The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Krista Mashore Shore Shot Selling Realty Secrets PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up, it's the Insurance Dudes Podcast. No. All right. You weren't expecting that. You weren't expecting it.
SPEAKER_04I'm super excited. Super excited for two reasons. So we have a dudet, which is awesome, right? And it's it's not an insurance dudet. Yes. Yes. But very, very pertinent to the insurance agency or to the insurance industry. So we are super stoked. It's Krista Mayshore. Recently just won a what's it? Two, you said uh what award did you win? Yeah, two. Two CC actually. 10 figure award. Huge. So huge. Congratulations. A lot of zeros, right? So um a lot of figures. A lot of figures.
SPEAKER_00A lot of figures. Ten million. It was 10 million awards.
SPEAKER_04That's amazing. Amazing. So welcome to the insurance dudes. Uh we are uh just why don't you why don't you tell folks a little bit about your journey uh that got you to that how you got to this place. I know that you've been doing real estate for for a while, and uh then you met Russell and uh sort of took off from there. Why don't you dive into that a little bit?
SPEAKER_01Before we get into that, I don't want to oh put you on the spot for icebreakers, but we always ask our first our guests what was the first concert you ever went to? And you can go way back to Barney if if that be the case.
SPEAKER_00I don't remember. I I'm I I think it was uh oh gosh, I know I went to like uh I can't remember. It was um I'll be sure, I think, was the first concert I ever went to. I'll be sure.
SPEAKER_01I'll be sure oh nice, yeah.
SPEAKER_00I think it was I'll be sure first.
SPEAKER_01I'll be sure.
SPEAKER_00All right, and the last one was some kind of a coach, some uh some kind of a um uh country concert.
SPEAKER_01Oh, nice, yeah, Craig. Come on, Craig, yay! Cool, so take us back to I'll be sure and from then on, how how did you get to this point? Because I know it's a very incredible journey, especially uh from our little pre-talk there.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. So I use so I used to be a teacher. Um, I taught third grade for six years, and then prior prior to that, I'll just kind of set the stage. So I haven't lived at home since I was 13. I ended up finding myself in some trouble when I was younger and started running away from home and then ended up in Juvenile Hall, and then I was in a group home, and then I was in a foster home all through high school. So, with that being said, I'm I have an amazing relationship with my parents now, but you know, I there were some tough times in between, uh, in between there. And like I haven't been at home since I was 13 years old. So um, that's kind of the start. And then I ended up meeting, going, put myself through college. I got a degree in teaching, a master's degree in in curriculum and instruction, and became a school teacher and did that for six years. And then one day uh my daughter got really, really sick. And so uh I left teaching to go be a stay-at-home mom because they told me that she was probably gonna have some severe like learning disabilities and you know, like bad stuff. So I left uh teaching and I was gonna just play real estate. My my goal is to just sell maybe three or four homes a year so I could make what I was making as a teacher and be a stay-at-home mom. And one day I came home and I came to find out that my husband at the time was having an affair, and it was not the first affair, it was one of many I came to find out, but I ended up um leaving him and we had just bought a brand new home. So we had a brand new home and two little girls under the age of uh you know two and four and a half, and um drained bank accounts and a like four thousand dollar mortgage. And so I realized really soon that I had to like, you know, I can't just play real estate, I gotta die. And so that year I sold 69 homes, my first year in real estate. Um and I've just been yeah, yeah, I've been in the top one percent of realtors um ever since, uh, nationwide. So that's kind of the story of where it started.
SPEAKER_01Wow. Take us through the sales process. I know so I did real estate for a little while. It's horrible. I was horrible, horrible. But I also didn't have the flyer under my butt to to get it done. Oh, and the time of life that I was in was horrible.
SPEAKER_00But you gotta work, it's a lot of work.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, take us through that first year. Just um, I know, like I know it's a grind.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it was a grind, especially back then, right? Like the way I do business now is so different than back then. But I used to knock on doors and I'd I'd, you know, um like sell my soul. And if it was Christmas dinner and somebody called and wanted to see a house, I would leave and show them. And it was just it was rough, right? I had to put create a safety um avenue for my children, wanted to make sure we stayed in our home. And so I was willing to do whatever it took to kind of to make that happen, and I did, and so it was really, really great. And I pretty much have sold a hundred homes every year since. And that wasn't that's not with a big team, it's with me and like an assistant and a transaction coordinator. My best year was 169 homes. Um, when I left real estate to yeah, to go coach, I sold 154 homes that year. Um, last year we only sold 90, but I only work on my real estate business five hours a month. I now just record videos and I'm the face of it. And my brother now goes in and takes the appointments and talks to the sellers and buyers. I don't deal with um people at all. And I, you know, I we we pretty much do really well. So I'm not that upset about only doing 90 homes. If I was still selling, we would do more. Yeah. Um, but now I'm coaching. So now I three years ago I started coaching agents. So I coach agents uh from across the country on how to utilize social media and video to dominate their markets, something that would absolutely work for your people. I mean, it's just it works so, so well for any industry, quite frankly. Um, so much so that I just recently wrote a book and it was geared towards like local professionals, like insurance agents and those kind of things, um, because it's just such a powerful tool.
SPEAKER_04What's the book called?
SPEAKER_00It's called the Ultimate Lead Gen Playbook.
SPEAKER_04Ooh. Well, we'll have to put a link to that.
SPEAKER_01Uh yeah in the notes. What is the website? Just before we got it.
SPEAKER_00You can go to get Christa's Book.com. So get Christa's Book.com and it'll take him through a like a free plus shipping offer on it. Yeah, it's alright. It's a bestseller on Amazon. So nice.
SPEAKER_04Well, congratulations on that. I feel like I'm gonna be saying congratulations the whole time.
unknownNo, no, no.
SPEAKER_00Oh, let me just say, I've had so many bad things happen. No one ever talks about that, but like I was just telling, you know, you two that when when uh like it's been tough with COVID. I mean, it's been some crazy times, right? Like there was a point in my business just you know, back in March where I was at a six-week burn rate and I didn't realize like what was happening in my business. And so it was to a point where I had to sell one of my rentals so I had money in the bank and keep so I could keep my you know my my um my coaching group open. And I just like kept on pushing and pushing and pushing. And you know, finally, Jason and Craig, like finally it it all took off. So it has not always been, you know, unicorns and butterflies. I've had plenty of of things go wrong. It's just but I just didn't give up, you know?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that that's interesting because a lot of times when you get to that point, and and most uh most folks, when they get to that point where it's like, oh no, you know, I I'm burning too much, it's not working, I need to I need to throw in the towel. And and the ones that really blow it up are the ones that realize, okay, I'm right here on this, you know, that that growth trajectory, I'm right near the elbow, and it's about to freaking go, but they fold right before.
SPEAKER_00So many people, and I can't tell you how many times, like even my own students will will they'll be like, it's been four months and I've been doing this and it's not working. And then on the fifth month, they're like, Oh my god, I got 12 listings and I got sick. You know, it's like it came out of nowhere. I'm like, no, it didn't come out of nowhere. It's all the momentum of what you've been doing, yeah. Yeah, but most people will not won't won't stick to it, you know. I think that's it's really sad because you know, somebody said this to me just recently, and I thought found it really funny. They said, So, like, for example, in insurance, are there insurance agents that can make a million dollars a year? Easily okay, easily. What about a million dollars a month?
SPEAKER_04Easy is easily, but yeah, but yes, you're the answer is yes, right? People have to do, yes.
SPEAKER_00Well, then if if the insurance agents that are out there aren't doing it, it's because they aren't doing it, it's not because it can't be done, right? It's like the only person involved it is it's your fault that you're not doing what other people have been able to do, right? I know that sounds kind of mean, but it's it's true.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, well, people don't want to look in the mirror.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Uh we just talked about we just were talking about that exact topic uh just before. So that's that's yeah, yep. But it's true, you have to take responsibility. I mean, if it's not working, it's it's the person that's on the other side of the mirror, not all the other things that we want to blame, right? Yep, yeah, absolutely. Go ahead.
SPEAKER_01Uh yeah, I was gonna say it can be so liberating too when you really do take that accountability for yourself and don't point fingers at anybody, just learn from the situation. How could I have done stuff better? What can I do to improve this? It's an incredibly liberating feeling rather than blaming everybody else where you're helpless.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and it's a constant change and pivoting, right? It's like, I mean, you gotta pivot constantly, and it's amazing what just a small tweak can do on the on the positive direction. You know, it's it's it's incredible. And I've live learned that firsthand so many times. Like, oh, just this one thing could make it make it go down the hill or make it go up, you know?
SPEAKER_04Yep, and and there's higher stakes as you as you scale and scale and scale. One little thing can really make a big difference. I love it.
SPEAKER_00Yes, yes.
SPEAKER_01So I want to get into a little bit of that lead gen. Um, some of the let us give us a taste of the book. What what are we um what are some of the things that we're gonna do?
SPEAKER_00Okay, so let me let me give you one strategy, and I'm gonna use real estate because that's my that's what I do. Okay, so what what what we teach people to do is how they cur can create content right on a local level. Um, and you can do it nationally, but it's just so much easier to do it locally, where you you you produce content and you you pay to for people to pay attention. So you create content that video content, and video is so so strong and so so powerful because there's this data behind utilizing video compared to non-video content, it's just astonishing. Like you get 800% more conversions, and I can just go on and on about how important video is. So I teach people how to utilize video, create content around their subject, create content around their community, you know, um, and this would work great for an insurance agent, somebody that will go and interview other local businesses and talk about like the best Taco Tuesday in town, or you know, I mean, yes yesterday, somebody was like, We watched your video on Taco Tuesday and we went and had tacos at the berea because of seeing your video. I'm like, oh, cool. Right. And and then we teach them how to create content regarding their subject matter, and then sometimes just like be a reporter, things they learn, they're really just anything community related or insurance related, let's just say, they're gonna be creating content around. And then we teach them how to take that content and it when you can tell somebody's watching a video on a specific subject matter, and we teach them to target people at that that watched something in the beginning and to retarget people. So now all of a sudden you know that if somebody's watching a video on selling a house, right? Then they're probably thinking about selling a house. So I'm gonna have them watch another video on selling a house. Then what I'm gonna do is I'm then gonna just keep educating them a little bit. And then, like on the third or fourth step, I'm gonna say, Hey, would you like a home evaluation? They're much more likely to say yes to that home evaluation because I've already developed a relationship with them. I've been informative, I've I positioned myself as the authority. They trust me by this point, they're not afraid to click. Then after they go to that landing page, then we send like video testimonials from past clients. Then we send them like marketing examples, then we send them more seller videos. From that one strategy last year, um, I sold four closed 48 seller transactions, um, generating over $760,000 in uh sorry, $740,600 in seller closed transactions just from that one strategy. Now, what most people do is they'll start with what's my home worth, right? Like, would you like insurance, an insurance quote? But no one wants an insurance quote. I'm targeting people that right, right, right.
SPEAKER_03I'm targeting people that nobody.
SPEAKER_00So it's like, no, I don't want that. I'm definitely not gonna give you my information because you might be a stalker, so no. So this way it just is much more likely to be able to convert.
SPEAKER_04It's it's remarkable because um a lot of our peers will see will see on Facebook, like they're using social media, great, but then like the post will be I just saved somebody 200 bucks on their insurance, and then it's just crickets underneath come and get a quote or hey, we're we're sitting around, come and get a quote. Well, you know, it's like, no, nobody is gonna respond to that, right?
SPEAKER_00No, no. There's there's this really cool study. Um, there's this book called I think it's called Sway. It's called Sway. And it talks about the pre-frame. Okay, so basically there was a study that was done from these these uh there's a college professor that was absent, and this was all set up, right? They did it, they did an experiment. And um, everyone got the exact so they they gave the students a biography of the of the of the professor, and they were exactly the same. All the accolades, you know, what he had done in the past, every single thing on the biography was exactly the same, except for two words. One said rather warm, and one said rather cold. He's a rather warm person. He's a rather cold person. At the end of the um training, the class, they gave them a like they gave the students a questionnaire, like, how'd you like him? Right, rating his performance. Like across the board, the one that got rather warm said he was so nice and he was, you know, friendly and he was a great teacher. And the ones that got the rather cold biography was like he's an a-hole, you know, he's not a very good teacher, he's curt, and he's rude and pompous, just from that. So what that teaches us, oh my god, that's a terrible picture of me right there. Like I froze like this. Yeah. So um, so what it what it tells you is that what people get from going from cold to warm to hot makes a huge, huge difference, right? So so I use this analogy like this. I'm sorry if I'm talking too much, but I just get excited about this stuff. So let's just say I do a like a video and I say it's a great market, like it's a great time to buy a house, right? Interest rates are low. That's that's a good time to do general marketing, it's blanket marketing because you're nurturing and your brand awareness and all that. But what about that veteran who doesn't have a lot of money in the bank? He's got a 625 credit score and probably can purchase. And he's a veteran, but he doesn't even think that he can purchase. So he doesn't even hear my messaging about the market being great and interest rates being low. Now, if I say, Are you a veteran with not a lot of money in the bank, but you've got a 625 credit score and you have a job, do you know that you can probably purchase a home and probably even pay less than you're paying for rent? Now all of a sudden, that is speaking directly to that, right? Right. So that's the whole idea behind video marketing and also getting people to want to work with you because they're they're they get to know you. I mean, I'll do a video like in the morning getting ready with no makeup on in my nightgown. Um, and I'm talking about like some a class that I just took of what I learned. And so people are getting to know me in these other areas, but then they're also seeing professional Krista that's targeting video content directly towards what they were interested in, and then also blanket marketing messages that's getting people to know me and position me as the authority and to nurture past clients and to get more referrals. So um I just find it, you know, it just works so well. It's this the exact strategy that I've used to be, you know, in the in the top 1% in the in the country, and the same thing I'm teaching my students to do that will go from nobody knowing who they are, brand new agents to beating top producing agents after a year. I mean, it's incredible.
SPEAKER_01And from the get, were you good at being on camera?
SPEAKER_00God, no. Are you kidding me? No one is, no one is. You're really weird if you like to be on camera. I mean, if you if somebody says I like to be on camera, I'm like, you're weird. Like, there's definitely something wrong with you. Like honestly, seriously, um there about out of a hundred people, you know, Jason and Craig, two will say they like to be on camera. The other 98 are petrified, they're worried about how they look or what they sound. Are they gonna mess up? Are people gonna like me? You know, I gotta my nose is big, whatever it might be, no one likes it. But it's the fastest way to develop a very loyal audience, just like the podcast, like you were just saying earlier, how that your podcast just has, you know, great raving fans because they know you and they like you, right? They they like you guys. Video is the exact same thing. I'm attracting the people that want to work with me and I'm repelling the ones that don't. And so, you know, back in the day where I was competing on listing appointments, there was times where I'd compete with eight people, and I'll tell you, they most likely already knew they were gonna hire me before I even got there because they they like I had like really messed it up, and even after people interviewing between four, six, eight people, I mean, I rarely would lose, and it's because they already had a relationship with me prior to me getting there because of those who love that because of the video, absolutely.
SPEAKER_04I mean, it's amazing.
SPEAKER_00So, this is a good idea for your your your your people, okay? I've got a good idea for you here. We go. So, yeah, your people should start creating video content specifically geared towards real estate agents, right? Like, because you they they want, right? Do you guys uh sell home insurance, don't you?
SPEAKER_01Your people, oh yeah, oh yeah, that's the holy grail. Well, whatever.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, okay. So you guys love realtors, all right? So then why don't you start creating content like towards realtors? You know, interview a local realtor, um, interview every local realtor, talk about how you know what what you're what you can do for them. Get create content targeting realtors that's just about regular stuff in the community. Let them see that they're active. I mean, I cannot think of one insurance agent except for my own, right? That comes to mind because nobody ever markets. Like if somebody says, Who's the number one insurance agent in Brentwood? I'd be like, I have no clue. I mean, I use the same guy forever, and changing is like the biggest pain in the ass in the world. So I will never probably change because it we all know how hard it is, unless somebody developed a relationship with me and I could tell that person I like them and they're gonna give me really good service. Maybe I'd be more willing to do it, right? So I think I don't think I know that that would work not only for your for them to go after realtors, but everybody needs like everyone that I sell a house to, they need insurance. So now it's like, oh, that insurance guy that I see all over Facebook. Oh, you're buying a house. Oh, and you know, go to call that, call call Craig, call Jason. I mean, we we create videos that get anywhere from 300 to 600 hours of watch time on them, right? 150,000 views, 6,000, you know, 6,400 uh engagements, clicks, likes, and shares because we're paying. That's like on a 200 ad spin, right? So imagine your people start doing this on a consistent basis, they will crush it because no one's doing it.
SPEAKER_04And you're doing that on YouTube.
SPEAKER_00I do it on through Facebook ads, all through Facebook. I do paid Facebook ads. Um, and that because you're that's where most people are going. But then I do video repurposing and I put all my my videos also on my website so I get SEO through Google, but also on YouTube, so I get SEO through YouTube. And then I tell people in my videos, hey go to YouTube to see all my videos. So I when I'm targeting them on Facebook, I I have them organically go over to YouTube.
SPEAKER_01Oh, wow. Wow. I don't know every agent out there that's listening. Please, please, this is it. This is the bomb. This is the this is the golden nugget that you need going forward, especially in the times we live in. Uh, we've been talking a little bit about social media and how this year is it. Like there, you're gonna miss the boat. Like, this is this is you we have more listeners over the last year, we have more views in social media than who knows if we'll ever have again. And this is the opportunity, and you are a hundred percent. I love it. Amazing advice.
SPEAKER_00It works though, and I know most people won't do it though. That's the sad thing. Like, most people are just will not do it, or they'll do it one or two times and they'll stop. But I'll I'll tell you, I mean, we've helped real estate agents from across the country do this. I've been coaching now for three years, we've helped thousands of agents, and um, in a 30-day time frame, the average agent will pick up two clients if they do this consistently, and that's just from a video text message where they take their phone and they go, Hey, you know, it's Krista. Jason just wanted to say hi, was thinking about you, and I saw that you had this amazing podcast and it was so good today. Just wanted to say hello and was thinking about you. And then that, then they see you on Facebook and they see your ads, and then they go, Oh my gosh, my friend is thinking about buying a house. She needs insurance. Why don't you call? Right? That's what starts to happen just from doing 10 video text messages and without even spending any money behind it. So imagine like people start to see you everywhere, and that's really what happens. I mean, it's just such a great strategy, but people are afraid of it and they they don't want to spend any money marketing themselves. Um, and they just, you know, they're they're hesitant to get on video. But it's if you don't like money, well, then don't do this. If you like money and you want to make an impact, then start.
SPEAKER_04Well, and what a great, great thing that people are afraid of it. And so there is that barrier to entry because of the fear. So huge opportunity, right? It means nobody else is gonna do it if you do it.
SPEAKER_01To be continuous.
SPEAKER_03Hey, Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it?
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_03Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium even the worst internet leads, where could they go? They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes.
SPEAKER_02It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_03I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_02Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03Live.teledudes.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_02Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_02Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah, which is awesome, but they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm into it. Craig are you gonna respond to these texts? I'm gonna respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. Mmm. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it.
SPEAKER_03I'm gonna text it right now.
SPEAKER_02520 214 2219.
SPEAKER_03All right. I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_02Bye, Mr. Craig. Wait, do they even listen to this on the radio anymore?
SPEAKER_03I love it.
SPEAKER_04I love it. Nice.
unknownUh
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman