The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Do You Have Real Estate Intelligence with Jas Takhar
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up. It's the Insurance Dudes Podcast.
SPEAKER_06Boom! Boom! Boom! Oh yeah. Oh yeah. Oh yeah. I'm excited about this one. We have Jazz Takar here uh live from his studio in our studios that are also in separate places and aren't really studios, but welcome to the insurance dudes.
SPEAKER_04I really appreciate this. Love the energy you guys are bringing already. I'm gonna have to make sure I go on a level 10 just to not only match you guys, but I'm gonna try to beat your energy today.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, well we actually like to take it to 11, if that's alright.
SPEAKER_04Well, look, now since we're doing that, I mean 13, 13 is my lucky number, so I'm gonna try to take it down.
SPEAKER_06Let's blow right past Spinal Tap and go to 13. I love it. I love it. So we're gonna dive in and start it with speed breakers. I don't know if you've heard the podcast or know anything of it, but anybody can do speed breakers. So I'll be looking down here at the uh sheet. Still haven't memorized them. Are you ready, sir?
SPEAKER_04I am. Let's go.
SPEAKER_06All right. Okay. Answer fast. Have you ever had a mullet?
SPEAKER_04No.
SPEAKER_06First crush.
SPEAKER_04Heidi Lambert, grade six.
SPEAKER_06Most embarrassing thing your mom ever caught you doing.
SPEAKER_03I'm not sure if I'm allowed to say that on this podcast.
SPEAKER_06You're honest. Fastest speed ever driven.
SPEAKER_03120 miles.
SPEAKER_06Good. I like that. Because we can't convert, so thank you. Favorite cereal. Crossing flakes. How many kids? Have you made cry, sir? Have you made cry? Please wait for the whole question.
SPEAKER_04I don't know. 52.
SPEAKER_06That sounds good. Count chocula or count Dracula?
SPEAKER_04Oh, Dracula.
SPEAKER_06Fastest mile. That's two Dracula's today.
SPEAKER_03Fastest mile. What that I ran?
SPEAKER_06See, we don't put any qualifications. It doesn't matter.
SPEAKER_03Oh, okay. I would say I've done 12 laps around my track in 12 minutes. I don't know how much miles that is.
SPEAKER_06That sounds pretty close. Favorite flavor?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_06We don't use any units. Yeah, see? Dogs or cats.
SPEAKER_05Oh, dogs.
SPEAKER_06Now, this may be sort of for you being from Canada, but tacos or burritos?
SPEAKER_05Oh, all day long burritos.
SPEAKER_06Oh, interesting. Favorite uh favorite video game?
SPEAKER_05FIFA.
SPEAKER_06Oh, I really liked that. That was a lot of fun. I remember that. Oh, and I guess they probably still have it, but I remember the old one. Oh, they do. But on. Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_04A PlayStation now, yeah.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. And of course, the everybody's favorite, Trump or Biden. And you don't have to answer that one. So thank you.
SPEAKER_05Look, I let me just answer because I really love Trump's tweets.
SPEAKER_04Watching his one-minute highlight reels between the two. I mean, it's really hard to choose, I gotta say. Watching from afar.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Okay, so that's interesting. That's true, right? He was an awesome tweeter. Like he had some good content, but Biden's rants and his are really interesting, and they make for amazing memes. So, what makes for better content? More entertaining? That's the question.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, you know what? I was watching Ben Shapiro not too long ago, a couple of maybe about four or five days ago, and he brought up a talk of it was a segment, sorry. Who wins, Biden or the teleprompter? And the teleprompter won out for like four days straight.
SPEAKER_05Like Biden was lost. He could not read and stay up with this teleprompter. So, I mean, Trump had some amazing content, but Biden's catching up, that's for sure.
SPEAKER_06Is was that is that inability to read an inability to see, or just not even being there?
SPEAKER_03Like, what is prompts the uh I think it's a mixture of all three, but definitely the latter there. I don't think he's all there right now, man.
SPEAKER_06Yeah.
SPEAKER_03I mean, there's definitely some age hitting him really hard right now.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. From what I see anyways, I mean you can safely say this from Canada. I don't know if we're gonna get a knock on the door now. Are we safe, Jason?
SPEAKER_04Sorry. Yeah, oh, exactly. I know I can sit here and say that.
SPEAKER_06They might not extract you, but we're in we could be in trouble.
SPEAKER_04We could. With what's been going on there, I I you're right, man.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. Well, and Canada is locked down, right? You can't really do much. Is that true? Or you can't visit?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, come on. No, I mean, we're in complete lockdown again. Wow. At March, March, April 2020, we went into this complete lockdown for probably about three months, and then there was like a semi-lockdown throughout the summer, all the way into yeah, I don't know what the heck. There's like three phases. You you could go to a restaurant, but four of you can sit. And there was like you can sit outside for a little bit, like 30 minutes.
SPEAKER_06Comes up with the equations, like the metrics on this thing.
SPEAKER_05That's what I'm trying to figure out. Like, who's coming up?
SPEAKER_06If you're standing, mask, sitting, no mask.
SPEAKER_02Legs folded, it's okay. Legs folded.
SPEAKER_06Can you cross your leg and not have the mask on? I don't know. Who knows?
SPEAKER_03It's so true. I'm gonna cross your legs. Well, it's almost like okay, there's no going outside, there's no going inside. There's no eating, but you can eat with three people. Like there's some weird ass rules that are around us right now, and we'll see how long this lasts for.
SPEAKER_02Very confusing times. How do Canadians feel about the vaccine?
SPEAKER_03Well, I mean, the number just one of the I read a stat literally 30 minutes ago. 65% of Canadians have gotten their first dose. Wow.
SPEAKER_06That and still locked down.
SPEAKER_03And still locked down, yeah. But to answer your question, that tells me that most people are bullish for a lack of a better word on getting in. So 65% have got their first dose. We are seeing some protests here in downtown Toronto where they're having a lot of people come out and say don't wear masks and don't take the vaccine. I mean, each to you know, I leave everyone, I mean, whoever's an adult, you can make your own decision. Now, the funny enough, I mean, we're starting to see some emails come through. I got a seven-year-old and a five-year-old, so I mean, it's not in my home, but my nieces and nephews, who are 12 to 16, they're getting emails saying, hey, like, tell your parents that it's safe to get a vaccine and they should take you to go get vaccinated.
SPEAKER_05I got a little problem with that. I got a little problem with that. That's very interesting.
SPEAKER_06That reminds me of a country in Europe during the 40s. Yes. Recruiting the kids to do stuff. Yeah. I won't name any names. Early 40s.
SPEAKER_03Early 40s, right? Yeah, I remember yeah. Like I know what country you're talking about. Yeah. It's a little long, okay. Since when did we think 12-year-olds should be making those kind of decisions, right? Very interesting.
SPEAKER_06Um they're not saying if they don't turn them in, are they?
SPEAKER_03No, not yet. Not yet. Not yet.
SPEAKER_06Okay. Well, that would be the next step, and that would be frightening. Yeah, for sure. So you are a huge producer of content and really big in real estate sales in Canada. I'd love you to walk us through producing content.
SPEAKER_02Odd phrasing there.
SPEAKER_06Well, I'm an odd one.
SPEAKER_02I'd love you to.
SPEAKER_06I'd love you to take us there and talk about content creation because clearly we don't know how to or what we're doing. And I'd love to hear from a pro.
SPEAKER_04Well, I know um uh your listeners and your audience obviously disagrees with you, and they know that you're just pulling everyone's leg in that sense.
SPEAKER_03I mean, to I know how hard as a fellow content creator it is to book guests and just put yourself up there. So big kudos to you guys, man, and your team. Um because I'm sure just you two can't do this on your own.
SPEAKER_06No, we tried.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I I know you guys did, and it just didn't, yeah. It couldn't have happened. It couldn't have happened. But for me, it really started three years ago to consistently produce in that range of three years ago. I probably started just with the podcast, and then it was only audio. Then I went to video, and then I quickly learned that oh, okay, with a 30-minute, 45-minute podcast with video, what I can do with it, I can get to 18, 19 pieces of content just out of one podcast. Okay, imagine if I could do two macro pillar pieces of content, which could be a podcast, it could be a QA show, it could be a webinar. I can produce more content. I can actually put it out more, which will hopefully bring me more awareness with the people that I'm trying to attract and repel the ones that I don't want to work with. Because they now, guys and gals, right, they get to make a decision when they've either seen me, heard me, read a blog, read a caption, saw an image. They can say, you know what? I really like this good-looking Indian guy who waves his hands all day. I do want to work with him. Or there's something wrong with that looking, not so good-looking Indian guy who wears a t-shirt, but yet talks to people about creating wealth in real estate. I want my advisor in real estate to be in a suit and a tie and speak very well. And so that's not what you're gonna find with me. And so that's when I put this content creation on steroids, and where I said, okay, I'm gonna build a whole team. And so in real estate, I'm sure you guys get it and your audience gets it. You get like stuff in the mail that just listed, the just sold, you get people who cold call you and door knock you. And I'm an avid, avid believer that in sales, throw everything up against the wall, see what sticks, see what you like to do, and then continue to do that. And all those things work. It's just for me, I didn't want to do any of that. I liked creating content, and so that's where I said, okay, you know what? I'm gonna spend all my marketing dollars into building a what I call my personal media squad. So I have seven, I have a creative director, I have uh three videographers and editors, I have animators now nostalgic about cartoons and a video of me turned it into a cartoon. It's a a little jazz we call him, and now I'm able to scale that out as well, right? More like what Walt Disney did with the Mickey Mouses and the Donald Ducks, right? That's kind of my thought process with that. That okay, I can actually little cartoon jazz can do a lot more than real jazz can, right? And so, yeah, I have a copywriter, an ad person as well. And so I put all my money back into the business, into content creation, which just gets me in front of more people, and then uh eventually that gets me more deals.
SPEAKER_06How much of that content that you create is dropped for organic versus paid traffic?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so for me, it's probably about 80% is organic. I've been cultivating a database for a lack of a better word. I call them my insiders for the last 16 years that I've been in real estate. I look over to my whiteboard just to see what the numbers look like as they get updated at the start of the week. It's 9,280 people. So my community is quite wide now in terms of scale. However, I produce, and the main reason I started with the production of content, that's kind of what I really want to get out to your audience today, is that I started this solely for one reason. I just wanted to give tools to my current community so they can introduce me to their family and friends, right? Like in the real estate business, it's a harder ask if I say, hey guys, when you know somebody who's thinking about buying, selling, and investing, can you please introduce them to me? Can you refer them? It's a harder ask, right? Yeah, yeah. And what's the chances of the stars aligning and the timing being perfect that you know somebody right at that time? So what I thought to myself is, okay, let me give my guys and gals some tools, which would be video, audio, blogs, Instagram, two, three-minute clips, and all that kind of stuff, where they can now introduce me to their friends, family, colleagues, and neighbors, as well as I can use that content and repurpose it in my emails, in my newsletters. Hey, did you see this video? Like now, I'm gonna say only about 50 to 60 percent of my content is real estate. I have other passions. There's more to me than just real estate. There's my passion for entrepreneurship. I like to start companies, I like to start businesses, I like to have a team around me. So there's 46 real estate agents on my team and 11 support staff. I like to document the journey of the ups and downs of that. Like I've failed way more times than I've ever succeeded. And so I want others to see that. So I chose to also show that content. If but if someone's listening and saying, dude, I don't really give a crap about like the entrepreneurship stuff. I like to sell insurance, I like to sell boats, but I also have a passion about FIFA soccer. I have a passion about the Avengers, the movies. What I would say to that person is talk about that. Because you know what? Imagine you can sell insurance to only avid Avenger fans. How much would you enjoy your business? So much more. And if you don't think you can design your business around your life, you're just wrong. You could. Like you literally could design your business around your life, but it starts with getting the clarity, in my opinion, of what you want, why you want it, because when shit gets hard and people tell you you look like an idiot on producing this content, you sound like an idiot, it's gonna be hard. It's gonna be hard. And so your why better be strong and then let the universe take care of the how. That's the universe's job, not your job.
SPEAKER_06Rogan always talks about the comments and just don't read the comments. What are you doing?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so I don't want to get beat up. If you want to get beat up, that's a place to go. Right.
SPEAKER_06Go to the the cesspool of the cesspool of negativity. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02So I have a question. So, real estate, I guess it's more accepted now doing this. I mean, I'm sure two years ago it would have been a lot less accepted. Now, you start telling people, hey, I'm gonna start filming myself and showing all kinds of pieces of content. The first thing we I mean, I've gotten this, and I'm sure you have, where it's like there's people think, especially like your family, you're being a little narcissistic here. You get those kind of comments, or you know, you definitely get pushback. So, A, what really catapulted you into doing this? And then obviously, along the ride, you have to justify what you're doing and spend and time. So at some point, you start looking at some sort of KPIs on your return of investment. And so I'm I know now you got that down, and now you're able to get a ton of content out of less work. I kind of want to just take that journey from the beginning to the end point and how you're able to get so much out of so little now, and how you were able to navigate from the beginning of the haters.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so luckily for me, my wife has always called me a narcissist. Like she's just been with her for 20 years. So when she started saying it when the videos started coming out, I was like, well, there's nothing really new now. We're just gonna put it on video. Um, but half kidding. I do have the two kids that I mentioned, but I don't show my kids. I don't actually show my wife as well. She just doesn't want to be part of it from that time.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, she doesn't want to watch it anyway, just like ours.
SPEAKER_03She doesn't want to watch it anyways.
SPEAKER_06You pretty much can say whatever you want.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I say whatever I want. She doesn't watch any of the content anyway. Um yes, when we started around here in my office, there's 1,300 in the organization. So I'm under the umbrella of a real estate brokerage. My 44 agents and the 11 support staff were branded under this uh company called Royal LePage Signatures, just a real estate company, it's a franchise, but we built our team and everyone under this franchise of 1300. When they started even till this day, I'm in the corner. I asked the broker, I've known them for 11, 12 years now. I said, listen, put us in the back. You know kind of how we like to do business. We like to open up some scotch around here on a Wednesday afternoon. If we, you know, if you're like you would like to yeah, it's up to why wouldn't you? We like to play some music, and then we like to do a lot of recordings, and so I set this room. There's a bunch of whiteboards around me, but then there's also some graffiti in this room for one of my backdrops, and then there's this media wall behind me, and then we got a bunch of uh cameras in here, and then I got my videographers walking around and content people, videographers and editors. I mean, I can say this because they've been around me for a long time, and I think they they're different, like they're not salespeople, they like to put their headsets on, they work at different times, they want to dress the way that they want to dress. So I built that culture in the back, but these other 1300 agents were like, what the F are you up to back there? This none of this makes sense. Like, and on top of that, like I've written a book on how to buy, sell, and invest in real estate on your own. I don't sell this book, I'm not showing it to you as a promotion piece. I'm saying it because I've always tried to disrupt the industry a little bit. So when I came up with this book a couple of years ago, I mean, I was already a little hated on by the real estate agents because I tell people, like, you don't need a real estate agent at all. Legally, you don't need one. Here's everything. I'm gonna tell you everything that we do because I know 99% of you are never gonna do it on your own anyway. Right. Just like anything else in life. You can teach me how to change the oil on my car. I'll leave my car in the middle of the highway before I try to change a smart one. I'm gonna leave it, call the deal. Like most people are like that. And so what I decided to do is say, I'm only gonna focus my branding and my messaging around teaching people how to do it on their own. I don't do a lot of call-to-action stuff, which is different than what you see on those just listed, just sold. It's not like call me, it's like, here's the education, go do a digital deep dive on me. When you're ready to do business, we'll go to the next step. So I think I was built for it to answer the first part of your question. Like, how did you deal with all the negativity and what people were saying? Because fast forward three years, I mean, there's more people now that hired maybe a videographer to follow them for half a day. I have it on all times, right? Because I had the foresight and I put it to one guy. I had an opportunity to do a podcast with Gary V, Gary Vaynerchuk, not too long, I don't know, two and a half years ago or something. And after him and I are done, I spent myself, my co-host slash VP, my business partner, as well as one of my videographers. We spent all day in his office. Um, let me go around to every single one of his people, like a full day spent in his office. But Gary, what he did is he pulled me aside. He's like, bro, I'm telling you right now, you just continue to do what you're doing, I guarantee you the business will come. And God bless that guy's soul, man, because it's exactly what happened to your point about KPIs. My true KPI is what people say to me in emails, direct messages, and now when I get onto Zoom calls or when people come into this room, which is like, okay, like we already know how to invest and we know we want to work with you. Can you just tell us which one? And that after being in real estate for 16 years, but really truly, there's a reason that red phone is behind me, because it's a reminder that I've been in sales for 26 years. It's all I've ever done since I was 12 years old. I've had no other job. I've always been working uphill, right? Like to build a rapport, how it is in the first 20 minutes of a sales call or a sales meeting. You're just trying to like give them the pitch of like what you do, what your company does. And that's all taken care of now. Like it's almost like, wow, if you haven't seen a piece of content, no disrespect, Mr. and Mrs. Prospect, Mr. and Mrs. Client, but here's a video. Take a look at it because it's gonna answer a majority of your questions. I'm still here to answer any of your questions, and so is my team. But I want you to get a taste of us first. Because you know what, at one point there's gonna probably be an F-bomb that's thrown in our relationship, and if that's gonna throw you off, let's not get started because it's not worth wasting your time or my time. We're gonna throw the F-bomb right at the get. Like, just so we're gonna let you know who you're working with. And look, it's translated into close to 650 to 700 homes every single year we do, year over year, for the last seven to eight years.
SPEAKER_06It's amazing how much.
SPEAKER_03I want to make sure I've got that answer. So I mean, I don't look at the metrics from a because it's different, right? When you send out a flyer, you can see how many people called you with content. It's a little different. And for anybody who's listening or watching right now, you need to do this for about 18 months before you'll break through the ice in that sense, where you will now get to you'll notice the brand awareness and you'll get the DMs and the calls of, oh my god, I just I'm surprised I'm doing business with you. I'm surprised I'm giving you a call. You're almost like a Z-less celebrity in that sense. And it just helps the sale.
SPEAKER_00Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh 100,000 premiums of even the worst internet lead, where can they go?
SPEAKER_01They can go to live.com. Are we gonna do that? Yeah, it's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will live and it will show you the project.
SPEAKER_00I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_01Let's do it.com.
SPEAKER_00Live.
SPEAKER_01There's a new community that we are further. It is our live technic community where you and I are going to answer people and give them free content. Right. We can't do that. We can offer them. 520, 214, 2219. 520, 214, 2219. I'm gonna refer to the new. It's gonna be our new community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can. Um calculated that you came up with calculated.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman