The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Matt Dietz Gets The Dietz On Building From Scratch Part 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up, it's the insurance dudes podcast. Boom boom. Matt Dietz.
SPEAKER_04What's up, fellas? Matt.
SPEAKER_01I suspect let's I suspect that the that the uh the the title to this will have something about the deets.
SPEAKER_04I think the deets. Yeah. Get the deets. The dirty deets done dirt cheap. Oh. I like that one.
SPEAKER_05Publish it. It's done. You need that. You need a neon sign of that. I do, right?
SPEAKER_01Dirty Deats Done Dirt Cheap. Done dirt cheap. That's good. Q music, please. Thanks for having me on, fellas. Absolutely. Absolutely. Up from uh blustery, Idaho. Idaho.
SPEAKER_02It's 55 degrees here, sunny. I should probably be on the golf course today, but yeah, that's golf weather. I'd rather be with you guys today. Well, thank you. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I just came back from Durango where it was at night, it was like 15 degrees. Oh yeah, that's chilly. That's a jacuzzi. So my head was frozen, and you know, the rest was too hot. Balmy. Yeah. Balmy. Yeah. Where are you guys at? Tucson, Arizona.
SPEAKER_04Oh nice.
SPEAKER_01Potentially Newport Beach, California.
SPEAKER_04Oh, okay.
SPEAKER_01Spoiler alert. Spoiler alert. Well, welcome to the show. We start the show with a segment that we like to call Speedbreakers. Speedbreakers. Speedbreakers. So cue the clock, Mr. Jason. And oh I don't know if we really have it. I think that a record was a minute and four seconds. So if you can beat a minute and four seconds, you may win fabulous prizes. Okay. I'm game. All right. Here we go. Ever had a mullet?
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah. I'm a generation X, graduated high school in 91. I had a good one. Like nice. First crush. First crush? What was my first crush? God. Um, that's a that's a good question. I think I had a I think I had a thing for oh, who was on Brenda 90210, right? She was Shannon Doherty. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Most embarrassing thing your mom ever caught you doing.
SPEAKER_02Oh shit.
SPEAKER_04Um that's a good report.
SPEAKER_02My mom found I I guess it wasn't, I don't know. My mom found a pack of cigarettes in my jean jacket when I was in high school, and she she didn't, she she took it out of my jacket and she put it on my dresser as a way to be like like I'm on to you.
SPEAKER_05So kudos on the jean jacket, by the way.
SPEAKER_02Jen X.
SPEAKER_05Yes. We found on the jacket. What's that? Any patches on the jacket?
SPEAKER_02Uh, I had a Judas Priest patch on the jacket. Amazing, phenomenal.
SPEAKER_01You win. I found uh e cig, an e-cig under my daughter's uh mattress after she'd gone to school, and that's I did the same approach, I just left it laying out on her counter. Yeah, like we watched you. We know. Uh fastest speed, yeah. She's like, Oh, thanks, you found it. My god, that that worked well. Uh, fastest speed ever driven.
SPEAKER_02I did 120 through Montana when there was no speed limit in Montana. There you go. Ooh, that's funny. The my gas gate, I could see my gas gauge going down as I was driving that speed.
SPEAKER_01Hilarious. Favorite cereal.
SPEAKER_02Favorite cereal. I I love Lucky Charms. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Uh how many kids? They are magically delicious.
SPEAKER_02They are. I have two kids. I have a 14-year-old.
SPEAKER_01Have you made cry? Have you made cry? I'm sorry. Please wait till the end of the question.
SPEAKER_02Oh, sorry. How many kids have I made cry? Uh at least two. At least two. There you go.
SPEAKER_01Count chocula or count Dracula. Counts chocula. Fastest mile.
SPEAKER_02Fastest mile. I think I broke. I didn't start running until later in my career when my hair started going gray. So I think I broke seven minutes. Nice. Favorite flavor. Favorite flavor. I love uh I like peppermint. Peppermint?
SPEAKER_01Dogs or cats? Dogs. It's always dogs. Tacos or burritos.
SPEAKER_02That's good. I guess it depends on the day. What's yesterday was Tuesday, so it would have been tacos. Taco Tuesday.
SPEAKER_01Everybody's favorite question, Trump or Biden? You don't have to answer that. Flea the fifth. Well, you've made it through speed break event. I don't think we set a world record pace on that one, but uh it was pretty solid.
SPEAKER_05I appreciate it. No, but that was uh fantastic answers. Fantastic. And you win with the Judas Priest uh patch on your it was a free freebie, free win.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, Jason.
SPEAKER_05I believe you have one last question. One last question. What was your first concert you ever went to?
SPEAKER_02I mean, I think we all know the answer to that question. My first concert was Judas Priest, Cinderella open for them. Breaking the law in 1991. Yes.
SPEAKER_05Oh wow. Breaking the law. It gets me excited. That is awesome.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_05True, it's true. You had long hair at that time, right? Oh, yeah. The mullet was in full effect. Did you wear spandex to the show?
SPEAKER_02No. No. No. I was denim. We were denim denim and like you know, the black rock t-shirt was all we needed, you know.
SPEAKER_05So you needed perfect. Yeah, it was great.
SPEAKER_04Love it.
SPEAKER_05Well, take us back from breaking the law to now. How did you get into insurance? Tell us that story.
SPEAKER_02I'll tell you that story. So I've been an insurance, I've been uh with my company, I'm a farmer's agent. I've been with farmers uh for 16 years now. Um, I worked in higher education for five years when I when I was in college, I didn't want to leave college, right? And so I got a job on a college campus for five years. I was a hall director. And so um I actually had an opportunity to get a master's degree. Um, I lived out in New York for a couple of years, so I got a master's degree in like leadership because I was supposed to open doors if I wanted to stay on campus and stuff like that. And then I moved out to Washington State, go kooks, um, and I worked at Washington State University for three years, which is where I met my wife. And um, she's from Idaho. So I followed her to Idaho because she was worth following. And um, we ended up getting married, and I took the first job that I could take down here, and I worked for Enterprise Rent A Car for three years. And that's where I learned that I could sell. I had a knack for sales at that point because I was selling their damage waiver at a very proficient rate. And um, but I also learned that if I wanted to move up in enterprise, I would have had to leave Idaho and I didn't want to leave. There was really only one position left for me to go. And so my dad always told me, he's like, man, he's been he'd been bugging me. He's like, man, you should look into insurance. You just you should look into insurance. And I was always pushing him off. I don't want to be an insurance guy, you know. But at this point, I was looking for one last move. I wanted my career, you know, and so I was like, all right, dad, I'll I'll I'll look into insurance and um interviewed with a handful of companies and liked what they had to say, and I liked what farmers had to say most, and I said I'll give it a shot. And I started my career as a farmer's agent, and I've been there ever since. And so that's how I got it. Yeah, I'm a scratch agent, so it was tough.
SPEAKER_05Take us through the first year, yeah. What was that like?
SPEAKER_02I mean, it was hard, you know. I didn't know anything, I I'd never run a business before. Um, I didn't even I'd been an employee my whole life up to that point, you know. And so I thought the guy that hired me was my boss. He wasn't my boss, you know, he's my he's my district manager. I'm my own boss, and it took me a while. So I did what I was a great agent because I did whatever he wanted me to do, because I thought he was my boss, you know. So I went to all his meetings and I did everything that he wanted me to do. And um, and he was a good he was a good trainer and a good DM, so that helped me out. But you know, the first year is all about uh like I didn't even know what I didn't know at that point, so I didn't know about marketing. I knew that all I needed to know was I needed to know how to make my phone ring. Like that was like my one-line mission statement was make your phone ring. I remember this moment sitting at my desk where I was like, hey, I got my shiny new computer and I got my phone, and I'm in business, you know, but nothing was happening. Yeah, I could stare at my phone all day. So I realized that I needed I needed to do something, and so I ran to do you guys remember these things? They were they were called bookstores. Do you remember bookstores? Bookstores vaguely, right? Like way back in the day. Sound like a book I ran like orders and I bought like all these sales books, and so I learned everything I could about sales and marketing, and um, so my first year was really just like a crash course on marketing and sales, and so um just learned as much as I could. I kind of I I there was an agent that I really respected, and I said, You're gonna be my mentor, and he was like, Cool, and so I'd run all my ideas by him and kind of emulated what he was doing and found a way to make it work, so yeah, it was exciting. Nice.
SPEAKER_01I caught something back there.
SPEAKER_05Oh, you go, you go, you go, no, you go at the same time, caught something back there. I want to catch it too, and then we'll go back.
SPEAKER_01It's much lighter and a totally different subject, but you said um you followed your wife to Idaho because she was worth following, and I wonder if that was the best description of that. What would she think of that?
SPEAKER_02I think she'd be happy to hear that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Worth following.
unknownOkay.
SPEAKER_01Well, luckily they don't listen, so right.
SPEAKER_04I might cut that clip out and just send that story, you know. Yeah.
SPEAKER_0219 years later, we're we're still married, so it was a great decision.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, yeah. Nice, nice, totally unrelated. Cool. So there, there you go. Totally unrelated. Now let's go back to sales. I I know you do some training and stuff like that. So I'm curious. I want to know that sales. Um, you know, it's tough. The first I know the first year is tough, and it's it's tough when we start cutting our teeth with sales and figuring this out, especially with uh at captives.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So do you want to know what I learned and how I learned it?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I do.
SPEAKER_02Okay, I'll tell you. Um perfect. You know, my at the time, at the time, our product wasn't really priced that competitively, you know. We so I had to learn to sell on value right away. So we weren't coming in with quotes just just winning on price. And and that's a objection that that I always had to overcome in my first few years because our our pricing wasn't that great. So I was taught pretty quickly to to sell on value, and and and I learned that people buy insurance for one of three reasons. One is for price, that's always going to be a part of the factor. Two is uh the coverages or what we're offering. And then three is the service that's given by us or the agency owner. So the only X factor there, the only thing that I have any control over is the service that we provide. Like I can't do anything with my product, I can't do anything with my pricing. You know, I can make sure that I'm I'm working up the price as competitively as I can with all the discounts and things like that. But there's a I'm gonna land on a price, you know, that's gonna be right. And so, so I was learned, I was taught to, you know, create doubt in a sales uh scenario so that when I'm doing a side-by-side comparison, I always had to make sure that my proposal had something extra to sell, you know. So if they're at 100, 300, I gotta make sure that I got 250, 500. You know, if they have $1,000 deductibles, I got to make sure I'm in at 500. So at the end of the presentation, it's like, look, I know this is $13 more a month, but I'm doubling your insurance. Doesn't that make sense to you? And so I had to always find a way to squeeze value into the proposal. And if they were already maxed out on their coverages, the only thing I had to lean on was myself. You know, I was like, look, I run a really uh efficient shop. You know, I answer my phone. Um, we're gonna give you the best service that you that that you deserve. And I learned early that a lot of people are shopping insurance because their agent never calls them back. And I was shocked that people were having that experience. Like I couldn't imagine being that agent who's not calling people back. So I made a vow to myself and taught my team that like we return all the calls all the time. Like we we don't wait. Even if we don't have the answer, we're gonna let them know that their message was received. And every time I'm coming in my office, and when I have messages, you know, I'm dialing the phone with people who need to talk to me, even as my computer's firing up. So like the service is the only thing that we really can can differentiate ourselves with. I mean, I got a I got another agent a half a mile from here, and I got another one a quarter of a mile from here. Like I could hit them with a six iron with a good wind behind me. And if I really get a hold of it, you know, like, but like we're there are three of us on the same block, you know, and so what do I have to do differently, you know, for them to want to buy for me. And so that's what I worked really hard on.
SPEAKER_05Love it. When the the agency that I that I that I first got into um here that I bought was in this this tiny shopping center. Um we are a captive, we're in a captive, and then there's also a farmers right there and a state farm. So literally we would just the only people that came in the office at that point were just somebody that was like, ah, I can go to I can go to all three of them right there.
SPEAKER_02It's like the insurance food court, right?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, that's exactly what it was. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's it's it's crazy, man. I I I love um, you know, I love what indies do, uh, but man, if you have the experience of selling for a captive, especially there for long enough where your captive was the most expensive or the the the most difficult, or or didn't provide one of the coverages that all the other big ones do, then um oh man, it's like that that experience is just so valuable.
SPEAKER_02It was, it was really important. So my closing ratio early in my career was in the low 20s. You know, that's just where I lived because that's so I would close one out of every four, one out of every five. And over the past three or four years, our closing ratio with with all the work that I put in over the past decade of building relationships here in town and earning referral sources and getting finally warm leads instead of cold leads, like our closing ratio last year was 48%. Wow, and that's we're really proud of that, you know. And it just I think it it took me a while to try and figure out why. Like, why is my closing ratio so much better? And it's just because the business that's coming to us is coming from trusted sources, and they're like, you just go talk to Matt and he'll take care of you. And so we're the they're coming to us with trust already installed, and that is really just magical, you know. So, like the they're ready to buy when when they come in the door, and that's just that's years of cultivating relationships with with the right people in town.
SPEAKER_01So what kind of infrastructure?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Oh what kind of infrastructure have you built up um now over all this time and having so many policies? Has that has that had to change your ability to talk to every client? Talk a little bit about that because I know that you know being the the person who everybody goes to can be a little maddening as you as you expand.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I heard so I I was working with a marketing guy a few years ago because I was a little I was a little worked up because I my book of business was getting bigger and I had producers bringing people on, and they were bringing people on that I didn't know. So I had clients that I didn't know, and I I was okay with that. Like I'm I want my producers bringing business in for me when I'm not in the office. That's that's by design, you know. But but I'm the agent, you know, I'm the face, I'm the my name's on the door and things like that. So I was worried that that these people wouldn't feel a connection to me, you know, and that was important. And so so I worked with a marketing guy, and we've done numbers of things over the years to try and get my name and face in their house, whether that's through the mail or through email or through social and things like that. And so um he said, Matt, he's like, You have a good problem here. He said, The thing that you need to remember is that um it's you don't necessarily need to know them. He says, but they need to know you. And that was really that was that was awesome for me to hear. So I started kind of broadcasting more about me to them through whether it's an email blast or a mailer, just giving them pieces of me so that they knew that I had a family and I had a son and a daughter, and I like to golf and I love Judas Priest or whatever it is, you know, so that they can have a connection with me. And when they come in the door, they feel like they know me. And that was really the same way that, like, if you ran into your favorite, you know, television star, you know, if you pass them on the street, like you feel like you might know them because you've watched them for years and things like that. Um, it was kind of I wanted to have that kind of you know, synthetic warmth, I guess, when people came in that they they knew me because they've seen my face because I've gotten in front of them so many times over the the year over the years, and so so that's something that we've worked hard to make sure that they feel a connection one way or another.
SPEAKER_05I love that. That is such a cool uh way to look at it. They don't, I don't need to know them, but they need to know me.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's a little different, right? It's I can't. I've got I don't know, I have like 1800 households, and there's probably 4,000 people. I I can't know 4,000 people. You just you just it's just the reality of it, and it I needed to understand that that was okay, and that that's what was important was that I needed to have some relief and be like, Matt, it's okay. You don't need to know them all, but you just your your role has changed a little bit, and that's that that's important to recognize.
SPEAKER_01It's tough to let go of the reins a little bit when you expand. Um, but yeah, I know that you've developed some one-to-many strategies, podcasting being one of them. Why don't you talk a little bit about that?
SPEAKER_00Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it?
SPEAKER_04Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium. Yes. Even the worst internet leads, where could they go?
SPEAKER_03They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_00I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_03Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_00Live.teled.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content, right? Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah, which is awesome, but they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. Are you gonna respond to these texts? I'm gonna respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it!
SPEAKER_00I'm gonna text it right now.
SPEAKER_03520 214 2219!
SPEAKER_00All right. I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_03Bye, Mr. Craig. Wait, do they even listen to this on the radio anymore?
SPEAKER_00I love it.
SPEAKER_01I love it. Nice.
SPEAKER_03Uh
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman