for age leads, got a bunch of stuff there, and then I'm on Twitter and LinkedIn under Bill Rice, too. So um I'm pretty easy to find.
SPEAKER_00Well, great, cool. Bill, thank you so much for coming on. Yes, did I take the wind out of your face? Yeah, it was fun talking to you guys. I'll run the gauntlet anytime. All right, cool. Love it. Well, we will see you down the road, and we'll put some links in the bottom so they can find you easily. Thank you, Bill. Awesome. All right, thanks, guys. Thanks so much. Have a good one.
SPEAKER_03Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Mm-hmm. Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium of even the worst internet leads, where could they go? They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_00I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_03Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teled.com.
SPEAKER_00Live.teledude.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_03Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah, which is awesome, but they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. Greg, are you gonna respond to these texts? I'm gonna respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it. I'm gonna text it right now. 5202142219. All right, I'll see you later, Mr. Jason. I don't think I can even listen to this on the radio anymore. I love it.
SPEAKER_00I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman