The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Brett Young Guns Mount Up To Scale Mega Agency PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up. It's the Insurance Dudes Podcast. What were some of the um what were some of the things that you learned along the way that took your agency um in some big strides?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, man, good question. Um, well, one of those moments, uh, Craig, coming back to that, was um we we we we moved, we delineated responsibilities between partners. Um in the early beginnings, you know, as a partnership, we kind of just did everything, you know, and we worked together as a team and we didn't want to create uh delineation to where people were and how the hierarchy works because we didn't want to step on each other's toes. But once the ego kind of faded and strategy kind of said, all right, this makes sense, um, we started to delineate. And at that point, uh, my brother did all the quoting and in-house, I would do all the sales, and then Susan did referral marketing. So she was out in the field every day knocking on uh referral partners' doors. And at that point, you know, it wasn't choppy where we were getting something and then coming back, getting something coming back. At that point, we started to have a constant flow of opportunities and started to develop some awareness in the community about what we were doing. So that was a big one. But I think what I learned from that was you need a system of consistent, uh repeatable um marketing results. Um, I I don't think agents put enough emphasis on uh the marketing funnel, you know. It it's it's it's it's your lifeblood. Um you should have so many leads that you don't know what to do with. Like you should you should be complaining about how many opportunities you have, and then someone's got to look at you and say, hey man, that's a good problem, right? If you're not there, then you should be you should you should be hammered. You should be hammered down the gas. And so I think that's what I learned first was you you need to be overrun with opportunities, and then you can be more selective, you can have higher quality conversions. Um that was one. And then number two, you're only as good as your team. And I I th I think we've known that for a long time. I think that's what we came into the industry with, but um, I I think there's just uh uh an epidemic in our space with recruiting, attracting, and retaining young talent. Um just because we take this more traditional approach. That's why I love what you guys have done and you made such noise with this podcast, is you know, you're breaking the mold. It's attractive to a young person, it's attractive to somebody that's dynamic, that wants to be involved with an industry that's doing fun things. Um, and and it's allowed us to really recruit and retain and develop uh talent that our competitors would never even get them to get into the insurance space. Right? We're not fighting over all the insurance agents around town that want to come work with us. You you have an unlimited supply of quality people if you would just make your business and the industry compelling enough for them to look your way. And I think that is the number one thing that I've learned through this process is if you can get that right, it's just everything else you could figure out. That one is is is an art.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. A couple things there that that I that I'd like to address. Um, number one, the marketing. And uh Jason said this a million times, but for some reason, insurance agents like to uh have it as a badge of honor that they don't buy leads, which I think is insane, right? I mean, I'm sorry, but if you don't have leads, then then how are you gonna grow? You have to have some kind of pull marketing, right? Something has to come your way and you have to pay for that to happen. That's just the way it works. Um, and then the that also then feeds the environment to which retains your staff, right? If you're gonna hire people, you cannot hand them the phone book like it was done to us because that doesn't work anymore. Um for a long time I would bring people on and I'd say, Well, I, you know, I was I used to make a thousand dials a day at Merrill Lynch, you have to too. And I've realized a while back that doesn't work, you know. That that especially with with how much an agent can pay somebody now, you know, they're it's pretty thin, especially if you're starting out, you have to give them as much as possible for them to be successful because then they make money, they're staying, right? And it's a good environment. But we've been we've been fortunate and blessed to to create a culture in our agencies that people want to come to work, you know, and they like it. And I'm sure it's the same thing there, but you have to spend money on the marketing. I you know, you hear it over and over. Um, I oh well, I can't afford it right now, but I I'm you know a couple months down the road. It's like, dude, if you can't afford it now, in two months it's gonna be worse.
SPEAKER_00It's an investment, right? It's not about cost, it's about return. So and I think there's a learning curve. You got to be willing to lose money because that's the name of the game, right? We don't do things just to get the return, doesn't have to be monetary. The return could mean I learn how to do this. Because if you're not gonna learn how to do it, you know, like I can take anything out of the box, you and I do the same thing. If I have a different background and have different skill sets and have learned from this, we do the exact same things. I get different results, right? So you have to be willing to be bad in order for you to get good. And I uh marketing is a great example of that, right? Like nobody just is awesome at marketing because they're just a marketing guru. No, they practiced it. It's a discipline, they fell forward, they make mistakes, they spent a bunch of money, it didn't return anything, and then they said, all right, well, I'm not gonna do that again. You know, I'll pivot. So one thing you said, I I love it, you said pull-through marketing. So what I you did in back in you know, my old days was I did what's called push-through marketing, right? I would go out, I'd get opportunities, I'd bring that back, right? What I learned was under most business models, especially ours, that's not scalable. And what you're talking about is being able to take somebody with a good personality that's hungry, that has drive, that can talk to somebody on the phone, but maybe doesn't have that killer mentality to rifle through a thousand phone calls. I want to be able to take that person and give them an opportunity to grow and be successful, right? So instead of me looking for the the 0.02% out there that can do that, my now frame and pool to pull from is so much wider because I've equipped them with a system where they could be successful. So I I love that, man. It's totally, totally true. If they can't be successful in your system, you're not gonna retain them.
SPEAKER_04Right. And you be you create the process. Now you're not training and looking for that 0.0001%, but you can plug anybody in there. If they can talk, if they if I mean not anybody, but but somebody who is willing to do a little bit of the effort and and is has a good personality. I mean, I you meet people all the time, you know, even at a your fast food, wherever, you know, selling cell phones, but you meet somebody, you're like, whoa, okay, I like this guy, right? And totally that's my fish is just talking to people.
SPEAKER_00And and I think one of the coolest things about that, man, that they that's cool. I can just tell that you guys have a cool culture because of what you do and who you are. And uh, you know, culture a lot of times is just a reflection of the person that's that's in charge of leading that culture. So that's cool. But I I to to be able to to to take somebody that just has a a desire for more, right? And be able to equip them to be successful. Number one, that's the bet that's my favorite thing to do on the planet. It is literally fills me up, it's my juice, it's what I love, right? So how many times have you heard somebody say, I just can't find good people, right? You hear it all the time. The reason you can't find good people is because you're looking for such a small target class of your your target is so small because your process and your system is re require such a specific type of person that no wonder you can't find good person. It is a correct thing. But if like you said, if you find somebody that has some general skill sets, like uh and you can make them successful, I think you have a scalable business. I think you have an opportunity that most people don't have. So that's a great point.
SPEAKER_03Yep, uh a hundred percent. And and that being able to create a uh a system where you can plug anybody into is the best position you can put yourself and your agency in. I I mean it's literally the the the McDonald's type model, right? Where it's um, you know, there's so much equity in that that people I don't think that everybody understands and is willing to put in the time for one thing that you said that was awesome too was uh you got to be bad to be good. You have to do it, like you just have to suck, like suck and suck fast so that you can be good.
SPEAKER_04This is the wrong podcast for that, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_03I love it. No, but we always say we always say fail fast. And and then when we bring in agents into our agency for the for sales position, it's like I want you to get on the phone, learn the script. We're gonna get on the phone and we're gonna uh coach you through calls, but but really just get out there and fail. Fail, fail, fail, fail. The more you fail, the the the faster you are to being ultra successful.
SPEAKER_00That's awesome, man. I totally agree. Uh my one of my favorite sayings somebody says in here is I'm bad getting better. You know, I'm bad getting better, you know. Like it's almost like a bad of it's almost like a badge of honor to be bad. It means that you're willing to do the activity even though you know you're not as good at it. You're not as good at it as you should be yet, you know. So take me, give me somebody with that type of attitude, and let's go to work, you know, like that. That's fun. Um, we can we can we can sharpen, we could sharpen the axe, but you gotta be willing to to you know wield it, if you will.
SPEAKER_03So yeah, that's so funny. That's the first time anybody's ever said that, and that is a hundred percent what I like to do. And I know it's it's not the the smartest thing to do is to take people that might have been from an outside industry that might not naturally be a good salesperson, but like create this new opportunity and basically change their life. I I once um had a salesperson in here, and when we first started doing meetings, um, I got her up in front of everybody and I said, Listen, um, she's naturally good at sales, right? And I said, Well, what about your parents? What were your parents like? Well, my mom, whatever, but like my dad, he was really, he was really good, outgoing and stuff like that. And I'm like, you've been ultra successful at every job that you've been to, right? And she she wasn't in the insurance before, and she was that sales skill, like that personality, changes your life. It changes your kids' lives, it changes the trajectory of everybody you know around you. It is the number one thing. So I love taking someone who doesn't know that, giving like teaching them those skills, putting them in a position where they they they came in, said, I'm bad at sales, right? Or or whatever pre-frame that they had. And then you give them the skills, they get this incredible um confidence from it, and it literally will change their life and everybody's life around them. That is, I think, one of the coolest things on the planet. And it's that's awesome.
SPEAKER_00It's a transferable skill too, right? Like the art of problem solving and communication is is a is a universal transferable skill that it it you'll you'll carry with it everywhere you go, and it will improve whatever situation you're in. So what a cool gift to be able to give that to somebody, right? And it's not for everybody, I get it, but I I'd argue that you know we're in the business of problem solving. So, you know, yeah, and being able to communicate that. So someone says they're not good at sales. I I think 80% of people say that that that they just haven't, I think they need to reframe that because you know, we're all in the business of communicating, you know. So it's a great thought. You know, one of the other things I don't if I can, guys, one of the things that I think would would be cool to share is that I've learned is that uh everything in here is open offices. Um so you talk about failing fast and failing forward and failing a lot. Well, what if you have five, six people all failing around you? I get five times as many reps as the person that has a closed office. I'm a big fan of having open like I'm in an open office and these guys are still hammering right now, and they know that we're here, but I just let them know. But I've never had a closed office on purpose because I think it's a cool example to set that says if I make a mistake, my mistake is your mistake. If you make an error, your error is mine. We're not talking ENL, we're just talking about a miss on a phone call. But um, but that you just you just it like it's an exponential acceleration, and then you debrief almost on every single deal, or you have an upset customer and they tell you why, and then you have a dialogue real quick for 10 seconds afterwards. Someone says, Oh, you know what? I probably should have done that. Let me try that next time. I think that's a secret sauce that some people miss, and uh, I think it's just powerful. That's using team to your advantage, you know.
SPEAKER_04All day. Yep. Yeah, 100%. Both of us have open open offices. He was just out here. We did a uh avent for some of the teledudes clients, and they they came out. And I mean, my guys, this is COVID, right? They're all they're like just in one little area. And I have a big, I mean, it's a pretty decent sized space where we built a gym and one for them. There's a big conference room, another office in the back. Wow. But but they they want to be. I'm like, hey guys, we can all you know go separate, be apart. They don't want to be apart because they they're able to pick up something from their, you know, they just finished the call, they didn't get it, but so and so's over here and and and they're crushing it. They're like, ooh, I like what they said, right? You're always picking up something. And with sales, it's like you have to constantly practice, you know, basically it's like batting practice.
SPEAKER_00And and how good is the energy in there comparatively? Yeah, it's crazy. Yeah, it's electric, yeah, right.
SPEAKER_04It's there were 14 agents there, and they're like, This is unbelievable. I'm like, just what they do, you know, and they like it. It's like I can't believe that they love this. And they, you know, they they do. So it's it's awesome. It's cool. I'm sure you have the same thing.
SPEAKER_03And Craig and I, yeah, and we we didn't always operate like that. So it's there there were points, and we talked about this months ago, where there were points where we both didn't want to go into the office. And it's because the lack of energy, and it's almost the opposite, right? It sucks it out of you. So it's like it's either it's either going to energize you and create energy, and and that exponentially happens to everybody that's in there. So it's either gonna create energy as a team or we're gonna die as a team and suck the energy out of each other.
SPEAKER_00Well, especially in this virtual environment, right? It's like, you know, I I did a post to the day. I was like, just because you could work virtually doesn't mean that you should, right? Like it has its place and flexibility is amazing because it adds to lifestyle, which that's a that's a big deal. That's the that's the thing. But you know, I I think either you need the office or the office needs you. Like the the energy that you bring when you're in a good mood and you're in a good place and you feel bulletproof, somebody needs that. And if we're truly a team and we truly care about our culture, then it's my responsibility to make sure that you get that when I come in, right? Or if I'm not having a good day and I've just gotten beat up, I I need that from somebody else. And collectively, that's how you keep energy levels up. That's where you keep a sustainable workplace, that's where you get that's where you get rid of burnout, you know. So, you know, I can't imagine doing what we do just completely isolated. What we do is we we we we have some uncomfortable conversations on a daily basis. So you better be in an environment that's positive where people feel you know supported um by the person next to them, you know.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, and I think that creates a ton of opportunity, a ton of opportunity now in getting acquiring other candidates because there's people, a lot of people are working from home now, and it it is not the best, right? They're they're by themselves, they they've they're stuck in their house with their spouse, and they're starting to hate each, you know, now they're hating each other. It's like it's like I I need to get out, right? And you have this high-powered energetic environment. I mean, people come running to you.
SPEAKER_00So it's yeah, I mean having having the ability to have flexibility is is is to me what I think most people want. Um, and maybe I'm biased because I'm more wired to this, which is fair disclaimer, but I think people want the ability or the the the the flexibility to be able to make that pivot and have control of their life. But to do that every day, I think that will fade away. We we are social people, like we need interaction with people. And to to not have that bond with the people that you spend so much time with, then you're really just collecting a check. Then you're really just you're just doing something to to to to make money. And we all know that if you do something just to make money, then it's unsustainable.
SPEAKER_04True. Along those lines, this is interesting. So um, do you know have you did you listen to Grant Botman episode?
SPEAKER_00I haven't.
SPEAKER_04Okay, so so he's out here in Tucson, he has an independent, but he's his whole thing is about culture. And one of the things that that he he does is he has unlimited time off. And and I thought, well, how I mean, how do you even do that? Like everybody would just be be off. And so I'm like, okay, I gotta figure out how I can do that and then offer it. And and so so I put I I put a similar thing in place, but they have to be tracking. If they're not trending to hit their minimum um requirements, they can't get it. And there's some you know stuff there. But people take less time off because they have the that flex, they have the option, the perceived flexibility as a result of it. I mean, even when they when they take the time off, if they're not tracking, they'll come in before, after, on the weekend just to make sure they get paid for that time off. And it's just it's genius. It's amazing, isn't it? It is amazing.
SPEAKER_00It's amazing, isn't it? The the the mind is crazy, right? Like once we feel like we don't have that shackles on us, we have freedom, you know, it's like, okay, well, now I'm playing for something different, you know. Yeah, I love that.
SPEAKER_04Makes sense.
SPEAKER_00We we have uh four tens for our customer service representatives. So it's so four days on or four four days, 10 hours, and then they have the fifth day off and they cycle, and um, so we just kind of stack it to give kind of some more flexibility. But I'm having to beg them to please take the day, like take the fifth day because they come in, you know, when they're when they're when they're off, because they don't want to leave their team hanging because the phones are blowing up, it's it's heavy, um, you know, the the the Florida marketplace down here for homeowners is absolutely a dumpster fire right now. It's insane. So but so that they're like, oh, well, I'm coming in on my day off because you know, I can't leave my team hanging. It's not about management or leadership impeding on them on what they have to do. Right. They it's it's them wanting to, they're they're part of something. So I don't know what the secret sauce is on that. I don't know what all the ingredients are, but I know that man, Craig, that's a that's a that's a that's a serious component. I love that. It it just it says I trust you. I trust you, you know, which is what what more can you ask for? It's awesome.
SPEAKER_04Well, look at the attitude with the Empire versus the attitude with the Rebel Alliance. Like the you know, the guys flying the X-Wings were much happier.
SPEAKER_00There you go. They're cooler, you know. Yeah, and they're way cooler. Yeah, no doubt.
SPEAKER_03So so Brett, this interview is a long time coming. Awesome, awesome to have you on. I want to know what the number one piece of advice you would give anybody coming into the industry or that wants to light a fire in their agency this year. What would you tell them?
SPEAKER_00Uh culture is a verb and culture always wins. Um, you know, I I there is there is not a bigger component to our business um that has uh that has been a bigger factor in um I wouldn't even say our success, our progression up until this point. Um it it is a it is a ridiculous competitive advantage. Um, it is not a um an uh a bullet point on a job offer. Um, it is genuinely a marketable um external um message of who you are, and it attracts uh some incredible people to an industry that they normally would not look at. So there you go. Love it.
SPEAKER_03If people want to get more of Brett or want to know more about your agency or everything you have going on, where can they reach you?
SPEAKER_00Oh, dudes, you guys are great. Um uh urbanyoung.com. It's E-R-B-A-N-D Young Herb and Young. There you go, boom. Um, but they can also find me on socials. I'm everywhere, man. I'm on the gram, I'm on LinkedIn. Uh you know, so yeah, just uh Brett Young, hit me up. I'd love the chat, man. I'm so encouraged by the community of agents who have started to reach out and collaborate on this stuff. And really, you guys have been a huge uh I've been watching you guys for a long time uh before this was cool. And it it's amazing what's happened when somebody kind of puts a spark and you've got all these people connecting and talking and collaborating and and and man, we're making the industry better, man. This this is what a what a cool place to be, and it's because of leaders like you guys that uh we're gonna attract the next generation to come behind us.
SPEAKER_03So it's cool. Thank you. Love it, man. Thank you, and thank you for what you do. Your energy is infectious. I'm sure everything about your agency is a phenomenal. So uh kudos to you, man. Thank you for coming.
SPEAKER_00Awesome. Thank you for having me, Jesus Rockstar. Thanks, dudes.
SPEAKER_03Thank you.
SPEAKER_01Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it?
SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_01Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh 100,000 in premium the worst internet leads, where could they go? They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we going to be there?
SPEAKER_02Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_01I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_02Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_01Live.teledudes.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_02Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_02Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah. Which is awesome, but they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm going to respond to these texts. I'm going to respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's going to be awesome. And it's a it's going to be our new texting community where we're going to get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. Mmm. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it. I'm gonna text it right now. 520-214-2219!
SPEAKER_01All right. I'll see you later, Mr. Jason. I love it.
SPEAKER_04I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman