The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes On this episode we are discussing one of the pillars. Hiring. I know it is a sexy topic to discuss. Don't miss out on this one.We Are Insurance Dudes!!! We Are Here To Learn From All The Incredible Insurance Dudes And Dudettes We Speak With And To Pass The Knowledge Nuggets That We Learn To Our Dedicated And Amazing DudeNation!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools...
Hello, Mr. Craig. Well, hello, Mr. Jason. Good evening.
SPEAKER_00
So going into season number two.
SPEAKER_01
Season two, season two, season two. Season two. Let's talk a little bit about hiring.
SPEAKER_00
Ooh, I like it. It's one of the pillars. It is one of the pillars. And we're gonna get into a couple more pillars in the next couple episodes. But let's get deep with higher. I do. Ten minutes deep. I did yes, ten minutes deep and four seconds wide.
SPEAKER_01
Um starting the clock that started 45 seconds ago.
SPEAKER_00
Hiring. So here's something that we always have said in the past, which is hiring is the exact same thing as prospecting. Yep. It's incredible. Like every part of it is. Yep. Whether it be the amount, a pool of people that you need to start prospecting to get them to into the funnel of booking those calls. Right? Interviewing those people, going all the way down to hiring.
SPEAKER_01
Yep. I think that as agents, we come with the wrong, the wrong approach. And we don't mean to, right? We we're putting out a million fires, it's all day long, it's a million things are happening, and we're learning, and oh no, now we gotta hire people, or we gotta hire people because the person that we hired before didn't work out. And and so we do it without a process in hand, right? And we and we're also not thinking about that whole funnel. And I think it's very, very, very important to lay that out, right? You just have to put it out and understand the numbers behind the funnel, and you also have to understand what your goal is of that funnel. So traditionally, I think this is what happens a lot, and we've seen it, and I've done it, and you've done it, where you are you you don't have you don't really have any framework for the interview. You're you're just going, you're just going shooting from the hip. Hey, look, I'm gonna use my gut. I can't, I could, if I had a dollar for every time somebody said, I don't need an assessment, or I don't need a process, or I don't need a list of questions, because I know I hire with my gut. I would love to hear how that worked out. Because anytime I did it, it didn't work out. Because unfortunately, you tend to like everybody, right? Unless they just are a hundred percent terrible, but usually they're on their top of their game at the interview. So let's you gotta have that 10 steps back further.
SPEAKER_00
Let's go backwards, right? Let's go. What usually happens, at least this was what happened in I think both of our agencies in the past, you have a staff, you're usually maybe a little understaffed, but right around where you need to be. Usually so and so leaves your agency. Oh my gosh, it's panic time. Because yep, and then all of a sudden you're willing to hire anybody with a pulse and a license. Yep. Right? So then whoever is willing at that point, you will get in the office. Then what happens is you've narrowed your market too, right? Uh they're not that good, but you've invested time with them, you keep them at the office too long, and then it starts the whole thing over again. They leave panic mode, you get the next the first person available.
SPEAKER_01
Yep.
SPEAKER_00
Right?
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, and uh it's interesting. You're going you and you set that qualifier, right?
SPEAKER_00
I cut out panic, yeah, so panic, panic, panic mode, right? Uh-huh. And then that process just keeps going. But we know that A, you have to have a process, and that's what we were just talking about prior to that, is is just having a process, but then the process is very similar to just the prospecting process. So I just wanted to, I don't know if anybody else has felt like that, where you're on that panic, you're willing to hire anybody type thing. And that's horrible. There's too many people out there that are awesome to use that method because what happens with that method is that you're guaranteed to not have much success.
SPEAKER_01
You're gonna go through it again. As much as you hate this process, you're setting yourself up to have the process happen again.
SPEAKER_00
Right. Yep.
SPEAKER_01
And yeah, it it's it could be super frustrating, and agents will also pigeonhole themselves into you said it, look they've got to be licensed. If they're licensed, oh, that's a big win. It's like, no, it's a big win if that licensed person happens to be good, and and typically if they're really good, they're not looking. Nobody's letting a solid, well-trained sales killer that has a license go.
SPEAKER_00
So let's get in the weeds of the process. What's the first thing you gotta do to hire? It's it's the first thing I'm not gonna set you up, Craig. Avatar. I was ready.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
You you're right? You gotta put the movie on.
SPEAKER_01
Look at those big blue people.
SPEAKER_00
That's exactly who you want to hire.
SPEAKER_01
Yes, avatar. Not that avatar, a marketing avatar.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, so so who's that perfect person in your agency? What qualities do they have? Where what are those things that you've okay? Let's say you were a newer agent and you worked at uh Sears before. A you haven't been employed in a while because Sears closed down a while ago. But who are those people that you worked with that were awesome? What did they do? What were those traits? Write them down.
SPEAKER_01
Or you went somewhere that had a salesperson and you actually enjoyed that conversation, right? Your speech is probably a better route than the Sears would be any anything, right? Because they're anywhere. Your top salesperson right now. What did they do before?
SPEAKER_00
Oh, uh worked at Albersons in the meat department. Yeah. Yep. Yep. Yeah, it's it's so, but but he had those traits, you know. I'll I'll never forget what did he say? We talked about uh, you know, how how he handles object objection, not objections, but how he handles like letdowns and stuff like that. And the way he described was exactly the way I wanted to hear somebody describe when they get let down on the phone and stuff. I said, you know what? If he has that kind of strong mental attitude towards towards that scenario, then I knew right then he has what it takes. So it's it's creating that that avatar. You know who my top top one is? Interrogator, right?
SPEAKER_01
No, she's number two. So interrogator was number two, and I and I did do the push-off on her. I said, I don't think that you're gonna be good at this.
SPEAKER_00
Love that.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, and I wanted her to be good, but I I said it, and she said, and she came right back at me. She goes, No, I know I'm gonna be good because I don't give up. So I will be good at this. If I'm not good at it, I will become good at it, which was brilliant. And she's uh she's consistently over 30k. But my number one, my number one producer, she did customer service on the phone in a call center for for UPS or FedEx, it was one of those for 20 years. 20 years, and then she worked at another agency that they they wouldn't move her up, so they just kept her telemarketing, but she stuck it out for two years telemarketing, Mr. Jason. Two years. So those two prior experiences told me that she's persistent. And the thing that I think is the most challenging and most difficult to find that you have to look for in everybody is persistence and consistency. Because that's what this job is all about. That's 100%. Anybody can get a license, that's the easy part. I mean, they give them to you now because of the COVID, you could just get a get one without even taking the test. So that's important, right? And then you can train them on how to sell. You give them the script, all they got to do is memorize it, right? Yeah, that's it. I hijacked it, Mr. Jason. You did. I love it. I love it. So now I I jumped ahead earlier, and then you went back 10 steps back. So let's talk about that interview.
SPEAKER_00
The interview. So the interview, it's aligning the questions to find your avatar, aligning the questions to really uncover if this person is the type of person that you want there. So here's one thing that I used to do. I used to ask people, what what what questions do I ask in the interview? Then I take their questions and ask the questions. I didn't even really know what I was looking for, answer-wise. Well, I kind of like that answer, you know. Yeah, that was just it. That's almost what I would say. Well, that seems like a great. I mean, I understand why they'd answer it that way, right? But there's but it wasn't real thought out in the sense where it's like I'm asking questions, and if they answer it this way, then this is good, and if they answer it this way, then this is bad. Like you, you know what I mean? You almost need to start with the answer, then figure out the question, and then ask them and make sure that they arrive, yeah, work backwards.
SPEAKER_01
But there's a and I think the a big focus needs to be on putting them in situations, not not hey, where do you see yourself in five years? Well, how much did you write last month? All this stuff they're gonna make up, you know. But tell me about a time at a previous job where you had a deadline, you were behind. What was your mind like? What did you do? What did you do to make sure that you could hit it?
SPEAKER_00
Right.
SPEAKER_01
Other situational things. You have a conflict with the worker. How'd you handle that?
SPEAKER_00
Yep.
SPEAKER_01
What's your favorite swear word? Remember that one? That was a good one. I actually like that because I I told them they need to start asking that at my agency because they're in there like sailors.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, and it's almost like you want to ask those questions, you want to, you know, so that's one like section of it, right? Then one section of it is you want to talk them, like sell them on the agency. What are the benefits of them working at your agency, right? Sell them on it, and when once after you sell them on it, you want to tell them, well, most people don't make it because they're not willing to do all these things, and you you know it's almost like then you unsell them on it, yeah. Sell them, unsell them and see if they stick. Yeah. And it's it is in both people's best interest because if you have all the benefits, then all the things that suck about your agency, you're laying it out there. Yeah, you know what I mean? You're putting your best foot forward, but then you're also putting your worst foot forward so that they see it all. It's very transparent. Yeah, and based on the questions that you've asked of your avatar, if they've answered those questions correctly or in the ballpark of what that perfect person looks like, you combine that with the benefits of your agency, with the negatives of your agency, and what they think about it so far, and then give them a definitive time that you might want to do a follow-up interview before before you offer them anything. But when you do offer them anything, give them a definitive time to call back in and give you an answer. I love that one because it shows if they're gonna show up to work on time or whatever, right? Yeah, and then and then the assessment. And why an assessment?
SPEAKER_01
Why a specific assessment?
SPEAKER_00
Why any assessment?
SPEAKER_01
Well, you just want to get a you want to have a benchmark because if you have your top producers, they all track a certain way. You want the people to have the same sales strengths.
SPEAKER_00
Yep. And that's it. That's a very that's a quantum, those are the now. You have quantifiable data by those lists of of questions that you ask based on your avatar. You have the benefits and negatives to your agency, so it gives them enough data, and then you do a j like a an assessment that you're giving to everybody with the same questions so that you have a comparable data to compare all of your candidates against. And I think that once you have all those things, it's doing the funnel, it's doing exactly what we do with the with our leads, which is and this was my benchmark when I was doing a lot of hiring for the last agency. Same numbers. Yep, same numbers. Took 60 people booking that interview call to get 20 people to show up, and then out of the 20 people, you pretty much found one person.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, but Jason, how am I gonna do that? That's crazy. You have to automate some of it. You have to. You can buy a Calendly account, you can buy Calendly for 10 bucks a month or 20 bucks a month. I think they even have a free one, right? You book this link, book this link, set that up.
SPEAKER_00
Only a third of them are gonna show up. You don't even need Calendly, you can just do Zoom call. Yeah, sign up directly to Zoom, even better. Make it simple.
SPEAKER_01
And I like the group interview.
SPEAKER_00
Fill the yeah, the group interview is the genius one because it saves you and your agency time. And just fill that pipeline. Make sure that every single day somebody's getting at least two people booked for those calls, right? At least two people a day or four people or what work backwards how many hires you need based on those numbers and work backwards with the amount of time that you have left and business work days. And so you know exactly how many people you need to book a day on those Zoom calls to hire the that person.
SPEAKER_01
But you work if you work that formula and you do that process, you will get a good candidate. It's just a great candidate. But doing five interviews and then saying, Oh, people all suck. There's nobody good in my market. Well, no, because you did five. It's the same as calling five internet leads one time. You're not gonna sell anything.
SPEAKER_00
And always look for unlicensed people too, because people are excited to leave their industry, whatever it may be, whether it be the grocery store or FedEx or UPS or whatever, doesn't matter. They're leaving it, they want something new, they're excited, they're gonna put their best foot forward, they're not burnt out. So just you know, be open-minded to that. If you need to look for people that are licensed too, just be open-minded to unlicensed people. I guarantee you you're gonna find some people with amazing personalities too, outside the industry.
SPEAKER_01
And set them up for success. Buy more leads than anybody, have more telemarketers, have a better system. Do the whole thing. If you do the whole thing right, they have no incentive to leave. If you create the situation where they're gonna write more business than it than they would anywhere else, why do they want to leave? Love it. Create the culture.
SPEAKER_00
Mic drop.
SPEAKER_01
Mic drop it. I don't want to drop it though. This is a cheap one. Right. But but that's a good one. I like that one. It is, it really works well.
SPEAKER_00
Well, that's it. That is the insurance dudes leading up to episode 300 and season two.
SPEAKER_01
Season two, season two, season two, season two, season two, seasonal season two, season two.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.