The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Brett Young Guns Mount Up To Scale Mega Agency PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up, it's the Insurance Dudes Podcast.
SPEAKER_01Finally, finally got Brett Young on here. I think it's maybe the fourth attempt. Fifth attempt? You know. Who knows?
SPEAKER_00If at first you don't succeed, try try again.
SPEAKER_01There you go.
SPEAKER_00It works. Awesome. Yeah, super great to meet you guys.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, really good to meet you. That's how insurance students have to do it anyway. We gotta make 90 phone calls to get somebody on the phone. And uh here we are. Persistence. Persistence pays off. So without even going into anything yet, we're gonna start with steep with speed breakers, which I can never preach. Yep. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_03And I'll I'll uh I'll time this. I'm scared.
SPEAKER_01The previous was a minute. One minute. Can you beat one minute? Alright. Okay. So time begins when I finish the first question. Is the timer on the board?
unknownYes.
SPEAKER_01I wish we could put a little ready. Alright. Get ready. Uh-oh. Now I gotta find it. Here we go. Have you ever had a mullet?
SPEAKER_00Have I ever had what? Say it again?
SPEAKER_01A mullet. A mullet.
SPEAKER_00No, never had a mullet.
SPEAKER_01A first crush.
SPEAKER_00Lindsay in sixth grade.
SPEAKER_01Ooh, most embarrassing thing your mom ever caught you doing. You have to be honest.
SPEAKER_00Man. Is this censored? So we so we know.
SPEAKER_01Fastest speed ever driven.
SPEAKER_00110.
SPEAKER_01Favorite cereal?
SPEAKER_00Tricks.
SPEAKER_01Oh, tricks are for kids. How many kids?
SPEAKER_00Two.
SPEAKER_01Have you made cry? Please for the full question. Two. Count Dracula or Count Dracula.
SPEAKER_00Count Dracula.
SPEAKER_01We had a lot of Dracula today. Fastest mile?
SPEAKER_00Too slow.
SPEAKER_01Too slow. Favorite flavor?
SPEAKER_00Strawberry.
SPEAKER_01Dogs or cats?
SPEAKER_00Nice. Dogs.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. Tacos or burritos.
SPEAKER_00Tacos.
SPEAKER_01And the ringer, Trump or Biden? Trump. Oh, he just says it. Most people are scared to say it. Yeah, everyone is. Awesome. Well.
SPEAKER_03Nice.
SPEAKER_01I love it.
SPEAKER_03110. 110?
SPEAKER_01Oh.
SPEAKER_03But we added you added the the the question at the end. So it'll take up five seconds. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01105 still. That doesn't prove anything. Okay.
SPEAKER_00So I don't win the crown.
SPEAKER_01No. Almost.
SPEAKER_00If you're not although your hat first relaxed.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. First loser.
SPEAKER_03So so Brett's got his uh his uh logo from his agency on his hat. And if you see this on the interwebs, you'll notice that it is not your traditional um agency logo. It's super cool.
SPEAKER_00Thanks. I appreciate that. It's a good logo. Thanks, man. I appreciate that. My uh my business partner it uh takes credit for that. I mean, he handles all the gear and he does a pretty good job. So I just show up with it on. It's it's it's it's way easier for me.
SPEAKER_01And and Nike's shirt with the load with your logo on it, it's great. I'm saying, man.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, he's got it dialed in over there. He does have it dialed in.
SPEAKER_01And where where are you located?
SPEAKER_00So we're out of central Florida. We've got an office here in Orlando, and then we've got an office in uh in Melbourne, Florida.
SPEAKER_03Okay, cool. Awesome. What was the first concert you ever went to?
SPEAKER_00The first concert I ever went to? God, that's a good question. Um, I think it was a Goo Goo Dolls concert.
SPEAKER_03Really? Was that now was that during the uh what was the big first song? Goo goo dolls. Oh, goo goo dolls. Good one. Gosh, song of the uh the angel soundtrack.
SPEAKER_00Um is it is it I'm gonna I'm gonna I'm gonna butcher this, but is it is it was it black black balloons? I was uh there was a lot of good tracks from from Goo Goo Dolls. It's been a minute, but that was a great show. Great show.
SPEAKER_03Oh yeah. Oh, that's I missed that.
SPEAKER_00I don't know when I'm gonna get to do that again, but uh virtually it's gonna be a hologram.
SPEAKER_03That would be phenomenal. So take us back to the goo goo days of the goo goo dolls and uh what brought you into insurance?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, man, right? That's kind of everybody's uh story, right? What how how did you land where you landed? And it's always something interesting, right? Um, you know, mine is different than maybe some people that I talked to. I actually got introduced in the insurance business. I was in network marketing for five years, uh working uh an insurance product and built a business, um, a pretty decent business, and learned a lot of the insurance concepts from doing that. Um, did some employee benefits with that product, um, had some success. And then ultimately um I was kind of running all around town trying to meet people on their lunch breaks and kind of uh with for for kind of some voluntary benefit type stuff. And I decided that the PNC world would be uh maybe a little bit more strategic for lifestyle-wise. And um, and I had learned kind of the team building concepts from that network marketing background and uh personal development and a lot of the different leadership stuff that's very prevalent in that space, and uh and then kind of getting attracted to the PNC world, that's kind of how those things collided. Yeah, right.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, is it a company that we would recognize?
SPEAKER_00Um the probably but it was a it was a product, it used to be called prepaid legal services, now it's called Legal Shield. Um they have uh a legal plan product that they that they offer, um, and then they obviously have an uh an identity theft product that they offer. And we built that built that business for five years and uh did loved it and then but uh transitioned a lot of those concepts and things that we've learned into the property and casualty space.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. A lot of people take uh kind of get schooling on how to run business or or develop processes and implement outside of the business uh outside of the insurance industry, and then they bring it to the insurance industry.
SPEAKER_00Right. I think that's a cool way, right? Because you get you get a couple different tastes from different environments, and what can you bring with your own twist and how can you make it your own? So yeah, I think that's a that was a that was a unique experience um that has served us well.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Did you so did you uh did and do you land it here or were you did you do insurance? Yes.
SPEAKER_00So from there I did what all um uh aspiring insurance agents do. I went and got my 220 with uh no job, and then I put an ad on Craigslist that I was willing to to work for free. So I did that. And then uh I found an agency, went to go work with them um as a producer. Um they gave me a laptop and a contract and said, here you go. I was still on my parents' insurance policy at that time period. I had never seen a deck page in my life. I got my 220 and I still hadn't seen a deck page. And uh, and then you know that was the rest. The the rest is history, man. So it's been uh it's been a cool ride.
SPEAKER_01How long did you do that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that was let's see, 13 years ago.
SPEAKER_0113 years ago. So what did you so times were a little different back then, right? We were just talking because that's about when I got into it too. Um and running the running uh uh the way that we run our agencies now, you couldn't have done back then because there just wasn't the tech, there wasn't social media, you know, where social media was just starting. I mean, there was barely even I don't even know if there was an iPhone yet, right? And so it's it's fascinating how much has changed, right, over that period of time. Like you were you had a notebook and were probably writing names in there and doing it, you know, the the old way. Certainly doing that. That's how I learn.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, make a list, contact that list, invite into that list, and then rinse and repeat, right?
SPEAKER_01So so what was what was your strategy at the beginning?
SPEAKER_00Go find anybody with a heartbeat because apparently the property and casualty space, everybody has it, needs it, wants it, buys it every year. So I was kind of ignorance on fire, man. I didn't know any better. I just knew that if I could get in touch with enough people, ask for opportunities, uh, get their current coverage, even if I hadn't learned all of it yet, if I can bring that back to the mothership and have somebody help me, then at least that gives me a shot to put something in front of them that could be better. Um candidly, that was my only strategy. I'd I'd learned that in my past life to that it it wasn't necessarily um, you didn't have to be the expert all the time, um, especially in in our space. I mean, it's a matter of uh, you know, contacting relationships, getting an opportunity. At that point, I was working with somebody who knew a lot more than me. Um, so I just positioned it as hey, I'm working with this person, they're a lot better than me. I'd love to have an opportunity to kind of take a look at what you have, you know. So yeah, that was it.
SPEAKER_03So take us from that time to now, because you guys are crushing it, it looks like. Um yeah, so I mean, and and I think the last 13 years, going back to Craig and my conversation earlier today, um, it really has been through a lot of changes. A lot of, you know, when internet first, you know, when internet was early 2000s, super scary, like, oh uh, you know, the internet's gonna take uh take our jobs, and then oh wait, it's not, but it's it's it's a tool, and it's kind of been um it's kind of been all over the place. So I'd I'd love to know like how you started and how you ended up where you are.
SPEAKER_00That's thank you for that. It's funny, yeah, because like we I look at it as it's a medium of communication now instead, but before it was like the big bad monster that's gonna replace all the agents, right? Um, and I'm I'm glad that isn't the case, but I'm also uh I'm always weary that you gotta be you gotta make sure we're getting better because otherwise, you know, the internet is undefeated. It's undefeated. Right. Um yeah. Um so yeah, um, so yeah, dude, I worked for there for a little bit and um uh uh I built that book um from scratch. Uh I moved my young uh wife who knew nothing other than just to trust and had good faith in me to do something crazy like that. I had always been entrepreneur, keep in mind that I had done multiple businesses before this, so that wasn't abnormal for me. But we moved to this town where the agency was, uh, did that for about 12, 13 months. Um, you know, believe it or not, I had a contract and I signed a non-compete. And um, you know, the the the idea was that I was gonna own my book um since we were starting from scratch, or at least I was gonna be vested for part of it. And we got to I move I you know, I moved to that town. She supported us the whole time. I think that first year I made like 13 grand. It was, you know, this is ridiculous. And so I on my renewals coming up, I finally, you know, you're telling your wife, hey, don't worry, hang in there. Renewal season is coming. We, you know, at least we're gonna get to the second year. And uh we got to the second year in the month after we got to the renewal cycle, they kind of knocked on my door and said, Hey, by the way, um, we're not gonna do that anymore. Um, you gotta you gotta write this amount, which was a big portion of business, and then we'll let you vest for your book. I was like, hold on a second. We had a we had a deal here, like and and and I signed something. Well, I signed the non-capete, but I never got that in writing because I was young and immature and I just didn't, I just didn't know any better. And so that was a really big moment for me because I had to kind of, I mean, that was we had worked, I had worked this whole time to build a reputation and do this deal. And now this kind of was like put to a decision um what you were gonna do. And uh I I didn't mean it's just I'm so grateful. Uh after all that, I mean, I literally I didn't even have a bed frame, it was a mattress on the floor for the entire time. Newly great. But so I go back to her and I'm like, hey, here's the deal. Uh here's what here's what it is. And then I start justifying why it's okay. Well, it's fine, it's not a big deal, and this, and and I just remember she just looked at me and she says, No, she goes, You you can't work there. And I'm like, Well, it's fine, you know. Well, here's what's the deal, it's not that big of a deal. And she's like, Absolutely not. That's that's bad integrity, that's not how we do things, and that's not gonna be a long-term fit. You need to go find another place. Um so I had to, yeah, man. So I mean, she's the hero, she's the strong one, not me. I'm I'm like, look, you know, this this this 13th month, I've been looking forward to this since we started. So, you know, uh it's okay. But um, so she kind of forced me to make a tough decision, and so I went out to look for um, and I had brought three or four um from my team, my past team, to come work at this agency. So we're building out this sales team. And so all these guys had been basically looking at me for this is the next step. So I had to make a decision that this wasn't gonna be. Well, of course, if you have three or four people that you've been kind of responsible for, you have to have the next thing lined up. You know, that's a that's a burden that um wasn't necessarily mine, but I kind of felt responsible. Um, so we went and looked for a place not to start an agency. We went and looked for a place where we could build a team inside of an agency. I wanted to I was I'm a team builder. I wanted to bring that team and build that out inside someone's agency. I had no intention or want to start an agency. Um, and then I went and worked or I went and interviewed with some of the bigger firms and some of the uh the major national kind of kind of shops and uh just realized that it just wasn't gonna be a good fit. Um it just, it just it was a little corporate for me. Um, it was just a little rigid, and I'm a creative. So uh we had this crazy idea at that time. I was working with my old business partner. His wife had come over to be an agent, and my brother, who is now my partner as well, there's three of us, uh, he was getting out of school um at the time and couldn't stand the internship that he just went through. So I he was easy. I recruited him to come do this stupid thing called start an insurance agency from scratch. Um, and man, it was the hardest and best thing we ever did. So from there we we we we started from one policy at a time and we started over, and it was really tough for three and a half years. And then after that, we started to really gain some traction and and fast forward today. We've you know, we've got 20, 22 team members, and we've had a significant you know organic growth rate for a really long time, and we're we're doing really well. So it was it was the hardest thing I've done, but I'm super blessed. And it was all because of that decision my wife made me made a long time ago.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Love it. Now I I don't want to skim over some because I know there's some good stuff there. One thing that I love that you did is you recognized having a team was more important than having the the the job, basically, because you knew that you could take this the team is your equity, you could take this team anywhere and you could thrive. So so you start this agency with two other dudes, nobody, and you take the four dudes that from the other business, right? And and you guys all start.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so one of those dudes was a partner, right? And it was him and his wife, which was uh the urban urban young uh rod. And so we're working together. That's you know, that's working. And then Taylor decided he was gonna come on this journey. Um, I recruited him with a with an eight dollar lunch from Chipotle, so boom, shout out to Chipotle. Um, and then the other guy uh became uh a producer and and came over and worked with us, and then we just you know, we literally bought three laptops and went to an upstairs bedroom, big basement, like a bonus room, and we built this out out of the house. And I still remember we had the that we used Google, uh, we used the Google numbers or phone. So people would call the office and it would ring to the cell phone. And we still make fun of this all to this day. It's great. So our phones would ring, one person would answer, and then uh it would be for me, and my brother would answer, yeah, no problem, let me transfer you. So he'd put it on mute and he would just hand me the cell phone. And and so I mean that and that was it, man. It was just a hustle, it was just a hustle and one policy at a time, one one step at a time.
SPEAKER_03So six of you guys in the in a bedroom.
SPEAKER_00So it was three of us, and then one outside producer at that point because um because technically uh Rod and Susan were one. Um Rod was working his full-time job. Uh he's been a very successful dude in in medical sales, and he had uh his own team and he was working that. So he's more of a passive investor, and then his wife was the agent uh for the first three and a half years until he was able to make the switch. And then uh Taylor, um uh who's the third business partner in my blood brother. I consider Rod my other brother. And then uh we had another gentleman who came over um who's no longer with us, but uh did a fantastic job and worked as a producer for three and a half years. So yeah.
SPEAKER_03That's cool. So take us through that. So you're working in a bedroom, and and and so for those three years, uh what was the what was it like? I mean, a few months of that, it had to be at some point, but somebody's gotta be going, dude, oh yeah, this is crazy. So take us through that whole. I want to I want to know the deets.
SPEAKER_00Man, faith is a uh is a powerful thing. Faith is a powerful, powerful thing. Um, I still look back, honestly, guys, and I I I still kind of shake my head and go, that that we escaped our own worst enemy, which was this is very difficult. You know, you you throw in the towel. Um, and this is what's challenging in our in our industry and our business is that uh that barrier to entry is is tough for newer agents, right? You you that first couple years is is a grind, you know. So um, I mean this was back before we had multi-raters. I was you know, we're quoting you know, every auto by itself till 9:30 at night, and then you know, trying to, you know, obviously sell these one or two the next day and then go out and get policies and bring them in. We had no sales uh uh marketing infrastructure yet. Um, but it was tough. I mean, we we had multiple conversations about is this worth it? We had multiple conversations about how long is this gonna take. Um, we had multiple conversations about just getting to a livable wage so we could manage. Um and uh ultimately at the end, it was about what's the long-term lifestyle look like? What is the what is the dream look like and is it worth it? And the answer always came back to absolutely it's worth it. We just got to get better.
SPEAKER_01Any moments. So, what were you about to throw in the towel?
SPEAKER_00Oh man, multiple moments. And anybody who's has partners, I mean, you guys know, I mean, there's it's not all sunshine and rainbows. I I know, you know, Rod Taylor and I have had multiple matches where you know the stress is mounting and you take it out on the other person, and you you you know, you sometimes you point fingers at people and you look back afterwards and you don't like yourself because of the way that you've acted, especially in those stressful situations. I think that's the biggest advantage we have is we have partners. We have, you know, there's three of us, but also that's the most challenging because we've had to grow together. So there have been I still remember we went to a barbecue place and uh you know we got out of the office, and I remember us looking around at each other and being like, is this even possible to sustain this? And uh the answer was no, unless we do something different. And at that moment, um we kind of pivoted and uh and changed our model a little bit and and it and it worked and and we caused some traction and it's been it's been good.
SPEAKER_03That's so cool, and it's so true uh with partners, there's always there's always uh giving a take to every everybody thinks the grass is greener on the other side, no matter what it what whatever you're talking about. But I want to know, so those first three years, what were some of the milestones that you're like, whoa, wait a minute, this is starting to work, or um what what was the timeline of that?
SPEAKER_00Man, I have a funny story if I could say this on air, but one of the one of the moments that I remember the most was so I had a uh we had a commercial account that we wrote, and this was early in my career. I'd been doing commercial for maybe two years at this point, and uh we wrote this nightclub, and it wasn't a big account, but for us it was a nice account. It was probably 40 and 40 in premium, and it was a good, it was a good, nice pop for us, especially the size. And I remember you know, high fives of getting this done, getting it, you know, bound, and uh it was a huge deal. And and um we had a virtual office, right? So you because you need a primary location, it can't just all be run out of your house. So we had this virtual office, and we, you know, we rent space, and he's like, All right, cool, I'm gonna come in, I'll sign docs and and I'll give you, I'll pay you. Well, of course, right? You you you you make it very clear to everyone that you don't take cash. Um, I we do at least, but this gentleman felt compelled to show up with cash and he shows up with this and he signs all the documents. And of course, I'm excited, right? Because this is a big account for us, I'm fired up. Everybody else is like sending me text message on the way there, congratulations. And he shows up, he signs the docs, and he takes this brown paper bag and he dumps out all this cash onto the onto the conference table. And I'm like super on like at this point, I'm like, oh, this is not good. Like, I don't know what to do. Do I say no? Like, do I say like yeah? Like, say, hey, thanks for the money, but I can't take it. You know, I don't I don't know what to do. I've never been in that situation before. Um, hindsight being 2020, I would have signed said, hey man, you I can't take that from you. Um, you gotta figure out that way to write me a check. So anyway, I end up taking it right to the bank. But as I'm walking out there, I literally text everybody, I'm like, look, this is where I am. I feel like I'm gonna get jumped as soon as I walk out here. Please, if you don't hear from me in five minutes, go ahead and make the call to the police. Long story short, I didn't get jumped. I I made a deposit. We were okay. But that was a moment, man, where it was like, All right, we're one, you're one relationship, you're one call, you're one no away from getting to a yes that could, you know, potentially put you on a path to have some significant momentum. So that was a big deal.
SPEAKER_01Was it the whole 40,000?
SPEAKER_00He didn't pay the whole 40,000, but he paid a lot of chunk of the hundreds. Let's just put it that way.
SPEAKER_01It's hilarious. It's so crazy. When you're starting a business, any business, there's this, it just there's this like very slow growth. You know, like it's it just seems like, oh shit, this is this is not sustainable, and you can't see the end. And it's at it it's at that breaking point that it just it makes that turn.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's almost like life wants you to prove to it that you're worth it. You know, it's like it it's it's it's making sure that you're worthy of the blessing that's coming your way. Because I mean, uh yeah, I I I totally agree with you, man. It's it's there have been so many moments to where um you know you want to throw the towel in and just grit, you know, nothing else but just grit shows as the you know the the promises to to to why you get to the next level. Um and I don't think that ever goes away, you know, honestly, like the higher the level, bigger the devil. Like I know that we're dealing with challenges right now that I never dreamed of, you know. So I just you constantly have to uh there's a there's a there's a saying around here that says that's we have good problems, you know, good problems. Um and you know, I I I hope that never goes away because to me that's the thrill of entrepreneurship, that's the thrill of business, that's the fun, that's the game. So it's just tough when you're not uh being compensated accordingly and you've got you know, you gotta feed feed your family. That's where it gets uh that's where it gets tough.
SPEAKER_01So bigger children solving, but no uh money in return is wrong.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's all it's all potential, right? It's all for the promise.
SPEAKER_03Um so what were some of the um what were some of the things that you learned along the way that took your agency um in in some big strides?
SPEAKER_00To be continuous.
SPEAKER_04Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it?
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_04Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium, yes, even the worst internet leads, where could they go? They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there?
SPEAKER_02Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_04I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_02Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teled.com.
SPEAKER_04Live.teledudes.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_02Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content, right? Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah, which is awesome. But they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm into it. Craig are you gonna respond to these texts? I'm gonna respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. Mmm. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it. I'm gonna text it right now. 520-214-2219.
SPEAKER_04All right. I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_02Bye, Mr. Craig. Wait, do they even listen to this on the radio anymore?
SPEAKER_01I love it. I love it. Nice.
SPEAKER_02Uh
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman