The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
The Kamperts_ Darth David Is Joe's Father In Amazing Insurance Alliance PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up. It's the Insurance Dudes Podcast. Yeah, I want to hear from Joe on this. So Joe, tell us about your your Facebook uh strategies and and how you're how you're using social media. Because I know you're strong on social, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's that's where I literally it don't ever come down. This is the first time, literally just during this call, is the only time that Facebook would ever be down for me. Um, I mean, I drive so much business through there. And and the thing about it too is I think you know, a lot of people when they hear social media or they hear Facebook, they think paid, I'm 100% organic. Um, you know, and I think that ultimately what comes down to that is one, it was the shift to where I'm like, okay, I'm spending tons of time on Facebook, right? Like, and I think that's when you're coming from a model where it's like, dude, I just hit the phone and I sell, right? That's I mean, that's how you make deals is you get on the phone to where now it's like I'm spending all this time on Facebook and it's like, man, am I like, am I working? Like, does this work? It was a huge shift, right? But how you have to do that shift is like you have to use Facebook as a business tool and not a thing to just look at everybody's babies or a bunch of you know wedding pictures and stuff like that. So, like if you scroll through my timeline, it is all either real estate investor groups, trucking groups, or insurance groups. I mean, there's like the only way that there's going to be personal feed is like if I'm close friends with them and like I engage with them. And so I've I've totally shifted my entire Facebook to it's it's only business. Um, it's only group work. So that's that's where I do a lot of my my work is in groups.
SPEAKER_05And I want you to talk a little bit more about that. So somebody who does use Facebook primarily for friends and family and stuff. I think you touched upon something that might have uh gone past some years. So you're saying that you join groups, a lot of groups, right? I heard you say uh uh uh real estate, trucking. Talk about those strategies and and what somebody else, because I know somebody's gonna listen to this, like, what what do you mean going on Facebook? All you know, all I see is A and Sally's pictures popping up, right? So tell us how you actually use it for somebody who might know it all.
SPEAKER_01You use the search feature, which is so funny. Nobody ever uses the search feature, and there's so much you can find with that freaking search feature, and it's like so many people just don't utilize that. And so, literally, what I did is so I went to my carriers. What am I competitive with? Okay, this is what I'm gonna niche down with, and then I'm just gonna go find a bunch of Facebook groups because and it was funny at the same time as when Facebook was really pushing groups, you know, like they're doing ads and everything, like go find a group. There's a group for everything, and like they're not lying, there's literally a group for everything, like, and so I just started going through and joining these groups, and you know, and I think the key to and I call it group mining, like literally mining data out of these groups, um, is you can't go spam. You know, I I don't pitch, like when I go in, I lead with value and education. Um, like for my truckers, which I'll I'll share this with y'all. And this literally just happened last night um to where I've been working this group for about six months, just going in, and like my whole thing is to help new venture, new authority guys get up off the ground. So, hey, look, this is all I do. Don't go spend the money over here, like go get a reliable 2012, you know, don't go get the 2021 big techs and the Dodge 4,500, you know, and just trying to help them save money because I don't, they don't ever think that or they'll go buy the truck and the trailer, and insurance is the last step in that. So I would lead with, hey, look, I see this all the being an insurance, right? I'm not telling them to reach out, like I'm just saying, hey, being an insurance, I see this all the time. Go do this, this, this, and this, and you know, and then you know, basically go from there to where they're like, oh dude, thank you so much. Well, I was leading with so much of that value and education that I don't even have to pitch them. They're just coming, they're like, Hey, like, well, can you help me with the insurance? I'm like, sure, man, happy to do that. Click my link, fill that out. I'll work everything from there. Well, the admin started taking notice, right? Um, so a couple weeks back, a few weeks back, he tagged me in a post. Um, didn't post anything, just tagged me on somebody's insurance request, and he's like, Y'all need to work with Joe. Never talked to the dude ever in my life. Um, literally have just been working that group. And there's probably there was 11,000 members at the time. And so he tags me. So it adds a level of exclusiveness to my name. Like, hey, dude, if he's he's the admin, he created this group, like we should probably work with Joe, right? So I probably got 10 to 15 trucking leads just off that. Um, to then it shifted to so now the past few weeks, he was just denying everybody's insurance request in the group and then just screenshotting them and sending them to me. So then it was even more exclusive. Like, I'm the only one that can see him because there's other insurance agents in there. Um, and then literally last night he poked. He's like, There's over 15 plus insurance requests per day. I've gotten with the other admins, and so he's got some moderators in there because they have now grown from 11 to 14,000. They are growing 1,000 members a week, right? Wow. So now guess who's the exclusive insurance agent for that 14,000 growing at a thousand members per week? That's great. It's Joe. And he so he tagged me in that last night. He created the actual post. All the admins are behind it. I mean, dude, I I got flooded. I had to like, I'm literally, I hired somebody last night because of how much was coming in. Like, I just don't have the time to work all of it. And that's all organic. I mean, it literally was just, you know, and I think you just have to use it as a as a business tool and not something where you can just go get lost down the rabbit hole. And next thing you know, you're like on YouTube, you know, watching whatever videos. And um, yes, where it's like that alone, right? And that's free. And I think everybody just when they hear Facebook, they think, paid, I gotta go, hey, what was the ad? And an agent literally asked me, What was the ad? I was like, there wasn't an ad. I got in with the admin, and now I'm the exclusive agent. And so got together with a bunch of agents this morning because we're only in 20 states at this point in time. I wanted to cover all 50 states, right? Because I don't want to give any other room to any other insurance agent. So I brought in um like four people I know that we can cover all 50 states, and it's freaking flowing through to where I literally just submitted a hundred K trucking deal um a couple days ago just from that.
SPEAKER_02So yeah, you you need to be helpful and play the long strategy, right? It's just it's the long game and and not expecting results or immediate results and just be helpful. Um, but that consistency also is is critical, not just show up and then that's it, you know, come back and ask.
SPEAKER_01Well, and and you know, one thing, one thing I would always I would encourage y'all, like don't just be the person, like if they're asking for assistance and you can actually help, don't just use an emoji or say me, like I mean, how I word, like I have an author badge in pretty much every group I'm in because I use proper grammar. I make my comment pop, I give them multiple options and how they can reach me and like hey, and get and set the expectation right there to where, like what Pops was saying, even if I'm fifth or seventh, I become Facebook ranks me as most relevant. Um, and then that badge does help because they see me as an author within the group, so I'm I'm well spoken or whatever, um, well written. And so then I just pop to the top. So there'll be all these other insurance agents below me, and then they'll just say, like me, but like they don't give them any way to contact them. I'm like, how are you supposed to help? Like, you didn't even give them your phone number, dude. Like, so I just you know use proper grammar and it's it's so simple, like and use correct punctuation, capitalization, all that.
SPEAKER_05Can you talk to that? What is an author badge? What I I didn't even know Facebook couldn't rank people, right?
SPEAKER_02I have it and I didn't even know what it was.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so there's there's badges that they basically based off of the members within the group, like I am, and there's depending on the group I'm in, other groups don't have like visual storyteller because I do a lot of pictures or a lot of, you know, I always will put a picture with my post. Um, and those are they're just badges within the group that help your ranking. So um I'm just noticed more so than maybe somebody who doesn't have that badge. Um, but it it depends on what you're doing, right? The author badge is because I very well typed out, um, you know, I again proper punctuation, all of that type of stuff, which I think some people like it's so simple, right? And like, but it's like, dude, I can't that hurt to read your comment, bro. Like, I mean, where's the period, right? Or it's like what like commas in the wrong place, and I'm like, oh god, that was hard to read. And so Facebook will just rank you, you know, but that it totally gets me to the top when I have a badge versus somebody who doesn't.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, and get and so if anybody's listening out there, Facebook wants people to stay on their platform, all the platforms do. So the more you offer value, they have algorithms, they will show your stuff to the group. So, like to Joe's point, Joe's getting like if somebody else posts in that group, their post isn't gonna be seen by that many people, but Joe's will be seen, they're gonna show it to more people because they know that Joe's providing more value to them, and they want their uh customers essentially to stay on their platform. So that's awesome. That was uh uh huge, huge nuggets for for everybody listening out there.
SPEAKER_01It's free. It's free, right? Can't be how often we get free these days, you know what I'm saying? I mean, that's that's the good stuff.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_05So you guys are crushing it. I want to know what are you guys uh stoked on this year? You know, where where are we headed and what are you guys doubling down on this year? And uh I'd like to hear, let's hear from David and then Joe.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. Um, so we literally were just uh not too long ago talking about this. So our our focus this year is customer experience. Um that's really that that's that's what we're going after this year. You know, when you're young and we're literally just writing business, you know, we're not doing all the follow-ups or the I should say the touch points throughout the year that we should be doing. So I think this year is about, I think, really building out a customer experience so that when someone encounters Redwood, it's not just a transaction or a process, but it's actually an experience. Um, so how do we do that? And so, but on multiple levels. So we're looking at experience to the customer as you know, as they're interacting with with our agency, the experience for our agents, like what's their experience for working in my office? You know, is it just boring, come in, do nothing, you know, whatever, or is there, you know, is there something more to it? So really again, elevating and building out and having that kind of experience, and then also experience for our agent program, for you know, our agent owners that are with us, that you know, what is their experience as they're interacting with us, as they're you know, selling for us, et cetera, what does that look like? So we're kind of looking at just the those uh groups or people that how they how they experience Redwood. And so really what we're trying to flesh out now is okay, so what what's really the key words around that? And then what are two or three things that we can really implement to be able to make that happen? So that's really what we're trying to focus on this year. Um, and then I would say the group thing, you know, Joe's been super, you know, he's just been really good in those groups. Um, so just continuing to do that and to help our other people do that as well. Because it's one thing, you know, for one of us to do it, but then how do we get all of our producers to be as effective as he is at doing that? So just making sure that we're sharing all the stuff that we're learning uh with all the people that are in our agency so that they can continue to do that same thing and have the same kind of success. Joe, love it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. And I would say, I mean, just to piggyback on that, so yeah, our three is like client, so just really providing that optimal client experience, um, you know, literally on whatever it might be, whether it's whether it's as simple as like a claim or billing or just response time, you know, we're like we're picking up on the first ring, we're not like letting them just go to voicemail. Um, you know, that's a big one. Obviously, so we we run a franchise agent program. So as we've really been able to refine that, um, what are like why us, right? Like why Redwood? And it's because the experience is is unlike any other, right? Um, and then again for people, this is what we're this is what I'm trying to do. Um, just as kind of I'm on the sales side, so I'm the VP of sales. Um so anything like in-house production is what I'm really trying to grow out our our in-house sales team to where actually we just hired two people this past week. Um, so great start for January. And I ultimately want to remove myself from production um so that I can focus on working more on the agency and expanding us and coaching and training, right? That's my actual true passion, um, which I can do that within the industry, which is awesome. I don't think every industry is like that. Um, and maybe sometimes people just use the industry to get to their passion, but it's like I can do both and I can make money while I'm doing it, and I can change people's lives, um, whether that's somebody who's a client or it's somebody who's working or selling for us. So um that's definitely where I'm trying to double down. I want to build out a sales team. Um, and not just, hey, hire a bunch of them, throw them at a wall, see who sticks. Like I really like I believe in if I find, if I take the time and I vet them and I filter them correctly, like why go hire 50 when I can find five that can do the same, right? Right. Um, so that's that's definitely what we're looking to do. Um, building out so we're doing obviously personal lines and commercial. Um, so our first step actually is the one guy's personal lines, and the girl is gonna be a commercial specialist for us. So it's gonna be awesome.
SPEAKER_02Congratulations.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, thank you. Yeah, that's I don't have to produce as much. Uh which I mean, don't get me wrong, sales is in my blood. Um, our first year, which was crazy. I I literally sold like 1.2 million. I sold 1.2 million myself, but like I was, I mean, I was just slapping anything on the books I could just to keep our doors open. So learn that the hard way is that, oh yeah, you spent all that time writing that, and I probably lost like 25% of it, if not more, um, on the back end. So it's like, dang, we did all that for like one year, and and dad was like, Well, dang, man, I paid you out that whole year, and I don't even give you the renewals, you know. So, you know, definitely learning experience in that. Uh, but now we're just really trying to write sticky business. Um, but you got to find the right people to fill the seats to do that, right?
SPEAKER_02And it's not scalable to do it yourself anyway. So you gotta so as we wind it down here, Joe, why don't you why don't you give one one thing you've learned and and and uh that tip that would help somebody that's taking the dive and trying to go scratch, um, one thing that that they must do in order to save themselves from some grief?
SPEAKER_01Network. Um, you know, I'm actually I I'm actually looking, I might pick your guys' brain on this. I'm actually looking to start a podcast of my own um called You Don't Know What You Don't Know. Um I've seen a lot of agents just jump into something thinking they know everything. And let me tell you, you do not know everything. Um, you know, so I'm a huge believer in networking. Um get around not only people in the industry, but they need to be like-minded, right? So where you guys are trying to achieve the same goals and pick their brains. Um, you want to be around people who are willing to collaborate versus you know somebody who's got the secret sauce and isn't willing to share. So that's you know, I started a networking event myself to where it's it's like no secret sauce. I'm straight up, I will give you any and everything. Like in literally, anybody watching this, like message me on Facebook. I will literally hop on a Zoom and give you all of my marketing programs, all of my scripts, how I do it, and I'll help you adjust that to your agency. And everybody's like, dude, what are you doing? Like, why, why? And I'm like, bro, look, I'll give you everything I do. You just got to be better at it than me. Like, I mean, that's if we're being honest, right? Like, I mean, hey, to each their own, but like I don't I believe in collaboration and it and what you put in is what you get out. You know, when you're when you're for the lack of a better term, when you're an ass to other agents, man, I mean, it's it's just bad karma. It really is. So my my one bit of advice is to get around people who have been in the industry or who are um just really just know more than you. And something you got to be humble to do that, right? Like stop talking, just listen to what they have to say. Um, you know, and that's I think that's been our biggest shift for us is is changing our network. Um, really, within the past six to nine months, we have been getting around people that are wow. You know, I would I thought we were doing good, like we're not even thinking big enough. Um it's where you need people like that around you. So that would be my bit of advice.
SPEAKER_02There's always a bigger fish. Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. How about you, David? Um, I would say investment, invest in yourself. Um, you know, for probably the first two and a half years, um, I didn't do anything for myself at all. Uh, and I think what I found was at in early 20, I probably you know, early 2020, probably first quarter into second quarter, like I just really I just was in a bad space, you know. And when things get tight and you start feeling like as soon as you get that thought that you need to pull back because you're not afraid, you know, you're afraid that something like it's not gonna happen, or oh, you know what, maybe I just need to uh I don't need to quite do that. Um, and and that was just kind of the headspace I was in. And I and I just was managing things and not really leading things. I didn't have really any passion about the business. Um, and then we went to an event um with Cody Askins in the fall of of 2020, and it was seeming like like yeah, like uh like like 15 people, 15 a power player event thing he had in Springfield. And again, as Joe talked about, I got around some guys and guys that were literally half my age. Like I told I like, oh my gosh, I felt so old. Because here's like this 24-year-old kid, and he's just crushing it in Idaho, Josh Lustig, hate you. Um I'm like, I'm so stupid. Like, why was I not doing that when I was his age? But I got around these guys and and I literally it just it it it literally just lifted the ceiling off of me where I'm like, Camper, you are thinking so small, you know. And here's these guys, you know, that are just I mean, they're crushing it, they're getting after it. And I just had to get my mojo back, you know, but I needed to be around other people to do that. And sometimes in this independent space, you know, you can be on an island, you know, maybe with a captive, you've got a group or a district or whatever, you're kind of as an independent, um, you you you lose that. Um, and so you gotta invest in yourself, uh get yourself, go to go to some events, go to some things, yeah, get some training, but spend some money on yourself to just, you know, to be better, whether that's a better leader, whether that's a better salesperson, you know, just your skills or skill set. Um and and hey, I know it's tough when you're first getting going, but just do whatever you can do. And you know, even if it's just watching free content on YouTube, I think it'll make a huge difference.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So it's just gotta have a yeah.
SPEAKER_05And I love what you said about like like it was the ego, right? You went there, you're like all these young, young guys there, but then like I mean, they're doing some really cool stuff. You take what you know, but then all this other stuff that you're learning, and now you have and you couldn't have done that if you didn't put the ego aside. I think the ego part of this is a huge, a huge one, especially if you've been in the industry a while, you know. I think we all have our days where we do extremely well. There's gonna be and then there's gonna be times that we kind of suck, and it's like you know you don't want to keep your ego on that wave that you rode at that time and and just be like, Well, you know, I used to do this, you know, like yeah, we see that a lot, and it's uh I love I love that uh yeah, you're you're totally right, and that's and when we when we came back from that retreat, so then we joined Closer's Click um with David Denning and and Sandra Gephardt because I had all this whatever, and then you just and and like they just kept me accountable, you know.
SPEAKER_00It's like it's one thing that you know, you kind of get that mindset shift, but then like you said, like you were just saying, you gotta go do something with it. And so I needed, I I had the weekend experience, and that's great, but you can go right back into the same thing where you just left, and you just go right back to doing the stuff you were doing. Um, so we were super fortunate to to I don't I can't remember now how we even found out about that group, but we got into that as kind of again, just kind of their initial uh their initial core group of people. And Sandra and David man, I mean, just every single week you had accountability to the things they were teaching us and showing us, and like you said, humble to say, hey, I I need yeah, there's absolutely stuff I need to learn and grow with, and they're giving me a good kick in the butt to make sure that that we're doing that. And that as a as a new agency, I mean it's been huge for us to keep it going.
SPEAKER_01Awesome. I want to, you know, for Pops for Pops, I think you know, I think mindset was a big thing for him, like what he touched on, but you know, he shifted from like when I because I wanted to go to everything, we didn't have the money, but I'd still ask, right? Because I wanted to go, I wanted to go meet people. Um, I just love getting out there. And he's like, dude, I don't think you understand how broke we are. And you know, I think that power players thing finally. I mean, we spent you know thousands of dollars going to do it, and that literally changed his mindset from this is an expense, it's investment, right? And I think when you're spending money, it's sometimes hard to look at it as investment, right? You know, especially if you're tight on money. Um, so that was a big thing for him. I think I saw this mindset. And I literally, the next morning, I'm on the phone trying to close a deal, and the dude comes running in my office and he's like playing his whole song is uh Drake started from the bottom. Now we hear, and he's playing it on his speed throw, and he's like, Yeah, man, like all hyped up. And like, I'm like, dude, I'm on the call, like I'm trying to close this deal, dude. Can you get out of my office?
SPEAKER_02But yeah, I've never
SPEAKER_01I've never seen him that energized. Um, and and just that, like, okay, let's freaking do this thing. And it was one event, right? And I think that's all it takes. Even if it's just one event, it can change your life forever for sure.
SPEAKER_02It's remarkable. People will pull the money out and then go invest it in another company. Jace and I talk about it all the time, but but you won't turn around and invest it in your own company where you're gonna get tight times instead of eight percent, twelve percent. And then there's risk. It's just it's crazy. So um, you guys, thank you so much. If somebody wants to work for you guys, how can they look up Redwood?
SPEAKER_00Redwood, yeah. Just go to RedTime RedwoodAgency Group.com. You can find us there. Um, Facebook, we're on and we're everywhere. Facebook, Instagram, Twitter. You know, just search for Redwood Agency Group and and you'll find us and you can get in touch with us.
SPEAKER_02Awesome. Well, perfect. Thank you guys so much for coming on. Uh, it's been awesome. Uh this has been great.
SPEAKER_00Such a great story.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, really good. Really good.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for having you guys on the podcast. Love what you guys are doing for the industry, you know, educating and helping people out. So again, I know it's tough. This, you know, you guys got day jobs and everything else you're trying to do, man. So thank you for everything you guys are doing to help people out. It's very cool.
SPEAKER_02Awesome. We'll see you on the next time.
SPEAKER_00Thank you. Yeah, thank you guys. Thanks, guys.
SPEAKER_04Hey, Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Mm-hmm. Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh write $100,000 in premium off of even the worst internet leads, where could they go?
SPEAKER_03They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process. Super awesome.
SPEAKER_04I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_03Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teled.com.
SPEAKER_04Live.teledudes.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_03Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah, which is awesome. But they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm into it. Greg, are you gonna respond to these texts? I'm gonna respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. Mmm. That's right. The calling calculator, sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it. I'm gonna text it right now. Five two zero two one four two two one nine.
SPEAKER_04All right. I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_03Bye, Mr. Craig. Wait, can they even listen to this on the radio anymore?
SPEAKER_02I love it. I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman