The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes chat with Justin Thomas Part 2We Are Insurance Dudes!!! We Are Here To Learn From All The Incredible Insurance Dudes And Dudettes We Speak With And To Pass The Knowledge Nuggets That We Learn To Our Dedicated And Amazing DudeNation!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!Are you interested in learning “How To Predictabl...
Buckle up, it's the Insurance Dudes Podcast. What are you seeing like going forward in the space? What gets you excited about marketing this year?
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, so is your audience and do you guys focus more on PNC, or do you do much with like life, health, annuities, retirement, and that type of stuff?
SPEAKER_01
I would say we're split. Yeah. Maybe a little bit more PNC. But we do have life and health. We've interviewed Cody Askins and David DuFord have both been on it, and I'm sure you're on YouTube, so you've seen both of those gentlemen.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah. Yeah. I was kind of thinking that you guys were more PNC. So really most of my clients that I work with are life and retirement, Medicare and Health. And this might be a good discussion to have with you guys, is because one of the things I've been working on that really excites me is using funnels to bring people to you rather than just creating like typical type leads that you then have to outbound work. You have to outbound call, you have to use like automation in order to get those people to work. So I like to use video and funnels to bring people to me. But what we're seeing is that cost per appointment is between like 40 all the way up to $140. So whenever I talk to a P and C agent, especially ones that only focus on like auto and maybe home, there's not enough margin for that type of advertising to work. What are your guys' thoughts on that? Does that sound accurate?
SPEAKER_01
Well, I think it depends. It depends on what that acquisition cost is at the end. If that appointment is gonna result in 50% of the time being closed business, I mean I'd pay $80 acquisition all day long. We'll pay $250. But if it you only close 5% of those appointments, then it's not gonna work, right? Then you have an $800 acquisition cost too much. Too much.
SPEAKER_04
Well, I think it's also the type of policy it is, right? The life and health is more of an emotional kind of policy, right? Where the P and C policy is more of a, hey, I have to do this. It doesn't really fulfill that same kind of need. It's more of an argument. So it's more of a chase. Yeah. So it's like more of like a commodity type of beginning. Not so much down the funnel, but the beginning is, where the beginning of like life and health is more of a pull at the heartstrings kind of thing.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, I agree with that. I think everybody enters that, like you can't start a P and C funnel by telling them that you bring all this value and it's better to pay more, right? You have to meet them and just like, hey, I mean, look at every billboard. You know that all the big carriers have spent a lot of money on market research to determine that everybody thinks it's a commodity, right? In fact, I think the lizard and the and flow both have spent billions of dollars to tell everybody that it's a commodity, right? And so that's what captive carriers and even independents who are selling multiple different for different carriers have to combat, right? But you still have to get them in the funnel. So when you get them in, it's this, hey, we're gonna save you some money, and then you slow it down and and you have a different conversation as you progress through.
SPEAKER_04
I read some marketing books where they were saying where you can't create desire, right? Desire is already there. How do you tap into that? And really the desire of most of the PNC isn't a desire for more coverage, because then you'd have to train them from square one. They're so far from knowing that part. To take a cold audience and get them to create the desire of more coverage. I mean, you can't scale that. But the desire, usually at the beginning of that funnel, is a price-based conversation. So I think that's the only way that is the desire at the beginning. That's what you have to tap into. That's a tough one.
SPEAKER_01
I think very rarely does that call start with hey, I was shopping around for higher policy limits. Like that just doesn't happen. I'm looking for a better deal. Like, that's how 99.9% of the things say, hey, I want higher policy limits in an umbrella. Is that something you can help me with? Like it just they don't know what an umbrella is, they don't know what their coverage limits are. They think they have full coverage and they have state minimum. Yeah, well, yeah, they know what the one that protects you from the rain is, but not the other one. Well, I mean, if they don't, then you're really in for it.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah. Interesting. Okay, well, it's good to know because I mean, as far as like those appointments, they close so much more. My clients tell me that they like them better than referrals. But what you said makes a lot of sense though, right? Because in life and health and retirement, like we put them through a 10 to 15 minute video before they book an appointment. That's because we we want to talk, we want to talk about emotion, we want to get them emotionally invested, we want to talk about some benefits and things like that. Rarely ever are we talking about price. But with P and C, I don't even know if they'd want to sit through a 10 to 15 minute video, at least not at the beginning. And so it's definitely interesting.
SPEAKER_01
Like that's interesting. On the life side, do they like if okay, you get the lead, they come through, you're talking to them, or whoever is talking to them, right? To start a conversation, do the exploration, create the rapport, all that stuff, and then they do the presentation. Is a common objection. Well, okay, I'm gonna go talk to a few more life agents and then I'll make a decision. Like, is that something that comes up, or is that pretty rare?
SPEAKER_00
Pretty rare because most of what I teach is to try and like find a hook that doesn't revolve around life insurance, right? So most people that go through these type of funnels, we don't use Google search ads as a traffic source because those people are too hot, they're too problem aware. They don't want to sit through a 10 to 15 minute video either. So um, if somebody's like literally looking for life insurance for life insurance sake, then they might have that objection. But most of the time, like when we're bringing people in, we're trying to find a hook, we're trying to find a pain that they haven't thought of, right? So it's using like cash value life insurance as a retirement vehicle, or it's using like non-ACA health insurance for people that are healthy or make too much money to get subsidies for health insurance. So it's finding these different ways, and it's also focusing. I teach all my people I work with, and my philosophy is just really niching down. And I believe in niching down in a way that most insurance agents aren't familiar with. Most insurance agents, when they think of niching, they think of product, right? They're gonna niche by final expense or Medicare or PNC. But at the end of the day, even inside of those product niches, there's so many different levels of people, right? And so somebody that's been making like a million dollars a year for the last 40 years compared to somebody making like 30k per year for the last 40 years, those people are gonna respond vastly different to different advertisements. And so, what I like to do is I like to focus on creating your own blue ocean, coming up with your own way to niche people together, clusters of people that have similar pain points based on the insurance that you want to sell them or the financial product that you want to sell them, and then become the expert with those types of people. Then you can sell multiple different policies too, which gives you longer lifetime value.
SPEAKER_04
Love that.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah.
SPEAKER_04
What are they seeing on the as a close ratio on those? Because they're obviously pretty teed up.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, yeah. So I mean, it's tough to give like a number because there's they they vary so differently between agent with their sales ability, but like one of my best guys, he closes like 60 to 70 percent, but he was also doing like 50 with appointments that he had his appointments that are bringing in. So he's just a really good closer. I would say like an ad more average number is like 25 to 30 close rate.
SPEAKER_01
Not bad.
SPEAKER_00
No, especially like when you consider a lot of these people come from having to call 50 weeds and get a hold of five of them, and then maybe or get a hold of close rates are a lot lower on those, but then you also have to call through so many of them. So let the technology do that work for the agents.
SPEAKER_01
You got to, it's 2021. Right. True. Yeah, it is.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, it's crazy. The amount of people that are still out there using a spreadsheet and knocking on doors have never made a video. And yeah, so much stuff they're missing out on.
SPEAKER_04
So, what would you the agents that are have the most success, what are some of their characteristics that stand out to you?
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, that's a really good question. So, as far as characteristics, I would say outgoing, being open, they don't have to be great on camera, they don't have to be great on audio coming in, but they need to be willing to learn and understand that like people don't want to just watch dull boringness, like they want your personality into it, and it doesn't have to be like a specific personality, you just have to be excited about what you're talking about. So, someone that's like not afraid to learn those things, and then ultimately, I think like the two really characteristics that are very important to success. First one is discipline, so someone that can actually sit down to work and get some stuff done and do it over and over and over again, and then somebody that won't give up because as an entrepreneur, the only thing that's guaranteed is you're gonna have problems, and so your ability to persevere and push through them is absolutely necessary if you're gonna be an entrepreneur.
SPEAKER_01
So true. You have to be ready for constant problems, and I think it once something goes really well, it's like okay, it's coming, right? Because it is just a cycle up and down. Yeah, I love what you said about enthusiasm too, because nobody connects with just dull, especially with a subject that the vast majority of the public finds extremely boring. So you do have to sexy it up with some really good tonality and fast tempo, or not fast tempo, but you know, upbeat. You have to be upbeat. Like we train our teams that way, we train all the telemarketers, like it is just non-stop. The focus is on how excited you've got to be excited because ain't no way the person on the other end of the phone is gonna get excited about this insurance if you aren't bringing the heat and and you just have to be fired up. Love it, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00
Exactly. Yeah, you can't expect them to be more excited than you, like that will never happen. So you have to be up here if you want them to be here, and then yeah, the other thing I like that you said that like upbeat tone, because I think a lot of the people, especially with Medicare agents or people who their demographic is older, they have this tendency to just slow down and talk to them like three-year-olds, and especially in video, they hate that. Like they don't want to sit through you just like super slowly going through the words, and maybe some of them might have hearing issues, but still like they appreciate upbeat and excitement too. A lot of people, yeah.
SPEAKER_04
Love it. Well, first off, where can people go to learn more about what you do before we yeah?
SPEAKER_00
Thanks. I mean, my website's probably gonna be the easiest place, it's insurance advertisingmasters.com. And then I've been a little bad about it this year putting out YouTube videos, but if you type in Justin Thomas Insurance on YouTube, I'll come up on there. And I'm planning to put a lot more content out. So I really enjoy putting out YouTube videos. It's just easy to get caught up in the business side of things, as I'm sure you guys realize. And so making content a commitment is something I need to work on.
SPEAKER_01
But yeah, you gotta you gotta put that on the calendar and make it happen because it's so easy to get caught up on all the other stuff, and it's the most fun, and that's the best part. Exactly.
SPEAKER_04
That's why we made a virtual craig, and that's what you see here. It's yeah, this is not me.
SPEAKER_01
No, it's a robot. Yeah, it's amazing. CGI.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, that's it.
SPEAKER_01
With AI. So, well, great, man. Thank you so much for coming on the podcast. Awesome to have you. Some great knowledge nuggets, and uh folks can uh oh Jason's show.
SPEAKER_04
I got one last question.
SPEAKER_01
Oh well, fire away, buddy.
SPEAKER_04
I would have to ask what is the number one piece of advice you give to any insurance agent either coming into the industry or somebody who's been in the industry that wants to kick start this whole social media craze that all the kids are talking about.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, kids talking about it? Um it should be. First thing is don't be afraid of social media and understand that if you want to continue to compete for the next 10 years, you have to embrace it. And the second thing is understand traffic, and your goal needs to be with everything, getting all of these different mediums of traffic into a place where you own it, right? Because if you just have a huge following on one platform, or even it doesn't even have to be huge, regardless. If you have a following on one platform, if you start to get views and things like that, you don't necessarily own that traffic, you could disappear any day with an algorithm change. So understanding things that are true assets, like an email list, figuring out a way to convert these views into actual emails that you own. And then also some other good assets that I see right now are having a podcast, having a YouTube channel, or a Facebook group, because these are all things that you have a lot more control of that rather than just posting to social media, because those are very, very heavily regulated and controlled by the algorithms, whereas these other things they tend to have a longer shelf life. So focusing on the things that are truly going to help you in the long term of your business and ignoring the other shiny stuff a little bit.
SPEAKER_01
That's great stuff.
SPEAKER_04
That is good stuff. No, it's true to look at it that way because I do see this is that people get in that mode of, hey, I'm just gonna post videos and just whatever, right? Just like pictures and this and that, and it only goes out to like a small fraction of their friends, and it's not even going out to anybody else, and it's like, what a waste of. I mean, you do need to leverage the tools that those social media platforms have given us to build our own audiences. I love that.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_04
Cool, man. JT went the distance, especially after all the technical difficulties and craziness and the chance of COVID. That's true. That's true. There's there's a chance. There is so thank you, JT. That was awesome.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, thank you. It's a pleasure to have you. Great to meet you. You're an officer and a gentleman.
SPEAKER_00
Thanks, guys. It was a pleasure being on.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, we'll see you down the road.
SPEAKER_02
Sounds good. Hey, Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh write 100,000 premium, even the worst internet leads, where could they go? They can go to live.inteled.com. That sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes.
SPEAKER_03
It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_02
I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_03
Let's do it. Sign up right now live.teledude.com.
SPEAKER_02
Live.teledude.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03
Hey Greg, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content. Right? We can talk to them. Yeah. Which is awesome, but they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm going to respond to these text. I'm going to respond to them for sure. I'm into it too. It's going to be awesome. And it's a it's going to be our new texting community where we're going to get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content, free content, and free calculator that you just came up with. Right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best tech community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it. I'm gonna check it right now. Five two zero two one four two two one nine.
SPEAKER_02
All right, I'll do later.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.